Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ZIYAD RAHMAN A.A.
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 6805 OF 2025
PETITIONER/S:
AHALIA INTERNATIONAL FOUNDATION,
AHALIA CAMPUS, KOZHIPPARA P.O., PALAKKAD DISTRICT,
REPRESENTED BY ITS TRUSTEE, PIN - 678557
BY ADVS.
NISHA GEORGE
GEORGE POONTHOTTAM (SR.)
SIDHARTH.R.WARIYAR
RESPONDENT/S:
THE STATE ENVIRONMENT IMPACT ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY,
(SEIAA KERALA), 4TH FLOOR, KSRTC BUS TERMINAL COMPLEX,
THAMPANOOR, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHAIRMAN, PIN - 695001
THE KERALA STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD,
HEAD OFFICE, PATTOM P.O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRPERSON, PIN - 695004
THE VADAKARAPATHY GRAMA PANCHAYAT,
VADAKARAPATHY, PALAKKAD, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
PIN - 678556
BY ADVS.
FOR R1 BY ADV.M.P.SREEKRISHNAN, SC
FOR R2 BY SHRI.T.NAVEEN, SC
R3 BY SRI. K.MOHANAKANNAN
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
13.03.2025, THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
JUDGMENT
The petitioner, a non-profit organization primarily focussed
on healthcare, has approached this Court being aggrieved by the
stand taken by the 2nd respondent- The Kerala Pollution Control Board,
insisting on environmental clearance for the constructions made by
the petitioner for granting Consent to Operate. The reliefs sought by
the petitioner are as follows:
“i. Issue a writ declaring that the petitioner is exempted from
procuring prior Environmental Clearance as per the amended
provisions of the Environmental Impact Assessment Notification,
2006 and the insistence of the Pollution Control Board to obtain
E.C is not a legal requirement;
ii. Issue a writ declaring that the 2nd respondent is bound to grant
consent to operate to the petitioner without insisting for
Environmental Clearance;
iii. Issue a writ of mandamus directing the 2nd respondent to issue
consent to operate to the petitioner;
iv. Issue a writ of mandamus directing the 1st respondent to issue
Environmental Clearance to the petitioner
v. Issue a writ of mandamus directing the 3rd respondent to issue
renewed Certificate of Registration for the Hospital of the
petitioner Trust;
vi. Dispense with the filing of English translation of vernacular
documents;
vii. Issue such other Writ, Order or direction as this Hon’ble Court
may deem fit in the facts and circumstances of this case.”
2. The facts that led to the filing of this writ petition are as
follows:
As the petitioner intended to establish a speciality hospital for
women and children, they obtained a building permit from the 3 rd
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
respondent
Grama
Panchayat,
as
evidenced
by
Ext.P1,
for
constructing a hospital building with a total area of 32437.35 sq.mts.
Exhibit P1 is dated 5.7.2008 and the construction of the hospital
began in 2009. The petitioner also obtained a ‘Consent to Establish’,
from the 2nd respondent as early as 01.07.2009, which is Ext.P2.
According to the petitioner, they have already provided necessary
measures for environmental conservation and sustainability. The
petitioner also obtained registration from the 3 rd respondent under the
Kerala Panchayat Raj (Registration of Private Hospitals and Private
Paramedical Institutions) Rules 1997, as early as in the year, 2011.
After completing the construction of the entire building, the petitioner
applied for ‘Consent to Operate’ from the 2 nd respondent on
29.12.2019. However, the 2nd respondent, instead of granting the
same, required the petitioner to re-submit the application along with
an
Environmental
Clearance
from
the
1 st
respondent
for
the
functioning of the hospital. This writ petition is submitted by the
petitioner in such circumstances challenging the same.
3. According to the petitioner, such a stipulation is not at all
necessary in view of the subsequent notification issued in this regard.
According to the petitioner, initially, the relevant notification was
Environmental Impact Assessment Notification, 2006 (SO 1533 (E)
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
dated 14.9.2006, which contemplated prior environmental clearance
in the case of construction projects having an area beyond 20,000
sq.mts. However, later, the requirement of prior environmental
clearance in respect of the construction projects was substituted by a
further notification dated 15.11.2018, wherein the minimum area for
which prior environmental clearance required, was enhanced to
50,000 sq.mts. from 20,000 sq.mts.
Exhibit P4(b) is the said
notification. Therefore, it was pointed out that, in the light of the
above, it is not necessary for the petitioner to obtain a prior
environmental clearance. Besides, it was also the case of the
petitioner that the petitioner is entitled to get an exemption in respect
of the building used for the purpose of education, as the petitioner is
running paramedical educational courses along with the hospital.
4. A statement was filed by the respondent No.1, wherein,
the contentions raised by the petitioner are opposed. It is pointed out
that the notification issued in the year 2018 cannot be made
applicable to the case of the petitioner, as the petitioner admittedly
commenced the work on the basis of an Ext.P1 permit in the year
2009.
At the relevant time, what was in existence was 2006
notification, which contemplated for prior environmental clearance for
all constructions beyond 20,000 sq.mts. Since the requirement was
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
“prior environmental clearance”, the subsequent notifications which
are having prospective operation only, cannot be made applicable to
the case of the petitioner.
5. The petitioner had already violated the requirement of
prior environmental clearance as on the date of commencement of the
project and the same cannot be effaced by relying upon subsequent
notification.
It was pointed out that, as far as 2018 notification is
concerned, the operation of the same is stayed by the High Court of
Delhi as per Annexure R1(a) order and also by the Principal Bench of
the National Green Tribunal as evidenced by R1(b).
In such
circumstances, on that reasons also, those notifications cannot be
relied on. It was also pointed out that, now a new notification was
issued by the Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change of
India on 29.1.2025, a copy of which is produced as Annexure R1(c)
wherein criteria remained the same viz., 20,000 sq.mts. It was also
pointed out that, even though it contemplates for certain exemption in
respect of industrial sheds, schools, college and hostel, educational
institution etc., the same cannot be availed by the petitioner, as
admittedly the petitioner had obtained a permit for a hospital and the
hospital is not one among the exempted categories as per the present
notification.
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
6.
I have heard Sri. George Poonthottam, the learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner assisted by Smt. Nisha
George, Sri.M.P. Sreekrishnan, the learned Standing Counsel for the
1st respondent, Sri.T.Naveen, the learned Standing Counsel for the 2 nd
respondent and Sri. K. Mohanakannan, the learned Standing Counsel
for the 3rd respondent.
7.
The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner vehemently
contended that under no circumstances, the 2 nd respondent can insist
for an environmental clearance, as 2018 notification (Ext. P4(b))
specifically contemplates the requirement of environmental clearance
from the 1st respondent only in respect of the buildings having an area
more than 50,000 sq.mts., whereas the petitioner’s building has an
area of 32437.35 sq.mts only. However, the crucial aspect to be noticed
is that as rightly pointed out by the learned Standing Counsel for the 1 st
respondent, admittedly, the petitioner started the construction of the
hospital in the year, 2009 on the basis of Ext.P1 building permit dated
25.5.2008. In Ext.P1 building permit it is specifically mentioned that the
total plinth area comes to 32437.35 sq.mts. It is also an admitted fact
that, the petitioner commenced the said construction based on the same.
Therefore, as on the said date, what was prevailing was the 2006
notification,
which
provided
for
prior
environmental
clearance
in
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
respect of the buildings having an area more than 20,000 sq.mts.
Therefore,
under
no
circumstances
the
petitioner
should
have
commenced any construction without obtaining prior environmental
clearance as envisaged in the year 2006 notification. The reliance
placed on the subsequent notifications cannot be accepted as well,
since those are having prospective operation only. In P. Mahendran
and Others v. State of Karnataka
and Others [(1990) 1 SCC
411], in para. 5 the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that, “It is a well
settled rule of construction that every statute or statutory rule is
prospective unless it is expressly or by necessary implication made to
have retrospective effect. Unless there are words in the statute or in
the Rules showing the intention to affect existing rights the rule must
be held to be prospective. If a rule is expressed in language which is
fairly capable of either interpretation it ought to be construed as
prospective only. In the absence of any express provision or
necessary intendment the rule cannot be given retrospective effect
except in matter of procedure”.
8.
Even if it is assumed for argument sake that, the
subsequent notifications are applicable, the petitioner cannot avail the
benefits of the same due to various reasons. Even though a
subsequent notification was issued in the year, 2014 granting certain
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
exemptions to buildings used for accommodating industrial sheds,
school, college, hostel, educational institutions etc, the petitioner
cannot claim the benefit of the same,
as
going by the building
permit, the construction was intended for establishing the hospital and
a construction for the hospital is not exempted. Moreover, 2014
notification was interfered with by the Division Bench of this Court in
WP(C) No.3097/2016 by quashing the same as it was found that, the
said notification was in deviation from the draft notification published.
The subsequent notification was published in the year, 2018 and the
same is already stayed by the High Court of Delhi as evidenced by
Annexure R1(a) order and also by the Principal bench of the National
Green Tribunal as evidenced by Annexure R1(b).
9. One of the contentions of the learned Senior Counsel was
that the order of stay passed by the Delhi High Court cannot be made
applicable in the State of Kerala, as according to him, the impact of
the stay order is confined to the territories of the Delhi High Court.
However, I am not inclined to accept the same. The legal position in
this regard is settled by various judicial pronouncements rendered by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court including the one in Kusum Ingots &
Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India and Another [(2004)6 SCC 254]. In
the said decision, in paragraph 22 it was categorically observed by the
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
Hon’ble Supreme Court that an order passed on a writ petition
questioning the constitutionality of a parliamentary Act, whether
interim or final keeping in view the provisions contained in clause (2)
of Article 226 of the Constitution of India, will have effect throughout
the territory of India subject of course to the applicability of the Act.
Therefore, the order of stay passed by the High Court of Delhi will
have its application, even in the territory of the State of Kerala. Even
if it is assumed that the said stay order will not have any effect, there
is an order of stay passed by the National Green Tribunal as
evidenced by Annexure R1(b) as well. The same is applicable
throughout the country. Therefore, the petitioner cannot rely on the
2018 notification.
10.
As far as the notification published
in the year 2025 is
concerned, the criteria therein remains the same ie. all constructions
having more than 20,000 sq.mts have to obtain prior environmental
clearance. Of course, it is true that, the said notification contemplates
for exemption for industrial sheds, college, hostel for educational
institution etc. for calculating plinth area for the purpose of applying
the above criteria. As mentioned above, it is evident from Ext.P1 that
the petitioner intended to establish a hospital, and there is no mention
of any educational institution. In the ‘Consent to Establish’, which the
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
petitioner obtained as evidenced by Ext.P2 in the year 2009 also, the
activities shown were that of the hospital. Therefore, there is no
material
to
show
that
the
construction
was
commenced
for
accommodating any educational institution.
11.
Thus, after carefully going through all the statutory
provisions and materials placed on record, I find that the petitioner is
not entitled to the relief sought for. Evidently, the petitioner had
obtained the building permit and started the construction intended for
a hospital, which was not excluded from the purview of the 2006
notification. As per the stipulations in the same, the requirement was
to obtain prior environmental clearance for all constructions beyond
the area of 20,000 sq.mts. Exhibit P1 building permit would indicate
that the extent of the building proposed by the petitioner was
32437.35 sq.mts and therefore it comes within the category of the
construction which requires prior environmental clearance. As far as
the notifications relied on by the petitioner are concerned, I have
already held that the same cannot have any retrospective application,
particularly because, what was required in 2006 was an environmental
clearance prior to the commencement of the construction.
Therefore, I do not find any merits in the contentions raised
by the petitioner and accordingly this writ petition is dismissed
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
without prejudice to the right of the petitioners to take necessary
steps for obtaining the environmental clearance.
Sd/ZIYAD RAHMAN A.A.
JUDGE
pkk*
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 6805/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF BUILDING PERMIT NO. 60/08
DATED 05.07.2008 OF THE VADAKARAPATHY GRAMA
PANCHAYAT
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF CONSENT TO ESTABLISH NO.
PCB/HO/PKLD/NOC/37/2008 DATED 01.07.2009
ISSUED BY THE STATE POLLUTION CONTROL
BOARD, AND VALID TILL 30.06.2012
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
REGISTRATION OF PRIVATE HOSPITALS AND
PRIVATE PARA MEDICAL INSTITUTIONS DATED
05.09.2011 REGISTERING THE HOSPITAL AS NO.
4/2011
EXHIBIT P3(A)
TRUE COPY OF THE REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE
DATED 11.06.2021 UNDER THE KERALA PANCHAYAT
RAJ (REGISTRATION OF PRIVATE HOSPITALS AND
PRIVATE PARA MEDICAL INSTITUTIONS) RULES,
1997 FOR THE YEAR 2021-22.
EXHIBIT P3(B)
THE REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE DATED
21.04.2022 UNDER THE KERALA PANCHAYAT RAJ
(REGISTRATION OF PRIVATE HOSPITALS AND
PRIVATE PARA MEDICAL INSTITUTIONS) RULES,
1997 FOR THE YEAR 2022-23.
TRUE COPY OF OWNERSHIP CERTIFICATE NO.
A2/1442/2011 DATED 12.12.2011 ISSUED BY THE
VADAKARAPATHY GRAMA PANCHAYAT
EXHIBIT P4
EXHIBIT P4(A)
TRUE COPY OF OWNERSHIP CERTIFICATE NO.
5086501/762/2023 DATED 29.04.2023 ISSUED BY
THE VADAKARAPATHY GRAMA PANCHAYAT
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF OFFICE MEMORANDUM F. NO. 2221/2020-IA.III DATED 07.07.2021.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.
SIA/KL/MIS/72912/2022 DATED 24.06.2022
ISSUED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE 1ST
RESPONDENT TO SRI. M. R. DINIL, ONE OF THE
2025:KER:30880
WP(C)No.6805 of 2025
TRUSTEES OF THE PETITIONER
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 02.01.2024 IN
WP(C) NO. 1394/2023 OF THE HON’BLE SUPREME
COURT
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 20.05.2024 ISSUED
BY THE CHAIRMAN, KSPCB TO THE PETITIONER,
ALONG WITH THE MINUTES OF THE HEARING
CONDUCTED ON 23.04.2024
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 05.06.2024
ISSUED BY THE MANAGING TRUSTEE OF THE
PETITIONER TO THE CHAIRPERSON OF THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO. KSPCB/780/2024/EE-1
DATED 25.08.2024 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P4(B)
TRUE COPY OF S.O. 5736(E) DATED 15.11.2018
ISSUED BY THE MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT,
FOREST AND CLIMATE CHANGE
EXHIBIT P4(C)
TRUE COPY OF S.O. 5733(E) DATED 14.11.2018
ISSUED BY THE MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT,
FOREST AND CLIMATE CHANGE
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE R1B
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 3.12.2018 IN
OA 1017/2018 ON THE FILES OF NGT
ANNEXURE R1C
A TRUE COPY OF SO 523 (E) DATED 29.01.2025
ISSUED BY MOEF AND CC
ANNEXURE R1D
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 06.01.2025
IN WP(C) SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL)
DIARY NO(S). 49103/2024
ANNEXURE R1A
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED
26.11.2018 IN WP(C) 12517 OF 2018 AND WP(C)
12570 OF 2018 ON THE FILES OF DELHI HIGH
COURT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review