Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 16.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 23.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011080482025
+
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
ANIL AHLUWALIA
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Paranjay Chopra, Advocate
(through videoconferencing).
Petitioner in person.
versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI AND ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Nawal Kishore Jha, APP for State
with SI Rohit Sagar, PS Laxmi Nagar.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GIRISH KATHPALIA
JUDGMENT
1.
This petition brought under the provisions of Section 528 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) assails order dated 19.04.2025
passed in the revisonal jurisdiction by the Court of Sessions, thereby
upholding the magisterial order of dismissal of the application under Section
175(3) BNSS [the erstwhile Section 156(3) CrPC].
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 1 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec455
69af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH
COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570
996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa,
cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:40:10 +05'30'
2.
On 07.01.2026, in the course of preliminary hearing, a prima facie
view was recorded that the present petition is not maintainable in view of the
bar enacted under Section 438(3) BNSS, insofar as what is prohibited by law
cannot be allowed backdoor entry by invoking inherent powers under
Section 528 BNSS. However, this principle is subject to an exception where
the petitioner establishes a case of gross injustice. On this aspect, learned
counsel for petitioner took time to examine. On 16.09.2026, I heard learned
counsel for petitioner on the issue of maintainability of this petition and
reserved the matter for orders.
3.
The circumstances relevant for present purposes are that the
petitioner filed an application under Section 156(3) CrPC along with a
complaint under Section 200 CrPC against the present respondents. By way
of detailed and well reasoned order dated 28.08.2023, the learned magistrate
dismissed the application under Section 156(3) CrPC and posted the matter
for recording pre-summoning evidence under Section 200 CrPC. The
petitioner challenged order dated 28.08.2023 by way of criminal revision
proceedings before the Court of Sessions. By way of order presently
impugned, the learned Court of Sessions dismissed the criminal revision
petition. Hence, the present petition.
4.
Briefly stated, the allegations levelled against the present respondents
by the petitioner in his complaint are as follows. On 23.04.2021, by way of
pathological examination, wife of the petitioner was found to be suffering
with Covid-19. On 25.04.2021, at about 10:00am, she started feeling
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 2 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569
af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH
COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d1557099
6b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa,
cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:39:58 +05'30'
difficulty in breathing, so on advise of Dr. P.N. Seth and Dr. Vijay Arora,
petitioner took her along with her oxygen cylinder to Max Super Speciality
Hospital, but they refused to admit her for want of beds. Thereafter,
petitioner took his wife to the present respondent no.1/hospital, where after
initial check-up, the present respondent no.3 demanded Rs.1,00,000/- in
cash to arrange bed and on fervent request of petitioner, his wife was
admitted by the present respondents no.3 & 4 after accepting an advance
payment of Rs.50,000/-. The present respondent no.4 prescribed Remdesivir
injection, costing Rs.25,000/- each on two prescriptions. Later, upon change
of shift of doctors, the present respondent no.6 changed the prescription and
asked the petitioner to deposit Rs. 20,000/-. On 27.04.2021 at about
11:30am, oxygen supply to wife of the petitioner was stopped, but the same
was restored on objection being raised. In the evening on that day, the
present respondent no.4 advised the petitioner to shift his wife to some other
hospital as they did not have ICU beds; and the present respondents no.3 &
4 threatened to discharge her, if she was not shifted out. At about 06:00pm
on that day, oxygen supply was again stopped and the present respondents
did not attend to her, so she passed away at about 07:27pm. Since the local
police failed to register FIR, he filed the complaint with application for
directions to register FIR.
5.
On the above complaint of the petitioner, the learned magistrate called
for Action Taken Report from the local police. In the status report, version
of the present respondents also was recorded and as per the same, wife of the
petitioner expired as her oxygen saturation was not stable and unfortunately
many patients lost their lives due to Covid-19 despite best efforts of the
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 3 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569a
f3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT
OF DELHI,CID - 7047638, postalCode=110003,
st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996
b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa,
cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:39:47 +05'30'
doctors.
6.
The learned magistrate after taking note of the relevant judicial
precedents took a view that since all facts, including identity of the accused
persons and evidence are within the knowledge of the petitioner, there is no
requirement for police investigation, though at a future stage if required,
police enquiry can be directed under Section 202 CrPC. With these
observations, the learned magistrate dismissed the application under Section
156(3) CrPC and posted the matter for recording pre summoning evidence.
The petitioner filed revision petition against dismissal of his said
application.
7.
In the order impugned in the present proceedings, the learned Court of
Sessions recorded in detail the allegations of the present petitioner and
quoted extensively from judicial precedents regarding the law related to
medical negligence. After taking into account the detailed narration of facts
as well as report of the Delhi Medical Council, the learned Court of Sessions
upheld the magisterial order and dismissed the revision petition. Hence, the
present petition, assailing the upholding of that magisterial order.
8.
While examining the maintainability of the present petition, what has
to be ascertained is as to whether the impugned denial of registration of FIR
and investigation is gross injustice, which can justify this High Court to
circumvent the explicit bar enacted under Section 438(3) BNSS and to
invoke inherent powers to direct registration of FIR.
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 4 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af396
2c6fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF
DELHI,CID - 7047638, postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40
f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:39:35 +05'30'
9.
Learned counsel for petitioner contended that the scope of revision
proceedings under Section 438 BNSS (the erstwhile Section 397 CrPC) is
distinct from the scope of inherent powers under Section 528 BNSS (the
erstwhile Section 482 CrPC). Learned counsel for petitioner contended that
present is a clear case of homicide as well as forgery of prescription, so a fit
case to direct registration of FIR. As regards maintainability of this petition,
learned counsel for petitioner placed reliance on two judicial precedents,
flowing from the Supreme Court, which are Krishnan & Anr. vs
Krishnaveni & Anr., (1997) 1 SCR 511; and Dhariwal Tobacco Products
Ltd. & Ors. vs State of Maharshtra & Anr., Criminal Appeal
No.2055/2007, decided on 17.12.2008. It was contended by learned counsel
for petitioner that merely because a litigant has availed remedy of criminal
revision, he cannot be barred from seeking invocation of inherent powers of
the High Court.
10.
The core issue in the present case, thus, pertains to the interplay of
Section 438(3) BNSS and Section 528 BNSS. It would be significant to note
that the erstwhile provisions under Section 397 CrPC and Section 482 CrPC
have in no manner been altered by Section 438 BNSS and Section 528
BNSS respectively. Therefore, the judicial precedents dealing with the
interplay of Section 397(3) CrPC and Section 482 CrPC would hold field
also as regards the interplay of Section 438(3) BNSS and Section 528
BNSS.
10.1 The purpose behind enactment of sub Sections (2) and (3) to Section
438 BNSS was to prevent delays in trial caused by accused by taking every
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 5 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec4556
9af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH
COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d155709
96b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa,
cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:39:23 +05'30'
order to every possible court of superior jurisdiction. Delay in trial almost
always benefits the accused. No doubt, the inherent powers vested in a High
Court are of wide magnitude and the same do not owe their existence to the
statutory provisions under Section 528 BNSS or even Section 482 CrPC; but
that cannot be read to mean completely untrammeled powers. While
exercising inherent powers, the High Court must be cautious not to permit a
backdoor entry to what is explicitly prohibited by sub Sections (2) and (3) of
Section 438 BNSS. If inherent powers are exercised in a routine manner by
the High Court, it would make sub Sections (2) and (3) of Section 438
BNSS completely otiose. At the same time, in exceptional circumstances,
where the High Court opines it to be a case of gross injustice or grave
miscarriage of justice, it shall not hesitate to invoke the inherent powers,
ignoring the prohibitions laid down by sub Sections (2) and (3) of Section
438 BNSS.
10.2 In the case of Krishnan (supra) relied upon by learned counsel for
petitioner himself, the Supreme Court examined the scope of both
provisions, namely Sections 397(3) and 482 CrPC and held that the object of
Section 397(3) is to put a bar on simultaneous revisional applications to the
High Court and the Court of Sessions, so as to prevent unnecessary delay
and multiplicity of proceedings. The Supreme Court held that the inherent
powers of the High Court are very wide, however, the High Court must
exercise such powers sparingly and cautiously where the Sessions Judge has
already exercised revisional powers; and that when the High Court notices
that there has been gross failure of justice or misuse of judicial mechanism
or procedure, sentence or order is not correct, it is but the salutary duty of
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 6 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec4
5569af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca,
ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d155
70996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e2
6fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:39:12 +05'30'
the High Court to prevent the abuse of process or miscarriage of justice or to
correct irregularities/incorrectness committed by the inferior criminal court
in its juridical process or illegality of sentence or order. The Supreme Court
specifically held thus:
“10. Ordinarily, when revision has been barred by Section
397(3) of the Code, a person — accused/complainant — cannot
be allowed to take recourse to the revision to the High Court
under Section 397(1) or under inherent powers of the High
Court under Section 482 of the Code since it may amount to
circumvention of the provisions of Section 397(3) or Section
397(2) of the Code. It is seen that the High Court has suo motu
power under Section 401 and continuous supervisory
jurisdiction under Section 483 of the Code. So, when the High
Court on examination of the record finds that there is grave
miscarriage of justice or abuse of the process of the courts or
the required statutory procedure has not been complied with or
there is failure of justice or order passed or sentence imposed
by the Magistrate requires correction, it is but the duty of the
High Court to have it corrected at the inception lest grave
miscarriage of justice would ensue. It is, therefore, to meet the
ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process that the High
Court is preserved with inherent power and would be justified,
under such circumstances, to exercise the inherent power and
in an appropriate case even revisional power under Section
397(1) read with Section 401 of the Code. As stated earlier, it
may be exercised sparingly so as to avoid needless multiplicity
of procedure, unnecessary delay in trial and protraction of
proceedings. The object of criminal trial is to render public
justice, to punish the criminal and to see that the trial is
concluded expeditiously before the memory of the witness
fades out. The recent trend is to delay the trial and threaten the
witness or to win over the witness by promise or inducement.
These malpractices need to be curbed and public justice can be
ensured only when trial is conducted expeditiously.”
(emphasis supplied)
10.3 In the case of Dhariwal Tobacco (supra), relied upon by learned
counsel for petitioner the question framed by the Supreme Court was as to
whether a petition under Section 482 CrPC can be dismissed only on the
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 7 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45
569af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca,
ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d1557
0996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa,
cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:39:02 +05'30'
premise that an alternative remedy of filing a revision petition under Section
397 CrPC is available. That is not the question involved in the present case.
The question involved in the present case is as to whether a person having
already availed of the remedy of revision under Section 397 CrPC
unsuccessfully can re-agitate the same issue by approaching the High Court
under Section 482 CrPC. However, in Dhariwal Tobacco (supra) also, the
Supreme Court referring to the earlier precedents reiterated the legal position
that when the High Court comes to conclusion that allowing the impugned
proceedings to continue would be an abuse of process of the court and that
the ends of justice require that the proceedings should be quashed, it would
not hesitate to do so.
10.4 In the case titled Exclusive Capital Ltd. vs State, Government of NCT
Delhi, 2026:DHC:6742, I had an occasion to examine the same issue as
involved in the present case. After recapitulating the relevant judicial
pronouncements in the cases tilted Amar Nath vs State of Haryana, (1977)
4 SCC 137; Madhu Limaye vs The State of Maharashtra, (1977) 4 SCC
551; State of Haryana vs Bhajan Lal, 1992 SCC (Cri) 426; and Girish
Kumar Suneja vs Central Bureau of Investigation, (2017) 14 SCC 809, it
was held thus:
“9. For present purposes, the legal position culled out of the
above cited judicial pronouncements is as follows. The provision
under Section 397(3) CrPC, which is now replaced by Section
438(3) BNSS stipulates an explicit prohibition that if a revision
petition has been preferred by any party to the High Court or to
the Court of Sessions, no further revision petition shall be
entertained by the said party. It is trite that what is explicitly
prohibited by law cannot be allowed backdoor entry by invoking
inherent powers, but this principle is subject to a harmonious
understanding that where the High Court, called upon to invoke
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 8 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec
45569af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca,
ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d1
5570996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff80
1e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:38:51 +05'30'
inherent powers is satisfied that the impugned order is clearly
without jurisdiction or abuse of process or there is gross
injustice, the High Court would be justified in rarest of rare
cases to invoke inherent powers and interfere. Such invocation
of inherent powers has to be done sparingly and not in routine.”
11.
In the present case, what is to be seen is as to whether the petitioner
has been able to set up a case which satisfies the above noted parameters for
invocation of inherent powers, in the sense as to whether dismissal of the
revision petition and the consequent upholding of dismissal of the
application under Section 156(3) CrPC can be treated as “rarest of rare case”
or of gross injustice or miscarriage of justice that would call for invoking the
inherent powers, which powers have to be invoked sparingly. The gross
injustice can be tested in a situation of the present nature by ascertaining as
to whether the petitioner has been rendered remediless after dismissal of his
revision petition, in the sense that the petitioner has no remedy other than
taking recourse to Article 126 of the Constitution of India, in which case the
decision of the Supreme Court need not be a reasoned decision; and if the
petitioner is left remediless, this Court would be justified to invoke inherent
powers and interfere to meet the ends of justice. I am of the considered view
that in the present case, the petitioner is not rendered remediless after
dismissal of his revision petition, because as mentioned above, his complaint
is already pending before the magisterial court for recording pre summoning
evidence.
11.1 Similar to the present case, the circumstances in the Exclusive Capital
(supra) also were that the order impugned before this court was the order
passed by the Court of Sessions in the revisional jurisdiction, upholding the
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 9 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec4
5569af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca,
ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d155
70996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e2
6fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:38:37 +05'30'
dismissal of application under Section 156(3) CrPC. After elaborate
discussion of the judicial precedents pertaining to the scope of Section
156(3) CrPC and Section 202 CrPC, it was concluded thus:
“15. To recapitulate, the learned magistrate as well as the
learned Court of Sessions have minutely discussed the overall
case set up by the present petitioner in arriving at concurrence,
broadly on the points that the dispute revolves around
interpretation of the contractual clauses; there is nothing that
requires immediate intervention of the State machinery in order
to decipher rights and liabilities of both sides under the
contract; and that since the present petitioner is fully aware of
not just identity of the proposed accused, but also the specific
role played by each of them, there is no need of police
assistance through custodial interrogation. And despite that, if
at some later stage, the magistrate so requires, police assistance
can always be taken invoking the provision under Section 225
BNSS, according to both courts. I am unable to find any
infirmity in the impugned order.
16. The petitioner, as rightly held by both courts below, may
step into the box and lead pre-summoning evidence, since it is
completely aware of the identity and role played by each of the
accused, and in case at some later stage, the magistrate so
requires, directions under Section 225 BNSS can always be
passed. That being so, it is certainly not a case that can be read
as gross injustice or miscarriage of justice to the present
petitioner, because it is not that the petitioner has been left
remediless on account of denial of directions to the police to
register FIR and investigate. Rather, grant of directions to
register FIR and investigate here would be gross injustice to
the accused persons, who would be arm-twisted on the basis of
those directions and would be compelled to settle what appears
to be only a civil dispute, synthetically tainted with criminality.
Nothing can be more abuse of process.”
(emphasis supplied)
12.
To conclude, the present is not a case of gross injustice or rarest of
rare case, in which this court can justifiably invoke inherent powers, which
powers have to be exercised sparingly; and that is so, because the petitioner
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 10 of 11 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3
962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF
DELHI,CID - 7047638, postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b
40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:38:26 +05'30'
is already before a court of competent jurisdiction, where his complaint is
already pending for pre summoning evidence. Consequently it is not a fit
case where inherent powers of the High Court be invoked in order to
interfere with the detailed and well reasoned orders passed by the learned
Magistrate and the learned Court of Sessions. Therefore, the present petition
is dismissed as not maintainable.
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec4
5569af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacca,
ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d155
70996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e2
6fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.09.23 10:38:09 +05'30'
GIRISH KATHPALIA
(JUDGE)
SEPTEMBER 23, 2026/ry
CRL.M.C. 119/2026
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL YADAV
10:56:33
Page 11 of 11 pages
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review