The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 04.2001. The possession was open, uninterrupted and continuous and it hostile to the right, title and interests of the plaintiff. The predecessor of the plaintiff and thereafter the plaintiff knowing fully way that by an unregistered deed, they did not derivative or adaptable title, till then they retained the title in hostile assertion of their adverse title.” [ 11 ] Thus, this assertion itself evinces that the basic claim of the plaintiffs over the suit land was on the basis of purchase by said unregistered deed of sale and they continued their possession based on such right of transfer/purchase. There is no material in the record as to how suddenly their possession became hostile to the original owner. Ms. Chakraborty, learned counsel argues that when the unregistered deed of sale was an illegal deed, so, the basic entry of plaintiff into the suit land was unauthorised and such unauthorised possession was continued by the plaintiffs for more than the statutory period of limitations continuously and uninterruptedly and therefore, the title of the plaintiffs became perfected for inaction on the part of the original owner. This Court is not, however, convinced with this submission inasmuch as when there was no existence of any hostile animus while taking entry into the suit land, mere continuance of possession by the plaintiffs would not change the nature of their possession un…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.37 of 2023
1. Amal Baidya,
S/o Late Jagadish Baidya
Age 46 years
2. Krishna Baidya,
S/o Late Jagadish Baidya
Age 52 years
All are residence of North Kalabaria, P.O. Maichara,
P.S-Belonia, District-South Tripura.
……………Appellant(s).
Versus
1. Shri Joydev Das,
S/o Late Nishi Kanta Das
A resident of Village:-North Jolaibari
P.S:-Baikhora, District:-South Tripura
2. Shri Vidyasagar Baidya,
S/o Late Jagadish Baidya,
A resident of Kalabaria, P.O- Maichara, P.S-Belonia,
District-South Tripura. PIN-799155
…………Respondent(s).
With
RSA No.38 of 2023
1. Amal Baidya,
S/o Late Jagadish Baidya
Age 46 years
2. Krishna Baidya,
S/o Late Jagadish Baidya
Age 52 years
All are residence of North Kalabaria, P.O. Maichara,
P.S-Belonia, District-South Tripura.
…………… Appellant(s).
Versus
1. Shri Joydev Das,
S/o Late Nishi Kanta Das
A resident of Village:-North Jolaibari
P.S:-Baikhora, District:-South Tripura
2. Shri Vidyasagar Baidya,
S/o Late Jagadish Baidya,
A resident of Kalabaria, P.O- Maichara, P.S-Belonia,
District-South Tripura. PIN-799155
…………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
:
Ms. Pinki Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Senior Advocate.
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate.
Date of Hearing
& Judgment
:
12.04.2024
Whether fit
for reporting
:
No.
_B_E_ F_O_R_E_
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
Both the appeals RSA No.37 of 2023 and RSA No.38 of
2023 have arisen out of a common judgment passed by Ld.
District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia dated 03.04.2023 in Title
Appeal No.2 of 2018 and Title Appeal No.03 of 2018 (Cross
Appeal) and are heard simultaneously and are being disposed of
by a common order.
[2]
The present appellants and respondent no.2, the three
brothers
as plaintiffs instituted Title Suit No.08 of 2011 praying
for declaration of their right, title and interest in the suit land by
way of adverse possession along with consequential relief of
injunction against the present respondent no.1. The present
respondent no.1 in turn instituted Title Suit No.44 of 2011(CC) by
way of filing counter claim against the present appellants and
respondent no.2 praying for declaration of his right, title and
interest over the suit land alongwith prayer for recovery of
possession. Ld. Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia dismissed the
suit bearing no. TS 08 of 2011 vide judgment dated 23.3.2018 and
allowed said TS 44 of 2011 (CC) on the same day by a separate
judgment by declaring right, title and interest of the present
respondent no.1 in the suit land and by directing recovery of
possession of the suit land from the present appellants and
respondent no.2.
[3]
Against the judgment and decree passed in TS 08 of
2011, the original plaintiffs i.e. the three brother preferred Title
Appeal bearing no. 02 of 2018 and against the judgment and
decree
passed in said TS 44 of 2011 (CC), they preferred Title
Appeal No. 03 of 2018 (Cross Appeal).
Both the appeals were
heard together by the Ld. District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia
and were dismissed by the said Ld. Court vide common judgement
dated 03.04.2023. Now, against the said common judgment and
decree, two second appeals are filed in this Court bearing no. RSA
No.38 of 2023(against the judgment passed in relation to TA
No.02 of 2018) and RSA No.37 of 2023(against the judgment
passed in relation to Title Appeal No.03 of 2018). In that context,
though a common order is being passed in respect of both the
second appeals, but for convenience of discussions, RSA No.38 of
2023 is being taken up as the lead case.
[4]
The claim of the plaintiffs has been that the original
owner of the suit land of 1.96 acres of Mouja-Kalabaria under
Maichara T.K. within the Belonia Revenue Circle was the present
respondent no.1 getting the same by way of allotment from
Government and he transferred the suit land to the plaintiffs’
predecessor namely Late Jagadish Baidya by an unregistered deed
of sale dated 25.04.1989 and since then they have been
possessing the suit land adversely to the interest of the original
owner i.e. respondent no.1. In the year 2007 the department of
Railway through the Government of Tripura initiated the proposal
for acquisition of certain lands including some portion of suit land
for extension of railway track from Agartala to Sabroom
and
suddenly hearing the same, the respondent no.1 came forward to
lodge his claim over the suit land with an intention to grab the
awarded money and tried to dispossess the plaintiffs from the suit
land. This is the reason why the suit was instituted by the plaintiffs
for declaration of their right, title and interest in the suit land by
way of adverse possession which was thwarted by the sole
defendant-respondent no.1 by filing the counter claim for recovery
of his possession.
[5]
Both side led their respective evidences both oral and
documentary in the said suit and counter claim and finally Ld. Trial
Court rejected said original suit and allowed the counter claim as
indicated above. Said decisions of the Trial Court were also
affirmed by the First Appellate Court as stated.
[6]
Ms. Pinki Chakraborty, learned counsel representing the
said original plaintiff appellants refers different paragraphs of
judgments of both Trial Court and the First Appellate Court to
contend
that there were manifest errors committed by the Trial
Court in appreciation of the evidences as adduced by the
appellants in the original suit leading to a perverse decision which
was further carried over in the judgment of the Ld. First Appellate
Court.
[7]
Ms. Chakraborty, learned counsel also relies on a
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ravinder Kaur Grewal &
Others vs Manjit Kaur & Ors, (2019) 8 SCC 729 wherein at
para 52 & 53 it was observed that under Article 64 also suit can be
filed based on the possessory title and law never intends a person
who has perfected title to be deprived of filing suit under Article 65
to recover possession and to render him remediless. Regarding law
of adverse possession it was also observed that such law does not
qualify only a defendant for the acquisition of title by way of
adverse possession, it may be perfected by a person who is filing a
suit. It only restricts a right of the owner to recover possession
before the period of limitation fixed for the extinction of his rights
expires.
[8]
Ms. Chakraborty, learned counsel also refers another
decision of this Court rendered in Laxmi Patari (Datta) & Ors.
vs Bibha Datta & Ors, (2016) 2 TLR 1055 wherein at para 17
this Court had given reference of another decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court rendered in Amrendra Pratap Singh vs Tej
Bahadur Prajapati, (2004) 10 SCC 65 and the relevant
paragraphs as quoted therein are reproduced below:
“22.
Every possession is not, in law, adverse possession.
Under article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963, a suit for
possession of immovable property or any interest therein
based on title can be instituted within a period of twelve
years calculated from the date when the possession of the
defendant becomes adverse to the plaintiff. By virtue of
section 27 of the Limitation Act, on the determination of the
period limited by the Act to any person for instituting suit
for possession of any property, his right to such property
stands extinguished.
The process of acquisition of title by adverse possession
springs into action essentially by default or inaction of the
owner. A person, though having no right to enter into
possession of the property of someone else, does so and
continues in possession setting up title in himself and
adversely to the title of the owner, commences prescribing
title on to himself and such prescription having continued
for a period of twelve years, he acquires title not on his own
but on account of the default or inaction on the part of the
real owner, which stretched over a period of twelve years,
results in extinguishing of the latters title. It is that
extinguished title of the real owner which comes to vest in
the wrongdoer. The law does not intend to confer any
premium on the wrongdoing of a person in wrongful
possession; it pronounces the penalty of extinction of title
on the person who though entitled to assert his right and
remove the wrongdoer and re-enter into possession, has
defaulted and remained inactive for a period of twelve
years, which the law considers reasonable for attracting the
said penalty. Inaction for a period of twelve years is treated
by the doctrine of adverse possession as evidence of the
loss of desire on the part of the rightful owner to assert his
ownership and reclaim possession.
23.
The nature of the property, the nature of title
vesting in the rightful owner, the kind of possession which
the adverse possessor is exercising, are all relevant factors
which enter into consideration for attracting applicability of
the doctrine of adverse possession. The right in the
property ought to be one which is alienable and is capable
of being acquired by the competitor. Adverse possession
operates on an alienable right. The right stands alienated by
operation of law, for it was capable of being alienated
voluntarily and is sought to be recognised by the doctrine of
adverse possession as having been alienated involuntarily,
by default and inaction on the part of the rightful claimant,
who knows actually or constructively of the wrongful acts
of the competitor and yet sits idle. Such inaction or default
in taking care of one’s own rights over property is also
capable of being called a manner of “dealing” with one’s
property
which results
property
and
vesting
in extinguishing one’s title
the
same
in
the
in
wrongdoer
in
possession of property and thus amounts to “transfer of
immovable property” in the wider sense assignable in the
context of social welfare legislation enacted with the object
of protecting a weaker section.”
[9]
Ms. A. Debbarma, learned counsel representing the
respondent no.1 on the other hand submits that contradictory and
self condemning pleas were taken by the plaintiffs by asserting on
one hand that their predecessor had entered into the suit land by
way of purchase by an unregistered deed dated 25.04.1989 and
on
the
other
hand,
asserting
adverse
possession
therein.
According to her, such contradictory claims are not tenable at law.
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel also argues that the possession
howsoever be long cannot be treated as an adverse possession
unless the elements of adverse possession are satisfied. Finally Ms.
Debbarma,
learned
counsel
submits
that
there
has
been
concurrent findings of both Ld. Trial Court as well as of Ld. First
Appellate Court and, therefore, the passageway for admission of
both the regular second appeals is now closed for absence of any
substantial questions of law.
[ 10 ]
It is the specific plea of the plaintiffs that their
predecessor had entered into the suit land on the strength of an
unregistered
deed
of
sale
dated
25.04.1989.
The
relevant
paragraph No.5 of the plaint of TS 08 of 2011 in this context
assumes relevance and, therefore, quoted hereinbelow:
“5. That the defendant released his possession by way of
an
unregistered
sale
deed
and
it
was
made
on
25.04.1989 and thenceforward the predecessor of the
plaintiff and thereafter the plaintiffs are in peaceful
possession of the said land. As such the plaintiffs have
perfected
their
title
over
the
land
on
and
from
25.04.2001. The possession was open, uninterrupted and
continuous and it hostile to the right, title and interests
of the plaintiff. The predecessor of the plaintiff and
thereafter the plaintiff knowing fully way that by an
unregistered deed, they did not derivative or adaptable
title, till then they retained the title in hostile assertion of
their adverse title.”
[ 11 ]
Thus, this assertion itself evinces that the basic claim of
the plaintiffs over the suit land was on the basis of purchase by
said unregistered deed of sale and they continued their possession
based on such right of transfer/purchase. There is no material in
the record as to how suddenly their possession became hostile to
the original owner. Ms. Chakraborty, learned counsel argues that
when the unregistered deed of sale was an illegal deed, so, the
basic entry of plaintiff into the suit land was unauthorised and such
unauthorised possession was continued by the plaintiffs for more
than
the
statutory
period
of
limitations
continuously
and
uninterruptedly and therefore, the title of the plaintiffs became
perfected for inaction on the part of the original owner. This Court
is not, however, convinced with this submission inasmuch as when
there was no existence of any hostile animus while taking entry
into the suit land, mere continuance of possession by the plaintiffs
would not change the nature of their possession unless there has
been a specific plea of ouster taken and proved by the plaintiffs.
[ 12 ]
Thus, this Court finds no error or perversity in the
judgments passed by both the Trial Court and the First Appellate
Court. In absence of any substantial questions of law to be
formulated for admission of the appeal, both the appeals bearing
RSA No.37 of 2023 and RSA No.38 of 2023 are hereby dismissed
being not admitted.
Both the appeals are accordingly disposed of.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
shall
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
RUDRADEEP
BANERJEE
Riki
BANERJEE
Date: 2024.04.23 17:45:02 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review