Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 7731/2025
Amit Rathor S/o Bablu Rathor, R/o Moti Nagar, P.S. Chechat,
Dist. Kota (Raj.)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through PP
2.
Rambabu S/o Ramesh, R/o Chandrapura, Chechat, Kota
Rural, Rajasthan.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Sahajveer Baweja, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Amit Punia, PP
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR UPMAN
Order
06/01/2026
1.
Instant Criminal Misc. Petition under Section 528 of BNSS
has been filed on behalf of the petitioner assailing the order dated
11.11.2025, passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Ramganj
Mandi, District Kota whereby the learned Judge without deciding
the application filed by the petitioner under Section 368 of BNSS
in Criminal Case No.35/2025 proceeded with the trial thereby
violating the petitioner’s right to fair trial.
2.
It is contended by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that
the petitioner is innocent and has falsely been implicated in the
matter. The petitioner has been suffering from Bipolar Affective
Disorder (BPAD) and has been of unsound mind since the year
2019. It is submitted that petitioner has been undergoing regular
medical treatment for the said condition. Counsel submits that FIR
(2 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
No.89/2025 came to be registered against the petitioner at Police
Station Ramganj Mandi, District Kota Rural, for offence under
Section 103(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, at the
instance
of
the
complainant/respondent
No.2.
As
per
the
allegations contained in the FIR, the complainant allegedly
received a phone call informing him that his brother, Vishal, had
been attacked by an unknown assailant with a knife, resulting in
his death. It is further submitted that during the course of
investigation, the police arrested the petitioner on 07.03.2025 and
subsequently, filed a charge-sheet against him for offences
punishable under Section 103(1) of the BNS, 2023 and Section
4/25 of the Arms Act. Learned counsel contends that the chargesheet has been filed solely on the basis of circumstantial evidence.
It is submitted that the petitioner had no role whatsoever in the
alleged murder of the deceased, nor was he present at the place
of occurrence at the relevant time and false evidence has been
created to implicate the petitioner in the matter.
3.
It is further contended that on 01.07.2025, the learned trial
Court framed charges against the petitioner and summoned PW-1,
PW-2 and PW-3 for their examination. It is stated that, on account
of the petitioner’s medical condition, an application under Section
368 of the BNSS, 2023, was moved on 28.08.2025 before the
learned trial Court, asserting that the petitioner was medically
unfit to face the trial and, therefore, was required to be dealt with
in accordance with the procedure prescribed under Section 368 of
the BNSS. It is further stated that, upon consideration of the said
application,
the
learned
trial
Court
directed
the
medical
(3 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
examination of the petitioner. However, it is contended that the
learned trial Court neither postponed the trial as contemplated
under Section 368 of the BNSS nor passed any specific order on
the application so filed. Instead, bailable warrants were issued
against PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3, and no separate order-sheet entry
was drawn in respect of the petitioner’s application under Section
368 of the BNSS. It is further contended that thereafter, placing
reliance on the medical opinion dated 30.10.2025 rendered by the
Medical Examination Board, the learned trial Court, without
assigning any reasons and without passing any order on the
application filed under Section 368 of the BNSS, proceeded to
pass the impugned order dated 11.11.2025, whereby the trial was
directed to continue, which is arbitrary and contrary to law.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that, in view of
the mandate contained under Section 368 of the BNSS, 2023, the
learned trial Court was duty bound to conduct a proper inquiry
with
regard
to
the
petitioner’s
mental
soundness
before
proceeding further with the trial. It is submitted that the said
provision is mandatory in nature and requires the Court to record
its judicial
satisfaction regarding
the
accused’s
capacity to
understand the proceedings and to effectively instruct his counsel.
It is further contended that the impugned order suffers from a
complete absence of such judicial satisfaction. According to
learned counsel, the order merely reproduces the medical opinion
without any independent assessment or reasoning as to whether
the petitioner possesses the requisite cognitive ability to face the
trial. It is submitted that no finding has been recorded with
(4 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
respect to the petitioner’s capacity to comprehend the proceedings
or to participate meaningfully in his defence, which is a sine qua
non for continuation of trial under Section 368 of the BNSS.
Learned counsel further submits that the impugned order has
been passed in utter disregard of the mandatory procedure
prescribed under Section 368 of the BNSS, as also in violation of
Article 21 of the Constitution of India and the principles of natural
justice.
It
is
contended
that
continuation
of
the
criminal
proceedings against a person who is medically shown to be
incapable of defending himself would render the trial inherently
unjust and legally unsustainable, thereby warranting immediate
interference by this Court to prevent further prejudice to the
petitioner’s fundamental rights.
5.
Thus, in such circumstances, it is prayed that the trial Judge
may be directed not to proceed with the trial without deciding the
application of the petitioner filed under Section 368 of BNSS.
Counsel relies upon the judgment passed by Kerala High Court on
20.02.2019 in the case of Babu Valleriyan versus State of
Kerala in Crl.M.C. No.7526/2018.
6.
Learned Public Prosecutor opposes the submissions advanced
by the Counsel for the petitioner and prays for dismissal of the
misc. petition.
7.
I have considered the submissions.
8.
For ready reference, provisions of Section 368 of BNSS are
reproduced herein below:
368: Procedure in case of person of unsound
mind tried before Court—
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
(5 of 8)
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
(1) If at the trial of any person before a Magistrate
or Court of Session, it appears to the Magistrate or
Court that such person is of unsound mind and
consequently incapable of making his defence, the
Magistrate or Court shall, in the first instance, try
the fact of such unsoundness of mind and
incapacity, and if the Magistrate or Court, after
considering such medical and other evidence as
may be produced before him or it, is satisfied of
the fact, he or it shall record a finding to that effect
and shall postpone further proceedings in the case.
(2) If during trial, the Magistrate or Court of
Session finds the accused to be of unsound mind,
he or it shall refer such person to a psychiatrist or
clinical psychologist for care and treatment, and
the psychiatrist or clinical psychologist, as the case
may be, shall report to the Magistrate or Court
whether the accused is suffering from unsoundness
of mind:
Provided that if the accused is aggrieved by the
information given by the psychiatrist or clinical
psychologist, as the case may be, to the
Magistrate, he may prefer an appeal before the
Medical Board which shall consist of—
(a) head of psychiatry unit in the nearest
Government hospital; and
(b) a faculty member in psychiatry in the nearest
Government medical college.
(3) If the Magistrate or Court is informed that the
person referred to in sub-section (2) is a person of
unsound mind, the Magistrate or Court shall further
determine whether the unsoundness of mind
renders the accused incapable of entering defence
and if the accused is found so incapable, the
Magistrate or Court shall record a finding to that
effect and shall examine the record of evidence
produced by the prosecution and after hearing the
advocate of the accused but without questioning
the accused, if the Magistrate or Court finds that no
prima facie case is made out against the accused,
he or it shall, instead of postponing the trial,
discharge the accused and deal with him in the
manner provided under section 369:
Provided that if the Magistrate or Court finds that a
prima facie case is made out against the accused in
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
(6 of 8)
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
respect of whom a finding of unsoundness of mind
is arrived at, he shall postpone the trial for such
period, as in the opinion of the psychiatrist or
clinical psychologist, is required for the treatment
of the accused.
(4) If the Magistrate or Court finds that a prima
facie case is made out against the accused and he
is incapable of entering defence by reason of
intellectual disability, he or it shall not hold the trial
and order the accused to be dealt with in
accordance with section 369.
9.
In the case of Babu Valleriyan (supra), Hon’ble Kerala
High Court in para-17 of the judgment has held as under:
17. Coming to the facts of the case, I find that
there were material before the Court in the form of
medical reports which revealed that the accused
was suffered from Paranoid Schizophrenia. The
learned trial Judge did not permit the accused to let
in any evidence to prove the factum of
unsoundness
of
mind.
Neither
was
the
Superintendent nor the treating Doctor examined
as a witness in Court. He did not call upon the
counsel for the accused, who had filed Annexure-1
application, bringing on record the fact of
unsoundness and his incapacity to lead evidence. It
is as if the learned Sessions Judge was toally
oblivious of the provisions of Chapter XXV of the
Code. Even in the report dated 06.09.2018, the
Superintendent of the Mental Health Center had
reported that the petitioner is suffering from
Paranoid Schizophrenia. When medical reports
were placed before the learned Sessions Judge to
the effect that the petitioner is suffering from
Schizophrenia, I am at a loss to understand why it
did not strike his mind that he should adopt the
procedure prescribed in Section 329 of the Code.
The fact that the accused was admitted in the
Mental Hospital and that he was posting the case
for trial. The procedure adopted by the learned
Sessions Judge is illegal and in gross violation of
the provisions of the Code. The learned Sessions
(7 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
Judge ought to have, in the first instance, tried the
fact of such unsoundness and incapacity and he
ought to have proceeded with the trial only if was
satisfied that the accused is of sound mind and is
capable of making his defence.
10.
In the present case, the petitioner has asserted that he is
suffering from Bipolar Affective Disorder, which is stated to be a
serious psychiatric ailment. Upon such assertion, the learned trial
Court called for a medical report regarding the petitioner’s mental
health. In compliance thereof, the Senior Medical Officer, Jail
Dispensary, Central Jail, Kota submitted a medical report dated
09.09.2025, opining that the petitioner’s mental health was stable
and
that
he
was
under
regular
medical
treatment.
Being
dissatisfied with the said report, the learned trial Court again
called for a further medical report. Accordingly, a report dated
03.10.2025 was submitted by the Department of Psychiatry, New
Hospital, Medical College Campus, Kota. The said report, upon
clinical observation, recorded that the petitioner had little or no
control over emotional expression, exhibited cognitive rigidity and
perseveration, and suffered from disturbances in thinking, which
cumulatively resulted in emotional disability. Despite the detailed
nature of the said report, the learned trial Court, vide letter dated
08.10.2025, without assigning any reasons, observed that the
report dated 03.10.2025 was unsatisfactory and directed the
Jailor, Sub Jail, Ramganj Mandi to obtain a fresh medical report.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner was examined by a Medical Board
consisting of three members, which submitted its report dated
30.10.2025. The Medical Board opined that the petitioner was not
(8 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:1427]
[CRLMP-7731/2025]
presently of unsound mind, was not intellectually disabled, and
was capable of withstanding court proceedings. Relying upon the
medical
opinion
dated
30.10.2025,
the
learned
trial
Court
proceeded with the trial. It is contended that this was done
without adjudicating upon the application filed by the petitioner
under Section 368 of the BNSS, 2023.
11.
In the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case, this
Court is of the view that before proceeding further with the trial,
the trial Court ought to have decided the application filed by the
petitioner under Section 368 of BNSS.
12.
Consequently, the Criminal Misc. Petition is disposed of with
the
direction
to
the
learned
trial
Court
to
first
pass
a
speaking/reasoned order on the application filed by the petitioner
under Section 368 of BNSS and then proceed with the trial.
13.
Stay application and misc. application(s), if any, also stand
disposed of.
(ANIL KUMAR UPMAN),J
Manoj Solanki /123
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review