Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:536
Serial No.24
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 120 of 2023
Date of Decision :12.06.2024
Shri. Andrew H.Khonglam,
Son of Shri. Shaphranglin E.Sohliya,
Resident of Lumbalang, Malki, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
The State of Meghalaya through the
Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya Civil Secretariat at Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya,
which post is now held by Shri. E.Kharmalki,
IAS, Chairman of the Departmental Promotion
Committee, Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya, held on 14.03.2023.
2.
The Joint Secretary of Meghalaya,
Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya Civil Secretariat at Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
3.
The Under Secretary, Government of Meghalaya
Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya Civil Secretariat at Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
4.
The Director of Mineral Resource,
Government of Meghalaya, Risa Colony,
Shillong – 793003, East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya,
which post is now held by Shri. P.D.Sangma, MCS,
2024:MLHC:536
Member of the Departmental Promotion Committee,
Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya, held on 14.03.2023.
5.
Smti. A.Kharpor, MCS,
Joint Secretary,
Personnel (AR) Department,
Government of Meghalaya,
Meghalaya Civil Secretariat, Shillong,
Member of the Departmental Promotion Committee,
Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya, held on 14.03.2023.
6.
Shri. P.Hoojon, MFS,
Joint Secretary,
Finance (B) Department,
Government of Meghalaya,
Meghalaya Civil Secretariat, Shillong,
Member of the Departmental Promotion Committee,
Mining and Geology Department,
Meghalaya, held on 14.03.2023.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.Chakrawarty, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. E.Laloo, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mrs. T.Yangi B, AAG with
Ms. R.Colney, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:536
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The petitioner by way of the instant writ petition has put a challenge
to the constitution and recommendations of a Departmental Promotion
Committee which had met on 14-03-2023, for considering the promotion
of the petitioner and 2 other candidates to the post of Chemist by alleging
that the said DPC had exercised powers which were in excess and beyond
the scope of such Committees.
2.
A brief overview of the facts is that the petitioner who is presently
serving as an Assistant Chemist in the Mining & Geology Department,
Government of Meghalaya, had initially entered service as a Lab Assistant
on the recommendation of the Departmental Selection Committee on 1001-2003 on a temporary basis. Thereafter, the petitioner by Office Order
dated 18-07-2006, was allowed to officiate temporarily in the promotional
post of Assistant Chemist which was then regularized vide Office Order
dated 22-07-2008. The writ petitioner had earlier approached this Court by
way of WP(C). No. 94 of 2018 with a prayer that he be considered for
promotion to the post of Chemist, and this Court, then by order dated 1504-2021 directed that, as and when the Departmental Promotion
Committee sat, the petitioner was to be considered for the same. This was
followed by another writ petition being WP(C). No.168 of 2021, on the
2024:MLHC:536
same prayer, wherein directions were issued that the promotional exercise
should be completed within a period of two months. A contempt
application was also filed alleging violation of this Court’s order, but
however, the same was withdrawn.
3.
In the DPC held on 14-03-2023, which was convened and had sat
for considering the promotion of the petitioner and two other candidates,
the petitioner as also the two other candidates were found not eligible to be
given promotion on the ground of nature of engagement in the case of the
petitioner and one Shri. R.D.Sangma, and lacking in qualification in the
case of the third candidate namely, Shri. M.Nongrum. The petitioner being
aggrieved with the findings and recommendations of the DPC as regards
his candidature, on the assertion that the DPC has exceeded its mandate, is
therefore before this Court by way of this instant application.
4.
Mr. S.Chakrawarty, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. E.Laloo,
learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner has firstly referred to the order
of this Court dated 05-04-2021, passed in WP(C). No. 94 of 2018, and
submits that this Court by the said order had observed that with regard to
promotion to the post of Chemist, as the petitioner is qualified in all
respects for consideration, his name was to be considered as and when the
Departmental Promotion Committee sat. It is contended by the learned Sr.
counsel that this Court having observed as such, and further the services of
2024:MLHC:536
the petitioner having been confirmed in the post of Assistant Chemist,
which is a feeder post for promotion to the post of Chemist, the DPC in
rejecting his candidature on the ground that his initial appointment had not
been regularized, and the recommendation that his case be taken up for
regularization, had gone beyond its mandate as permissible by law. He
further submits that similar recommendation had also been made by the
DPC with regard to the candidature of Shri. R.D.Sangma which is uncalled
for in such proceedings, inasmuch as, the name of the petitioner and the
two others had been shortlisted by the Department itself for consideration
by the DPC. He therefore submits, the said proceedings being irregular and
beyond the scope and mandate of the DPC, the same was liable to be
interfered with by this Court, and the said proceedings be declared null and
void.
5.
Mrs. T.Yangi B, learned AAG assisted by Ms. R.Colney, learned
GA on behalf of the respondents, in reply submitted that the DPC held on
14-03-2023, was in compliance to the directions of this Court and was
constituted as per the
‘The Meghalaya Mineral Service Rules, 2018’
which though still a draft, is being followed by the Department. She further
submits that the rejection of the petitioner’s candidature by the DPC
cannot be said to be illegal, irregular or malafide, as the DPC was correct
in observing after scrutinizing the petitioner’s service records that the
2024:MLHC:536
initial temporary appointment was yet to be regularized. It is also
submitted that the promotion given to the petitioner to the post of Assistant
Chemist could not have been regularized, inasmuch as, he was serving in
an officiating capacity and therefore, there was no question that the
petitioner be considered for further promotion. On the aspect of
interference being sought by the petitioner on the findings of DPC, the
learned AAG has contended that unless the process of assessment is
vitiated either on the ground of bias, malafides or arbitrariness, Courts do
not sit as an Appellate Authority over a Committee that has been duly
constituted, and consists of members who have expertise and experience in
the matter. In support of her arguments, learned AAG has cited the
following decisions:
(i)
H.S.Sidhu vrs. Devendra Bapna & Ors. (2016) 1 SCC 495,
para 13.
(ii)
Union Public Service Commission vrs. M.Sathiya Priya &
Ors. (2018) 15 SCC 796, paras 17, 21, 22 & 23.
(iii)
Mohd. Mustafa vrs. Union of India & Ors. (2022) 1 SCC
294, paras 15, 18 & 36.
She therefore, submits that as the findings of the DPC being based
on hard facts are not vitiated in any manner, the writ petition deserves no
consideration.
2024:MLHC:536
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, it is seen that the case
of the petitioner is a curious case indeed. This observation is being made in
view of the fact that though the initial appointment of the petitioner as Lab
Assistant on being selected by the Departmental Selection Committee on
10-01-2003 was purely on a temporary basis, for all practical purposes this
appointment was considered substantive and regular by the respondents. It
is not understood as to how the petitioner whose services were yet to be
regularized, was allowed to officiate in the promotional post of Assistant
Chemist from 18-07-2007, which was then regularized on the
recommendation of a DPC held on 11-07-2008. The petitioner was
subsequently allowed to cross the Efficiency Bar by order dated 04-092014, and thereafter, by Office Order dated 30-01-2020, was confirmed in
service against the post of Assistant Chemist. As such, from these
sequence of events, it was but natural that the petitioner aspired for
promotion to the higher post of Chemist on attaining the required
qualifying years of service, for which he sought a mandamus from this
Court by way of WP(C). No. 94 of 2018, followed by WP(C). No. 168 of
2021. In the order dated 05-04-2021, this Court on the respondent’s
submission of the eligibility criteria for appointment to the post of
Chemist, along with a list of names of the persons who were to be
2024:MLHC:536
considered for promotion which included the petitioner, had recorded the
same at para 6 thereof, and the same is reproduced herein below:
“6. On the last date, i.e. on the 31.03.2021, this Court on
being apprised about this position, had directed the learned
State counsel for the respondent No. 1 to 4 to obtain precise
instructions as to whether the petitioner is being considered
by the respondents for promotion to the vacant post of
Chemist as has been indicated in the letter. Today, Mr. H.
Abraham, learned GA to this query, has referred to that part
of the instructions received from the respondents 1-4,
wherein eligibility criteria for promotion and names of
persons who are to be considered have been given. This note
is taken cognizance by this Court at this stage, and the
eligibility criteria and names of persons as submitted, is
reproduced herein below: “ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA - Appointment to the post of
Chemist shall be made 50% by promotion from amongst the
Assistant Chemist who must possess B.Sc. with chemistry
and have rendered not less than 5(five) years of continuous
service in the post of Assistant Chemist on the first day of
the years in which the selection is made.
NAME OF THE PERSONS.
Sl.
No.
Name &
Designation of
incumbent
1. Shri M. Nongrum,
Asstt. Chemist
2. Shri Robert D.
Sangma, Asstt.
Chemist
3. Shri A. Khonglam,
Asstt. Chemist
Dt. of
joining in
the present
post.
30.08.2002
Dt. of
regularization
in the present
post
18.07.2006
Educational
Qualification
17.09.2002
Adhoc/
Officiating
B.Sc.
(Chemistry)
18.07.2006
18.07.2006
B.Sc.
(Chemistry)
P.U.C.
Remarks
By.
D.P.C.
Yet to be
regulariz
ed
By
D.P.C.
2024:MLHC:536
7.
From what has been narrated above, it can be plainly seen that the
Department for all practical purposes considered and treated the petitioner
as a regular employee, to the extent that even before this Court had
furnished his name as one of the candidates who were to be considered for
promotion to the post of Chemist. At this juncture, after the petitioner has
rendered over 21 years in service, the stand that is sought to be taken by
the respondents that the entire service life of the petitioner would not
amount to vesting him with any rights or actionable claim would surely
result in the violation of his rights, as he also has been visited with civil
consequences. This Court cannot overlook the fact that apart from his
initial appointment which may be at the most irregular, but not illegal, the
career progression of the petitioner has been in accordance with law, and at
this stage to rewind the clock and divest him of rights he has since accrued,
would result in manifest injustice being caused.
8.
In the backdrop of these facts therefore, and to balance the equities,
it is accordingly directed that as per the recommendation of the DPC held
on 14-03-2023, the respondent No. 4 i.e., the Director of Mineral
Resources shall immediately take up the case of the petitioner with the
concerned Departments for regularization of his initial appointment either
by the Meghalaya Public Service Commission or the District Selection
Committee as the case may be. This may be facilitated by a special
2024:MLHC:536
selection by the concerned body. As the petitioner is serving against a
sanctioned post, and having been duly confirmed in the same by the
respondents, it shall not be open for them to review or revert the petitioner
to his initial post, as in the considered view of this Court the regularization
of the petitioner’s services will be but a formality keeping in mind the fact
that he had been appointed much prior to 2007, wherein in such similar
adhoc or temporary appointments, the Cabinet by a Memorandum dated
23rd June, 2022, had regularized such appointments.
9.
Further, no case having been made out to show that the DPC
proceedings were vitiated in any manner, the same is not interfered with.
10.
Accordingly, as per the directions given hereinabove, the writ
petition stands closed and disposed of.
11.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
12.06.2024
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
ANNA LIYA RYNJAH
Date: 2024.06.12 18:25:52 +05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review