Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No. 246 of 2022
Date of Decision:06.03.2024
1. Smti Amanda B. Basaiawmoit
D/o (L) James P. Suting
R/o Lower Nongrim Hills,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills
District, Meghalaya.
2. Shri Batskhem Myrboh,
S/o Shri Khin Lyngdoh
R/o Thangsning,
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
3. Shri Kerlihok Lyngdoh Buam
S/o Shri Ehbok Rynjah
R/o Central Nongrim Hills
(House No. c/o-014),
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya
1.State of Meghalaya
Represented by
Commissioner &
Secretary to the Govt. of
Meghalaya, Education
Department, Shillong.
2.The Principal Secretary
to the Govt. of
Meghalaya, Education
Vs.
Department, Shillong
3.The Joint Secretary to the
Govt. of Meghalaya,
Education Department
Shillong
4.Director of Higher and
Technical Education,
State of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
5.Joint Director of Higher
and Technical Education
State of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
6.The Director, Directorate
of Local Fund Audit,
State of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
________________________________________________________
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Mr. S. Sen, Adv. with
Ms. S. Shallam, Adv.
Mr. S.K. Roy, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Yes/No
1.
The petitioners are Teachers in Deficit Colleges with the
writ petitioner No. 1, serving as an Associate Professor in Shillong
College, and the writ petitioners 2 and 3, as Assistant Professors in
Synod College. The writ petitioners have preferred the instant writ
petition jointly pleading a common cause of action that, though they
have been placed at a higher stage of Academic Grade Pay, they have
been denied the increments to which they are entitled to under the law.
It has been therefore prayed that the respondents be directed to extend
additional increments to the writ petitioners, fix their pay in the
appropriate stage and further to grant consequential benefits including
arrears.
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
2.
The brief background facts are that the Ministry of Human
Resource Development on 31.12.2008, had formulated a Scheme
providing for two Pay Bands for Teachers of Universities and Colleges
at Rs. 15600-39100 and Rs. 37400-67000 with appropriate Grade Pay
and that each Pay Band shall have different stages of Academic Grade
Pay providing opportunities to Teachers for Upward movement. The
said Scheme at Para-8 thereof, with regard to increment, provided that
the pay fixation formula recommended by the Sixth Central Pay
Commission as accepted by the Central Government be adopted for
teachers and equivalent positions in the Library and Physical Education
cadre. The Government of Meghalaya then adopted the aforesaid
Scheme dated 31.12.2008, for implementation of the UGC norms by
letter dated 23.03.2010. Thereafter, the petitioner No. 1 on 01.08.2011,
was placed from Stage 1 to Stage 2 (Rs. 6000 to 7000 AGP) and the
writ petitioners Nos. 2 and 3, on 16.04.2013 and 01.06.2014,
respectively. The matter it appears rested at that and it was only after
the writ petitioners had represented with regard to the pay anomaly
arising out of pay fixation of teachers drawing UGC Scale of pay that
the issue came alive. The Joint Director Higher Technical Education,
then by a communication dated 24.08.2020, pursuant to the
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
representations filed by the petitioners, requested the government, to
extend the promotional increment while promoting the teachers of both
Government Colleges, as well as Deficit Grant-in-Aid colleges from
one stage to a higher stage as per UGC Regulations, 2010.
3.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for the petitioners has
submitted that by operation of the Scheme at the relevant point of time,
80% of the liability of the pay of such teachers was to be borne by the
Central Government and 20% was borne by the State Government, for
the period 01.01.2006 to 31.03.2010, and in pursuance thereof, an
amount of over Rs. 45 Crores was released to the State Government.
This it is submitted, is substantiated by a communication dated
16.12.2016. He argues that as the UGC Regulations have been adopted,
its recommendations are binding on the State respondents as has been
held in Gambhirdhan K. Gadhvi vs. State of Gujarat reported in
(2022) 5 SCC 179. In further support of his submissions, the learned
counsel has also placed reliance on the case of Dr. J. Vijayan & Ors.
vs. State of Kerala & Ors. reported in 2022 SCC Online SC 958 and B.
Bharat Kumar & Ors. vs. Osmania University & Ors. reported in
(2007) 11 SCC 58. On the question as to the delay in approaching the
Court, it is submitted by the learned counsel that none has occurred,
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
inasmuch as, by letter dated 24.08.2020, the Joint Director of Higher &
Technical Education, had acknowledged the entitlement of the writ
petitioners for increment on placement on a higher Academic Grade
Pay (AGP), and as no action was taken on the letter, the instant writ
petition was filed on 2022. It has been lastly argued that the entitlement
of increment being a statutory right, the same cannot be barred by lapse
of time, and the non-granting of the increment is a continuous wrong.
4.
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA at the outset has
submitted that the writ petition suffers from delay and laches, inasmuch
as, the petitioners have approached this Court after a delay of 12 years.
In this regard the learned counsel has placed reliance on the cases of
Bichitrananda Behera vs. State of Orissa & Ors. reported in 2023
SCC Online SC 1307 and C. Jacob vs. Director of Geology and
Mining & Anr. reported in (2008) 10 SCC 115. It is submitted that the
writ petitioners have filed the writ petition solely on the basis of the
letter of the Joint Director dated 24.08.2020, and no other ground has
been made out to explain the delay. It has been strongly argued that the
contents of the aforesaid letter, is only an opinion expressed by the
person concerned and that the same does not create any legally
enforceable right in favour of the petitioners. It has also been
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
contended that the petitioners by filing the instant case are merely
taking a chance, that too, after 2 years since the issuance of the letter
dated 24.08.2020, and that in the intervening period, the writ
petitioners never raised their grievance at any point of time. The
learned counsel submits that whatever rights the petitioners possessed,
stand extinguished as on date, due to the laches and also the fact that
they have continued accepting their remuneration thereafter, without
any protest.
5.
On the question of the applicability of the UGC
Regulations 2010, and its extent thereof, it has been submitted that the
objective of the Regulations is to declare the minimum qualification for
appointment of teachers and other Academic staff, and for maintenance
of standards in Higher education in the Universities and Colleges, and
that the grant of Central assistance for implementing the Scheme was
subject to fulfillment of regulations and guidelines. The binding nature
of the Regulations he contends, is only to the extent that central
financial assistance would be refused, if the said Scheme was not
followed in its totality. He submits that in the instant case the Central
funds having been released and received without any observations to
the contrary by the Central Government and the State having spent
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
close of 57 Crores, for implementation of the Scheme of Pay Revision
for Colleges Teachers, there has been no deprivation as alleged. The
learned counsel, has also relied on the affidavit filed by the State and
has submitted that for the said period in question i.e. 01.01.2006 to
31.03.2010, the Ministry of HRD, Department of Higher Education had
released financial assistance to meet 80% of the additional expenditure
and the remaining 20% was borne by the State. This amount, he
submits being only for that period the aforesaid funds as sanctioned had
already stood utilized and settled much prior to the filing of the writ
petition, and the issue of promotional increment stands closed. Further
he submits, nowhere have the writ petitioners indicated or quantified
the amounts which they claim are due, or declared the amount which
was received by them at the relevant point of time. The writ petition
being vague and hit by delay and laches, he argues does not deserve
any consideration and is liable to be dismissed.
6.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, in spite of
the lengthy submissions that have been advanced, the core question as
can be understood, is limited only to the claims of promotional
increments, on the petitioners being placed on a higher stage of
Academic Grade Pay. This is seen was as per the Ministry of Human
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
Resource Development (Department of Higher Education), Scheme of
revision of pay of teachers etc., on the recommendations of the 6 th
Central Pay Commission dated 31.12.2008, which was adopted by the
UGC, in its Regulations of 2010. Undeniably, the petitioners had been
placed in the higher stage of AGP i.e. from stage I to stage II (60007000), at the relevant point of time, which would have cloaked them
with a vested right to the promotional increment, as provided by the
scheme and supported by the Central Government to the extent of 80%
of additional expenditure involved in the implementation of the scheme
for the period from 01.01.2006 to 31.03.2010.
7.
As the facts indicate, the Central Government had released
an amount of Rs. 45,57,41,316/- (Rupees Forty-Five Crores FiftySeven Lakhs Forty-One Thousand Three Hundred and Sixteen) only,
which amounted to 80% of the total expenditure, on account of
implementation of the scheme in the State. A communication dated
16.12.2016, from the Ministry of Human Resource Development,
addressed to the Principal Accounts Officer, MHRD, with regard to the
release of financial assistance to meet 80% of additional expenditure
for implementation of the revision of pay scale of University and
College Teachers in the State of Meghalaya, which has been brought
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
on record subsequently, testifies to this fact. The central assistance in
implementing the scheme, as can be seen from the communication was
also subject to the condition that the entire scheme of revision of pay
scales, together with the conditions as laid down were to be followed
and implemented by the State Government.
8.
The entire chapter regarding the implementation of the
scheme dated 31.12.2008, which was w.e.f. 01.01.2006 to 31.03.2010,
as also the extension of revised UGC scale of pay on the basis of the 6th
Pay Commission Recommendation, then came to a close with the
release of an amount of Rs. 56,96,76,645/- (Rupees Fifty-Six Crores
Ninety-Six Lakhs Seventy-Six Thousand Six Hundred and Forty-Five)
only, in total inclusive of 80% central share, and 20% state share, to
meet all the stated requirements such as arrears, UGC scale of pay,
D.A, placements, increments, etc. Thereafter, as placed by the
respondents, with the coming into force of the 7th Central Pay
Commission Recommendations, revised UGC scales were then fixed
on the basis of the said recommendations, and as per the State
respondents, the Government of Meghalaya had released an amount of
Rs. 76,98,72,180/- (Rupees Seventy-Six Crores Ninety-Eight Lakhs
Seventy-Two Thousand One Hundred and Eighty) only, for which 50%
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
thereof, being the central share, is yet to be reimbursed to the State.
The claim of the petitioners therefore is confined to the window, when
the scheme was alive. It is to be noted further that, as per the
communication dated 16.12.2016, the MHRD had made the release of
central assistance, subject to the scheme of the revision of pay and
other conditions to be laid down by the UGC, being implemented. This
chapter, with the release of the entire funds being closed, this Court has
only to examine, as to whether this closed chapter, in spite of the delay
and the events that have transpired thereafter, can be re-opened, or
whether, it can be held that the writ petitioners by their conduct, have
by their delay and laches in seeking any remedy, waived their rights to
any entitlement under the Scheme, which has since lapsed.
9.
As observed earlier, the entitlement of the petitioners being
confined only to a certain period, the same cannot constitute a
continuing right or entitlement, inasmuch as, they are now governed
under a new regime of pay revision and admissible scales as per the 7 th
Central Pay Commission Recommendations. This Court cannot lose
sight of the fact that, the writ petitioners have slept over their rights, on
their being placed on a higher stage of Academic Grade Pay, and there
is nothing on record to show that they had ever agitated for such
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
entitlement till the year 2020, and thereafter, on the basis of the letter of
the Joint Director of Higher and Technical Education, Meghalaya dated
24.08.2020, requesting for consideration, then approached this Court
only in the year 2022. The long delay has neither been explained, nor is
there any other reason that can be ascribed to excuse or condone the
conduct of the petitioners. Furthermore, it is observed, apart from
referring to the Pay Fixation Formula of the Central Civil Service
(Revised Pay), Rules 2008, for calculation of the additional increments,
the writ petitioners have not calculated or given a tangible amount,
except to pray for direction for grant of additional increments on the
placement on the higher stage of Academic Grade Pay, in the post of
Assistant Professor and for fixation of pay at appropriate stage and
grant of arrears and consequential benefits. The vague nature of their
prayer is also indicative of their uncertainty of the additional
increments, the amounts thereof, that they claim to be entitled to. Be
that as it may, the main concern being the delay taking into account the
fact that, the amounts of pay revision etc., due under the
recommendation of the 6th Pay Commission, have since been released,
without any objection being raised from the MHRD, as to the correct
and full implementation of the scheme dated 31.12.2008, in the
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
considered view of this Court, therefore any rights that had accrued to
the writ petition under the scheme by their conduct itself, has since
been extinguished.
10.
The Supreme Court in the judgment cited by the counsel for
the respondents, namely Bichitrananda Behera vs. State of Orissa &
Ors. reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1307, has dealt with the
question of delay and laches, and acquiescence, and has also analyzed
and quoted extensively other Supreme Court judgments on this aspect,
it has been held in Para -21 as follows.
“21. Profitably, we may reproduce relevant passages
from certain decisions of this Court:
(A) Union of India v Tarsem Singh, (2008) 8 SCC 648:
“To summarise, normally, a belated service related
claim will be rejected on the ground of delay and laches
(where remedy is sought by filing a writ petition) or
limitation (where remedy is sought by an application to
the Administrative Tribunal). One of the exceptions to
the said rule is cases relating to a continuing wrong.
Where a service related claim is based on a continuing
wrong, relief can be granted even if there is a long delay
in seeking remedy, with reference to the date on which
the continuing wrong commenced, if such continuing
wrong creates a continuing source of injury. But there is
an exception to the exception. If the grievance is in
respect of any order or administrative decision which
related to or affected several others also, and if the
reopening of the issue would affect the settled rights of
third parties, then the claim will not be entertained. For
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
example, if the issue relates to payment or refixation of
pay or pension, relief may be granted in spite of delay as
it does not affect the rights of third parties. But if the
claim involved issues relating to seniority or promotion,
etc., affecting others, delay would render the claim stale
and doctrine of laches/limitation will be applied. Insofar
as the consequential relief of recovery of arrears for a
past period is concerned, the principles relating to
recurring/successive wrongs will apply. As a
consequence, the High Courts will restrict the
consequential relief relating to arrears normally to a
period of three years prior to the date of filing of the writ
petition.”
(Emphasis supplied)
(B) Union of India v N Murugesan, (2022) 2 SCC 25:
"Delay, laches and acquiescence
20. The principles governing delay, laches, and
acquiescence are overlapping and interconnected on
many occasions. However, they have their distinct
characters and distinct elements. One can say that delay
is the genus to which laches and acquiescence are
species. Similarly, laches might be called a genus to a
species by name acquiescence. However, there may be a
case where acquiescence is involved, but not laches.
These principles are common law principles, and
perhaps one could identify that these principles find
place in various statutes which restrict the period of
limitation and create non-consideration of condonation
in certain circumstances. They are bound to be applied
by way of practice requiring prudence of the court than
of a strict application of law. The underlying principle
governing these concepts would be one of estoppel. The
question of prejudice is also an important issue to be
taken note of by the court.
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
Laches
21. The word “laches” is derived from the French
language meaning “remissness and slackness”. It thus
involves unreasonable delay or negligence in pursuing a
claim involving an equitable relief while causing
prejudice to the other party. It is neglect on the part of a
party to do an act which law requires while asserting a
right, and therefore, must stand in the way of the party
getting relief or remedy.”
11.
Acquiescence is writ large in the instant case, coupled with
the fact that, the non-grant of the additional increment is not a
continuing wrong, with the coming into force of fresh Pay Revision, by
way of subsequent recommendations under the 7th Central Pay
Commission. Further, as noted earlier with the release of the required
amounts by the MHRD, and the chapter having been closed,
reconsideration of the claims of the petitioners will necessarily entail
an exercise involving the fresh release of amounts under a lapsed
scheme on a claim, which should have been brought before the Court,
at least 12 years ago. The fault being squarely on the shoulders of the
writ petitioners, the reliefs as prayed therefore, in the considered view
of this Court, cannot be granted at this late stage.
12.
The point raised with regard to UGC Regulations, 2010,
being a piece of subordinate legislation and therefore inviolable is
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
noted, but the law in its application will not apply in the instant case, as
it is not a case of violation, inasmuch as, the same has been
implemented, albeit the irregularity, that has been highlighted by the
writ petitioners belatedly by way of this writ petition. The judgment
placed by the petitioner namely Gambhirdhan K. Gadhvi vs. State of
Gujarat (supra), will have no application, as it is with regard to
qualifications for appointment as Vice Chancellor. The other judgments
placed being of limited application, are not discussed.
13.
Accordingly, as discussed hereinabove, the writ petitioners
case being hit by delay and laches, whatever rights derived from the
scheme, are no longer available to them. The writ petition is therefore
not entertained, and on this ground alone stands dismissed.
14.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
06.03.2024
“V. Lyndem PS”
WP(C) No. 246 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review