Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 161 of 2017
Date of Decision: 07.06.2022
Vs.
Shri Albert Suting
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. K.C. Gautam, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner is before this Court challenging the
impugned order of termination dated 01.09.2016 whereby the
petitioner was inflicted with major penalty of removal from service,
pursuant to ex parte Departmental Proceedings. Against the order of
termination, the petitioner had preferred a statutory appeal assailing
the same on the ground of denial of opportunity of being heard which
came to be dismissed by order dated 06.03.2017, affirming the
findings of the Disciplinary Authority. In the course of hearing of the
instant matter, the records of the said departmental proceedings were
also requisitioned from the respondent authority.
2.
As it appears from the pleadings and submissions that
have been made on behalf of the petitioner, the main ground is the
alleged denial of opportunity of hearing being afforded to the
petitioner and consequently, contentions have also been raised as to
the arbitrariness and irregularity in the proceedings, especially on the
factum of service of show cause notice and non-supply of the enquiry
report.
3.
The respondents on the other hand have outlined the track
record of the petitioner and have from the records endeavoured to
show that there has been no denial of rights as alleged and that in fact,
even after due notice, the petitioner voluntarily and with full
knowledge did not participate in the said enquiry, and as such no
prejudice has been caused.
4.
Mr. K.C. Gautam, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the proceedings against the petitioner was drawn up even
before the stage of issuance of show cause notice, and an Enquiry
Officer was appointed on 22.01.2016, prior to the issuance of show
cause notice and statement of allegations dated 18.02.2016. He further
submits that there is nothing on record to show that the showcause
notice dated 18.02.2016, was ever served upon the petitioner. It has
also been contended that even the newspaper publication dated
03.08.2016, directing the petitioner to appear was published after the
completion of the enquiry, and a copy of the enquiry report was never
served upon the petitioner. The learned counsel submits that the
proceedings were vitiated on account of serious procedural lapses
which has resulted in grave injustice being caused. Reliance has been
placed on the following judgments in aid of the petitioners’ case, on
the points of the essentiality the service of a show cause notice, the
supply of documents and list of witnesses, apart from the appointment
of an Enquiry Officer before commencement of the proceedings and
the non-supply of the Enquiry Report.
i)
UOI vs Dinanath Shantaram Karekar (1998) 7 SCC 569
ii)
State of Punjab vs. V.K. Khanna (2001) 2 SCC 330
iii)
State of Uttaranchal vs. Kharak Singh (2008) 8 SCC 236
iv)
State of U.P. vs. Saroj Kumar Sinha (2010) 2 SCC 772
5.
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA for the State
respondents in reply, has submitted that this is a case where the
petitioner has voluntarily abandoned his duties/service, and this fact is
clearly reflected from his long and un-authorized absence of a period
of 807 days, which ought to be viewed strictly, as the petitioner is a
policeman and a member of a disciplined force. It is also submitted
that the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition by suppressing
certain facts with a view to mislead this Court and that the records as
produced will make it amply clear that the petitioner was afforded
adequate opportunity which was not availed by him.
6.
The learned GA submits that as per office records the
petitioner on falling ill on 17.06.2014 was sent for medical check-up
to the Civil Hospital, Jowai and thereafter was referred to Nazareth
Hospital, Shillong as he was suffering from fatty liver, and after being
referred, never reported for duty thereafter, nor did he make a single
communication with his Department regarding his absence from duty,
or make a single effort to resume his duties. It is contended that there
was nothing that could have prevented the petitioner from re-joining
his duties, or from informing his superior authorities, and the
petitioner’s absence of 807 days without any information, would by
itself render the petitioner unfit to be retained in a disciplined service
like the police force.
7.
The learned GA on the facts regarding the disciplinary
proceedings, has taken this Court through the records to show that the
petitioner has been repeatedly served with notices since 12.02.2015,
asking him to report for duty, the receipt of the show cause notice
dated 18.02.2016 and also a subsequent notice dated 30.05.2016
directing the petitioner to appear before the Enquiry Officer on
17.06.2016. He submits that witnesses were examined which
corroborated the conduct of the petitioner and notices were even
issued in the newspapers as the petitioner failed to make any
appearance, which however failed to evoke any response from the
petitioner. He lastly submits that there is no infirmity or irregularity in
the proceedings, and in the context of the said proceedings, supply of
the enquiry report, was inconsequential taking into account the refusal
of the petitioner to participate or to respond to the repeated reminders.
The learned counsel apart from distinguishing the judgments placed
by the counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the case of Rajan
Kumar Mitra vs. Andrew Yule & Co. Ltd., & Ors. reported in (1997)
10 SCC 386, where he submits it has been held that where a delinquent
has chosen not to participate in the enquiry proceedings, he thereafter
cannot assail his termination on merits.
8.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties, considered
their submissions, examined the materials on record, especially the
records of the proceedings which has been produced before the Court
by the respondents. This Court though not sitting in appeal over the
findings of the Respondent authority, is concerned only in examining
as to whether adequate procedural safeguards were adopted and
whether natural justice has been violated as alleged and as such, while
considering this matter had called for the records, as there were
pointed contentions raised on the denial of opportunity being given to
the petitioner.
9.
Without further alluding to the submissions and
contentions raised on behalf of the parties, the examination of the
records by this Court, especially of the Departmental Proceedings, has
revealed as follows:
i)
After falling ill and referred to Nazareth Hospital on
17.06.2014, by order dated 01.12.2014, under the hand of
the Commandant, it has been noted that till the said date, no
information was received from the petitioner and his pay was
sought to be withheld. (Exhibit IV)
ii)
On 19.01.2015, a notice was issued to the petitioner
directing him to report back for duty within 7 days, the same
was received by the petitioner duly signed on 12.02.2015
(signature marked as Exhibit-VI A in the proceedings).
iii)
On 13.10.2015, a second notice was issued asking the
petitioner to report for duty failing which disciplinary action
was contemplated. This notice as per the report has also been
served upon the petitioner (signature marked as Exhibit-VII
B in the proceedings).
iv)
22.01.2016, order drawing up ex parte proceedings against
the petitioner on failure to respond to notices duly served.
v)
18.02.2016, a show cause notice along with statement of
allegations issued, however, the fact that the show cause has
been served cannot be conclusively established from the
records.
vi)
30.05.2016, notice issued directing the petitioner to appear
before the Enquiry Officer on 07.06.2016 duly received by
the petitioner on 31.05.2016 and again on 01.06.2016
(signature marked as Exhibit-X A, and XV A in the
proceedings).
vii)
07.06.2016 onwards statement of the PWs, eight in number
were recorded and it is noted before each sitting, notices duly
issued to the petitioner on 17.06.2016, received on
18.06.2016 (Exhibit-XVI A) 23.06.2016 received on
27.06.2016 (Exhibit-XX A). 22.07.2016 received on
27.07.2016 (Exhibit XXII).
viii) Newspaper publications/notices dated 03.08.2016 directing
the petitioner to appear within 5 days failing which the
Departmental Proceedings which was initiated was to be
disposed of ex parte. (Exhibit -XXV Shillong Times, and
Exhibit- XXVI Mawphor, Vernacular daily)
10.
The chronology of events as seen from the records show
that the petitioner from the date of referral to the Hospital in Shillong
i.e., 17.06.2014, remained in un-authorized absence and despite
notices being issued to him from 2014 onwards, for reasons best
known chose not to re-join his Battalion to resume his duties, nor did
he make any attempt to justify his unauthorized absence. It is not a
case where the proceedings were initiated behind the back of the
petitioner or that he was un-aware, as he was in receipt of repeated
notices during the pendency of the said proceedings. The respondents
as noted, had even resorted to publication of a notice in a few
prominent daily newspapers seeking his attendance which however,
did not evoke any response from the petitioner.
11.
The allegations of the petitioner as to the non-observance
of the principles of natural justice and that the proceedings were highly
irregular and not in accordance with law, are belied by his own
conduct as evidenced from the records. Notwithstanding the fact that
he may not have been in receipt of the show cause notice dated
18.02.2016, this alone cannot be taken in isolation to be a valid or a
cogent ground to be considered sufficient to annul the proceedings or
declare them invalid. A pertinent fact that cannot be overlooked is that
the proceedings were held ex-parte, as the petitioner refused to
respond even after being fully aware about the disciplinary
proceedings and the consequences it would entail on his nonparticipation. The further ground taken that the enquiry report had not
been supplied, is inconsequential in the facts of the present case and is
of no relevance, as in the view of this Court, the petitioner by his
actions had totally waived his rights in every respect to seek any other
relief or to question his termination at this stage.
12.
As observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court ‘one who
seeks equity must do equity’ and the petitioner being a member of a
disciplined force, where the standards of behavior and conduct stand
at a much higher plane than employees in other trades and professions,
the relief as claimed therefore cannot be sustained.
13.
For the foregoing reasons, and without further discussing
or dwelling upon the facts or the decisions as cited by the counsels,
this writ petition deserves no further consideration and is accordingly
dismissed.
14.
Parties to bear their own costs.
15.
Registry to return the records to the learned Government
Advocate.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
07.06.2022
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review