Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: ITA No. 16/2007
Reserved on: 26.02.2026
Pronounced on:11.03.2026
Uploaded on: 11.03.2026
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced : Full
Ajay Food Products
….. Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)…..
Through: Mr. M.K.Bhardwaj, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Manik
Bhardwaj, Advocate.
Vs
Income Tax Officer and others
Through:
….. Respondent(s)…
Ms. Pariksha Parmar, Assisting counsel to Mr.
Suraj Singh Wazir, Advocate
Mr. K.D.S. Kotwal, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
PER OSWAL-J
1. The appellant is a partnership concern engaged in the manufacture of
Soya Naggets from Soya Beans and had availed the credit facility
from State Bank of India against hypothecation of stock in the form of
raw material and finished goods apart from mortgage of immovable
property comprising factory, land along with building, machinery etc.
On 25.09.2000, the appellant filed the statement of stock-raw material
ITA No.16/2007
and finished goods on estimated basis to avail cash credit facility, and
inflated stock was shown as the appellant was sure that no verification
of the stock and its valuation shall be made by the bank, as the factory
building, land and machinery were furnished as collateral security.
The bank accepted the statement of stock at its face value.
2. It is stated that the Assessing Officer during assessment proceedings
checked the books and called for statements of hypothecated stocks
filed with the bank. The value and quantity recorded in the books of
accounts on 25.09.2000 were as under:S.No.
1.
2.
Name of Items
Weight/Quantity Value/Amount
(Rs)
DOC Soya (Raw 20666 Kgs
351322.00
Material)
Soya Nuggets
2573 Kgs
51460.00
3. On the contrary in the statement filed with the Bank on 25.09.2000,
the stocks and its value were as under:S.No.
Name of Items
1.
DOC
Weight/Quantity Value/Amount
(Rs)
60000 Kgs
1020000.00
2.
Soya Nuggets
8000 Kgs
160000.00
4. The appellant was confronted by the Assessing Officer regarding the
discrepancy between the hypothecated stock declared to the bank and
the stock reflected in the books of account. In response, the appellant
explained that, in order to avail a higher cash credit facility from the
bank, estimated figures of stock and its valuation were furnished in
the printed proforma supplied by the bank. It was further stated that it
was done as a matter of routine, with the understanding that the bank
would not verify the contents thereof, particularly since collateral
ITA No.16/2007
security had also been provided. The appellant clarified that the
figures mentioned in the hypothecation statement were merely
estimates and had no correlation with the actual stock position or its
actual valuation as on 25.09.2000. It is stated that, pursuant to the
inquiries conducted from the bank, the bank confirmed that no
verification or physical checking of the stocks reflected in the
hypothecation statement dated 25.09.2000 had been undertaken.
However, despite the absence of any discrepancy in the quantity or
valuation of stock as recorded in the books of account, respondent
No.1 held that the appellant had failed to furnish true and correct
particulars of its income to the Department. Consequently, an addition
of ₹7,77,218/- was made vide order dated 31.03.2004.
5. Aggrieved by the order dated 31.03.2004, the appellant preferred an
appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Jammu,
who, vide order dated 08.09.2004, modified the addition of
₹7,77,218/- to ₹7,00,000/-. The reduction was effected by allowing a
margin of 10% on account of rounding off on estimation in the
valuation of stocks as reflected in the hypothecation statement.
6. Being aggrieved by the order dated 08.09.2004 passed by the
appellate authority; the appellant preferred a further appeal before the
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Amritsar Bench, Amritsar. However,
the appellant did not succeed, as the said appeal was dismissed vide
order dated 20.07.2007.
7. Aggrieved by the order dated 20.07.2007, the appellant has filed the
present appeal, raising the same grounds as were urged before the
ITA No.16/2007
Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) as well as before the Income
Tax Appellate Tribunal, Amritsar Bench, Amritsar.
8. Mr. Bhardwaj, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant, has
placed reliance upon the judgment rendered by a co-ordinate Bench of
this Court in Ashok Kumar Vs. Income Tax Officer, reported in
(2006) 201 CTR (J&K) 178 contending that the present case is
squarely covered by the ratio laid down therein.
9. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the
appellant’s contention, that it is a common business practice to furnish
inflated estimates to the bank for obtaining a higher cash credit
facility, cannot be accepted. It was argued that such a practice is not
recognized in law and has consistently been disapproved by the
Courts. In support of his submissions, reliance has been placed upon
the judgments of the High Court of Madras in case titled Coimbatore
Spinning & Weaving Co. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax,
passed in (1974) 95 ITR 375, High Court of Punjab and Haryana in
case titled Shakuntla Thukral Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax,
passed in ITA No. 302 of 2013 dated 06.02.2014 and High Court of
Madhya Pradesh, Gwalior Bench in case titled Suraj Bhan Oil (P)
Ltd. Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, passed in IT Appeal
No. 121 of 2021 dated 18.02.2022.
10.Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
11.Vide order dated 09.03.2016, the following substantial questions of
law were framed:-
ITA No.16/2007
(i)
Whether any notional addition to the returned income can be
sustained in law when the Income Tax Officer has neither
rejected the books of accounts, nor the (respondent No.1) has
held that stocks shown to the bank were available with the
appellant or that valuation of stock given in the statement of
hypothecation filed on 25.09.2000 was correct?
(ii)
Whether the impugned order of the tribunal is sustainable in law
which is based upon incorrect appreciation of law and is
perverse as it is based upon no evidence?
Substantial Question of Law No.1
12.It is contended by learned Senior Counsel that inflated stock figures
were furnished to the bank for the purpose of availing a higher cash
credit facility, which, according to him, is a usual practice in business.
It is, therefore, submitted that the Assessing Officer was not justified
in making an addition of ₹7,77,218/- as taxable income. In support of
his contention, learned counsel has placed reliance upon the judgment
rendered by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Ashok Kumar Vs.
Income Tax Officer. However, the judgment relied upon was
rendered in the peculiar facts and circumstances of that case. In the
said matter, the Assessing Authorities as well as the Tribunal had
overlooked the significant fact that the goods/stocks reflected in the
trading account as on 31.03.1990 were duly verified and valued at
cost, whereas the declaration made to the bank was not based on cost
valuation, but was merely a rough estimate. Furthermore, in that case,
only the value of the product was mentioned in the statement
furnished to the bank, and not the quantity. In those circumstances, the
co-ordinate Bench quashed the order passed by the Assessing
Authority.
ITA No.16/2007
13.In the present case, however, the factual position is materially
different. Not only the quantity but also the value of the raw material
was specifically mentioned in the statement submitted to the State
Bank of India, Purani Mandi, Jammu. At the foot of the statement, the
appellant had certified that the quantities of raw material, goods-inprocess and finished goods shown therein represented the true and
accurate stock position as on the date of the statement and were in
conformity with the permanent books of account. Thus, there was a
clear admission on the part of the appellant with regard to both the
quantity and value of the stock lying with it. In contrast to the case
relied upon by learned Senior Counsel, the quantity was not
mentioned and the estimate was held to be rough and tentative,
whereas no such circumstance exists in the instant case.
14.The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Amritsar Bench, Amritsar has
also returned a categorical finding that there existed a substantial
discrepancy between the two sets of documents. It was noticed that
there was a difference of approximately 39,500 kgs. in respect of Soya
DOC and about 5,500 kgs. in respect of Soya Nuggets under the head
of finished goods. At no stage was this significant variation
satisfactorily explained by the appellant, except by reiterating that the
inflated figures were furnished to secure a higher cash credit facility.
15.The High Court of Madhya Pradesh, in Suraj Bhan Oil (P) Ltd. Vs.
Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, has observed that a catena of
decisions rendered by various High Courts have consistently held that
the practice adopted by industrialists of declaring stock quantities to
banks in excess of the actual position, for the purpose of obtaining
ITA No.16/2007
higher loans or overdraft facilities, is not recognized as conforming to
fiscal discipline. Such a tendency has been deprecated as amounting
to commercial immorality, aimed at securing unjustified financial
advantage by furnishing incorrect statements of stock position to the
bank.
16.In view of the fact that the appellant had specifically mentioned both
the quantity and the value of the goods in the statement furnished to
the bank, and the said statement carried a clear endorsement that the
quantities of raw materials, goods-in-process and finished goods
shown therein represented the true and accurate stock position as on
the date of the statement and were in conformity with the permanent
books of account, it cannot be said that the Assessing Authority erred
in placing reliance upon such statement furnished to the bank. This
court is of the opinion that the practice of declaring inflated quantities
of stock to the bank for the purpose of securing higher cash credit, in
fact amounts to commercial immorality and such practice cannot be
countenanced in law.
17.In view of the foregoing discussion, we hold that the Assessing
Authority was justified in making the addition to the taxable income
on the basis of the statement furnished by the appellant to the bank.
Accordingly, Substantial Question of Law No. 1 is answered against
the appellant and in favour of the respondents.
Substantial Question of Law No.2
18.So far as Substantial Question of Law No. 2 is concerned, it has been
contended that the appellant has failed to demonstrate before this
Court as to how the order passed by the learned Tribunal is perverse
ITA No.16/2007
or based on no evidence. In the absence of any material to substantiate
such a plea, we find no merit in the contention raised. Accordingly,
Substantial Question of Law No. 2 is also answered against the
appellant and in favour of the respondents.
19.Viewed thus, and in light of the findings recorded hereinabove on
both the Substantial Questions of Law framed by this Court, we are of
the considered opinion that no case for interference is made out. The
impugned orders passed by the authorities below do not suffer from
any
illegality,
perversity,
or
jurisdictional
error
warranting
interference in the exercise of appellate jurisdiction. The contentions
advanced on behalf of the appellant have been duly considered and
found to be devoid of merit. The conclusions arrived at by the
Assessing Authority, as affirmed by the Commissioner of Income Tax
(Appeals), Jammu and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Amritsar
Bench, Amritsar, are based on proper appreciation of the material on
record and do not call for any reappraisal by this Court.
20.In view of the above, this appeal is found to be without any merit and
the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
(Arun Palli)
Chief Justice
Jammu
11.03.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.03.11 14:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
ITA No.16/2007
Yes.
No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review