Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 5300 of 2023
Judgment Reserved On : 20.02.2026
Judgment Delivered On :02.04.2026
1 - Lalit Kumar Gupta S/o Parmeshwar Prasad Gupta, Aged About 40
Years R/o Pachpedi, District Bilaspur Chhattisgarh, Pincode- 495551
2 - Anup Kumar Patel, S/o Amrut Lal Patel, Aged About 31 Years, R/o
N/22, Jamchapar, Lendhra, District Raigarh Chhattisgarh, Pincode496551
3 - Ushakiran Khute, W/o Someshwar Khute, Aged About 30 Years R/o
Pamgarh
District
Janjgir
Champa,
Rasonta,
Janjgir-
Champa,
Chhattisgarh, Pincode- 495554
4 - Rituraj, S/o Gajanand, Aged About 30 Years R/o Ward-03, MeghMarket, Utai, District Durg (Chhattisgarh)
5 - Hulsi, D/o Revaram, Aged About 32 Years R/o Dabharapara Ward02, Sounga, P.O. Girod, District Dhamtari Chhattisgarh, Pincode493662
6 - Rupesh Nirmalkar S/o Kumal Ram Nirmakar, Aged About 27 Years,
Digitally signed
by SHYNA AJAY
DN: cn=SHYNA
SHYNA AJAY,
o=PERSONAL,
AJAY
st=Chhattisgarh,
c=IN
R/o Ward No. 17, Lalbhadur Nagar, District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh
Pincode- 491557.
7 - Thaneshvar Kumar, S/o Vigtan Kumar, Aged About 31 Years R/o 40
Goji, District Dhamtari Chhattisgarh Pincode- 493663
8 - Jayanyi Patel, D/o Radhesshyam Patel, Aged About 30 Years R/o
House
No.
123,
Patelpara,
Dandhapali,
Raigarh,
Madhopali,
Chhattisgarh Pincode- 496551
9 - Kartikeshwar Dansena, S/o Hemlal Dansena, Aged About 26 Years
R/o Hemlal Dansena, Ward No. 08, Rajivnagar, Sariya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh Pincode- 496554
10 - Pawan Kumar Chouhan, S/o Suraj Chouhan, Aged About 30 Years
R/o House No. 83, Boirdih Marg, District Raigarh Chhattisgarh,
Pincode- 496551
11 - Himani Rajput, D/o Patrhakhan Singh, Aged About 25 Years, R/o
208, Durga Nagar Birgaon, Ward No. 29, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
Pincode- 493221
12 - Priyanka Kushwaha, D/o Omprakash Kushwaha, Aged About 31
Years R/o Ward No. 04, Kushwahapara, Madanpur, Surajpur
Chhattisgarh Pincode- 497001
13 - Kanak Kumar S/o Pramod Kumar, Aged About 31 Years R/o Baba
Talapara, Ranitarai, District Durg Chhattisgarh. Pincode- 491223
14 - Samantak Kumar Tandan, S/o Darash Ram Tandan, Aged About
39 Years, R/o 57, Ward No. 06, Mahka, District Janjgir Champa,
Chhattisgarh, Pincode- 495556
15 - Ravindra Kumar, S/o Bholaram Painkra, Aged About 28 Years R/o
Ward No. 10, Nilkanthpur, Balrampur, Chhattisgarh, Pincode- 497224
16 – Kartikeshwar Dansena, S/o Hemlal Dansena, aged about 26
years, R/o Ward No.08, Rajivnagar, Sariya (np), Chhattisgarh, Pincode496554
17 - Kishore Kumbhkar S/o Purushottam Kumbhkar, Aged About 26
Years R/o Ward No. 54, Sanjay Nagar, Near Ramjanki Mandir, DisttRaipur Chhattisgarh, Pincode- 492001
18 - Man Singh Sahu S/o Sita Ram Sahu Aged About 30 Years R/o
Parkhanda Gudguda, Parkhands, Dhamtari Chhattisgarh, Pincode493663
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary Health and Family
Welfare Department Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Capital Complex,
Atal Nagar Police Station And P.O. Rakhi Nawa Raipur, District Raipur,
C.G.
2 – Director, Health Services, Directorate, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal
Nagar, Nava Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Divisional Joint Director, Health Services, Raipur/ Durg Division,
District- Raipur, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9297 of 2023
1 - Anil Deshmukh S/o Mr. Sahadev Deshmukh, Aged About 40 Years
R/o Ward No. 18, Bhendsar, Durg, (C.G.)
2 - Mohammad Azaz S/o Mohammad Murad, Aged About 30 Years R/o
House No. 976, Ward No. 01, Panchsheel Nagar, Durg (C.G.)
3 - Nand Kishor S/o Mr. Naresh Ram, Aged About 27 Years R/o Potora,
Durg (C.G.)
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of
Health Services, Mahanadi Bhavan, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Naya
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Director Directorate Of Heath Services, Indrawati Bhavan, Atal
Nagar, Naya Raipur, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Divisional Joint Director Health Services, Raipur/Durg Division, Old
Nursing Hostel, D.K.S. Bhawan Premises Raipur, District Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause Title downloaded from CIS Periphery)
For Respective
Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Acharya and Mr. Arpan Verma,
Advocates
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Sangharsh Pandey, Government Advocate
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
C A V Order
1. The Writ Petitioners in both the captioned petitions are aggrieved
by the decision of the respondent authorities in cancelling the
recruitment process for the posts of Staff Nurse, Radiographer,
Medical Lab Technologist and Opthalmic Assistant.
This
cancellation pertains to the recruitment process initiated vide the
advertisement dated 24.3.2022.
2. Since both the writ petitions involve a common question of law
and are founded on similar facts and circumstances, they have
been clubbed together, heard analogously, and are being
disposed of by this common order.
3. The petitioners in WPS No.5300/2023 have prayed for the
following reliefs :
(1) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue a writ/writs, direction/directions, order/orders
quashing
the
order/notice
dated
23/06/2023
(Annex.P/1) and issue appropriate writs to reinstate
the recruitment process for advertisement dated
18.7.2022 (Annex.P/6) for the post of ophthalmic
assistant from the stage it stood cancelled.
(2) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
grant any other relief(s), which is deemed fit and
proper in the aforesaid facts and circumstances of
the case.
4. The petitioners in WPS No.9297/2023 have prayed for the
following reliefs :
(1) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to
issue
a
writ/writs,
direction/directions,
order/orders quashing the impugned order dated
20.11.2023 (Annex.P/1), passed by Divisional Joint
Director, Health Services and the Hon'ble Court
may kindly be pleased to quash the decision of the
respondents in respect of the cancellation of the
entire selection process initiated in pursuance of the
advertisement dated 18.07.2022.
(2) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to grant any other relief(s), which is deemed fit and
proper in the aforesaid facts and circumstances of
the case.
5. For the sake of convenience and clarity, WPS No.5300/2023 has
been treated as the lead case, and the facts of the said petition
are being referred to for the purpose of adjudication. The decision
rendered herein shall, however, govern the connected writ
petition as well, as the issues raised therein are identical in
nature.
6. The grievance of the petitioners is that the respondent authorities
initiated a recruitment process for the post of Opthalmic Assistant
vide an advertisement dated 24.3.2022. Though the process
progressed through multiple stages, including issuance of an
eligibility list and the verification of documents, but the
advertisement was subsequently cancelled without assigning any
reasons. The petitioners contend that this cancellation was done
in an arbitrary and capricious manner.
7. The case, as canvassed by the petitioners in WPS No.5300/2023
(treated as the lead case), is that vide a letter dated 23.8.2021, a
total 65 posts of Opthalmic Assistant were sanctioned for the
Raipur Division, to be filled through a direct recruitment process.
It was specifically mandated that these posts were sanctioned
exclusively for direct recruitment, accordingly any seats reserved
for promotional vacancies were not to be included in the
aforementioned
sanctioned
strength.
Respondent
No.1
(Secretary, Department of Health and Family Welfare) issued a
directive vide letter dated 21.3.2022 to conduct recruitment based
on merit, whereby 85 marks were to be allotted for academic
merit and 15 marks for experience. Pursuant to this, an
advertisement was issued on 24.3.2022 for 06 posts of Opthalmic
Assistant in the Raipur Division, however, the said advertisement
was subsequently amended on 25.3.2022, and the said posts
were withdrawn without assigning any reasons. Thereafter, a
fresh advertisement dated 18.7.2022 was issued by respondent
No.3
(Divisional
Joint
Director,
Health
Services)
inviting
applications for 50 vacancies for the post of Opthalmic Assistant
across the Raipur/ Durg Divisions. The aforesaid advertisement
indicated that the sanctioning of posts was based on the
letter/order dated 23.8.2021 and it categorically stated that the
number of seats was subject to modification. Furthermore, the
advertisement stipulated that the selection would be conducted
based on merit and experience, as detailed in Clause 15.
Subsequent of submission of application forms, a list of eligible
candidates was published, wherein about 216 aspirants were
found eligible. After the invitation of objections, candidates were
called for document verification on 5.9.2022. However, despite
the documents having been duly verified
and while the
candidates were awaiting the final results, the entire selection
process was cancelled for the third time, without assigning any
reasons whatsoever.
This illegal action of the respondent
authorities has caused irreparable prejudice to the several
candidates, many of whom have now become age-barred,
thereby losing their eligibility for public employment. In this
regard, asserting that the decision to cancel the advertisement
was illegal and arbitrary, the petitioners in WPS No.9297/2023
moved a representation before the concerned authorities seeking
a reconsideration of the recruitment process. The said petitioners
also filed WPS No.8884/2023 before this Court, wherein, by order
dated 10.11.2023, the concerned authority was directed
to
consider and decide the representation of the petitioners within a
stipulated period.
Subsequently, the representation filed by the
petitioners was rejected vide letter dated 20.11.2023. This
rejection letter also fails to assign any specific reason by the
respondent authorities, only citing ‘unavoidable reasons’ for the
cancellation of the advertisement and the recruitment process.
Furthermore, the letter states that a fresh advertisement will only
be issued after receiving sanction from the Finance Department
and thereafter, the recruitment would be conducted through the
CG Professional Examination Board (Vyapam). Hence, these
Petitions.
8. Mr. P. Acharya and Mr. Arpan Verma, learned counsel for the
respective petitioners would jointly submit that the entire action
taken by the respondent authorities is per se illegal. They submit
that the cancellation of the advertisement is arbitrary and
unsustainable in law, as no reasons were assigned for the same.
The recruitment process had reached an advanced stage, the
select list had been prepared and the documents were duly
verified. At a stage where appointment orders were expected to
be issued, the cancellation of the advertisement and the entire
selection process is nothing but a manifestation of the whimsical
attitude of the respondent authorities. Learned counsel for the
respective petitioners further submit that no model employer can
be permitted to act in such an arbitrary and malafide manner.
They
further submit that the cancellation of advertisement
infringes the legal rights of the petitioners. Although the
petitioners do not have a vested right to appointment, they
possess a legitimate expectation of a fair conclusion to the
recruitment process. He submits that having submitted their
candidature for the post(s) of Opthalmic Assistant and having
progressed through the stages of merit-based selection and
document verification, the petitioners reasonably expected to be
considered for appointment. Instead, the respondent authorities
arbitrarily cancelled the entire recruitment process at its final
stage and such an action warrants interference of this Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. They also submit
that the rights which have been accrued in favour of the
petitioners have been denied in a casual manner. In support of
their submissions, learned counsel for the petitioners would rely
upon the judgments rendered in the matters of State of Assam
and others Vs. Arabinda Rabha and others reported in (2025)
7 SCC 705, Anamica Mishra Vs. U.P. Public Service
Commission, reported in 1990 Supp SCC 692, Union of India
and others Vs. Rajesh P.U. Puthuvalnikathu and another,
reported in (2003) 7 SCC 285 and Sachin Kumar Vs. Delhi
Subordinate Service Selection Board and others, reported in
(2021) 4 SCC 631. Learned counsel for the petitioners lastly
submit that due to the arbitrary and illegal acts of the respondent
authorities, some of the petitioners have now crossed the
requisite age limit. It is, therefore, submitted that in the interest of
justice, the petitioners must be considered in any subsequent or
fresh recruitment process by granting them necessary age
relaxation.
9. On the other hand, Mr. Sangharsh Pandey, learned counsel for
the State submits that the petitioners do not possess an absolute
right to appointment only by virtue of their names appearing in the
Select List. He submits that the preparation of a Select List does
not confer any indefeasible right upon a candidate to claim
appointment.
Moreover,
subsequent
selection
as
the entire advertisement and
process
have
been
cancelled,
the
petitioners cannot seek appointment on the basis of an
advertisement that has ceased to exist. He further submits that no
legal rights accrued in favour the petitioners simply because a
Select List was prepared or their documents were verified. He
submits that
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held, time and
again, that mere appearance of a name in the Select List does
not confer any indefeasible right upon a candidate to claim
appointment. Once the recruitment process itself has been
terminated, the petitioners cannot claim a right to appointment.
He further submits that it was specifically mentioned in the letter
dated 20.11.2023 that the advertisement was cancelled due to
unavoidable reasons. Furthermore, the order stipulated that upon
receiving the requisite sanction from the Finance Department,
fresh recruitment for the post of Opthalmic Assistant would be
initiated through the CG Professional Examination Board
(Vyapam). Hence, the petitions being devoid of merits, are liable
to be dismissed.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also
perused the documents annexed with the writ petitions.
11. Admittedly, as per the rejection letter dated 20.11.2023 issued in
response to the representation filed by the respective petitioners,
the respondent authorities sought to justify the cancellation of the
advertisement and the recruitment process by citing ‘unavoidable
reasons’. The letter further avers that after obtaining the requisite
sanction from the Finance Department, fresh recruitment
proceedings
would
be
initiated
through
the
Chhattisgarh
Professional Examination Board (Vyapam).
12. The first and foremost issue for consideration is whether the
petitioners possess any indefeasible right to claim appointment
on the basis of the subject advertisement and the recruitment
process initiated by the respondent authorities.
13. It is trite law that mere inclusion of a name in the Select List does
not confer any indefeasible right upon the petitioners to claim
appointment.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held
that the successful completion of a selection process does not, by
itself, grant an aspirant a vested right to be appointed. In the
present case, although the advertisement was cancelled at an
advanced stage, the fact remains that no recruitment process is
currently pending. Once the advertisement itself has been
cancelled, the petitioners can no longer assert a legal right to
recruitment based on a process that has ceased to exist. The
recruitment and subsequent cancellation of a selection process
fall within the exclusive domain of the concerned employer. An
employer, after evaluating the relevant circumstances, is entitled
to cancel the process at any stage, subject to the rider that such
action must not be illegal, arbitrary or whimsical in nature.
14. From a perusal of the averments in the writ petitions, it appears
that the entire recruitment process had reached an advanced
stage and was subsequently cancelled owing to lack of requisite
sanction from the Finance Department. Since there was an
administrative requirement for financial sanction, the reasons
provided by the respondent authorities for cancellation of the
recruitment process appear to be legally justified. Further, in the
absence of clearance from the Finance Department for the
sanctioned posts, the respondent authorities were left with no
alternative but to cancel the advertisement and the entire
selection
process.
While
this
action
undoubtedly
caused
grievance to the petitioners, we must weigh this against the
administrative and financial constraints faced by the State. It is
evident that without the requisite financial sanction, the
respondent authorities cannot proceed with appointments, as
such sanction is a prerequisite for disbursal of salaries and other
benefits.
15. Learned counsel for the respondent/State has also contended
that certain anomalies were detected in the advertisement,
therefore, in order to rectify these discrepancies and ensure a
transparent process, the respondent authorities took a policy
decision to cancel the entire selection process. In my view, such
an action cannot be termed unjustified. The decision to cancel the
recruitment is found to be bona fide, justifiable and free from the
vice of arbitrariness, as it was further necessitated by the valid
administrative requirement of obtaining clearance
from the
Finance Department
16.In the matter of Arabinda Rabha (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has considered this aspect and has held in para 59 & 60
has under :
59. We are conscious of the line of decisions of this Court
and have noted some of them here, which lay down the
law that mere empanelment/enlistment does not result in
accrual of any indefeasible right in favour of such
empanelled/selected candidate as well as the law that the
employer may, in its wisdom, either decide to cancel the
select list or not carry on the process further resulting in
the notified/advertised vacancy/vacancies not being filled
up pursuant to the selection process, which has been
conducted. What it means is that an empanelled/selected
candidate can claim no right of appointment, if the State
has cogent and germane grounds for not making the
appointment. However, at the same time, it is also the law
that the appointing authority cannot ignore the select
panel or decline to make the appointment on its
whims. Shankarsan Dash [Shankarsan Dash v. Union of
India, (1991) 3 SCC 47 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 800] cautions
that the State has no licence to act in an arbitrary manner.
In R.S. Mittal v. Union of India [R.S. Mittal v. Union of
India, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 230 : 1995 SCC (L&S) 787] , a
coordinate Bench held that when a person has been
selected by the Selection Board and there is a vacancy
which can be offered to him, keeping in view his merit
position, then, ordinarily, there is no justification to ignore
him for appointment and that there has to be a justifiable
reason to decline to appoint a person who is on the select
panel. The position in law finds reiteration in a decision of
recent origin in Dinesh Kumar Kashyap v. South East
Central Railway [Dinesh Kumar Kashyap v. South East
Central Railway, (2019) 12 SCC 798 : (2019) 2 SCC
(L&S) 693] , where the majority held that the employer
must give cogent reasons for not appointing selected
candidates.
60. Any decision taken not to appoint despite there being
vacancies and a valid select list, obviously, is in the nature
of a policy decision. It has to be borne in mind that
securing public employment is the dream of many, who
put their heart and soul to prepare for it. Nowadays,
aspirants undertake rigorous study sessions as well as
training modules to equip themselves, which also comes
at a heavy cost. That apart, since every process of
recruitment necessarily involves substantial expenses
which are borne from the public exchequer and at the
same time the aspirants for the posts (who, as per their
own estimation, have performed sufficiently well and
therefore stand a good chance of being appointed upon
figuring in the select list) cherish fond hopes of a bright
and secure future, the law is clear that the policy decision
not to carry the process forward must be taken bona fide,
there has to be justifiable reason if the process is
abandoned midway, and such decision must not suffer
from the vice of arbitrariness or the whims of the decision
maker. This acts as a check on the employer's power
deciding against not making any appointment from the
select list despite availability of vacancy/vacancies on the
advertised/notified public post(s). A writ court may, upon
reaching the requisite satisfaction, intervene in such
manner and make such directions as the facts and
circumstances warrant. We, therefore, do not find it
acceptable that the aspirants, not having an indefeasible
or vested right of appointment, do not also have the right
to question any decision adverse to their interest affecting
achievement of their goals to secure public employment.
Whether, and to what extent, any relief should be granted,
must depend on the facts of each case.
17. Likewise, in a judgment rendered in the matter of Employees
State Insurance Corporation and another Vs. Dr. Vinay Kumar
and others, reported in (2022) 18 SCC 358, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held in para 7 & 8 as under :
7. The cardinal principle we must bear in mind is that this is a
case of direct recruitment. A candidate who has applied does
not have a legal right to insist that the recruitment process set
in motion be carried to its logical end. Even inclusion of a
candidate in the select list may not clothe the candidate with
such a right. This is, however, different, no doubt, from holding
that the employer is free to act in an arbitrary manner. But, at
the same time, in the first place, direction which is given by the
High Court to conclude the recruitment within 45 days is clearly
untenable. This is for the reason that, as noticed, the
advertisement dated 1-3-2018 was put on hold on 21-3-2018
before the last date indicated for filing the application by
advertisement dated 1-3-2018. As the very advertisement was
put on hold, it is quite likely that any candidate who may have
been desirous of applying, may not have applied being
discouraged by the fact that the advertisement has been put
on hold. Therefore, the direction to conclude the proceedings
within 45 days is unsupportable.
8. Question would arise as to whether the direction could be
given to proceed with the recruitment process by giving
peremptory direction to the appellant. Here again, we cannot be
oblivious to the first principle which we have indicated viz. the
absence of any legal right with the candidate who has merely
made an application. At the same time, we do feel trammelled
by the fact that the case which is sought to be set up viz. that
there may not be any need for filling up the post, was not as
such set up before the High Court or the Tribunal. Such an
attempt is being made before this Court. In such circumstances,
we are of the view that a fair and time-bound decision must be
taken by the appellants not oblivious to the fact that persons
have applied and they would also look forward to a fair
treatment at the hands of the body like the appellant.
18. Furthermore, in a judgment rendered in the matter of The
Transmission Corporation of Telangana State Limited and
another Vs. Chukkala Kranthi Kiran and others, reported in
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1785, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held as under :
32. High Court turned Section 79 on its head and held the
said provision did not create an embargo on the new State
to make appointment in its services from a select list
prepared for the composite State of Andhra Pradesh. The
reasoning of the High Court flies in face of the fact that a
selected candidate does not have a vested right to
appointment and Section 79 cannot be read as an
enabling provision vesting such a right and encroaching
on the appellant's right to take an independent decision in
light of the altered circumstances to continue with the
earlier selection process or to initiate a fresh selection
process.
19. Reverting to the facts of the present case, when the matter is
examined in light of the principles laid down in the aforesaid
judgments rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is apparent
that the respondent authorities possessed justifiable grounds for
cancellation of both the advertisement and the recruitment
process. The core issue remains the absence of financial
sanction, which was not accorded to the respondent authorities.
Since the petitioners do not possess an indefeasible right to seek
a writ of mandamus for their appointment, this Court does not find
any cogent ground to interfere with the administrative decision of
the State/Employer.
20. The recruitment is a complete process, commencing with the
issuance of an advertisement based on sanctioned posts and
culminating in the appointment of the candidates concerned. In
the present case, while rejecting the representation, the
respondents have categorically stated that the recruitment
process was cancelled due to lack of financial sanction from the
Finance Department. They have further informed that after
obtaining the requisite sanction, the posts shall be re-advertised
and a fresh selection process will be conducted through the
Chattisgarh Professional Examination Board (Vyapam).
21. In light of the foregoing reasons and considering the facts and
circumstances of the case, this Court is of the view that a policy
decision based on valid administrative grounds, such as lack of
financial sanction, falls within the permissible exercise of
executive discretion and it can’t be termed as arbitrary or
malafide. Hence, the relief sought by the petitioners cannot be
granted. However, the respondents are under an obligation to
initiate a fresh recruitment process in a timely manner. Notably,
the advertisement was cancelled on three separate occasions, as
a result, many aspirants who were initially in the prescribed age
limit may now have become overaged. This situation warrants
serious consideration by the respondent authorities.
22. In view of the above, this Court deems it appropriate to direct the
respondent authorities to grant appropriate age relaxation to the
petitioners while issuing a fresh advertisement for the subject
posts. As a model employer, it is expected that the concerned
respondents will pass appropriate orders in this regard in
accordance with law.
23. With the aforesaid directions/observations, the Writ Petitions are
disposed of.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Shyna Ajay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review