Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.36303 of 2022
….
Petitioner
Mr. B. Routray, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. S. Sekhar, Advocate
Ajay Kumar Madangi
-versusState of Odisha and
Others
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. P.P. Behera, ASC
Mr. P.K. Mohanty, Sr.
Adv. with Ms. K.T.
Mudali, Advocate for
Commission
CORAM:
JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
Order No.
05. 1.
This
matter
ORDER
11.02.2026
is taken up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties. Instruction
provided by the department and so produced by the
learned Addl. Standing Counsel be kept in record.
3.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer:“The petitioner, therefore, most humbly prays
that this Hon'ble Court may be graciously pleased to
quash the order dated 12.10.2022 of O.P No.l at
Annexure-15 and further be pleased to direct the Opp.
Parties 1 & 2 to pass necessary order forthwith with
regard to reallocation of the petitioner from ORS
(Group-B) Cadre to OAS, Group-A (Junior Branch)
// 2 //
Cadre with effect from the date of appointment of O.P.
No.4 with all service and Financial benefits.
And further be pleased to pass any other suitable
order/orders, direction/directions as the Hon'ble Court
may deem just and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
4.
It is contended that pursuant to the Advertisement
issued by the Odisha Public Service Commission (in short
“the Commission”) on 05.11.2019 vide Advertisement
No.11 of 2019-20 for OCS Examination, 2019 so issued
under Annexure-1, petitioner made the application vide
Annexure-2, by indicating his category as ‘Schedule Tribe’
and Sub-category as ‘Ex-serviceman’.
4.1. It is contended that in Advertisement issued under
Annexure-1 as against the post of OAS Group-A (Junior
Branch), there were 7 (seven) vacancies meant for ST
candidate with 2 (two) reserved for ST (women). Out of the
total vacancies so reflected in the advertisement, 2 (two)
posts were reserved for Ex-serviceman, and 1(one) post
for Sports person.
4.2. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner
contended that in the recruitment so held by the
Commission, petitioner in the final merit list issued by
the Commission under Annexure-6 on 08.10.2021, was
placed at Sl. No.131 and his category was mentioned as
ST Ex-Serviceman. In the said merit list, the name of
Opp. Party No.4, finds place at Sl. No.133 and his
category was indicated as ST.
// 3 //
4.3. It is contended that since petitioner made his
application as a ST candidate and admittedly he had
secured more mark than the person placed at Sl.
No.133/Opp. Party No.4 being placed at Sl. No.131,
petitioner’s name could not have been recommended by
the Commission under Annexure-6 as against ST ExServiceman Category. It is contended that because of the
wrong
committed
by
the
Commission
while
recommending the names vide Annexure-6, petitioner
when was appointed as against the post of ORS (GroupB), Opp. Party No.4 was appointed as against the post of
OAS (Group-A) (JB), vide Notification dated 28.12.2021
under Annexure-7. Petitioner on being so victimized and
after publication the Notification under Annexure-8,
made a grievance before Opp. Party No.1 on 29.12.2021
under Annexure-9 inter alia with the following prayer:“As per the final merit list I should have been adjusted I
allocated in the ST category so that I should get OAS Cadre
but I have been allotted cadre ORS. As per the policy of Govt.
of Odisha, while allocating cadre the primary category i.e. ST,
should not be violated and in that case special category i.e.
EXSM may not be considered. Therefore, it is requested to
look the matter and necessary action from your side be
initiated and allocation of cadre may be done to mitigate the
problem, for this help I shall be obliged.”
4.4. It
is
contended
that
on
receipt
of
such
representation from the petitioner, Opp. Party No.1 vide
letter dated 20.01.2022 under Annexure-10, forwarded
the same to the Commission for disposal at their level.
However,
on
receipt
of
the
communication
under
Annexure-10, the Commission vide its letter dated
10.03.2022
under
Annexure-11,
while
giving
the
// 4 //
clarification to the following effect, requested Opp. Party
No.1 to take a final decision on the issue. The clarification
reads as follows:“If a candidate coming under horizontal reservation
(Woman, ex-serviceman, PwD, Sportsperson) has secured a
position in the merit list, he/she can avail a service or cadre
of higher choice of his/her preference by virtue of the
position in the merit list under the parent vertical category
irrespective of the horizontal category he/she represents.”
4.5. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner
contended that on the face of such clarification issued by
the Commission under Annexure-11, when no decision
was taken, petitioner moved another application before
Opp. Party No.1 on 17.05.2022 under Annexure-12 and
thereafter moved this Court by filing W.P.(C) No.15130 of
2022. This Court vide order dated 04.07.2022 under
Annexure-14, when directed Opp. Party No.1 to take a
decision on the petitioner’s claim, the same was rejected
vide
the
impugned
order
dated
12.10.2022
under
Annexure-15.
4.6. While assailing the impugned order, it is the main
contention of the learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioner that petitioner taking into account the
mark secured by him and his placement over Opp. Party
No.4 in the final merit list issued by the Commission
under Annexure-6, would have
been recommended as
against ST category and petitioner
accordingly would
have been appointed as against the post of OAS, Group-A
(JB). But because of the wrong committed by the
Commission
in
recommending
him
as
a
ST
Ex-
// 5 //
serviceman
candidate,
he
was prejudiced
with his
appointment as against ORS Group-B, though Opp. Party
No.4 having secured less mark than the petitioner, was
appointed as against OAS, Group-A (Junior Branch) vide
the Notification issued under Annexure-8.
4.7. It is also contended that in the recruitment so held
by the Commission pursuant to Annexure-1 and as found
under
Annexure-20
series,
the
cut-off
mark
for
recommendation was fixed at 73.469 for ST (Male) and
93.878 for Ex-serviceman. It is further contended that in
the examination in question, petitioner had secured
78.061. It is accordingly contended that since petitioner
had not secured the cut-off mark so fixed for ExServiceman category, his name could not have been
recommended
category,
by
while
the
Commission
making
the
as
against
recommendation
that
under
Annexure-6.
4.8. It is also contended that since admittedly petitioner
had secured more mark than Opp. Party No.4 with his
placement at Sl. No.131 vis-à-vis Opp. Party No.4 at Sl.
No.133, petitioner should have been recommended as a
ST category candidate and consequentially should have
been appointed as against the post of OAS, Group-A
(Junior Branch). It is also contended that as per the RTI
information provided by the Revenue and Disaster
Management
Department
on
08.09.2022
under
Annexure-17, as against 7(seven) posts meant for ST
candidates in the advertisement in question, pursuant to
// 6 //
the recommendation and notification issued by the Govt.,
3 ST (Male) candidate and 3 ST (Female) candidates have
joined as against the post of OAS Group-A (Junior
Branch).
4.9. It is accordingly contended that since two (2) posts
remained vacant
in ST (Male) category, because of the
non-joining of the selected candidates, petitioner can very
well be accommodated as against the said vacant post of
OAS, Group-A (Junior Branch) with due modification of
the order of appointment issued vide Notification under
Annexure-8.
5.
Mr. P.P. Behera, learned Addl. Standing Counsel on
the other hand made his submission basing on the
instruction provided in Court today. It is contended that
pursuant to the recruitment process undertaken by the
Commission,
petitioner
since was
recommended
as
against ST Ex-serviceman category, he was accordingly
appointed as against ORS, Group-B post vide Notification
dated 28.12.2021 under Annexure-8. It is accordingly
contended that no illegality or irregularity can be found
with
the
impugned
appointment
of
the
petitioner
pursuant to Annexure-8 Notification as against the post
of ORS, Group-B.
5.1. It is further contended that petitioner when made a
representation under Annexure-9 and the same was
referred
to
the
Commission
vide
Annexure-10,
Commission when gave its clarification vide Annexure-11,
// 7 //
Opp. Party No.1 vide letter dated 27.05.2022, once again
requested the Commission to take appropriate action on
the issue as per law. But vide letter dated 27.06.2022 of
the Commission, the view expressed by the Opp. Party
No.1 that petitioner has been rightly selected under ST
Ex-serviceman category (at Sl. No.131 of the OCS
Examination, 2019) with his appointment as against the
post of ORS, Group-B was upheld.
5.2. It is accordingly contended that since grievance
made by the petitioner under Annexure-9, was ultimately
rejected by the Govt. so confirmed by the Commission
vide letter dated 27.06.2022, petitioner is not eligible and
entitled to get any benefit.
5.3. It is further contended that if petitioner will be
appointed as against OAS, Group-A (Junior Branch) in
respect
of
the
recruitment
Annexure-1, the same
will
initiated
lead
to
pursuant
to
discontentment
amongst the existing cadre of OAS, Group-A (JB), already
appointed pursuant to Annexure-1, and basing on
subsequent recruitments undertaken by the Commission.
6.
Mr. P.K. Mohanty, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the Commission on the other hand contended that
since petitioner made the application under Annexure-2
pursuant to Annexure-1 by indicating his category as ST
and sub-category as Ex-serviceman, he was rightly
recommended by the Commission under Annexure-6 as
against ST Ex-Serviceman category.
// 8 //
6.1. However, it is fairly contended that petitioner taking
into account the mark secured by him in the examination
and being placed above Opp. Party No.4, he would have
got the benefit of recommendation as a ST category
candidate. It is also contended that since on the face of
the
clarification
issued
by
the
Commission
under
Annexure-11, Govt.-Opp. Party No.1 while issuing letter
dated 27.05.2022 held that petitioner has been rightly
appointed as against the post of ORS, Group-B, the said
decision of the Govt. was upheld, with issuance of the
communication dated 27.06.2022.
7.
To the submission made by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the Commission and the learned
State Counsel, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioner contended that petitioner will have no grievance
if he will be given the benefit of appointment as agianst
the post of OAS, Group-A (JB), with the benefit from
today itself.
8.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
considering the submissions made, this Court finds that
pursuant to the advertisement issued by the Commission
under Annexure-1, for filling up various posts and
services coming under OCS (Group-A & B), petitioner
made the application as a ST candidate with his subcategory as Ex-Serviceman. It is found that petitioner in
the said recruitment, though secured more mark than
Opp. Party No.4 and placed at Sl. No.131 with Opp. Party
No.4 at Sl. No.133, but his name was recommended as
// 9 //
against ST Ex-Serviceman category and Opp. Party No.4
was recommended as against ST category by the
Commission under Annexure-6.
8.1. Because
of
such
wrong
committed
by
the
Commission while recommending the name of the
petitioner vis-à-vis Opp. Party No.4 vide Annexure-6,
petitioner was appointed as against the post of ORS,
Group-B with Opp. Party No.4 as against the post of OAS,
Group-A (Junior Branch).
8.2. Since it is not disputed that petitioner had secured
more mark than Opp. Party No.4 in the recruitment in
question as a ST candidate, as per the considered view of
this Court, his names should have been recommended as
against ST category, instead of recommending his name
as against ST Ex-Serviceman category. It is also the view
of this Court that cut-off mark for Ex-Serviceman
category being fixed by the Commission at 93.878,
petitioner’s name could not have been recommended as
against ST Ex-Serviceman category with his mark at
78.061.
8.3. Since it is not disputed by any of the parties that
petitioner had secured more mark than Opp. Party No.4
as a ST candidate and he having not secured the cut-off
mark in Ex-Serviceman category, it is the view of this
Court that petitioner should have been recommended as
against
ST
category
by
the
Commission
and
consequentially he should have got the benefit of
// 10 //
appointment as against the post of OAS, Group-A (Junior
Branch).
8.4. Since for the wrong committed by the Commission,
petitioner was deprived to get the benefit of appointment
as against the post of OAS, Group-A (Junior Branch), this
Court
while
quashing
the
impugned
order
dated
12.10.2022 under Annexure-15 and taking into account
the interim order passed by this Court on 09.01.2023
“that any appointment made in the meantime shall be
subject to result of the writ application”, direct Opp. Party
Nos.1 and 2 to provide appointment to the petitioner as
against the post of OAS Group-A (Junior Branch) with his
seniority to be reckoned from today itself.
8.5. However, services rendered by the petitioner as
against the post of ORS, Group-B be counted towards
other service benefits. This Court directs Opp. Party Nos.
1 and 2 to issue a fresh order of appointment in favour of
the petitioner appointing him as against the post of OAS
Group-A (Junior Branch), within a period of 6 (six) weeks
from the date of receipt of this order.
9.
The Writ Petition accordingly stands disposed of.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASUDEV SWAIN
Reason: AuthenticationBasudev
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 17-Feb-2026 15:42:28
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review