Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 26651 OF 2024
PETITIONERS:
AISHA P
AGED 66 YEARS
MEMBER, BAR COUNCIL OF KERALA, W/O E SANKARAN
POTTY, AGED 66 YEARS, SREESAKARAM,
PADINJATTINKARA, KOTTARAKKARA P.O., KOLLAM, PIN 691506
ASHRAF K A,
AGED 54 YEARS
S/O ABDUL RAHIMAN, KUNNUMMAL, PUTHIYAKAVU,
PAPPINVATTOM, THRISSUR, PIN - 680685
BY ADVS.
THOMAS ABRAHAM
MERCIAMMA MATHEW
ASWIN.P.JOHN
R.ANANTHAPADMANABAN
PAUL BABY
SWATHY A.P.
THARA ELIZABETH THOMAS
RESPONDENTS:
BAR COUNCIL OF INDIA
21 ROUSE AVENUE, INSTITUTIONAL AREA, NEAR BHAL
BHAVAN, NEW DELHI REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
PIN – 110002.
BAR COUNCIL OF KERALA
BAR COUNCIL BHAVAN, HIGH COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN – 682031.
HONORARY SECRETARY
BAR COUNCIL OF KERALA, BAR COUNCIL BHAVAN, HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682031.
T S AJITH
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
ATHULYA, MAMMIYOOR, GURUVAYOOR P O, THRISSUR,
(ADV.AJITHTS@GMAIL.COM), PIN – 680101.
N MANOJ KUMAR
ADVOCATE, STATE ATTORNEY, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF
KERALA), HIGH COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031
RESIDING AT AMAR, HOUSE NO. 49,697 R RAJEEV
NAGAR, ELAMAKKARA P O, ERNAKULAM –
(MANOJNARENDRAN@GMAIL.COM), PIN – 682026.
SHARAFUDEEN M
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT SHAS,
CHETTAMCOONNU P.O., THELLICHERRY, KANNUR,
(SHARAFUDHEEN.ADV@GMAIL.COM), PIN - 670101
SANTOSH KUMAR P
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT THE
LAW AND JUSTICE, MANJALIKKULAM, THAMBANOOR P O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM –
(ADVSANTHOSHKUMARP@GMAIL.COM), PIN - 695001
RAJKUMAR K R
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT
THATTATHAMBILIL HOUSE, WARIAM ROAD, ERNAKULAM –
(RAJKUMARKRKHC@GMAIL.COM), PIN - 682816
JAYACHANDRAN K P
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT S/O.
SRI. PURUSHOTHAMAN PILLA, ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR
COUNSEL OF KERALA), TC 9/1200, DWARAKA, TEMPLE
ROAD, SASTHAMANGALAM P O, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
(KPJADV@YAHOO.CO.IN), PIN - 695010
SAJEEV BABU P
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT
PURUSHOTHAMS BUILDING, DWARAKA MADAM, NEAR NEW
BHARATH STUDIO, ANANTHAVALEESWARAM, NEAR
COLLECTORATE, KOLLAM- (ADVSAJEEVBABU@GMAIL.COM),
PIN - 691009
ANIL KUMAR K N
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT S/O.
SRI. NARAYANAN NAIR, P O ROAD, PERUMBAVOOR, (ANILRATIONAL@GMAIL.COM), PIN – 683542.
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
SHAJI B S
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT RITU,
T.C/14/2056(4), VENPALAVATTOM, ANAYARA P O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM (ADVANAYARASHAJI@GMAIL.COM),
PIN – 695029.
MOHAMMED SHA P A
ADVOCATE, (MEMBER, BAR COUNSEL OF KERALA), HIGH
COURT CAMPUS, ERNAKULAM 682031 RESIDING AT 4C,
EXPRESS ESTATE APARTMENTS, NEAR A J HALL, KALOOR,
ERNAKULAM – (ADVOCATESHAH@YAHOO.CO.IN), PIN 682017
BY ADVS.
M.U.VIJAYALAKSHMI
K.JAJU BABU (SR.)(K/116/1981)
SRI.RAJIT
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
ADMISSION ON 07.03.2025, THE COURT ON
THE FOLLOWING:
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
02.04.2025 DELIVERED
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
C.S.DIAS,J.
===========================
W.P (C)No.26651 of 2024
===========================
Dated this the 2nd April, 2025
JUDGMENT
The petitioners are the members of the Bar Council of
Kerala, who were co-opted to the two vacancies that arose due
to the death and the resignation of two members. The 1st
petitioner was elected by the members of the Bar Council of
Kerala ('BCK', for brevity) on 20/3/2022, and she was co-opted
as a member of the XIIth BCK on the same day by resolution
No.161 of 2022. Similarly, the 2nd petitioner was elected on
20/8/2023 and was co-opted as a member on the same day by
resolution No.254 of 2023. The term of the XII th BCK expired on
6/11/2023, on completion of 5 years as stipulated under Section
8 of the Advocates Act, 1961 (‘Act’ for brevity). Since the
elections of the next BCK could not be conducted within the
stipulated time, the Bar Council of India (‘BCI’, for short), in the
exercise of its powers under the proviso to Section 8, extended
the term of the BCK by a further 6 months. The extended period
also expired on 6/5/2024. After that, the BCI extended the term
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
of
the
XIIth
BCK
for
an
additional
term
of
months. Subsequently, by Ext.P1 communication, the BCI
nominated a few among the 25 BCK members to the three
committees viz. (i) Office Bearers of the Committee, (ii)
Executive Committee and (iii) Enrolment Committee. The
cardinal purpose of constituting the committees was to continue
the day-to-day functioning of the BCK, ensure that the election
is conducted within 18 months, and take necessary steps to
conduct periodical enrolments of fresh applicants. The BCI had
earlier issued Ext.P1(a) notification amending Rule 32 of the
Bar Council of India Certificate and Place of Practice
(Verification) Rules, 2015 (‘Verification Rules’, for brevity). The
said rule stipulates that in case the term of the elected members
of any State Bar Council is likely to expire due to delay in the
process of identification of non-practising advocates, verification
of their certificates, and delay in the preparation of the electoral
roll for the election to the State Bar Council, the BCI may allow
the elected members of the State Bar Council to continue for an
extended tenure. However, stating that Rule 32 only mentions
the extension of the term of the elected members/office bearers
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
of the State Bar Council, the petitioners are being kept out of
the meetings of the XII th BCK. The extension granted by the BCI
for the period beyond the periods mentioned under Section 8
and the proviso to Section 8 of the Act has to be made
applicable to all the members without any distinction. The coopted members cannot be held in a different class from the
elected members. The petitioners are deprived of their right to
continue as members of the XIIth BCK. The strength of the BCK,
as per Section 3(2)(b) of the Advocates Act, 1961, is 25, as the
electorate exceeds
10,000
members.
The
filling
of
the
vacancies of elected members through co-option is a statutory
procedure that cannot be watered down by any casual decision.
The enrolment function is not an extraordinary meeting and 10
days’ notice to all members of the State Bar Council is
mandatory. Therefore, the meeting for the proposed enrollment
is illegal. Hence, the writ petition.
2. The first respondent has filed a statement through its
Standing Counsel contending that the petitioners were co-opted
as members of the BCK. The five-year term of the BCK came to
an end on 06.11.2023. The term was then extended for six
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
months till 06.05.2024. After that, the BCK was dissolved. BCI
then constituted a special committee invoking its powers under
Rule 32 of the Verification Rules. The petitioners have no legal
right to continue as members of the BCK because they were coopted members, and the term of the BCK has not been
extended. This Court has rejected the challenge against the
constitution of the Committee in W.A.No.788/2024. The
judgment has become final. Therefore, the writ petition may be
dismissed.
3. The respondents 2 and 3 have filed a counter
affidavit stating that the cases challenging the amendment to
Rule 32 of the Verification Rules are pending consideration
before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. To avoid conflicting
judgments, the cases pending before the various High Courts
on the same question have been transferred to the Hon'ble
Supreme Court. The 1 respondent is competent to amend the
st
Rules in view of the powers under the Advocates Act, 1961.
Rule 32 has been amended with the bona fide intention of
removing advocates from the rolls of the Bar Council who do
not possess valid certificates. By Ext.R2 (a) letter, the BCK had
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
requested the BCI to extend the term of the XII th BCK as per the
amended Rule 32 to complete the verification process.
Accordingly, by Ext.2 (b), the BCI has extended the tenure of all
the elected members by another 18 months. After that, by
Ext.R2 (c), committees were constituted, and they have taken
charge on 21.05.2024. The challenge against Ext.R2 (c) was
rejected by this Court by Exts. R2 (d) and (e) judgments. As the
petitioners are co-opted members, they cannot continue as
members of the XIIth BCK. The writ petition may be rejected.
4. Heard: Sri. Thomas Abraham, the learned Counsel for
the petitioners; Sri. Rajit, the learned Counsel for the 1st
respondent/ BCI, and Sri. Jaiju Babu, the learned Senior
Counsel for respondents 2 to 4 and 8.
5. Sri. Thomas Abraham submitted that he was not
pressing relief No. (iv), i.e., to quash Ext.P1 letter to the extent
of constituting three committees.
6. The petitioners’ grievance is that they are being
sidelined from the XIIth BCK in view of Ext.R2 (b) resolution
passed by the BCI.
7. It is undisputed that the petitioners were elected and co-
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
opted as members of the XIIth BCK as per Rule 17 of Chapter IV
of the Bar Council of Kerala Rules, 1979, on the death and
resignation of two members. It is also not disputed that the
original term of five years of the XII th BCK came to an end
on 6.11.2023. As the elections were not conducted within the
stipulated timeframe, the BCI, in exercising its powers under the
proviso to Section 8 of the Act, extended the term of the XII th
BCK for an additional six months, which expired on 6.5.2024.
Before the expiry of the extended term, by Ext.R2(a) letter, the
BCK had requested the BCI to extend the term of the XII th BCK
by invoking its powers under the amended Rule 32 of the
Verification Rules. Consequently, the BCI passed Ext.R2 (b)
resolution extending the tenure of the elected members of the
XIIth BCK for 18 months to complete the verification process. It
was also resolved that a committee be constituted to complete
the verification process. Accordingly, by Ext.R2 (c) letter dated
20.05.2024, three committees were constituted.
8. In the above context, it is necessary to refer to the
amended Rule 32 of the Bar Council of India Certificate and
Place of Practice (Verification) Rules, 2015, which reads as
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
follows:
“Rule 32. In case the term of elected members of any state Bar
Council is likely to expire/expires due to delay in the process of
identification of non-practicing advocates or verification of their certificates
or delay in the preparation in the electoral roll for the election to the state
Bar Councils due to the aforementioned reasons, the Bar Council of India
may allow the elected members/and the office-bearers of the State Bar
Council(s) to continue to function beyond their extended tenure under
Section 8 of the Advocates Act, 1961 in order to complete the process of
verification and in order to ensure that no non-practicing Advocate
becomes a voter or a member of any state Bar Council. The State Bar
Council(s) shall be required to complete the process of verification within
a period of 18 months from the date of extension of their tenure by the
Bar Council of India and shall complete the process of election within a
period of 6 months therefrom.
In case, of failure to complete the process of verification and
the election within the said extended period as prescribed under this
Rule, the Bar Council of India may dissolve the State Bar Council
and shall proceed to constitute the Special Committee as provided
under Section 8A of the Advocates Act, 1961”.
(emphasis given)
9. The above Rule bestows the BCI with the power to
extend the term of a State Bar Council up to 18 months to
identify non-practising Advocates and verify their certificates to
conduct the fresh election, dehors the timeframe stipulated
under Section 8 of the Act, viz., 5 years and 6 months (the
original term plus the extended term).
10. The BCI is conferred with the power to extend the term
of
a
State
Bar
Council
identification/verification
up
process.
to
Once
months
the
for
the
process
is
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
complete, the elections have to be held within 6 months.
However, if the process cannot be completed within 18 months,
then the BCI may dissolve the State Bar Council and proceed to
constitute a Special Committee as contemplated under Section
8 A of the Act.
11. On an analysis of the above provisions, I disagree with
the submission of the learned Counsel for the 1st respondent
that the XIIth BCK has been dissolved. If that is the case, in view
of Rule 32 of the Verification Rules, the BCI is not empowered
to extend the term of the members and is bound to constitute a
Special Committee under Section 8 A of the Act. Hence, this
Court is of the view that the XIIth BCK is in existence but is
functioning through the three committees constituted under
Ext.R2 (c) order.
12. It is also to be noted that the request of the BCK in
Ext.R2 (a) letter was to extend the term of the XII th BCK as per
the amended Rule 32 of the Verification Rules. Accordingly, by
Ext.R2 (b) resolution, the BCI extended the term of the elected
members of the BCK. Taking the words ‘elected members’ as a
cue,
the
petitioners
are
not
being
invited
to
the
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
programs/functions of the XIIth BCK because they are co-opted
members and not elected members.
13. Section 3 (2) (b) of the Act mandates that those
State Bar Councils having an electorate exceeding ten
thousand members, in addition to the Advocate General of the
State as the Ex-officio member, the State Bar Council shall
consist of twenty-five members, to be elected from amongst the
advocates on its electoral roll. Hence, the strength of BCK is 26
members.
14. To maintain the strength of the members at the
above number, Rule 2 (e) of the Bar Council of Kerala Rules,
1979, is incorporated to fill a casual vacancy that may arise
before the expiry of a member's term of office. Rule 17 lays
down the procedure for filling such casual vacancies.
15. There is no dispute that the petitioners were elected
by the members and co-opted to the XII th BCK, as per the
procedure contemplated under the Rules, to ensure that the
BCK functions with the statutory strength. Since BCI has
extended the term of the XIIth BCK by Ext. R 2(b) resolution,
irrespective of the fact that the petitioners were co-opted to the
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
BCK at a later stage, the petitioners cannot be differentiated
from the elected members. The Act and the Rules do not treat
co-opted members as a separate or distinct class. The
petitioners have the right to continue as members of the XII th
BCK until it is dissolved. The elected members mentioned in
Ext.R2 (b) resolution include the petitioners.
In light of the above discussions, I allow the writ
petition by declaring that the elected members of the XII th Bar
Council of Kerala in Ext R2 (b) resolution shall also mean and
include the petitioners. The petitioners shall be entitled to all the
rights and privileges of elected members of the Bar Council of
Kerala as mentioned in Ext.R2 (b) resolution.
The writ petition is ordered accordingly.
Sd/-C.S.DIAS, JUDGE
ma/01/04/2025
2025:KER:27410
W.P (C) No.26651 of 2024
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 26651/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION
NO.BCI:D:2494/2024 DATED 20/5/2024
ISSUED BY THE BAR COUNCIL OF INDIA
Exhibit P2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE
NO.KBC/M/XII-EMT./3871/2024 DATED
20/7/2024
Exhibit P3
THE TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION
DATED 22/7/2024 SENT BY THE PETITIONERS
EXHIBIT P1(a)
THE TRUE COPY OF THE GAZETTE
NOTIFICATION NO.BCR:D:3430/2023 DATED
23/6/2023
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R2(a)
True copy of the letter dated 13.4.2024
of the Secretary of Bar Council of
Kerala addressed to the 1st respondent
Exhibit R2(b)
True copy of the letter dated 6.5. 2024
of the 1st respondent
Exhibit R2(c)
True copy of the communication dated
20.5.2024 issued by the 1st respondent
Exhibit R2(d)
True copy of the judgment dated
3.6.2024 of this Honorable Court in
WP(C) No. 18361/2024
Exhibit R2(e)
True copy of the judgment dated
19.8.2024 of this Honorable Court in
W.A No. 788/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P4
The true copy of the letter dated
6/5/2024 issued by the Secretary, Bar
Council of India to the Secretary, Bar
Council of Kerala
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review