Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 127 of 2021
Date of Decision: 13.04.2023
Shri. Amzad Khan
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The writ petitioner being aggrieved with his removal from
service on account of unauthorized absence, which he claims is not
willful, but due to compelling circumstances is before this Court,
assailing the order of removal dated 17.06.2020, passed by the respondent
No. 4, and the appellate order dated 15.02.2021, passed by the respondent
No. 3, whereby the order of removal has been upheld.
2.
The petitioner who was serving in the Meghalaya Police, due to
his unauthorized absence for the period from 14.12.2019 to 18.03.2020,
without any information to his superiors was subjected to departmental
proceedings. The said proceedings culminated in the orders of removal
from service, which the petitioner alleges is arbitrary, and the punishment
awarded disproportionate to the alleged misconduct. It has also been
contended that, adequate opportunity was not afforded to the writ
petitioner and that there was no willful absence from duty as the petitioner
was hospitalized and suffering from psychiatric issues, brought upon by
alcohol dependency.
3.
Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, the
petitioner was unable to attend his duties, as he was undergoing treatment
for his physical and psychiatric ailments, and in the departmental
proceedings, while admitting to the unauthorized absence before the
Enquiry Officer, however did not file any show-cause, but had produced
medical certificates indicating his medical condition. He submits that, the
petitioner could not attend to his duties or inform his superiors, is due to
these compelling circumstances and his absence can in no manner, be
considered as willful. Learned counsel has further submitted that, on the
earlier occasions, when he was absent without leave or information, the
respondents had condoned the same, as they were aware about his
medical condition, but for the last period of his unauthorized absence, he
has been harshly dealt with, which is disproportionate to the act of
misconduct. At the most he submits, an order of compulsory retirement
could have been passed in the facts and circumstances of the case.
4.
The learned counsel however, in the course of hearing, did not
press the aspect of not being afforded adequate opportunity to defend his
case, but has limited his challenge to whether the absence can be
considered willful, and whether the petitioner has been awarded
punishment, which is not commensurate with the infraction. Reliance has
been placed on the following judgments, on the point of willful absence
and extent of penalty.
i)
Krushnakant B. Parmar vs. Union of India & Anr.
(2012) 3 SCC 178
ii)
State of Punjab vs. Dr. P.L. Singla (2008) 8 SCC 469
iii)
Chairman-Cum-Managing
Director,
Coal
India
Limited & Anr. vs. Mukul Kumar Choudhuri & Ors.
(2009) 15 SCC 620
iv)
Order dated 15.03.2023, passed in Civil Appeal No.
10604/2010 (Eastern Coal Fields Limited & Ors. vs. Ajit
Mondal & Ors.)
5.
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG assisted by Ms. R. Colney,
learned GA on behalf of the respondents submits that, adequate
opportunity had been afforded to the writ petitioner, and when notice to
resume duty dated 09.01.2020, which was published in The Shillong
Times, did not evoke any response from the petitioner, a show-cause
notice was issued on 04.03.2020, which was duly received by the writ
petitioner. However, he submits as reflected from the impugned order, the
petitioner did not submit any written explanation to the show-cause
notice, and inspite of all opportunities being provided in the course of
inquiry to the petitioner, to examine the prosecution witnesses, at the time
of recording statements, the petitioner declined the same. The learned
AAG then submits that, the petitioner did not offer any explanation as to
his absence, to show that the same was not willful, and in this regard, has
referred to a Fitness Certificate issued by the Shillong Hospital, which
shows that, he was fit to join service as on 15.02.2020, but still remained
absent.
6.
The punishment inflicted, he argues is just and proper, inasmuch
as, the petitioner habitually remained absent from duty without
information. To illustrate this point, the learned AAG has referred to the
affidavit filed by the respondents, wherein at Para – 14, twelve instances
of absenteeism have been shown. He submits that, inspite of the leniency
shown by the respondents all along, the petitioner has continued with
dereliction of his duties by remaining absent without information. He
further submits that, the petitioner being a member of a disciplined force,
such behaviour and conduct is impermissible. The learned AAG while
concluding his submissions, has also placed reliance on the same
judgments, placed by the petitioner to show, as to how the said judgments
infact, work against the petitioner’s case, and submits that, there being no
illegality or irregularity in the disciplinary proceedings, and adequate
opportunity having been given, no case for interference has been made
out.
7.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties, it is first to be
noted that, the impugned removal order has not been assailed on the
ground that, the proceedings held, were not as per the set procedure, or
that, they were vitiated by non-adherence to the Principles of Natural
Justice, but the challenge is on the findings arrived at, and the quantum
of punishment. On the question of findings, as is well settled, this Court
is not sitting as a Court of appeal and judicial review is not of the decision
arrived at, but is confined to the decision making process. In the instant
case, where the petitioner has not denied the charges and in fact, has not
even bothered to file a show-cause, there is no scope for any further
examination of the case on this aspect, and the charges stand proved. The
compelling circumstances, which have been urged by the petitioner to
show that, the unauthorized absence was not willful is belied by the
Fitness Certificate annexed by the petitioner himself as Annexure – 10 to
the writ petition, wherein he has been shown fit to join service w.e.f.,
15.02.2020, but as per the charge, had remained absent till 18.03.2020.
8.
On the issue of the proportionality of the punishment awarded,
it would be expedient to reproduce the extract of Para – 14 of the affidavit
of the respondents, wherein the periods that the petitioner was
unauthorisedly absent have been detailed to show the antecedents of the
petitioner in his service record, which are as follows.
1) 82 (eight-two) days Leave Without Pay for unauthorized
absence from duty w.e.f. 27.11.2011 AM to 16.02.2012 PM
vide B.O. No. 1068 Dated 19.03.2012.
2) Awarded 5 (five) days P.D. for two hours daily for
consuming alcohol while on duty at the residence of ExCM Bungalow Shri D.D. Lapang vide B.O. No. 4016 Dated
06.12.2013.
3) 40 (forty) days Leave Without Pay for his unauthorized
absence from duty w.e.f. 30.04.2014 PM to 09.06.2014 PM
vide B.O No. 2023 Dated 18.06.2014.
4) 10 (ten) days Leave Without Pay for his unauthorized
absence from BN/HQ w.e.f. 02.06.2015 AM to 12.06.2015
AM vide B.O. No. 2218 Dated 18.06.2015.
5) 61 (sixty-one) days Leave Without Pay for his unauthorized
absence from duty w.e.f. 15.12.2015 AM to 13.02.2016 PM
vide B.O. No. 690, Dated 01.03.2016.
6) Departmental Proceeding No. 2/17 was drawn up against
him for his gross misconduct and dereliction of duty vide
B.O. No. 2773 Dated 14.09.2017
7) 343 (three hundred forty-three) days Leave Without Pay for
remaining
unauthorized
absence
from
duty
w.e.f.
13.05.2016 AM to 21.04.2017 AM vide B.O. No. 3098 Dated
16.10.2017.
8) 15 (fifteen) days Leave Without Pay for his unauthorized
absence from duty w.e.f. 26.01.2018 AM to 09.02.2018 PM
vide B.O. No. 600 Dated 20.02.2018.
9) 10 (ten) days Leave Without Pay for his unauthorized
absence from duty w.e.f. 28.06.2018 PM to 08.07.2018 PM
vide B.O No. 3663 Dated 05.11.2018.
10)
189 (one hundred eighty-nine) days Leave Without Pay
for his unauthorized absence from duty w.e.f. 23.10.2018 to
29.04.2019 PM vide B.O. No. 1497 Dated 02.05.2019.
11)
Departmental Proceeding No. 2/20 was drawn up
against him for his gross misconduct and dereliction of duty
vide B.O. No. 3005 Dated 12.05.2020.
12)
96 (ninety-six) days Leave Without Pay for his
unauthorized absence from duty w.e.f. 14.12.2019 AM to
18.03.2020 PM vide B.O. No. 2970 Dated 07.05.2020.
9.
The petitioner being a member of the disciplined force, is infact,
required to maintain higher standards of conduct. In this context, the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Union of India &
Ors. vs. Datta Linga Toshatwad reported in (2005) 13 SCC 709 at Para6, which is reproduced below, applies to the case of the petitioner.
“6.
One cannot ignore the large number of
cases which come to this Court of members of
uniformed forces remaining absent from duty
without any reasonable explanation. Whenever
action is taken, the usual plea taken is of having
been ill or some such false pretext, and even fake
or false medical certificates are produced in
support of such a plea. We would not have taken
a serious view of the matter had it not been a case
of a constable belonging to CRPF remaining
absent for an indefinite period. Even if we assume
that the respondent was suffering from depression
and was being treated as an outdoor patient, the
medical certificates produced by him show that he
was restored to normalcy on 4-4-1998 yet the
respondent did not choose to report for duty. The
order of dismissal was passed seven months later
i.e. on 2-11-1998. This itself discloses the
hollowness of the claim of the respondent
regarding mental depression and imbalance
which he claims to have suffered.”
10.
The decisions as placed by the petitioner, being of no assistance,
as the facts of the instant case stand on a different footing, are not
discussed.
11.
For the foregoing reasons and circumstances, no case is made
out for any interference and the writ petition accordingly is dismissed.
12.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
13.04.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review