Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ORISSA HIGH COURT : CUTTACK
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
An application under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution of
India.
***
Akash Chhatar & Others
Petitioners.
…
-VERSUS-
Central Board of Secondary Education, New Delhi
represented through its Chairman, CBSE Integrated Office
Complex, New Delhi & Others
…
Opposite Parties.
Counsel appeared for the parties:
For the Petitioners
: Mr. Kunal Kumar Swain, Advocate
For the Opposite Parties
: Mr. T. Pattanayak, Adv.
(For the CBSE)
P R E S E N T:
HONOURABLE
MR. JUSTICE ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA
Date of Hearing : 11.02.2026 :: Date of Judgment : 26.02.2026
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
J UD G M E N T
ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA, J.—
1.
This writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioners
praying for quashing the impugned memorandum dated
08.10.2025 (Annexure-6 series) issued by the Under Secretary
(Confidential),
Central
Board
of
Secondary
Education,
Regional Office, Bhubaneswar and for issuance of necessary
directions to the Opp. Parties to publish the result of the
petitioners, in respect of their Senior School Certificate
Examination (Class-XII) within a stipulated time and to pass
such other order/orders or direction/directions as the Courts
deems fit and proper in order to give complete relief to the
petitioners.
2.
The case of the petitioners is that, they (petitioners) were
the regular students of Class-XII of Padampur Public School
in the District of Bargarh. They (petitioners) appeared their
Senior School Certificate Examination, 2025 (Class-XII) under
the Central Board of Secondary Education in Odisha Adarsha
Vidyalaya, Bandupali as the regular students on the basis of
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
the admit cards vide Annexure-2 series issued to them by the
CBSE (Opp. Party No.1). Though, in the said examination,
they (petitioners) had done extremely well, but their results in
the website were published on dated 13.05.2025 reflecting as
R.L., (Result Later) category. The Principal, Padampur Public
School, Padampur intimated them (petitioners) to the official
order dated 26.05.2025 issued by the Opp. Party No.2
(Regional Director, Central Board of Secondary Education,
Regional Office, Bhubaneswar) stating that, the petitioners
were found involved in unfair practice giving similar answers
in some subjects with other students in the same centre, for
which, their entire result of 2025 has been cancelled.
To which, the petitioners challenged the same by filing
WPC No.16032 of 2025 praying for quashing the cancellation
of their results and to direct the Opp. Parties to publish their
results.
The said Writ Petition vide WPC No.16032 of 2025 of the
petitioners were decided analogously with other writ petitions
by this Court and the Judgment thereof was passed on dated
15.09.2025 as per Annexure-3, wherein the C.B.S.E (Opp.
Party No.1) was directed to make an enquiry in terms of ByeWP(C) No.34046 of 2025
Laws 36 of the CBSE after giving reasonable opportunity of
participation to the petitioners stipulating the outer limit of
that enquiry within two weeks keeping all the contentions of
the parties open.
In pursuance to the said analogous Judgment passed on
dated 15.09.2025 in WPC No.16032 of 2025 along with other
WPCs vide Annexure-3 by this Court, the CBSE (Opp. Party
No.1) conducted an enquiry into the matter through its UFM
Sub-Committee and during the course of that enquiry, the
UFM Sub-Committee of the CBSE supplied a printed format to
the petitioners asking them 18 questions each in the form of
yes or
no such as i) whether he/she has adopted unfair
means or not, ii) what is the name of his/her principal iii) Do
you know the invigilators etc.
Out of the said 18 questions, the above 3 questions were
not related to the subjects in question.
3.
Thereafter, a copy of the memorandum dated 08.10.2025
vide Annexure-6 series were issued by the Under Secretary
(Confidential),
Central
Board
of
Secondary
Education,
Bhubaneswar (Opp. Party No.3) on behalf of Opp. Party No.1
(CBSE) to the petitioners informing them that:
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
They are found indulged in Unfair Means activity under
Rule 36.2(vi) & (viii) of the Examination Bye-Laws.
Accordingly, as per Rule 36.3(v) of the Examination ByeLaws of the Board, their results of Main Examination 2025 are
hereby cancelled in the subject(s) in respect of which, they were
found indulged in Unfair Means and they will be permitted to
appear in the examination next year i.e. 2026 subject to
meeting of other eligibility criterias under failure category.
4.
As per the writ petition of the petitioners, though, the
result of almost all candidates of the same centre has been
published, except few like the petitioners and their result has
been cancelled by the Opp. Parties clandestinely taking a
discriminating attitude towards them (petitioners), for which,
the above memorandum dated 08.10.2025 (Annexure-6 series),
i.e. the cancellation of their entire result alleging malpractice
in some subjects on the ground of giving similar answers with
their adjacent students in that centre cannot be sustainable
under law.
Therefore, the petitioners challenged the said Annexure6 series by filing this Writ Petition under Articles 226 & 227 of
the Constitution of India on the ground that,
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
when the results of other students of the same centre
have been published by the Opp. Parties and when no
incriminating material has been seized from the petitioners
relating to the adoption of any malpractice by them and when
neither the Principal, nor the centre superintendent or the
invigilators of that centre have made any allegation against
the petitioners regarding the adoption of any malpractice and
when the answers in the subjects in respect of the allegation
of malpractice has been alleged were in Multiple Choice form
and when the teachers of the same school have taught all the
students similarly in all subjects, then, on the ground of
similarity in the answers of the petitioners in some limited
subjects reflected in Annexure-6 series with other students
cannot be the basis for terming them (petitioners) that, they
had adopted malpractice during examination. For which, the
above
alleged
allegations
against
the
petitioners
being
baseless, the same are liable to be quashed.
5.
The Opp. Party Nos.1 and 2 adopted their counter filed
in
the
similar
nature
of
Writ
Petition
vide
WP(C)
No.31318/2025 as their counter in this Writ Petition and
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
challenged the Writ Petition of the petitioners taking their
stands that,
“the CCTV footages of both the Examination Centres
was sought by them for confirmation about the alleged
Unfair Means, but, the CCTV footage after 11.30 A.M. of the
examination centre were not made available in the centres,
though, all the examination centres were instructed to
install CCTV for the fairness of the examinations and
preserve CCTV recordings till two months after the result
declaration.
Although the Principals of the Examination Centres,
Centre Superintendents, Observers and few Invigilators
were called to appear before the UFM Sub-Committee during
enquiry, but there was total lack of cooperation by the said
officials. So, it is held and considered that the above
abnormalities
are
not
possible
without
the
active
involvement of the candidates.
As per Clause No. 36.3 (v) of the Examination Bye Laws
of the Board, the Board has the right to cancel the result of
all subjects of a student, if the Board is satisfied about the
use of unfair means in a paper or papers. Rule 36.3 (v) does
not compel cancellation of result of all candidates, the Board
has discretion to impose proportionate punishment.
In the present matter, keeping in view the findings of the
expert which showed abnormal patterns across certain
candidates; indicating possible use of UFM, the decision
taken by the Board was lawful.
Out of Total 1185 candidates in both the Centres,
885 candidates were considered having used UFM wherein
students
allowed
to
appear
in
Supplementary
Examination 2025 and 383 students (44 candidates of
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
Class-X and 339 candidates of Class-XII) were allowed to
appear in the Main Examination 2026. Out of 502
candidates (who were placed to appear in Supplementary
Exam 2025 in the order), 459 candidates were declared
pass either in Main Exam 2025 or Supplementary Exam
2025.
Under the CBSE, more than 46 lakh students will
be appearing in Class X and Class XII Examinations in
2026 from India and 26 countries abroad and if such
activities are left unattended and without apt punishment to
all involved, ensuring a fair conduct of examination will only
become a dream. Hence, strict action is the need of the hour.
As per Office Order dated 26.05.2025 asked to
the Odisha Adarsha Vidyalaya Sangathan to initiate
disciplinary action against the involved Principal and
invigilators of the concerned examination centres. In
response thereof, the Odisha Adarsha Vidyalaya Sangatha,
has informed that an enquiry in the matter is presently
being conducted. Copies of the Memorandum, Article of
Charges and the Memos of Evidence and List of Witnesses
of the Disciplinary Authority of the Odisha Adarsha
Vidyalaya Sangatha against erring/ delinquent officials are
ANNEXURE - D/1 Series.
The
Central
Board
of
Secondary
Education
(CBSE), vide Notice dated 12.09.2025, has issued a show
cause notice to Padampur Public School, Bargarh, Odisha
about its disaffiliation.
So, for the above reasons, the writ petition filed
by the petitioners is to be dismissed against them (Opp.
Parties).”
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
6.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
petitioners and the learned counsel Mr. T. Pattanayak for the
Opp. Party Nos.1 & 2.
7.
In support of the averments made in the Writ Petition,
the learned counsel for the petitioners relied upon the
following decisions:
I. Board of Secondary Education, Odisha and Another
Vs.
Gayatri Hota and Others:2001(I) OLR 398
II. Rajesh Kumar and Another Vs. The Institute of
(India): C.A. No.5057 of 1997 decided
on 25.07.1997
III. Vanshika Yadav Vs. Union of India & Others:
8.
Engineers
(2024)
SCC 743
As per the rival submissions of the learned counsels of
both the sides on the basis of the writ petition, counter and
rejoinder, the crux of this writ petition is that,
“whether
the
impugned
memorandum
dated
08.10.2025 Annexure-6 series issued by the C.B.S.E.
regarding the cancellation of the results of Senior School
Certificate
Examination,
(Class-XII)
of
the
petitioners alleging their indulgence in adopting unfair
means during examination in some limited subjects
indicated in Annexure-6 Series given similar answers in
some questions thereof with other students in the same
centre is sustainable under law?”
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
9.
It is the undisputed case of the parties that,
“neither
the
centre,
in
which
the
petitioners
were
appearing examination was scratched on the ground of mal
practice nor there was any report from the principal, centre
superintendent, invigilators or any flying squad about any mal
practice by any students including the petitioners in the said
centre or any incriminating material was found from the
possession of the petitioners or from the examination hall.
The result of Senior School Certificate Examination, 2025
(Class-XII) of the said centre, in which, the petitioners were
appearing has not been cancelled except the petitioners along
with some other few students, but the result of all other
students were duly published. Much after the evaluation of the
answer sheets of the petitioners, the final result of the
petitioners has been cancelled on the ground that, the
petitioners were found involved in the use of suspected unfair
practice, as there are similarity of answers in some questions
and mistakes committed by the students..
As per the report of the UFM Sub-Committee of the CBSE,
as the petitioners could not answer some of the questions put to
them during enquiry by the members of that UFM SubCommittee, then, on application of Rule 36.2 (vi) & (viii) of the
examination Bye-Laws of the CBSE, their results of 2025 have
been cancelled.”
10. It is the specific/definite plea of the Opp. Party Nos.1
and 2 in Para No.9 of their counter which was filed in WPC
No.31318 of 2025 and which was adopted in this writ petition
that,
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
“all the examination centres were instructed by the CBSE (Opp.
Party No.1) to install CCTV for the fairness of the examinations
and to preserve the CCTV recording till two months after the
declaration of the result, but the same has not been followed.
The principals of the examination centres, centre superintendents
and invigilators, those were called to appear before the UFM
Sub-Committee, they did not cooperate the UFM Sub-Committee.”
11. The above pleas of the Opp. Party Nos.1 and 2 in their
counter supported with an affidavit is going to show that, the
principals of the examination centres, centre superintendents
and invigilators being the agents of the Opp. Party No.1
(CBSE), they have not acted as per the directions of their
principal i.e. Opp. Party No.1 (CBSE) for conducting the
examinations, in the manner, they were instructed to conduct.
12. When the CBSE (Opp. Party No.1) published the final
result of all the students of the same examination centre
except
the
petitioners
and
some
other
few
students
forgiving/condoning the negligent acts of their agents i.e.
principals, centre superintendents and invigilators of the said
centre in conducting the examination, then, at this juncture,
the Opp. Party Nos.1 and 2 should not have cancelled the
result of the petitioners alleging adoption of malpractice
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
against them in respect of some subjects by each petitioners
indicated in Annexure-6 Series on the basis of inference,
surmises
and
conjectures
without
any
direct
evidence/material.
So, the above conduct of the Opp. Party Nos.1 and 2 i.e.
the adoption of pick and choose method in publishing the
final result of all the students except the petitioners along
with some other few students without any direct evidence or
material is not free from discrimination, which is ultimately
affecting the right to equality guaranteed under Article 14 of
the Constitution of India, 1950.
When there is no authentic/concrete legal proof before
the UFM Sub-Committee to reach in a definite conclusion that,
the petitioners had adopted malpractice during examination
in respect of some answers in some limited subjects indicated
in Annexure-6 series, then, at this juncture, the cancellation
of the result of the petitioners as per Annexure-6 series on the
basis of asking some questions to the petitioners during
enquiry
by
UFM
Sub-Committee
Members
cannot
be
sustainable under law.
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
Because, the aforesaid decision of the Members of the
UFM-Sub-Committee is on presumption, conjectures and
surmises without any legal basis.
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already been
clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:
(A) In a case between Board of Secondary
Education, Orissa, Cuttack Vs. Gayatri Hota
and Others reported in 2001 (I) OLR 398
that,
malpractice
in
examination
and
cancellation of results—Results of some
examinees were withheld for taking recourse of
malpractice in examination—Out of them some
were exonerated and the result of the
petitioners were cancelled as decided by the
examination committee—Neither the centre
superintendent nor or from any other quarter,
there was complaint of malpractice. There was
possibility of some similarity in answers as the
questions were objective in nature and those
were short questions. On the basis of suspicion,
a positive decision cannot be arrived at.
(B) In a case between Rajesh Kumar and
Another Vs. The Institute of Engineers
(India) decided in Civil Appeal No.5057 of
1997 (SC) on 25.07.1997 that, results of some
candidates withheld for adopting unfair means
and
malpractices
in
the
examinations.
Explanations of examinees not accepted-Results
of the said examinees cancelled-Suit by two of
the said examinees before Civil Court-When the
matter came before the High Court, it directed
the Institute to redecide the matter-This time the
Institute adopted a new technique to test the
ability of the examinees and decided the matter
against them-Held, the orders of the Institute in
cancelling the results of the appellants'
examinations and disqualifying them for two
succeeding examinations were in access of
jurisdiction and are quashed. The Institute
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
should declare the result of the examinees
forthwith.
(C) In a case between Chairman, J & K State
Board of Education Vrs. Feyaz Ahmed Malik
& Others reported in AIR 2000 SC 1039 that,
matters concerning campus discipline of
educational institutions and conduct of
examinations, the duty is primarily vested in
the authorities in-charge of the institution, and
in such matters Court should not try to
substitute its own views in place of the
concerned authorities nor thrust its views on
them.
(D) In a case between Harish Chandra Tewari
& others Vs. The Board of H.S. & Another
reported in AIR 1981 (All.) 144 that, the
Hon’ble Division Bench did not accept the
charge of copying solely on the ground that,
the answers of the true translation given by
the examinees remarkably tallied with one
another and also held that, similarity in
some of the answers in the two answer books
in question was not proper, there being no
direct evidence that, any one observed the
petitioner using unfair means during the
course of the examination. Cancellation of
result quashed.
(E) In the cases between Basanta Kumar
Pradhan & Others Vs. State of Orissa &
Others reported in 2011 (1) OJR 868 that,
there was allegation of malpractice—which was
challenged before the High Court—Held, the
examination committee should have sufficient
materials to come to a conclusion that, there
was malpractice and it cannot base their
decisions on presumption, conjectures and
surmises, as no incriminating materials were
found from the possession of any particular
student nor were found from the examination
halls as would been from the report of the flying
squad. Held, the decisions of the Examination
Committee to award ‘00’ marks to the petitioner
in History Paper-1 of Higher Secondary +2
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
Examination, 2009 cannot be sustained. (Para
Nos.5 to 7)
13. Here in this matter at hand, when the result of the
examination of all the students of the same centre, in which
the petitioners had appeared has already been published in
due time, but when the result of the petitioners along with
some other few students have been cancelled on the ground of
their indulgence in malpractice in some questions in respect
of some limited subjects indicated in Annexure-6 series during
examination alleging similar answers with other students and
when neither the principal nor the centre superintendent or
the invigilators of the examination centre had alleged any
allegation regarding adoption of any malpractice by the
petitioners during examination and when as per law, the
conduct of examinations is primarily vested in the authorities
in charge of the institution at the time of conducting
examination and when there was no allegation regarding the
adoption of any malpractice by the petitioners during
examination by the in-charge of the examination centre, who
was vested with all powers and authorities to conduct the
examination and when the results of the petitioners have been
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
cancelled due to giving incorrect answers in some questions of
the members of the UFM Sub-Committee, then, at this
juncture, by applying the principles of law enunciated in the
ratio of the aforesaid decisions, the cancellation of result of
the Senior School Certificate Examination (Class-XII), 2025 of
the petitioners on the basis of inference, presumptions,
conjectures and surmises without any direct evidence or
material is not sustainable under law.
Therefore, there is justification under law for making
interference
with
the
impugned
memorandum
dated
08.10.2025 (Annexure-6 series) issued by the Under Secretary
(Confidential),
Central
Board
of
Secondary
Education,
Regional Office, Bhubaneswar through this writ petition filed
by the petitioners. For which, the Annexure-6 series are liable
to be quashed.
14.
As such, there is merit in the writ petition filed by the
petitioners. The same is to be allowed.
The
impugned
(Annexure-6
series)
(Confidential),
Central
memorandum
issued
Board
dated
08.10.2025
by
the
Under
Secretary
of
Secondary
Education,
Regional Office, Bhubaneswar are quashed.
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
15.
All the Opp. Parties are jointly and severally directed to
publish
the
result
of
the
Senior
School
Certificate
Examination (Class-XII) of the petitioners 2025 within a week
from the date of this Judgment and to communicate the result
of the petitioners as well as its consequential certificates and
mark sheets as per the rules immediately after publication of
their results.
16. As such, this writ petition filed by the petitioners is
disposed of finally.
High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
The 26 .02. 2026// Rati Ranjan Nayak
Sr. Stenographer
(ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA)
JUDGE
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RATI RANJAN NAYAK
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC
Date: 27-Feb-2026 17:25:06
WP(C) No.34046 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review