Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
(1) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14897/2021
Saurabh Singh Sanket Son Of Tikam Singh, Aged About 28 Years,
51- Farida Bagh, Uit Colony, Prithvi Raj Nagar, Bhagwan Ganj,
Ajmer ( Rajasthan) 305001
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi 110001
2.
Staff Selection Commission Through Its Chairman, Block No.
12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, 110003
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi- 110003
4.
Presiding Officer/member Of The DME/RME Board of SisAsis/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
at
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan)- 305007.
----Respondents
Connected With
(2) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 12986/2021
Manish Kasotiya Son Of Shri Ishwar Lal, Aged About 27 Years,
Resident Of Karni Colony, Dala Balaji Road, Kuchamancity, District
Nagaur, At Present Resident Of B-86, Tara Nagar, Jhotwara, Jaipur
(Raj.)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Union
Of
India,
Personnel,
Public
Through
Its
Grievances
Secretary,
And
Ministry
Pensions,
Of
Govt.
Secretariat, New Delhi.
2.
Commissioner, Staff Selection Commission, Block No. 12,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-1100003
3.
Staff Selection Commission, Northern Region, Block No. 12,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-1100003 Through Its
Regional Director.
----Respondents
(2 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
(3) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 13250/2021
Sumit Kumar Sehra S/o Shri Suresh Chand Sehra, Aged About 25
Years, Resident Of Village Post Kalyanpura Khurd Kotputali District
Jaipur.
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110003.
2.
Regional Director (NR), Staff Selection Commission, Block
No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110003.
3.
Presiding
Officer,
DME/RME
Board
Of
Sis-ASIs
(GD)
(Male/female) Recruitment, 2019 Through Staff Selection
Commission Centre At GC-1, CRPF, Ajmer (Rajasthan).
----Respondents
(4) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 13699/2021
Vishnu Kumar Yadav S/o Sube Ram Yadav, Aged About 23 Years,
Resident Of Village Kajota, Post Chhilodi, Tehsil Laxmangarh, Alwar,
Rajasthan.
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Union Of India, Through Secretary, Ministry Of Personnel,
Public Grievances And Pensions, Department Of Personnel
And Training Staff Selection Commission Having Its Address
At Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi 110003.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Northern Region, Through
Regional Director, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road,
New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Presiding
Officer,
DME/RME,
Board
Of
SIs-ASIs/GD
(Male/Female), Recruitment - 2019, Through SSC, Centre At
GC-I, CRPF, Ajmer, Rajasthan.
----Respondents
(5) S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 13886/2021
Kishor Parihar Son Of Bhagwana Ram, Aged About 25 Years,
Present Address - Room No. 31, Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Welfare
Society, Jhalana Doongri, Jaipur (Rajasthan)-302004.
----Petitioner
(3 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi -110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(6) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14137/2021
Amit Kumar Bhambhu Son Of Jai Pal Bhambhu, Aged About 24
Years, Present Address - House No. 157, Gangotri Nagar, Near
Triveni Pulia, Jaipur (Rajasthan)- 302018
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi-110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(7) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14389/2021
Vijay Pal Son Of Ved Prakash, Aged About 25 Years, Present
Address House No. 43, Ward No. 05, Lilas (121), Bhiwani
(Haryana) - 127046.
----Petitioner
(4 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(8) S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14390/2021
Ramchandra Nath Siddh Son Of Poos Nath Siddh, Aged About 26
Years, Present Address, Plot No. B-16, Bhagwan Nagar, Todi
Harmada, Jaipur ( Rajasthan) 332013
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of Inida,
North Block, New Delhi 110001
2.
Staff Selection Commission Through Its Chairman, Block No.
12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110003
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi 110003
4.
Presiding Officer/Member of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan)- 305007
----Respondents
(9) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14599/2021
Ashish Dhaka Son Of Ram Lal, Aged About 25 Years, Present
Address- Sonu Boys Pg, 562, Bhagat Singh Marg, Muktanand
Nagar, Durgapura, Jaipur (Rajasthan)- 302018.
----Petitioner
(5 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(10) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14604/2021
Narsingh Bairwa Son Of Mool Chand Bairwa, Aged About 24 Years,
Present Address - Ward No. 5, Garudwasi, Garoodwasi, Jaipur
(Rajasthan) - 303901
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(11) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14838/2021
Rajan Sisodiya Son Of Chandra Prakash Sisodiya, Aged About 24
Years, Address Behind Trd Railway Colony, Bairwa Mohalla, Sawai
Madhopur (Rajasthan) - 322001.
----Petitioner
(6 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(12) S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14895/2021
Jitendra Kumar Meena Son Of Kailash Chand Meena, Aged About 27
Years, Village Rehadiya Post Chandera Tehsil Baswa, District Dausa
( Rajasthan) 303323
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi 110001
2.
Staff Selection Commission Through Its Chairman, Block No.
12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, 110003
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi- 110003
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
( Rajasthan)- 305007
----Respondents
(13) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14896/2021
Ankit Meena Son Of Bhajan Lal Meena, Aged About 26 Years,
Khaspuriya Village Post Gambhira Tehsil Nainwa, Bundi ( Rajasthan)
323801
----Petitioner
(7 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi 110001
2.
Staff Selection Commission Through Its Chairman, Block No.
12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, 110003
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi- 110003
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan)- 305007
----Respondents
(14) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15047/2021
Siddharth Son Of Shiv Charan Meena, Aged About 26 Years,
Address
-
Village
Post
Jagjeevanpur,
Tehsil
Weir,
Bharatpur
(Rajasthan) 321408
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(15) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1005/2022
Mali Ram Yadav Son Of Mool Chand Yadav, Aged About 27 Years,
Address Village Ladakabas, Post Bagawas, Ahiran, Kotputli, Jaipur
(Rajasthan)-303106.
----Petitioner
(8 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Department
Of Home, Ministry Of Home Affairs, Government Of India,
North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2.
Staff Selection Commission, Through Its Chairman, Block
No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110003.
3.
Regional
Director
(NR),
Northern
Region
(NR),
Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi - 110003.
4.
Presiding Officer/Member Of The DME/RME Board Of SIsASIs/GD (Male/Female) Rectt-2019, Through Staff Selection
Commission
(SSC),
Centre
At
GCC-I,
CRPF,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan) - 305007.
----Respondents
(16) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15684/2022
Bhawani Singh S/o Shobha Singh, Aged About 22 Years, R/o Village
Nolkha, Post Muhami, District Ajmer (Raj.).
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Ministry Of Personnel, Public Grievances
And Pensions, Department Of Personnel And Training, Staff
Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi-110003.
2.
The Director General, CRPF (Recruitment Branch), East
Block-07, Level-4, Sector-01, R.K. Puram, New Delhi110066.
3.
The Commandant, CRPF, Ajmer.
----Respondents
(17) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14693/2023
Ashish Kumar S/o Shri Mukesh Kumar, Aged About 22 Years, R/o
Chhattisgarh (Rajasthan), Presently Residing At Village Gorir, Tehsil
Khetri, District Jhunjhunu (Raj.)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Ministry Of Home Affairs, Grah
Mantralaya, North Block, New Delhi Through Its Secretary.
2.
The Director General (CRPF), Recruitment Branch, East
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
(9 of 18)
[CW-14897/2021]
Block-07, Level-4, Sector-01, R.K. Puram, New Delhi.
3.
The Staff Selection Commission, (Department of Personnel
and Training) Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New
Delhi- 11003. Through Authorised Officer.
4.
The Board Of CT/GD (Male/Female) Rectt. 2022, Through
S.S.C. Centre At GC-1, CRPF, Ajmer (Rajasthan) Through
Authorised Officer.
----Respondents
(18) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 289/2024
Amit Kumar S/o Shri Jale Singh, Aged About 25 Years, Resident Of
Dhani Bagariya Ki, Village Sunari, Tehsil Khetari, District Jhunjhunu
Rajasthan- 332716
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Union Of India, Through Home Secretary, Ministry Of
Home Affairs, Ministry Of Home Affairs, North Block New
Delhi 11001
2.
Central Reserve Police Force, Through Its (Estt.) Dte.
Central Reserve Police Force, Block No.- 1, C.G.O. Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110003.
----Respondents
(19) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 670/2024
Ajay Kumar Meena Son Of Shri Ramkishan Meena, Aged About 27
Years, Resident Of Vpo Nangal Lat, Tehsil Todabhim, Karauli,
Rajasthan.
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Union Of India, Through Secretary Ministry Of Home Affairs,
Government Of India, New Delhi.
2.
Director General, Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), East
Block-07, Level-04, Sector-01, R.K. Puram, New Delhi.
3.
The Commandant CRPF, DV/DMR Board Of ASI/ST & HC/M
Rectt.-2022, Centre At Golf Course Road-I, CRPF, Ajmer,
Rajasthan.
----Respondents
(10 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
(20) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1110/2024
Banti Singh Jat Son Of Shri Hari Mohan, Aged About 25 Years,
Resident Of Khedi Chandla, Iraniya, Shree Mahaveer Ji, Karauli,
Rajasthan 322234.
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Union Of India, Through Its Secretary, Ministry Of Home
Affairs, Government Of India North Block, New Delhi.
2.
Director General Of Central Reserve Police Force, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, 110003.
3.
Secretary, Staff Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGOComplex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, 110003.
4.
Commandant (Rectt.), 147 Battalion Presiding Officer Group
Centre I, CRPF, Golf Course Road, Ajmer Rajasthan 305007.
----Respondents
(21) S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1482/2024
Ramveer Son Of Shri Gillo, Aged About 28 Years, Resident Of
Village Bhagora, Post-St Lakhanpur, Tehsil Weir, District Bharatpur
(Raj.)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Central Reserve Police Force, Through Director General,
Directorate General, CRPF, East Block-7, Level-4, Sector-1,
R.K. Puram, New Delhi-110066
2.
Presiding Officer, PST and DV Board Of ASIST and HCMIN,
CRPF, Ajmer.
----Respondents
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Tribhuvan Narayan Singh Advocate
with Mr. Vikash Meena Advocate and
Ms. Kiran Meena.
Mr. Bajrang Sepat Advocate on behalf
of Ms. Komal Kumari Giri Advocate.
Mr. Abhimanyu Yaduvanshi Advocate.
Mr. Heera Lal Gothwal Advocate.
Mr. Akshay Dutt Sharma Advocate.
Mr. Dinesh Yadav Advocate.
(11 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
For Respondents
:
[CW-14897/2021]
Mr. Ashish Kumar Advocate.
Mr. Devesh Yadav Advocate on behalf
of Mr. R.D. Rastogi, Senior Advocate.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND SHARMA
Judgment
12/03/2026
1.
All the aforesaid writ petitions arise out of substantially
identical
factual
matrix,
involving
common
questions
for
consideration, similar grievance and an identical cause of action,
hence, all the writ petitions were analogously heard together. With
the consent of learned counsel for the parties, for the sake of
convenience and to avoid repetition of facts, the present batch of
writ petitions is being decided by this common judgment, treating
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14897/2021 (Saurabh Singh Sanket vs.
The Union of India & Others) as the lead case and the facts
pleaded therein are being taken as the representative facts for
adjudication of the issues involved.
2.
The
facts,
in
brief,
are
that
the
Staff
Selection
Commission issued a notification for recruitment to the posts of
Sub-Inspector in Delhi Police, CAPFs and Assistant Sub-Inspector in
CISF Examination, 2019, pursuant to which the petitioner, being
fully eligible, applied online. The selection process comprised
multiple
stages
including
Paper-I,
Physical
Standard
Test
(PST)/Physical Endurance Test (PET), Paper-II and Detailed Medical
Examination (DME), all of which were mandatory. The petitioner
successfully cleared the written examinations as well as the
physical tests and was consequently shortlisted for the Detailed
Medical Examination. It is further averred that as per the applicable
(12 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
procedure, a candidate declared unfit in DME is entitled to prefer
an appeal for Review Medical Examination (RME) before a Review
Medical Board in terms of Office Memorandum dated 31.05.2021.
3.
It is the case of the petitioners in all the petitions that
upon undergoing DME, they were declared medically unfit on
account of different and multiple deficiencies. Aggrieved thereby,
the petitioners exercised their right to appeal and underwent
Review Medical Examination at GC-I, CRPF, Ajmer, wherein also the
petitioners were again held medical unfit by showing different
reasons than the reasons shown during DME. As a consequence of
being declared medically unfit in both examinations, the petitioners
became ineligible for further consideration in the recruitment
process, despite having cleared all earlier stages.
4.
The reasons assigned for declaring the respective
petitioners medically unfit in the Detailed Medical Examination
(DME) as well as in the Review Medical Examination (RME) vary
from case to case and have been specifically indicated in the
records. For the sake of clarity and ready reference, the same are
being compiled and set out in detail in the following tabular
statement:
Writ
Name of Petitioner
DME
Petition No.
14897/2021
Saurabh Singh Sanket
12986/2021
Manish Kasotiya
1. Squint
2.
Defective
distant
vision
3. DNS (Lt) side
4. Less dental points
1. DNS (RT) side
2. Haemorrhoips
3. Cubitus Varus(Hand)
4. Hyper extension
Deformity of both
elbow Joints(Hands)
5. Varicose Veins of bot
lower limbs(Legs)
RME
1. Squint
DNS
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
(13 of 18)
13250/2021
Sumit Kumar Sehra
13699/2021
Vishnu Kumar Yadav
13886/2021
Kishor Parihar
14137/2021
Amit Kumar Bhambhu
14389/2021
Vijay Pal
14390/2021
Ramchandra Nath Siddh
14599/2021
Ashish Dhaka
14604/2021
Narsingh Bairwa
14838/2021
Rajan Sisodiya
14895/2021
Jitendra Kumar Meena
14896/2021
Ankit Meena
15047/2021
Siddharth
1005/2022
Mali Ram Yadav
15684/2022
Bhawani Singh
14693/2023
Ashish Kumar
289/2024
Amit Kumar
670/2024
Ajay Kumar Meena
[CW-14897/2021]
1. Squint
2. B/L Hydrocele
3. Drooping of Right
shoulder
4. Abdominal Curvature
1.
Tinea
versicolor
(Chronic skin disease)
1. Squint/Ptosis
2. Tremors +
3. Murmur +
1. Overweight by 05 Kg
2. Squint
3. DNS left side
4. Cubitus valgus
1. DOV R+ 6/12
2. Cubitus Valgus
1. Tattoo Mark on right
forearm
2. Cubitus Valgus
1. Cubitus valgus
1. Tinea versicolor
2. Chronic skin disease
1. Cubitus Valgus
deformity right elbow
(carrying angle 20
degree)
1. Squint
2. Defectice distance
vision
3. Obstructive DNS Lt.
side
1. Squint
2. Anal Fissure
3. Cubitus Varus
4. Tremors+
1. Squint
2. Ptosis
3. DNS(Lt) side
4. Cubitus Varus
5. Varicose veins of
both lower limbs
1. squint
2. Severe hypertrophy
of tonsillar glands
3. DNS (Lt) side
4. Hemorrhoids
5. Cubitus varus
1. Tattoo mark on rt.
forearm
1.
defective
distant
vision b/c eyes
2. knock knees
3. b/c ins valgum
4. Hearing b/c ear
1. Hemorrhoids
2. Vitiligo over perpuce
1.
Defective
vision 6/12 be
2. hypertension
distant
1. Ptosis
eye)
2. C Squint
(Left
1. Skin
disease
1. Squint
fungal
1. Cubitus Valgus
1. Cubitus Valgus
1. Tattoo Scar
Mark
2. Cubitus Valgus
1. Cubitus valgus
a/w
abnormality
of
left
elbow joint
1.
Pityriasis
versicolor
1. Cubitus Valgus
(Rt) side
1.
Obstructive
DNS Lt. side
1. Squint (Le)
1. Cubitus Varus
2. Squint
3. Ptosis
1. Squint
2. b/l tonsllar
hypertrophy
1. tattoo mark on
rt. forearm
1.
defective
distant
vision
1. Genital vitiligo
(on prepuce)
dermatologist
opinion
taken
1.
Defective
distant
vision 6/9 be
(14 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
1110/2024
Banti Singh Jat
1. Anal fissure
1482/2024
Ramveer
1. Tattoo on Right
Forearm
5.
1. Fissure in ano
o/e
fissure
present at 6
O’clock position.
1. Recent surgical
procedure
for
removal of tattoo
on right forearm
The petitioner in S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14897/2021
has further pleaded that subsequent to his rejection, he got himself
medically examined at Sawai Man Singh Hospital, Jaipur, which is a
reputed Government Medical Hospital, where, upon examination by
a specialist in the Department of Ophthalmology, it was opined that
the petitioner did not suffer from squint and was medically fit for
the post in question. The petitioner has also relied upon opinions of
other specialists, who similarly found no evidence of squint. It is
contended that despite such contrary medical opinions, the
respondents proceeded to declare the result and scheduled
document verification, thereby excluding the petitioner from further
participation.
Similar
contentions
have
been
raised
by
the
petitioners in other connected writ petitions.
6.
Being aggrieved, the petitioners have approached this
Court challenging the memorandum of unfitness issued in DME and
the result of RME. Learned Counsels for the petitioners argued that
action of the respondents is arbitrary, unjustified and contrary to
the medical evidence. It is asserted that there exists a clear
variance between the findings of the respondents’ medical boards
and those of independent government specialists and that no
detailed clinical findings or confirmatory diagnostic reports were
supplied to substantiate the conclusion of unfitness.
(15 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
7.
[CW-14897/2021]
In reply to the writ petition, the respondents have
opposed the writ petitions and justified the action of declaring the
petitioners medically unfit, contending that the same has been
done strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions of the
recruitment
advertisement
issued
by
the
Staff
Selection
Commission. It is submitted that Clause 11.7 of the advertisement
clearly provides the procedure for medical examination, including
Detailed
Medical
Examination
(DME)
and
Review
Medical
Examination (RME) and categorically stipulates that the decision of
the Review Medical Board shall be final, with no further provision
for appeal or re-examination. Therefore, the petitioners cannot
seek constitution of another Medical Board, as the same would be
contrary to the prescribed selection procedure and would amount
to seeking a differential treatment in violation of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
8.
Learned counsels for the respondents submitted that the
petitioners participated in the entire selection process with full
knowledge of the applicable rules and procedure, including the
finality attached to the findings of the Review Medical Board. Both
the DME and RME were conducted by duly constituted Medical
Boards in accordance with the guidelines issued by the Ministry of
Home Affairs and there has been no violation of any rule,
procedure, or guideline. The petitioner was examined at both
stages and was declared unfit on medical grounds and no mala
fides have been alleged against the members of the Medical
Boards. In such circumstances, the expert opinion rendered by
specialised medical authorities cannot be substituted or interfered
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
(16 of 18)
[CW-14897/2021]
with merely on the basis of contrary opinions obtained from civil
doctors or hospitals. It is emphasised that the medical standards
prescribed for uniformed services such as CAPFs are significantly
higher and more stringent than those applicable to civil posts,
keeping in view the nature of duties performed under extreme
conditions and, therefore, medical certificates issued by civil
hospitals cannot override the findings of the specialised Medical
Boards constituted for recruitment.
9.
Heard learned counsels of the parties and carefully
examined the record.
10.
The material placed on record, as noticed hereinabove,
unequivocally demonstrates that there exists an admitted and
substantial variation between the findings recorded in the Detailed
Medical Examination (DME) and the Review Medical Examination
(RME), inasmuch as each of the reports assigns different and at
times inconsistent reasons for declaring the petitioners medically
unfit. This inconsistency is further compounded by the reports
issued by the civil hospitals, which prima facie cast a cloud of
doubt over the correctness and reliability of the conclusions drawn
in the DME and RME.
11.
It is true that the respondents have sought to justify the
said divergence by contending that the standards and degree of
medical fitness prescribed for personnel of the Central Armed Police
Forces
(CAPFs) are considerably more stringent than those
applicable to ordinary civil services and, therefore, the opinion
rendered by civil hospitals cannot override or prevail upon the
specialised assessment undertaken in the DME and RME.
(17 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
12.
[CW-14897/2021]
Ordinarily, this Court would exercise restraint and would
be slow in interfering with expert medical opinions, particularly
those rendered by duly constituted Review Medical Boards.
However, the peculiar facts of the present cases, marked by
evident inconsistencies and the resulting element of uncertainty,
persuade this Court to adopt a course that would dispel any
lingering doubt and ensure fairness to all parties concerned. In that
view of the matter, this Court considers it just, proper and in the
interest of justice to direct that the petitioners be subjected to a
fresh
and
comprehensive
medical
examination
by
a
duly
constituted Medical Board at the Army Hospital (Research &
Referral), New Delhi, the standards of which are indisputably at par
with, if not more rigorous than, those prescribed for CAPFs. The
opinion so rendered by the said Medical Board shall be treated as
final, conclusive and binding upon both the petitioners and the
respondents.
13.
Consequently, these writ petitions stand disposed of with
a direction to the respondents to approach the competent authority
at Army Hospital (R&R), New Delhi along with opinions of DME and
RME of the respective petitioners for constitution of separate
Medical Boards in respect of each petitioner, comprising at least
three specialised Medical Officers relevant to the alleged medical
unfitness. Upon constitution of such Boards, the respondents shall
ensure that intimation is furnished to the respective petitioners at
least seven days in advance, specifying the date, time and place of
examination.
The
Medical
Board
shall
thereafter
conduct
a
thorough and detailed examination of each petitioner and prepare
(18 of 18)
[2026:RJ-JP:11697]
[CW-14897/2021]
an exhaustive report in duplicate, one copy to be supplied to the
respondents and the other to the concerned petitioner. The findings
of the said Medical Board shall bind both parties and in the event,
the report is favourable to any petitioner, the respondents shall
proceed to consider such petitioner for further steps in the
selection
process
and
if
otherwise
found
eligible,
extend
appointment in accordance with law. The entire exercise, as
directed hereinabove, shall be completed within a period of fortyfive days from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment.
14.
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
15.
Office is directed to place a copy of this judgment on
record of each connected writ petition.
(ANAND SHARMA),J
MANOJ NARWANI /1 to 17 & 19 to 22.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review