Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 3403 OF 2017
JUDGMENT:
Assailing the Order and decree dated 28.08.2017 in M.V.O.P.No.300 of
2016 passed by the Chairman, Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Tribunal-cumPrincipal District Judge, Kadapa, respondent Nos.1 and 2 filed the instant
appeal for awarding compensation at Rs.12,00,000/- for the untimely death of
K. Mani Raju.
2.
The parties are being referred to as ‘petitioners’ and ‘respondents’ as
arrayed in the petition before the Tribunal, for the sake of convenience and
clarity.
3. The case of the petitioners is thus:
On 24.12.2015 at about 06.30 P.M, while the deceased proceeding from
Porumamilla to Kalasapadu on his motorcycle and when he reached Sidda
Murthipalli Village, the driver of APSRTC bus bearing No.AP28 Z 820 drove
the same in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against his motorcycle
and as a result of which, deceased sustained fatal injuries. Immediately after
the accident, while he was shifting to RIMS Hospital, Kadapa, died on the way
to hospital. As on the date of the accident, deceased hale and healthy, was
aged about 18 years, working as motorcycle mechanic and was earning
Rs.300/- per day and contributing the same for maintenance of his family.
Due to the sudden demise, the petitioners, who are dependants of the
deceased lost their financial support as well as love and affection. Since the
accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
APSRTC bus bearing No.AP28 Z 820, a case in Crime No.103 of 2015 is
registered of the offences under Sections 337 and 304-A of the Indian Penal
Code (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Code’) against the driver of the offending
vehicle. Respondent No.1 is APSRTC represented by its Regional Manager,
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
Kadapa City, respondent No.2 is the Manager, APSRTC Depot, Giddaluru
(town), Prakasam District and respondent No.3 is the driver of the offending
vehicle and as such, the respondents are jointly and severally liable to pay the
compensation.
4.
Having received notice, respondent Nos.2 and 3 remained ex parte.
Respondent No.1 filed written statement refuting the averments made in the
petition, wherein, inter alia contended that there is no negligence on the part
of the driver of the bus, the said bus was not at all involved in the accident and
it is planted for the purpose of the case, a false case is foisted against the
driver of the bus as the accident took place prior to the arrival of the bus at the
spot where accident took place, deceased had no valid driving license, as on
the date of the accident, petitioners claimed excessive compensation, and
with other formal denials, prayed to dismiss the petition.
5.
Taking into consideration of the aforementioned pleadings, the learned
Tribunal settled the following issues:
1) Whether the deceased K. Mani Raju died due to the injuries
sustained in a motor vehicle accident on 24.12.2015, due to rash
and negligent driving of the driver of the APSRTC bus bearing
No.AP28-Z-820?
2) Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to
what amount and from whom?
3) To what relief?
6.
During trial, petitioner No.2 examined himself as PW.1 and the
petitioners have got examined independent witnesses as P.W Nos.2 & 3, and
filed Exs.A1 to A4 documents. As against the said evidence, respondent No.1
has not adduced either oral or documentary evidence. At the culmination of
trial, learned Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs.12,00,000/- for the
untimely death of K. Mani Raju.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
7.
Being aggrieved by the said Order and decree, the respondent Nos.1
and 2/appellants preferred the instant appeal, urging the principal grounds
that:
(i)
The Order and decree of the learned Tribunal is contrary to law, weight
of evidence and probabilities of the case.
(ii)
The learned Tribunal ought to have held that there was no negligence
on the part of the driver of the bus and that the accident occurred only
due to the rash and negligent driving of the deceased.
(iii)
The learned Tribunal ought to have seen that the deceased had no valid
driving license.
(iv)
The learned Tribunal erroneously taken the income of the deceased at
Rs.6,000/- per month.
(v)
The learned Tribunal erred in awarding compensation under various
heads and granted excessive compensation.
(vi)
The learned Tribunal erroneously added 50% of the income to the
actual income of the deceased towards future prospects, and with other
formal grounds, prayed to allow the appeal.
8.
Heard both sides.
9.
Perused petition and other material available on record including the
impugned order dated 28.08.2017.
10.
On hearing both sides and upon perusing the material placed on
record, the points that would arise for consideration are as follows:
(1) Whether K. Mani Raju died in the accident dated 24.12.2015
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
APSRTC bus bearing No.AP28-Z-820?
(2) Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation? If so, to
what amount?
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
(3) Whether the Order and decree dated 28.08.2017 passed in
M.V.O.P.No.300 of 2016 by the Chairman, Motor Vehicle Accident
Claims
Tribunal-cum-Principal
District
Judge,
Kadapa
are
sustainable in facts and law?
(4) To what relief?
11.
Admittedly, petitioners have not filed any appeal or cross objection
challenging the findings of the learned Tribunal, however, being the first
appellate court and final fact finding court, this court has to re-examine and reappreciate the entire oral as well as documentary evidence on record.
12. Point No.1:
(a)
Now, it is necessary to analyze the evidence on record to answer the
points. As seen from the record, during trial, petitioner No.2 filed examinationin-chief in lieu of chief examination by reiterating the averments mentioned in
the petition. In order to prove the manner and method of accident, petitioners
relied upon the evidence of PW Nos.1 and 2 coupled with Exs.A1 to A4
documents. It is evident from the record that P.W.1 who is father of the
deceased is not an eye witness to the accident and the only available
evidence to prove the manner and method of accident is that of P.W.2 and he
testified that on 24.12.2025, he attended beldari work in Chennareddypalli
Village and after completion of work, while he was proceeding to his village,
driver of the APSRTC bus bearing No.AP28 Z 820 drove the same in a rash
and negligent manner and dashed against the motorcycle of the deceased
and as a result, deceased fell down and his motorcycle dashed one Thirupal
Reddy, he also sustained injuries. According to him, the accident occurred
only due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the bus.
(b)
Further, a case in crime No.103 of 2015 under Sections 337 & 304-A of
the Code is registered vide EX.A1/First information report against the driver of
the APSRTC bus and after completion of investigation, police laid
EX.A4/Charge sheet alleging that the accident occurred due to the rash and
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
negligent driving of driver of the bus. No rebuttal evidence is adduced by the
respondents. Having filed written statement, respondent No.1 has not
examined the driver of the bus who is the best person to speak about the
accident and his non-examination is fatal to the case of respondents. So, the
evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 coupled with EXs.A1 and A4 clinchingly proves that
the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of driver of the
bus. It is evident from EX.A3/Postmortem report that the deceased
succumbed to the injuries sustained in the accident.
Hence, this point is
answered holding that the accident occurred only due to the rash and
negligent driving of driver of the APSRTC bus bearing No.AP 28 Z 820,
deceased sustained injuries in the said accident and succumbed to the said
injuries.
13. Point No.2:
(a)
As per the version of petitioners, they are parents of the deceased and
the deceased hale and healthy, aged about 18 years, working as motorcycle
mechanic and was earning Rs.300/- per day, as on the date of the accident
and due to his sudden demise, they lost their financial support as well as love
and affection. As seen from EX.A2/Inquest report and EX.A3/Post-mortem
report, age of the deceased is mentioned as 18 years. There is no contra
evidence to that effect. So, it can safely be concluded that the age of the
deceased was 18 years as on the date of accident and the relevant multiplier
is ‘18’. The petitioners who are none other than the dependants of the
deceased are entitled for compensation.
(b)
So far as earnings of the deceased is concerned, petitioners have relied
upon the evidence of P.W.3 and he testified that the deceased working as two
wheeler mechanic in his mechanic shed and was drawing Rs.300/- per day.
The learned Tribunal assessed the notional monthly income at Rs.6,000/-.
There is no reason to disbelieve the evidence of P.W.3 and except posing bald
suggestions, nothing useful material is elicited in the cross examination of
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
P.W.3. In the given facts and circumstances coupled with the evidence of
P.W.3 and on a hypothesis basis, monthly income of the deceased have to be
considered at Rs.9,000/-.
(c)
By applying the principles in Sarala Varma and Others Vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation and another 1 and National Insurance Company
Ltd Vs. Pranay Sethi and others 2 and Magma General Insurance
Company Limited v. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram and others3, this court
has assessed the compensation as follows:
Heads
Sl.
No.
Annual Income (Rs.9000 X 12)
1.
Calculation
Rs.
1,08,000.00
Rs.
54,000.00
3.
Deduction towards personal expenses
(1,08,000x1/2)
Total income (1,08,000-54000)
Rs.
54,000.00
4.
Future prospects (40% of 54000)
Rs.
21,600.00
5.
Rs.
13,60,800.00
Rs.
80,000.00
7.
Total loss of dependency (54,000+21,600) =
75,600x18
Loss of consortium (40,000x2)
(filial)
Funeral expenses
Rs.
15,000.00
8.
Loss of estate
Rs.
15,000.00
Rs.
14,70,800.00
2.
6.
Total
(d)
In the given facts and circumstances of the case, petitioners are entitled
for Rs.14,70,800/- (Rupees Fourteen Lakhs Seventy Thousand Eight
Hundred Only) and in this courts well considered view, the compensation
awarded is just, adequate and reasonable, as the deceased left his
dependents.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2017) 16 SCC 680
(2018) 18 SCC 130
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
(e)
So far as the liability of the respondents is concerned, it is to be noted
that a finding is already recorded in issue No.1, holding that respondent
No.3/Driver of bus bearing No.AP28 Z 820 was solely responsible for the
accident and respondent Nos.1 & 2/APSRTC are vicariously liable to
indemnify the liability of respondent No.3/driver. Hence, this issue is
answered, holding that the respondent Nos.1 to 3 are jointly and severally
liable to pay compensation.
14. Point No.3:
Upon reappraisal of the evidence on record, and for the foregoing
reasons, this court came to conclusion that the learned Tribunal erred in
assessing the quantum of compensation and as such, the same is liable to be
modified. Hence, this point is answered accordingly.
15. Point No.4:
(i)
In the result, and in view of the findings in point Nos.1 to 3, this
Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed, while modifying the
order of the learned Tribunal by enhancing the compensation from
Rs.12,00,000/- (Rupees Twleve Lakhs Only) to Rs.14,70,800/- (Rupees
Fourteen Lakhs Seventy Thousand Eight Hundred Only) together with
interest at the same rate as awarded by the Tribunal, from the date of the
claim petition till the date of realization, subject to payment of additional court
fee on Rs.4,70,800/- (Rupees Four Lakhs Seventy Thousand Eight
Hundred Only) by the petitioners before the Registry within thirty (30) days
from today.
(ii)
Out of the said compensation amount, Rs.7,35,400/- (Rupees Seven
Lakhs Thirty Five Thousand Four Hundred Only) each is awarded to the
petitioner Nos.1 and 2. Apportionment is ordered accordingly.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.3403 of 2017
(iii)
Time for deposit, as aforesaid, with interest, excluding the amount, if
any, already deposited, is one (1) month from the date of receipt of a copy of
this judgment.
(iv)
On such deposit, petitioner Nos.1 and 2 are permitted to withdraw the
compensation as awarded supra along with accrued interest thereon,
excluding the amount, already paid.
(v)
There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
SUNITHA GANDHAM, J
Dt: 02.11.2026
Vns
Whether the order is :
✓
Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No
✓
Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review