Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132s7 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI
CRIM INAL PETITION NO: 1019 3 0F 2024
Between:
Amithab Bagchi, s/o. Ranjith Bagchi, Aged 12 years, R/o. Dalton Gunj,
Jharkhand, Lodged at chenchalguda central prison, Hyderabad.
.Petitioner/Accused No.28
AND
The'State of Telangana, Through SHO, Karimnagar Rural P.S., Represented by
its Public Prosecutor, High Court at Hyderabad.
...RespondenUComplainant
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances
stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may
be pleased to quash the impugned order dated 22-07-202+ passeO by the lV
Additional District and Sessions Judge, at Karimnagar, in Crl.M.P.No.1ZB of ZOZ4
in PRC No.69 of 2019 in Crime tto.Ot of 2008 of p.S. Karimnagar Rural, by
which the learned court, cancelled the bail granted by it to
tne petitioner/
Accused No.28 in crr.M.p.No.1B of 2024, vide
oid", dated 30.01 .2024.
I.A. N o: 10F 2024
Petition under Section 521 of
that in the circumstances
stated in the Memorandum of Grounds
,BN-s!.praying
or
crimin'ar
be pteased to susp_e{.
,p:It,^or,_the High court may
impug,eo
Lro"i'irflo
lh:
learned rV Additio.nar District
.22.07.2024 passed by the
,nJ-se-ssions
J;;;, At
'6e
Karimnagar, in crr. M.p.
No 12B or 2024 in pRCN;.
;0'i6
Karimnagar Rural pendin!
"fthe ,oou" ciiminat No 01 or zooa or p s.
oirpoJrr of
petition.
"il"t;ir"
t.
N o:
OF 20
Petition under Section ,rq,,:lILSi.plr,ing
stated in the Memorandum
that in the circumstances
of ciounos or crimin'ai F.tition,
be pteased to retea.e t,e pltIil'n"rl
,n.-H,Jn court may
e""*.J..ttl.ze on bailln.dc.
2024 (earrier pR.c
r.ro.50 of
os'J',i"o1s1 0n-tnl--ri*',
,nu rv noor. District and
Ji'
a oi p
:,'.[,i'"li [1?T :il,i*
n
ar Ru
ff;ffi
!o
If ,,#;o3;;[ i :',
t'it]I,
",
ra,
This Fetition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of
Grounds of tlriminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri B. Nalin
Kumar, Senitrr Counsel representing Sri G. Jabali, Advocate for the Petitioner
and Sri M. Ramachandra Reddy, Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the
Sole Responclent.
The Court made the following: ORDER
I
.i.;\
't
/,
STATE OF TELANGANA
FOR-ftIE
COURT
IN THE HIGH
HYDERABAD
.Y-'
THE
JUSTICE JUVVADI
HONOURABLE SMT'
AT
SRDEVI
P
D
Between:
... Petitioner
Amithab Bagchi
The State of Telangana
by Public Prosecutor
AND
rep resented
ResPondent
ORDER:
This Criminal Petition is
filed bY the Petitioner-accused
No.2Sseekingtoquashtheimpugnedorderdated22.0T.2024
passedbythelearnedlVAdditionalDistrict&SessionsJudge
atKarimnagar(hereinafterreferredasthe.learnedSessions
Judge')
in P'R'C'No'69
in CRL'M'P'No' 128 of 2024
Crime No.1 of 200g of Karimnagar
of 2019 in
Rural Police Station, wherein
theapplicationfiledbytheprosecutionunderSectiona3g(2)of
seeking to cancel the bail
Procedure
Criminal
of
the Code
againstthepetitioner,wasallowedandthebailgrantedtothe
petitioner was cancelled
02- Heard sri B. Narin Kumar,
representing sri G- Jabari,
and Sri M.Ramachandra
prosecutc,r for
rearned counser
03(a)' Learned senior
was produr3ed in crime
for the petitioner
Reddy, learned Additional public
the State. perused
submitted that the petitioner
rearned senior counser
the record.
counser for the petitioner
who is arrayed as accused
No.1 0f 200g on 01 .02.2010
then he has been in judicial
Magistrate of First
bair to the petitioner
not furnish sureties, subsequenfly,
numbered as pRc No.6g
and since
custody. On 1g.1O.2O1Othe
learned ll Additional Judicial
Karimnagar granted defaurt
No.2g
Class,
but he courd
charge sheet was fired
and
of 2o1g and on bair apprication
fired
by the petitioner, the rearned
sessions Judge vide orders
30'01 '2014 granted bair to the petitioner.
The prosecution has
filed an apptication seeking cancellation
.RL.M.P.No 12g of 2014 before
dated
of bail vide
the rearned sessions Judge,
prior to the furnishing of sureties
by the petitioner and the
learned Sessions Judge erroneously allowed the same and
cancelledthebailofthepetitionervideimpugnedorder.ltis
furthersubrnittedthattherearenonewcircumstancesbrought
beforethelearnedSessionsJudgeandthereisnoviolationof
anyconditionsofthebailorderasthepetitioner-accusedNo.28
stillremainedintheiudicialcustody.Exerciseofpowerunder
Section439(2)oftheCodeofCriminalProcedurebytheSame
Courtwhichgrantedbail,withoutthepresenceofanynew
circumstancesortheviolationofanyoftheconditionsimposed,
n 362 of the Code'
violation of Sectio
would be gross
03(b)'
quash the impugned
While praying to
Judge' the
by the learned Sessions
order passed
learned counsel for
decision in Gurcharan
petitioner relied upon a
the
Singh and
othersv.State(DethiAdministration)lwhereintheHon,ble
Supreme Court at Paragraph
No'16 held that:
,,16.....underSection43g(2)ofthenewCode,the
may direct any
High Court or the Court of Sessron
oit bait to be anested
person who has been released
old Code' Secfion
committed to custody' tn the
and
different language
4gS(2) was worded in somewhat
or Courf of Session
when it said that a High Court
person who been admitted to bail
may cause any
and may commit
under subsection (1) to be arrested
under Secfion 498(2)
him to custody. ln other Words'
of the old Code, a person who had been admitted
bail by the High Court could
be committed to custody
onty by the High Court' Similarly' if a
'(tgzq 1 scc 110
to
person was
aclmitted to bail
Ccturt of Se
by a Court of
;::::rr:,W:: ;:;,' r ;- :: ::'J,':;
application ft
, ,,[iJ":;'::::;::::ril
to ,bair, ,o
r h s re s t r c
i;!; !*'tIt ! ;i; i:::;
j:"
:i^x ;' ;:"; :; i::
::;;
"/::::x:
["f"i!i l;::,,:ff
"lr'committinn
; J,
do
",i i,
::,,:;
s, tt must,,
Sessrbn cannot
granted by the
cancel a bait which
High Courtunless
arise duing the progre.ss
person has been
occusEd person to
has already been
new circumslances
of the triat after an accused
admitted to bail by
however, a Court
::::r::::,:,
the High Couft.
of Sessrbn had admitted
bail, the State has two
may fiove the Sessrbns
circumstances have arisen
known to the Sfafe and
Court being the superior
Judge if certain new
*nin were not earrier
to that
well izpproach the High
Court under Section 439(2)
to commit the accused to
custody. When, however,
the State is aggrieved by the
Judge granting bail and
circumstances that leave
already existed, it is futire
an
options. tt
necessarily, therefore,
Court. The State may as
tf,
order of the Sessacns
there are no new
copied up except those
for the sfafe to move the
Sesstbns Judge again and
it is compete nt in taw to
move the High Court for cancellation of the bait. This
posiffon follows from the subordinafe posifion of the
Coutl'"
Courtof Session vis-a-vis the High
03(c). Further, he relied upon a decision in the case of
Abdul Basit v. Mohd- Abdul Kadir Choudhaff wherein
Hon'ble Supreme Court at paragraph Nos.19, 21
and 26 held
that:
"19. Therefore, the concept of setting aside an
unjustified, illegal or peruerse order is different from
the concept of cancellation of a bait on the ground of
accused's misconduct or new adverse facts having
surtaced after the grant of bail which require such
cancellation and a perusal of the aforesaid decisions
would present before us that an order granting bait
can only be sef asrde on grounds of being illegal or
contrary to law by the Court superior to the Court
which granted the bait and not by the same Court.
. lt is an accepted principle of law that when a
matter has been finally disposed of by a Court, the
Court is, in the absence of a direct statutory provision,
functus officio and cannot enteftain a fresh prayer for
relief in the mafter unless and untit the previous order
of final disposal has been sef aside or modified to that
extent. lt rb a/so seft/ed taw that the judgment and
order granting bail cannot be reviewed by the Court
passrng such judgment and order in absence of
any
express provision in the Code for the same. Secfion
362 of the Code operates as bar to any alteration
review of fhe cases disposed of by the Court.
The
singular exception to the said statutory bar
correction of clerical or aithmetical error by the
'? 1zor11
ro scc zsl
or
is
Court.
the
26. ln the instant case, the order for bail in the bail
application preferred by the accused-petitioners
hercin finally disposes of the issue in consideration
ancl grants relief of bail to the applicants therein.
Since, no express provision for review of order
gra,tting ball exists under the Code, the High Court
becomes functus officio and Secfion 362 of the Code
applies herein baning the review of judgment and
order of the Court granting bail to the accusedpetilioners. Even though the cancellation of bail rides
on t,\e satisfaction and discretion of the Coud under
Seclion 439(2) of the Code, it does not vest the power
of review in the Court which granted bail. Even in the
light of fact of misrepresentation by the accusedpetiticners during the grant of bail, the High Court
coulcr not have enteftained the respondent/infomant's
praye'r by sifting in review of its judgment by
enten'aining miscellaneous petition."
03(d). Further, he relied upon a decision in the case of
Javed Gulam Nabi Shaik v. Sfafe of Maharashfra3 wherein it
was held at Paragraph Nos.19, 20 and 21that:
"19. lf the State or any prosecuting agency including
the co'Lrt concemed has no wherewithal to provide or
protect the fundamental right of an accused to have a
speedt, trial as enshined under Afticle 21 of the
Constilution then the Sfale or any other prosecuting
agency should not oppose the plea for bail on the
ground that the cime committed is senbus. Atticle 21
" 2024 ScC onlino SC 1693
!}.
of
irrespective
the Constitution applies
of the nature of
the crime'
sfill an
the petitioner is
postulate of
over-arching
The
convict'
a
accused; not
to
accused is presumed
to add that
20- We may hasten
that an
criminatiurisprudence
be brushed
proven guitty cannot
until
innocent
be
penal law may
stringent the
howsoever
tightly'
aside
be.
that the
21. We are convinced
the
manner in which
the Court have
well as
prosecuting agency as
a speedy
accused to have
the
of
ight
the
proceeded'
been infringed thereby
coutd be said to have
triat
violating Articte 21 of
the Constittttion'"
04. On the other hand' learned
Additional Public
ProsecutorappearingfortheStatefiledcountersubmittingthat
thepetitioner-accusedNo.2Sisapolitburomemberofthe
banned cPl (Maoists) and operating
pan-lndia and that if the
petitioner is released on bail, he is likely to re-join
the Maoist
organization and to go underground as a
full time
terrorisuextremist and likely to evade to face
the trial and that
the accused is a dangerous criminal and planning to
commit
further acts of violence and sabotage and it is possible
that he
will destroy evidence and will threaten witnesses and will
tamper with the evidence and that he was already convicted
and sent enced to undergo Rigorous lmprisonment fOf Life and
eight years of
imprisonment
in two cases
vide crime
No.166 0f
2009 of Chutia,
Ranchi District
and Crime
No'Rccrt /2011/NIA/GAW,
respecti,rely.
Petition, the
Nationar rnvestigating
Hence, while praying
rearned Additionar pubric
relied upon a
decision in the
anothera wherein
Paragraph No.27
to dismiss this
prosecutor
case of Ajwar
it was held by
ought not to be
Criminal
for the state
v. Waseem and
the Hon,ble Supreme
that:
"27' rt is equa'y
Agency,
Court at
we, settted that bait
once granted,
cancetted in a mechanical
manner.
However' an unreasoned
or peruerse order of bait is
alway:; open to interference
by the supeior Court. tf
there are serious attegations
even i,F he has not misused
such an order can be
agarnsl the accused,
the bait granted to
cancelled by the sarne
that has granted the bait.
him,
Court
Bait canalso be revoked
by
a superior Court if it transpires
that the courts O;r^,
have ignored the rerevant
materiar avairabre on record
or not looked into the gravity
impact <>n the society
of the offence or the
resutting in such an
05' This court has carefury
submissions and perused the material
order.,,
considered the rivar
available on record. tt is
nOt in dispUte that bail was granted to the petitioner bv the
learnedSer;sionsJudgebyorderdated30.01.2024.
o
lzoz+15 s.c.R.
a'75'.2oz4 t NSC 438
The
'tt
petitionerhadnotfurnishedSuretiesandWaScontinuingin
judicialcustody.Theprosecutionfiledanapplicationseeking
order dated 22'07 '2024
impugned
The
of bail'
cancellation
cancelling bail
same Court which
the
by
passed
was
granted
bail
is that
06. The settled legal Position
from setting
stands on a different footing
cancellation of bail
aside an illegal bail
shall be founded
order. cancellation of bail
on any violation of
bailconditions,ormisuseofliberty'orinterferencewith
investigationortrial,orlikelihoodofabsconding,oremergence
of new adverse circumstances after
grant of bail'
oT.Further,onceaCourtgrantsbaitandfinally
disposes of the bail application, in the
absence of statutory
provision for review, the Court becomes functus officio' Section
362 0f the code of criminal Procedure bars alteration
or review
of such final order except for clerical or arithmetical errors. ln
the present case, a perusal of the impugned order does not
disctose any supervening circumstances arising after grant of
bail, or violation of any bail condition by the petitioner, or
materiar showing
petitioner was
0g'
't
misuse of riberty,
still in custody for
the apprication for
mainry to the seriousness
petitioner' and
the grounds urged
by the
canceration of bair
rerate
of the ailegations,
the possibility of his
matters which were
antecedents of the
future conduct. These
avairabre, or courd
at the time of granting
prosecution, if aggrieved
any new or
the proper course open to
by the order granting bair,
approach th' superior court,
but not to seek canceration
before the siame court on the
are a,
have been considered,
bair. rn the absence of
supervening circumstances,
when the
want of sureties.
is to be noted that
prosecution in
ffrore particurarry
the
was to
of bair
very same set of facts. rt is arso
well setfled that bair granted can
be set aside by a superior
court if it is found that the courts betow
material avairabre on record, or have
gravity of ther offence or the impact
have ignored rerevant
faired to consider the
of the offence on society,
resulting in the grant of bail.
09.1'ltheaboveviewofthematter'theimpugnedorder
which
passed mechanically
be
to
effect' appears
which is in
amountstore-appreciationoftheearlierbailorderandoperates
^'
-
l-
rt-?
I
.\
aSareviewoftheordergrantingbail,whichisimpermissibletn
law. Though the allegations
nature,
are serious
against the petitioner
itself' cannot
gravity of the offence' by
been granted' in
cancel bail once it has
supervening circumstances'
in
be a ground to
the absence of any
of the
subsequent conduct
of new material warranting
accused, o[ emergence
such
cancellation'moreparticularly,cancellationofbailbythevery
an
granted bail' amounts to
who
Judge
and
same Court
illegalityandmaterialirregularity.lnviewoftheabove
considered opinion
the
of
is
court
this
discussion,
learned sessions Judge was
that the
not justified in invoking powers
of criminal
under section 439(2) of the code
Procedure in the
absenceofsuperveningcircumstancesand,therefore,the
impugned order is liable to be set aside'
10. Accordingly, this criminal Petition is allowed and the
impugned order dated 22.07.2024 passed by the
learned lv
Additional District & Sessions Judge at Karimnagar, is hereby
set aside. However, it is made clear that, if the prosecution
is
aggrieved by the order granting bail, the proper course open to
it is to approach the superior court and liberty is accordingly
\
granted to the prosecution
to avail such remedy,
with law.
As ia sequel, pending
miscellaneous
shall stand closed.
in accordance
applications, if
any,
o.'rfP';IaiS{HH ,/
//TRUE COPYII
One Fair Copy
SECTION OFFICER
t<
irj.,Xi.t?[3[,:,l
SRIDEVI
To,
1 The
2.
Statir
The lV Additionat
District e
oistrici..cnHo,."_cilj;;ii*,;,;"",j:n j,:1X;,,:L[il,fl
ll*Xi,,n,r,.
3. Two CCs to the public prosecrtnr
Lr;^r- n_
"- ' r''roecutor' High
Hyderabad.
Court for
loUTi
I iii_.BJ:.
riri G.'Jabari, Advocate
:
l#; t,ffi
-'-r';vrl, Ad
the State of Telangana
at
[opUc]
6. The Under Sr:cretary,
Union
v!
Rnairs, w-ew t)elhi ' ' "v'| ' of lndia Ministry of Law, Justice
and company
s A s s o c a 1,."^,1
p,., y, H 's"
is h c
":,e
nrgn
s o u rt ro r t h e
uourt
fl,,?
Buildings
8._ ${::ff,"f"',:?
Two CD Copres
-!
at Hyderabad.
;[i,r'r""''
Kam/pSI
i
@
,
'
HIGH COURT
DATED:2010212026
1 ItE S
1',
k'
oo
*
ORDER
CRLP.No.10193 ot 2024
LOWING THE
CRIMINAL PETITION
?6 7.
>e
zI
? 5 ft8 m26
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review