Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
****
M.A.C.M.A. No. 2289 of 2012
Between:
ANDHRA PRADESH STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, MUSHEERABAD,
HYDERABAD.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. VELLANKI
LAKSHMI,
W/O.
VELLANKI
SEETARAMAIAH,
HOUSEWIFE, R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTHI COLONY, PATAMATA,
2. VELLANKI NAGA SWARAJYA LAKSHMI, W/O. VELLANKI
VENKATESWARA RAO, EMPLOYEMENT, R/O. PLOT NO. 60,
MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
3. VELLANKI KUSALAVA CHOWDARY, S/O. VENKATESWARA RAO,
R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
4. VELLANKI RAAGA SUVARCHALA, D/O. VENKATESWARA RAO,
STUDENT, R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
5. BODDU YESUPADAM, S/O. JOHN, DRIVER,APSRTC CITY BUS
NO. AP 9Z 3883, ROUTE NO. 8-B, R/O. VELLATUR, KRISHNA
DISTRICT. ( 5TH RESPONDENT NOT NECESSARY PARTY )
...RESPONDENT(S)
DATE OF JUDGMENT/ORDER PRONOUNCED: 11.09.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
1. Whether
Reporters
of
Local
newspapers may be allowed to see
the Judgments?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may
be
marked
to
Law
Reporters/Journals
Yes/No
3. Whether Your Lordships wish to see
the fair copy of the Judgment?
Yes/No
__________________________
JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
* THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
+ M.A.C.M.A. No. 2289 OF 2012
% 11.09.2026
Between:
ANDHRA PRADESH STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, MUSHEERABAD,
HYDERABAD.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. VELLANKI
LAKSHMI,
W/O.
VELLANKI
SEETARAMAIAH,
HOUSEWIFE, R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTHI COLONY, PATAMATA,
2. VELLANKI NAGA SWARAJYA LAKSHMI, W/O. VELLANKI
VENKATESWARA RAO, EMPLOYEMENT, R/O. PLOT NO. 60,
MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
3. VELLANKI KUSALAVA CHOWDARY, S/O. VENKATESWARA RAO,
R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
4. VELLANKI RAAGA SUVARCHALA, D/O. VENKATESWARA RAO,
STUDENT, R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
5. BODDU YESUPADAM, S/O. JOHN, DRIVER,APSRTC CITY BUS
NO. AP 9Z 3883, ROUTE NO. 8-B, R/O. VELLATUR, KRISHNA
DISTRICT. ( 5TH RESPONDENT NOT NECESSARY PARTY )
! Counsel for the Appellant:
^ Counsel for the respondents:
< Gist :
> Head Note:
? Cases Referred:
(2017) 16 SCC 680
(2020) SCC Online SC 410
2024 INSC 584
(2005) 6 SCC 344
(2012) 1 SCC 455
...RESPONDENT(S)
Sri. P. Venkata Rao, SC for APSRTC
Sri. Umadevi Manchala
APHC010545552012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3605]
FRIDAY, THE 11th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2289/2012
Between:
1. ANDHRA PRADESH STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, MUSHEERABAD,
HYDERABAD.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. VELLANKI LAKSHMI, W/O. VELLANKI SEETARAMAIAH, HOUSEWIFE,
R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTHI COLONY, PATAMATA,
2. VELLANKI
NAGA
SWARAJYA
LAKSHMI,
W/O.
VELLANKI
VENKATESWARA RAO, EMPLOYEMENT, R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI
COLONY, PATAMATA,
3. VELLANKI KUSALAVA CHOWDARY, S/O. VENKATESWARA RAO,
R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
4. VELLANKI RAAGA SUVARCHALA, D/O. VENKATESWARA RAO,
STUDENT, R/O. PLOT NO. 60, MARUTI COLONY, PATAMATA,
5. BODDU YESUPADAM, S/O. JOHN, DRIVER,APSRTC CITY BUS NO.
AP 9Z 3883, ROUTE NO. 8-B, R/O. VELLATUR, KRISHNA DISTRICT. (
5TH RESPONDENT NOT NECESSARY PARTY )
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. P VENKATA RAO SC For APSRTC
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. .
2. UMADEVI MANCHALA
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
M.A.C.M.A.No.2289 of 2012
The Court made the following JUDGEMENT:
1. The Appeal is filed by the A.P.S.R.T.C challenging the award of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-II Additional District Judge, Vijayawada,
dated 25.02.2006 in M.V.O.P.No.767 of 2002, assailing the quantum of
compensation.
I. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
2. The learned counsel for the Appellant/APSRTC submits that the
Tribunal committed an error in assessing the monthly income of the deceased
at Rs.5,900/- merely on the basis of the salary certificate without examining any
competent authority from the concerned college to prove the salary certificate.
That the Tribunal erred in applying the multiplier of ‘15’, according to the learned
counsel, the age of the deceased was 42 years and, therefore, the appropriate
multiplier is ‘14’, and prayed for modification of the award by reducing the
quantum of compensation for the aforesaid reasons.
3. Per contra, the learned counsel for the Claimants submits that the
Tribunal was justified in assessing the income of the deceased at Rs.5,900/- per
month.
The Tribunal rightly relied on the evidence of PW3, who was working
as an Office Assistant in the College, and who deposed on the aspects of
employment, income of the deceased, service and salary certificates.
4. The learned counsel for the Claimants fairly submits that, having
regard to the age of the deceased, the applicable multiplier is ‘14’.
5. The learned counsel further contended that, though the Claimants
have not preferred any Appeal or Cross Objection, this Court, for determining
just compensation, is empowered to correct an error committed by the Tribunal
and to award just compensation in accordance with law, and submits that the
Claimants are entitled to future prospects at the rate of 40%, considering the
permanent nature of the employment of the deceased. It is also submitted that
the Tribunal erroneously deducted 1/3rd of the income of the deceased towards
his personal and living expenses, whereas the Claimants are four in number
and, therefore, only 1/4th ought to have been deducted under that head, and
prayed to enhance the compensation.
II. ANALYSIS:
6. The case of the Claimants is that they are the mother, wife, son and
daughter of Vellanki Venkateswara Rao/deceased. That on 24.11.2001, the
said Venkateswara Rao was proceeding on his bicycle, near Brother’s Ice
Parlour, Benz Circle, when the Respondent No.1 drove the offending APSRTC
Bus/ AP 9 Z 3883 in a rash and negligent manner, and dashed it against the
said bicycle on its back, he sustained grievous injuries and succumbed to the
injuries on the spot. In this regard, Crime No.581 of 2001 was registered against
the Respondent No.1. The Claim is filed for Rs.7,10,000/-.
7. The 1st Respondent did not file counter. The 2nd Respondent filed
counter denying the material averments of the Claim Petition, including the
manner of the accident and the negligent driving of the 1st Respondent. Also
pleaded that there was no rash and negligent driving of the 1st Respondent, but
the negligent riding of the bicycle by the said Venkateswara Rao/deceased was
the cause for the accident, that they are not liable to pay compensation, and
prayed to dismiss the Claim.
8. As the case is not settled, the Tribunal framed the following points for
determination:
1.
Whether the deceased died in the motor accident due to rash and
negligent driving of the offending crime vehicle by the 1st
Respondent?
2.
What is the age and income of the deceased on the date of the
accident?
3.
Whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation? If so, to what
amount and from whom?
4.
To what relief?
9. In the Tribunal, the Claimants examined the evidence of PW.1 to 3,
PW.1: V.N.S.Lakshmi, PW.2: K. Narasimha Rao, PW.3: S.D.N.V. Vikram,
exhibited A1 to A7/Ex.A1-FIR, Ex.A2-Inquest report, Ex.A3- P.M.Report, Ex.A4M.V.I. Report, Ex.A5-Charge Sheet, Ex.A6- Service Certificate, Ex.A7-Salary
Certificate
and Ex.X1-Service Certificate, Ex.X2-Salary Certificate, Ex.X3-
Salary statement from 1/2000-9/2001, 10/01-11/01, Ex.X5-Service particulars,
Ex.X6-Authorisation letter. The 2nd Respondent is examined RW1.
10. The Tribunal answered all 4 points in favour of the claimants.
11. The sole point to be determined in this Appeal is whether the
Claimants could prove that the salary of Vellanki Venkateswara Rao/deceased
was Rs.5,900/- per month and what is the compensation to be awarded? After
conclusion of the arguments, there is no dispute on the road accident, negligent
driving by the 1st Respondent by the offending Bus, death of Vellanki
Venkateswara Rao in the accident, and relationship of the Claimants.
12. The Tribunal, upon appreciation of the evidence on record, including
the evidence of PW.2/eye witness and the Charge Sheet/Ex.A5, also convicting
the 1st Respondent by the Magistrate, recorded a finding that the accident was
due to the rash and negligent driving of the offending Bus by the Respondent
No.1.
13. The Tribunal further recorded a finding based on the evidence of
PW.3, Salary Certificate, Service Certificate, Records/Ex.A6, A7 and X.1 to X.6,
that the deceased was working as a college clerk and arrived at his income of
Rs.5,900/- per month, deducted 1/3rd towards his personal and living expenses,
applied multiplier ‘15’, arrived at compensation of Rs.7,02,000/- and also
awarded Rs.30,000/- towards loss of estate and consortium. Also, the Tribunal
observed that though the total is Rs.7,32,000/-, but confining to Rs.7,10,000/and accordingly awarded compensation of Rs.7,10,000/- as claimed by the
Claimants.
14. This Court in M.A.C.M.A.M.P.No.5070 of 2006 dated 11.10.2006
ordered an interim stay on condition that the Petitioner/Appellant shall deposit
half of the Award amount, together with proportionate costs and interest, within
a period of 6 weeks from today.
On such deposit, the Claimants shall be
entitled to withdraw their respective shares in the same proportion, subject to
the same conditions as imposed by the Tribunal, without furnishing any security.
The Appeal has been listed for many times over all these years.
15. The material on record reveals that the deceased was working as a
college clerk. The salary certificate and service certificates produced before the
Tribunal disclose that the deceased had been working in the College since
29.08.1983 and shows he was in permanent employment.
16. The Tribunal assessed his monthly income at Rs.5,900/- per month.
The contention of the Appellant that the salary certificate was not proved by
examining an officer from the concerned college is incorrect, as the evidence of
PW3, who was working as an Office Assistant, lends support to the employment
and income of the deceased. Further, the salary certificate and service
certificates indicate that the deceased was in employment since 29.08.1983.
17. As per the law laid down by the Hon’ble Constitutional Bench of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in National Insurance Company v.
Pranay Sethi1, in para 61(iii), for permanent job, 30% to be added as future
prospects for the age group of 40 to 50 years. As rightly contended by the
learned Counsel for the Claimants, this Court has power under Order XLI, Rule
33 of CPC, thus inclined to invoke the power to award just compensation and
comply with the law as per Pranay Sethi case supra. In this case, as per the
Claimants the deceased was working in the college since 29.08.1983 till
21.11.2001 i.e., the date of the accident, so the deceased was in job for about
18 years, thus, the deceased be termed as he was in permanent job, thus, the
Claimants are entitled for the future prospects 30% as the age of the deceased
was arrived at 41 years by the Tribunal, which is not in dispute, thus, the salary
of Rs.5,900/- + 30% of Rs.5,900/- = Rs.7,670/- per month, and his annual
Income is Rs.92,040/- (Rs.7,670 x 12).
18. As rightly contended by the learned Counsel for the Claimants, 1/3rd
is to be deducted instead of 1/4th towards his personal and living expenses, as
the Claimants are 4 in number, as per the law in Pranay Sethi case supra, ¼th
to be deducted towards his personal and living expenses, thus the loss of
dependency would be Rs.69,030/-.
As rightly contended by the learned
Counsel for the APSRTC, the applicable multiplier is ‘14’, as the age of the
deceased was 41 years on the date of the accident, thus as per the law in
Pranay Sethi case supra, the applicable multiplier is ‘14’, and the applied
multiplier of ‘15’ by the Tribunal is modified accordingly, thus, loss of earnings
arrived at Rs.69,030/- per annum, to be multiplied by ‘14’, thus total loss of
earning would be Rs.9,66,420/-.
(2017) 16 SCC 680
19. Whereas the Tribunal awarded Rs.30,000/- towards loss of estate
and loss of consortium. As per the law in Pranay Sethi case supra, for the
Loss of Estate, Loss of Consortium and Funeral Expenses should be
Rs.15,000/-, Rs.40,000/- and Rs.15,000/- respectively. The aforesaid amounts
should be enhanced at the rate of 10% for every three years.
20. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in United India Insurance
Company Limited Vs. Satinder Kaur and others2, held that the parents and
children are also entitled to Consortium.
21. Thus, the Claimants/Mother, wife, son and daughter of the deceased
are entitled to Rs.48,000/- each towards Loss of Consortium, Rs.18,000/towards Loss of Estate and Rs.18,000/- towards Funeral expenses respectively.
22. It is needless to mention that the law in Pranay Sethi case supra,
including on Future Prospects, deduction for personal and living expenses,
multiplier, Loss of Consortium, Loss of Estate and Funeral Expenses etc., has
been applied retrospectively (see Rojalini Nayak Vs Ajit Sahoo3)
23. The compensation awarded by the Tribunal under different heads and
the compensation enhanced by this Court are as follows:
S.
No
Head of the
claim
1.
Loss of
Dependency
2.
Loss of
Consortium
(2020) SCC Online SC 410
2024 INSC 584
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
(Rs.)
7,02,000/-
30,000/-
Compensation
enhanced by
Remarks
this Court
(Rs.)
9,66,420/- Income Rs.5900 +
30% FP = Rs.7670,
Annual Rs.92,040 –
1/4th
towards
personal expenses=
Rs.
69,030/x
multiplier ‘14’ as per
Pranay Sethi case.
1,92,000/- Rs.48,000/each
for
the
four
Claimants as per
3.
Loss of Estate
4.
Funeral
Expenses
Total
Nil
7,32,000/(The Tribunal
confined to
Rs.7,10,000/-)
Pranay Sethi and
Satinder
Kaur
cases
per
Pranay
18,000/- As
Sethi case
per
Pranay
18,000/- As
Sethi case
11,94,420/-
24. Thus, the Claimants are entitled to Rs.11,94,420/- as stated in the
Table, but the claim is filed for Rs.7,10,000/-, thus the Court Fee is to be paid
for the compensation awarded over and above the claim of Rs.7,10,000/- The
compensation of Rs.11,94,420/- shall be apportioned among the Claimants as
per the ratio ordered by the Tribunal. The interest of 7.5% per annum as
ordered by the Tribunal is maintained.
25. As stated supra, the Appellant moved an application for stay, and
accordingly, on 11.10.2006, this Court granted stay of the Award. As discussed
supra, the Appellant has no case to interfere in the Award of the Tribunal,
except for the multiplier, but the Appellant being a Public Sector Corporation,
contributed to the pendency of this Appeal for about 20 years before this Court,
this act of the Appellant has a cascading effect, such as leading to this Appeal
being added to very old list of pending cases, denting the image of the Judiciary
for the pendency of this Appeal for all these years and also put to suffer the
Claimants (widowed mother, wife and two children) for all these years, as they
could not get the half of the awarded compensation.
26. The Advocate Fee is prescribed under A.P. ADVOCATES’ FEE
RULES, 2010. Rule 40, which provides for fixing of fee for all CMAs as fixed in
the Lower Court, whereas Rule 15 provides that in Original Petitions for
matrimonial, land acquisition, claims regarding Motor Vehicle Accidents,
Arbitration, Succession Certificate etc., fee shall be fixed by the Court at not
less than Rs.1,500/- and not more than Rs.25,000/-. Thus, the Trial Court or
this Court cannot fix not more than Rs.25,000/-.
27. Thus, in view of the long pendency of the Appeal and the
circumstances, it necessitates for examination of the law on Costs and
Advocate Fee.
III. LAW ON COSTS AND ADVOCATE FEE:
28. The Hon’ble Full Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Salem Advocate Bar Association, Tamil Nadu Vs Union of India (UOI)4,
while dealing with amendments to the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, held that
costs should be realistic and reasonably to reimburse the other party, quoting
Section 35, observed no upper limit to amount of costs awardable.
Also
observed that judicial notice can be taken that many unscrupulous parties take
advantage of the fact that either the costs are not awarded or nominal costs are
awarded on the unsuccessful party. Also, observed that unfortunately, it has
become a practice to direct parties to bear their own costs. That the costs to be
actual reasonable costs, including the cost of the time spent by the successful
party, the transportation and lodging, besides the payment of the court fee,
lawyer's fee etc., to the litigation. That it is for the High Courts to examine these
aspects and make rules. That awarding of costs must be treated generally as
mandatory in as much as, that the liberal attitude of the Courts in directing the
parties to bear their own costs had led parties to file a number of frivolous cases
in the Courts or to raise frivolous and unnecessary issues, which are extracted
hereunder;
“V. COSTS:
“24.Section 35 of the Code deals with the award of
costs and Section 35-A with award of compensatory costs
in respect of false
or vexatious claims or defences.
(2005) 6 SCC 344
Section 95 deals with the grant of compensation for
obtaining arrest, attachment or injunction
on
insufficient grounds. These three sections deal with three
different aspects of award of costs and compensation.
Under Section 95, costs can be awarded upto Rs. 50,000/-,
and under Section 35-A, the costs awardable are upto Rs.
3,000/-. Section 35-B provides for award of cost for causing
delay where a party fails to take the step which he was
required by or under the Code to take or obtains an
adjournment for taking such step or for producing evidence
or on any other ground. In circumstances mentioned in
Section 35-B an order may be made requiring the
defaulting party to pay to other party such costs as would,
in the opinion of the court, be reasonably sufficient to
reimburse the other party in respect of the expenses
incurred by him in attending the court on that date, and
payment of such costs, on the date next following the date
of such order, shall be a condition precedent to the further
prosecution of the suit or the defence. Section 35
postulates that the cost shall follow the event and if not,
reasons thereof shall be stated. The award of the cost of
the suit is in the discretion of the Court. In Sections 35 and
35-B, there is no upper limit of amount of cost awardable.”
“25. Judicial notice can be taken of the fact that
many unscrupulous parties take advantage of the fact that
either the costs are not awarded or nominal costs are
awarded on the unsuccessful party. Unfortunately, it has
become a practice to direct parties to bear their own costs.
In large number of cases, such an order is passed despite
Section 35(2) of the Code. Such a practice also
encourages filing of frivolous suits. It also leads to taking
up of frivolous defences. Further wherever costs are
awarded, ordinarily the same are not realistic and are
nominal. When Section 35(2) provides for cost to follow the
event, it is implicit that the costs have to be those which are
reasonably incurred by a successful party except in those
cases where the Court in its discretion may direct
otherwise by recording reasons thereof. The costs have to
be actual reasonable costs including the cost of the time
spent by the successful party, the transportation and
lodging, if any, or any other incidental cost besides the
payment of the court fee, lawyer's fee, typing and other
cost in relation to the litigation. It is for the High Courts to
examine these aspects and wherever necessary make
requisite rules, regulations or practice direction so as to
provide appropriate guidelines for the subordinate courts to
follow.”
26. The Model Case Flow Management Rules read as under:
……………………………...
COSTS:
27. So far as awarding of costs at the time of
judgment is concerned, awarding of costs must be treated
generally as mandatory in as much as the liberal attitude
of the Courts in directing the parties to bear their own
costs had led parties to file a number of frivolous cases in
the Courts or to raise frivolous and unnecessary issues.
Costs should invariably follow the event. Where a party
succeeds ultimately on one issue or point but loses on
number of other issues or points which were unnecessarily
raised, costs must be appropriately apportioned. Special
reasons must be assigned if costs are not being awarded.
Costs should be assessed according to rules in force. If
any of the parties has unreasonably protracted the
proceedings, the Judge should consider exercising
discretion to impose exemplary costs after taking into
account the expense incurred for the purpose of
attendance on the adjourned dates.
29. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Sanjeev Kumar Jain vs
Raghubir Saran Charitable Trust & Ors5, while dealing with awarding of
costs, also relied on Salem Bar Association case supra, observed the need to
revise and streamline the Court Fee and equally urgent need to revise the
advocate's fee provided in the Schedule to the Rules, that most of which are
outdated and have no correlation with the prevailing rates of fees, which are
extracted hereunder;
“19. The costs in regard to a litigation include (a) the court
fee and process fee; (b) the advocate's fee; (c) expenses of
witnesses; and (d) other expenses allowable under the Rules. We
have already referred to the need to revise and streamline the
(2012) 1 SCC 455
court fee. Equally urgent is the need to revise the advocate's fee
provided in the Schedule to the Rules, most of which are outdated
and have no correlation with the prevailing rates of fees. In regard
to money suits, specific performance suits and other suits where
ad valorem court fee is payable, the Advocate's fee is also usually
ad valorem……………….”
“20. ………………….There is need to provide for awarding
realistic advocates' fee by amending the relevant rules periodically.
This Court, of course, in several cases has directed payment of
realistic costs. But this Court could do so, either because of the
discretion vested under the Supreme Court Rules, 1966 or having
regard to Article 142 of the Constitution under which this Court has
the power to make such orders as are necessary to do complete
justice between the parties.”
21. A serious fallout of not levying actual realistic costs
should be noted.
A litigant, who starts the litigation, after
sometime, being unable to bear the delay and mounting costs,
gives up and surrenders to the other side or agrees to settlement
which is something akin to creditor who is not able to recover the
debt, writing off the debt. This happens when the costs keep
mounting and he realizes that even if he succeeds he will not get
the actual costs. If this happens frequently, the citizens will lose
confidence in the civil justice system. When a civil litigant is denied
effective relief in Courts, he tries to take his grievances to `extra
judicial' enforcers (that is goons, musclemen, underworld) for
enforcing his claims/right thereby criminalizing the civil society. This
has serious repercussions on the institution of democracy.
22. We, therefore, suggest that the Rules be amended to
provide for `actual realistic costs'. The object is to streamline the
award of costs and simplify the process of assessment, while
making the cost `actual and realistic'…………….”
30. In view of the law as stated supra, this Court is referring to an
illustration to drive on Costs, Advocate Fee and allied aspects.
a) If a Lecturer/Engineer aged 25 years, who has a
permanent job and earning Rs.1,00,000/- per month, who has
wife and parents, died in a road accident by negligence of
other party, the Claimants will get compensation including
50% future prospects, after deducting 1/3rd towards personal
and living expenses i.e., Rs.1,00,000/- salary + Rs.50,000/-
future prospects, 1/3 deduction towards personal and living
expenses of the deceased, thus the Claimants are entitled to
compensation of Rs.2,16,00,000/- towards loss of earnings
(Rs.1,50,000/- / x 2/3 X 12 months X 18 multiplier to be
applied for the age of 25 years). Further, the 3 Claimants are
also entitled to Rs.48,000/- each under the head of loss of
Consortium, Rs.18,000/- under loss of estate and Rs.18,000/under
funeral
expenses,
total
compensation
of
Rs.2,17,80,000/- depending on the facts of the case, whether
the offending vehicle is insured or not, they are entitled to the
aforesaid compensation. But the Claimants cannot get more
than Rs.25,000/- towards Advocate Fee under Rule 15 of A.P.
Advocate Fee Rules, 2010 from the unsuccessful
Respondents.
b) Whereas in a suit for recovery of money for
Rs.2,17,80,000/- based on a Promissory Note, Mortgage
Deed or Agreement of Sale etc., the successful Party will get
Advocate Fee of Rs.6,55,100/- as per Rule 6 of A.P. Advocate
Fee Rules, 2010, from unsuccessful Party/s.
31. Whereas in the former case, the Claimants will get a meager amount
of Advocate Fee and cannot get more than Rs.25,000/- but in the latter case,
the successful party in the suit will get Advocate Fee of Rs.6,55,100/-. In the
Execution Petitions (EPs) also, the Courts shall fix the Advocate Fee, which is
½ in case of contest, from the fee allowed in the suit or proceeding as the case
may be under the Rules, and ¼ in case of no contest. Thus generally the
Insurer or Insured is benefited for allowing nominal Court Fee in MVOP/Original
Proceeding, MACMA or EP at the cost of the Claimants. In fact, generally, the
claimants may incur more amount towards Advocate Fee when they are
pursuing the claim either before the Tribunal or before this Court. Thus, this
Court is of the humble view that by this Rule 15 before the Tribunal and Rule 40
before this Court, the Claimants/Insured/Insurer etc., are not getting realistic
costs, thus in most of the cases, the Claimants/Parties are facing frivolous or
vexatious contests before the Tribunal and this Court, if the Advocate Fee is
suitably increased by way of amendments to the Rules, also a provision for
Advocate Fee ranging from 1 to 3 times be awardable depending on the facts of
the case including frivolous or vexatious pleas, for protracting the case, for the
time and effort put by a party and his/her counsel, for obtaining status-quo, stay
etc., without there being sufficient material, then the law as stated in Salem Bar
Association and Sanjeev Kumar Jain cases supra will be complied, the
Claimants/successful party will get the realistic costs without depriving their right
to reimbursement, then the frivolous or vexatious Claims or defences in Original
Petitions, Appeals and Execution Petitions can be curbed significantly.
32. It is needless to mention that the view of this Court in the preceding
para is also applicable in Civil Suits, CMAs, Revisions, Appeal Suits, Second
Appeals, Execution Petitions, Writs and Writ Appeals etc., for awarding realistic
costs for the successful party. Also a provision for Advocate Fee be made to
award Advocate Fee ranging from 1 to 3 times depending on the facts of the
case including for frivolous or vexatious pleas, for protracting the case, for the
time and effort put by a party and his/her counsel, for obtaining Interim
Injunction, Attachment, status-quo, stay etc., in Original Proceeding, Revision or
Appeal etc, then a mischievous party will not venture for seeking such orders or
seek extension of such orders without there being sufficient grounds in his/her
case, deterring the higher the abuse by him, the higher the costs need to pay
upto 3 times of the Advocate Fee by him on loosing the case.
33. There is a general notion that if the Advocate Fee is increased in the
Rules, the Advocates will be benefiting by the increase, this Court is of the view
that notion is incorrect as generally the successful party, who is getting the
realistic costs by the increase of the Rules, from the unsuccessful party.
34. This Court is of the humble view, that the law and discussion as
stated supra, the fee prescribing minimum, maximum etc., in the Rules, 2010,
requires revision under Article 227 of the Constitution of India in view of the
passage of around 16 years from framing of the Rules, 2010 as some of them
are with outdated fee structure, with no correlation with the prevailing rates of
fees as per the law stated supra.
35. The Bar Council and the Bar Associations shall take an effective lead
in these issues, there are numerous issues of like this nature.
If they are
addressed, the litigants will enhance faith in the Profession and the Profession
will flourish, and finally the image of the Judiciary will be enhanced in the
administration of justice.
36. It is also appropriate to refer to the law in Salem Bar Association
case supra, while dealing with Notice under Section 80 of CPC, which held on
the duty of the concerned Public Servant, to give a suitable reply to the notice, if
the notice is not replied or the reply is evasive or vague, the Court shall award
heavy cost against the Government and direct it to take appropriate action
against the concerned Officer including recovery of costs from him, the same is
extracted here under;
“40. These provisions cast an implied duty on all
concerned governments and States and statutory authorities
to send appropriate reply to such
notices. Having regard
to the existing state of affairs, we direct all concerned
governments, Central or State or other authorities, whenever
any statute requires service of notice as a condition precedent
for filing of suit or other proceedings against it, to nominate,
within a period of three months, an officer who shall be made
responsible to ensure that replies to notices under section 80
or similar provisions are sent within the period stipulated in a
particular legislation. The replies shall be sent after due
application of mind. Despite such nomination, if the Court finds
that either the notice has not been replied or reply is evasive
and vague and has been sent without proper application of
mind, the Court shall ordinarily award heavy cost against the
Government and direct it to take appropriate action against the
concerned Officer including recovery of costs from him.”
37. When the law is applied with such vigor at the stage of Legal Notice
under Section 80 of CPC, which is prior to institution of the suit, against the
concerned Public Servant for recovery of costs and departmental action, it
clearly shows that if a public servant in a Suit or proceeding including Revision,
Appeal, Execution Petition, upon taking frivolous or vexatious pleas, the law in
Salem Bar Association case supra will apply with much vigor as the latter is
in suits or proceedings before the Courts/Tribunals. If the law is implemented in
this fashion by the Courts in the Districts as laid down in Salem Bar
Association case supra, the frivolous or vexatious pleas will be curbed, which
will enhance the image of the Judiciary in the administration of justice. Further,
the State’s litigation, which is the biggest litigant before the Courts, also can be
reduced significantly when the law is complied as stated supra. It is needless to
mention that the concerned Officers and legal teams from time to time need to
revisit their litigation formats and strategies in this technology era to comply with
the law, check their new cases and pending cases at all levels to identify and
process them to settle at the earliest, or at the first hearing of the matter under
Order X Rule 1A of CPC, or at the earliest in the National Lok Adalat, then they
can comply with the law and also avoid costs and departmental actions as
stated supra.
38. It is needless to mention that the Counsels have a duty to assist the
Courts/Tribunals to comply with the law as stated supra. The Courts/Tribunals
have a duty to ensure compliance with the law as stated supra.
39. In the present case, in view of Rule 40 r/w 15 of the Advocate Fees
Rules, 2010, the Advocate Fee cannot be fixed for more than Rs.25,000/-.
Thus, confined to Rs.25,000/- in the circumstances of the case.
40. The principles on Costs, Advocate Fee and allied legal aspects stated
herein above are illustrative but not exhaustive. It is appropriate to place the
quote of Sri Mahatma Gandhi “An ounce of practice is worth more than
tons of preaching”.
IV. CONCLUSION:
41. In the result, the Appeal is dismissed with costs of Rs.25,000/payable to the Claimants in the circumstances of the case, while enhancing the
compensation from Rs. 7,10,000/- to Rs.11,94,420/- as stated in the Table with
interest at 7.5% p.a. from the date of filing of the Petition till the date of
realization subject to payment of additional Court Fee by the Claimants over
and above the claim of Rs.7,10,000/- within 30 days from the date of receipt of
this Judgment. The compensation awarded by this Court shall be apportioned
among the Claimants as per the ratio ordered by the Tribunal. The
2nd Respondent may recover these costs from the concerned Employee, who
was responsible for filing the Appeal and who was/are responsible for
continuing this Appeal for about 20 years. The 2nd Respondent is directed to
examine to initiate departmental action against the concerned as per the law
stated supra.
42. The Registrar General is directed to place the file before the Hon’ble
the Chief Justice of Andhra Pradesh for kind consideration.
_________________________
JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
Dated : 11.09.2026
LR copy to be marked
B/o.
CHD
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
M.A.C.M.A. No.2289 of 2012
Date: 11th September, 2026
CHD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review