Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010965382018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3596]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE 20th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 3271/2018
Between:
1. ANDE NARASIMHA RAO @ NARASAY, S/O MANGAIAH, AGED
ABOUT 43 YEARS
VENKANURU VILLAGE, AVANIGADDA
MANDAL
...APPELLANT
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep. by its Public
Prosecutor, High Court at Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. B PARAMESEWARA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI
MONDAY, THIS THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
SPECIAL DIVISION BENCH
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 3271 of 2018
JUDGMENT :- (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Sole accused in Sessions Case No.127 of 2016 on the file of the
Court of the X Additional District & Sessions Judge-cum-Special
Sessions Judge, Krishna, Machilipatnam, is the appellant.
He was
tried by the learned Additional Sessions Judge under two charges.
1) First charge was under Section 302 IPC.
2) Second charge was under Section 506 IPC.
2.
Substance of the charge is that, on 11.05.2015, at about
5.30 p.m., the accused hacked one Narasimha Rao (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the deceased’) with M.O.5-knife near his mango garden,
causing his death, and, in the course of the same transaction,
criminally intimidated P.W.1 by threatening her with the very same
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
knife when she attempted to rescue the deceased, thereby committed
offences punishable under Sections 302 and 506 of IPC.
3.
After completion of trial, the learned Additional Sessions Judge
convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to
suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for ‘LIFE’ and also to pay a fine of
Rs.1000/-, in default to suffer Simple Imprisonment for a period of three
(3) months. Learned Additional Sessions Judge further convicted the
appellant under Section 506 IPC and sentenced him to suffer Rigorous
Imprisonment for a period of seven (7) years and also to pay a fine of
Rs.500/-, in default to suffer Simple Imprisonment for a period of three
(3) months.
Both the substantive sentences were directed to run
concurrently.
4.
Case of the prosecution, as emanated from the evidence of
prosecution witnesses, briefly, is as follows:
i) The accused as well as the prosecution witnesses are all
residents of Vekanuru Village, Avanigadda Mandal. The deceased was
also the resident of same village. P.W.1 is wife, P.W.2 is son and
P.W.3 is mother-in-law of the deceased respectively. P.Ws.4 and 5 are
relatives of the deceased.
ii) The deceased had purchased an extent of Ac.1.00 of land in
Vekanuru Village in the year 2011, wherein he developed a mango
garden. The accused had also purchased an extent of Ac.0.70 cents of
land from P.W.6 and raised a mango garden therein. The land
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
belonging to the accused was situated adjacent to that of the
deceased.
iii) About fifteen days prior to the date of incident, the accused
requested the deceased to supply water from the latter's irrigation
engine for irrigating his mango garden. However, the deceased
declined the request. Aggrieved by the refusal of the deceased to
supply water for irrigating his garden, the accused developed grudge
against him.
iv) While so, on the morning of 11.05.2015, the deceased went
to his paddy field and returned home in the afternoon. After having his
lunch, he took rest for a while. Thereafter, at about 4.00 p.m., the
deceased, along with his wife, P.W.1, proceeded to their mango
garden situated on the other side of the Krishna River. After collecting
mangoes, the deceased also gathered some grass, and at about 5.30
p.m., while they were returning home, the accused emerged all of a
sudden and hacked the deceased on his neck with M.O.5–knife. When
P.W.1 attempted to intervene and rescue the deceased, the accused
threatened her with the very same knife with dire consequences, Due
to fear, P.W.1 went behind a tree and witnessed the accused hacking
the deceased. After the deceased fell to the ground, the accused
continued the attack by hacking him again on the neck with
M.O.5-knife. According to P.W.1, the accused inflicted two blows on
the neck of the deceased before fleeing from the scene of offence.
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
v) Thereafter, P.W.1 went to the deceased and found him lying
dead. She then returned home and informed P.W.2 and the other
family members about the incident and she fainted. On receiving the
said information, P.W.2 and the other family members proceeded to
the scene of offence and found the dead body of the deceased.
Thereafter, at about 1.00 a.m. on 12.05.2015, P.Ws.1 and 2, along with
others, went to Avanigadda Police Station and lodged a report- Ex.P1.
On receipt of the said report, P.W.13, the then
Sub-Inspector of
Police, Avanigadda Police Station, registered a case in Crime No.96 of
2015 under Section 302 IPC. He issued copies of First Information
Report to all the concerned. First Information Report was marked as
Ex.P12.
vi) On receipt of the information from P.W.13, P.W.15, the then
Inspector of Police, Avanigadda Circle, took up investigation. He
recorded statements of P.Ws.1 and 2 at the police station. Immediately
he visited the scene of offence along with P.Ws.1, 2 and 13. He found
the dead body of the deceased lying in a pool of blood. He posted a
constable and the Village Administrative Officer (VAO) to guard the
scene of offence. He noticed the house of the accused locked.
vii) On the same day, at about 8.00 a.m., P.W.15 secured the
presence of P.W.7 and others and visited the scene of offence. In the
presence of the said mediators, he prepared an observation reportEx.P2. He also got the scene of offence photographed through P.W.9.
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
Photographs were marked as Ex.P6. He also seized M.Os.1 to 4 at the
scene of offence under a cover of Panchanama-Ex.P2 and prepared a
rough sketch of the scene of offence- Ex.P13. He held inquest over the
dead body in the presence mediators-P.Ws.7 and others. Inquest
report was marked as Ex.P3. Subsequently, he sent the dead body for
post-mortem examination.
viii)
P.W.8,
Civil
Assistant
Surgeon,
District
Hospital,
Machilipatnam, who was on deputation to Avanigadda, conducted
autopsy over the dead body of the deceased and found five external
injuries. He opined the cause of death was due to shock and
haemorrhage due to severed carotid arteries and other structures of
the neck caused by a sharp-edged weapon applied with force.
ix) On 14.05.2015, P.W.15 apprehended the accused at his
house in the presence of P.W.7 and other mediators. Pursuant to the
confession made by the accused, M.O.5–knife, along with the bloodstained clothes of the accused, i.e., M.Os.8 and 9, were recovered
under a cover of panchanama-Ex.P4. Then, P.W.15 arrested the
accused and remanded him to judicial custody. On 15.07.2015, the
Investigating Officer forwarded the material objects to the Forensic
Science Laboratory (FSL) for chemical analysis.
x) On 17.07.2015, P.W.15 recorded statement of P.W.9. On
06.08.2015, he recorded statement of P.W.6. During the course of
investigation, he also collected copies of sale deeds pertaining to the
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
lands owned by the accused and the deceased marked as Exs.P14
and P15. He sent a requisition to P.W.11 under Ex.P7.
xi) After receiving all the documents and after completion of
investigation, P.W.15 filed charge sheet.
5.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined P.Ws.1 to 15
and marked Exs.P1 to P16 and exhibited MOs.1 to 9. On behalf of the
defence, Ex.D1- News item published in daily newspaper was marked.
6.
When the accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
he denied the incriminating evidence appearing against him. Accepting
the evidence of P.W.1, the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
convicted the accused as aforesaid.
7.
Heard Sri B.Paramesewara Rao, learned counsel for the
appellant and Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor for the respondent/State.
8.
We have carefully scrutinized the entire evidence on record.
9.
In the present case, P.W.1 is sole eyewitness to the incident.
The remaining witnesses were examined to speak about the events
that transpired subsequent to the incident and the information furnished
to them by P.W.1. P.W.1, in her evidence, stated that on the morning of
11.05.2015, the deceased went to his paddy field and returned home in
the afternoon. After having lunch, at about 4.00 p.m., she accompanied
the deceased to their mango garden. At about 5.30 p.m., while they
were returning home, the deceased was walking ahead of her and she
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
was following him after locking the gate of the garden. At that juncture,
the accused emerged all of a sudden and hacked the deceased on his
neck with M.O.5-knife, causing him to fall to the ground. When P.W.1
attempted to intervene and rescue the deceased, the accused
threatened her with the very same knife. Due to fear, she stood behind
a nearby tree and witnessed the incident. She further stated that, after
the accused fled away from the scene, she approached the deceased
and found him lying dead. Thereafter, she returned home, informed her
son, P.W.2, and the other family members about the incident and,
according to her, lost consciousness. At about 1.00 a.m. on
12.05.2015, she, along with P.W.2 and other family members,
proceeded to Avanigadda Police Station and lodged Ex.P.1-report.
10.
A careful scrutiny of the evidence of P.W.1, however, discloses
certain material discrepancies and inherent improbabilities. In Ex.P.1,
P.W.1 stated that the accused hacked the deceased twice on the neck,
whereas, in her evidence, she stated that the accused hacked the
deceased thrice on the neck. This material inconsistency relates to the
manner of attack and cannot be lightly brushed aside.
11.
It is also significant to note that, though the incident took place at
about 5.30 p.m., Ex.P.1 came to be lodged only at about 1.00 a.m. on
the next day, despite the police station being situated at a distance of
only nine kilometres from the place of incident. Thus, there is a
considerable delay in setting the criminal law into motion. The
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
explanation sought to be offered by the prosecution is that P.W.1
became unconscious immediately after returning home. The said
explanation does not appear to be wholly convincing and give rise to a
legitimate doubt as to whether it was introduced only to account for the
delay in lodging the report.
12.
It is the version of the prosecution that P.W.1 crossed the
Krishna River at the relevant point of time also appears to be inherently
improbable. Consequently, the testimony of P.W.1, suffers with
material inconsistencies and improbabilities, requires careful scrutiny
before it can be safely acted upon.
13.
It is the specific case of the prosecution that the deceased
removed his shirt and lungi before crossing the Krishna River and
crossed the river wearing only banian and underwear. Curiously, the
shirt and lungi of the deceased were found in his hands at the scene of
offence. If that be so, the prosecution version that P.W.1 alone crossed
the Krishna River without any assistance appears to be highly
improbable and does not inspire confidence.
14.
It is evident from the evidence of P.W.1 as well as the other
prosecution witnesses that there were several houses situated on
either side of the road leading to the house of P.W.1. Despite allegedly
witnessing the brutal attack on her husband, P.W.1 admittedly did not
raise any alarm or hue and cry while returning home, nor did she
inform any of the villagers residing in those houses about the incident.
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
The evidence further discloses that there was a temple situated at a
distance of about 500 metres from the place of incident where people
usually assemble. Even then, P.W.1 did not seek help from anyone or
disclose the incident to the persons present there. Such conduct is
wholly unnatural and inconsistent with the normal human behaviour
expected of a person who had just witnessed the brutal murder of her
husband. This circumstance also creates a serious doubt as to whether
P.W.1 had, in fact, witnessed the incident in the manner alleged by the
prosecution.
15.
Another significant circumstance, which casts a serious doubt on
the prosecution case is the admission made by P.W.2, the son of
P.W.1, during his cross-examination, which reads as follows:
"At about 1:00 a.m. in the midnight, we
reported the matter to the police. Till that time
we were not having knowledge about the
whereabouts of my father."
16.
The aforesaid admission made by P.W.2 assumes considerable
significance. If, as deposed by P.W.1, she had actually witnessed the
incident and informed P.W.2 and the other family members
immediately after returning home, there was no occasion for P.W.2 to
state that, till lodging the report at about 1.00 a.m., they were not aware
of the whereabouts of his father. This material admission renders the
version of P.W.1 highly doubtful and lends support to the defence
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
contention that she was not present at the scene of offence and had
not witnessed the actual occurrence.
17.
Further, the ocular testimony of P.W.1 does not receive due
corroboration from the medical evidence adduced through P.W.8.
P.W.8, who conducted post-mortem over the dead body of the
deceased, noticed as many as five external incised injuries. He further
admitted in his cross-examination that the deceased might have
consumed food about two hours prior to his death, as partially digested
rice was found in the stomach.
18.
According to P.W.1, after taking lunch, the deceased took rest for
some time and thereafter, at about 4.00 p.m., both of them proceeded
to the mango garden, where the incident allegedly occurred at about
5.30 p.m. The aforesaid version is not in consonance with the medical
evidence of P.W.8, who opined that the deceased had consumed food
about two hours prior to his death. The medical evidence, therefore,
creates a serious doubt with regard to the time of incident spoken to by
P.W.1 and probabilises that the incident might have taken place much
earlier than 5.30 p.m.
19.
Another circumstance which creates a serious doubt about the
prosecution case pertains to the arrest of the accused. According to
P.W.15, Investigating Officer, the accused was arrested on 14.05.2015.
However, P.Ws.1 and 2, in their cross-examination, categorically
admitted that the accused had been taken into police custody on the
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
very date of the incident, i.e., 11.05.2015. This material contradiction
with regard to the date of arrest remains unexplained by the
prosecution. Such an inconsistency assumes significance, as it casts a
serious doubt on the prosecution version relating to the arrest of the
accused and the subsequent investigation carried out pursuant thereto.
20.
Another material circumstance which casts a serious doubt on
the
prosecution
case
is
the
forensic
evidence.
P.W.15,
the
Investigating Officer, deposed that the blood-stained clothes of the
accused and the blood-stained knife were seized and forwarded to the
Forensic Science Laboratory for chemical analysis. However, Ex.P.11,
report issued by P.W.12, Scientific Officer, categorically discloses that
no blood stains were detected on M.O.5-knife or on M.Os.8 and 9, the
clothes seized from the accused. This material contradiction between
the evidence of the Investigating Officer and the scientific evidence
remains wholly unexplained. The absence of blood stains on the
alleged weapon of offence and the clothes of the accused considerably
weakens the prosecution case and renders the recovery and seizure
highly doubtful.
21.
Coming to the aspect of motive, the prosecution alleged that the
accused bore a grudge against the deceased, as the latter had refused
to supply water to the fields of the accused. However, the said
allegation is not borne out by the evidence on record. On the contrary,
the prosecution witnesses themselves, including P.Ws.2 and 3,
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
categorically admitted in their evidence that, prior to the incident, the
accused and the deceased were on cordial terms and used to move
closely with each other. In the absence of any convincing evidence
establishing prior enmity, the motive attributed by the prosecution loses
its significance.
22.
Except the shaky evidence of P.W.1, there is no other evidence
connecting the accused with the commission of offence. As already
discussed, the evidence of P.W.1 suffers from material inconsistencies,
inherent improbabilities and lacks corroboration on material particulars.
It is highly improbable that P.W.1 could have crossed the Krishna River
alone without the assistance of anyone. Equally significant is her
conduct in not raising any alarm or hue and cry despite allegedly
witnessing the brutal murder of her husband. Such conduct is wholly
unnatural and inconsistent with the normal behaviour expected of a
person
placed
in
such
circumstances.
These
circumstances
substantially impair the credibility of her testimony.
23.
Having carefully analysed the evidence of P.W.1 in the light of
the entire material available on record, we are of the considered
opinion that her testimony does not inspire confidence of the Court.
The material contradictions, inherent improbabilities, unexplained delay
in lodging the First Information Report, the significant admission made
by P.W.2, the inconsistencies between the ocular and medical
evidence, the doubtful circumstances surrounding the arrest of the
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
accused, the absence of corroborative forensic evidence, and the
failure of the prosecution to establish the motive cumulatively create a
serious doubt about the truthfulness of the prosecution case.
24.
In view of the foregoing discussion and the circumstances
brought on record, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable doubt. Consequently, the appellant is entitled to the benefit
of doubt.
Therefore, the conviction and sentence recorded by the
learned X Additional District and Sessions Judge-cum-Special
Sessions Judge, Krishna, Machilipatnam, against appellant is liable to
be set aside.
25.
In the result, the Criminal Appeal is allowed and the conviction
and sentence recorded by the learned X Additional District and
Sessions Judge-cum-Special Sessions Judge, Krishna, Machilipatnam
under Sections 302 and 506 IPC against the appellant in Sessions
Case No.127 of 2016 vide judgment dated 31.08.2018 is hereby set
aside and he is acquitted of the offences under Sections 302 and 506
IPC. Fine amount, if any, paid by the appellant shall be refunded to
him.
26.
As the appellant was released on bail pursuant to the order of
this Court dated 18.04.2024 in I.A.No.1 of 2024, his bail bonds shall
stand cancelled.
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall
stand closed.
_____
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
____________________________
JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
Date: 20.07.2026
Asr
Crl.A.No.3271 of 2018
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
JUDGMENT
Criminal Appeal No.3271 of 2018
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Date: 20.07.2026
Asr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review