Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH CO
,TffI"r#=^BIflEoFTELANGANA r348sl
TUESDAY, THE.ELEVENTH
DAY OF AUGUST
TWo THoUSAr.ro nNo
rwrrulvtrx
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE
CHIEF JUS.TICE SRI APARESH
rHE HoNouRorr. r*LlrtrcE
KUMAR SINGH
G.M. MoHruDDrN
WRI TA PPEA L NO: 831 0 F
Writ Appeal under clause 1l
aatea ;troqr)inzo r'
#lF ,i":'ii8Ja":"%;;l::i1fl:?i:r#fi:'i,rx%fflthe order
Between:
1. Ambala Jayavardhan, S/o..late
R/o Va rbhapur vitrao3, Erkathu
Mallaiah, Age.
Kirana shop,
_53 ,years _Occ.
r!!r; M;ffi i i'u"n *rtono"
District, Teranoana.
*,,; o;;:' dilty,l,"
::
:3 i!,,ii!,r:;#n;,:1".,*,f,f
i#i;i#;^
wrc v""r,#.*",v, i;ll,Ir,lHll
_
Ambara RnuraaniBl[]"li L",li,lili.
R/o.Varbhapur viraoe, Erkathun,iv
vir"rl'J,
i""iumakonda
District, Teranqana.
4. Ambata Govardhai, slo rate'ri,taljl;il
48. years occ. Asricuiture,
d;1,
RT0 Varbhapur vi'age.
Erkathu.,rv rrrr".irr, ixlrrrronou
District, Terangana.
AND
...APPELLANTS AA/R|T PETITIONERS
3,4,7&12
1. The State of Telanoana._Rep by its principal
Secretary, Revenue (LA and JA
Department) Secreiariat erildir6r,iirKt
ffiria'n
Hyderabad
2. The Chief Commissioner of lanO AOminiJrrt.l_Cr._Chairperson,
R and R
o/o ccLn, r'r*pliri"iiution Road, opp Annapuina
ff,:ru;:":r"#mittee
3 The National Hiqhwav nut[91t1
ol]1Oia. Rep. by its. Regionat Officer,
Banjara
Hills,Road No.3, Beside SSH Stuff C;["S"."iuj"rroro
4 The Project Director, Nationat High*av;
Ariiloiiii? rnoi", ptU, Warangat,
Balasamudram, Hanumakonda Oistrict.
5. The District Collector, Hanumakonda
District
6. The Addl collector and Administrator,
R and R Hanumakonda, Hanumakonda
District.
7. The Revenue Divisionar officer-cum-Land
Acquisition officer, Hanumakonda,
Hanumakonda District.
8. The Tahsildar, Erkathurthy Mandar,
Hanumakonda, Hanumakonda District_
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
Hotel Business Fl/o '
y:alsj_occ.
s0
Age.
Agaiah.
9. Maduri Thirupathi, s/o rate
i;"'makonda District' Telangana'
suraram village Elkatnu'rii;tffi
vears occ Lorry driver'
upprGi?h.,,As:-:5
rri"
Telangana
10.Ambala Kumaraswamy,
Hanumat<onda District'
er;'"ir";"hiri!nour'
uiIus"'
R/o Valbhapur
5'B- vears occ Agriculture'
N;;;'i'n'
Telangana'
11 Dulam Prabhakar' S'"'"ili;'
rtil"o'r' H]anumat<onda District' Business'
rtxalh"utiltv
vittage
R/o.Valbhapur
vears
N'""'iun
s't
Telangana'
12. Dulam Sampath
N4ano"r'.ulnumakonda District
tapper'
Toddy
R/o.Valbhapur vi rage erk'5iiu'tni
45 vears occ
st*'i'i"'iluir'iah'
lqe
a
l3.tVlanda Sadarardam
o'"' r e n g a n a
ill
il"i
ng"
""i"
ng" !!
occ
"
rylTi!3 i
I I e"i* I 5l,l*;:.: *i[:}V"yl[*i Ase
55 vears'
sn'ir Vari Mohammed
It Bx. i]lill- s:"i'i"
-'u'v1e
Ase
vears
131s v'ti rr'4ohammed'
];.;l NJ;l;
tr'4andal' Hanmakonda
Elkaihurutv
;ils":
All are agricult"", *Jtu'u"'#
I
?[Xl"Jono"n,, No 9 to
'16 are not necessary parties)
...RESPONDENTS /WRIT
PETITONERS
l.A. NO: 20F 2026
stated in the
CPC praying that in the circumstances
Petition under Section 151
pleased to direct the
petition' the High Court may be
the
of
support
in
frled
affidavit
rs dated bY
representation of writ petitione
the
consider
witt
fort
respondents
hile restoring
passed in W P No 25680 of2023w
042026
dated
order
suspending
theinterimorderdt,2l,Og.2023pendingdisposaloftheWritAppeal
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI' GADDE
ANILKUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent Nos' 1'2&5to8:
GP FOR LAND ACQUISITION
Counsel for the Respondent Nos' 3&4: SRI
P' HARINATH GUPTA '
The Court made the following: ORDER
SC FOR NHAI
IN
HIGH corl RTF ORT
HES
TATE OF
GAN A
AT II YD ERA BAD
TII EH ON ,BLT] THf CHI
EF JUST ICE S RI AP
ARE SHK UMA R SIN
CH
AND
THE H ON'B LE SR IJU
STICE G.M MOHII] DDIN
WRI T APP EAL No.8 3IO
F 2026
Da tc d : I1.0 8.2026
Between:
Arnbala I ay av arclhan.
S/o. lare Mallaiah and
3 orhers
,..Appellants
I he State of l elangana.
Uy its
l.O
Revenue
and
principal Secrerary,
(l_A & jA l)eparrment).
Secrelariat Buildings, BRKR
Bhavan.
I h derabad and I5
others
... Responden ls
JUDG ME NT:
Fleard Mr. Gadde Anil Kurnar. Iearned
appellants' Mr' E' Ramesh chandra
counsel appearing lor the
Goud. learnecr Governrnent pleader
tbr Land Acquisition, appearing fbr respondent
Nos.l,2 and 5 to g and
Mr. P. tiarinath Gupta, learned Standing Counsel
lor National Flighways
Authoritl of tndia (N AI). appoarine lirr respontlent Nos.3
antl ,1.
out o1'tuelve' are
\\ rit Petitioners .
|our of ths
2.
d31cd
irnpugnecl tudg11gn1
lvhetebY the Iearrrecl
()1 04 2 026 passed in
\\Iit Colut
5l.ilttltol'\ rcttlctl''
rtnJcr
1956 (hereinalier
rel'erred
enrerrain thc \\ rit
Pctitiott'
l.
['he * rtt
aggrieved b-v the
W P No 25680 oi 2023'
petitioners
re legated the writ
5e c t1"11
l(i(5) ot' the National
to avail the
llghua-rs Act'
I956')' rvhile relusing
to as' 'the Act of
the
petitionel s apprclached
Iearr-re
to
d rvrit Court tbr a
declaration that theactionoltheclll]cialresponclentsinnottakingStepS
Scherne and passing
(R&R)
I(esettlement
and
to prePare Reh abilitation
a* ard ullde r
Secrion J
I ransparencl in
I ol' thc l{ight to Irair Compensation
and ll'esettlernent
L'and Acquisition' t{ehabilitation
to as' 'the
2013 (hereinaller ref'erred
categor)
petrtioners belong to the
lanrilies itr r ics' ol' the acquisition
Act of 2013')' though
o1'project aflected and
unconst itu
tional
Act'
the *'rit
displaced
rrade for vu'iclening ol the
Warangal section
road liorn l(alirruasar to
and
cxisting
ol'NF1-563' as illegal and
'fhc $rit petitioners also sought direction to l"he
thc
otlicial resporldellts to prepare
I{&l{ Scheme and to extend the ivrit
as provided in
peritioners all thc entillernents
Sihedulc. ol'ltc Act ol lU ll helorc laking
the Second and ['hird
possession ol'their re\Pecti\c
propertics. In the *rit proceedings. there uas an interirn order ol'slaltls
tluo vith re-eard to posscssion ol. the appellants
o\,,er the subject
properties. However. according to the appellants, ilnrnediately alier
passing of the irnpugned .iudgment. their houses have been dernolished
and thel' are on roads.
-l'hese
appellants do not have any grievance as
regards thc compcnsation arrardcd in licu ol'the acquisition ol thr:ir
lands and structures standing therer-rpon. l'hey. however, are aggrieved
by non-consideration o1-their claim firr R&R Scheme in terrns ol the
Second and I'hird Schedulcs o1' thc Act o1'2013. rvhich applies tcr
acquisitions rnade under the Act ol 1956.
4.
[n order to buttress the atbresaid point, learned counsel lor the
appellants has drautr thc attcnt;oll ol'this ('ourt to thc ordcr datcd
28.08.2015 issued under Section ll3(l) ol' thc Act o1'2013 b1 the
Central Governtnent wherein the benetits available to the landowners
under the Act of 20 I 3 are exterlded 1o similarly placed landowners
rvhose lands are acquired undcr the I3 cnactments specilied in the
Fourth Schedule thcreunder. uhich includes the Act ol 1956 at serial
No.7. Learned counsel lbr the appellants has also relied upon the
cornprehensive guiclclines issttcd undcr thc Act of 1956 by the Ministrl'
of Road. -l ransport and llighrrars. datcd 28 122017' spccilicalll'
paragraph 4.4 thereof in order to contend that land losers under the
acquisition made under the Act ol' 1956 are not only entitled to
compcnSationinacctlrdancerriththcliirstScheduleol.thtlActol.20l3.
l
but also R&ll Scherrc in accordancc uith the Second Schedule arld the
infrastructural atncnities in accordance ri ith the Third Schedule. as the
\ct of' 195(r i. ;pcciticd at serial \o." in the I ilurth SchcclLrlc ol'the Act
ol 2013 uith el't'ect tiom 0l 0l.20 15. Paragraph 44 ol' the said
suidelincs rcild \ as tlnder
Iollorrinir tltc rtotitlcrtiorr ol' tlle alorcsatcl Orditranccs the
\1 rr.ir\ (rl I{(ra(l llarl\l)(rrl & llighrrars issLlcd a lcttel date(l
'() 0. :1)li rrlrcrchr tlrc .clect prorisit,tts ot l(t-( lt-^Rl{ \ct.
101.1 \\cre nadc applicablc to tlre \ll.\ct.
i956 urth el'lect honr
shous that thc
the
albresaid
i)10 l0l5 .\ con.ioint reading ol
jl''
r\LrgLrst 1015'
till
OrLli,rancc rAr'ren.lnlcnt) rctltaitlcd irl force
'Rt'nt\:Ltl rl'Dtllicttlties Orrlct'$as issLLed br the Depaftrllent ol
Lancl Resortrces otr 28i' ,\trgLtst 2015. irhich took el'fect fronr
(tl .()').20 l-i Ilorrcret. sirrcc lhc ciatc ol'applicatiorr o1'the sclected
rclcrrnt plorisiotts ot'the I{li( 11.,\RR \ct.20ll tJ thc Ntl Act.
()5(. rras 0l 0i.l0l5 rrr tcrrrr\ of tlrc Olclinancc (Anrcndnlcrrt)
\rr () ol' l0l-1. it lctnaitrs atr utranrbiguous and accepted position
rhrit the pro\isions ot' tlte Ilight to Fair Conrpetrsation and
rar.pitrenl irr [.ancl Acqtrisiticrrr. l{ehabrlitatron and Rcseftlemertt
\et- l0 Ll. relatiIs to 1hc dctertninatiolr ot co ttpensattort irt
lccoTdance rl th thc I:ilst SchcdLrle. rehahilitation arrd rcseltlenrent
I i .co|clance \\ ith tllc Sccotlil Sclledr-rlc and inlr astt Ltcttrre
irntcrrities rr accotclattcc rrrth thc lllild SchedLrlc hilrc heetl tuade
I
lrll
Act. 1956'
rr1,pl cahlc io all casc: r,l larrtl acclrrisitiotr utrtlcr the
to
Scll(]'lLlle
l-oLrt'tlr
in
the
.(.llre cLracttttetlt:llcctlictl lt1 Sr.
\o. I
thc I(|C'ft. \RR \ct. rrith eflcct lrom 01.01'2015"
Ir I\ sLrbrnitted that the apPlication of the
trit pctitioncrs t\ as
e\anrrnc(l h\ the [)istrict C'ollcctor. [{anumakonda' btrt orl the
cllr t-c'tion Il itrn the l)ro ject I)ircctor'. NH,'\1. I'lU. Warangal' he has
denied sLrelr clattn lbr Il&R Schcrne trndcr thc Scctlnd and
Schcclrrlcs ()t th!'.\e r ot'l0
darcd ir.05.l( l.t
-l-hird
ij tirr \ational IIish\\ars Projects rld€ Ineltto
lhis aesrrcrc(l thc urit petitioncrs to approach the
learned writ.()urt. Ilo$,e'er. thc
learned n.rit.ourt relegated rhe r.vrit
)
petitioners to avail the rcnrcd) undcr Scction lC(5) ol'thc nct ol'1956.
which. in the instant casc. would not arise as there is no award in respect
of'the claims to which thg rvrit petitioncrs are entitled under the Second
and l-hird Schedules ol the Act of 20 13.
'fherefore. being aggrieved.
tbur olthe aggrieved urit petitioners have pret'erred the instant appcal.
6.
l-earned Standing Counsel tor NI]AI appearing lor respondent
Nos.3 and 4 has fairly' submitted that the clarification of the Pro.lect
Director. Nl IAI. Pll.J. Warangal. rclcrrcd to in the tncrlro datcd
15.05.2023 would not stand the test ol' legal scrutin). in vie$ 01' the
extension of the benelits to the land loscrs under thc Act of 1956 also. as
applicable under the Firsl. Second and l'hird Schedules of the Act of
2013. tt is his subrnission that respondcnt No.7. who is the competent
authority. rnay be directed to consider the claim of the appellants in
accordance with lau'. It is also subrnitted that the appellants and others
havc got cnhanced cotnponsation as against acclLrisition of'their lands
and structures standing thercupon and thel' do not have anl grievance as
against it.
7.
[-earned Governuent Pleader lbr l.and Accluisition rcpresenting
respondent No.7 submits that i1'a direction is issued upon the colnpetent
authoritr'/Rer en ue Dir isional Olllccr cunt - L.and Acquisition Oftlcer.
Hanurrak,,nda. for c0nrideration ol the claint ol'the appellarrts tou'ards
R&l{ Schcrrc Ltndcr tht Second and I hird Schcdules ol the Act ol20l3'
the sautc shall he consitlered in accordance s ith la'"r
l)urins thc cortrsc ot' hearirls- learned counsel lbr the parties
brought l() lh. lloticc ol this ('olrrt the.iudgnlent dated 16042026
passed h1' this Court in W A.No 434 ol 2026 ' which rvas pref'erred b1'
sorne ol lhg urit pctitioners. lhis Court. *hile setting aside the
impugncLl iudgmcnl. granted libcrty to the appcllants tlterein to approach
rcsl.ron dcrt
t \o
thcrcin. rr ith a clainr tbr cntitlcrtcnt torl ards I{&R
Schenrc unde'the Sccond ancl lhird Schedulcs ol the Act o1'20l3
lt
\\ AS tirrthcr directetl that upon strch application being made' respondent
No.7 thcrcin rroultl lakt a dccisiotl in accortlanco rvith lau tithtn a
pcriorl ol eight riccl<s tiorn thc date of receipt ol thc cop) of thc
.juclgrlcnt n1611q rr ith the application
l his Court also took note ol' the
sLrhrrissiort n'acle hr the appcllants thcrein that their houscs have bcen
dcntolrrhed a-icr pus.ing of'thc inrlTugned .iudgrrent and ohscrr ed that it
rr ould bc open fbr the ut to sccl< directions ll orll the colnpetent
authoritl
tfr proi rding ternporarl sheltcr in the r.neantirrre. $'hich shall also be
consitlcrctl in accortlarlcc rvith lari
g.
Upon hearing the learned counsel
lnd
note of'the facts and circuntstancc:
fbr the parties and alter taking
thc lcgll prtrr isions referrcd to
view that
hercinabove, we are o['the considered
the powers under the Act of
acquisition made in exercise of
arc available
entitlcd to the benetits which
Third Schedutes o1' the Act ol 20
ll' in vicu ol thc (]overnrrent Ordcr
Transport and Highuays has also
'fhe Ministry of Road'
issued the comprehensive
in that regard. [.lowever' it appears
guidelines
of the Act of 1956
to the remedY under Section 3G(5)
rernedy under Section 3G(5) olthe
thc aflected parties arc aggric"cd
claims under thc Second and
b1 thc auard rrladc in rcspcct
ol thcir
'l'hird Schedules ol. the Act ol 2013' ln
\\'arrants interf-erence'
is set
Accordingll'. the inrpugrred.iudgrncnt
entitlettlent
-l'he
Act o1'1956 would arise only in case
such circumstances. the imptlgnetl ludgrncnt
are granted IibertY
out
that this aspect was not pointed
ririt Court rvhilc relegating the $rit
and missed b)' the learned
l0
1956 are
under the First' Second and
herernabove
dated 28.08.2015 ret'erred to
petitioners
the land losers under thc
asidc 'l-he appellants
to approach respondent No 7 with a clairn
Second and
towards R&R Schenle under the
Schedules oi thc Act ol 2013
being made. rcspondent No 7
fbr
-fhird
Nccdlcss to sa\. on such application
w'ould take a clecision in accordancc
lau rvithin a period of eight r'r'eeks fionl
u ith
the date of receipt ol a copy of
thrs.iudenrent zrlone \\ith the application. Since the appellants conrend
thaL their houscs hare bcen detnolishcd afier passing of the impugned
.;udgrnent. it uoulcl he open lbr thern to seek directions fiorrr the
conrpctent iluth()rit) lirr proricling tcrlporar) shcltcr in the ntcantirne.
rr hich shall also hc considcrccl in accorciancc rr itlr lau
I
1.
.fhe
insrant \\'rit Appeal stands disposed ol' accordingll .
-l'here
shall bc no ordcr as t() eosts
\liscellancous applicalions pcndine. ilanl'. shall stand closed
SD/. MOHD. ISMAIL
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
,TRUE COPY//
,6'
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principal Secretary. Revenue (LA and JA Department) Secretariat
Buildings, 8R(R Bhava n. Hyderabad
2. The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration-Cum-Chairperson, R and R
lr4onitoring Committee O/o. CCLA, Nampally Station Road, Opp Annapurna
Hotel, Hydera bad.
3. The Regional Officer, National Highway Authority of lndia, Banjara Hills,
Road No.3, Beside SBH Staff College, Hyderabad.
4. The Project Drrector, National Highways Authority of lndia, PlU, Warangal,
Balasamudram, Hanumakonda District.
The
District Collector, Hanumakonda District
5.
6. The Addl Collector and Administrator, R and R Hanumakonda, Hanumakonda
District.
7. The Revenue Divisional Officer-Cum-Land Acquisition Officer, Hanumakonda,
Hanumakonda District.
The
8.
Tahsildar Elkathurlhy Mandal, Hanumakonda, Hanumakonda District.
9. One CC to SR GADDE ANILKUMAR Advocate IOPUC]
10.Two CCs to GP FOR LAND ACQUISITION High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
1l one cc to SRI p HARTNATH GUprA, sc FoR NATTONAL HTGHWAYS
AUTHORTTY OF tNDtA toPUC]
12.Two CD Copies
BM
TKS
t
'\, r\ --
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1110812026
'r
\J
JUDGMENT
a
I AUG 2025
z
o
J!
WA.No.831 of 2026
)
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
{
Ai c
\1) '
\)
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review