Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 14TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 25371 OF 2015
PETITIONER:
AJAYAKUMAR E.K.
DEVASWOM OFFICER, SREE POORNATHRAYEESA TEMPLE,
TRIPUNITHURA, RESIDING AT KRISHNAKRIPA, CHOTTANIKKARA
P.O., ERNAKULAM - 682 312.
BY ADVS.
SMT.K.R.KRISHNAKUMARI
SMT.P.V.RADHAMANI
RESPONDENTS:
COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, OFFICE OF THE COCHIN
DEVASWOM BOARD, DEVASWOM BUILDING, THRISSUR - 680 001.
THE SPECIAL DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER
OFFICE OF THE COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD, DEVASWOM
BUILDING, THRISSUR - 680 001.
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER (VALUABLES)
OFFICE OF THE COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD, DEVASWOM
BUILDING, THRISSUR - 680 001.
THE DEVASWOM ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
TRIPUNITHURA GROUP, THRIPUNITHURA- 682 301.
ADDL.R5 SMT.KOMALAM,
HARICHANDANAM HOUSE, SANSKRIT COLLEGE ROAD,
TRIPUNITHURA-682 301.
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
ADDL.R6 SRI.VASUDEVAN MOOTHATHU,
ILAYIDATH ILLOM, KOTTAKKAKOM, TRIPUNITHURA-682 301.
ADDL.R7 SRI.M.MOHANAN MENOKKI [EXPIRED]
MEPPARAMBATH HOUSE, PUNITHURA P.O., TRIPUNITHURA-682
301. [ADDL.R5 TO R7 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
28/03/2023 IN I.A-1/2022 IN WP(C) 25371/2015]
ADDL.R8 SRI.SIVASANKARAN MENOKKI,
MEPARAMBATH HOUSE, PUNITHURA.P.O., TRIPUNITHURA-682301
[ADDL.R8 IS THE LEGAL HEIR OF THE DECEASED 7TH
RESPONDENT AS PER ORDER DATED 28/03/2023 IN I.A-1/2023
IN WP(C) 25371/2015]
BY ADVS.
SRI.KRISHNA MENON, SC, COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD
L.RAJESH NARAYAN
SRI.G.RAJAGOPAL, SC, COCHIN DEVASWOM BOARD
K.P.SUDHEER
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI. K. P. SUDHEER, SC, CDB
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
05.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
JUDGMENT
Muralee Krishna, J.
The petitioner who is the Devaswom Officer of Tripunithura
Devaswom under the management of the 1st respondent Cochin
Devaswom Board filed this writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking the following reliefs:
“a) To issue a writ of certiorari or other appropriate writ,
order or direction quashing Exts.P7, P8
and P14 to the
extent of fixing the liability of one fourth of Rs.28,650/- for
the loss of articles which have not yet been handed over to
the petitioner as unsustainable and in violation of the
petitioner's fundamental rights under Articles 14 & 21 of the
Constitution of India since those items were lost prior to
27.06.2006, i.e., the date of taking over charge by the
petitioner as the Devaswom Officer, Tripunithura Group;
b) To issue a writ of certiorari or other appropriate writ,
order or direction quashing Clause (7) of Ext.P7 to the extent
of fixing the liability for the loss of articles which have not
yet been handed over to the petitioner as unsustainable
since those items were lost prior to the date of taking over
charge
by
the
petitioner
as
the
Devaswom
Officer,
Tripunithura Group;
c) To declare that the petitioner is not liable to discharge the
liability of one fourth of Rs.28,650/- for the loss of articles
which have not yet been handed over to the petitioner as
unsustainable and in violation of the petitioner's fundamental
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
rights under Articles 14 & 21 of the Constitution of India since
those items were lost prior to the date of taking over charge
by the petitioner as the Devaswom Officer, Tripunithura
Group;
d) To issue a writ of certiorari or other appropriate writ, order
or direction quashing Ext.P6 to the extent of fixing the
liability of Rs.33,884.85 for the loss of articles which have
not yet been handed over to the petitioner and which were
lost long prior to the date of taking over charge by the
petitioner as the Devaswom Officer, Tripunithura Group as
unsustainable and in violation of the petitioner's fundamental
rights under Articles 14 & 21 of the Constitution of India.
e) To issue a writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ,
order or direction directing the respondents 1 to 3 to refund
an amount of Rs.33,884.85 which was alleged as liability and
compelled to be deposited by the petitioner as per Ext.P5
series receipts;
f) To issue a writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ,
order or direction directing the respondents 1 to 3 to prepare
and maintain the Pandam Pathram Register and Major
Eradavu
Register
Tripunithura,
after
in
Sree
rectifying
Poornathrayeesa
the
anomalies
Temple,
in
those
Registers, in compliance with the direction of the 1 st
respondent in Ext.P2 order;
g) To issue a writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ,
order or direction directing the respondents 1 to 3 to prepare
and maintain Thanathu Register in Sree Poornathrayeesa
Temple, Tripunithura.
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
h) To declare that the petitioner is not liable to discharge
any liability in respect of the loss of any movable and
immovable properties under the Tripunithura Devaswom
Group due to the anomalies in the Pandam Pathram Register
and Major Eradavu Register in Sree Poornathrayeesa Temple,
Tripunithura and due to the absence of Thanathu Register in
the Tripunithura Devaswom Group, the charge of which have
not yet been handed over to the petitioner”.
2.
The
petitioner
entered
service
as
Devaswom
Assistant/LDC under the 1st respondent Cochin Devaswom Board
in Chottanikkara Devaswom on 06.11.1996.
He was promoted
and posted in the grade of Devaswom Officer at Chottanikkara
Devaswom on 01.04.2002. He took charge as Devaswom Officer
in Tripunithura Devaswom on 28.06.2006. Sree Poornathrayeesa
Temple is the only temple under Tripunithura Devaswom.
Immediately on taking charge, the petitioner noted several
anomalies in the Pandam Pathram Register
(‘P.P. Register’ in
short) and Major Eradavu Register (‘M.E. Register’ in short) kept
in the temple and by way of Ext.P1 letter dated 31.07.2006 he
informed these anomalies to the 4th respondent Devaswom
Assistant Commissioner. According to the petitioner, there are
three P.P. Registers in Tripunithura Devaswom. They are (i) P.P.
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
Register
in
the
custody
of
the
Assistant
Commissioner,
Tripunithura Devaswom in which the articles referred to therein
are in the joint custody of Assistant Commissioner, Devaswom
Officer, Moothathu and Menokki in the temple, (ii) P.P. Register in
the custody of Devaswom Officer; and (iiii) P.P. Register in the
custody
of Mel
Santhi. As per
Ext.P2
proceedings
dated
28.09.2006, the 1st respondent authorized the Pandam Pathram
Special Officer who is at present re-designated as Assistant
Commissioner
(Valuables)
(3rd
respondent)
to
conduct
an
inspection on the anomalies reported in Ext.P1. But no inspection
was conducted by the 3rd respondent till date.
2.1.
While so, the Test Audit of Receipt Accounts of
Tripunithra Devaswom for the year 2005-2006 was conducted
from the office of Deputy Director of Local Fund Audit, Cochin
Devaswom Board, Thrissur, with effect from 23.05.2007. As per
Ext.P3 audit notes of the Test Audit it was found that the charge
of the items in P.P. Registers and M.E. Register were not handed
over to the petitioner by his predecessors and there are anomalies
in those Registers. By Ext.P4 letter dated 18.01.2008, the
petitioner requested the 2nd respondent Special Devaswom
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
Commissioner to issue orders for repairing the gold Kolam and
gold Golaka which are being used for the temple festivals in the
months of Vrischikam and Kumbam. The said letter was annexed
with Ext.P4(a) letter dated 15.01.2008 of the Thanthri of the
temple. Pursuant to Ext.P4 and P4(a), the 3rd respondent
inspected the gold Kolam and Golaka and also other items in the
P.P. Register and found that certain items lost weight and some
items are missing. This Court interfered in the above issue and
ordered to repair the gold Kolam and gold Golaka based on the
report of the observer appointed by this court.
2.2.
In the year 2010, the then Pandam Patram Special
Officer inspected the articles mentioned in the P.P. Registers and
found certain articles missing. As orally directed by the 3 rd
respondent, in order to rectify the P.P. Register and M.E Register
which are in the custody of the Devaswom Officer, the petitioner
deposited some amounts and was issued with Ext.P5(a) to P5(e)
receipts for a total sum of Rs.33,884.85/-.
2.3.
Thereafter the 2nd respondent issued Ext.P6 order
dated 19.05.2010 regarding the inspection of P.P. Register in the
Devaswom and exonerated the petitioner from the liability of
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
missing articles after recording the payments effected by the
petitioner by Ext.P5 series. But on 19.05.2010 the 2nd respondent
issued Ext.P7 order also fixing the liability of missing articles
referred to in the P.P Register which is in the joint custody of
Assistant
Commissioner,
Devaswom Officer,
Moothathu
and
Menokki.
In that order, the 2nd respondent found that the
Devaswom Officer is solely responsible for the missing articles in
the M.E. Register. On 19.05.2010 itself the 2nd respondent issued
Ext.P8 notice fixing the liability of missing articles assessed as per
Ext.P7 to all the four joint custodians including the petitioner. On
receipt of Exts.P7 and P8, the petitioner submitted Ext.P9
explanation dated 03.06.2010 producing therewith Ext.P9(a)
photocopies of relevant pages of P.P Register.
From the said
document, it is evident that the key of the Kallara Bhandaram
which is in the joint custody of the aforesaid four persons was
handed over to the then Devaswom Officer only on 31.10.2002
and thereafter the key was not handed over to the successor.
2.4. On 07.04.2011 this Court passed Ext.P10 order dated
07.04.2011 in I.A. No. 716 of 2011 in an unnumbered R.P. of 2011
in DBA No. 11 of 2011 directing that the petitioner and the
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
Assistant Engineer shall not be entrusted with any other official
duties or shall not be transferred until the renovation work of the
Sreekovil of Sree Poornathrayeesa temple is completed. By
Ext.P11 order dated 27.04.2011, the 2nd respondent directed the
petitioner to participate in the discussion in respect of rewriting of
the P.P. Register in the temple to be held in the chamber of the 2nd
respondent on 03.05.2011. After discussion on that date, the 2 nd
respondent passed Ext.P12 order, but no decision has been taken
on the rewriting of the P.P. Register. Though the petitioner sent
several reminders to the respondents, no action has been taken
to implement Ext.P2 order and to rewrite the Registers in the
temple.
2.5. On 11.11.2013 the petitioner submitted Ext.P13
representation before the President and Members of the 1 st
respondent, requesting to take steps to rectify the existing
anomalies and rewrite all the Registers. But without considering
the explanations of the petitioner as well as the other joint
custodians and without hearing the affected parties including the
petitioner, the 2nd respondent passed Ext.P14 order dated
26.12.2014 fixing the liability of Rs.28,650/- to the four joint
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
custodians and directing them, including the petitioner, to remit
one-fourth of that amount. On receipt of Ext.P14, the petitioner
submitted
Ext.P15
representation
to
the
2nd
respondent.
Thereafter the petitioner approached this Court with the above
writ petition.
3.
On 19.08.2015 when this writ petition came up for
consideration, the learned Standing Counsel for Cochin Devaswom
Board took notice for the respondents. This Court granted an
interim order staying all further proceedings pursuant to Ext.P14
for effecting the recovery of one-fourth of Rs.28,650/- from the
petitioner for the loss of the articles, on condition that the
petitioner provides fixed deposit receipt for Rs.28,650/- drawn on
his name in a Nationalised Bank of his choice and lien marked in
favour of Cochin Devaswom Board within a period of two months,
before the Registrar General of this Court.
4. On 15.10.2015 as per the order in I.A. No.12599 of 2015,
the interim order imposing a condition to provide a fixed deposit
receipt for Rs.28,650/- by the petitioner was modified to the effect
that the petitioner has to produce a fixed deposit receipt for
Rs.7200/- within a period of three weeks. In pursuance to the said
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
direction, the petitioner produced the fixed deposit receipt along
with a memo and it was kept in the safe custody of the Registrar
General as item No.946 which was renewed from time to time.
5. By I.A. No.1 of 2022, the petitioner sought impleading of
additional respondents 5 to 7. When notice was issued to the
proposed additional respondents it was reported that the notice
issued to the 7th respondent was returned with an endorsement
'deceased’.
Thereafter the petitioner filed I.A. No.1 of 2023
seeking to implead additional 8th respondent stating that he is
competent to represent the estate of the proposed additional 7 th
respondent who is no more. As per the order dated 28.03.2023
in I.A. No.1 of 2023, additional respondents 5 to 8 were impleaded
in the writ petition. It was ordered that whether or not all the
legal heirs of the deceased 7th respondent need to be impleaded
is a matter to be decided at subsequent stages of the proceedings.
6. By I.A. No.7629 of 2017 dated 19.05.2017, the petitioner
produced Exts. P17 to P19 documents.
7. The 1st respondent Cochin Devaswom Board filed a
counter affidavit dated 11.02.2025 opposing the averments in the
writ petition. Paragraphs 3 and 4 of that counter affidavit read
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
thus:
“3. Chapter 4 of the Devaswom Manual deals with the
registers to be maintained by the 1st respondent. Clause 16
deals with Major Eradavu Register. In this regard true copy
of the relevant pages of Chapter 4 of the Devaswom Manual
is produced herewith and marked as Exhibit R1 (a).
According to the petitioner, when he assumed charge as the
Devaswom Officer of Thripunithura devaswom he realised
that the registers kept in the temple had not been properly
maintained and several anomalies were existing in the
registers. It was in that circumstances the petitioner
submitted
Exhibit
P1
letter
dated
31.07.2006.
The
contention of the petitioner that no inspection was
conducted by the 3rd respondent regarding the anomalies
alleged in respect of the registers maintained in the office
of Sree Poornathrayeesha Temple is incorrect. During the
pendency of the above writ petition, the Honourable
Supreme Court in SLP (Civil) No. 7947/2018 appointed the
then Registrar General of this Honourable Court to prepare
an inventory of the valuables in the temple and a detailed
report and inventory was also submitted before the
Honourable Supreme Court.
4. According to the petitioner, the predecessor of the
petitioner has not handed over the items mentioned in the
registers maintained in the temple in question. The
petitioner concedes that by Exts. P5(a) to P5 (e) receipts an
amount of 33,884.85/- was remitted by him. The contention
of the petitioner that by Ext.P6 order dated 19.05.2010 he
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
was exonerated from the liability of missing articles is
incorrect. Exhibit P6 would show that in view of the
remittances effected by Exhibits P5 (a) to (e), the 2 nd
respondent passed Exhibit P6 order. Exhibit P7 order was
issued in respect of the missing articles which was in the
joint custody of the Assistant Commissioner, Moothath,
Menokki and the petitioner (Devaswom Officer). The
Devaswom Officer cannot shirk his responsibility in respect
of the articles included in the Major Eradavu register. Ext.P8
notice dated 19.05.2010 was issued to the petitioner and
other persons responsible for the missing of articles. It is
also alleged that no personal hearing was afforded to the
petitioner before issuing Ext.P14 order dated 26/12/2014.
Ext.P15 is the representation submitted by the petitioner on
receipt of Ext.P14 order. The contention of the petitioner
that the amount deposited in terms of Ext.P5 (a) to (e)
receipts are liable to be refunded is unsustainable. It is
submitted
that
there
is
absolutely
no
illegality
or
arbitrariness in issuing Exts. P7, P8 and P14 orders. The
said orders were issued after considering the explanations
offered by the petitioner. So, the petitioner is not entitled to
get any relief and the writ petition may be dismissed with
costs.”
8. To the counter affidavit filed by the 1st respondent, the
petitioner filed a reply affidavit producing therewith Exts. P20 to
P28 documents.
9. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
learned Standing Counsel for Cochin Devaswom
Board and its
officials.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
charge of the items in P.P Register and M.E. Register were not
handed over to the petitioner at the time of his taking charge as
a Devaswom Officer in the Tripunithura Devaswom on 28.06.2006
which was mentioned by him in Ext.P1 letter filed before the
Devaswom Assistant Commissioner at the earliest point of time,
after taking the charge. In fact, after 31.10.2002, nobody verified
the Registers as evident from Ext.P9(a) the relevant pages of the
P.P. Register dated 31.10.2002. The learned counsel brought the
attention of this Court to Ext.P16 the relevant pages of M.E.
Register wherein some items were entered as not entrusted and
argued that the petitioner who was not entrusted with the
properties entered in the P.P. Register and M.E. Register cannot be
held liable for the missing of the items which occurred prior to his
taking over the charge.
11. On the other hand the learned Standing Counsel for the
Cochin Devaswom Board submitted that the missing of items were
found out at the time of audit of the accounts of the Tripunithura
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
Devaswom for the year 2005-06. The reduction in the weight or
missing of some items including gold and silver were mentioned
in Ext.P3 report. If the items were not handed over to the
petitioner, he could have refused to take charge of the Registers
concerned.
12. The petitioner is the Devaswom Officer of Tripunithura
Devaswom under the Tripunithura Group with effect from
28.06.2006. According to the petitioner at the time of his taking
charge as the Devaswom Officer, he noted anomalies in the P.P.
Register and M.E. Register kept in the
Sree Poornathrayeesha
Temple. He brought the missing items to the notice of the 4 th
respondent by Ext.P1 letter dated 31.07.2006. Though, by Ext.P2
proceedings dated 28.09.2006, the 1st respondent directed the 3rd
respondent to conduct an inspection of the P.P. Register and M.E.
Register in the Tripunitura Devaswom and to submit a report
before the 1st respondent, the same has not been complied till
date. It is also the case of the petitioner that in the year 2010, as
directed
by
the
3rd
respondent,
he
deposited
a
sum
of
Rs.33,884.85/- in order to rectify the anomalies in the P.P. Register
and M.E. Register. However, the 2nd respondent issued Ext.P7
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
order dated 19.05.2010 fixing the liability of missing articles
referred to the P.P Register in the joint custody of the Assistant
Commissioner, the petitioner, Moothathu and Menokki. Though the
petitioner submitted Ext.P13 representation dated 11.11.2013
before the 1st respondent to rectify the anomalies, Ext.P14 order
dated 26.12.2014 was issued by the 2nd respondent fixing the
liability of Rs.28,650/- to the four custodians of the Registers
concerned.
According to the petitioner he was not heard before
passing such an order by the 2nd respondent. But, according to the
respondents, the petitioner cannot escape from the liability of the
missing articles which was statutorily in his custody after taking
charge as a Devawom Officer.
13.
During the course of arguments, the learned Standing
Counsel for the Cochin Devaswom Board invited our attention to
Articles 137 and 138 of Chapter X of the Devaswom manual which
stipulates the manner in which the Nadavaravu articles have to be
dealt with. Chapter X of the Devaswom manual deals with other
items of Devaswom receipts. Articles 137 and 138 deal with
Nadavaravu. They read thus:
“137. Nadavaravu-In almost all the temples articles such as
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
gold and silver ornaments, bell-metal articles such as lamps,
etc., perishable articles including bulls, cows, calves, goats
and other live-stock are offered as vazhivadus, which are
credited in the Nadavaravu register in Form No. XXV
Appendix XIV to be maintained in each Devaswam. In some
cases, the donors express a wish that the articles offered by
them may be preserved for the daily use in the temple
without their being sold in auction. In such cases, they are
preserved, if unobjectionable, for the use of the temple
according to the wishes of the donors and are taken to the
register of ornaments and vessels (vide article 320)
maintained in each Devaswam in Form No. XXVI Appendix
XIV. The other articles as are not required for the temple use,
are disposed of in auction and the sale proceeds credited to
the Devaswam. Such of the articles of Nadavaravu as can be
used for nithyanidanam expenditure may be utilised for such
purposes and the cost credited by adjustment. The disposal
of these articles shall be as follows:138. Sale
of Nadavaravu articles.-Nadavaravu
articles
belonging to Devaswams may be classified under two headsMajor and Minor.
All the articles of gold, silver, bell-metal and precious stones
may be classed as Major and all the other articles as Minor.
Explanation,-Ornaments and vessels made of copper, brass,
iron and other articles and all kinds of furniture and other
articles made of wood and perishables are to be included in
the latter class. 'Perishables' means articles which are
subject to damage or decay, e. g., all sorts of fruits and other
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
vegetable stuff, silk, cloth, sugar and molasses and also
include bulls, cows, calves, goats and other live-stock; but
do not include elephants.
1.
MAJOR ARTICLES
List of all articles of gold, silver, bell-metal and precious
stones received in a year to be disposed of should be
submitted to the Diwan not later than the 1st of Thulam of
the succeeding year for sanction. When sanction is received
the Devaswam Commissioner should arrange to collect the
articles to be sold in different centres according to the
importance of the locality for the sale of articles and notify
in the Cochin Government Gazette a month at least in
advance of the dates and places of the sale and also the
conditions of the sale. The sales should be conducted by the
Devaswam Commissioner on the dates fixed in the
notification and the facts reported to the Diwan with the sale
lists for confirmation. When the sales are confirmed by the
Diwan, the articles should be weighed and handed over to
the bidders and the sale proceeds realised and remitted into
the Treasury then and there. Particulars of remittance into
the Treasury should also be reported to the Diwan. Such of
the articles of Nadavaravu which should at the donor's
request be preserved may be ordered by the Commissioner
to be preserved in the Devaswams and these articles should
be entered as such in the Registers of ornaments and
vessels (Article 320) maintained in the Department.
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
2. MINOR ARTICLES.
Ornaments, vessels, etc., of copper, wood and other
materials not classified under major articles received as
Nadavaravu in a year in the several Devaswams should be
duly listed by the Assistant Commissioner or the Deputy
Tahsildar of Cranganur, as the case may be, and the lists
together
with
separate
lists
of
other
useless
and
unserviceable articles belonging to each Group to be sold
should be submitted to the Devaswam Commissioner for
sanctioning the same, not later than the 1st of Thulam of the
succeeding year. After the receipt of the sanction of the
Commissioner the articles as per the list may be sold in
public auction by the Assistant Commissioners or the Deputy
Tahsildar of Cranganur, as the case may be, and the results
reported to the Commissioner with the sale-lists for
confirmation. After the sales are confirmed the articles
should be handed over to the bidders and the sale amount
realised and remitted into the Treasury and the fact reported
to the Commissioner.
All-perishable articles including bulls, cows, calves, goats
and other live-stock will be disposed of then and there in
public auction by the local Devaswom officers to the best
advantage and the sale proceeds realised by them and
credited to the accounts and the sale list submitted to the
Commissioner for confirmation through the immediate
supervising officers. After the sales are confirmed the
Assistant Commissioner or the Deputy Tahsildar, as the case
may be, should verify the remittance of the amounts into
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
the Treasury.
Note,-A ledger of all articles received should be maintained
in Form No I Appendix X and the monthly totals and
progressive totals struck signed by the officers. This will be
the basis for transfer of charge which should be recorded
then and there. Disposal should be noted in this in detail
and checked and attested by the Assistant Commissioner
and the balance struck”.
14.
As per the Devaswom manual, the Register of
Ornaments and vessels to be preserved have to be maintained in
form No. XXVI-Appendix XIV. Similarly, the Nadavaravu items
have to be entered in Form No.1-Appendix X. According to the
Devaswom Board, there is flow in the management of the
Nadavaravu articles and hence some of them were found missing
in the registers concerned and the persons who are the custodians
of these registers including the petitioner are liable for the missing
articles. While going through Exts. P7 and P14 orders of the 2nd
respondent we notice that those orders were passed without
giving an opportunity to the petitioner to put forward his
contentions before the 2nd respondent. During the course of
arguments,
the
learned
Standing
Counsel
for
the
Cochin
Devaswom Board invited our attention to the judgment dated
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
20.06.2014 passed by this Court in W.P.(C) No. 2978 of 2013
which is a writ petition filed by the
Assistant Commissioner of
Tripunithura Group who is one among the four persons who were
found responsible for the missing of valuables, complaining about
non-disbursal of DCRG, wherein this Court directed the 1st
respondent to release the DCRG to the petitioner therein retaining
a sum of Rs.7163/- deposited by her. In that judgment, this court
held that if in a detailed enquiry, it was ultimately found that the
petitioner therein was not at all responsible for the loss, then she
is entitled to claim the amount retained by the Board.
It was
further directed that the enquiry shall be completed within six
months from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment.
15. Having considered the pleadings and materials on record
and submissions made at the Bar, we are of the view that Ext.P14
order of the 2nd respondent finding the petitioner and other three
custodians of the valuables as responsible for the missing items
worth Rs.28,650/- is liable to be set aside, since the said order
was passed without hearing the petitioner and others.
In such circumstances, we dispose of this writ petition by
setting aside Ext.P14 order dated 26.12.2014 passed by the 2nd
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
respondent and direct the 2
nd
respondent to decide the matter
afresh after giving an opportunity to the petitioner and other
affected parties to put forward their contentions on merit, as
expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within three months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. It is made clear that
the petitioner can submit fresh representation before the 2nd
respondent explaining his defence. The deposit made by the
petitioner in pursuance to the direction of this Court shall be
subject to the decision that would be taken by the 2nd respondent.
Sd/ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
sks
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 25371/2015
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Renewed Fixed
Deposit Receipt
Renewed FD Receipt
Renewed Fixed Deposit Receipt
Renewal of FD Receipt deposited with
Registrar General
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R 1 ( a )
True copy of the relevant pages of Chapter
4 of the Devaswom Manual
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit-P20
Exhibit-P21
Exhibit-P22
Exhibit-P23
Exhibit-P24
Exhibit-P25
Exhibit-P26
Exhibit-P27
True copy of the relevant pages of Chapter
4 of the Devaswom Manual issued by the 1st
respondent in the year 2014
True copy of the Judgment of this Hon’ble
Court dated 27.11.2017 in
WP(C)No.35340/2014
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 10.09.2018 in
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 04.02.2019 in
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 26.11.2021 in
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 24.01.2022 in
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 04.08.2022 in
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 19.01.2024 in
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
Exhbit-P28
True copy of the Order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 28.01.2025 in
SLP(C)No.7947/2018
EXHIBIT -P10- TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF
THIS HON'BLE COURT DATED 07.04.2011 IN
I.A.NO.716/2011 IN R.P. NO.OF 2011 IN
DBA.11/2011
EXHIBIT-P11- TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER
NO.A9.2467/08 DATED 27.04.2011 ISSUED BY
THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P12- TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER
NO.A9.2467/08 DATED 23.06.2011 ISSUED BY
THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P13- TRUE COPY OF THE
REPRESENTATION DATED 11.11.2013 SUBMITTED
BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE PRESIDENT AND
MEMBERS OFTHE 1ST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P14- TRUE COPY OF THE
ORDERNO.A9.2467/08 DATED 26.12.2014 ISSUED
BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P3-TRUE COPY OF THE NOTES OF AUDIT
OF RECEIPT ACCOUNTS OF TRIPUNITHURA
DEVASWOM FOR THE YEAR 2005-06 WAS CONDUCTED
FROM THE OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF
LOCAL FUND AUDIT DATED 09/07/2007.
EXHIBIT-P16- TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT
PAGES OF THE MAJOR ERADAVU REGISTER
EXHIBIT-P1-TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
31/07/2006 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P2-TRUE COPY OF THE PROEEDINGS
DATED 28/09/2006 ISSUED BY THE IST
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P4-TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
18/01/2008 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT -P15- TRUE COPY OF THE
REPRESENTATION SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P4(A)-TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER OF
THANTHRI DATED 15/01/2008.
EXHIBIT-P5(B)-TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT NO.
4173 DATED 04/03/2010 FOR RS. 4,284/EXHIBIT-P5(B)-TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT NO.
4174 DATED 04/03/2010 FOR RS.24,392.25
EXHIBIT-P5(C)-TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT NO.
4175 DATED 04/03/2010 FOR RS. 450/EXHIBIT-P5(D)-TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT NO.
4176 DATED 04/03/2010 FOR RS.2,346.60
EXHIBIT-P5(E)-TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT NO.
4183 DATED 24/03/2010 FOR RS.4,284/EXHIBIT-P6-TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. A92467/08 DATED 19/05/2010 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P7-TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. A92467/08 DATED 19/05/2010 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P8-TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. A92467/08 DATED 19/05/2010 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P9-TRUE COPY OF THE EXPLANATION
DATED 03/06/2010 SUBMITTED BY THE
PETITIONER BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P9(A)-TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOCOPIES
OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE P.P. REGISTER
DATED 31.10.2002
EXHIBIT P17-TRUE COPY OF ORDER
NO.A1.9991/15 DATED 18.09.2015 ISSUED BY
W.P.(C)No.25371 of 2015
2025:KER:26774
THE SECOND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT-P18-TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION TO
EXT.P17 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE
THE FOURTH REPSONDENT ON 30.12.2015
EXHIBIT P19 – TRUE COP OF THE
REPRESENTATION SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE RESPONDENTS THROUGH PROPER
CHANNEL ON 12.5.2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review