Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010652222016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3548]
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1248/2016
Between:
1. ANDHRA PRADESH STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION,
REPRESENTED BY ITS VICE CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING
DIRECTOR, MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SHAIK ANISHA SULTANA
7 OTHERS, W/O. LATE KHAJA
MOHIDDIN, MUSLIM, AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS, HOUSE-WIFE,
D.NO.8-14-69, KOPPULAVARI STREET, WINCHIPET,VIJAYAWADA,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
2. SHAIK BHASHI, S/O. LATE KHAJA MOHIDDIN, MUSLIM, AGED
ABOUT 6 YEARS, STUDENT, D.NO. 8-14-69, KOPPULAVARI
STREET, WINCHIPET, VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
3. SHAIK FARWEZ, S/O. LATE KHAJA MOHIDDIN, MUSLIM, AGED
ABOUT 1 YEARS, MOTHER'S PROTECTION, D.NO.8-14-69,
KOPPULAVARI
STREET,
WINCHIPET,
VIJAYAWADA.
(RESPONDENTS 2 AND 3 ARE BEING MINORS REP.BY THEIR
NATURAL GUARDIAN AND MOTHER I.E., 1ST RESPONDENT
HEREIN)
4. SHAIK FATIMUNNISA DIED, (PETITIONERS REPRESENTED BY
THEIR GPA HOLDER SHAIK MASTAN)
5. SHAIK MASTAN BASTAN BABA, S/O. LATE ABDUL KHADAR, AGED
ABOUT 55 YEARS, D.NO. 87-14-69, KOPPULAVARI STREET,
WINCHIPET, VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DIST.
6. SMT SHAIK MOBINA SULTANA, W/O. SHAIK JANI BASHA, MUSLIM,
AGED 32 YEARS,
D.NO. 87-14-69, KOPPULAVARI STREET,
WINCHIPET, VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DIST.
7. SMT REHANA SULTANA, W/O. SHAIK JANI BASHA, MUSLIM, AGED
32 YEARS D.NO.87-14-69, KOPUPULAVARI STREET, WINCHIPET,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DIST.
8. PEDAPUDI BABULU, S/O. RAMULU, HINDU, AGED ABOUT 43
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
YEARS, DRIVER APSRTC, R/O. NARSIPATNAM, VISAKHAPATNAM
DISTRICT. (RESPONDENT NO.8 IS NOT NECESSARY IN THIS
APPEAL)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying that the High Court may be
pleased to allow the MACMA by setting aside the Order and Decree dated
1-6-2015 passed by the Court of the Motor Accidents Clams Tribunal-CumXVI Additional District and Sessions Judge, Nandigama, Krishna District in
MVOP.No.37 of 2013 and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2015(MACMAMP 5791 OF 2015
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 29 days in presenting the appeal filed against the Order
and Decree dated 1-6-2015 passed by the Court of the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal-Cum-XVI Additional District and Sessions Judge, Nandigama,
Krishna District in MVOP.No.37 of 2013 and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2016(MACMAMP 116 OF 2016
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of all further proceedings pursuant to the order and decree dated
1-6-2015 passed by the Court of the Motor Accidents Clams Tribunal Cum
XVI Additional District and Sessions Judge, Nandigama, Krishna District in
MVOP.No.37 of 2013 including execution proceedings, pending disposal of
the above MACMA.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO(SC FOR APSRTC KKAC)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. CHALLA AJAY KUMAR
The Court made the following:
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
JUDGMENT:
Heard,
Sri G.Gopinath, learned counsel representing Sri Aravala Rama Rao,
learned Standing Counsel for Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport
Corporation/appellant, and Sri Challa Ajay Kumar, learned counsel appearing
for the claimants.
1.
Embittered with the Judgment and Decree passed by the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-XVI Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Nandigama (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”), in M.V.O.P.No.37 of
2013, dated 01.06.2015, the present appeal is filed by the Andhra Pradesh
State Road Transport Corporation (hereinafter referred to as “APSRTC”),
challenging the Award of Rs.7,98,000/- with interest @ 7.5% per annum from
the date of filing of the petition till the date of realization.
2.
The parties are arrayed as they were before the Tribunal.
3.
The appeal is filed by the Corporation, contending that the
Tribunal erred in awarding compensation of Rs.7,98,000/- without there being
any acceptable evidence on record specifically when the accident was not
proved by the claimants regarding rash and negligent driving. The
contentions, which are germane to decide the case as contended before the
Tribunal in the M.V.O.P. filed by the claimants, have to be looked into.
4.
The petition was filed under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act,
r/w Rule 455 of A.P. Motor Vehicles Rules, claiming compensation of
Rs.13,00,000/- with interest @ 24% per annum from the date of the accident
till the date of realization. Initially, the petition was numbered as
M.V.O.P.No.359 of 2010 and later it was transferred to the Motor Vehicle
Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-VII Additional District Judge, Vijayawada.
Subsequently, the matter was transferred to the Tribunal and the same was
renumbered as M.V.O.P.No.37 of 2013.
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
5.
Before the Tribunal, the 1st petitioner is the wife, petitioners 2 and
3 are the children and the 4th petitioner is the mother of the deceased. During
the pendency of the petition, the 4th petitioner died and her legal
representatives were impleaded as petitioners 5 to 7.
6.
The case before the Tribunal is that on 24.09.2009 at about 01.00
hours, while Shaik Khaja Mohiddin (hereinafter referred to as “deceased”) was
travelling by a bus bearing No.AP28Z3178 from Hyderabad to Vijayawada,
driven by the 1st respondent, and when it reached Paritala village, the bus
dashed a lorry resulting the death of the deceased instantaneously. Some of
the passengers also received injuries. The deceased was shifted to D.V.R.
Community Health Centre, Nandigama, where the doctors declared him as
dead. Basing on the report of the brother of the deceased by name Mastan @
Mastan Baba, Kanchikacherla Police registered Crime No.176 of 2009 under
Sections 337, 304-A of IPC and the Motor Vehicles Inspector gave his opinion
that the accident was not occurred due to any mechanical defect in the
vehicle.
7.
The deceased was working as Manager in Baji Shamiyana,
Vijayawada, and was earning Rs.9,500/- per month and due to the sudden
and premature death of the deceased, the petitioners were put to hardship
and mental agony. The deceased was aged about 35 years at the time of
death and as the 1st respondent was driving the vehicle with rash and
negligent manner, the accident occurred, and the petitioners filed the petition
for compensation.
8.
In oppugnation to the said petition, the 2nd respondent filed
counter and Adoption Memo was filed by the 1st respondent adopting the
same counter averments. While denying the averments in the counter, it was
contended that the accident occurred due to the sudden stopping of the lorry
without giving any indication and without taking left margin and that there is no
rash and negligent driving on the part of the 1st respondent and only for the
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
reasons stated, the accident has occurred and that the respondents 1 and 2
are not liable to pay any compensation.
9.
Considering the said contentions, the Tribunal framed the
following issues:
i.
Whether the deceased Khaja Mohiddin died in a motor
accident occurred on 24.9.2009 at 01.00 hours near
Paritala village due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the bus bearing No.AP 28Z 3178?
ii.
What is the correct age and income of the deceased by
the date of accident?
iii.
Whether the petitioners are entitled to the compensation
as prayed for? If so, from whom and to what amount?
iv.
To what relief?
10.
On behalf of the claimants, Exs.A1 to A6 were marked and
PWs.1 and 2 were examined. On behalf of the respondents, RW1 was
examined and no oral or documentary evidence was adduced. Ex.A1 is the
attested copy of FIR, Ex.A2 is the attested copy of inquest report, Ex.A3 is the
attested copy of postmortem report, Ex.A4 is the Xerox copy of driving license
of the 1st respondent, Ex.A5 is the salary certificate of the deceased and
Ex.A6 is the Death Certificate of the 4th petitioner.
11.
The Tribunal, while answering issue No.1 relating to the
contention of rash and negligent driving on the part of the 1st respondent,
observed that the 1st petitioner examined herself as PW2 and in her evidence
reiterated the averments made in the affidavit, asserting that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the 1st respondent. RW1, the
driver, was examined and supported his version as stated in the counter. He
deposed that the accident occurred due to a lorry which was suddenly
stopped on the National Highway without giving any signal, and that the lorry
driver had failed to take necessary precautions. He further stated that he had
taken all precautions to avoid the accident. It was also contended in the
counter that the police, in collusion with local people, had filed the charge
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
sheet against him. In response to the said contentions, the Tribunal rightly
concluded that the driver ought to have maintained a safe distance even if the
lorry had stopped suddenly. The Tribunal further observed that, in such
circumstances, the accident could not have been avoided, which clearly
indicates rash and negligent driving on the part of the 1st respondent.
Accordingly, the issue was answered in favour of the petitioners and against
the respondents.
12.
While coming to issue No.2, there is no dispute regarding the age
of the deceased as 35 years, which is substantiated by the inquest report,
Ex.A2 and the postmortem report, Ex.A3, which supports that the age of the
deceased was 35 at the time of accident.
13.
When coming to the income of the deceased, the petitioners got
marked the salary certificate issued by the employer of the deceased stating
that he used to draw Rs.9,500/- per month and the salary certificate was
marked as Ex.A5. The said certificate was not accepted by the Tribunal only
on the ground that except marking Ex.A5, there is no attempt made by the
petitioners to examine the concerned person, who has issued the certificate
and since it was issued by a private authority and not a Government Agency,
the certificate cannot be taken as authentic and estimated the income of the
deceased as Rs.6,000/- per month.
14.
The income, which is estimated as Rs.6,000/- per month by the
Tribunal, is found to be erroneous since there is no reasoning by the Tribunal
to come to such a conclusion and cannot disbelieve the said exhibit only on
the ground that the certificate was issued by a private authority and not a
Government Agency. This Court finds not even an effort made by the Tribunal
to see whether the respondents made any effort to cross-examine PW2, who
got marked Ex.A5 and particularly, in the absence of any contra evidence, it
would not be justified on the part of the Tribunal to come to such a conclusion,
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
fixing the income of the deceased as Rs.6,000/- per month on mere
assumption.
15.
When a concerned person, who is the employer of the deceased
issued a certificate fortifying that the deceased was drawing Rs.9,500/- per
month, the Tribunal ought to have believed the said certificate and in the case
or event, the certificate is deemed to be suspicious, the Tribunal should have
given cogent reasons for such disbelieving and in the absence of reasoning,
confirming the income of the deceased as Rs.6,000/- per month, this Court
finds it difficult to accept the version and hence, the finding of the Tribunal to
that effect is liable to be set aside as erroneous in limine.
16.
While answering issue No.3, the Tribunal has rightly taken into
consideration the other aspects, such as personal and living expenses and
deducted 1/3rd of his income i.e., Rs.24,000/- (Rs.72,000 x 1/3). After
deducting the said amount, the contribution to the family comes to Rs.48,000/(Rs.72,000 – Rs.24,000). The multiplier of ‟16 adopted by the Tribunal is
justified and the compensation derived was Rs.7,68,000/- (Rs.48,000 x 16).
Additionally, Rs.20,000/- was awarded to the 1st petitioner towards loss of
consortium and Rs.10,000/- towards funeral expenses. In totality, the
petitioners were awarded Rs.7,98,000/- with interest @ 7.5% per annum from
the date of the petition till the date of realization. The compensation was
directed to be paid by the 2nd respondent considering the doctrine of vicarious
liability since the 2nd respondent is the owner of the offending vehicle and as
the 2nd respondent is the one to pay the compensation ultimately, the issue
was answered accordingly, holding the 2nd respondent liable to pay the
compensation.
17.
As stated supra, except for the modification, regarding the
estimation of income of the deceased at Rs.9,500/- per month by this Court
instead of Rs.6,000/-, the rest of the compensation awarded by the Tribunal
holds good and needs no interference.
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1248 of 2016
18.
In view of the above findings of this Court, the compensation after
the observations made above will be as follows:
Sl.No.
1.
2.
3.
Head
Compensation awarded
Income per month
Rs.9,500/Annual income
Rs.9,500 x 12 = Rs.1,14,000/rd
1/3
towards personal and Rs.38,000/- (Rs.1,14,000 x 1/3)
living expenses
Contribution to the family
Rs.76,000/(Rs.1,14,000
–
Rs.38,000)
After applying multiplier „16‟
Rs.12,16,000/- (Rs.76,000 x 16)
Loss of consortium
Rs.20,000/Funeral expenses
Rs.10,000/Total
Rs.12,46,000/-
4.
5.
6.
7.
19.
Accordingly, the Judgment and Decree, dated 01.06.2015,
passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-XVI Additional District
and Sessions Judge, Nandigama, in M.V.O.P.No.37 of 2013, is hereby
modified, enhancing the compensation from Rs.7,98,000/- to Rs.12,46,000/-,
while the other part of the judgment is not interfered and the enhanced
compensation shall be apportioned as directed by the Tribunal. It is made
clear that the petitioners/claimants are not entitled for any interest on the
enhanced compensation.
20.
In fine, the Motor Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is
dismissed, modifying the Judgment and Decree of the Tribunal to the extent
indicated above. There shall be no order as to costs.
21.
As a sequitur, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
___________________________
TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA, J
Date : 18-03-2026
BMS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review