Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/amithab-bagchi-vs-the-state-of-telangana-20260220/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil

Amithab Bagchi vs The State of Telangana

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Telangana High Court
Date
20 February 2026
Case No.
CRLP 10193/2024
Result
Allowed
Bench
Justice Juvvadi Sridevi
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

06. The settled legal Position from setting stands on a different footing cancellation of bail aside an illegal bail shall be founded order. cancellation of bail on any violation of bailconditions,ormisuseofliberty'orinterferencewith investigationortrial,orlikelihoodofabsconding,oremergence of new adverse circumstances after grant of bail' oT.Further,onceaCourtgrantsbaitandfinally disposes of the bail application, in the absence of statutory provision for review, the Court becomes functus officio' Section 362 0f the code of criminal Procedure bars alteration or review of such final order except for clerical or arithmetical errors. ln the present case, a perusal of the impugned order does not disctose any supervening circumstances arising after grant of bail, or violation of any bail condition by the petitioner, or materiar showing petitioner was 0g' 't misuse of riberty, still in custody for the apprication for mainry to the seriousness petitioner' and the grounds urged by the canceration of bair rerate of the ailegations, the possibility of his matters which were antecedents of the future conduct. These avairabre, or courd at the time of granting prosecution, if aggrieved any new or the proper course open to by the order granting bair, approach th' superior court, but not to seek canceration before the siame court on the are a, have been considered, bair. rn the absence of superve…

09. 1'ltheaboveviewofthematter'theimpugnedorder which passed mechanically be to effect' appears which is in amountstore-appreciationoftheearlierbailorderandoperates ^' - l- rt-? I .\ aSareviewoftheordergrantingbail,whichisimpermissibletn law. Though the allegations nature, are serious against the petitioner itself' cannot gravity of the offence' by been granted' in cancel bail once it has supervening circumstances' in be a ground to the absence of any of the subsequent conduct of new material warranting accused, o[ emergence such cancellation'moreparticularly,cancellationofbailbythevery an granted bail' amounts to who Judge and same Court illegalityandmaterialirregularity.lnviewoftheabove considered opinion the of is court this discussion, learned sessions Judge was that the not justified in invoking powers of criminal under section 439(2) of the code Procedure in the absenceofsuperveningcircumstancesand,therefore,the impugned order is liable to be set aside'

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

132s7 I IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI CRIM INAL PETITION NO: 1019 3 0F 2024 Between: Amithab Bagchi, s/o. Ranjith Bagchi, Aged 12 years, R/o. Dalton Gunj, Jharkhand, Lodged at chenchalguda central prison, Hyderabad. .Petitioner/Accused No.28 AND The'State of Telangana, Through SHO, Karimnagar Rural P.S., Represented by its Public Prosecutor, High Court at Hyderabad. ...RespondenUComplainant Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to quash the impugned order dated 22-07-202+ passeO by the lV Additional District and Sessions Judge, at Karimnagar, in Crl.M.P.No.1ZB of ZOZ4 in PRC No.69 of 2019 in Crime tto.Ot of 2008 of p.S. Karimnagar Rural, by which the learned court, cancelled the bail granted by it to tne petitioner/ Accused No.28 in crr.M.p.No.1B of 2024, vide oid", dated 30.01 .2024. I.A. N o: 10F 2024 Petition under Section 521 of that in the circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds ,BN-s!.praying or crimin'ar be pteased to susp_e{. ,p:It,^or,_the High court may impug,eo Lro"i'irflo lh: learned rV Additio.nar District .22.07.2024 passed by the ,nJ-se-ssions J;;;, At '6e Karimnagar, in crr. M.p. No 12B or 2024 in pRCN;. ;0'i6 Karimnagar Rural pendin! "fthe ,oou" ciiminat No 01 or zooa or p s. oirpoJrr of petition. "il"t;ir" t. N o: OF 20 Petition under Section ,rq,,:lILSi.plr,ing stated in the Memorandum that in the circumstances of ciounos or crimin'ai F.tition, be pteased to retea.e t,e pltIil'n"rl ,n.-H,Jn court may e""*.J..ttl.ze on bailln.dc. 2024 (earrier pR.c r.ro.50 of os'J',i"o1s1 0n-tnl--ri*', ,nu rv noor. District and Ji' a oi p :,'.[,i'"li [1?T :il,i* n ar Ru ff;ffi !o If ,,#;o3;;[ i :', t'it]I, ", ra, This Fetition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of Grounds of tlriminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri B. Nalin Kumar, Senitrr Counsel representing Sri G. Jabali, Advocate for the Petitioner and Sri M. Ramachandra Reddy, Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Sole Responclent. The Court made the following: ORDER I .i.;\ 't /, STATE OF TELANGANA FOR-ftIE COURT IN THE HIGH HYDERABAD .Y-' THE JUSTICE JUVVADI HONOURABLE SMT' AT SRDEVI P D Between: ... Petitioner Amithab Bagchi The State of Telangana by Public Prosecutor AND rep resented ResPondent ORDER: This Criminal Petition is filed bY the Petitioner-accused No.2Sseekingtoquashtheimpugnedorderdated22.0T.2024 passedbythelearnedlVAdditionalDistrict&SessionsJudge atKarimnagar(hereinafterreferredasthe.learnedSessions Judge') in P'R'C'No'69 in CRL'M'P'No' 128 of 2024 Crime No.1 of 200g of Karimnagar of 2019 in Rural Police Station, wherein theapplicationfiledbytheprosecutionunderSectiona3g(2)of seeking to cancel the bail Procedure Criminal of the Code againstthepetitioner,wasallowedandthebailgrantedtothe petitioner was cancelled 02- Heard sri B. Narin Kumar, representing sri G- Jabari, and Sri M.Ramachandra prosecutc,r for rearned counser 03(a)' Learned senior was produr3ed in crime for the petitioner Reddy, learned Additional public the State. perused submitted that the petitioner rearned senior counser the record. counser for the petitioner who is arrayed as accused No.1 0f 200g on 01 .02.2010 then he has been in judicial Magistrate of First bair to the petitioner not furnish sureties, subsequenfly, numbered as pRc No.6g and since custody. On 1g.1O.2O1Othe learned ll Additional Judicial Karimnagar granted defaurt No.2g Class, but he courd charge sheet was fired and of 2o1g and on bair apprication fired by the petitioner, the rearned sessions Judge vide orders 30'01 '2014 granted bair to the petitioner. The prosecution has filed an apptication seeking cancellation .RL.M.P.No 12g of 2014 before dated of bail vide the rearned sessions Judge, prior to the furnishing of sureties by the petitioner and the learned Sessions Judge erroneously allowed the same and cancelledthebailofthepetitionervideimpugnedorder.ltis furthersubrnittedthattherearenonewcircumstancesbrought beforethelearnedSessionsJudgeandthereisnoviolationof anyconditionsofthebailorderasthepetitioner-accusedNo.28 stillremainedintheiudicialcustody.Exerciseofpowerunder Section439(2)oftheCodeofCriminalProcedurebytheSame Courtwhichgrantedbail,withoutthepresenceofanynew circumstancesortheviolationofanyoftheconditionsimposed, n 362 of the Code' violation of Sectio would be gross 03(b)' quash the impugned While praying to Judge' the by the learned Sessions order passed learned counsel for decision in Gurcharan petitioner relied upon a the Singh and othersv.State(DethiAdministration)lwhereintheHon,ble Supreme Court at Paragraph No'16 held that: ,,16.....underSection43g(2)ofthenewCode,the may direct any High Court or the Court of Sessron oit bait to be anested person who has been released old Code' Secfion committed to custody' tn the and different language 4gS(2) was worded in somewhat or Courf of Session when it said that a High Court person who been admitted to bail may cause any and may commit under subsection (1) to be arrested under Secfion 498(2) him to custody. ln other Words' of the old Code, a person who had been admitted bail by the High Court could be committed to custody onty by the High Court' Similarly' if a '(tgzq 1 scc 110 to person was aclmitted to bail Ccturt of Se by a Court of ;::::rr:,W:: ;:;,' r ;- :: ::'J,':; application ft , ,,[iJ":;'::::;::::ril to ,bair, ,o r h s re s t r c i;!; !*'tIt ! ;i; i:::; j:" :i^x ;' ;:"; :; i:: ::;; "/::::x: ["f"i!i l;::,,:ff "lr'committinn ; J, do ",i i, ::,,:; s, tt must,, Sessrbn cannot granted by the cancel a bait which High Courtunless arise duing the progre.ss person has been occusEd person to has already been new circumslances of the triat after an accused admitted to bail by however, a Court ::::r::::,:, the High Couft. of Sessrbn had admitted bail, the State has two may fiove the Sessrbns circumstances have arisen known to the Sfafe and Court being the superior Judge if certain new *nin were not earrier to that well izpproach the High Court under Section 439(2) to commit the accused to custody. When, however, the State is aggrieved by the Judge granting bail and circumstances that leave already existed, it is futire an options. tt necessarily, therefore, Court. The State may as tf, order of the Sessacns there are no new copied up except those for the sfafe to move the Sesstbns Judge again and it is compete nt in taw to move the High Court for cancellation of the bait. This posiffon follows from the subordinafe posifion of the Coutl'" Courtof Session vis-a-vis the High 03(c). Further, he relied upon a decision in the case of Abdul Basit v. Mohd- Abdul Kadir Choudhaff wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court at paragraph Nos.19, 21 and 26 held that: "19. Therefore, the concept of setting aside an unjustified, illegal or peruerse order is different from the concept of cancellation of a bait on the ground of accused's misconduct or new adverse facts having surtaced after the grant of bail which require such cancellation and a perusal of the aforesaid decisions would present before us that an order granting bait can only be sef asrde on grounds of being illegal or contrary to law by the Court superior to the Court which granted the bait and not by the same Court. . lt is an accepted principle of law that when a matter has been finally disposed of by a Court, the Court is, in the absence of a direct statutory provision, functus officio and cannot enteftain a fresh prayer for relief in the mafter unless and untit the previous order of final disposal has been sef aside or modified to that extent. lt rb a/so seft/ed taw that the judgment and order granting bail cannot be reviewed by the Court passrng such judgment and order in absence of any express provision in the Code for the same. Secfion 362 of the Code operates as bar to any alteration review of fhe cases disposed of by the Court. The singular exception to the said statutory bar correction of clerical or aithmetical error by the '? 1zor11 ro scc zsl or is Court. the 26. ln the instant case, the order for bail in the bail application preferred by the accused-petitioners hercin finally disposes of the issue in consideration ancl grants relief of bail to the applicants therein. Since, no express provision for review of order gra,tting ball exists under the Code, the High Court becomes functus officio and Secfion 362 of the Code applies herein baning the review of judgment and order of the Court granting bail to the accusedpetilioners. Even though the cancellation of bail rides on t,\e satisfaction and discretion of the Coud under Seclion 439(2) of the Code, it does not vest the power of review in the Court which granted bail. Even in the light of fact of misrepresentation by the accusedpetiticners during the grant of bail, the High Court coulcr not have enteftained the respondent/infomant's praye'r by sifting in review of its judgment by enten'aining miscellaneous petition." 03(d). Further, he relied upon a decision in the case of Javed Gulam Nabi Shaik v. Sfafe of Maharashfra3 wherein it was held at Paragraph Nos.19, 20 and 21that: "19. lf the State or any prosecuting agency including the co'Lrt concemed has no wherewithal to provide or protect the fundamental right of an accused to have a speedt, trial as enshined under Afticle 21 of the Constilution then the Sfale or any other prosecuting agency should not oppose the plea for bail on the ground that the cime committed is senbus. Atticle 21 " 2024 ScC onlino SC 1693 !}. of irrespective the Constitution applies of the nature of the crime' sfill an the petitioner is postulate of over-arching The convict' a accused; not to accused is presumed to add that 20- We may hasten that an criminatiurisprudence be brushed proven guitty cannot until innocent be penal law may stringent the howsoever tightly' aside be. that the 21. We are convinced the manner in which the Court have well as prosecuting agency as a speedy accused to have the of ight the proceeded' been infringed thereby coutd be said to have triat violating Articte 21 of the Constittttion'" 04. On the other hand' learned Additional Public ProsecutorappearingfortheStatefiledcountersubmittingthat thepetitioner-accusedNo.2Sisapolitburomemberofthe banned cPl (Maoists) and operating pan-lndia and that if the petitioner is released on bail, he is likely to re-join the Maoist organization and to go underground as a full time terrorisuextremist and likely to evade to face the trial and that the accused is a dangerous criminal and planning to commit further acts of violence and sabotage and it is possible that he will destroy evidence and will threaten witnesses and will tamper with the evidence and that he was already convicted and sent enced to undergo Rigorous lmprisonment fOf Life and eight years of imprisonment in two cases vide crime No.166 0f 2009 of Chutia, Ranchi District and Crime No'Rccrt /2011/NIA/GAW, respecti,rely. Petition, the Nationar rnvestigating Hence, while praying rearned Additionar pubric relied upon a decision in the anothera wherein Paragraph No.27 to dismiss this prosecutor case of Ajwar it was held by ought not to be Criminal for the state v. Waseem and the Hon,ble Supreme that: "27' rt is equa'y Agency, Court at we, settted that bait once granted, cancetted in a mechanical manner. However' an unreasoned or peruerse order of bait is alway:; open to interference by the supeior Court. tf there are serious attegations even i,F he has not misused such an order can be agarnsl the accused, the bait granted to cancelled by the sarne that has granted the bait. him, Court Bait canalso be revoked by a superior Court if it transpires that the courts O;r^, have ignored the rerevant materiar avairabre on record or not looked into the gravity impact <>n the society of the offence or the resutting in such an 05' This court has carefury submissions and perused the material order.,, considered the rivar available on record. tt is nOt in dispUte that bail was granted to the petitioner bv the learnedSer;sionsJudgebyorderdated30.01.2024. o lzoz+15 s.c.R. a'75'.2oz4 t NSC 438 The 'tt petitionerhadnotfurnishedSuretiesandWaScontinuingin judicialcustody.Theprosecutionfiledanapplicationseeking order dated 22'07 '2024 impugned The of bail' cancellation cancelling bail same Court which the by passed was granted bail is that 06. The settled legal Position from setting stands on a different footing cancellation of bail aside an illegal bail shall be founded order. cancellation of bail on any violation of bailconditions,ormisuseofliberty'orinterferencewith investigationortrial,orlikelihoodofabsconding,oremergence of new adverse circumstances after grant of bail' oT.Further,onceaCourtgrantsbaitandfinally disposes of the bail application, in the absence of statutory provision for review, the Court becomes functus officio' Section 362 0f the code of criminal Procedure bars alteration or review of such final order except for clerical or arithmetical errors. ln the present case, a perusal of the impugned order does not disctose any supervening circumstances arising after grant of bail, or violation of any bail condition by the petitioner, or materiar showing petitioner was 0g' 't misuse of riberty, still in custody for the apprication for mainry to the seriousness petitioner' and the grounds urged by the canceration of bair rerate of the ailegations, the possibility of his matters which were antecedents of the future conduct. These avairabre, or courd at the time of granting prosecution, if aggrieved any new or the proper course open to by the order granting bair, approach th' superior court, but not to seek canceration before the siame court on the are a, have been considered, bair. rn the absence of supervening circumstances, when the want of sureties. is to be noted that prosecution in ffrore particurarry the was to of bair very same set of facts. rt is arso well setfled that bair granted can be set aside by a superior court if it is found that the courts betow material avairabre on record, or have gravity of ther offence or the impact have ignored rerevant faired to consider the of the offence on society, resulting in the grant of bail. 09.1'ltheaboveviewofthematter'theimpugnedorder which passed mechanically be to effect' appears which is in amountstore-appreciationoftheearlierbailorderandoperates ^' - l- rt-? I .\ aSareviewoftheordergrantingbail,whichisimpermissibletn law. Though the allegations nature, are serious against the petitioner itself' cannot gravity of the offence' by been granted' in cancel bail once it has supervening circumstances' in be a ground to the absence of any of the subsequent conduct of new material warranting accused, o[ emergence such cancellation'moreparticularly,cancellationofbailbythevery an granted bail' amounts to who Judge and same Court illegalityandmaterialirregularity.lnviewoftheabove considered opinion the of is court this discussion, learned sessions Judge was that the not justified in invoking powers of criminal under section 439(2) of the code Procedure in the absenceofsuperveningcircumstancesand,therefore,the impugned order is liable to be set aside' 10. Accordingly, this criminal Petition is allowed and the impugned order dated 22.07.2024 passed by the learned lv Additional District & Sessions Judge at Karimnagar, is hereby set aside. However, it is made clear that, if the prosecution is aggrieved by the order granting bail, the proper course open to it is to approach the superior court and liberty is accordingly \ granted to the prosecution to avail such remedy, with law. As ia sequel, pending miscellaneous shall stand closed. in accordance applications, if any, o.'rfP';IaiS{HH ,/ //TRUE COPYII One Fair Copy SECTION OFFICER t< irj.,Xi.t?[3[,:,l SRIDEVI To, 1 The 2. Statir The lV Additionat District e oistrici..cnHo,."_cilj;;ii*,;,;"",j:n j,:1X;,,:L[il,fl ll*Xi,,n,r,. 3. Two CCs to the public prosecrtnr Lr;^r- n_ "- ' r''roecutor' High Hyderabad. Court for loUTi I iii_.BJ:. riri G.'Jabari, Advocate : l#; t,ffi -'-r';vrl, Ad the State of Telangana at [opUc] 6. The Under Sr:cretary, Union v! Rnairs, w-ew t)elhi ' ' "v'| ' of lndia Ministry of Law, Justice and company s A s s o c a 1,."^,1 p,., y, H 's" is h c ":,e nrgn s o u rt ro r t h e uourt fl,,? Buildings 8._ ${::ff,"f"',:? Two CD Copres -! at Hyderabad. ;[i,r'r""'' Kam/pSI i @ , ' HIGH COURT DATED:2010212026 1 ItE S 1', k' oo * ORDER CRLP.No.10193 ot 2024 LOWING THE CRIMINAL PETITION ?6 7. >e zI ? 5 ft8 m26 *

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Telangana HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →