Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:10720-DB
NAFR
Digitally signed
by INDRAJEET
INDRAJEET SAHU
Date:
SAHU
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
2026.03.03
10:45:53 +0530
WA No. 159 of 2026
1 - Amit Kumar Rathore S/o Late Shri Purushottam Lal Rathore Aged About
24 Years R/o Near Shri Moti Netralaya, Behind Keshav Furniture, I.B. Rest
House Road, Nahar Par, Janjgir, Distt. Janjgir Champa, Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Water Resource Department,
Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur, Distt. Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Managing Director Chhattisgarh Infrastructure Development Corporation,
Chhattisgarh Rajya Kaushal Vikas Pradhikaran Bhawan, Second Floor, Old
P.H.Q. Campus, Near Raj Bhawan, Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant
For State
For Respondent No.2
:
:
:
Shri Anniruddha Shrivastava, Advocate.
Shri Praveen Das, Addl.Advocate General.
Shri Rajeev Shrivastava, Sr. Advocate
along with Ms. Sakshi Chhabra, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ramesh Sinha, CJ
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Judgment on Board
02.03.2026
Per, Ramesh Sinha, CJ.
1. Heard the counsel for the parties on I.A. No.01/2025, which is an
application for condonation of delay of 87 days in filing the instant
appeal.
2. For the reasons mentioned in the application I.A. No.01/2025 i.e.
application for condonation of delay, the same is allowed and delay is
condoned. With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the
appeal is heard finally.
3. The appellant has filed this writ appeal against the order dated
25.07.2025, passed by the learned Single Judge in Review Petition No.
176/2025 (Managing Director Chhattisgarh Infrastructure Development
Corporation Vs. Amit Kumar Rathore and Another), whereby the
learned Single Judge has allowed the review petition and recalled the
order dated 06.05.2025 passed in WPS No. 3162/2025 preferred by
the present appellant / petitioner thereby restoring the writ petition to its
original number.
4. Brief facts of the case are that the father of the Appellant/Petitioner was
initially an employee of the dissolved Madhya Pradesh State Road
Transport Corporation (MPSRTC) and, after reorganization of the
State, his services were absorbed in the Chhattisgarh Infrastructure
Development Corporation (CIDC) while he was posted on deputation
as Conductor in the office of Superintendent of Police, Janjgir. He
unfortunately
died
Appellant/Petitioner
in
harness
applied
for
on
24/12/2020,
compassionate
thereafter
the
appointment
on
20.01.2021 along with requisite documents, however, despite repeated
representations and correspondence made by the Collector with the
General Administration Department seeking clarification in view of
policy changes, no final decision was communicated to him.
Subsequently, policy developments including order dated 13/12/2022
permitting compassionate appointment to dependents of employees of
dissolved State Transport Corporation on suitable Class-III/Class-IV
posts and circular dated 06/10/2023 withdrawing the earlier restriction
to Shiksha Karmi Grade-III posts were issued, however, the claim of
the Appellant/Petitioner remained unattended. Aggrieved, he preferred
W.P.(S) No. 3162/2025, wherein by order dated 06/05/2025 the learned
Single Bench directed consideration of his claim within 90 days, but in
Review Petition No. 176/2025 the said order was recalled on
25/07/2025 at the instance of CIDC, allegedly on the ground that his
claim had already been rejected though no such rejection order was
ever communicated to him or produced earlier. It is further the case of
the Appellant/Petitioner that similarly situated dependents have been
granted consideration pursuant to Court orders, and being aggrieved
by the recall of the favourable order and continued non-consideration
of his claim for compassionate appointment, he has preferred the
present appeal.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned Single
Judge has gravely erred both in law and on facts in allowing the
Review Petition and recalling the order dated 06.05.2025, without
appreciating that the appellant had, since 2021, submitted repeated
representations
along
with
all
requisite
documents
seeking
compassionate appointment, yet no reasoned decision was ever
communicated to him by the authorities. It is contended that the
original order in W.P.(S) No. 3162/2025 merely directed consideration
of his claim and did not issue any specific adverse direction against
respondent No. 02, and therefore the review at its instance was wholly
misconceived. The learned Single Judge, it is urged, failed to consider
that similarly situated dependents have been granted consideration
pursuant to court directions and also overlooked the subsequent policy
developments, particularly the order dated 13/12/2022 and circular
dated 06/10/2023, whereby compassionate appointment to dependents
of employees of the dissolved MPSRTC absorbed in CIDC was
permitted on equivalent Class-III/Class-IV posts and the earlier
restriction to Shiksha Karmi Grade-III under circular dated 19/07/2011
stood withdrawn. Reliance is placed on the judgment in Kuldeep Singh
Thakur v. State of Chhattisgarh and Others in WPS No. 995/2020 to
contend that once the post of Shiksha Karmi Grade-III ceased to exist
and the 2011 circular was recalled, the authorities were bound to
consider the claim under prevailing Instructions, 2013. It is further
argued that the humanitarian object of compassionate appointment—
providing immediate financial relief to the bereaved family of a
deceased employee dying in harness has been completely ignored.
The alleged rejection order was never communicated nor produced
during the pendency of the writ petition and could not have been
introduced at the stage of review, as review jurisdiction is limited and
cannot be exercised as an appeal in disguise, as held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Perry Kansagra v. Smriti Madan Kansagra reported
in (2019) 20 SCC 753 and Lily Thomas v. Union of India reported in
(2000) 6 SCC 224. Hence, the impugned order passed in review is
unsustainable and liable to be set aside.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent / CIDC opposes the
submissions made by the learned counsel for the appellant and
submits that the learned Single Judge, after considering all the aspects
of the matter has rightly allowed the review petition filed by the writ
petitioner / respondent No.2 herein, in which no interference is called
for.
7. Learned counsel for the respondent / State submits that he is a formal
party in the appeal, however, supports the judgment passed by the
learned Single Judge.
8. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned order and other documents appended with the writ appeal.
9. From perusal of the impugned order, it transpires that the learned
Single Judge allowed the review petition preferred by the writ petitioner
/ respondent No.2 herein observing as follows:
“6. From bare perusal, it is manifest that though while hearing the
writ petitions under review the CIDC was properly represented on
advance copy, however, due to lack of proper instructions he
could not place anything. However, the writ petitions were
disposed off directing the Chief Secretary to the State
Government to look into the grievance and claim of the writ
petitioner afresh.
7. Be that as it may, now the review petitioner bringing several
facts and orders/ circular issued by the authorities with regard to
the policy framed regarding grant of compassionate appointment
preferred the present review petition, which was not brought
before this court at the time of hearing of writ petitions, hence, all
the review petitions are allowed.
8. Consequently, the orders passed in WPS No. 2555 of 2025,
3302 of 2025, 2890 of 2025 and 3162 of 2025 dated 16.04.2025,
08.05.2025, 29.04.2025 and 06.05.2025, respectively are hereby
recalled and the said writ petitions are restored to their original
numbers.”
10. On a pointed query being made to learned counsel for respondent No.2
– Chhattisgarh Infrastructure Development Corporation (CIDC) as to
why proper instructions were not furnished at the time of hearing of the
review petition despite the Corporation being duly represented, the
learned Senior Advocate appearing on its behalf submitted that since
appearance had been entered on advance copy, complete instructions
were not readily available and, therefore, the Court could not be
effectively assisted.
11. We are unable to accept the said explanation. Merely because
appearance was entered on advance copy cannot absolve the
respondent-Corporation of its obligation to properly assist the Court. It
was incumbent upon the counsel either to ensure that requisite
instructions were obtained or to seek appropriate time from the Court
for that purpose. However, no such request was made when the review
petition was taken up for hearing.
12. Learned counsel for respondent No.2 further submitted that, as
observed by the learned Single Judge in the impugned order passed in
the review petition, the appellant had suppressed material facts
relevant to the case.
13. In response, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that no facts
were suppressed. A perusal of the impugned order would reveals that
the alleged rejection of earlier representation was never communicated
to him which cannot be construed as suppression of facts by the
appellant.
14. Having considered the rival submissions and perused the impugned
order, we are not inclined to interfere with the order passed by the
learned Single Judge in exercise of review jurisdiction. The recall of the
earlier order and restoration of the writ petition to its original number
cannot be said to be wholly without jurisdiction so as to warrant
interference in this intra-court appeal.
15. However, we find substance in the grievance of the appellant that there
was lack of proper assistance on behalf of respondent No.2 – CIDC at
the stage of hearing of the writ petition. Once the authority was
represented through its counsel before the writ Court, it was incumbent
upon it to fully and effectively assist the Writ Court. The failure to do so
has resulted in unnecessary prolongation of proceedings and
avoidable hardship to the appellant by filing this writ appeal.
16. It is further observed that the conduct of respondent No.2 – CIDC, in
failing to place proper instructions and relevant materials before the
learned Single Judge at the time of hearing of the writ petition, has not
only reflected a lack of due diligence but has also caused
inconvenience to the learned Single Judge who has passed the order
dated 06.05.2025 in the writ petition and thereafter, had to recall its
own order in the review petition vide order dated 25.07.2025. A litigant,
particularly a statutory Corporation like CIDC, is expected to act with
responsibility and fairness while assisting the Court. The inability of its
counsel to provide adequate instructions, without even seeking
adjournment or time to obtain the same, led to an incomplete and
unsatisfactory assistance to the Court, thereby compelling the learned
Single Judge to proceed in circumstances where the necessary clarity
from the respondent-Corporation was lacking. Such casual approach
on the part of respondent No.2 undermines the sanctity of judicial
proceedings and cannot be countenanced.
17. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, while upholding the
order dated 25.07.2025 passed in Review Petition No.176/2025, we
deem it appropriate to saddle respondent No.2 with costs for the
manner in which the matter has been conducted before the writ Court.
18. Though we were inclined to impose costs of Rs. 1,00,000/- in view of
the conduct of respondent No.2 – CIDC, however, upon repeated and
earnest requests made by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on
its behalf, we deem it appropriate that the respondent No.2 – CIDC
shall pay cost of Rs.50,000/- to the appellant within a period of three
weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order, failing
which the said amount shall be recovered as arrears of land revenue
by the competent authority and shall be paid to the petitioner, at the
earliest.
19. The appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review