Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010222382022
2026:GAU-AS:13810
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL
PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7210/2022
AMLESH KUMAR SINGH
S/O- LATE PANCHANAND SINGH,
PERMANENT R/O- VILLAGE FURSATPUR, P.O- GARKHA UNDER
GARKKHA POLICE STATION, IN THE DISTRICT OF CHHAPRA (SARAN),
BIHAR, PIN-841311
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS
REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF COAL,
RAJPATH CENTRAL SECRETARIAT, NEW DELHI- 110001
2:THE COAL INDIA LIMITED
HAVING ITS HEAD OFFICE COAL BHAWAN
PLOT NO. AF-III
ACTION AREA- 1A
NEWTOWN
RAJARHAT
KOLKATA- 700156
3:THE GENERAL MANAGER
NORTH EASTERN COALFIELDS
COAL INDIA LIMITED
MARGHERITA
PIN- 786181
DIST- TINSUKIA
ASSAM
4:THE AREA MANAGER
NORTH EASTERN COALFIELDS
COAL INDIA LIMITED
MARGHERITA
PIN- 786181
DIST- TINSUKIA
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner :
MR P KATAKI, MS. M DEVI,MRS R BEGUM
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, COAL INDIA, MR. A M DUTTA (R2,3,4), MR M Z AHMED (R-2,3,4)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
15.09.2026
ORDER
Heard Mr. P Kataki, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mrs. R
Begum, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. M Z Ahmed,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. A M Dutta, learned counsel for
the respondent Nos. 2 to 4.
2.
By way of this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner is assailing, inter alia, the non-recommendation of
the case of the petitioner on 04.09.2020 for dependent employment
under the National Coal Wage Agreement [hereinafter referred to as
NCWA].
3.
The case of the petitioner is that his father late Panchananad
Singh who was working as an Office Superintendent posted at Tipong
Colliery of North Eastern Coal India Ltd. having its office at Margherita,
District-Tinsukia died while in service on 28.01.2017. Accordingly, the
petitioner on 12.08.2017 filed an application form for getting
employment as per the provisions of Para 9.3.2 of the NCWA-V as the
dependent of the said deceased employee.
4.
On 30.08.2019 the then Assistant Manager, North Eastern Coal
Fields India, Margherita informed the agent of the Tipong Colliery that
the proposal of employment of the petitioner was examined and
forwarded to the Coal India Limited, Kolkata for approval by its
Screening Committee.
5.
It was mentioned therein that the date of birth of the candidate
is not clear. Two dates were mentioned in the said application, namely,
one date of birth as 15.10.1988 as per the HSLC examination
certificate and the other as 01.01.1985 as recorded in the service book
of his late father. However, no outcome of the aforesaid exercise
having been informed, the petitioner sought the information under the
RTI Act.
6.
In response thereof, the respondent No. 3 informed the
petitioner by letter dated 11.06.2022 that due to non-recommendation
by the Screening Committee of the Coal India Limited, Kolkata for offer
for appointment due to non-establishment of the genuineness of the
identity of the dependent applicant, the case of the petitioner could
not be considered for appointment under the NCWA-V.
7.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that the Matriculation
and Higher Secondary Certificates issued by the Bihar School
Examination Board, Patna as well as the Birth Certificate issued by the
Registrar, Births and Deaths, having been submitted before the
authority showing the date of birth of the petitioner as 15.10.1988, the
same ought to have been accepted and the appointment in question
ought to have been considered in favor of the petitioner. Accordingly,
the decision of the competent authority of Coal India Limited, Kolkata
not to recommend the case of the petitioner suffers from gross abuse
of the power, the same being illegal and irrational. Situated thus, the
present writ petition has been preferred.
8.
Mr. Kataki, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits
that the date of birth of the petitioner initially have been wrongly
disclosed by his late father in his service book, however, the mark-
sheet as well as the birth certificate clearly indicates the correct date of
birth of the petitioner as 15.10.1988 and as such, there is no confusion
whatsoever as regards his date of birth. In this light, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner submits that the competent authority ought
to have accepted the date of birth recorded in the mark-sheet as well
as the birth certificate and consider the case of the petitioner for his
appointment under the dependent employment scheme framed by the
respondent authorities.
9.
In support of his submission that in the event there is a
discrepancy in the date of birth, the date recorded in the mark-sheet
shall prevail, Mr. Kataki, learned senior counsel for the petitioner relies
upon the decision of a Co-ordinate Bench of the Jharkhand High Court
in the case of Umesh Ram -Vs- The Central Coalfields Ltd. in
WP(S) No. 3532/2018.
10.
Per contra, Mr. M Z Ahmed, learned senior counsel for the
respondents submits that the competent authority having noted that
there is a doubt as regards the genuineness of the date of birth
recorded in the birth certificate and the identity of the petitioner as the
petitioner has been identified as one Sri Amlesh Kumar in the
recommendation of the NEC committee, the case of the petitioner for
recommendation for offer of dependent employment could not be
considered. He further submits that the petitioner’s father while filling
up the details of the dependents at the time of entry in the service
book on 22.12.1987 had himself disclosed that amongst his wife,
mother and children, name of one of his sons is Amlesh Kumar Singh,
i.e., the petitioner herein and whose date of birth is 01.01.1985. He
further submits that there is no clear recommendation of the NEC
committee as suggested by the learned counsel for the petitioner in his
favor, inasmuch as, the name recorded in the recommendation of the
NEC committee is in respect of one Amlesh Kumar, whereas the name
of the petitioner is Amlesh Kumar Singh. The Screening Committee
accordingly did not recommend the offer of employment to the
petitioner. He further submits that the decision of the competent
authority as such could not be termed as arbitrary or irrational. He
further submits that since the decision of the competent authority is
arrived upon consideration of the relevant materials, this Court while
exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
would not sit in appeal against such decision. He accordingly submits
that the instant writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
11.
I have given my prudent consideration to the arguments
advanced by the learned counsels for the parties and perused the
materials available on record. I have also duly considered the case
laws cited at the bar.
12.
The issue involved in the instant writ petition essentially
pertains to the rejection of the petitioner’s claim for dependent
employment in Coal India Limited, the respondent company, on the
ground that the genuineness of his identity could not be established on
account of discrepancies in his name and date of birth.
13.
It appears that, as per the service records of the deceased
father of the petitioner, the name and date of birth of the petitioner
were
recorded
as
“Amlesh
Kumar
Singh”
and
“01.01.1985”,
respectively. However, in the educational certificates issued by the
Bihar School Examination Board and the Bihar Intermediate Education
Council, as well as in the birth certificate issued by the Department of
Planning and Development, the name and date of birth of the
petitioner are recorded as “Amlesh Kumar” and “15.10.1988”,
respectively.
14.
It appears that, following the death of the deceased employee,
his wife submitted an application dated 18.04.2017, offering her eldest
son, i.e. the petitioner, for dependent employment under Clause 9.3.0
of the NCWA. In the said application, the name of her son was
mentioned as “Amlesh Kumar Singh”. Thereafter, the petitioner
submitted another application dated 28.07.2017, enclosing an affidavit
and a newspaper cutting, seeking to explain the discrepancy in his
name and date of birth. In the said application, he mentioned his name
as “Amlesh Kumar”.
15.
It further appears that the petitioner thereafter submitted a
formal application dated 12.08.2017, in terms of the provisions of
NCWA-V (now NCWA-IX), along with the verification roll, identification
certificate, attestation form and other requisite documents. In the said
application, while furnishing his date of birth, the petitioner mentioned
two different dates, namely, “01.01.1985” as per the service record
and “15.10.1988” as per the matriculation certificate. Further, while
furnishing the particulars of the surviving members of the deceased
employee, the petitioner disclosed his age as 32 years and 1 month as
on 11.08.2017. Thus, the materials on record disclose that there were
discrepancies not only in the name of the petitioner but also in the
date of birth furnished by him in the course of his claim for dependent
employment.
16.
It appears that, upon receipt of the relevant papers and
documents, the case of the petitioner for dependent employment was
processed in accordance with the applicable rules of the respondent
company and was forwarded on 25.01.2019 for consideration and
approval of the competent authority of Coal India Limited, Kolkata.
Thereafter, the Screening Committee of Coal India Limited considered
the case and, by its observations dated 24.07.2019, recorded as
follows:
"1. From the recommendations of NEC Committee, the date of
Birth of the Candidate, Sri Amlesh Kumar is not clear, there are
two dates mentioned there, one DoB (15-10-1988) as per HSLC
Certificate) and other (01-01-1985) as recorded in the service
book (C/27), PS-3, PS4 (C30, 32) & LTC Clam (C/34) of the
deceased employee. Therefore, NEC Committee may look into
the records to ascertain and recommend alongwith supporting
documents, the correct Date of Birth of the candidate Sri
Amlesh Kumar.
2. Signature & seal of GM (NEC) is not present on Page 2 of
Application Form (Proforma-1) submitted by the candidate. This
may kindly be obtained before resubmission by NEC Committee
to CIL Hqr (C/6).
3. In Indemnity Bond, two sureties are jointly held responsible
but they have not categorically accepted that irregularities
found in any of the facts stated by dependents/family will
subject the sureties to disciplinary/legal action.
In view of above, the committee is of the view that NEC
Committee may be advised to look into the above resubmit and
observation the case file/recommendations after addressing
the above stated issues."
17.
Thereafter, by letter dated 30.08.2019, the concerned unit of
NEC, Coal India Limited was directed to clarify the matter. Upon the
requisite clarification being furnished, the proposal was again
forwarded to Coal India Limited, Kolkata on 01.11.2019. Thereafter,
the Screening Committee of Coal India Limited, Kolkata, in its meeting
held on 04.09.2020, considered the proposal and did not recommend
the petitioner’s case for dependent employment. The relevant
observations of the Screening Committee read as follows:
“The genuineness of the identity of the dependent applicant Shri
Amlesh Kumar Singh is not established on verifying the Date of Birth
as mentioned in Service Book and PS-3. In view of this, the
Committee does not recommend for offer of employment."
18.
Thereafter,
the
case
of
the
petitioner
for
dependent
employment was again placed before the local management level at
NEC, CIL, Margherita, whereupon the following observation was made:
“Though in the service book of Late Panchanand Singh
the date of birth of Sri Amlesh Kumar is mentioned as 01-011985 and in PS-3 as 2 years as on 01-01-1987 but as per his
educational certificate submitted by him, his date of birth is
recorded as 15-10-1988. The certificate has also been verified
from the concerned Board and Board has confirmed the date of
birth of Shri Amlesh Kumar as 15-10-1988 (Pg No. 48& 75).
Further as per the provision of Implementation Instruction
No. 76 of NCWA (Pg No. 91& 92):
Quote
In the case of appointees who have passed Matriculation
or equivalent examination, the date of birth recorded in the said
certificate shall be treated as correct date of birth and the same
will not be altered under any circumstances.
Unquote"
19.
Thereafter, the case of the petitioner was once again
forwarded
for
communication
consideration
dated
of
the
18.11.2020.
competent
The
authority
competent
by
authority
recommended that the case be examined in the light of the decision in
the sub judice dependent employment case of Shri Souvik Sengupta,
son of late Moloy Sengupta of NEC.
Accordingly, the case of the petitioner was once again
processed at NEC, CIL, and necessary steps were undertaken to
ascertain the genuineness of the identity of the petitioner, namely,
Amlesh Kumar. For the said purpose, a committee conducted an
enquiry with the neighbours and co-workers of late Panchanand Singh.
Upon such enquiry, it was found that Amlesh Kumar was the son of
late Panchanand Singh and that he had completed his Intermediate
examination from the Bihar School Examination Board, wherein his
date of birth was recorded as 15.10.1988.
20.
It appears that the said NEC Committee was of the opinion
that, in terms of Implementation Instruction No. 76 of NCWA, the date
of birth recorded in the matriculation certificate/admit card was
required to be treated as final.
21.
Accordingly, by letter dated 27.12.2021, NEC forwarded its
recommendation in favour of the petitioner, namely, Amlesh Kumar, to
Coal India Limited, Kolkata. The relevant portion of the said
recommendation reads as follows:
“In view of the above and further as per the provision of 11 No
76 the Screening Committee of NFC hereby confirm that the
correct date of birth of Shri Amlesh Kumar S/o Late
Panchanand Singh is 15 10-1988 which has been recorded in
his educational certificate and Birth Certificate and therefore it
is recommended for approval of the competent authority to
provide dependent employment to Shri Amiesi Kumar S/o Late
Panchanand Singh.”
22.
The aforesaid recommendation of NEC was thereafter placed
before the competent authority, i.e. the Screening Committee of Coal
India Limited, Kolkata. Upon consideration of the recommendation of
the NEC Committee and the case of the petitioner, the Screening
Committee, in its meeting held on 04.02.2022, rejected the claim of
the petitioner by reiterating its earlier decision taken in the meeting
held on 04.09.2020 not to recommend his case for dependent
employment. The relevant observations recorded therein read as
follows:
“After going through the case file and deliberations of NEC
committee (noting no. 228/PIR/2929 dated 27/12/2021), this
committee has made the following observation:
SN
Observation
DOB
The DOB as recorded by Lt. Panchanand Singh in Service
Book i.ro his son Sri Amlesh Kumar is mentioned as
01/01/1985
Lt Panchanand Singh submitted PS-3 on 17/05/1998 wherein
DOB of Sri Amlesh Kumar Singh is mentioned as-
02 yrs as on
01/01/1987
The DOB as recorded by Lt Panchanand Singh in LLTC i.ro his
son Sri Amlesh Kumar is mentioned as-
27 yrs as on
08/02/2018
As per Matriculate Certificate submitted by Sri Amlesh Kumar
the date of birth is mentioned as
15/10/1988
In view of the above as the committee constituted by NEC
has not been able to establish the genuineness of the identity of
dependent applicant Sri Amlesh Kumar Singh so there is no
reason to make any changes in the recommendation dated
04.09.2020, which did not recommend for offer of appointment
due to non-establishment of genuineness of the identity of the
dependent applicant Shri Amlesh Kumar Singh." Accordingly,
the claim for employment of the Petitioner was regretted by the
competent authority of Coal India Limited.”
23.
Accordingly, the claim of the petitioner for dependent
employment was regretted by the competent authority. Thereafter, the
decision of the respondent company was communicated to the
petitioner’s mother by letter dated 16.05.2022, whereby she was called
upon to apply for monetary compensation within a period of 15 days,
failing which it would be presumed that she was not interested in
availing the same.
24.
The respondents have filed its affidavit-in-opposition on
08.08.2023, relevant paragraphs of which read as under:
“18. That while denying the correctness of the averments made
in Paragraph 8 of the Petition, your humble answering
deponent submits that the provision of "Employment to
Dependants" of North Eastern Coalfields, Coal India Limited
(Respondent Company) is defined at Chapter-IX (Social
Security) under Clauses 9.3.0, 9.4.0 and 9.5.0 of the National
Coal Wage Agreement (NCWA) as adopted by the Respondent
Company from time to time. The 1st National Coal Wage
Agreement (NCWA-I) was adopted on 11/12/1974, which was
in operation with effect from 15 January, 1975 to 31 December,
1978, and thereafter, various NCWAs have been adopted, and
presently, the provisions of the NCWA-XI are in operation in the
Respondent Company. The claim of the Petitioner was rightly
rejected by the Respondent Company on the ground of nonestablishment of genuineness of the identity of the Petitioner,
Amlesh Kumar Singh for discrepancy with regard to the name
and date of birth of the Petitioner in as much as in the Service
Record of the father of the Petitioner, Late Panchanand Singh,
the name of the Petitioner was written as "AMLESH KR. SINGH"
and the date of birth of the Petitioner was recorded as
01/01/1985 whereas the Petitioner has submitted his birth
Certificate and the Bihar School Examination Board Certificate,
wherein the name of the Petitioner is mentioned as "AMLESH
KUMAR" and his date of birth is mentioned as 15/10/1988.
Further, no service record can be altered after the death of an
employee. It is also pertinent to mention that the deceased
employee had signed the service record after declaring his
dependent details, and as such the claim of the Petitioner that
the date recorded in the service book had no documentary
evidence is totally wrong and baseless, and in that view of the
matter, the claim of the Petitioner that the decision taken by the
competent authority of Coal India Limited, Kolkata not to
recommend the case of the Petitioner suffers from the gross
abuse of power, same being illegal and irrational, is devoid of
merits and is categorically denied.”
25.
It appears that the issue involved in the instant writ petition is
not strictly as to whether the date of birth recorded in the
matriculation certificate/mark-sheet or the date of birth recorded in the
service book is to prevail. In this regard, Implementation Instruction
No. 76 provides as follows:
“(B) Review determination of date of birth in respect of existing
employees.
i) (a) In the case of the existing employees Matriculation
Certificate or Higher Secondary Certificate issued by the
recognised Universities or Board or Middle Pass Certificate
issued by the Board of Education and/or Department of Public
Instruction and admit cards issued by the aforesaid Bodies
should be treated as correct provided they were issued by the
said Universities/Boards/Institutions prior to the date of
employment.”
A perusal of the aforesaid provision indicates that, while
reviewing the date of birth of an existing employee, the matriculation
certificate or higher secondary certificate issued by a recognized
university or board, or a middle pass certificate issued by the Board of
Education and/or Department of Public Instruction, as well as an admit
card issued by the aforesaid bodies, may be treated as correct,
provided that the same was issued prior to the date of employment.
However, in the instant case, this Court is not concerned with
determination of the date of birth of the deceased employee. The issue
is with regard to the conflicting particulars relating to the name and
date of birth of his son, who is claiming appointment under the
dependent employment scheme
26.
The controversy assumes significance in view of the fact that
the petitioner’s father, while furnishing the particulars of his
dependents in his service record, had disclosed the name of the
petitioner as “Amlesh Kumar Singh” and his date of birth as
01.01.1985. The petitioner’s mother, while subsequently applying for
dependent employment for the petitioner, also disclosed his name as
“Amlesh Kumar Singh” and his date of birth as 01.01.1985.
It further appears that, although the petitioner subsequently
disclosed his date of birth as 15.10.1988, purportedly on the basis of
his
matriculation
certificate,
in
his
application
for
dependent
employment, he simultaneously disclosed his age as 32 years and 1
month as on 11.08.2017. The said disclosure is, on the face of it,
inconsistent with the date of birth of 15.10.1988 furnished by him in
the same application.
27.
Most significantly, the petitioner’s father, while furnishing the
particulars of his dependents in his service book on 22.12.1987, had
recorded the name of his son as “Amlesh Kumar Singh” and his age as
about 2 years as on the said date. If the petitioner’s date of birth is, in
fact, 15.10.1988, as subsequently claimed on the basis of his
matriculation certificate, the aforesaid entry made by his father on
22.12.1987, i.e. prior to the date of the petitioner’s claimed birth,
cannot be reconciled with such claim.
28.
Thus, the materials on record disclose cumulative discrepancies
concerning both the name and date of birth of the petitioner. It
appears that these discrepancies were taken into consideration by the
competent authority while examining the petitioner’s claim for
dependent employment and ultimately resulted in rejection of his
claim.
29.
It is well settled that, while exercising writ jurisdiction, the
Court is primarily concerned with the decision-making process and not
with the decision per se. Where the decision-making process is found
to be arbitrary, unreasonable or otherwise vitiated by illegality, this
Court can certainly exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction to correct the
same.
30.
Keeping the aforesaid principles in mind and upon careful
perusal of the materials available on record, this Court does not find
any such arbitrariness or illegality in the decision-making process of
the competent authority as would warrant interference in exercise of
its extraordinary writ jurisdiction.
31.
The decision of the competent authority appears to have been
founded upon the particulars disclosed by the petitioner’s parents in
the contemporaneous records, as well as the disclosures subsequently
made by the petitioner himself while seeking appointment under the
dependent employment scheme. The petitioner has not been able to
satisfactorily reconcile the discrepancies relating to his name and date
of birth appearing in the aforesaid records. The submission advanced
by learned counsel for the petitioner that, in the event of a discrepancy
in the date of birth, the date recorded in the matriculation certificate
ought to prevail cannot, in the facts and circumstances of the present
case, be applied mechanically. The applicability of such a principle
would necessarily depend upon the facts and circumstances in which
the discrepancy has arisen. In the present case, the contemporaneous
entry made by the petitioner’s father in the service book on
22.12.1987, recording the petitioner’s name and age as about two
years, raises a serious inconsistency with the petitioner’s subsequent
claim that his date of birth is 15.10.1988.
Accordingly, the decision relied upon by learned counsel for the
petitioner, namely, Umesh Ram (supra), is distinguishable on facts
and does not advance the case of the petitioner.
32.
It is, however, made clear that this Court is not, in the present
proceeding, adjudicating upon the genuineness or otherwise of the
matriculation certificate or birth certificate produced by the petitioner.
For the purpose of examining the validity of the decision-making
process, it is sufficient to note that the material discrepancies
concerning the petitioner’s name and date of birth remained
unexplained. In such circumstances, the decision of the competent
authority not to recommend the petitioner for dependent employment
cannot be said to suffer from arbitrariness or illegality warranting
interference by this Court.
33.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the petitioner has failed to
make out any case warranting interference by this Court in exercise of
its extraordinary writ jurisdiction. Consequently, the writ petition
stands dismissed.
34.
Before parting with the records of this proceeding, it is
pertinent to place on record certain facts which have come to the
notice of this Court while editing the draft judgment after its dictation
in open Court.
It appears that, while filing the instant writ petition, the
petitioner’s name was reflected as “Amlesh Kumar Singh” in the causetitle of the synopsis, list of dates, index and proceeding. In the
affidavit, though the petitioner’s name was initially typed as “Amlesh
Kumar”, the last name, namely, “Singh”, was subsequently inserted by
hand, without any signature or initial of the person making such
insertion. Consequently, the case came to be registered in the CIS with
the petitioner’s name as “Amlesh Kumar Singh”. It is, however, noticed
that, after registration of the case, the last name “Singh” was erased
by applying whitener in the cause-title appearing in the synopsis, list of
dates, index and proceeding, thereby changing the petitioner’s name
from “Amlesh Kumar Singh” to “Amlesh Kumar”. A similar correction
appears to have been made in the affidavit by applying whitener over
the last name “Singh”, which had earlier been inserted by hand.
Significantly, none of the aforesaid corrections bears any signature,
initial or date. The petitioner’s name, including his last name, assumes
significance in the controversy involved in the present writ petition.
The manner in which the petitioner’s name appears to have been
altered in the records, particularly after registration of the case in the
CIS, where the petitioner’s name continues to be reflected as “Amlesh
Kumar Singh”, raises serious concerns regarding the sanctity and
integrity of the Court records.
In the absence of any office note,
endorsement, signature or initial evidencing or authorising such
alteration, the circumstances prima facie indicate an unauthorised
alteration of the Court records. The matter, therefore, cannot be
ignored. Accordingly, the Registry is directed to enquire into the matter
and place a report before the Hon’ble Chief Justice on the
Administrative Side for such further action as may be deemed
appropriate.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review