The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
45. A consistent line of precedent of this Court follows the principle that retrospective seniority cannot be granted to an employee from a date when the employee was not borne on a cadre. Seniority amongst members of the same grade has to be counted from the date of initial entry into the grade. This principle emerges from the decision of the Constitution Bench of this Court in Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers' Assn. v. State of Maharashtra. The principle was reiterated by this Court in State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath, and State of Uttaranchal v. Dinesh Kumar Sharma. In Pawan Pratap Singh v. Reevan Singh, this Court revisited the precedents on the subject and observed: (Pawan Pratap Singh case, SCC pp. 281-82, para 45) ‘45. … (i) The effective date of selection has to be understood in the context of the Service Rules under which the appointment is made. It may mean the date on which the process of selection starts with the issuance of advertisement or the factum of preparation of the select list, as the case may be. (ii) Inter se seniority in a particular service has to be determined as per the Service Rules. The date of entry in a particular service or the date of substantive appointment is the safest criterion for fixing seniority inter se between one officer or the other or between one group of officers and the other recruited from different sources. Any departur…
12. As such in view of the stated position of law, and there being no special circumstances or rules present that vest the petitioners with any right to claim for promotion from a retrospective date, there is no merit in the instant writ petition and the same is dismissed.
13. No order as to costs. Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 04
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 250 of 2020
Date of Decision: 30.01.2023
Shri Andrew Shabong & Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mrs. T.Yangi B. Sr. Adv. with
Ms. P. Tariang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H. Abraham, GA with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The case of the petitioners 3 in number in brief is that they
had all joined in service in 2009 after due selection to the post of
Lower Divisional Assistants in the Public Works Department,
Government of Meghalaya. The grievance as made out is that though
they had become eligible for promotion as far back in 2014, and
although there were vacancies in the promotional post of Upper
Divisional Assistants, the Departmental Promotion Committee which
was to consider the promotion of eligible LDAs did not meet for
several years, and that only in 03.03.2020 pursuant to a meeting of the
DPC held on 11.11.2019, the petitioners were given promotion to the
post of UDA with effect from the date of joining and not
retrospectively.
2.
Mrs. T. Yangi B. learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms.
P. Tariang, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the
petitioner No. 1 had joined service on 02.02.2009, petitioner No. 2 on
02.01.2009 and petitioner No. 3 on 11.02.2009, and as all had rendered
5 years of continuous service by 2014, had become eligible for
promotion to the post of UDA. It is further submitted that since 2012,
vacancies were present in the post of UDA, but however as the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) which ought to sit
regularly as per the Rules, did not meet to consider promotion of
eligible
employees,
the
writ
petitioners
submitted
several
representations to the respondent No. 3, requesting a meeting of the
DPC, to consider their promotion to next higher post from the date
they had become eligible.
3.
The learned Senior counsel submits that it is only on
11.11.2019 that the DPC met, and the petitioners were recommended
for promotion to the next higher post of UDA, which was thereafter
accordingly acted upon by Office Order No. 4 of 2019 issued on
03.03.2020. She submits that however their promotion was effective
from the date of joining. It is contended by the learned counsel that
vide Office Memorandum dated 06.03.1998, all Departments and
Offices have been advised to hold the Departmental Promotion
Committee well in time, preferably even before the date of occurrence
of vacancies and that the same had also been recommended by the
Fifth Pay Commission. This she submits, had not been adhered to by
the respondents which has resulted in the denial of the petitioners’
rights to be promoted from 2014. In support of her arguments, reliance
has been placed on the following judgments: i)
Judgment & Order dated 26.05.2022 passed in WP(C) No.
592 of 2021 (Shri Ahongshangbam Tomba Singh vs. State
of Manipur & Ors.) in the High Court of Manipur at
Imphal.
ii)
Judgment dated 1 July, 2996 (H.B. Sharma vs. Union of
India) Delhi High Court
iii)
Union of India & Anr. vs. Manpreet Singh Poonam & Ors.
reported in (2022) 6 SCC 105
4.
In reply Mr. H. Abraham, learned GA submits that the
non-holding of the DPC earlier was due to the fact that the office
records of the Department were gutted in a fire, and as such the
advisory on the holding of the DPC was not available. However, he
submits the DPC in its meeting held on 11.11.2019 had addressed the
grievances of the writ petitioners by recommending them for
promotion to the next higher post and suggested that Government
approval, be obtained with reference to the date eligibility of the
qualified candidates to UDA post. He further submits that the same
was not considered, as the delay in holding of the DPC was due to
genuine and unavoidable reasons, and there was no intentional,
deliberate or willful delay. The learned counsel further submits that in
view of the Government notification 04.09.2003, wherein it had been
clarified that regular promotion should be effective from the date an
officer takes over charge after promotion, orders had been issued
accordingly after the recommendation of the DPC.
5.
The learned counsel then closed his arguments by
submitting that seniority cannot be claimed from a date an employee
had not even been borne in the cadre, and that seniority is not to be
considered from the date when vacancy arose, but from the date on
which appointment was made to the post.
6.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties.
7.
The only point for consideration in the present writ petition
is the justifiability of the claim of the petitioners to promotion from a
retrospective date to the promotional post of UDA. As has been noted
from the arguments of the petitioners, their claim is based on only one
ground, which is that on the date when they had become eligible for
promotion, vacancies were available but due to the non-sitting of the
DPC, the said promotions could not be effected, which resulted in their
loss of seniority, which in turn has affected their future promotional
prospects.
8.
In matters of promotion with retrospective effect, it is
settled law that the same cannot be resorted to except on very sound
reasons and foundation, it becomes necessary to do so. There have
been cases, no doubt wherein retrospective promotion had been
granted and approved by the Courts, but the same were done on
consideration of special circumstances surrounding that particular
case, such as by operation of certain rules.
9.
In the instant case, as observed earlier the only claim to
retrospective date of appointment is due to the non-sitting of the DPC.
No averments have been made that scheduled DPC or DPC’s had been
cancelled or that there was any mala fide intent in not convening the
same. The only stand is that as per an advisory issued by the
respondents in the year 1998, DPC’s were to sit at regular intervals.
This however has been countered by the respondents in their reply,
that as per notification dated 04.09.2003, regular promotion should be
effective from the date the officer takes charge, after promotion orders
have been issued on the basis of recommendations of the DPC. The
Memorandum dated 04.09.2003 is reproduced hereinbelow:GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
PERSONNEL & ADMV. REFORMS (B) DEPARTMENT
………….
NO. PER(AR).123/87/9 Dated Shillong the 4th September, 2003
MEMORANDUM
There have been a number of instances, where
Administrative Departments have approached Government in the
Personnel & A.R. (B) Department for advice/views/approval in the
matter of promotion.
It is clarified that in matters of promotion made on the
basis of recommendations of the Departmental Promotion
Committee, the promotion cannot be made with retrospective effect.
The interse-seniority of members of service shall be in the order in
which the names appears in the list as recommended by the
Departmental Promotion Committee and the date of joining will
have no effect on the aforesaid seniority.
It is further clarified that full charge arrangement
cannot be considered and treated as cases of regular promotion,
even in cases where full charge arrangement is immediately
followed by regular promotion to the higher cadre/post. Regular
promotion should be effective from the date the Officer takes over
charge, after the promotion orders have been issued on the basis of
recommendation of the Departmental Promotion Committee. It has
been noticed that some doubts arises as to the date from which such
a regular appointment/promotion is to be given effect to, in the
absence of specific instructions in the matter. In order to clear any
doubt on the matter, it is reiterated that regular
appointment/promotion in such cases, should be with effect from the
date as stipulated in the original Government Notification/Office
Order by which such promotion under regulation 4(d) is made, or,
in the absence of a stipulated date there in, from the date of issue of
that Government Notification/Order itself.
(Sd/- W.M.S. Pariat),
Principal Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Personnel & Admv. Reforms (B) Department”
10.
Promotion to a higher post in the instant case is not a case
of functional promotion, but as can be seen involves a process of
selection and recommendation by a duly constituted DPC. A mere
existence of a vacancy therefore, will not create a vested right for an
eligible employee to claim for appointment on promotion to the said
post, especially when the same has to be finalized through a selection
process. A case that is relevant and has a bearing on the point in issue
wherein leading cases have been digested is the case of Union of India
& Anr. vs. K.L. Taneja & Anr., and other similar cases [WP(C) No.
8102/2012] decided by the Delhi High Court on 12.04.2013. In this
judgment which has great persuasive value, after analyzing many
cases on this point, at Para-21, it has been held as follows:“21. The cornucopia of case law above noted brings out
the position:(i)
Service Jurisprudence does not recognize
retrospective promotion i.e. a promotion from
a back date.
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
11.
If there exists a rule authorizing the Executive
to accord promotion from a retrospective date,
a decision to grant promotion from a
retrospective date would be valid because of a
power existing to do so.
Since mala fides taints any exercise of power
or an act done, requiring the person wronged
to be placed in the position the person would
find himself but for the mala fide and tainted
exercise of power or the act, promotion from a
retrospective date can be granted if delay in
promotion is found attributable to a mala fide
act i.e. deliberately delaying holding DPC,
depriving eligible candidates the right to be
promoted causing prejudice.
If due to administrative reasons DPC cannot
be held in a year and there is no taint of
malice, no retrospective promotion can be
made.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India
& Anr. vs. Manpreet Singh Poonam & Ors. reported in (2022) 6 SCC
105 in Paragraphs 18 to 21 also held as follows:“18. A mere existence of vacancy per se will not create
a right in favour of an employee for retrospective
promotion when the vacancies in the promotional post
are specifically prescribed under the rules, which also
mandate the clearance through a selection process. It is
also to be borne in mind that when we deal with a case
of promotion, there can never be a parity between two
separate sets of rules. In other words, a right to
promotion and subsequent benefits and seniority would
arise only with respect to the rules governing the said
promotion, and not a different set of rules which might
apply to a promoted post facilitating further promotion
which is governed by a different set of rules.
19. In the present case, the authority acting within the
rules has rightly granted promotion after clearance of
DPC on 17-04-2012 with effect from 01-07-2011, when
the actual vacancies arose, which in any case is a
benefit granted to the respondent in Civil Appeal
No.518 of 2017. In our view, this exercise of power by
the authority of granting retrospective promotion with
effect from the date on which actual vacancies arose is
based on objective considerations and a valid
classification.
20. This Court in Union of India v. K.K. Vadera has
clearly laid down that the promotion to a post should
only be granted from the date of promotion and not
from the date on which vacancy has arisen, and has
observed that: (SCC p. 627, para 5)
“5….We do not know of any law or any rule under
which a promotion is to be effective from the date of
creation of the promotional post after a post falls vacant
for any reason whatsoever, a promotion to that post
should be from the date the promotion is granted and
not from the date on which such post falls vacant. In the
same way when additional posts are created,
promotions to those posts can be granted only after the
Assessment Board has met and made its
recommendations for promotions being granted. If on
the contrary, promotions are directed to become
effective from the date of the creation of additional
posts, then it would have the effect of giving promotions
even before the Assessment Board has met and assessed
the suitability of the candidates for promotion. In the
circumstances, it is difficult to sustain the judgment of
the Tribunal.”
21. Similarly, this Court in Ganga Vishan Gujrati v.
State of Rajasthan, has held that: (SCC pp. 52-53, para
45)
45. A consistent line of precedent of this Court follows
the principle that retrospective seniority cannot be
granted to an employee from a date when the employee
was not borne on a cadre. Seniority amongst members
of the same grade has to be counted from the date of
initial entry into the grade. This principle emerges from
the decision of the Constitution Bench of this Court
in Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers' Assn. v. State
of Maharashtra. The principle was reiterated by this
Court in State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath,
and State of Uttaranchal v. Dinesh Kumar Sharma. In
Pawan Pratap Singh v. Reevan Singh, this Court
revisited the precedents on the subject and observed:
(Pawan Pratap Singh case, SCC pp. 281-82, para 45)
‘45. … (i) The effective date of selection has to be
understood in the context of the Service Rules under
which the appointment is made. It may mean the date
on which the process of selection starts with the
issuance of advertisement or the factum of preparation
of the select list, as the case may be.
(ii) Inter se seniority in a particular service has to be
determined as per the Service Rules. The date of entry
in a particular service or the date of substantive
appointment is the safest criterion for fixing seniority
inter se between one officer or the other or between one
group of officers and the other recruited from different
sources. Any departure therefrom in the statutory rules,
executive instructions or otherwise must be consistent
with the requirements of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution.
(iii) Ordinarily, notional seniority may not be granted
from the backdate and if it is done, it must be based on
objective considerations and on a valid classification
and must be traceable to the statutory rules.
(iv) The seniority cannot be reckoned from the date of
occurrence of the vacancy and cannot be given
retrospectively unless it is so expressly provided by the
relevant service rules. It is so because seniority cannot
be given on retrospective basis when an employee has
not even been borne in the cadre and by doing so it may
adversely affect the employees who have been appointed
validly in the meantime.’
This view has been re-affirmed by a Bench of three
Judges of this Court in P. Sudhakar Rao v. U. Govinda
Rao.”
12.
As such in view of the stated position of law, and there
being no special circumstances or rules present that vest the petitioners
with any right to claim for promotion from a retrospective date, there
is no merit in the instant writ petition and the same is dismissed.
13.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
30.01.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review