Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010161402018
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4972/2018
ANANDA TOKBI
S/O. LT. HAREN TOKBI, VILL. JUNGTHUNG TIMUNG GAON, P.S.
DOKMOKA, P.O. DUARBAMUNI (DENGAON), DIST. KARBI ANGLONG,
ASSAM PRESENTLY POSTED AS SUB-DIVISIONAL POLICE OFFICER,
NAZIRA, SIVASAGAR, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, HOME AND
POLITICAL DEPTT., DISPUR, GHY.-06.
2:THE ADDL. SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM HOME (A) DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY.
ASSAM.
3:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
ASSAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI-07
ASSAM.
4:THE ENQUIRY OFFICER
THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
STF
ASSAM
SRIMANTAPUR
GUWAHATI- 32
Page No.# 2/13
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. B C DAS, MR D N BHATTACHARYYA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 26.02.2026
Heard Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, learned counsel, appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. J. K. Goswami, learned Additional Senior
Government Advocate.
2.
The petitioner in the present proceeding has presented a challenge
to an order dated 23-03-2018, issued by the Disciplinary authority imposing
upon him a penalty of withholding of one increment with cumulative effect
in pursuance to a Departmental proceeding instituted against him in the
matter. The petitioner has also assailed the enquiry report submitted, which
had led to the passing of the impugned order dated 23-03-2018 along with
the order passed by the Appellate authority upholding the impugned order
dated 23-03-2018.
3.
The petitioner, while working as a Sub-Divisional Police Officer
(SDPO), Gossaigaon, basing on certain allegations relating to the discharge
of duties by the petitioner during the period when communal violence had
broken out in Kokrajhar district, he came to be placed under suspension
w.e.f 26-07-2012. The petitioner was thereafter reinstated in his service
w.e.f. 07-10-2013. Prior to reinstatement of the petitioner in his service, a
Departmental proceeding was instituted against the petitioner by way of
issuance of a show-cause notice dated 18-05-2013 wherein 5 (five)
Page No.# 3/13
allegations came to be leveled against the petitioner which all pertains to
the period when the petitioner was functioning as the Sub-Divisional Police
Officer, Gossaigaon. The petitioner submitted his show-cause reply to the
said show-cause notice dated 18-05-2013, on 29-05-2013 and therein by
highlighting the vagueness with regard to the allegations leveled against
him, proceeded to submit his clarifications in the matter and also denied the
allegations so leveled against him.
Being not satisfied with the show-cause reply so submitted in the matter by
the petitioner, the Disciplinary authority of the petitioner proceeded to direct
for holding of an enquiry in the matter and for the purpose appointed an
Enquiry Officer and a Presenting Officer. The petitioner participated in the
enquiry. On conclusion of the enquiry, the Enquiry Officer submitted his
report on 11-04-2017.
A copy of the said report was forwarded to the petitioner by his Disciplinary
authority vide communication dated 15-04-2017 requiring the petitioner to
file his representation thereon. The petitioner thereafter submitted a
representation dated 24-07-2017 dealing with the findings recorded by the
Enquiry Officer in his enquiry report dated 11-04-2017. Upon submission of
the said enquiry report, the Disciplinary authority of the petitioner
considered the same in the light of the representation submitted by the
petitioner and, vide order dated 23-03-2018, proceeded to impose upon the
petitioner penalty of withholding one increment with cumulative effect,
w.e.f. the date of the next increment due to the petitioner.
Further, the period of suspension undergone by the petitioner w.e.f. 26-072012 to 07-10-2013 was also directed to be regularized as on duty and,
accordingly, the Departmental proceeding instituted against the petitioner
came to be closed.
The petitioner, being aggrieved by the penalty as imposed upon him,
preferred an appeal before the Appellate authority on 18-04-2018. The
appeal not being considered and disposed of after a reasonable period of
time, the petitioner approached this Court by way of instituting the present
Page No.# 4/13
writ petition.
4.
During the pendency of the present writ petition, the Appellate
authority, vide an order dated 12-08-2025 proceeded to consider the appeal
and reject the same and thereby uphold the penalty as imposed upon the
petitioner by his Disciplinary authority. The Appellate authority’s order,
having been furnished to the petitioner, he amended the present writ
petition and thereby presented a challenge to the order of the Appellate
authority also.
5.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, learned counsel for the petitioner, after
reiterating the facts as noticed hereinabove, has at the outset, by taking
this Court through the allegations leveled against the petitioner in the
show-cause notice dated 18-05-2013, has submitted that a perusal of the
same would reveal that the Disciplinary authority, while proceeding to level
allegations against the petitioner, no concrete particulars were so disclosed
and the allegations leveled were vague to the core of it. He submits that
the provisions of Rule 9 (2) of the Assam Service (Discipline and Appeal)
Rules, 1964, mandates that the Disciplinary authority is required to frame
definite charges on the basis of allegations on which the enquiry is
proposed to be held. He submits that a perusal of the allegations so
leveled would reveal that no definite allegations with requisite particulars
came to be leveled against the petitioner and the allegations are vague to
the core of it. Accordingly, he submits that an enquiry based on such
vague and indefinite allegations would not have been maintainable against
the petitioner.
6.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, has submitted that after the show-cause
notice was received by the petitioner, he, after highlighting the vagueness
Page No.# 5/13
with regard to the allegations leveled against him, had dealt with the
allegations leveled by basing on the steps taken by him while working as
SDPO, Gossaigaon, during the violence that had erupted in the area at that
relevant point of time.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, submits that the petitioner had brought on record
all requisite materials disclosing the steps taken by him in the matter, which
would reveal that the petitioner is not guilty of not having taken any steps
for containing the violence that had erupted at that relevant point of time.
7.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, submits that an enquiry having been
directed, the petitioner had participated in the said enquiry. He submits that
the petitioner, while deposing in the enquiry had categorically stated that he
desired to adduce defence witness and also wanted to cross-examine,
Jitmol Doley, IPS, who had earlier deposed as Prosecution witness,
however, the said prayer of the petitioner came to be rejected. Learned
counsel submits that on account of such refusal on the part of the Enquiry
Officer a prejudice came to be caused to the petitioner and he was
prevented from defending the charges framed against him effectively. He
further submits that the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer, under the
said circumstances, would not mandate an acceptance from this Court.
8.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, by taking this Court to the enquiry report has
submitted that the Enquiry Officer, after noticing the deposition of the
Departmental witnesses, had proceeded to record his findings basing
thereon, while nothing material is contended to have been brought on
record against the petitioner, the Enquiry Officer had recorded a finding to
the effect that the petitioner could not produce documentary proof of his
physical presence in his jurisdiction between 20-07-2012 to 22.07.2012. He
submits that the said finding recorded by the Enquiry Officer is to be viewed
in the light of the rejection of the prayer of the petitioner to adduce
Page No.# 6/13
documents and defence witnesses. He further submits that show-cause
notice having not specified the period during which the said allegations
were leveled against the petitioner and the same being relatable in the
show-cause notice to the entire period when the petitioner was functioning
as the SDPO, Gossaigaon, the specification of a period by the enquiry
officer in the enquiry report during which the petitioner was alleged to be
not present in his jurisdiction is clearly uncalled for and would not mandate
an acceptance. He further submits that the enquiry officer had recorded a
categorical finding to the effect that the petitioner had remained
untraceable w.e.f. 20-07-2012 to 23-07-2012 except the night of 23-072012, which is clearly perverse. Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, again reiterates that
the said findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer is also beyond the charges
so framed against the petitioner and accordingly the same would not
mandate an acceptance.
9.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, submits that although the petitioner in his
representation referred against the enquiry report had brought on record
the inconsistencies so existing in the enquiry report submitted by the
Enquiry Officer, the Disciplinary authority while proceeding to pass the
order dated 23-03-2018 had not considered the same in its proper
perspective and accordingly the charges leveled against the petitioner was
held to have been established and a penalty of withholding of one
increment with cumulative effect came to be imposed upon the petitioner,
which would mandate an interference from this Court.
10.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, has also submitted that in terms of the
provisions of Rule 7 of the said Rules of 1967, imposition of a penalty of
withholding increments with cumulative effect not having been provided
for, he submits that the said penalty was not permissible to be so imposed
upon the petitioner.
Page No.# 7/13
11.
Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, has further submitted that it would be
permissible for the Disciplinary authority to only impose a penalty which
has been set out in the provisions of the Rules governing such
Departmental proceedings. Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya, by referring to the
order of the appellate authority, highlighting the delay occasioning in
issuing the same, has submitted that the appellate authority had not
applied its mind to the contentions raised by the petitioner in his appeal
memo and had by only referring to the order of penalty imposed upon the
petitioner by the disciplinary authority without further examining the basis
for the imposition of such penalty which was highlighted by the petitioner
to be perverse in his appeal memo, the appeal came to be dismissed. He
submits that the said Appellate order would also mandate an interference
from the Court.
12.
In the above premises, Mr. D. N. Bhattacharya prays that this Court
would be pleased to set aside the orders impugned in the present writ
petition.
13.
Per contra, Mr. J. K. Goswami, learned Additional Senior Government
Advocate, appearing for the State Respondents, submits that the plea taken
by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the charge leveled against the
petitioner was vague and untenable, would not mandate an acceptance,
inasmuch as, a perusal of the charges so framed against the petitioner, it is
discernible that the same was so leveled against him with regard to the
period when the petitioner was serving as the Sub-Divisional Police Officer,
Gossaigaon, and during the period when the communal violence had
erupted in the area. He submits that these two parameters having been set
out in the allegations so leveled against the petitioner, the plea taken by the
Page No.# 8/13
learned counsel for the petitioner that the allegations leveled against the
petitioner was vague, would not mandate an acceptance from this Court.
14.
Mr. J. K. Goswami, has submitted that what was alleged against the
petitioner was the inaction on his part to take appropriate measures at the
time when the communal violence had erupted in the area wherein, he was
so posted as SDPO. Mr. J. K. Goswami, submits that the same is also
evident from the allegations leveled against him.
15.
Mr. J. K. Goswami, submits that the charges framed against the
petitioner, which relates to commission of serious lapse and willful
dereliction of duty by him, as well as negligence of duty, if viewed in the
light of materials available in the show cause issued to the petitioner would
reveal that the same are not vague as alleged by the learned counsel for
the petitioner. Mr. J. K. Goswami, by referring to the findings recorded by
the Enquiry Officer, submits that the same is found to have been so
recorded, basing on the materials coming on record in the enquiry. He
submits that in the enquiry, the deposition of the Departmental witnesses
have brought on record the fact that the petitioner, when the said
communal violence had erupted, although was posted in the area, had not
taken steps for containing such violence which had led to the spreading of
the same to the nearby areas.
16.
Mr. J. K. Goswami, has submitted that the evidences adduced by the
Departmental witnesses have brought on record the fact that the petitioner
was not found to be discharging his duties w.e.f. 20-07-2012 for 3 (three)
days and accordingly, the same being the period when the said communal
violence had so erupted, the dereliction of duty as alleged against the
petitioner was established in the enquiry. Mr. J. K. Goswami, has submitted
that the Enquiry Officer, for the purpose of arriving at his conclusions with
regard to the materials coming on record, had to apply the principle of
Page No.# 9/13
preponderance of probability and not the principle of proof beyond
reasonable doubt. He submits that the materials coming on record when
examined by applying the principles of preponderance of probability, it is
seen that the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer in the matter would
not mandate an interference. Accordingly, Mr. J. K. Goswami submits that
the findings of the Enquiry Officer having been concurred to by the
Disciplinary authority, a lenient penalty came to be imposed upon the
petitioner of withholding of one increment with cumulative effect which
according to him would not mandate an interference from this Court.
17.
In the above background, Mr. J. K. Goswami, has submitted that this
Court would be pleased to uphold the penalty as imposed upon the
petitioner so as to maintain the discipline of the force and not put a
premium upon the dereliction of duty established against a responsible
Police Officer in the enquiry, by directing his reinstatement in service.
18.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials available on record.
19.
The petitioner in the present proceeding was issued with a show-
cause notice dated 18-05-2013, leveling the following allegations and
charges against him;
“(1) While you were posted as Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Gossaigaon,
under Kokrajhar District, since the breakout of communal violence in
Kokrajhar District, you were found evasive and untraceable at the time of
need and neglecting your duties as SDPO of the sensitive Gossaigaon SubDivision.
(2) Your unauthorized absence from duty, and lack of supervision in such a
volatile situation caused serious breach of the peace in the Sub-division.
(3) Besides, the fallout of this incidents that led to wide spread communal
Page No.# 10/13
conflagration from one village to another in Gossaigaon Sub-division and
law and order of the Sub division went beyond control, the people went on
a large scale communal rampage by indulging violence, burning, looting
and many innocent people get injured due to attacks and counter attacks.
(4) You failed in containing law and order situation and securing the life
and property of public of Gossaigaon Sub-Division.
(5) Your cowardliness in blatant violation of the spirit and letter under
proviso of Rule-115 of the Assam Police Manual. Part-III and Rule -98(a)
of the Assam Police Act. 2007.”
Your above action amounts to serious lapse and willful dereliction of duty
which tantamount to gross misconduct and negligence of duty on your
part as a responsible Senior Police Officer.
Hence, you are, charged with gross misconduct, negligence of duty and
dereliction of duty.”
20.
A perusal of the said allegations leveled against the petitioner would
reveal that the petitioner was alleged to have remained evasive and
untraceable while there was a breakout of communal violence in Kokrajhar,
district. It was further alleged that he had neglected his duties as SubDivisional Police Officer, Gossaigaon. The absence of the petitioner was
projected as unauthorized absence and the lack of supervision was alleged
to have resulted in a volatile situation causing breach of peace in the SubDivision. The petitioner was alleged to have failed in containing the law
and order situation and securing the life and property of the public of
Gossaigaon Sub-Division. The petitioner was also alleged of cowardliness
in blatant violation of the spirit and letter under Proviso to Rule 115 of the
Assam Police Manual, Part III and Rule 98(a) of the Assam Police Act,
Page No.# 11/13
2007. The petitioner, on receipt of the said show-cause notice, submitted
his show-cause reply on 29-05-2013 thereto, and in his said show-cause
reply, the petitioner in details set out the duties performed by him during
the period when the communal violence had occasioned in the area under
his control. The petitioner denied the allegations leveled against him.
Being not satisfied, a Departmental enquiry was ordered in the matter and
the petitioner is also found to have participated in the said enquiry.
On conclusion of the enquiry, the Enquiry Officer submitted his report on
11-04-2017 holding that the charge of being evasive and being untraceable
w.e.f., 20-07-2012 to 23-07-2012, except the night of 23-07-2012, was
found to be established beyond a reasonable doubt against the petitioner.
The said finding was recorded by the Enquiry Officer basing on a conclusion
drawn that the petitioner, herein, could not produce any documentary proof
of his physical presence in his jurisdiction between 20-07-2012 and 22-072012.
The petitioner was found by the Enquiry Officer to only have produced
evidence of his presence within his jurisdiction w.e.f. 23-07-2012 and 2407-2012 through the GD entries and a W.T. message. The conclusion drawn
by the Enquiry Officer to the effect that the petitioner had not produced any
documentary evidence to establish his presence within his jurisdictional
area is to be examined in the light of the statement recorded of the
petitioner in the enquiry wherein, the prayer of the petitioner for crossexamination of the prosecution witness Jitmol Doley, IPS, and also to
adduce defence witnesses was rejected by the Enquiry Officer. The Enquiry
Officer in his report had relied upon the deposition of said Jitmol Doley, IPS,
then SP Kokrajhar, for the purpose of drawing conclusions against the
petitioner, herein. The Enquiry Officer having placed a reliance upon the
deposition of said Jitmol Doley, IPS, the denial of opportunity to the
petitioner to cross-examine said prosecution witness Jitmol Doley, IPS, in
the considered view of this Court has caused prejudice to the petitioner.
Page No.# 12/13
Further, the petitioner had sought for adducing defence witnesses to bring
on record materials with regard to his whereabouts, during the period the
communal violence had flared up in the area under his jurisdiction. The
same was however rejected by the Enquiry Officer. Such rejection of the
prayer of the petitioner to adduce defence witnesses has caused prejudice
to the petitioner, in effectively defending the charges framed against him.
21.
The conclusions drawn by the Enquiry Officer in the enquiry report
being found by this Court to have been so drawn without providing
reasonable opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, herein, to defend the
charges framed against him a prejudice being caused to the petitioner
being apparent, such conclusions drawn by the Enquiry Officer in the
considered view of this Court stands vitiated.
Further, the Disciplinary authority basing on such vitiated conclusions could
not have proceeded to impose any penalty upon the petitioner.
22.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court would now examine
the order dated 23-03-2018 passed by the Disciplinary authority. The
Disciplinary authority for the purpose of drawing his conclusions in the
matter had agreed with the findings recorded by the Enquiry officer in his
enquiry report. However, while drawing such conclusion, the Disciplinary
authority had not dealt with the plea raised by the petitioner in his
representation of the deprivation caused to him in defending his case in the
enquiry.
23.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the conclusions
drawn by the Disciplinary authority in the order dated 23-03-2018 stands
vitiated.
Accordingly, the penalty of withholding of 1 (one) increment with
cumulative effect as imposed upon the petitioner would also stand vitiated.
Page No.# 13/13
24.
In view of the above position, the order dated 23-03-2018 passed by
the Disciplinary authority stands set aside and the period of suspension of
the petitioner w.e.f., 26-07-2012 to 07-10-2013 is directed to be regularized
as on duty with all consequential benefits. The Appellate authority having
only reiterated the conclusions drawn by the Enquiry Officer and the
Disciplinary authority, the said order is also found for the reasons assigned,
hereinabove, to also be vitiated and accordingly, the Appellate authority's
order dated 12-08-2025 also stands set aside. The petitioner be authorized
the withheld increment with all consequential benefits.
25.
The penalty imposed upon the petitioner having been interfered
with, it is provided that in the event the said penalty had caused any
deprivation to the petitioner, in his service career, the same be remedied by
the respondent authorities, appropriately.
26.
With the above observations and directions, the present writ petition
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review