Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/27
GAHC010291382019
2026:GAU-AS:11440
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/9127/2019
AMULYA PAUL
S/O- LT. SACHINDRA PAUL, R/O- VILL- BHOGDOL, P.O. ORANG, P.S.
ORANG, DIST.- UDALGURI, BTAD, ASSAM, PIN- 784114
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
BEING REP. BY THE SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF HOME
AFFAIRS (CENTRAL SECRETARIAT), P.O. NEW DELHI, PIN- 110001
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
BEING REP. BY THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
HOME DEPTT.
ASSAM SACHIBALAYA
DISPUR
P.O. GHY
PIN- 781006
3:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NIRVACHAN SADAN
ASHOKA ROAD
NEW DELHI- 110001
4:THE OFFICE OF THE STATE CO-ORDINATOR OF NATIONAL REGISTER OF
CITIZENS (NRC)
ASSAM
1ST FLOOR
ACHYUT PLAZA
G.S.ROAD
BHANGAGARH
GHY-05
DIST.- KAMRUP (M)
Page No.# 2/27
ASSAM
5:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
UDALGURI
ASSAM
PIN- 782105
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
UDALGURI
ASSAM
PIN- 78210
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
For the petitioner
: Mr. A.R. Shome, Advocate.
For respondents
: Mr. N. Upadhaya, CGC.
: Ms. A. Verma, standing counsel.
: Mr. P. Sarmah, Addl. Sr. Govt. Advocate.
: Mr. A.I. Ali, standing counsel
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 06.08.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 13.08.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
(K.R. Surana, J)
Heard Mr. A.R. Shome, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. N. Upadhaya, learned CGC, Mr. A.I. Ali, learned standing counsel for
the ECI, Mr. P. Sarmah, learned Addl. Senior Govt. Advocate and Ms. A. Verma,
Page No.# 3/27
learned standing counsel for the Border matters, FT and NRC.
2.
By filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the constitution of
India, the petitioner, namely, Amulya Paul, has assailed the ex parte opinion
dated 13.09.2018, passed by the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal (2 nd),
Darrang, Mangaldai in F.T. 2nd Case No.620/2008, arising out of Ref case
No.7380/98, by which the petitioner was declared to be illegal migrant of post
25.03.1971 stream.
3.
This writ petition was filed on 26.11.2019 and notice was issued
by order dated 13.05.2020, and records were called for examination and the
petitioner was allowed to go on bail. The matter was thereafter, listed on
17.07.2026 and then on 05.08.2026, when with the consent of all sides, the
learned counsel for the petitioner was heard at the “motion stage”. As similar
matters were being heard, the matter was adjourned for hearing the learned
CGC, State and Departmental counsel. Accordingly, the matter was finally heard
on 06.08.2026 at the “motion stage”.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has made three-fold
following submissions:a.
It was submitted that as per the process server’s report notice of the
proceeding dated 10.01.2017, issued by the learned Tribunal was
served on the petitioner, but though the service report contains the
purported signature of the petitioner, but the process server’s report
does not mention about the date on which the notice was served on
the petitioner.
b.
It is further submitted that as per the form of notice it was alleged
Page No.# 4/27
that the petitioner had entered into India on 01.01.1966 and
25.03.1971. However, as per the impugned ex parte opinion, the
petitioner was declared to be foreigner who had illegally entered into
Assam after 25.03.1971.
c.
It was submitted that in the column no.4 of the Form of Enquiry
under Annexure-A, the year of his birth is mentioned as 1965 and
therefore, the petitioner would be a citizen of India under Section 3 of
the Citizenship Act.
5.
In support of the prayer to assail the ex parte opinion, the
learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to the case Sabitri Dey @
Swasthi Dey v. Union of India and Ors., Civil Appeal No. 2820/2024, decided on
13.07.2026 by the Supreme Court of India, reported in 2026 INSC 694.
6.
Per contra, the learned standing counsel for the FT and Border
matters has made her submissions to oppose the prayer for setting aside the ex
parte opinion and she has referred to the records received from the learned
Tribunal. The learned CGC and the learned Addl. Senior Govt. Advocate had
adopted the submissions made by the learned standing counsel for the FT and
Border matters.
7.
Considered the submission and the case cited by the learned
counsel for the petitioner. Also perused the records received from the learned
Tribunal.
On ex parte opinion:
8.
The records reveal that the petitioner was duly served with a
notice issued on 30.03.2010, to appear before the learned Tribunal on
Page No.# 5/27
19.04.2010 and the service report contains his signature. After service, the
service report dated 13.04.2010 was returned to the learned Tribunal. As per
order dated 19.04.2010, the petitioner had entered appearance in the case and
submitted his hazira (attendance-sheet filed before Tribunal) and the said hazira
is available in the Tribunal’s record. Accordingly, the next date of the
proceedings was fixed on 12.08.2010. Since his first and last appearance before
the learned Tribunal on 19.04.2010, the petitioner had remained continuously
absent without any steps for more than 8 (eight) years from 12.08.2010 till
13.09.2018. Thereafter, the learned Tribunal had passed the ex parte opinion on
13.09.2018.
9.
The learned Tribunal’s record further reveals that after the
petitioner had defaulted in appearing before the learned Tribunal, the learned
Tribunal had again issued another notice on 06.05.2011 and the said notice was
also duly served upon the petitioner, which was received by him by putting his
signature on the service report. The service report containing petitioner’s
signature was returned on 15.06.2011. However, the petitioner, despite
receiving the second notice, did not appear and did not take any steps before
the learned Tribunal.
10.
Thereafter, the learned Tribunal had once again issued another
notice dated 10.01.2017, to the petitioner. The said third notice was duly served
on the petitioner by putting his signature on the service report. By the said
notice, the petitioner was directed to appear on 13.02.2017. The service report
was returned back to the learned Tribunal on 13.02.2017, but the petitioner
again did not appear or took any steps before the learned Tribunal.
11.
Despite notice being served thrice, the learned Tribunal had
Page No.# 6/27
adjourned the case on 17 (seventeen) dates awaiting appearance of the
petitioner. Thereafter, the impugned ex parte opinion was passed on
13.09.2018.
12.
Hence, this is not a case where there was a single default by the
petitioner in appearing before the learned Foreigners Tribunal. Notice was duly
served to the petitioner thrice, which is evident from the fact that at the backpage of the notice, the signature of the petitioner is available, which is neither
disputed nor denied by the petitioner. This is also not a case where the learned
Tribunal had shown any haste in passing the opinion, rather, this is a case where
the learned Tribunal had not complied with the mandate of Paragraph 3(14) of
the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 by not making any attempt to dispose of
the proceeding within the time of 60 days from the date of reference, as
provided thereunder.
Suppression of facts in this writ petition:
13.
The fact that notice/ summons was served thrice to the
petitioner has been withheld by the petitioner and the said fact has been
suppressed. Therefore, had the Court did not examine the records, it would not
have come to light that the petitioner was served with notice/summons thrice.
The petitioner has suppressed that he had appeared before the learned Tribunal
on 19.04.2010, and then abandoned his defence.
14.
Suppression of facts disentitles the petitioner a right to be heard.
Yet, as the issue of citizenship is involved, for ends of justice, the merit of the
case has also been examined.
On the initiation of reference:
Page No.# 7/27
15.
The Tribunal’s record reveals that in the year 1997, the name of
the petitioner was entered in the electoral roll for 70 Mazbat Legislative
Assembly Constituency (hereinafter referred to as LAC for short). The Election
Commission India had ordered intensive revision of electoral roll for the 70
Mazbat LAC in Assam with reference to 01.01.1997 as the qualifying date.
Resultantly, house to house enumeration was conducted during the period from
16.01.1997 to 15.04.1997. The Electoral Registration Officer (hereinafter
referred to as ERO for short) of the said 70 Mazbat LAC, having doubt about the
citizenship of the petitioner, had directed on-the-spot local verification. On
consideration of the report of such verification, the ERO had expressed that
there was a reasonable doubt that the petitioner is not a citizen of India.
Accordingly, the matter was forwarded to the Superintendent of Police, Darrang,
Mangaldai, who is the competent authority under the erstwhile Illegal Migrants
(Determination by Tribunals) Act, 1983 [IM(DT) Act]; the Foreigners Act, 1946;
and rules made thereunder, to ascertain as to whether or not the petitioner is a
citizen of India. On receipt of the Verification Report, the reference, as per the
format prescribed under the erstwhile IM(DT) Act was submitted by the ERO on
24.10.1979, enclosing therewith the LVO’s report and the notice informing the
petitioner. It is seen from the record that the Superintendent of Police, Darrang,
Mangaldai, had directed a Sub-Inspector (Border) to verify and submit the
report. Thereafter, the reference was submitted before the erstwhile Illegal
Migrants (Determination) Tribunal [IM(D)T for short].
16.
The Supreme Court of India, in the case of Sarbananda Sonowal
v. Union of India, (2005) 5 SCC 665 , declared the IM(DT) Act to be ultra vires
and all the proceedings before the then IM(D)T’s were transferred to the
Foreigner’s Tribunals having jurisdiction. As a consequence, the said case was
Page No.# 8/27
transferred to the learned Foreigners Tribunal (2 nd), Darrang, Mangaldai, for
disposal. Thus, the form of enquiry, which was being used under the erstwhile
IM(DT) Act, has remained on the record.
17.
However, with the declaring of the erstwhile IM(DT) Act, 1983 as
ultra vires, the legal position has altered. Under IM(DT) Act, the onus was on
the State and/or the complainant to prove that the suspect is a foreigner.
However, under Section 9 of the Foreigners Act, 1946, the burden of proof lies
on the proceedee/suspect to prove that he/she is not a foreigner but an Indian
citizen.
18.
This position has been referred to by the Supreme Court of India
in the case of Sarbananda Sonowal (supra) (paragraph 26) , and reiterated in
the case of Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India, (2007) 1 SCC 174
(hereinafter referred to as Sarbananda Sonowal-II for convenience).
19.
Moreover, it may be stated that this Court, in the case of
Shukurjan Nessa @ Sukurjan v Union of India & Ors., W.P.(C) 245/2019,
decided on 28.02.2025, had elaborately dealt with the reference initiated by the
ERO. The relevant part of the said judgment and order is extracted
hereinbelow:14. The point raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the reference
was blank and not properly filled up and therefore, the grounds of suspecting the
petitioner to be a foreigner has not been furnished to her is taken up first.
15. In this case, the reference was made by the Superintendent of Police
(Border), Barpeta, on receipt of communication dated 16.03.1998, issued by the
Electoral Registration Officer, 44 No. Jania L.A.C., which is accompanied with a
three page Local Verification Report (Annexure-A) by one Sri Khagen Kalita, J.E. In
the said LVO Report dated 17.10.1997, it has been mentioned at two places to the
effect that no documents produced during field verification.
16. Therefore, this is not a case where any enquiry was made under the
provisions of Foreigners Act, 1946 or Rules framed thereunder, where investigation
Page No.# 9/27
is done under the authority of the Superintendent of Police (Border). The
jurisdictional Superintendent of Police (Border) is the prescribed authority to make
reference before the Illegal Migrants (Determination) Tribunal constituted under
the erstwhile Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals) Act, 1983 and Rules
framed thereunder.
17. There is an important facet, which is contained in the judgment and order of
this Court in the case of Sayam Uddin (supra), which must be referred to. We are
in respectful agreement with the said judgment and therefore, paragraphs 11 to
22 thereof are quoted below:11. In the year 1997, Election Commission of India had undertaken an
intensive revision of electoral rolls in the State of Assam as apprehensions
were expressed from various quarters that the electoral rolls were infested
with the names of foreigners/illegal migrants. In the course of this exercise
citizenship status of as many as 3,13,046 persons whose names were in the
draft voters lists were found to be doubtful and accordingly they were
marked as doubtful “D” voters in the electoral rolls after local verification.
12. Legality of this exercise was challenged before this Court in HRA
Choudhury Vs Election Commission of India, reported in 2002 (1) GLT 1. The
challenge made was rejected by a Division Bench of this Court. In HRA
Choudhury (supra) this Court examined the guidelines dated 17.07.1997 of
the Election Commission of India laying down the procedure to carry out the
exercise.
12.1.
As per paragraph 3.8 of the guidelines the Electoral Registration
Officer was required to consider the verification report received from the
Local Verification Officer. If he was satisfied on such report and such other
material/information as may be available about the eligibility of a person, he
should allow his name to continue on the electoral roll. Where, however, he
was not so satisfied and had reasonable doubt about the citizenship of any
person, he was required to refer such doubtful cases to the competent
authority under the then Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals) Act,
1983 or the Foreigners Act, 1946 as the case may be. For convenience of the
Electoral Registration Officers, Election Commission devised proformas.
12.2.
As per paragraph 3.9, after the case of a person was referred by
the Electoral Registration Officer to the competent authority, he should wait
for the decision of the relevant Tribunal in relation to that person and act
according to such decision.
12.3.
As per paragraph 3.10, where the relevant Tribunal decided that
any such person was not a citizen of India, Electoral Registration Officer
should proceed under Rule 21 A of the Registration of Electors Rolls, 1960 to
have the name of such person deleted from the electoral roll before it was
finally published.
12.4.
This Court in HRA Choudhury (supra) held that such guidelines
and decision of the Election Commission were in accordance with Article 324
Page No.# 10/27
of the Constitution of India besides conforming to the principles of natural
justice. It was held that such guidelines cannot be held to be arbitrary or
vitiated by mala fide or partiality.
13.
At this stage, it may be mentioned that the Illegal Migrants
(Determination by Tribunals) Act, 1983 is no longer in existence, the same
having been declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in Sarbananda
Sonowal Vs Union of India reported in (2005) 5 SCC 665. Therefore, in so far
paragraph 3.8 of the guidelines dated 17.07.1997 is concerned, the reference
would be under the Foreigners Act, 1946.
14. The above exercise was repeated in the year 2005 with the Election
Commission of India again going for intensive revision of electoral rolls in the
State of Assam taking 01.01.2005 as the qualifying date. In this connection,
guidelines dated 17.06.2004 were issued by the Election Commission of
India. Paragraph 2.2 of the guidelines dealt with “D” voters. It was
mentioned that the guidelines issued in 1997 would be followed while dealing
with such category of persons. Paragraph 8 dealt with verification by Electoral
Registration Officers. It laid down the procedure while carrying out such
verification including verification by Local Verification Officer. As per
paragraph 8.6, Local Verification Officer would conduct the verification by
making an on the spot visit and the person concerned could adduce any one
or more of the documents mentioned therein in support of his claim as a
citizen of India. After due verification, the Local Verification Officer was
required to submit his report in the prescribed format. Under paragraph 8.8,
Electoral Registration Officer on receipt of the verification report from the
Local Verification Officer should consider the same. Where he was satisfied
about the eligibility of a person, he should allow the name of such person to
continue on the electoral roll but where he was not so satisfied and had
reasonable doubt about the citizenship of any person he should refer such
doubtful cases to the competent authority under the then Illegal Migrants
(Determination by Tribunals) Act, 1983 or the Foreigners Act, 1946 in a
prepared format (Annexure-B to the guidelines dated 17.06.2004) to the
competent authority for making reference to the Tribunal and await the
decision of such Tribunal.
15. As pointed out by Mr. Barua, in Mameja Khatun (supra) a Single Bench
of this Court directed that “D” voters should not be allowed to cast their
votes with the clarification that “D” voters would include persons whose
names were included in the electoral rolls but their citizenship was doubted
or disputed and also those whose cases were pending before the Foreigners
Tribunals. This decision of the learned Single Bench was confirmed by the
Division Bench in Writ Appeal No. 114/2011 (State Vs Mameja Khatun). By
the judgment and order dated 13.10.2015, the Division Bench directed
Election Commission of India and other authorities to implement the
directions of the Single Bench in letter and spirit.
Page No.# 11/27
16. At this stage, it may also be mentioned that in WP(C) No. 274/2009
filed by Assam Public Works which is pending before the Supreme Court of
India wherein NRC updation exercise in the State of Assam is being
monitored by the Supreme Court of India, on 25.10.2013, Supreme Court
clarified that as far as persons in the “D” list are concerned, undoubtedly
they were doubtful voters and therefore their names could not be included
unless the NRC is updated and unless the Foreigners Tribunals declared them
to be Indian citizens.
17. The Foreigners Act, 1946 is an act to confer upon the Central
Government certain powers in respect of foreigners. This Act provides for the
exercise of certain powers by the Central Government in respect of the entry
of foreigners into India; their presence in India and their departure
therefrom. Section 2 (a) defines a “foreigner” to mean a person who is not a
citizen of India. Section 3 confers power to the Central Government to make
orders making provision either generally or with respect to all foreigners or
with respect to any particular foreigner or any prescribed class or description
of foreigners, for prohibiting, regulating or restricting the entry of foreigners
into India or their departure therefrom or their presence or their continued
presence therein.
17.1. In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 3 of the Foreigners Act,
1946, Central Government made the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964. As
per order 2 (1), the Central Government may by order refer the question as
to whether a person is or is not a foreigner within the meaning of the
Foreigners Act, 1946 to a Tribunal to be constituted for the purpose for its
opinion.
18. Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt. of India had issued notification dated
19.04.1958 in exercise of powers conferred by Clause-(1) of Article 258 of
the Constitution of India whereby the President with the consent of the State
Government concerned entrusted to the Governments of each of the States
mentioned therein including the State of Assam the functions of the Central
Government in making orders of the nature specified in Section 3 of the
Foreigners Act, 1946. Another notification dated 17.02.1976 was issued by
the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs in the exercise of the
powers conferred by Article 258 (1) of the Constitution entrusting the
Superintendents of Police and Deputy Commissioners (In-charge of Police)
under the Government of Assam the functions of the Central Government in
making orders of the nature specified in Section 3 of the Foreigners Act, 1946
within their respective jurisdictions subject to the conditions mentioned
therein which included the condition that exercise of such functions would be
in respect of nationals of Bangladesh and that while exercising such
functions, Superintendents of Police and Deputy Commissioners (In-charge of
Police) shall comply with such general or special directions as the
Government of Assam or the Central Government may issue from time to
Page No.# 12/27
time.
19. Article 258 of the Constitution deals with power of the Union to confer
powers etc on States in certain cases. Clause (1) of Article 258 starts with a
non-obstante clause. It says that notwithstanding anything in the
Constitution, President may with the consent of the Government of a State
entrust either conditionally or unconditionally to that Government or to its
officers, functions in relation to any matter to which the executive power of
the Union extends. Clause (3) provides for making of payment by the
Government of India to the State concerned such sum as may be agreed
upon or in default of agreement through arbitration in respect of any extracost of administration incurred by the State in connection with the exercise of
powers and duties of the Government of India conferred or imposed upon a
State Government.
20. Thus, under the Central Government notifications dated 19.04.1958 and
17.02.1976, Government of Assam, Superintendents of Police and Deputy
Commissioners (In-charge of Police) have been delegated the power to make
reference to the Foreigners Tribunal under order 2 (1) of the Foreigners
(Tribunals) Order, 1964 to seek opinion as to whether the proceedee is a
foreigner or not within the meaning of the Foreigners Act, 1946.
21. Thus from the above, what transpires is that there are two categories of
“D” voters:- (i). those who were marked as “D” voters in the electoral roll by
the Electoral Registration Officer following enquiry by Local Verification
Officer; and (ii). those whose references are pending before the Foreigners
Tribunals.
22.
In so far Electoral Registration Officer is concerned the exercise
undertaken by him while marking a person as a “D” voter in the electoral roll
is a quasi judicial exercise. If he holds the view after examining the enquiry
report of the Local Verification Officer that the concerned person is not a
citizen of India he is required to forward the case of that person to the
competent authority i.e., the Superintendent of Police. If it is so forwarded by
the Electoral Registration Officer, the jurisdictional Superintendent of Police
has to make a reference to the competent Foreigners Tribunals under order
2(1) of the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 based on the report received
from the Electoral Registration Officer. Question of making further enquiry by
the Superintendent of Police in such a case would not arise because enquiry
has already been made by the Electoral Registration Officer by exercising
quasi judicial powers and the Superintendent of Police cannot sit over such
decision of the Electoral Registration Officer. He has to forward the same by
making the reference to the competent Foreigners Tribunal for its opinion.
17. The said judgment by the learned Single Judge has stood affirmed by the
virtue of judgment and order dated 29.07.2019, passed by the Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Sayam Uddin v. The Union of India & Ors., W.A. 170/2019.
18. The learned counsel for the petitioner had cited the case of Moslem Mondal
Page No.# 13/27
(supra) and Amina Khatun (supra) to support his contention that if LVO report is
blank, the reference is vitiated. In this regard, it would be relevant to mention that
as per the contents of para-10 of the case of Moslem Mondal (supra), the
Superintendent of Police, Barpeta, suspecting the respondent therein as illegal
migrant within the meaning of the Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals)
Act, 1983, made a reference under Section 8 (1) of the said Act read with Rule 9
(A) of the Rules framed thereunder and accordingly, Case No. 1311/2003 was
registered before the IM(D)T, Barpeta and the said proceeding was subsequently
transferred to the Foreigners Tribunal and registered as F.T. Case No. 243/2006.
Therefore, in the said case, reference was not made by Electoral Registration
Officer (EVO for short). Hence, the decision of Moslem Mondal (supra), being
distinguishable on facts, is not found to help the petitioner in any manner.
19. However, in the case of Amina Khatun (supra), which was decided on
28.04.2022, the reference was made by the Superintendent of Police (Border),
based on LVO by the ERO. But when the said writ petition was being heard and
decided by a Coordinate Bench, it appears that the previous decision of the
learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Sayam Uddin v. The Union of
India & Ors., 2019 (4) GLT 456, as affirmed by the Division Bench of this Court in
the case of Sayam Uddin v. Union of India & Ors., W.A. 170/2019, decided on
29.07.2019, were not brought to the notice of this Court. Therefore, under such
circumstances, the Court is of the considered opinion that under the well settled
principles of stare decisis, the decision in the case of Amina Khatun (supra) would
be per incurium. Accordingly, the decision rendered in the case of Amina Khatun
(supra) will also not be of any help to the petitioner.
20. In the present case, the proceedings which were hitherto pending before the
Illegal Migrants (Determination) Tribunals were transferred by the Supreme Court
of India to the Foreigners Tribunal vide directions issued in the case of Sarbananda
Sonowal (supra). The said fact has been stated in para-1 of the impugned opinion.
Hence, this Court would refrain from making any observations on the LVO Report
in this case because the Foreigners Tribunals would have no power or jurisdiction
to remand the reference back to the Superintendent of Police (Border) for a fresh
enquiry by the LVO/ERO.
21. Therefore, the challenge to the proceeding before the learned Foreigners
Tribunal on the ground that certain paragraphs and/or columns of the Local
Verification Officer’s (LVO) Report, as forwarded by the Electoral Registration
Officer (ERO) were left blank, is held to be not maintainable on facts and in law
morefully referred to hereinbefore. The point of determination no. (i) is answered
accordingly.”
20.
Hence, as the proceedings of F.T. Case No. 620/2008, was
transferred by virtue of orders passed by the Supreme Court of India in the case
Page No.# 14/27
of Sarbananda Sonowal (supra), and in light of the decision this Court in the
case of (i) Sayam Uddin (supra)(decision by learned Single Bench) , (ii) Sayam
Uddin (supra)(Division Bench), and (iii) Shukurjan Nessa @ Sukurjan (supra), it
would not be open to this Court to question the transfer of reference.
21.
It may be stated that the petitioner, despite being served with
notice of appearance thrice, did not question the manner in which reference was
made. Therefore, following the decision of the Supreme Court of India in the
case of Sabitri Dey @ Swasthi Dey (supra), and Council for Research in
Ayurvedic Sciences & Ors. v. Bikartan Das, 2023 INSC 733: (2023) 0
Supreme(SC) 763, where the Supreme Court of India had referred to the extent
of power which can be exercised by High Court under certiorari jurisdiction, the
petitioner has not been able to make out a case where this Court would
examine the Reference submitted by the ERO and thereafter by the
Superintendent of Police, Darrang, Mangaldai.
22.
The three points urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner
are now taken up:-
a.
Process server’s report:
i.
It was submitted is that the process server’s report does
not contain the date of service.
ii.
It is not in dispute that the process server’s report contain
clear intimation to the petitioner to appear on the next date of the
proceeding, which was fixed on 13.02.2018.
iii.
Though the date on which notice was served to the
petitioner is not mentioned. But in this case, the petitioner had
Page No.# 15/27
suppressed material fact that notice was actually served on him.
The petitioner has not pleaded that the notice was served within
the due date, but was served after the date of appearance. His
case of total denial of service of notice, which is ex facie untrue.
iv.
As narrated hereinbefore, the petitioner was served with
notice/summons
of
appearance
thrice.
The
petitioner
had
appeared before the learned Tribunal on 19.04.2010, but took a
conscious decision not to participate in the proceeding and defend
himself despite the fact that as per the contents of the said notice,
the petitioner was accused of being a foreigner and that the
burden of proof lies on him.
v.
In this case, despite the notice of the case being served
thrice, which were received by him, the learned Tribunal had given
8 (eight) years’ time to the petitioner to contest the proceeding.
Thus, the learned Tribunal had failed to follow the mandate of
Paragraph 3(14) of the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964, to
dispose of the reference within a period of 60 (sixty) days from
the date of receipt of reference.
vi.
Under the aforesaid facts, by showing leniency to the
petitioner, the proceedings before the Foreigners Tribunal cannot
be made a farcical exercise. If the same is done, any proceedee
can walk in and walk out of the Foreigners Tribunal as per his/her
own sweet wish and desire. Allow an ex parte order to be passed,
and then assail the said ex parte opinion whenever he so wishes.
Such a procedure, is definitely not the mandate of the case of
Page No.# 16/27
Sabitri Dey @ Swasthi Dey (supra), cited by the learned counsel
for the petitioner.
vii.
Accordingly, the Court is constrained to hold that under the
distinguishable facts and circumstance of this case, the said cited
decision of Sabitri Dey @ Swasthi Dey (supra), is not found to help
the petitioner in any manner.
viii.
Moreover, in this case, the learned Tribunal has examined
the materials produced before it by the State and those materials
have been referred to in the impugned opinion.
ix.
As per the mandate of the Section 9 of the Foreigners Act,
1946 and the decision of the Supreme Court of India in the case
of Sarbananda Sonowal -I (supra), the burden of proof lies on the
petitioner to show that he is an Indian and not a foreigner, which
he has miserably failed to discharge. This Court, while exercising
certiorari jurisdiction, would be slow in appreciating documents
which the petitioner had failed to produce before the learned
Tribunal. The said view of this Court is guided by observations
made by the Supreme Court of India in paragraphs 34 to 38 of the
case of Sabitri Dey @ Swasthi Dey (supra).
x.
It may be clarified herein that under the ERO’s reference,
the same is a power exercised under the Rules/ Notifications/
Election Manual of the Election Commission of India, which are
under the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and the
Superintendent of Police (Border) has no role in the investigation
and therefore, in terms of Section 9 of the Foreigners Act, 1946,
Page No.# 17/27
the burden of proof would lie solely on the petitioner, for which
the Court would be guided by the observations made by the
Supreme Court of India in paragraph 26 of the case of
Sarbananda Sonowal- I (supra).
xi.
Therefore, the first point urged by the learned counsel for
the petitioner is answered by holding that the non-disclosure of
the date of service of notice, in this case in hand, is not fatal.
b.
The second point: The form of notice mentions that the petitioner
had entered into India on 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971:
i.
It was urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner that
as per the form of notice it was alleged that the petitioner had
entered into India on 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971. However, as per
the impugned ex parte opinion, going beyond the reference, the
learned Tribunal had declared the petitioner to be foreigner who
had illegally entered into Assam after 25.03.1971.
ii.
Under Section 2(a) of the Foreigners Act, 1946, “foreigner”
means a person who is not a citizen of India.
iii.
The reference to the persons entering into India between
01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971 is made in Section 6-A (3) of the
Citizenship Act, 1955. The provisions of Section 6-A of the
Citizenship Act, 1955 provides for special provisions as to
citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord. Section 6-A
of the Citizenship Act, 1955 is quoted below:-
iv.
6A. [Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by
Page No.# 18/27
the Assam Accord. [Inserted by Act 65 of 1985, Section 2 (w.e.f.
7.12.1985).]
(1) For the purposes of this section
(a) Assam means the territories included in the State of Assam
immediately before the commencement of the Citizenship
(Amendment) Act, 1985;
(b) detected to be a foreigner means detected to be a foreigner in
accordance with the provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 (31 of
1946), and the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964by a Tribunal
constituted under the said Order;
(c) specified territory means the territories included in Bangladesh
immediately before the commencement of the Citizenship
(Amendment) Act, 1985;
(d) a person shall be deemed to be of Indian origin, if he, or either
of his parents or any of his grandparents was born in undivided
India;
(e) a person shall be deemed to have been detected to be a
foreigner on the date on which a Tribunal constituted under the
Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 submits its opinion to the effect
that he is a foreigner to the officer or authority concerned.
(2) Subject to the provisions of sub-sections (6) and (7), all persons of
Indian origin who came before the 1st day of January, 1966 to Assam
from the specified territory (including such of those whose names were
included in the electoral rolls used for the purposes of the General
Election to the House of the People held in 1967) and who have been
ordinarily resident in Assam since the dates of their entry into Assam
shall be deemed to be citizens of India as from the 1st day of January,
1966.
(3) Subject to the provisions of sub-sections (6) and (7), every person
of Indian origin who
(a) came to Assam on or after the 1st day of January, 1966 but
before the 25th day of March, 1971 from the specified territory;
and
Page No.# 19/27
(b) has, since the date of his entry into Assam, been ordinarily
resident in Assam; and
(c) has been detected to be a foreigner, shall register himself in
accordance with the rules made by the Central Government in this
behalf under section 18 with such authority (hereafter in this subsection referred to as the registering authority) as may be
specified in such rules and if his name is included in any electoral
roll for any Assembly or Parliamentary constituency in force on the
date of such detection, his name shall be deleted therefrom.
Explanation. - In the case of every person seeking registration
under this sub-section, the opinion of the Tribunal constituted
under the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 holding such person
to be a foreigner, shall be deemed to be sufficient proof of the
requirement under clause (c) of this sub-section and if any
question arises as to whether such person complies with any other
requirement under this sub-section, the registering authority shall,
(i) if such opinion contains a finding with respect to such other
requirement, decide the question in conformity with such finding;
(ii) if such opinion does not contain a finding with respect to such
other requirement, refer the question to a Tribunal constituted
under the said Order having jurisdiction in accordance with such
rules as the Central Government may make in this behalf under
section 18 and decide the question in conformity with the opinion
received on such reference.
(4) a person registered under sub-section (3) shall have, as from
the date on which he has been detected to be a foreigner and till
the expiry of a period of ten years from that date, the same rights
and obligations as a citizen of India (including the right to obtain a
passport under the Passports Act, 1967 (15 of 1967) and the
obligations connected therewith), but shall not be entitled to have
his name included in any electoral roll for any Assembly or
Parliamentary constituency at any time before the expiry of the
said period of ten years.
(5) a person registered under sub-section (3) shall be deemed to be a
citizen of India for all purposes as from the date of expiry of a period of
ten years from the date on which he has been detected to be a
Page No.# 20/27
foreigner.
(6) Without prejudice to the provisions of section 8,
(a) if any person referred to in sub-section (2) submits in the
prescribed manner and form and to the prescribed authority within
sixty days from the date of commencement of the Citizenship
(Amendment) Act, 1985, a declaration that he does not wish to be
a citizen of India, such person shall not be deemed to have
become a citizen of India under that sub-section;
(b) if any person referred to in sub-section (3) submits in the
prescribed manner and form and to the prescribed authority within
sixty days from the date of commencement of the Citizenship
(Amendment) Act, 1985, for year or from the date on which he
has been detected to be a foreigner, whichever is later, a
declaration that he does not wish to be governed by the provisions
of that sub-section and sub-sections (4) and (5), it shall not be
necessary for such person to register himself under sub-section
(3).Explanation. - Where a person required to file a declaration
under this sub-section does not have the capacity to enter into a
contract, such declaration may be filed on his behalf by any person
competent under the law for the time being in force to act on his
behalf.
(7) Nothing in sub-sections (2) to (6) shall apply in relation to any
person
(a) who, immediately before the commencement of the Citizenship
(Amendment) Act, 1985, is a citizen of India;
(b) who was expelled from India before the commencement of the
Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985, under the Foreigners Act,
1946 (31 of 1946).
(8) Save as otherwise expressly provided in this section, the provisions
of this section shall have effect notwithstanding anything contained in
any other law for the time being in force.]”
v.
Therefore, in order to claim to be a citizen of India, the
onus is on the petitioner to show that he is a person of Indian
origin as provided for in Sub-Section (2) of Section 6-A, and/or
Page No.# 21/27
that either of his parents or grandparents were born in
undivided India as per the requirement of Clause (d) of Subsection (1) of Section 6-A.
vi.
This Court, in the case of Rukia Begum Barbhuiya @
Rukia Begum v. The Union Of India and Ors., 2023 4 GLT
1208; 2023 0 Supreme(Gau) 568 had examined the issue of
reference of stream of 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971 and stream
of post 25 03.1971. It would be appropriate to extract
hereinbelow the relevant part of the said judgment and order:vii.
“12. A reading of the provisions of Section 6 A makes it
explicit that it is a special provision as to citizenship of persons
covered by the Assam Accord and the core provisions of Section 6 A
are that a person who may have entered the State of Assam from the
specified territory prior to 01.01.1966 shall be deemed to be a citizen
of India from the 1st day of January, 1966. The further provision is
that such persons who entered the State of Assam from the specified
territory after 01.01.1966, but before 25.03.1971 from the specified
territory, and has been detected to be a foreigner, shall register
himself with the Foreigners Registering Authority of the district
concerned and upon having been registered shall be debarred of any
voting rights for a period of ten years, but otherwise retaining all
such other rights that a citizen of India may be bestowed with under
the provisions and further that upon expiry of the period of ten years,
even the voting rights would be restored back. In case of persons,
who had entered the State of Assam from the specified territory on
or after 25.03.1971, such persons are to be declared as foreigners.
13. In view of the provisions of Section 6 A of the Citizenship Act
1955, Clause 2(1) of the Foreigners Tribunal Order 1964 would now
have to be understood that once a reference is made, the reference
would be whether the person concerned is or is not a foreigner,
meaning thereby, whether the person concerned is a foreigner, who
had entered the Staten of Assam from the specified territory on or
after 25.03.1971 or he is a person who belongs to any of the other
Page No.# 22/27
categories i.e., a person who entered the State of Assam from the
specified territory before 01.01.1966 or between 01.01.1966 and
25.03.1971. No other meaning can be attributed to the reference
under Clause 2(1) of the Foreigners Tribunal Order 1964 i.e. whether
a person is or is not a foreigner within the meaning of the Foreigners
Act 1946. We further take note that even if a reference is made by
setting up a question whether the person had entered the State of
Assam from the specified territory between 01.01.1966 and
25.03.1971, the reference would have to be understood to be a
reference under Clause 2(1) of the Foreigners Tribunal Order 1964
i.e., as to whether he is a foreigner or not. If the reference is worded
whether the person concerned, is a person who had entered the
State of Assam from the specified territory between 01.01.1966 and
25.03.1971, in order to arrive at any such conclusion that the
reference itself is faulty inasmuch as, the decision of the Tribunal
upon the materials on record would be that the person concerned
had entered the State of Assam from the specified territory on or
after 25.03.1971, in such circumstance, the only situation that can be
envisaged is that the Tribunal first arrives at a conclusion of its own
that the person concerned had entered the State of Assam from the
specified territory on or after 25.03.1971, meaning thereby that the
reference itself had been answered by the Tribunal. After having
answered the reference, it would be an inconceivable situation that
merely because the reference is worded whether the person had
entered the State of Assam from the specified territory between
01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971 it has to be referred back to the referral
authority to make a fair reference now putting up a question whether
the person concerned had entered the State of Assam on or after
25.03.1971. In such situation, as the matter would have to be
referred back only after a final decision has been arrived at and now
if the reference is again made with a corrected expression in the
questions framed, the same may lead to further complications that
the subsequent reference would be barred by the principles of res
judicata inasmuch as it would be a subsequent reference on the
same issue between the same set of parties where an earlier decision
had already been arrived at. It is noticed that in Falani Bibi (supra)
the aforesaid aspect of the further implication of a corrected
reference being again made had not been gone into and from such
point of view, it can be said that the view taken therein would be per
inquiriam of the further consequences of a fresh reference being
Page No.# 23/27
made.
21. We further add that going by the statutory provisions of Clause
2(1) of the Foreigners Tribunal Order 1964 any reference would have
to be understood to be a reference to the Tribunal on the question
whether the person so referred is a foreigner or not within the
meaning of Foreigners Act 1946, where again foreigner is given the
meaning of a person who is not a citizen and aga in where a citizen is
defined under the Citizenship Act 1955.
viii.
Therefore, as per the provision of Section 2(a) of the
Foreigners Act, 1946, the reference can only be as to whether
or not the suspected person is a foreigner or not. The stream
of period between 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971 is only available
under Section 6-A of the Citizenship Act, 1955. Therefore, the
benefit of Section 6-A of the Citizenship Act, 1955 would
become available to the petitioner after he has been able to
satisfy the learned Foreigners Tribunal that he is covered by
the provisions of Section 6-A of the Citizenship Act. But in this
case, the petitioner has not been able to prove that he is
entitled to the benefit of Section 6-A of the Citizenship Act,
1955.
ix.
Therefore, the second point of determination is
answered by holding that merely because in the form of notice
it was alleged that the petitioner had entered into India on
01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971, would not come in the way of the
learned Foreigners Tribunal to answer the reference by holding
that the petitioner was a foreigner of post 25.03.1971 stream.
Thus, the answer to the reference cannot be held to be
Page No.# 24/27
unsustainable by holding that the learned Tribunal had gone
beyond the reference by declaring the petitioner to be
foreigner
who
had
illegally
entered
into
Assam
after
25.03.1971.
c.
The third submission: In column no.4 of the Form of Enquiry under
Annexure-A, the year of his birth is mentioned as 1965, would mean
that the petitioner is a citizen of India.
i.
It was submitted that in column no.4 of the Form of
Enquiry under Annexure-A, the year of his birth is mentioned as
1965 and therefore, the petitioner would be a citizen of India
under Section 3 of the Citizenship Act.
ii.
It is reiterated herein that the Form of Enquiry was the one
prescribed under the erstwhile IM(DT) Act, 1983. Under the said
Act, the burden to prove that a suspect was a foreigner was on
the State. However, in a proceeding under the Foreigners Act,
1946, Section 9 thereof casts burden on the proceedee to prove
that he/she is not a foreigner but an Indian.
iii.
It is in public domain that for election duty, the Election
Commission of India requisition Government employees from
various departments for election duty.
iv.
In the relevant Column No.4 and 5 of
Annexure-A, i.e. the Format for Enquiry, the following are
mentioned:4. Date of birth: 1965
}
5. Place of birth Bhogdal (Orang) } (Oral statement).
Page No.# 25/27
v.
In this case, the Verification Officer has disclosed his
designation as “SE, DIP”. Thus, from the said designation, it can
be
presumed
that
the
Verification
Officer
was
either
a
Superintending Engineer or a Section Engineer, but not a police
officer. Accordingly, whatever entry that has been made in the
Format of Enquiry, which is referred to as Annexure-A, is as per
disclosure made by the petitioner during enquiry and those entries
are not a result of any investigation. The Enquiry Officer has
clearly disclosed that those entries were based on oral statement
of the petitioner. In Column No.6 and 8 of the form as against the
query – Whether he and his father is registered as an elector in
any constituency in India, the reply recorded is “No”.
vi.
Therefore, merely because of the petitioner’s oral
statement that he was born in 1965 and place of birth is Bhogdal
(Orang), it cannot be said that the same constitutes cogent proof
that the petitioner is a citizen of India by birth.
vii.
The entry made in the said column no. 4 does not establish
that he is a citizen of India by descent. The petitioner’s disclosure
in column no.6 and 8 of the same form is to the effect that neither
he nor his father were electors in any Constituency.
viii.
Therefore, the third point urged by the learned counsel for
the petitioner is decided in the negative and against the petitioner
by holding that a mere entry in the Format of Enquiry – AnnexureAm mentioning that as per the oral statement of the petitioner, he
was born in 1965 is not a proof of citizenship and it cannot be
Page No.# 26/27
held that the petitioner had discharged his burden under Section 9
to prove that he is not a foreigner but an Indian.
23.
Thus, in light of the discussions above, the Court is of the
considered opinion that in this case, the petitioner had been served with notice
to appear before the learned Tribunal on 3 (three) occasions. The notice was
duly
served
and
contains
the
signature
of
the
petitioner
towards
acknowledgment of receipt of the notice. Moreover, despite notice being served
thrice, the Tribunal had granted the petitioner enough opportunity to appear
and contest the case, which the petitioner did not avail.
24.
In this case, the default on part of the petitioner to appear and
contest the case/ proceeding is deliberate and intentional. The petitioner has
claimed in this writ petition that only when he went to the Office of the NRC, he
came to know that he was declared to be a foreigner. The said statement
appears to be ex facie false and cannot be believed for the simple reason that in
the year 1997, his citizenship was doubted. Therefore, as a consequence, his
name would either not appear in any subsequent voter list or even if his names
appears in any subsequent voter list, against his name, a “D’ mark would be
entered. The letter ‘D’ is an abbreviation of word “doubtful”. Thus from the year
1997 till 2018, i.e. 21 years, the petitioner did not take any steps to have his ‘D’
mark removed, itself is indicative of the fact that he was aware of the
proceedings before the erstwhile IM(D)T and before the Foreigners Tribunal
(2nd), Darrang, Mangaldai.
25.
Therefore, on all counts, the petitioner has not been able to
make out a case to interfere with the ex parte opinion dated 13.09.2018, passed
by the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal (2 nd), Darrang, Mangaldai in F.T. 2nd
Page No.# 27/27
Case No.620/2008, arising out of Ref case No.7380/98.
26.
Consequently, the writ petition fails and the same is dismissed.
27.
The interim bail granted to the petitioner by order dated
13.05.2020, stands recalled. The consequences of the impugned opinion shall
follow.
28.
The parties are left to bear their own cost.
29.
The learned standing counsel for the FT and Border matters is
directed to transmit a downloaded copy of this order to the Home and Political
(B) Department for their record.
30.
The Registry shall return the learned Tribunal’s record along with
a copy of this order to be made a part of the record by the said learned
Tribunal.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
Munna Kumar
Kumar
Date: 2026.08.13 11:45:46
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review