Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010181502019
2026:GAU-AS:8665
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
WP (C) NO. 6207 OF 2019
Md. Amir Ali aged about 62 years
S/o.- Md. Akkash Ali,
R/o.- Karchuwabori.
P.S.- Jagiroad
District- Morigaon, Assam
……..Petitioner
-Versus1.
The Union of India, represented by the Secretary to
the Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, Tilok
Marg, New Delhi-1.
2.
The State of Assam, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Home Department, Dispur, Guwahati-6.
3.
The Deputy Commissioner, Morigaon, P.O. & District-Morigaon, Assam,
PIN-782105.
4.
The Superintendent of Police (B), Morigaon, P.O. & District-Morigaon,
Assam, PIN- 782105.
5.
The Election Commissioner of India, New Delhi-1.
6.
The State Co-Ordinator NRC, Assam Bhangagarh, Guwahati-5.
::BEFORE ::
……..Respondents
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
Page No.# 2/13
For the Petitioner
:Mr. B. Islam, Adv.
For the Respondents
:Ms. A. Verma, SC, Home Deptt.
Mr. G. Sarma, SC, NRC
Mr. P. Sarma, GA, Assam
Mr. P. Sarma, GA, Assam
Mr. A. I. Ali, SC, ECI
Date of Hearing
: 09.06.2026
Date of Judgment
: 15.06.2026
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Shamima Jahan, J.)
1.
Heard Mr. B. Islam, the learned counsel for the petitioner Also heard Ms.
A. Verma, the learned Standing Counsel, Home Deptt.; Shri G. Sarma, the
learned Standing Counsel, NRC; Shri P. Sarma, the learned Government
Advocate, Assam and Shri A. I. Ali, learned Standing Counsel, ECI.
2.
By this application filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner has sought for invoking the extraordinary power under the said Article
for setting aside the opinion rendered by the Foreigner’s Tribunal No. 1 st,
Morigaon, Assam in Case No. F.T. (C) 333/2006, corresponding to Police
Reference I.M.(D)T. Case No. 555, Dated: 04.03.1986, whereby the petitioner
was declared as a foreigner post 1971, stream.
3.
Facts: The petitioner, in order to establish that, he is not a foreigner and
he is an Indian citizen had relied on the Voters List of 1966, by which it was
shown that the father of the petitioner, namely, Akkash Ali, appeared as a voter
and that, the mother of the petitioner, namely, Jamiran Nessa also appeared as
Page No.# 3/13
a voter in the said list. In the said voter list, the projected father of the
petitioner was at Serial No. 43 and the projected mother of the petitioner was at
Serial No. 37 and the place of residence was shown at village- Balimukh, MozuaPakariya, Police Station- Morigaon, in the District of Nagaon.
4.
In the subsequent Voters List, i.e. the Voters List of 1970, the name of
the petitioner’s projected father as well as the projected mother was shown at
Serial. No. 43 & Serial. No. 37 respectively, from the same place. Thereafter, the
petitioner placed the Voter’s List of 1985, wherein, the name of the petitioner
appeared along with his projected father and projected mother and with his
wife. However, in the said list, it was shown that the petitioner and his family
members resided at a different place, i.e., village-Karchuwabori, Mouza-Manaha,
P.S.- Jagiroad in the District of Nagaon. The petitioner had thereafter, placed the
Voter’s List of 1989, by which, the same position continued, i.e, his name
appeared along with his projected father and mother also showing his wife as a
voter therein.
5.
Furthermore, the petitioner has also placed the Voters List of 2005, in
which the name of the petitioner is shown along with his parents as well as
brothers and his wife. The place shown in the said list was the second place
mentioned in the Voters Lists of 1985 and 1989. Similar is the position with
regard to Voters List of 2011, which the petitioner had relied on, as well as
Voters List of 2017. However, in the said 2017 Voters List the name of the
petitioner was shown with his projected parents as well as his wife and his
younger brother, namely, Riaj Uddin.
6.
The petitioner, to establish his link with his projected father and projected
Page No.# 4/13
mother had relied on the certificate issued by the Gaon Burah of VillageBilimara, Karchuwabori, Mouza-Manaha, in the District of Morigaon, Assam,
wherein, it was stated that the petitioner being the son of Akkash Ali and
Jamiran Nessa is known to him. The petitioner has also relied on the certificate
issued by the same Gaon Burah, by which it was certified that Sri Riaj Uddin is
the son of the petitioner and that they are known to him. Thereafter, the
petitioner relied on two certificates issued by the president of Jhargaon Gaon
Panchayat and that one of them was in connection with the fact that the
petitioner being the son of Akkash Ali is the inhabitant of Jhargaon, MouzaManaha and the other was in connection with the fact that Riyaj Uddin, son of
the petitioner was also the inhabitant of the said locality.
7.
Apart for the said documents, the petitioner had filed his written
statement dated 15.12.2006, stating inter alia that his father was living at
village-Karchuwabori, under Police Station-Jagiroad and that, he is the son of
Akkash Ali and he was born in the said village. He further stated that his father’s
name appeared in the Voters List of 1965, vide Serial. No. 38 under Bokani (S.C)
LAC and that, his name appeared in the Voters List of 1989 as well as in the
Voters List of 2005 and also that he had one son and one daughter. The
petitioner, thereafter, had filed an additional written statement on 08.06.2018,
by which, he stated that the Enquiry of the Superintendent of Police, (Border),
Morigaon was based on false information, and that, he is the son of Akkash Ali
and that his family was original resident of Village Balimukh, P.S.-Morigaon, in
the District of Nagaon, and that, due to financial constraints his family shifted to
the nearby village of Karchuwabori. He reiterated the statements made in the
first written statement to the effect that his father was in the Voters List of
1966, as well as in 1970. He also stated that petitioner was born and brought
Page No.# 5/13
up at Balimukh and that, he casted his vote in 2005 with his parents at
Karchuwabori. He also stated that, thereafter, he had regularly voted as could
be seen from the subsequent voters list. He, as such, stated that the authority
did not verify the documents placed by him and the case was decided against
him mechanically.
8.
The petitioner has also submitted that he filed his evidence on affidavit
before the learned tribunal and in the said affidavit, he had reiterated, the
statements made by him in his two written statements.
9.
Submissions: Mr. B. Islam, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the father and mother of the petitioner appeared in the Voters
Lists of 1966 and 1970 from the same place, i.e., village-Balimukh, MouzaPakaria, in the District of Nagaon, and that, in the Voters List of 1985, the name
of the petitioner appeared along with his parents and also in the subsequent
Voters Lists of 1989, 2005, 2011 as well as 2017. The learned counsel submitted
that although, initially the parents of the petitioner was from a different place
but due to financial problems, the petitioner and his family shifted to
Karchuabori and therefore, in the subsequent voters list the names appeared
from the said place. He however, fairly, submitted that the certificates issued by
the Gaon Burah as well as the President of Gaon Panchayat, were not proved in
accordance with law.
10.
He further, tired to establish the linkage of the petitioner with his parents
by showing the aforesaid Voters Lists of 1966 and 1970. To substantiate his
argument, he placed a judgment delivered by this court in “Abdul Matali @
Mataleb Vs. Union of India” , reported 2015 (2) GLT 617; by which it was
Page No.# 6/13
held that the case of the proceedee cannot be rejected on the ground of some
anomalies regarding the names and ages of the proceedee and his parents.
11. On the other hand, Ms. A. Verma, the learned Standing Counsel for the FT
& Border Matters, submitted that age discrepancy is writ large, not in one voters
list but in a number of them. She submitted that the petitioner did not place
voters list before 1985, although, he was eligible to vote much before the said
year.
12.
She further stated that, in the instant case the IMDT reference was made
in the year 1986 and the case was registered in the year 2006 and the opinion
was given in the year 2019. She as such submitted that the petitioner could not
have voted post 1986, as has been shown in the instant case. She also
submitted that the petitioner did not cull out the names of other family
members of his projected parents. She relied on a judgment of this court
delivered in “Basiron Bibi Vs. Union of India” reported in (2018) (1) GLT
372;, by which, this court had distinguished the judgment passed in “Abdul
Matali” (Supra) placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner.
13. Analysis and Findings: At the outset, this court would like to examine
the voter’s list submitted by the petitioner. The first voters list placed by the
petitioner was the Voters List of 1966, wherein, the petitioner has stated that
the name of his projected father, namely, Akkash Ali was at Sl. No. 43 and his
projected mother was at Serial. No. 37 and the place of residence mentioned in
the said voters list was village-Balimukh, Mouza-Pakaria in the District of
Nagaon. In the subsequent voters list, i.e., Voters List of 1970, the projected
father and the projected mother of the petitioner appeared as voters at Serial.
Page No.# 7/13
No.43 and Serial. No. 37, respectively from the same place. However, it is seen
that the age mentioned in the said voters list in respect of the projected father
and projected mother of the petitioner was same, i.e., the projected father was
35 years of age and projected mother was 22 years of age in both the voters
list.
14.
However, after a gap of 15 years, the petitioner placed a Voters List of
1985, by which, it was shown that the name of the petitioner appeared with his
projected parents along with his wife and in the said voters list, the age of the
said petitioner was stated to be 35 years. The place of residence of the
petitioner along with his projected parents and his wife was stated to be villageKarchuwabori, Mouza-Manaha, in the District of Nagaon. The house number
from where, his projected parents appeared as voters was also different. It was
House No. 9, whereas, in 1985 Voters List, it was House No. 143. Thereafter, in
the Voters List of 1989, the age of the petitioner was shown as 30 years and his
name was shown along with his projected parents and his wife in the said
voters list from the new place.
15.
The name of the projected mother in the Voters List of 1989, was also
spelt differently as Jafiran, whereas, in the earlier voters list, the name of the
projected mother was Jamiran. It is unknown, as to why, the petitioner was
shown to be of a lesser age in 1989 voters list then shown in 1985 voters list.
Moreover, the age of the petitioner, by calculating his age as shown in the
affidavit appended in the instant writ petition would be in 1957 and by
considering the said year of birth, the petitioner becomes eligible to vote in the
year 1977/1978, but the petitioner has not produced the voters list before 1985,
where his name should have been included in the erstwhile voters list.
Page No.# 8/13
Furthermore, in the Voters List of 2005, it is shown that the petitioner had a
brother namely, Momin Ali, who was shown to be of 49 years of age as on 2005.
However, the name of Momin Ali did not find place in the earlier voters list. In
the said list, another brother of the petitioner was also mentioned, namely,
Tamir Ali, whose age was shown to be 35 years but again, his name was not
shown in any of the previous voters list. In 2011 Voters List, however, the same
position continued but in the subsequent voters list of 2017, the name of the
brothers namely, Momin Ali and Tamir Ali did not find place in the same. The
said discrepancies were noticed in the said voters list placed by the petitioner.
16.
The petitioner had relied on the certificate issued by the Gaon Burah as
well as by the president of Gaon Panchayat but the said certificates were not
proved by calling the authorities, who had issued the same. It is no res integra
that production of documents is not sufficient proof to the link of the proceedee
with his family members, unless the author of the said documents was
examined and the said documents stand proved. In the instant case, there is
only one DW and the petitioner himself had adduced his evidence in the form of
the said defense witness.
17.
Apart from the discrepancies noted in the voters list, there appear other
discrepancies in the instant case also. In the first written statement filed by the
petitioner on 15.12.2006, he stated that his father, namely, Akkash Ali was living
in the village, i.e. Karchuwabori and that, he was born and brought up in the
said village but in the subsequent written statement, he stated that the family of
the petitioner was the original resident of Village-Balimukh, Mouza-Pakaria in
the District of Nagaon and that they shifted to the other village called
Karchuabori. He further stated in the second written statement that he was born
Page No.# 9/13
and bought up at Balimukh in the District of Nagaon. It is also seen from the
Voters Lists of 1966 and 1970, that the projected parents of the petitioner were
from the Village-Balimukh, Mouza-Pakaria in the District of Nagaon. Similarly, in
his statement before the learned Tribunal, he stated that he was born and
brought up in village Balimukh, in the District of Nagaon and that, his family had
shifted to the other village of Karchuabori.
18.
In the case of “Sirajuddin Hoque Vs. State of Assam” reported in
(2019) 5 SCC 534; the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that, one single
discrepancy in the name of the grandfather of the proceedee cannot be
considered as fatal, in view of no discrepancies with regard to other names and
facts. The relevant portion is quoted herein below:
“3. We have heard learned Counsel for both sides
extensively and have gone through the documents
produced by the Appellant ourselves. On a perusal of the
same, we find that a number of documents have been
relied upon by the Appellant starting with a voters' list of
his grandfather Kematullah in village Sotobashjani. There
is no doubt that the great grandfather's name Amtullah
appears as Amtullah throughout the document. Equally,
there is no doubt about the father's name which appears
as Hakim Ali throughout. The only discrepancy found is
that in some of the documents Kefatullah later becomes
Kematullah. However, what is important to note is that
his father's name Amtullah continues as Amtullah and the
other family members associated continued as such. Also
produced are NRC Registration details of the year 1971 of
the grandfather who is noted to be Kefatullah in this
Page No.# 10/13
document. Other voters lists are then produced where the
letter F becomes the letter M with other family names
remaining the same. In fact, the Appellant has himself
produced a document of 1981 from the Income Tax
Department giving his Permanent Account Number. Apart
from these documents, certain other later documents
have also been produced including photo identity cards
issued by the Election Commission of India and identity
cards issued to his brother including voters lists in which
the Appellant's name appears.”
19. In the instant case, there is not one discrepancy that can be seen but
there are many discrepancies both in the voters list as well as in the statements
of the petitioner. In the voters list as has been stated above, the place from
where the projected parents of the petitioner voted in the years 1966 and 1970
was different along with the house nos. and in the subsequent voters list, both
were different. Another discrepancy was seen in the said Voters Lists of 1966
and 1970, to the effect that the age of the projected parents of the petitioner
remained the same both in 1966 and 1970. Although the petitioner stated that,
due to financial constraints his family shifted to the new place but the said fact
was not stated in his first written statement. Further, there were no voters list
from the year 1970 to 1985, showing the status of the petitioner as well as his
projected parents as electors or as voters and after a gap of 15 years, the
petitioner had given the voters list, showing his name along with his projected
parents from a different village and from a different house no. and the age
projected in respect of the petitioner was 35 years, which shows that his name
should have been with his projected parents before the said list.
Page No.# 11/13
20.
Thereafter, the age discrepancy was again seen in the Voters List of 1989,
wherein, the age of the petitioner was shown to be of a lesser age, i.e., 30
years. Further, in the subsequent voters list, the brothers of the petitioner were
shown to be the voters but then again, their name disappeared in the rest of
the voters list. The name of the projected mother of the petitioner had also
undergone changes in the said voters list as stated above.
21. There appears no documents apart from the voters list to established the
link of the petitioner with his family members whose name should appear before
the cut of date of 25.03.1971. Further, it is seen in the Voters Lists of 1966 and
1970, that apart from the names of the projected parents of the petitioner,
there were other members of the family of the parent of the petitioner.
However, the petitioner had not mentioned the relation of the said members
with him in any of his statements. He has rather not mentioned the names of
his siblings as well as other family members in his statements. He had only
stated about his daughter and son in the same. It is a trite law that in order to
establish linkage, documentary evidence is required and in the instant case, the
documentary evidences produced by the petitioner have many discrepancies
questioning its authenticity and few documents were not even proved.
22. Further, as the learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the judgment of
“Abdul Matali” (Supra) and as pointed out by the learned counsel for the FT
Matters, that the said judgment has been distinguished, this court states here
that in the said judgment of “ Basiron Bibi”(Supra), this court had held that
discrepancies in the voters list done by the officials of the Election Commission
cannot be considered in favour of the proceedee. It was further held that, the
proceedee cannot not insist that only that portion of the voters list, which are in
Page No.# 12/13
his or her favour should be accepted and those portions going against his or her
should be over looked.
23.
Further, in “Nur Begum Vs. Union of India” reported in (2020)
Volume 3 GLT 347; this court had held as follows:
“6. The statement of D.W. 2 i.e. Jahurun Begum, who
claimed to be the mother of the petitioner, cannot be
relied upon in the absence of any documents showing her
relationship, either to the projected grandfather, father or
to the petitioner herself. Oral testimony of D.W. 2 alone,
sans any documentary support, cannot be treated as
sufficient to prove linkage or help the cause of the
petitioner. Surprisingly, the petitioner failed to produce a
single voter list in her name even until the age of 50
years. We would reiterate that in a proceeding under the
Foreigners Act, 1946 and the Foreigners (Tribunals)
Order, 1964 the evidentiary value of oral testimony,
without support of documentary evidence, is wholly
insignificant.
Oral
testimony
alone
is
no
proof
of
citizenship. The evidence of D.W. 2, thus, falls short of
being considered as cogent, reliable and admissible
evidence, so much so, to establish linkage of the
petitioner to the projected grandfather, grandmother and
father. The petitioner utterly failed to prove her linkage to
Indian parents relatable to a period prior to the cut-off
date
of
25.03.1971
through
cogent,
reliable
and
admissible documents.”
24. In view of the discrepancies mentioned above, which is not one in number,
but so many as well as due to lack of prove of other documents, this courts
Page No.# 13/13
finds it fit that the instant petition be dismissed. No order to costs.
25.
The petition is disposed of.
26.
Records be sent back forthwith along with a copy of the order.
Amit
Das
DN: c=IN, o=Personal,
postalCode=783380, l=Bongaigaon,
st=Assam, street=Nataji
Nagar ,Babupara, Bongaigaon,
Bongaigaon Assam India 783380,
title=7232,
2.5.4.20=03e4fb506e793dc06e715bc4
085056004e440b7e9d5cf4cfd09adf70
7c28e4c8,
serialNumber=77a8b780f0bf03e8b7f5
17b45ea6e22a8edd4f96fbabe26b1a5d
942764139af4,
email=ad773209@gmail.com, cn=Amit
Das
Date: 2026.06.19 11:49:07 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review