Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 198 of 2019
Date of Decision: 17.02.2023
Shri. Ajay Kumar & 191 Ors.
Vs.
Union of India & 3 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Nongbri, Adv. with
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
This is an application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
filed by the 192 petitioners herein seeking direction of this Court to extend the
beneficial provisions of the scope of the Judgment and Order dated 23.08.2012
passed by this Court in W.P. (C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and also to place the
petitioners above their juniors in the seniority list of clerical cadres of Warrant
Officer.
2.
The basis of this litigation is that the petitioners are employees of
Assam Rifles under the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs and
are working as Havildar (Clerk) which is a cadre post in the clerical grade of
Assam Rifles. Though the petitioners were enrolled under the provisions of
the Assam Rifles Act, 1941, however the pay and allowances and other service
benefits are regulated under the Civil Services Rules which was made
applicable after the recommendation of the 4th Central Pay Commission
wherein the Assam Rifles was made part of the Central Police Organisations,
which includes the CRPF, BSF, ITBP, CISF etc., since 01.01.1986.
3.
That after implementing the pay scale of the Central Police
Organisations (CPOs), the entry post in Assam Rifles was retained in the rank
of Lance Naik with the scale pay of ₹ 825-15-900-EB-20-1200 which is
contrary to the recommendation of the 4th CPC and Government Orders
thereon. This anomalous situation continued even after the 5 th CPC
recommendations w.e.f. 01.01.1996.
4.
In order to remove this disparity, the President was pleased to
rationalize the rank and pay structure of non-gazetted cadre of the Central
Police Organisations which was done so vide Memo No. 27012/1/97-PC
Cell/PF. I dated 10.10.1997.
Sl.
No.
Rank Structure
Constables/Security
Assistant
Rationalised
pre- Replacement
pay
revised pay scales
scales
Rs. 950-1400
Rs. 3050-80-4590
5.
Head Constables
Asst. Sub-Inspector
Sub-Inspector/ACIOII
Inspector/ACIO-I
Subedar Major
Rs. 975-1660
Rs. 1320-2040
Rs. 1640-2900
Rs. 3200-85-4900
Rs. 4000-100-6000
Rs. 5500-175-9000
Rs. 2000-3200
Rs. 2000-3500
Rs. 6500-200-10500
Rs. 6500-200-10500
+ Rs. 200/-
The Office Memorandum dated 10.10.1997 referred to above, have not
been implemented by the Assam Rifles. The Assam Rifles on the pretext of
implementing the said Order dated 10.10.1997, has however, vide its letter No.
A/I-A/5th/Pay/97-98/93 dated 27.02.1998 re-designated the existing post of
Havildar Clerk to that of Warrant Officer Clerk (equivalent to the post of
Assistant Sub-Inspector) with the pay scale of ₹ 4000-6000 with effect from
10.10.1997 but not from 01.01.1996 as was directed by the Government of
India. This was also done only as a one-time measure for the existing Havildar
Clerks only. Though the petitioners were enrolled in the post of Havildar Clerk
having similar recruitment qualification for the clerical cadre of other CPOs,
where Assistant Sub-Inspector is the entry level post in the pay scale of ₹13202040, the petitioners were entitled for grant of entry grade of Warrant Officer
rank but such benefit was not given to them.
6.
That aggrieved by the discriminatory actions of the respondent
authority, about 1339 employees of the Assam Rifles filed a writ petition
before this Court being numbered as W.P.(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and this
Court vide order dated 23.08.2012 has allowed prayer of the petitioners
therein, the operative portion being found at para 14 of the same which reads
as follows:
“14. In the result, this writ petition stands disposed of with the
direction to the respondent No.2, the Director General of Assam Rifles
to take up the matter again with the respondent No.1, i.e. the Secretary
to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Home Affairs to bring parity in
respect of rank structure and pay of the Assam Rifles clerical cadre at
par with other CPOs by introducing rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector
(Warrant Officer) at the entry grade w.e.f. 1.1.1986 in the scale of pay
of Rs1320-2040 (revised Rs.4000-6000) w.e.f. 1.1.1996 or any other
date as the authority deem it fit and proper with all consequential
service benefits in the light of the Government of India, Ministry of
Finance resolution dated 20.9.1997 communicated through MH letter
bearing No.2701-02/1/97 PC Cell/Pef-1 dated 10.10.1997. The whole
exercise would be completed within a period of 6 (six) months from
the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment and order.”
7.
The judgment and order dated 23.08.2012 (supra) was then challenged
by the Assam Rifles authority before a Division Bench of this Court which
then disposed of the same being W.A. (SH) No. 40 of 2012 vide order dated
30.04.2013 whereby the order of the learned Single Bench was modified to
the extent that the financial benefit directed to be given to the petitioners would
be w.e.f. January 2010 notionally.
8.
Again, being aggrieved by the said order dated 30.04.2013 the
respondents in W.A. (SH) No. 40 of 2012 then approached the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in S.L.P. (C) No. 29908 of 2013 and the same was disposed of
vide order dated 17.11.2015. The Hon’ble Supreme Court while deciding the
matter had restored the judgment and order dated 23.08.2012 passed by the
Single Bench with a slight modification to the same that the words “or any
other date as the authority deem it fit and proper” appearing at para 14 of the
said judgment be deleted.
9.
In compliance with this Court’s order dated 23.08.2012 in WP(C) No.
277 (SH) of 2010, the Directorate General Assam Rifles vide Memo A/Pers/II04/Clk/2016/774 dated 28.06.2016 on being approved by the Ministry of
Home Affairs vide their communication number U.O. 27013/2/2016.PF.IV
dated 22.06.2016 has conveyed sanction of the competent authority to bring
effect to the aforesaid judgment.
10.
However, while putting into action the said sanction order dated
22.06.2016, about 1232 of the original writ petitioners were accorded the
benefits thereof, while some of the original writ petitioners who admittedly
were enrolled in the clerical cadre after 29.10.2002 were denied such benefits.
11.
The said personnel who were denied such benefits then approached
this Court by instituting contempt proceedings being numbered as Cont. Cas
(C) No. 21 of 2016 arising out of WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010. On 13.11.2018
when the matter was listed for consideration before this Court, the contemnors
therein has informed the Court that the judgment referred to would be
implemented vis-à-vis the contempt petitioners within six weeks. As a result,
the contempt proceeding was closed.
12.
Consequently, the Directorate General Assam Rifles vide order No.
Rec (Adm-I)/WO Clk/2019/319 dated 12.04.2019 has ordered implementation
of the related order dated 23.08.2012 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 277
(SH) of 2010 to the remaining 89 original petitioners who are now also
covered by the administrative order No. A/Pers/1104/Clk/2016/774 dated
28.06.2016.
13.
It is the petitioners’ case that as a consequence of the implementation
of the said judgment and order dated 23.08.2012, the benefit of parity in rank
and pay structure being accorded to those petitioners who have approached
this Court in W.P.(C) No. 277(SH) of 2010, a situation has arisen whereby the
petitioners herein were then superseded by their juniors, more particularly
those who were enrolled after 29.10.2002.
14.
Mr. P. Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that
in the process of implementation of the judgment and order dated 23.08.2012,
the respondent authorities have extended the benefits to all similarly situated
incumbents including some of the petitioners in the said W.P.(C) No. 277(SH)
of 2010 who were enrolled after 29.10.2002. This has caused an anomalous
situation inasmuch as the petitioners herein have been superseded by their
juniors who are now placed higher than them in the rolls and are also receiving
higher pay scale. In fact, some of the said juniors were enrolled in the year
2005, 2006 and 2008 and as such, the assertion of the respondent authorities
that the said judgment is confined only to those who joined service before
29.10.2002 is not correct.
15.
Admitting that the petitioners are governed by the Recruitment Rules
of 2002, yet it is contended that the reference to the same is irrelevant as it is
obvious that on the implementation of the said judgment dated 23.08.2012, an
anomalous situation has been created in the clerical cadre inasmuch as the
petitioners herein have been superseded by their junior colleagues who were
enrolled in the year 2005, 2006 and 2008.
16.
The learned counsel has further submitted that even if the assertion of
the respondents that the a mistake was committed by the respondent authorities
while implementing the said judgment dated 23.08.2012 vis-à-vis the 89
petitioners who were benefited by virtue of the order dated 12.10.2018 of this
Court in Contempt Petition No. 21 of 2016, the petitioners were made to suffer
for no fault of theirs when their rank and pay structure have been substantially
lowered as compared to their junior colleagues.
17.
In support of the case of the petitioners, the learned counsel has relied
upon the case of State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors v. Arvind Kumar Srivastava
& Ors: (2015) 1 SCC 347, para 22 and also the case of Life Insurance
Corporation of India & Ors v. Jagmohan Sharma & Ors: (1998) 9 SCC 219.
18.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC appearing on behalf of the respondent
Union of India has submitted that at the outset, this petition is not maintainable
as the petitioners were enrolled as per the Recruitment Rules 2002 published
vide GSR No. 472 wherein the entry level rank is that of Havildar (Clerk).
This is following the Notification issued by the Central Government dated
29.10.2002 apparently to bring uniformity in ministerial cadres in all Central
Police Organisations (CPOs). The post of Havildar(Clerk) in Assam Rifles is
equivalent to the post of Head Constable (Ministerial) in BSF and CRPF
respectively.
19.
The learned CGC has however conceded that it was through oversight
and inadvertence that the names of the 89 petitioners in the original array of
parties in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 could not be detected in course of
proceedings to enable an application for appropriate prayer to be moved before
the Court for necessary orders in this regard. Be that as it may, the fact that as
far as the 89 petitioners are concerned, this Court has settled the matter vide
order dated 13.11.2018 in Cont. Case (C) No. 21 of 2016 and as such to the
extent indicated the issue has become final with the issue of the relevant order
passed by the Director General Assam Rifles being No. Rec (Adm-I)/WO Clk/
2019/319 dated 12.04.2019.
20.
The learned CGC has further submitted that this Court while granting
relief to the petitioners in the Cont. Case (C) No. 21 of 2016 vide order dated
12.10.2018 and final order dated 13.11.2018, the same cannot be taken as a
precedent by the petitioners herein as the condition of recruitment of the
petitioners under the said Recruitment Rules of 2002 has been maintained in
the rank of Havildar (Clerk) at the entry level and for this Court to change the
said entry level to that of Warrant Officer (Clerk), which is a promotional post
as per the said Recruitment Rules of 2002, the same will upset the settled
position.
21.
In this instant case, the learned CGC has submitted that if the relief
sought for by the petitioners herein is granted, it would be in violation of the
Assam Rifles Recruitment Rules, 2002 wherein another anomalous situation
would arise inasmuch as granting rank of warrant officer to the petitioners of
Assam Rifles enrolled after 29.10.2002 would upset the equilibrium of the
Assam Rifles vis-à-vis the other CPOs/CAPFs which may result in a flood of
litigation by the aggrieved parties.
22.
In support of his case, the learned CGC has cited the following
judgments:
i.
Union of India & Anr. v. Arulmozhi Iniarasu & Ors.: (2011) 7
SCC 397, para 14, 17 and 26;
ii.
Maharaj Krishan Bhatt & Anr. v. State of Jammu and Kashmir
& Ors.: (2008) 9 SCC 24, para 21;
iii.
Director of Horticulture, Odisha v. Pravat Kumar Dash & Ors.:
(2019) 8 SCC 294, para 18;
iv.
Khoday Distilleries Ltd. & Ors. v. Mahadeswara S.S.K. Ltd.:
(2012) 12 SCC 291, para 7;
23.
This Court has duly considered the submission and contention raised
by the learned counsels for the rival parties. The main consideration in this lis
is whether the petitioners herein were affected by the import of the judgment
and order dated 23.08.2012 in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 vis-à-vis their
colleagues who were allegedly junior to them in the cadre, but who were
benefitted by the decision in the said judgment and order dated 23.08.2012.
24.
On what has been recorded above, the facts and circumstances may not
be reiterated but would be pointed out and repeated only as and when required
and necessary.
25.
Shorn of unnecessary details, what is evident is that a group of about
1339 employees of the Assam Rifles had approached this Court in the year
2010 by way of the said WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 seeking parity of rank
and pay structure in the Assam Rifles as was available in other CPOs or
CAPFs. This Court vide order dated 23.08.2012 had allowed the prayer made
and has directed the competent authority to take steps in such regard. The
matter having travelled right up to the Apex Court of this country, the order of
the learned Single Judge was upheld.
26.
By the relevant notification, the Assam Rifles has put into effect the
dictum of the Court and has granted parity of rank and pay structure by
indicating that the entry grade in the ministerial/clerical cadre of the Assam
Rifles will be that of Warrant Officer (Clerk) at par with the rank of Assistant
Sub-Inspector in the other CPOs. However, initially, the Assam Rifles
authorities have granted relief to all the petitioners in the said WP(C) No. 277
(SH) of 2010 but, has left out about 89 of them on the pretext that the relevant
notification has conveyed benefit to only those personnel who have joined
service before 28.10.2002, when the Recruitment Rules, 2002 came into effect
on 29.10.2002 and those 89 petitioners having been enrolled beyond
29.10.2002, they are therefore not entitled to be the beneficiaries of the said
order dated 23.08.2012.
27.
Again, as pointed out above, the 87 petitioners filed a contempt
petition before this Court which was allowed vide order dated 13.11.2018.
This, has necessitated the issuance of a separate order being Rec (Adm-I)/WO
Clk/2019/319 dated 12.04.2019 wherein the 87 personnel who were enrolled
after 29.10.2002 are now designated as Warrant Officer (Clerk) (Equivalent
to Assistant Sub-Inspector in other CAPFs) from the date of enrolment.
28.
Apparently, as pointed out by the petitioners herein, though they have
been appointed after 29.10.2002 in the entry grade of Havildar (Clerk) and the
next promotional post is that of Warrant Officer (Clerk), it is obvious that they
have been superseded by their junior colleagues, who, even in spite of being
borne in the cadre of Havildar (Clerk), by virtue of the said judgment and order
dated 23.08.2012 and the relevant notification dated 12.04.2019 and also
admittedly being enrolled in the year 2005, 2006 and 2008, these juniors have
now been placed above the petitioners in as far as rank is concerned and also
drawing a higher pay scale than the petitioners herein.
29.
This factual position has not been denied by the respondent authority.
The direct admission and realization of this anomalous situation and the
assurance to correct the same has been clearly pleaded by the respondent as
could be seen from paragraph 19 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondents, relevant extract of which is reproduced hereinbelow :
“19….Therefore, the answering respondents submit that all the
present writ petitioners would be protected their seniority for grant of
higher promotions and as and when the present writ petitioners be
promoted to rank of warrant officer (Clerk) they would be placed
above to Warrant Officer (who were their juniors as Hav (Clerk). And
for grant of higher promotion in the rank of Nb/Sub (Clerk) actual
seniority of the then Hav/Clerk would be maintained. The answering
respondents further submit that an official letter in this regard would
be issued, in due time…”
30.
Even without discussing the impact of the authorities cited by the
parties in connection with this case, the admission of the respondents as
pointed out above would only prove that the petitioners have been superseded
by the 89 juniors and that the anomaly created as a result thereto would be
rectified in due time.
31.
This being the case, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
respondent authority is to correct and rectify the anomalous situation of the
petitioners vis-à-vis their junior colleagues by issuing necessary orders in this
respect.
32.
The case of the petitioners stands vindicated and the prayer made in
this petition is therefore legitimate. The same is hereby allowed.
33.
Consequently, the respondents are directed to issue necessary orders
as regard the case of the petitioners and to ensure that their standing in the rolls
as well as the pay structure is commensurate with their seniority. This exercise
is to be completed within a period of six weeks preferably.
34.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
17.02.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review