Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.33077 of 2024
Alone Trust
….
Petitioner
….
Opposite Parties
-VersusUnion of India and others
Advocates appeared in this case:
For Petitioner
: Mr. P.K. Dutta, Advocate
For Opp. Parties
: Mr. P.K. Parhi, Deputy Solicitor General of India
Mr. J.B. Mohanty, Central Government Counsel
Mr. Debashis Tripathy, Addl. Govt. Advocate
Mr. Manoj Kumar Mishra, Senior Advocate
(Amicus Curiae)
Mr. Subir Palit, Senior Advocate (Amicus Curiae)
CORAM:
HON’ BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANASH RANJAN PATHAK
JUDGMENT
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing : 19th November, 2025
Date of Judgment : 5th February, 2026
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------HARISH TANDON, CJ.
1.
On the advent of human civilization taking a paradigm shift
from a community-based power to monarchy and taking shape in the
form of a country, the Symbol, Flag, and/or Emblem were used
symbolizing honour, right and the authority exercised to achieve the
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
object of justice, ethos behind the purity of the administration and
above all, inculcating the sense of values towards the motherland. It
not only encompasses the honour and pride to any nation but also
depicts its historical, cultural and moral values.
2.
The National Symbol or the Emblem adopted by the nation
percolates a sense of responsibilities and core values of life which at
times, is distinct from the other nations within the globe.
Preservation of the core cultural, ethical and moral values and its
dissemination through the Symbol, Flag and Emblem is aimed not
only to unite the people of the country but to be reminded of the
basic values of life.
3.
After the independence achieved by the people of our
country from the colonial rule, the first and foremost task, which
was felt inevitable to represent the sovereign republic identity and
its values in adopting the National Flag, National Anthem and also
the National Emblem. It was proposed in the Constituent Assembly
that the National Emblem should be inspired from the mode of rule
and the governance embraced by the capital of Ashoka, which
illuminates and/or resolute the sovereignty, unity and ancient
civilization and its heritage.
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
4.
Before the adoption of the Constitution of India and after the
independence achieved from the British colonial rule on 15th
August, 1947, the dominion of India adopted the State Emblem
through a press communique dated 29th December, 1947 to be
published or broadcast on 30th December, 1947 which should
consist of the Sarnath Lion Capital of king Ashoka with the lions
standing on an abacus having Dharma Chakra in the center, a bull on
the right and horse on the left and the outlines of the Dharma Chakra
on extreme right and left with further stipulation that a suitable
motto will be included in due course as soon as one has been
decided upon. Subsequently, the State Emblem representing the
Lion Capital of king Ashoka with motto “Satyameva Jayate” in
Devanagari was adopted as a State Emblem of India on 26th
January, 1950.
5.
Immediately after the adoption of the Constitution of India
to take effect from 26th January, 1950, in contemporaneous period of
time, the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act,
1950 was promulgated, tracing the source of powers from the
residuary Article 97 of List-I, defining the word "Emblem" to mean
any Emblem, Seal, Flag and Insignia, the coat of arms or pictorial
representation as specified in the schedule appended thereto.
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
6.
The said Act contains an exhaustive provision, including the
prohibition of improper use of the Emblems and Names, yet there
appears a continuous improper use thereof in diversified fields,
including in trade and commerce. The Constitution Bench of the
apex Court in M/s. Sable Waghire & Company v. The Union of
India, reported in (1975) 1 SCC 763, though was considering the
pictorial representation and the words, Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj
used as a registered trademark by the said company engaged in a
business of manufacturing, marketing and selling bidis across the
country, the challenge was made by the said company to the
constitutional validity of the said Act and its vires and in pursuit of
addressing
such
issues,
the Constitution
Bench
succinctly
recapitulated the object and purpose, underlining the promulgation
of the said act in the following:
“15. Let us, therefore, have a background of the
promulgation of the Act. The Statement of Objects and
Reasons will make the position clear and may be quoted
in extenso:
The
General
Assembly
of
the
United
Nations
Organisation recommended in 1946 that members of the
United Nations should take necessary legislative or
other appropriate measures to prevent the use, without
proper authority, and in particular for commercial
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
purposes, of the emblem, the official seal and the name
of the United Nations and of the abbreviations of that
name. A similar recommendation has since been
received also from the World Health Organisation for
prevention of the use of its name (and abbreviations),
emblem and official seal. Instances have also come to
light of the use in India (and abroad) of the Indian
National Flag and emblem and of the names or pictorial
representations of Mahatma Gandhi and other national
leaders, for commercial and trade purposes and in a
manner likely to offend the sentiments of the people. The
provisions of the Indian Trade Marks Act, 1940, Indian
Patents and Designs Act, 1911, Indian Merchandise
Marks Act, 1889, and the Indian Companies Act, 1913,
are not adequate to prevent these abuses. The Bill seeks
to prevent the improper use of these names, emblems,
etc., for the purpose of trade, business, calling,
profession, patent or design, and to impose a penalty for
misuse of emblems, etc., specified in the Schedule and
empowers the Central Government to make additions
and amendments in the Schedule as and when
necessary.”
7.
While recapitulating the celebrated and oft-quoted words of
William Shakespeare, used in his play Romeo and Juliet that, "What
is in a name; That which we call a rose by another name would
smell as sweet” in the following:
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
“16. What is in a name” may not always be innocent.
Logically proper names are not connotative but have
often gathered a content, a halo, around them sometimes
or for all times to come. National or international
significance gets attached to certain names or
institutions over the years or ages and then they belong
to the nation or to all nations. Human sentiments and
often a deep sense of religiosity pervade through and
provide a sacred mantle as it were to the nomenclature.
In order to arouse national sentiments everywhere
invocation of “Chhatrapati Shivaji” in manifold ways in
the era of struggle for independence of our country is
now, by turn of history, replaced by an ardent worship
of the proud heritage by a grateful nation. Law
reflecting the national consciousness, therefore, forbids
ordinary commercial use of the sacred name by
individuals in their own interest as opposed to national
interest.”
8.
Despite such preventive law being in place since 1950, the
improper use of the Emblem continued and ultimately, after several
decades, a specific legislation relating to Emblem and its use in a
more reasonable and responsible manner was enacted, i.e., the State
Emblem of India (Prohibition of Improper Use) Act, 2005. The
primary object behind such legislation is to prohibit the improper
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
use of the State Emblem of India for professional and commercial
purposes and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.
9.
The definition of an Emblem as given in the Act of 1950
undergone a sea change and a new definition was assigned to mean
the State Emblem of India as described and specified in the
Schedule to be used as an official seal of the Government. The
Schedule appended to the said Act vividly contains the description
and the design of the Emblem with the motto, "Satyameva Jayate""Truth alone triumphs" written in Devanagari Script below the
profile of the lion capital. Appendix I & II of the said Schedule
depict the pictorial features of the Emblem being an adaptation from
the Sarnath Lion Capital of Ashoka, preserved in the Sarnath
Museum.
10.
Apropos, the power to make Rules having provided in the
said Act, the State Emblem of India (Regulation of Use) Rules, 2007
was framed and notified on 4th October 2007. Rule-3 of the said
Rules postulates the design of an official seal to be an Emblem
enclosed in an oval or round frame, which may contain the name of
the Ministry or the Office between the inner and outer rims of a
frame and in the event, the full name of the Ministry or Office is not
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
feasible and/or possible, the abbreviated form can be used. Rule-8
contains an exhaustive provision related to display of Emblem on a
public building in such manner as provided therein and it would be
apposite to reproduce the said provision in the following:
“8. Display on public buildings.– (1) The emblem may
be displayed on very important public buildings, like,
the Rashtrapati Bhawan, Parliament House, Supreme
Court and Central Secretariat buildings.
(2) The emblem may be displayed on Raj Bhawan or Raj
Niwas and State Legislature, High Courts and
Secretariat buildings of the States or the Union
Territories that have adopted the emblem or have
incorporated the emblem in the Emblem of the State or
the Union Territory.
(3) The emblem may be displayed on the premises of
India's Diplomatic Mission abroad and the heads of
Missions may display the emblem at their residences in
the countries of their accreditation.
(4) The emblem may be displayed on the buildings
occupied by India's Consulates abroad at the entrance
doors thereof and on the residences of Heads of
consular posts in the countries of their accreditation.”
11.
One of the significant aspects was addressed in the said Rule
in relation to a use of the Emblem in the official seal as the same
was restricted to the authorities specified in the First Schedule
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
appended thereto. While making the said Rules, the framers of the
law were conscious of the user of the Emblem in the vehicle and the
use thereof was restricted to the authorities enumerated in the
Second Schedule appended thereto.
12.
We are not concerned with the use of the Emblem for other
purposes as incorporated in Third Schedule, as the entire focus was
concentrated to the improper depiction of the Emblem in various
public buildings, including the precincts of the Courts. The
petitioner has also highlighted improper use of the Emblem in public
places, like Indira Gandhi Park, Bhubaneswar, where the motto,
"Satyameva Jayate" is conspicuously absent.
13.
The petitioner further flagged a significant and important
mistake having committed in the 1st Prize of 2024 TABLEAUX on
26th January, 2024, where the State of Odisha won the 1st Prize
during the 75th Republic Day Parade, as the motto, "Satyameva
Jayate" was not written below the profile of a lion capital and four
numbers of Ashoka Chakras were not encrypted under each lion in
between elephant and horse.
14.
Upon noticing such mistakes, the petitioner, being a public-
spirited person, filed the instant Public Interest Litigation seeking
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
the reliefs in the form of mandamus, so that immediate steps may be
taken against such misuse of the State Emblem of India and also to
create a mass awareness program amongst the common citizens of
India percolating the importance in legal, social and cultural values
of the said State Emblem.
15.
It would sheer augment the volume of the judgment in
adumbrating the stand of the State as it would be suffice to say that
the State, in its affidavit, has not only acknowledged their statutory
responsibility in guarding the improper use of the Emblem and
activating the process of the provisions of law but also admitted the
mistakes having committed and the remedial measures to be taken in
this regard.
16.
At the time of entertaining the writ petition and perceiving
the importance and the significance of the proper and reasonable use
of the Emblem, we requested Mr. Manoj Kumar Mishra and Mr.
Subir Palit, the Senior Members of the Bar to give their suggestions
by appointing them as Amicus Curiae. The suggestion of the learned
Amicus Curiae not only contains the suggestions but also the
initiatives to be taken ensuring the compliance and preservation of
the dignity of the Emblem. The learned Amicus Curiae highlighted
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
the importance of promoting social media awareness, which is most
powerful and cost-effective medium to reach out the citizens across
all age groups. The learned Amicus Curiae also suggested the
regular monitoring mechanisms by engaging the officials of the
State, not only to take action on the misuse of the State Emblem of
India but also to prevent such misuse.
17.
The setting up of the State Level Task Force was also felt by
the Amicus Curiae as a preventive measure and the Standard
Operating Procedure to regulate its functioning was also felt
necessary. According to learned Amicus Curiae, the timely reporting
of the misuse should be made accessible through Online Reporting
Portal and a Helpline number can also be assigned. All such broader
suggestions and the remedial measures highlighted by the Amicus
Curiae need deep introspection on its workability, feasibility and
implementation within the framework of law.
18.
It admits no ambiguity that despite the preventive and/or
prohibitory legislation being in place, the misuse appears to
continue, not with any malice or ill motive but by mistake, because
of the lack of proper awareness having inculcated into the users of
the said State Emblem. This phenomenon is not restricted to the
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
State of Odisha but in other States across the country and the Courts
of the country has frowned upon such improper use of the Emblem,
which can be envisioned from a Division Bench judgment of the
Karnataka High Court in Re: High Court Legal Services Committee
(Writ Petition No.4635 of 2024), decided on 4th April, 2025.
19.
The writ of mandamus was issued upon various authorities
and the preventive measures to be undertaken in the following:
“8. A writ of mandamus is hereby issued to
(i)
The Secretary, Ministry of
Home Affairs,
Government of India
(ii)
The Secretary, Ministry of Road Transport,
Government of India
(iii)
The Director, Ministry of Consumer Affairs,
Government of India
(iv)
The Principal Secretary, Department of Home,
Government of Karnataka and
(v)
The
Principal
Secretary,
Department
of
Transport, Government of Karnataka, to strictly
implement the provisions of,
(a) The Emblems and Names (Prevention of
Improper Use) Act, 1950;
(b) The Emblems and Names (Prevention of
Improper Use) Rules, 1982;
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
(c) The State Emblem of India (Prohibition of
Improper Use) Act, 2005;
(d) The State Emblem of India (Regulation of Use)
Rules, 2007 as well as Rules of 2010;
(e) All applicable provisions of Central Motor
Vehicle Rules, 1989, in particular Rules 50
and 51, as well as the applicable rules of
Karnataka Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989, in
particular 145-A;
9. The respondents are directed to instruct and require
all implementing authorities below them to ensure the
compliance of the aforementioned statutory provisions
of the Acts and the Rules.
10. In addition to the above general directions to
implement the Act and the Rules, the following specific
directions are given which would further sub-serve the
public purpose,
(i) The respondent-authorities are directed that notice
shall be issued by way of different public modes through
print and visual media to remove all kinds of
unauthorised
Flags,
Emblems,
Names,
Symbols,
Stickers, Seals, Logos of any kind which are prohibited.
There shall be instructions to all to remove such
emblems and discontinue unauthorised use thereof
within four weeks.
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
(ii) The higher-ups of the respondents shall chalk out the
methods and programmes to sensitise the officials and
implementing authorities to see and ensure that the
misuse of National Emblem and National Symbols in
various forms do not occur, stopped and prevented.
(iii) Where such conduct of using them unauthorisedly is
noticed, they are dealt with sternly.
(iv) The respondents shall instruct the implementing
authorities to register the cases under the provisions of
the relevant Acts and the Rules wherever the complaints
with regard to the misuse of the National Symbols and
Emblems are found correct. Necessary circulars in this
regard should be issued.
(v) The school children or the law students shall also be
involved in spreading awareness against misuse and
unauthorised display of National Symbols and Emblems
by any person, body or organization.
(vi) The respondents should frame regulations for
imposition of fine and for cancellation of driving licence
by providing such penal measures in the relevant Rules
for violating law on use of the National Emblems and
Symbols.
(vii) The traffic police should be educated by
undertaking programmes and imparting training to keep
observance and proper vigil to take penal action
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
whenever they come across the violation of the kind and
nature.”
20.
Such directions are exhaustive but apart from the same, we
feel certain directions would put an impetus to a due and meaningful
implementation of the provisions of the said Act. In order to
eradicate any confusion and/or discrepancy in understanding the
directions issued in the instant PIL, we hasten to add that the
directions by the High Court of Karnataka will be treated as an
integral part of the directions passed by us in the instant Public
Interest Litigation.
21.
We have noticed that because of the lack of proper
awareness, the misuse of the State Emblem of India appears to be a
reality. The awareness must be generated across the people of the
country, including the State of Odisha and the sense of responsible
use of the Emblem must be ubiquitously ensured. We thus pass the
following additional directions:
(i)
The State shall create a State Level Task Force, which would
comprise of a high-ranking Officer of the Home Department
to act as the Chairman thereof with one Member from Police,
Transport, Education, I & PR, Law, Urban and Panchayati
Raj to monitor and review any suggestion, objection and/or
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
reporting of the misuse of the State Emblem of India on a
monthly basis.
(ii)
The State shall make a Standard Operating Procedure for
functioning of the said State Level Task Force and would also
review the reports of the said Task Force to be submitted on a
monthly basis. The State shall create a unified online
reporting portal as a single window for accessibility of every
citizen of the country to upload the photos, videos, geo-tagged
complaints, which should contain the Frequent Asked
Questions (FAQs) illustrating the permissible and the
prohibited uses and the timely intervention and the action to
be taken shall be uploaded under the action taking icon. Such
portal not only to be integrated to the State Level Task Force
but also be integrated with the District e-offices to provide an
auto route to the DMs, SPs, and the RTOs.
(iii)
The convergence and the synergy to be created in the different
Departments of the Government, which would include the
local bodies and the civic bodies for due implementation of
the provisions of the said Act ensuring not only timely
intervention but may prevent any such misuse.
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
(iv)
All the institutions using the State Emblem must be
communicated in case of any mistake in depicting the State
Emblem to remedy and rectify such mistakes within six
weeks from the date of such communication.
22.
In the light of the observations and directions made
hereinabove, the instant writ petition is disposed of.
23.
Let this judgment be circulated amongst the different
Departments of the Government as well as the High Court for taking
remedial measures as suggested herein above.
24.
We put our note of appreciation to Mr. Manoj Kumar
Mishra and Mr. Subir Palit, learned Senior Members of the Bar for
their suggestions in the instant matter.
(Manash Ranjan Pathak)
Judge
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
S. Behera
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUMANTA BEHERA
Designation: Senior Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 05-Feb-2026 21:06:17
W.P.(C) No. 33077 of 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review