Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/29
GAHC040003342025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/13/2025
Nyajum Yinyo and 5 Ors
Son of Late Damnyo Yinyo, posted at Govt Upper Primary School, IG Park, Itanagar,
PO and PS Itanagar, Papum Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Smti Monya Boje
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Damo Boje
presently posted at Govt Upper Primary School
IG Park Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Yomto Sora
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Koyum Sora
presently posted at Govt Upper Primary School
Peri Kamki
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Pojar Gamlin
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Kopu Gamlin
presently posted at Govt Primary School
Gemo Tali
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Smti Larni Tajom
Age:
Page No.# 2/29
Occupation :
Wife of Shri Pojar Gamlin
presently posted at Govt Primary School
Gemo Tali
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Smti Dagbi Jilen
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Shri Yitak Jilen
presently posted at Govt Primary School
Raj Bhawan
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The State of AP and 5 Ors
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar 791111
2:The Commissioner Finance
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Finance
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
3:The Finance Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
4:The Secretary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
5:The Director of Secondary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
6:The Director of Elementary Education
Page No.# 3/29
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Education
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 79111
Advocate for the Petitioner
: A K Purkayastha, Dusu Rillung,Suraj Sharma,Uttam Deka
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), SC (Education),Taba Tagum
Linked Case : WA/14/2025
All Arunachal Pradesh Elementary Teachers Associations and Anr
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by its President
Shri Pill Takur
Son of Late Pill Teni
permanent resident of Village Korli
PO Yazali
PS Yazali
District Lower Subansiri
Arunachal Pradesh
Pin 791119. presently residing at P Sector
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
District Papum Pare
Arunachal Pradesh
Pin 791111
2: Pill Takur (Vice President)
Age: 47
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Pill Teni
permanent resident of village Korli
PO Yazali
PS Yazali
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh 791119 presently residing at P Sector
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh 791111
VERSUS
Page No.# 4/29
The State of AP and 8 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Chief Secretary
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
2:The Commissioner Finance
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Finance
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
3:The Finance Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Finance
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
4:The Secretary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
5:The Director of Secondary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
6:The Director of Elementary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Education
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
7:The Under Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 5/29
Address:Department of Education
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
8:The Director of Secondary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Education
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
9:The Director of Elementary Education
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Education
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
-----------Advocate for : A K Purkayastha
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 8 Ors: Advocate ,
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
Advocate for the appellants:
Mr. A. K. Purkayastha
Advocates for the respondents:
Mr. I. Choudhury,
A.G.,
Mr. T. Tagum, Edu. Dept.
Date on which judgment is reserved :15.06.2026.
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 16.09..2026.
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment
: Full judgment.
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced
:
Yes
Page No.# 6/29
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
(Susmita P. Khaund, J)
Case of the Appellants
1. The appellants are aggrieved by the common judgment and
order dated 09.01.2025 passed by the Single Bench in WP(C) No.
466/2022 as well as in WP(C) No. 151(AP)/2018, whereby both the
writ petitions were dismissed, being bereft of merits.
2. The State of Arunachal Pradesh represented by the Chief
Secretary; the Commissioner of Finance; the Finance Secretary,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh; the Secretary Education; the
Director of Secondary Education and the Director of Elementary
Education are arrayed as respondent Nos. 1 to 6 respectively in
W.A. No. 13(AP)/2025. In addition to the above respondents, The
Under Secretary, Government of Arunachal Pradesh; The Director
of Secondary Education, Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
Education Department and The Director of Elementary Education
are arrayed as respondent nos. 7, 8 & 9 respectively in W.A.
14(AP)/2025. Both the appeals are conjointly taken up.
3. The appellants in WA No. 13(AP)/2025 are, (i) Shri Nyajum
Yinyo, (ii) Smt. Monya Boje, (iii) Shri Yomto Sora, (iv) Shri Pojar
Gamlin, (v) Smt. Larni Tajom, and (vi) Smt. Dagbi Jilen; and the
appellants in WA No. 14(AP)/2025 are, (i) All Arunachal Pradesh
elementary Teachers Associations and (ii) Shri Pill Thakur.
Page No.# 7/29
4. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants that
the Single Bench has arrived at an erroneous decision that the
appellants are not entitled to arrear salary with effect from
01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013 and in view of such perverse findings,
the impugned judgment and order is not sustainable in law and is
liable to be set aside and quashed. It is contended by the learned
counsel for the appellants that the impugned judgment is vitiated
by the vice of perversity as the State Government may or may not
accept the recommendations of Pay Commission. It is submitted
that the Single Judge was not justified in holding that the Apex
Court has held that while exercising judicial review, it should not
interfere with the policy decisions having financial implication of
the State, in view of the settled proposition of law laid down by the
Apex Court in holding that the financial constraints or implication
cannot be resorted to, by the State Government in refusing to pay
the arrear of salary to the Government employees as lawfully
accrued under the recommendation of the 5 th and 6th CPC and
consequently the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside due
to apparent misconception of law.
5. The learned counsel for the appellants has contended that the
Single Bench was not justified in holding that the State
Government has got prerogative to deny the arrear of the
appellants by taking policy decision, in view of the fact that no
policy decision can take away the substantive and basic
fundamental and constitutional rights of citizens by taking the plea
of financial constraints more particularly, when the Government of
Page No.# 8/29
Arunachal Pradesh extended the benefits of arrear salary for the
period with effect from 01.04.1998 up to 31.03.2013 to the
employees of other Government Departments.
6. It is contended that the decision was in gross violation of the
constitutional mandate of equity as guaranteed under Article 14 of
the Constitution of India. It is averred that relinquishment, if any,
made by Arunachal Teachers Association (ATA for short) in course
of negotiation between the authorities and the ATA, this decision of
ATA does not have any implication so as to construe the appellants
to have relinquished or waived their bona fide and legitimate claim
for arrear salary w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013 under the 5 th
and 6th Central Pay Commission (CPC for short). The decision of
ATA relinquishing rights is dated 21.09.2011, which is marked as
annexure-A of the writ petition, and it clearly reflects that ATA in
an express and inequitable term relinquished the claim of the
appellants and all other teachers of Elementary Education for the
period
w.e.f.,
01.04.1998
to
31.12.2005
covered
by
the
recommendation of the 5th Pay Commission but did not at all waive
or relinquish the other part of the claim for arrear salary for the
period w.e.f., 01.06.2006 up to 31.03.2013 and is covered by the
recommendation of the 6th CPC. Consequentially, the impugned
decision of the Single Judge seems to have been vitiated by the
vice of perversity. It is submitted that even the High Power
Committee (HPC for short) constituted by the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh (vide annexure-G of the writ petition)
Page No.# 9/29
recommended for release of the arrear salary for the aforesaid
period as recommended by the 5 th and 6th CPC in a phased
manner, keeping in view the financial constraints through
implication of the State Government.
7. It is averred that the respondent authorities have admitted
through their affidavit-in-opposition that the Government after
acceptance and adoption of the recommendation of 5th and 6th
CPC in their entirety without any modification, alteration,
substitution etc., did not alter, modify, amend etc., any part of the
recommendations of the 5th and 6th CPC by taking any Cabinet
decision whatsoever. Thus, the Single Judge has erred by holding
that the State Government shall have the prerogative or discretion
to accept or not to accept the recommendations of 5 th and 6th
CPC.
8. It is submitted that Cabinet decision can be altered, modified,
substituted or amended by the Government only by way of another
Cabinet decision. It is further contended that it is a settled
proposition of law that once an affidavit is filed on oath, the same
affidavit cannot be substituted by any contrary affidavit, retracting
the earlier submission through the initial affidavit. It is averred that
the Single Bench has already taken into consideration the
subsequent
and
contradictory
affidavit
by
the
respondent
Authorities. Thus, in view of the negotiation between the ATA and
the Education Department, the Law Department examined the
claim of the appellants and took a decision to recommend a lump
Page No.# 10/29
sum amount of Rs. 5,64,000/- as arrear for the period w.e.f.,
01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013 which had accrued under the 5 th and 6th
CPC.
9. It is further emphasized through the argument that the decision
of the Single Judge was unreasonable and unconscionable, as per
the letter of the Government of India dated 02.02.2002, the
revised pay-scale vide order dated 15.02.2013, was notionally fixed
w.e.f., 10.04.1998 to 31.03.2013 and the actual benefits of the
revision was granted to w.e.f., 01.04.2013. It is ex facie erroneous
that the rules of the Central Government is not applicable to any
State other than Union territories and the impugned judgment and
order was based on misconception and wrong appreciation of
facts.
10. The appellants are aggrieved by the decision of the Single
Judge, the decision of the Finance Department as well as
Education Department and consequent notification orders dated
13.08.2009 and 08.09.2009, asnecessary approval was accorded
by the Government for providing the benefits of arrear salary i.e.,
the 5th and 6th CPC with effect from 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013. It
is submitted that arrear is a part of the salary. Arrear cannot be
denied on the plea of policy decision or financial constraints or on
the plea of relinquishment being made by a third party association
which violates the basic fundamental rights under Article 14 and 21
of the Constitution of India.
11. The Secretary of Finance namely, Mr. Tappi Loma vide Office
Page No.# 11/29
communication dated 02.02.2002, informed both the Secretary and
Commissioner of Education Department, Government of A.P., that
the Education Department being an Administrative Department
shall be required to file necessary affidavit-in-opposition in
connection with WP(C) No. 151(AP)/2018 and the Finance
Department decided not to file any separate affidavit-in-opposition
in connection with the writ petition and decided to rely entirely on
the affidavit of the Education Department.
12. Mr. Tappi Loma himself filed the affidavit-in-opposition in
connection with the petition being WP(C) No. 466(AP)/2022 and
the said admitted facts accordingly leads to the conclusion that the
higher authorities of both Finance and Education Department had
the knowledge regarding the pendency of the writ petitions and all
the affidavits filed by the Education Department in pursuance to
the decision of the Finance Department vide Office memo
communication dated 02.02.2022. It is further argued that the
suspension, and the departmental proceeding against the Director
of Elementary Education does not indicate that the affidavit filed
by him was a false affidavit and, it is prayed to set aside the
impugned decision of the Single Bench.
Respondents Case
13. An affidavit-in-opposition has been filed by the respondent
Nos. 4, 5 and 6. Through their affidavit-in-opposition and through
their oral argument, it is submitted on behalf of all the respondents
that the 5th Central Pay Commission recommendations came to be
Page No.# 12/29
implemented by the Government of India vide notification No.
GSR-569(A) dated 30.09.1997. Subsequently, the Government
implemented the 5th CPC, vide notification No. FIN/E/II/77/97
dated 09.10.1997. It was followed by another Office memorandum
No. FIN/E/II/77/97 dated 23.10.1997, whereby it had clarified the
revision of pay-scales in respect of the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, that the Part-A of the First Schedule would be applicable.
Thus, as per the aforesaid Office memorandum (O.M. for short)
dated 23.10.1997, the pay-scales as notified in Part-B and Part-C of
the Schedule would not be applicable to the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh.
14. Prior to the implementation of the 5 th CPC, the elementary
teachers were drawing a pay scale of Rs.1350-50-450-1440-401800-50-2200/1400-40-1800-50-2300. The pay-scale was revised
under the 5th CPC and accordingly, the elementary teachers were
paid at the pay-scale of Rs. 4500-125-7000 (entry scale). The
senior scale was revised to S-9 and they were revised to the payscale of Rs. 5000-150-8000 and the selection scale was revised to
S-10 and revised to pay-scale of Rs. 5500-175-9000.
15. Therefore, no arrear of salary is pending in respect of the
primary teachers/elementary teachers against the 5th CPC.
Annexure-A to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by respondent Nos.
4, 5 and 6 in W.A. 13/2025 is the copy of the First Schedule, Part-A
showing various revised pay scales notified by the 5 th CPC vide
notification dated 30.09.1997 and Annexure-B is the notification
Page No.# 13/29
dated 09.10.1997 and a copy of the O.M. dated 23.10.1997 is
marked as Annexure-C to the affidavit-in-opposition. It is further
contended by the respondents that after implementing the 5 th
CPC, the Government of Arunachal Pradesh had also implemented
the
recommendation
of
the
6th
CPC
vide
O.M.
No.
FIN/E/II/22/2008 dated 05.01.2009.
16. The pay-scale of the elementary teachers under the Education
Department was revised as per 6th CPC and ordered for
implementation of Part-B pay-scale under the 6 th CPC for teachers
serving under the Government schools of Arunachal Pradesh
corresponding to the 5th CPC w.e.f., 01.01.2006, vide order dated
08.09.2009 and order No. ED/II/556/2009. The teachers serving
under the Education Department including elementary teachers
have received the revised scale under 6 th CPC as notified by the
Education Department vide order dated 08.09.2009. Hence, no
arrear salary is pending with respect to the elementary teachers of
the Education Department even under the 6th CPC.
17. Learned Advocate General laid stress in his argument that after
receiving the revised pay scale as per 5 th CPC and 6th CPC,
suddenly the Association (ATA) started demanding revision and
enhancement of the pay-scale as per Government of India Letter
No. F.5-21/97/UT.1 dated 04.04.2002. It is emphasized on behalf of
the respondents that the letter dated 04.04.2002 issued by the
Government of India was specifically meant for Union Territories
Page No.# 14/29
mentioned therein and as such, it was not applicable to the State
of Arunachal Pradesh (Annexure F).
18. In response to such demand of the ATA, several meetings and
discussions with all the stakeholders were held and the financial
implication thereof was considered. The Government of Arunachal
Pradesh took a generous view and decided to accept the request
of the Association. Accordingly, the pay-scale of the elementary
teachers/Misc.teachers serving under the Education Department,
was revised and re-fixed by order No. ED2/550/2009 dated
15.02.2013,
issued
by
the
Commissioner
(Education).
The
Government of Arunachal Pradesh revised the pay-scale fixed by
the Government of India vide Letter dated 04.04.2002, although
such pay-scale was specifically meant for employees of Union
Territories of the Government of India and not for the Government
of Arunachal Pradesh. A plain reading of the order dated
15.02.2013, makes it abundantly clear that the concerned teachers
were already enjoying the benefits of the 5 th CPC recommendation
and what was granted by the said order was an additional benefit
in terms of the Government of India letter dated 04.04.2002.
(Annexure-G to the affidavit-in-opposition is the copy of the order
issued by the Commissioner).
19. It is averred that since the elementary teachers serving under
the Education Department of the State had already received a
revised pay scale under the 5th and 6th CPC, therefore, in order to
pay them higher pay-scale as mentioned in the aforesaid
Page No.# 15/29
Government of India letter dated 04.04.2002, the revised pay-scale
as mentioned in the aforesaid order dated 15.02.2013, was
notionally fixed w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013, and the actual
benefit of the revision was granted w.e.f., 01.04.2013. Accordingly,
all the concerned teachers represented by the ATA had accepted
the revised pay scale as notified by the Education Department vide
order dated 15.02.2013.
20. It is contended that all the appellants/writ petitioners herein
availed the benefit of the 5th CPC recommendations way beyond
what they were actually entitled to, and it appears that the
appellants/writ petitioners got wiser with passage of time and
preferred the connected writ petition i.e. WPC No. 151(AP)/2018 in
the year 2018, after a prolonged delay, claiming arrears of salary
w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013. Unfortunately, the Nodal Officer
(Court), the Office of the Directorate of Elementary Education,
namely, Shri Bamar Yinyo who is also an interested party in the
aforesaid connected writ petition and the former Director of
Elementary Education, namely, Sri Otem Tayeng had filed false
affidavits dated 27.02.2022, 18.10.2022 and the additional-affidavit
dated 16.05.2023, in the connected WP(C) No. 151(AP)/2018,
whereby the claim of the appellants/writ petitioners was falsely
admitted by misrepresentation of the factual aspects of the case
without the knowledge and approval of the competent Authority of
the Education Department at the Government level.
21. It is submitted that the Nodal Officer (Court) and the then
Page No.# 16/29
Director of Elementary Education were placed under suspension
and proceedings were drawn up against them. The Department of
Education filed a fresh affidavit-in-opposition on 12.09.2023,
through the Secretary, Education in WP(C) No. 151(AP)/2018.
22. Learned Advocate General laid stress in his argument that the
documents were available with the appellants/writ petitioners but
the appellants have suppressed all the relevant and material facts
in the present writ appeal. Documents were also placed before the
Single Judge but eventually in this writ appeal, these documents
have been suppressed by the appellants. On the basis of these
documents, the Single Bench was pleased to hold that no arrear
salary is pending in respect of primary/elementary teachers against
recommendation of the 5th CPC. It is alleged that the appellants by
resorting to blatant falsehood and suppression of relevant and
material facts, have tried to mislead this Court to achieve
something which they could not lawfully achieve in the connected
WP(C) No. 151(AP)/2018. It is no more res integra that a person
approaching the Court must come with clean hands as this Court
has the inherent power to refuse to proceed in the matter, so as to
prevent the abuse of the process of the Court.
23. Learned Advocate General laid stress in his argument that the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, by applying its best wisdom
and having considered all aspects of the matter including financial
implication thereof, had taken a conscious policy decision to extend
actual financial benefit in terms of the Government of India letter
Page No.# 17/29
dated 04.04.2002, although not applicable to the aforementioned
categories of teachers from 01.04.2013 onwards with notional pay
fixation benefit without arrears, vide order dated 15.02.2013,
which is within the prerogative and discretion of the State
Government.
It is submitted that such decision and order of the State
Government being in the realm of policy decision is not open to
judicial review. Hence, the instant writ appeal filed by the
appellants is not tenable in law and is liable to be dismissed.
24. The Hon'ble Apex Court has time and again held that Courts
while exercising the power of judicial review should not interfere
with the policy decisions having financial implication on the State.
In a catena of decisions, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has
repeatedly held that recommendations of Pay Commission are not
binding upon the State Governments and as such, the State may
not accept the Pay Commission's recommendations.
25. Heard learned counsel Mr. A. K. Purkayastha for the appellant. Also heard
learned A.G., Mr. I. A. Choudhury for the State of Arunachal Pradesh assisted
by learned Standing Counsel, Mr. T. Tagum for the Education Department.
26. The arguments have already been discussed in the foregoing discussions.
Before deciding both the appeals conjointly, an analysis of the decision of the
Single Bench is relevant.
Decision of the Single Bench
27. It was held by the Single Judge that the case as projected by
the writ petitioners in these two connected writ petitions was with
regard to the non-payment of purported arrear salary of
Page No.# 18/29
primary/elementary
teachers
serving
under
the
Education
Department, w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013. While raising the
preliminary objection, the learned Advocate General emphasized
that the writ petitions under consideration are barred by delay and
laches as evident from the challenges made therein, which pertain
to
minutes
of
the
ATA
meeting
held
on
21.09.2011,
recommendation of the High Power Committee dated 12.09.2012,
order dated 15.02.2013 and the speaking order dated 04.10.2014.
It is apparent that the delay was inexplicable.
28. It was held by the Single Bench that essentially the claim of
the writ petitioners was for payment of arrear salary w.e.f.,
01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013. Admittedly, the challenge made pertains
to minutes of ATA meeting dated 21.09.2011, recommendation of
the High Power Committee dated 12.09.2012, order dated
15.02.2013, and the speaking order dated 04.10.2014. However,
considering that some of the petitioners have approached the
Court in the year 2014 by filing WP(C) No. 463/2014, but, although
the same was dismissed on withdrawal, liberty was granted to file
afresh and accordingly, the present writ petition No. 151/2018 was
filed.
29. The Single Judge held that there was no delay and laches and
as such the writ petitions were not barred by delay and laches. The
Single Bench has held that the plea of the respondents that the
writ petitions are hit by the principles of waiver and estoppel has
force to a certain extent as the petitioners/appellants in both the
writ petitions were admittedly members of ATA and had renounced
Page No.# 19/29
their claim so made in the writ petitions. However, it was held that
the appellants could not be non-suited only on the principles of
waiver and estoppel and the plea of the appellants were
considered on merits.
30. It was held by the Single Bench that undisputedly, the 5 th CPC
recommendations came to be implemented by the Government of
India
vide
Notification
No.
GSR-569(E),
dated
30.09.1997.
Subsequently, the Government of Arunachal Pradesh implemented
the 5th CPC vide Notification No.FIN/E/II/77/97, dated 09.10.1997.
It
was
followed
by
another
Office
Memorandum
No.
FIN/E/II/77/97, dated 23.10.1997, whereby it was clarified that the
revision of pay-scale with respect to the State Government, the
Part 'A', of the First Schedule would be applicable.
31. Thus, it was held by the Single Judge that vide O.M. dated
23.10.1997, the pay-scales notified in Part-B and Part-C of the
Schedule would not be applicable to the Government employees of
Arunachal Pradesh. It was observed that prior to implementation of
the 5th CPC, the elementary teachers were drawing a pay-scale of
Rs.1350-50-450-1440-40-1800-50-2200/1400-40-1800-502300.Their pay-scale was revised under the 5 th CPC and
accordingly, the elementary teachers were paid at the pay-scale of
Rs. 4500-125-7000 (entry scale). The senior grade was revised to
S-9
and
they
were
revised
to
the
pay-scale
of
Rs.
5000-150-8000 and the Selection scale was revised to S-10 and
revised to pay-scale of Rs. 5500-175-9000.
Page No.# 20/29
32. It was thus held that the State respondents have clarified the
implementation of the First Schedule, Part-A of the 5 th CPC. The
O.M. dated 23.10.1997, was considered and it was held that no
arrear salary is pending in respect of primary/elementary teachers
against the recommendation of the 5th CPC. It was also held that
the record reveals that after implementation of the 5 th CPC, the
Government also implemented the recommendation of the 6th CPC,
vide O.M. dated 05.01.2009. Accordingly, the pay-scale of
primary/elementary teachers under the Education Department was
again revised as per the 6th CPC and ordered for implementation of
Part B pay-scale under the 6th CPC for teachers serving under the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh corresponding to 5 th CPC w.e.f.,
01.01.2006, vide order dated 08.09.2009. It was held that all the
teachers
serving
under
the
Education
Department
of
the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh including the appellants have
received the revised pay-scale under the CPC as notified by the
Education Department.
33. The Single Bench agreed with the submission of the Learned
Advocate General that the record reveals that ATA under which the
petitioners/appellants are also members, has demanded revision
and enhancement of the pay-scale as per Government of India
letter dated 04.04.2002, after having received revised pay-scale as
per the 5th and 6th CPC. The perusal of the letter dated 04.04.2002
issued by the Government of India, clearly depicts that the same
Page No.# 21/29
was meant for Union Territories. Thus, it was held not to be
applicable to the state of Arunachal Pradesh.
34. However, in response to such demand of the ATA, the
Government decided to accept the request of the Association and
accordingly, the pay-scale of the elementary teachers etc., serving
under the Department of the Government was revised and re-fixed
vide order No. ED/II/550/2009, dated 15.02.2013, issued by the
Commissioner (Education) of the Government of A.P. as per revised
pay-scale fixed by the Government of India vide letter dated
04.04.2002, although such pay scale was specifically meant for
employees of Union Territories, and not for the State of Arunachal
Pradesh.
35. It was held by the Single Bench that a bare perusal of the
order dated 15.02.2013, makes it amply clear that the concerned
teachers, including the petitioners were already enjoying the
benefits of the 5th CPC. Additional benefits were granted to them
in terms of the Government of India letter dated 04.04.2002. It
was held by the Single Bench that in order to pay the
primary/elementary teachers, including the appellants, higher payscale as per the Government of India letter dated 04.04.2002, the
revised pay-scale vide order dated 15.02.2013, was notionally fixed
w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013, and the actual benefit of the
revision was granted w.e.f., 01.04.2013. Accordingly, all the
teachers represented by the ATA had accepted the revised payscale as notified by the Education Department and have received
Page No.# 22/29
their pay-scale. Thus, the primary/elementary teachers, including
the petitioners/appellants have received their revised pay-scale
under the 5th and 6th CPC.
36. The Single Bench also dealt with the argument on behalf of the
appellants that the respondent Authorities have admitted
the
claim of the appellants/petitioners in their earlier affidavit and now
they cannot turn around and deny the same by filing a fresh
affidavit.
37. The fact that the Nodal Officer (Court) of the Office of the
Directorate of Elementary Education, namely, Sri Bamar Yinyo, is
also an interested party in the aforesaid writ petition and he and
the then Director of Elementary Education, namely, Sri Otem
Tayeng had filed false affidavits dated 27.02.2022 and 18.10.2022,
and the additional-affidavit dated 16.05.2023, and that the claim of
the appellants was falsely admitted by the misrepresentation of the
factual aspects of the case, without the knowledge and approval of
the competent Authority of the Education Department at the
Government level and upon having detected such serious
misconduct committed by the aforementioned two officers, the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh had placed them under
suspension and disciplinary proceedings have been initiated
against them and on that aspect, the Single Bench held that, “This
Court is not persuaded to take a view that the claim of the
petitioners has been admitted, but constrained to observe that
such action initiated against be brought to its logical conclusion.”
Page No.# 23/29
38. The Single Bench relied on the decisions of the Supreme Court
referred to by the respondents and held that the decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court clearly shows that the recommendations
of the Pay Commission are not binding upon the State
Governments and the State Governments may or may not accept
the Pay Commission's recommendations.
39. It was held by the Single Bench that the Supreme Court has
also held that the Court while exercising judicial review should not
interfere with the policy decisions having financial implications.
Stressing on the fact that in order to pay a higher pay-scale to the
teachers including the petitioners/appellants, serving under the
Education Department, the Government of Arunachal Pradesh, as
per the Government of India letter dated 04.04.2002, revised payscale vide order dated 15.02.2013, and the pay-scale was
notionally fixed w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013, and the actual
benefit of the revision was granted w.e.f., 01.04.2013.
40. It was also held that all the teachers including the petitioners
represented by the ATA had accepted the revised pay scale as
notified by the Education Department vide order dated 15.02.2013,
and have accepted and received the pay-scale, and the teachers
have already received the revised pay-scale under the 5 th and 6th
CPC. It was then held that the petitioners/appellants are barred
from claiming arrear salary w.e.f., 01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013. The
petitioners/appellants prayer for payment of arrear salary w.e.f.,
01.04.1998 to 31.03.2013, was held to be unjustified and thereby,
Page No.# 24/29
the prayer was rejected and the petition was dismissed as the
petition was found to be devoid of merits.
Decision
41. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions
at the Bar.
42. We record our concurrence to the decision of the Single Bench.
The decision of the Single Bench cannot be considered to be
perverse or erroneous. The Single Bench has elaborately discussed
the
issues
projected
by
the
appellants.
It is held the appellants have raked up an issue which, in fact, is
not an issue at all.
43. It has been correctly held that the pay-scale of the appellants
have been fixed notionally from the stage of 5 th and 6th CPC w.e.f.,
01.04.1998 up to 31.03.2013. It is true that the Pay Commission's
recommendation do not have binding force until accepted and
notified by the Government on a decision of the Cabinet. It is also
trite law that while exercising judicial review, a Court should not in
a routine manner interfere with the policy decisions having
financial implications on the State.
44. This Court cannot be oblivious of the fact that the appellants
demanded revision and enhancement of pay-scale as per
Government of India letter dated 04.04.2002, after having received
revised pay-scale as per the 5th and 6th CPC. The letter dated
04.04.2002 issued by the Government of India, clearly depicts that
Page No.# 25/29
the same was meant for Union territories only and was not
applicable to the State of Arunachal Pradesh. However, in response
to such demand, the State decided to accept the request of the
ATA and accordingly, the pay-scale of the elementary teachers etc,
serving under the Department was revised and re-fixed vide order
dated 15.02.2013, as per revised pay-scale fixed by the
Government of India vide letter dated 04.04.2002, notwithstanding
the fact such pay-scale was specifically meant only for employees
of the Union territories and not for the State of Arunachal Pradesh.
45. This fact alone clearly reveals that the appellants have not
been prejudiced and no fundamental rights as per Article-14 of the
Constitution has been violated.
46. Relating to the contradictory affidavits allegedly filed by the
two erring officials who were also interested parties, the Bench
refrained from passing any orders and the decision was left to the
wisdom of the Department. It was alleged by the Single Judge that
the Nodal Officer (Court) of the Office of the Directorate of
Elementary Education, namely, Bamar Yinyo and the former
Director of Elementary Education, namely, Otem Tayeng, had filed
false affidavits dated 27.02.2022, 18.10.2022 and 16.05.2023, in
connection with WP(C) No. 151(AP)/2018, whereby the claim of
the appellants was falsely admitted on behalf of the respondents
and without knowledge and approval of the competent Authorities
of the Education Department at the Government level.
47. The argument on behalf of the appellants that this affidavit has
Page No.# 26/29
been retracted and contradicted by another affidavit holds no
water. Equity prevails when any submission with misrepresentation
and misleading facts is ignored and the cause of the parties who
approach with clean hands are taken into consideration. It cannot
be held that the acceptance of the affidavit disowning the earlier
three affidavits dated 27.02.2022, 18.10.2022 and 16.05.2023,
allegedly submitted surreptitiously by the erring officials has not
been accepted by the Single Judge. The Single Judge did not take
a view that the claim of the appellants has been falsely admitted,
but the Bench left it to the Department to proceed with any action
if taken against the allegedly erring officials.
48. The cases of the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred by the
appellants in connection with writ petitions, i.e., WP(C)/466/2022
and WP(C)/151(AP)/2018, have also been referred to by the
appellants in connection with both these appeals and we agree
with the observation of the Single Bench that the facts and
circumstances of these appeals are not similar to the cases of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court referred to by the appellants.
49. After implementation of the 5th CPC, the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh had also recommended the implementation of
the 6th CPC vide O.M. dated 05.01.2009. Annexure-B is the O.M.
dated 09.10.1997, which clearly reflects that:“After fixation of pay as on 1-1-96, each employee may be allowed to draw
the difference of pay only between the pay fixed in the revised scale and the
pay drawn in the pre-revised scale. This, therefore, follows that the quantum
of other allowances drawn on pre-revised scale as on 1-1-96 other than
Page No.# 27/29
Dearness allowance, now merged with the revised pay scales will continue to
be drawn by the employees till further orders are received from the Govt. of
India. The revised allowances other than Dearness allowance will be effective
from 1st August, 1997. The arrears would be paid in cash with the stipulation
that, where the amount of arrear is less than Rs.5000/- it should be paid in
one installment and where it is in excess of Rs.5000/-, it should be paid in
two installments, in the first installment, payment should be restricted to
Rs.5000/- plus 50% of the balance amount of arrear.”
Annexure-C of the affidavit-in-opposition dated 29.07.2025 filed by
the respondent Nos. 4, 5 & 6 clearly reflects the O.M. dated
23.10.1997, notifying that:“(1) In so far as the revision of pay in respect of the Government employees
of Arunachal Pradesh is concerned, only the scale to scale revision as notified
in PART 'A' of the FIRST SCHEDULE to the said Rules will be applicable, The
scales of pay as notified in PART 'B' AND PART ‘C’ of the FIRST SCHEDULE to
the Rules, are not applicable to the Govt. employees of Arunachal Pradesh.
(2) This is in continuation of Government Office Memorandum
NO.FIN/E/11/77/97 dated 9-10-97.
50. Thus, there was a jump from Rs. 1350—2300 to 4500-125700, after the 5th CPC for the Elementary teachers and the Senior
scale was revised from 1400—2600 to 5000-150-8000 (S-9) and
the selection scale was revised to (S-10) from 1640—2900 to 550175-9000. It is not disputed that no arrear salary is pending in
respect of primary teachers/elementary teachers against the 5 th
CPC. Thus, it is apt to reiterate that no arrear is due under the 5 th
CPC.
51. Annexure-D of the affidavit dated 29.07.2025 is the O.M. dated
05.01.2009 and Annexure-E is the order dated 08.09.2009,
Page No.# 28/29
implementing Part-B pay-scale under the 6 th CPC for teachers
serving under the Government schools of Arunachal Pradesh
corresponding to the 5th CPC w.e.f., 01.01.2006. As the teachers
serving under the Education Department including elementary
teachers have received the revised scaled under the 6 th CPC, no
arrear salary is pending with respect to the elementary teachers of
the Education Department even under the 6th CPC.
52. Now, the demand of the appellants for arrear salary as per the
Government of India letter No. 04.04.2002, is not justified as the
Annexure-F of the affidavit clearly depicts the Government of
India’s order dated 04.04.2002, is for revision of pay-scales (senior
and selection scales)
for primary school teachers
in the
employment of the Government of India in Union territories and
other autonomous bodies and not for any State. This letter was
specifically meant for the Union territories but considering the
demand of the ATA, the Government took a generous view and
decided to accept the request of the Association. Through their
affidavit-in-opposition to the affidavit-in-reply, the appellants have
submitted that they have not claimed the benefits meant only for
the Union territories but their prayer is for the difference in the
arrear accrued which is a justified demand as the appellants have
been granted the benefits on the basis of the Government of India
letter dated 04.04.2002. The appellants are praying for difference
of arrear from 1998 to 2013.
53. Annexure-G of the affidavit-in-opposition is the order dated
Page No.# 29/29
15.02.2013, which makes it clear that the "scales of pay of the
appellants and similarly placed employees will be notionally fixed
from 5th CPC stage as adopted in the State level w.e.f., 01.04.1998
under relevant rules/orders and actual financial benefits thereof,
however will be tenable from 01.04.2013 i.e., pay and allowances
from the month of April, 2013 without arrears.” This makes it
abundantly clear that the teachers were already enjoying the
benefits of the 5th CPC and 6th CPC. The appellants thus failed to
contradict the statements and submissions of the respondents. The
appellants have received their dues of 5 th and 6th CPC and in
addition to their enhanced pay-scales, they have also reaped the
benefits of Pay revision meant for the Union territories.
54. Thus, it can be safely held that no prejudice is discernible.
There appears to be no justified ground to interfere with the order
impugned by the appellants.
55. Both the appeals are dismissed, being devoid of merits.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review