Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Shri Naw Raj Bhattarai,
S/o Shri Nar Hair Bhattarai,
R/o Namin Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Ranipool,
East Sikkim
…..
Petitioner
Versus
1.
The State of Sikkim
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
2.
Department of Personnel (DOP),
New Secretariat Building Development Area,
Through Commissioner-cum-Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
3.
Human Resource Development Department,
Through the Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
4.
The Regional Officer,
All India Council for Technical Education, (AICTE),
Eastern Regional Office,
L.B. Block, Sector III,
College of Leather Technology Campus,
Salt Lake City,
Kolkata- 700 091.
5.
The Principal,
Advance Technical Training Centre (ATTC),
Bardang,
P.O. Bardang & P.S. Singtam,
East Sikkim.
….. Respondents
Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Appearance:
Mr. Naw Raj Bhattarai, Petitioner in person.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate
General. Mr. S. K. Chettri, Government Advocate
for respondent nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5.
Mr. D. K. Siwakoti, Advocate for respondent
no.4.
------------------------------------------------------------------------With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Shri. Amosh Shanker,
S/o Shri Yam Kumar Shanker,
R/o Tharpu Busty, P.O. Tharpu,
P.S. Soreng, West Sikkim.
…..
Petitioner
Versus
1.
The State of Sikkim
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
2.
Department of Personnel (DOP),
New Secretariat Building Development Area,
Through Commissioner-cum-Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
3.
Human Resource Development Department,
Through the Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
4.
The Technical Director,
Technical Education, HRDD,
Government of Sikkim,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
5.
The Regional Officer,
All India Council for Technical Education, (AICTE),
Eastern Regional Office,
L.B. Block, Sector III,
College of Leather Technology Campus,
Salt Lake City,
Kolkata-700 091.
6.
The Principal,
Advance Technical Training Centre (ATTC),
Bardang,
P.O. Bardang & P.S. Singtam,
East Sikkim.
….. Respondents
Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. Amosh Shanker, Petitioner in person.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate
General. Mr. S. K. Chettri, Government Advocate
for respondent nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6.
Mr. D. K. Siwakoti, Advocate for respondent
no.5.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing
:
23.02.2021
Date of Judgment
:
03.04.2021
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
As both W.P. (C) No 29 of 2017 and W.P. (C) No. 30 of
2017 raises similar issues this common judgment shall
dispose both of them.
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
2.
Heard the petitioners in person in both the writ
petitions; Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, learned Additional Advocate
General for respondent nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 in W.P. (C) No 29
of 2017 and respondent nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6 in W.P. (C)
No. 30 of 2017 and Mr. D.K. Siwakoti, learned counsel for
respondent no.4 in W.P. (C) No 29 of 2017 and respondent
no.5 in W.P.(C) No. 30 of 2017.
3.
The petitioners in person (Naw Raj Bhattarai) in W.P.
(C) No. 29 of 2017 and (Amosh Shanker) in W.P. (C) No. 30
of 2017) submits that although their appointment orders
state that they had been appointed on contractual basis,
the Advanced Technical Training Centre (ATTC) had always
treated them as regular employees and its failure to
regularise them in spite of various assurances violates their
fundamental rights. It is also their case that the ATTC has
failed to keep the student faculty ratio as per the
requirements set by the All India Counsel for Technical
Education (AICTE) and on that ground also a direction to
regularise them would be maintainable. The petitioners
submits that they are qualified to hold the regular posts
and as their appointments were done in accordance with
the
constitutional
scheme
of
appointments
i.e.
by
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
advertising the posts in a newspaper; inviting eligible
candidates; conducting written examination and viva voce
and selecting eligible candidates for the advertised posts,
they should be regularised. They have drawn the attention
of this court to chapter III of the Service Rules of the
Advanced Technical Centre, 2003 (Service Rules) which
provide that all appointments shall be made on contract
basis for one year and that based on an “appraisal report”
they shall be considered for regular appointment on
probation. It was submitted that the records would reveal
that the ATTC had not expressed its dissatisfaction on their
performance
and
therefore,
considering
regularisation ought to have been done.
them
for
They drew the
attention of this court to the specific pleading in W.P. (C)
No.29 of 2017 i.e. paragraphs 14 and 13 in W.P. (C) No.29
of 2017 and W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017 respectively in which
they had stated that the ATTC had even made them fill up
a form for self assessment during their service which
assertion has been accepted as matter of record in the
counter affidavits filed on behalf of the State respondents
including ATTC. It is their case that they have been sent for
various training programmes by ATTC and those training
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
programmes were under the Carrier Advancement Scheme
meant for movement to higher grades as the knowledge
obtained from such training would be beneficial to the
students. It is also their case that they had been in
continuous service during the entire period and that they
were employed against sanctioned posts and worked till
2016 in such capacity. The petitioners relied upon Union
Public Service Commission v. Girish Jayanti Lal Vaghela &
Ors.1; B.S. Minhas v. Indian Statistical Institute & Ors.2;
Secretary, State of Karnataka v Umadevi (3)3; Malathi Das
v. Suresh4 and Mandeep Sunwar v. State of Sikkim5.
4.
The learned Additional Advocate General (learned
AAG) submitted that the perusal of the writ petitions as
well as the records would reveal that there has been no
violation of any right, leave alone any fundamental right of
the petitioners. She relied upon Mani Subrat Jain & Ors. v.
State of Haryana & Ors.6 to submit that no one can ask for
mandamus without a legal right.
1 2006 (2) SCALE 115
2 AIR 1984 SC 363
3 (2006) 4 SCC 1
4 (2014) 13 SCC 249
5 SLR (2017) Sikkim 53
6 (1977) 1 SCC 486
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
5.
The learned A.A.G. submits that the appointment
orders are clear and unambiguous and that the petitioners
were appointed on contract basis on specific terms and
conditions. It is her case that the terms and conditions of
contract specifically provided that they shall have no right
to claim for regularisation. It was further submitted that
once the contractual period came to an end that was the
end of the service and the petitioners could have no
grievance just because ATTC did not continue their service.
She relied upon State of Maharashtra & Ors. v. Anita &
Anr.7; Umadevi (3) (supra); Union of India v. Arulmozhi
Iniarasu8.
In addition, in so far as Amosh Shanker is
concerned, the learned AAG also pointed out that he had
applied for the sanctioned post advertised on 22.09.2016
but had failed to qualify for the same and as such he was
estopped
from
challenging
his
discontinuance
from
contractual service. The learned AAG also argued that the
Service Rules are meant for regular employees of ATTC and
that contractual employees like the petitioners would be
7 (2016) 8 SCC 293
8 (2011) 7 SCC 397
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
governed by the terms and conditions of the contracts
entered into.
6.
Mr. D. K. Siwakoti, learned counsel for AICTE submits
that there is no prayer sought by the petitioner against
AICTE and as such their role in the present litigation is
limited. Nevertheless, the learned counsel guided this Court
through the various documents relating to the student to
lecturer ratio issue raised by the petitioners in person. The
learned counsel also relied upon certain judgments to
assist this court. They are: A. Umarani v. Registrar,
Cooperative
Societies9;
State
of
Madhyapradesh
v.
Mohd.
Abrahim10; Mani Subrat Jain (supra) and Nihal Singh v. State of
Punjab11.
7.
Before this court examines the facts it would be
relevant to consider the various judgment cited at the bar.
In Uma Devi (3) (supra) the Constitutional Bench of the
Supreme Court considered the legality of the action of the
State in resorting to irregular appointments without
following the procedure for appointment contemplated by
the Constitution of India.
9 (2004) 7 SCC 112
10 (2009) 15 SCC 214
11 (2013) 14 SCC 65
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
8.
In Nihal Singh (supra) the Supreme Court examined
whether it could compel the State to create posts and
absorb the appellants therein into the service of the State
on a permanent basis consistent with the decision in
Umadevi (3) (supra). While doing so the Supreme Court also
noted that in Umadevi (3) (supra) the Supreme Court while
recognising the authority of the State to make temporary
appointments declared that the regularisation of the
employment of such persons which was made without
following the procedure conforming to the requirement of
the scheme of the Constitution in the matter of public
employments cannot become an alternative mode of
recruitment to public appointment. The Supreme Court
further noted that it had in Umadevi (3) (Supra) declared that
the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Courts under Article
226 or Article 32 cannot be exercised to compel the State or
to enable the State to perpetuate an illegality. The Supreme
Court noted that in Umadevi (3) (supra) the Constitution
Bench had held that compelling the State to absorb
persons who were employed by the State as casual workers
or daily wage workers for a long period on the ground that
such a practice would be an arbitrary practice and violative
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
of Article 14 and would itself offend another aspect of
Article 14 i.e. the State chose initially to appoint such
persons without any rational procedure recognized by law
thereby depriving vast number of other eligible candidates
who
were
similarly
situated
to
compete
for
such
employment.
9.
In Nihal Singh (supra) the Supreme Court found that
the initial appointments of the appellants could have never
been categorised as an irregular appointment as their
initial appointment were made in accordance with the
statutory procedure contemplated under the act. Thus it
was held that even going by the principles laid down in
Umadevi (3) (supra) the State cannot be heard to say that the
appellants therein were not entitled to be absorbed into the
services
of the State on permanent basis as
their
appointments were purely temporarily and not against any
sanctioned posts created by the State.
10. In Malati Das (supra) the Supreme Court held on facts
that since similarly placed employees had been regularised
by State and in some cases such regularisation was
effected even after decision in Umadevi (3) (Supra), stand
taken by the appellants in refusing regularisation on
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
ground
that
claimants
do
not
fulfil
conditions
for
regularisation as laid down in Umadevi (3) (supra) was not
sustainable.
11. In Mandip Sunwar (supra) a Single Judge of this court
held that the Constitutional philosophy of employment is
enshrined in Article 14 read with Article 16 of the
Constitution of India and that public employment has to be
made after a proper competition among qualified persons
on the basis of invitation through wide publicity, enabling
all required candidates to make application for the same;
selection is required to be made in accordance with
statutory provisions, on merit, in the spirit of the
constitutional mandate of equality of opportunity without
discrimination.
12. In Mani Subrat Jain (supra) the Supreme Court held:
“It is elementary though it is to be restated that
no one can ask for a mandamus without a legal
right. There must be a judicially enforceable right as
well as a legally protected right before one suffering
a legal grievance can ask for a mandamus. A
person can be said to be aggrieved only when a
person is denied a legal right by someone who has
a legal duty to do something or to abstain from
doing something.”
13. In Anita (supra) the Supreme Court examined the
appointments of 471 posts of legal advisors, law officers
and law instructors on contractual basis pursuant to
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
government resolutions. It was found that the intention of
the government was to fill up the said posts on contractual
basis and that the respondents therein at the time of
appointment had entered into agreement in terms of which
the appointment was purely contractual creating no right,
interest or benefit of permanent service in respondent’s
favour. It was held that having accepted contractual
appointment,
the
respondents
were
estopped
from
challenging terms of their appointment and when the
government had taken a policy decision to fill up post on
contractual basis, the Tribunal and High Court ought not
to have interfered with it to hold that appointments were
permanent in nature.
14. In Arulmozhi (supra) the Supreme Court examined its
various decisions on the doctrine of legitimate expectations
and its impact in administrative law. It noted that in Sethi
Auto Service Stations v. DDA12 the Supreme Court had
held:
“32. An examination of the aforenoted few
decisions shows that the golden thread running
through all these decisions is that a case for
applicability of the doctrine of legitimate expectation,
now accepted in the subjective sense as part of our
12 (2009) 1 SCC 180
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
legal jurisprudence, arises when an administrative
body by reason of a representation or by past
practice or conduct aroused an expectation which it
would be within its powers to fulfil unless some
overriding public interest comes in the way.
However, a person who bases his claim on the
doctrine of legitimate expectation, in the first
instance, has to satisfy that he has relied on the
said representation and the denial of that
expectation has worked to his detriment. The Court
could interfere only if the decision taken by the
authority was found to be arbitrary, unreasonable
or in gross abuse of power or in violation of
principles of natural justice and not taken in public
interest. But a claim based on mere legitimate
expectation without anything more cannot ipso facto
give a right to invoke these principles.”
15.
In A. Umarani (supra) it was held by the Supreme
Court that when appointments were made in contravention
of mandatory provisions of the Act and statutory rules
framed
thereunder
and
in
ignorance
of
essential
qualifications, the same would be illegal and cannot be
regularised by the State.
16. In Mohd. Abrahim (Supra) the Supreme Court held that
it was necessary for the State to follow the constitutional
scheme laid down in Article 14 and Article 16 and relevant
recruitment rules and appointment through side door being
appointment in violation of the said Articles would be
illegal.
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Pleadings in W.P. (C) No 29 of 2017
17. Naw Raj Bhattarai filed a writ petition on 06.06.2017
seeking an appropriate writ directing the respondents to
take him back in service and other reliefs. It was contended
that he had been appointed as lecturers as per the
constitutional mandate following the issuance of an
advertisement
and
thereafter
being
selected
after
a
selection process as per the Service Rules.
18. Respondent nos.1, 2, 3 and ATTC filed their composite
counter-affidavits on 26.07.2017 opposing the writ petition
and asserting that he was a contractual employee; his
employment would thus be governed by the terms and
conditions agreed upon and further after his term expired
he would have no right to claim regularisation. It was also
asserted that the recruitment and service condition of the
lecturers and all the employees of ATTC is governed by the
Service Rules which came into force on 01.04.1999. The
State respondents have highlighted the provisions of the
Service Rules as enumerated in chapter III. It has been
asserted that a selection committee was constituted vide
notification dated 07.03.2015 as per All India Council for
Technical Education (Carrier Advancement Schemes) (CAS)
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
for the Teachers and other Academic Staff in Technical
Institutions
(Diploma)
Regulations,
notified
on
08.11.2012. According to the State respondents there are
altogether 19 posts of lecturers in ATTC including 4 posts
of lecturers in the department of mechatronics and 1 post
of the head of the department. The State respondents
assert that in the month of June, 2012, two regular
lecturers in mechatronics department were sent for further
studies. They completed it in June, 2015 and thereafter,
joined duties. It is asserted that it was on account of their
absence that Naw Raj Bhattarai was appointed on contract
basis on 28.02.2013 and continued till 31.12.2016.
19. Naw Raj Bhattarai filed his rejoinder on 21.08.2017.
He countered the State respondent’s assertion regarding
him being appointed due to the absence of the 2 regular
lecturers in mechatronics department by stating that if it
had been so then he should have been terminated in the
year 2015 itself. It was submitted that the very fact that
even for the session 2016 his service was renewed till
December, 2016 would belie the assertion.
20. On 01.11.2017 the AICTE filed an affidavit in
opposition against the writ petition. The AICTE asserted
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
that it had not issued any notification nor is there any
provision under their Acts and rules for appointment of
temporary faculty by their institutions. AICTE stated that
as per the information projected by ATTC student to faculty
ratio was adequate.
21. On 12.10.2017 Naw Raj Bhattarai filed his rejoinder
to the reply filed by AICTE disputing that the ATTC had
complied with the student lecturer ratio. On 15.05.2018 an
additional affidavit was filed by AICTE in which AICTE
asserted
that
on
inquiry
it
was
found
that
the
infrastructure and faculty members of ATTC were in order.
On 26.05.2018 Naw Raj Bhattarai filed his response to the
additional affidavit filed by AICTE disputing the claim made
by
AICTE.
On
19.06.2018
the
AICTE
filed
another
additional affidavit pursuant to the order dated 29.11.2017
passed by this court permitting AICTE to inspect ATTC and
submit a report as to whether the terms and conditions or
guidelines are being complied by it. It was stated that an
Expert Visiting Committee (EVC) was constituted by the
competent authority that visited the ATTC and after
conducting
inspection
submitted
its
report.
Various
deficiencies had been pointed out in the report pursuant to
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
which a show cause notice was issued dated 06.03.2018.
The ATTC was allowed to file a reply and was also heard.
Thereafter, the Standing Hearing Committee of the AICTE
accepted the documents submitted by ATTC in respect of
each of the deficiencies pointed out except one.
Pleadings in W.P. (C) No 30 of 2017
22. Amosh Shanker filed a writ petition on 13.06.2017
also seeking directions upon the State respondents to take
him back in service, to regularize him and for other reliefs
on the ground that he had been appointed under the
constitutional scheme and as such had a right to be
regularized.
23. The respondent nos.1, 2, 3, 4 and ATTC (State
respondents) has filed a composite counter-affidavit on
21.08.2017 disputing Amosh Shanker’s claim. It is the case
of the State respondents that he was a contractual
appointee and as such under the terms and conditions
agreed upon he has no right to claim for regularization. It is
further submitted that as Amosh Shanker had taken his
chance to be considered for selection to the two regular
posts of lecturer (mechanical) and failed to be selected he is
estopped from claiming for regularization. The State
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
respondents had made identical assertion regarding the
Service Rules as in the counter-affidavit filed by them in
Writ Petition (C) No. 29 of 2017.
24. Amosh
Shanker
has
filed
a
rejoinder
dated
18.10.2017 to the counter-affidavit filed by the State
respondents as well. In the rejoinder he has sought to rely
upon the approval process hand book of the AICTE for
penal action in case of violation of its regulation for
providing false information while applying for approval of
extension. He has disputed all the assertions made by the
State respondents in the counter-affidavit.
(i)
The AICTE has filed an affidavit in opposition dated
25.11.2015 asserted that it had not issued any notification
nor is there any provision under their acts and rules for
appointment of temporary faculty by their institutions.
AICTE stated that as per the information projected by ATTC
the faculty student ratio was adequate.
(ii)
An additional affidavit was filed by State respondents
on 23.04.2019 clarifying that altogether ten candidates
were called for viva voce as per the marks obtained in the
written test and thereafter final select list were prepared.
Copy of the list of qualified candidates who appeared for
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
written test held on 26.11.2016 was annexed along with a
notice
dated
05.01.2017
showing
the
list
of
three
candidates declared qualified in order of merit and
recommended for appointment. Amosh Shanker does not
feature in either of the two lists.
26.09.2016
two
posts
of
It transpires that on
lecturer
(mechanical)
were
advertised for appointment on regular basis. A written
examination and viva voce was also conducted. Amosh
Shanker had applied for the said post and had appeared in
the written examination held on 26.11.2016. Amosh
Shanker was however, placed at serial no.14 of the merit
list of successful candidates and those two posts were filled
by two other persons.
The issue and its considerations.
25. The issue that needs to be determined in both the writ
petitions is whether on the facts stated above the
petitioners had a right to be taken back in service and
absorbed in the regular establishment or in the alternative
be considered by ATTC for regularization as per rule 8(2) of
the Service Rules?.
26.
The record reveals that Naw Raj Bhattarai first
applied for employment in response to an advertisement
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
issued by ATTC on 03.02.2013 pursuant to which he was
employed as lecturer (mechatronics) on contractual basis
for the period 01.03.2013 to 31.12.2013 after a selection
process. A perusal of the advertisement reflects that the
ATTC had sought appointment for temporary contractual
posts. The appointment letter also made it clear that the
post was temporary and contractual and that Naw Raj
Bhattarai would have no right to claim for regularization.
Yet another advertisement was issued on 30.10.2013
pursuant to which Naw Raj Bhattarai was employed again
on contract basis from 01.01.2014 to 31.12.2014. This
advertisement was for both temporary as well as regular
posts. In the case of lecturer (mechanical), however, only
one temporary post for lecturer (electronics) was advertised
pursuant to which Naw Raj Bhattarai was once again
offered and appointed on contract basis for a period of
another year. Thereafter, pursuant to an interview held on
07.11.2013 Naw Raj Bhattarai was once again appointed
on contract basis for a period of one year w.e.f. 01.01.2014.
After the expiry of the last contract period, the ATTC issued
two appointment letters dated 17.12.2014 and 01.12.2015
extending Naw Raj Bhattarai’s contractual employment till
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
31.12.2016. On each occasion when his contract was
renewed he accepted all the terms of contract including
that he had no right to claim for regularization.
27. In the case of Amosh Shanker also it is noticed that
he was selected on contract basis pursuant to an
advertisement issued on 30.10.2013. The advertisement for
various posts of lecturers and other officers were for both
temporary and regular employment. Three temporary posts
and two regular posts for lecturer (mechanical) were
advertised.
The
terms
and
conditions
specified
that
candidates selected for temporary posts will be for one year
contract term. It also specified that the top two candidates
as per merit lists of lecturer (mechanical) would be
employed initially for one year contract. Based on work
performance after completion of contract period they would
be considered for regularization. The first appointment
letter dated 07.07.2014 was for the period 07.07.2014 to
31.12.2014. It was contractual with no right to claim for
regularization.
On
17.12.2014
Amosh
Shanker’s
contractual appointment was extended from 03.01.2015 to
31.12.2015. This contract period was renewed by ATTC by
offering him the post once again on 01.12.2015 for the
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
period 11.01.2016 to 31.12.2016. On each occasion of
renewal of contract period he submitted a joining report
without a protest. Even Amosh Shanker accepted all the
terms of contract including that he would have no claim for
regularization.
28. Both the petitioners’ contract came to an end on
31.12.2016.
29. It
transpires
that
during
the
period
of
their
contractual service the petitioners were sent for various
training programmes to the National Institute of Technical
Teachers’ Training & Research Centre (NITTTR) Kolkatta. It
is their case that the short term training programme
recognised by AICTE and conducted by NITTTR is meant
for movement to higher grades under Carrier Advancement
Scheme for regular staff of the institute only, not for
temporary faculty. It is also their case that the ATTC has
always projected them as regular lecturers which is seen
while browsing the official website of AICTE. They further
contend that they were also made to fill up a “self
assessment report” during their service with ATTC and
therefore, they ought to be considered for regularisation.
30. In Umadevi (3) (supra) the Supreme Court held:-
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“11. In addition to the equality clause
represented by Article 14 of the Constitution, Article
16 has specifically provided for equality of
opportunity in matters of public employment.
Buttressing these fundamental rights, Article 309
provides that subject to the provisions of the
Constitution, Acts of the legislature may regulate the
recruitment and conditions of service of persons
appointed to public services and posts in connection
with the affairs of the Union or of a State. In view of
the interpretation placed on Article 12 of the
Constitution by this Court, obviously, these
principles also govern the instrumentalities that
come within the purview of Article 12 of the
Constitution. With a view to make the procedure for
selection fair, the Constitution by Article 315 has
also created a Public Service Commission for the
Union and the Public Service Commissions for the
States. Article 320 deals with the functions of the
Public Service Commissions and mandates
consultation with the Commission on all matters
relating to methods of recruitment to civil services
and for civil posts and other related matters. As a
part of the affirmative action recognised by Article
16 of the Constitution, Article 335 provides for
special consideration in the matter of claims of the
members of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes for employment. The States have made Acts,
rules or regulations for implementing the above
constitutional guarantees and any recruitment to the
service in the State or in the Union is governed by
such Acts, rules and regulations. The Constitution
does not envisage any employment outside this
constitutional scheme and without following the
requirements set down therein.
12. In spite of this scheme, there may be
occasions when the sovereign State or its
instrumentalities will have to employ persons, in
posts which are temporary, on daily wages, as
additional hands or taking them in without following
the required procedure, to discharge the duties in
respect of the posts that are sanctioned and that are
required to be filled in terms of the relevant
procedure established by the Constitution or for
work in temporary posts or projects that are not
needed permanently. This right of the Union or of
the State Government cannot but be recognised and
there is nothing in the Constitution which prohibits
such engaging of persons temporarily or on daily
wages, to meet the needs of the situation. But the
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
fact that such engagements are resorted to, cannot
be used to defeat the very scheme of public
employment. Nor can a court say that the Union or
the State Governments do not have the right to
engage persons in various capacities for a duration
or until the work in a particular project is completed.
Once this right of the Government is recognised and
the mandate of the constitutional requirement for
public employment is respected, there cannot be
much difficulty in coming to the conclusion that it is
ordinarily not proper for the Courts whether acting
under Article 226 of the Constitution or under Article
32 of the Constitution, to direct absorption in
permanent employment of those who have been
engaged without following a due process of
selection as envisaged by the constitutional scheme.
13. What is sought to be pitted against this
approach, is the so-called equity arising out of giving
of temporary employment or engagement on daily
wages and the continuance of such persons in the
engaged work for a certain length of time. Such
considerations can have only a limited role to play,
when every qualified citizen has a right to apply for
appointment, the adoption of the concept of rule of
law and the scheme of the Constitution for
appointment to posts. It cannot also be forgotten
that it is not the role of the courts to ignore,
encourage or approve appointments made or
engagements given outside the constitutional
scheme. In effect, orders based on such sentiments
or approach would result in perpetuating illegalities
and in the jettisoning of the scheme of public
employment adopted by us while adopting the
Constitution. The approving of such acts also results
in depriving many of their opportunity to compete for
public employment. We have, therefore, to consider
the question objectively and based on the
constitutional and statutory provisions. In this
context, we have also to bear in mind the exposition
of law by a Constitution Bench in State of
Punjab v. Jagdip Singh [(1964) 4 SCR 964 : AIR
1964 SC 521] . It was held therein: (SCR pp. 97172)
“In our opinion where a government
servant has no right to a post or to a
particular status, though an authority under
the Government acting beyond its competence
had purported to give that person a status
which it was not entitled to give he will not in
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
law be deemed to have been validly
appointed to the post or given the particular
status.”
xxxxxx
“43. Thus, it is clear that adherence to the
rule of equality in public employment is a basic
feature of our Constitution and since the rule of law
is the core of our Constitution, a court would
certainly be disabled from passing an order
upholding a violation of Article 14 or in ordering the
overlooking of the need to comply with the
requirements of Article 14 read with Article 16 of the
Constitution. Therefore, consistent with the scheme
for public employment, this Court while laying down
the law, has necessarily to hold that unless the
appointment is in terms of the relevant rules and
after a proper competition among qualified persons,
the same would not confer any right on the
appointee. If it is a contractual appointment, the
appointment comes to an end at the end of the
contract, if it were an engagement or appointment
on daily wages or casual basis, the same would
come to an end when it is discontinued. Similarly, a
temporary employee could not claim to be made
permanent on the expiry of his term of appointment.
It has also to be clarified that merely because a
temporary employee or a casual wage worker is
continued for a time beyond the term of his
appointment, he would not be entitled to be
absorbed in regular service or made permanent,
merely on the strength of such continuance, if the
original appointment was not made by following a
due process of selection as envisaged by the
relevant rules. It is not open to the court to prevent
regular recruitment at the instance of temporary
employees whose period of employment has come to
an end or of ad hoc employees who by the very
nature of their appointment, do not acquire any
right. The High Courts acting under Article 226 of
the Constitution, should not ordinarily issue
directions for absorption, regularisation, or
permanent continuance unless the recruitment itself
was made regularly and in terms of the
constitutional scheme. Merely because an employee
had continued under cover of an order of the court,
which we have described as “litigious employment”
in the earlier part of the judgment, he would not be
entitled to any right to be absorbed or made
permanent in the service. In fact, in such cases, the
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
High Court may not be justified in issuing interim
directions, since, after all, if ultimately the employee
approaching it is found entitled to relief, it may be
possible for it to mould the relief in such a manner
that ultimately no prejudice will be caused to him,
whereas an interim direction to continue his
employment would hold up the regular procedure for
selection or impose on the State the burden of
paying an employee who is really not required. The
courts must be careful in ensuring that they do not
interfere unduly with the economic arrangement of
its affairs by the State or its instrumentalities or
lend themselves the instruments to facilitate the
bypassing of the constitutional and statutory
mandates.”
xxxxxx
“45. While directing that appointments,
temporary or casual, be regularised or made
permanent, the courts are swayed by the fact that
the person concerned has worked for some time and
in some cases for a considerable length of time. It is
not as if the person who accepts an engagement
either temporary or casual in nature, is not aware of
the nature of his employment. He accepts the
employment with open eyes. It may be true that he
is not in a position to bargain—not at arm's length—
since he might have been searching for some
employment so as to eke out his livelihood and
accepts whatever he gets. But on that ground alone,
it would not be appropriate to jettison the
constitutional scheme of appointment and to take
the view that a person who has temporarily or
casually got employed should be directed to be
continued permanently. By doing so, it will be
creating another mode of public appointment which
is not permissible. If the court were to void a
contractual employment of this nature on the ground
that the parties were not having equal bargaining
power, that too would not enable the court to grant
any relief to that employee. A total embargo on such
casual or temporary employment is not possible,
given the exigencies of administration and if
imposed, would only mean that some people who at
least get employment temporarily, contractually or
casually, would not be getting even that
employment when securing of such employment
brings at least some succour to them. After all,
innumerable citizens of our vast country are in
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
search of employment and one is not compelled to
accept a casual or temporary employment if one is
not inclined to go in for such an employment. It is in
that context that one has to proceed on the basis
that the employment was accepted fully knowing
the nature of it and the consequences flowing from
it. In other words, even while accepting the
employment, the person concerned knows the
nature of his employment. It is not an appointment
to a post in the real sense of the term. The claim
acquired by him in the post in which he is
temporarily employed or the interest in that post
cannot be considered to be of such a magnitude as
to enable the giving up of the procedure established,
for making regular appointments to available posts
in the services of the State. The argument that since
one has been working for some time in the post, it
will not be just to discontinue him, even though he
was aware of the nature of the employment when
he first took it up, is not one that would enable the
jettisoning of the procedure established by law for
public employment and would have to fail when
tested on the touchstone of constitutionality and
equality of opportunity enshrined in Article 14 of the
Constitution.”
xxxxxxx
“47. When a person enters a temporary
employment or gets engagement as a contractual or
casual worker and the engagement is not based on
a proper selection as recognised by the relevant
rules or procedure, he is aware of the consequences
of the appointment being temporary, casual or
contractual in nature. Such a person cannot invoke
the theory of legitimate expectation for being
confirmed in the post when an appointment to the
post could be made only by following a proper
procedure for selection and in cases concerned, in
consultation with the Public Service Commission.
Therefore, the theory of legitimate expectation
cannot be successfully advanced by temporary,
contractual or casual employees. It cannot also be
held that the State has held out any promise while
engaging these persons either to continue them
where they are or to make them permanent. The
State cannot constitutionally make such a promise.
It is also obvious that the theory cannot be invoked
to seek a positive relief of being made permanent in
the post.”
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
31. The Supreme Court in Umadevi (3) (supra) has clearly
recognized the State respondents’ right to appoint persons
on temporary basis. In spite of the constitutional scheme,
the Supreme Court held, there may be occasions when the
sovereign State or its instrumentalities will have to employ
persons, in posts which are temporary as additional hands
or taking them in without following the required procedure,
to discharge the duties in respect of the posts sanctioned.
The Supreme Court held that there was nothing in the
Constitution which prohibits such engaging of persons
temporarily to meet the needs of the situations. A reading
of the Service Rules makes it clear that it does not
contemplate appointment of any person on contract basis
besides what is contemplated in Rule 8(2). A reading of
Rules, 5, 6, 7 and 8 makes it clear that the provisions are
meant for regular appointments. However, there is no
manner of doubt that the State respondent did posses the
right to appoint persons on temporary basis to meet its
exigencies. Although the claim made by ATTC that the
petitioners had been employed temporarily due to the
exigency of some of its regular employees being sent for
training may not sound appealing sans contemporaneous
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
records, the fact that ATTC had in fact sought for
temporary employment and that the petitioners were
appointed purely on contract basis cannot be doubted. It is
also clear that both the petitioners accepted the terms of
contract and therefore, they were bound by it. It is correct
that the petitioners were initially appointed pursuant to an
advertisement issued. However, the advertisements were
specific
and
it
sought
for
temporary
contractual
employment. It is equally correct that the petitioners were
selected after undergoing a selection procedure akin to the
procedure prescribed in the Service Rules. However, merely
because the ATTC chose to follow the selection procedure
as prescribed for regular employment also for contractual
appointment; sought for self assessment reports and
incorrectly projected the petitioners as regular employees it
cannot be held that their appointments were regular.
Further, their continuation beyond the periods as per the
advertisements was ad hoc. The State respondents were
certain that they were seeking temporary employees.
During the entire period of service, the petitioners could
not have also had a single doubt in their mind that they
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
were not contractual employees bound by the terms of their
contracts.
32. The petitioners’ grievance about the State respondents
not keeping the student to lecturer ratio even if proved may
lead to other consequences upon ATTC. In a writ of this
nature
were
the
petitioners
are
seeking
relief
for
regularization of contractual service it may not be correct to
examine the failure of the ATTC to keep the student to
lecturer ratio. However, it definitely cannot be a reason for
this court to direct regularization of contractual employees.
The petitioners’ contentions that they were regularly sent
for training under the Carrier Advancement Scheme is
responded to by the State respondents stating that they
were so trained keeping in mind its benefit upon the
students. It is quite certain that their training and
experience
would
have
greatly
benefited
the
State
respondents, the students as well as the petitioners
themselves. However, this also cannot be a factor for this
court to direct the State respondents to do, what has been
held illegal by the Supreme Court. Consequently, both the
issues are held against the petitioners.
W.P. (C) No.29 of 2017
Naw Raj Bhattarai v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 30 of 2017
Amosh Shanker v. State of Sikkim & Ors.
33. The writ petitions fails and are accordingly dismissed.
In the circumstances, no order as to cost.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: Yes
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review