Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally signed
by SUMIT
SUMIT KUMAR
Date:
KUMAR 2026.09.10
16:06:56
+0530
CGHC010340712026
2026:CGHC:39584
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WP227 No. 1131 of 2026
Agriculture Insurance Company Of India Ltd. Through Regional Manager,
Address Regional Office, L.I.C. Investment Building, Phase - 2, Second
Floor, Pandri, Raipur (C.G.), Alternate Address - Office Block - 1, Fifth Floor,
Plate B And C, East Kidwai Nagar, New Delhi, 110023
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Branch Manager Punjab National Bank Branch Bhandarpur, Address
Bhandarpur, Tehsil - Khairagarh, District - Rajnandgaon (Present District K.C.G.) (C.G.), 491414
2 - Shrawan Kumar Chakradhari S/o Gulamram Chakradhari Aged About 65
Years R/o Village - Banbod, Tehsil - Khairagarh, District - Rajnandgaon
(Present District - K.C.G.) (C.G.) - 491445
--- Respondent(s)
WP227 No. 1134 of 2026
Agriculture Insurance Company Of India Ltd. Through Regional Manager,
Address Regional Office, L I C Investment Building, Phase - 2, Second Floor,
Pandri, Raipur (C.G.) Alternate Address - Office Block - 1, Fifth Floor, Plate B
And C, East Kidwai Nagar, New Delhi, 110023
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Branch Manager Punjab National Bank Branch Bhandarpur, Address
Bhandarpur, Tehsil - Khairagarh, District - Rajnandgaon (Present District - K.
C. G. (C.G.), 491414
2 - Jayendra Kumar Verma, S/o Satrughan Verma, Aged About 49 Years R/o
Village - Khairbana, Tehsil - Dongargarh, District - Rajnandgaon, (Present
District K. C. G.) (C.G.) - 491881
--- Respondent(s)
WP227 No. 1132 of 2026
Agriculture Insurance Company Of India Ltd. Through Regional Manager,
Address- Regional Office, Lic Investment Building, Phase- 2, Second Floor,
Pandri, Raipur (C.G.) Alternate Address- Office Block- 1, Fifth Floor, Plate B
And C, East Kidwai Nagar, New Delhi, 110023
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Branch Manager Punjab National Bank Branch- Bhandarpur, AddressBhandarpur, Tehsil- Khairagarh, District- Rajnandgaon (Present DistrictK.C.G.) (C.G.), 491414
2 - Prakash Gond S/o Preetram Mandawi Aged About 48 Years R/o VillageJagannathpur/karela, Tehsil- Khairagarh, District- Rajnandgaon (Present
District- K.C.G.) (C.G.)- 491445
--- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Suraj Patel, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sharad Mishra, Advocate
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J.)
Order on Board
09/09/2026
1.
As all these three writ petitions arise from a common order passed by
the learned National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New
Delhi, and involve common questions of fact and law, they were heard
together and are being disposed of by this common order.
2.
The petitioner in all the petitions has filed the present writ petition
seeking for the following reliefs :“(i) That this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to
allow the writ petition and consequently, issue an
appropriate writ/order/direction thereby quashing/setting
aside the impugned order dated 01.10.2025 passed by
the
National
Consumer
Disputes
Redressal
Commission, New Delhi.
(ii) That this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue an appropriate writ/order/direction thereby staying
the operation and effect of the impugned order dated
01.10.2025, till the pendency of this writ petition.
(iii) That any other order/relief which this Hon’ble Court
may deem fit, proper and just in the facts and
circumstances of the present case may also kindly be
awarded to the petitioner in the ends of justice & equity.
(iv) That the cost of the petition may kindly also be
awarded to the petitioner.”
3.
The present writ petitions are filed by the Agriculture Insurance
Company of India Ltd. challenging the order of the National Consumer
Disputes
Redressal
Commission
affirming
the
order
of
the
Chhattisgarh State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission,
whereby the petitioner/Insurance Company and Punjab National Bank
were held jointly and severally liable to compensate the respondentfarmers under the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY). The
respondent-farmers had availed Kisan Credit Card loans, and the
Bank had deducted the crop insurance premium from their accounts
and remitted the same to the Insurance Company for Rabi 2019-20.
However, the Bank failed to upload the farmers' particulars on the
National Crop Insurance Portal (NCIP), resulting in denial of insurance
coverage despite the farmers being otherwise eligible and similarly
situated
farmers
having
received
compensation.
The
District
Consumer Commission initially exonerated the Insurance Company
and held only the Bank liable, but the State Commission modified the
order by holding that while the Bank was negligent in not uploading the
farmers' data, the Insurance Company had also committed deficiency
in service by retaining the premium amount for several months without
either extending insurance coverage or refunding the premium within
the prescribed time under the applicable Government notifications.
The National Commission affirmed the said finding, holding both
agencies jointly and severally liable. Aggrieved thereby, the Insurance
Company approached this Court contending that under the PMFBY
Operational Guidelines, the responsibility for uploading farmers' data
rested exclusively with the Bank and, therefore, the entire liability
ought to have been fastened upon the Bank alone.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the parties jointly submit that the
controversy involved in the present writ petitions is squarely covered
by the decision of this Court rendered in WP(227) No. 845 of 2026
(Agriculture Insurance Company Of India Ltd. v. Branch Manager
and another) and the connected batch of petitions vide order dated
17.07.2026. It is, therefore, prayed that the present writ petition may
also be decided in terms of the said order.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents annexed to the writ petition.
6.
This Court, while deciding WP(227) No. 845 of 2026 and the
connected batch of petitions by order dated 17.07.2026, observed as
under:
“13. In the present case, the controversy does not relate
to the entitlement of the complainant/farmers to receive
compensation under the PMFBY, as the said issue has
attained finality. The limited question raised by the
petitioner/Insurance Company is with regard to the
fastening of joint and several liability upon it along with
the Respondent No. 1/Bank. The State Consumer
Disputes
Redressal
Commission,
upon
a
detailed
appreciation of the PMFBY Operational Guidelines, the
Government notifications and the material available on
record, modified the order of the District Commission by
holding both the Respondent No. 1/Bank and the
petitioner/Insurance Company liable, which has been
affirmed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission. It is well settled that while exercising
jurisdiction under Article 227, this Court does not sit as a
Court of appeal over the findings recorded by the
tribunals below and interference is warranted only where
the findings suffer from patent perversity, manifest
illegality or jurisdictional error. The parameters governing
the
exercise
of
supervisory
jurisdiction
stand
authoritatively explained by the Supreme Court in Shalini
Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra Shankar Patil, (2010) 8 SCC
329, wherein it has been held that Article 227 is intended
to keep subordinate courts and tribunals within the
bounds of their authority and cannot be invoked for reappreciation of evidence and held that:“40. Same principles have been followed by this
Court in Mani Nariman Daruwala v. Phiroz N.
Bhatena1 , wherein it has been held that in exercise
of its jurisdiction under Article 227, the High Court
can set aside or reverse finding of an inferior court
or tribunal only in a case where there is no
evidence or where no reasonable person could
possibly have come to the conclusion which the
court or tribunal has come to. This Court made it
clear that except to this "limited extent" the High
Court has no jurisdiction to interfere with the
findings of fact (see SCC pp. 149-50, para 18). In
coming to the above finding, this Court relied on its
previous decision rendered in Chandavarkar Sita
(1991) 3 SCC 141
Ratna Rao v. Ashalata S. Guram 2. The decision in
Chandavarkar is based on the principle of the
Constitution Bench judgments in Waryam Singh3
and Nagendra Nath4 discussed above.
41. To the same effect is the judgment rendered in
Laxmikant
Revchand
Bhojwani
v.
Pratapsing
Mohansingh Pardeshi5. In SCC para 9 at pp. 57980 of the Report, this Court clearly reminded the
High Court that under Article 227 that it cannot
assume unlimited prerogative to correct all species
of hardship or wrong decisions. Its exercise must
be restricted to grave dereliction of duty and
flagrant abuse of fundamental principles of law and
justice.
42. Same views have been taken by this Court in
respect of the ambit of High Court's power under
Article 227 in Lonand Grampanchayat v. Ramgiri
Gosavi6 (AIR pp. 222-34, para 5 of the Report) and
the decision of this Court in Jijabai Vithalrao Gajre
v. Pathankhan7. The Constitution Bench ratio in
Waryam Singh8 about the scope of Article 227 was
again followed in Ahmedabad Mfg. & Calico Ptg.
Co. Ltd. v. Ram Tahel Ramnand9.
4310*. In a rather recent decision of the Supreme
Court in Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai 11 a
two-Judge Bench of this Court discussed the
principles of interference by the High Court under
(1986) 4 SCC 447
Waryam Singh v. Amarnath, AIR 1954 SC 215
Nagendra Nath Bora v. Commr. Of Hills Division and Appeals, AIR 1958 SC 398
(1995)6 SCC 576
AIR 1968 SCC 222
(1970)2 SCC 717
Waryam singh v. Amarnath AIR 1954 SC 215
(1972)1 SCC 898
10 *ED: Para 43 Corrected vide official Corrigendum No. F.3/ED.B.J./84/2010 dated 26-08-2010.
11 (2003)6 SCC 675
Article 227. Of course in Surya Dev Rai this Court
held that a writ of certiorari is maintainable against
the order of a civil court, subordinate to the High
Court (SCC p. 688, para 19 of the Report). The
correctness of that ratio was doubted by another
Division Bench of this Court in Radhey Shyam v.
Chhabi Nath12 and a request to the Hon'ble Chief
Justice for a reference to a larger Bench is
pending. But insofar as the formulation of the
principles on the scope of interference by the High
Court under Article 227 is concerned, there is no
divergence of views.
44. In para 38 sub-para (4) at SCC p. 695 of the
Report, the following principles have been laid
down in Surya Dev Rai and they are set out:
"38.(4) Supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of
the is exercised for keeping the subordinate courts
within the bounds of their jurisdiction. When a
subordinate court has assumed a jurisdiction which
it does not have or has failed to exercise a
jurisdiction which it does have or the jurisdiction
though available is being exercised by the court in
a manner not permitted by law and failure of justice
or grave injustice has occasioned thereby, the High
Court may step in to exercise its supervisory
jurisdiction."
45. Sub-paras (5), (7) and (8) of para 38 are also
on the same lines and extracted below: (Surya Dev
Rai case SCC pp. 695-96)
"38.(5) Be it a writ of certiorari or the exercise of
supervisory jurisdiction, none is available to correct
mere errors of fact or of law unless the following
requirements are satisfied: (I) the error is manifest
12 (2009)5 SCC 616
and apparent on the face of the proceedings such
as when it is based on clear ignorance or utter
disregard of the provisions of law, and (ii) a grave
injustice or gross failure of justice has occasioned
thereby.
(6)
*
*
*
(7) The power to issue a writ of certiorari and the
supervisory
jurisdiction
are
to
be
exercised
sparingly and only in appropriate cases where the
judicial conscience of the High Court dictates it to
act lest a gross failure of justice or grave injustice
should occasion. Care, caution and circumspection
need to be exercised, when any of the abovesaid
two jurisdictions is sought to be invoked during the
pendency of any suit or proceedings in a
subordinate court and the error though calling for
correction is yet capable of being corrected at the
conclusion of the proceedings in an appeal or
revision preferred there against and entertaining a
petition
invoking
certiorari
or
supervisory
jurisdiction of the High Court would obstruct the
smooth flow and/or early disposal of the suit or
proceedings. The High Court may feel inclined to
intervene where the error is such, as, if not
corrected at that very moment, may become
incapable of correction at a later stage and refusal
to intervene would result in travesty of justice or
where such refusal itself would result in prolonging
of the lis.
(8) The High Court in exercise of certiorari or
supervisory jurisdiction will not convert itself into a
court of appeal and indulge in re appreciation or
evaluation of evidence or correct errors in drawing
inferences or correct errors of mere formal or
technical character."
49. On an analysis of the aforesaid decisions of
this Court, the following principles on the exercise
of High Court's jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution may be formulated:
(a) A petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is
different from a petition under Article 227. The
mode of exercise of power by the High Court under
these two articles is also different.
(b) In any event, a petition under Article 227 cannot
be called a writ petition. The history of the
conferment of writ jurisdiction on High Courts is
substantially
different
from
the
history
of
conferment of the power of superintendence on the
High Courts under Article 227 and have been
discussed above.
(c) High Courts cannot, at the drop of a hat, in
exercise of its power of superintendence under
Article 227 of the Constitution, interfere with the
orders of tribunals or courts inferior to it. Nor can it,
in exercise of this power, act as a court of appeal
over the orders of the court or tribunal subordinate
to it. In cases where an alternative statutory mode
of redressal has been provided, that would also
operate as a restrain on the exercise of this power
by the High Court.
(d) The parameters of interference by High Courts
in exercise of their power of superintendence have
been repeatedly laid down by this Court. In this
regard the High Court must be guided by the
principles laid down by the Constitution Bench of
this Court in Waryam Singh and the principles in
Waryam Singh have been repeatedly followed by
subsequent Constitution Benches and various
other decisions of this Court.
(e) According to the ratio in Waryam Singh,
followed in subsequent cases, the High Court in
exercise of its jurisdiction of superintendence can
interfere in order only to keep the tribunals and
courts subordinate to it, "within the bounds of their
authority".
(f) In order to ensure that law is followed by such
tribunals and courts by exercising jurisdiction which
is vested in them and by not declining to exercise
the jurisdiction which is vested in them.
(g) Apart from the situations pointed in (e) and (f),
High Court can interfere in exercise of its power of
superintendence when there has been a patent
perversity in the orders of the tribunals and courts
subordinate to it or where there has been a gross
and manifest failure of justice or the basic
principles of natural justice have been flouted.
(h) In exercise of its power of superintendence
High Court cannot interfere to correct mere errors
of law or fact or just because another view than the
one taken by the tribunals or courts subordinate to
it, is a possible view. In other words the jurisdiction
has to be very sparingly exercised.
(i) The High Court's power of superintendence
under Article 227 cannot be curtailed by any
statute. It has been declared a part of the basic
structure of the Constitution by the Constitution
Bench of this Court in L. Chandra Kumar v. Union
of
India13
and
therefore
abridgment
by
a
constitutional amendment is also very doubtful.
(j) It may be true that a statutory amendment of a
rather cognate provision, like Section 115 of the
Civil Procedure Code by the Civil Procedure Code
(Amendment) Act, 1999 does not and cannot cut
down the ambit of High Court's power under Article
227. At the same time, it must be remembered that
such
statutory
correspondingly
amendment
expand
the
does
High
not
Court's
jurisdiction of superintendence under Article 227.
(k) The power is discretionary and has to be
exercised on equitable principle. In an appropriate
case, the power can be exercised suo motu.
(l) On a proper appreciation of the wide and
unfettered power of the High Court under Article
227, it transpires that the main object of this article
is to keep strict administrative and judicial control
by the High Court on the administration of justice
within its territory.
(m)
The
object
of
superintendence,
both
administrative and judicial, is to maintain efficiency,
smooth and orderly functioning of the entire
machinery of justice in such a way as it does not
bring
it
into
any
disrepute.
The
power
of
interference under this article is to be kept to the
minimum to ensure that the wheel of justice does
not come to a halt and the fountain of justice
remains pure and unpolluted in order to maintain
public confidence in the functioning of the tribunals
and courts subordinate to the High Court.
13 (1997)3 SCC 261: 1997 SCC (L&S) 577
(n) This reserve and exceptional power of judicial
intervention is not to be exercised just for grant of
relief in individual cases but should be directed for
promotion
of
public
confidence
in
the
administration of justice in the larger public interest
whereas Article 226 is meant for protection of
individual grievance. Therefore, the power under
Article 227 may be unfettered but its exercise is
subject to high degree of judicial discipline pointed
out above.
(o) An improper and a frequent exercise of this
power will be counterproductive and will divest this
extraordinary power of its strength and vitality.”
14. The same principle has been reiterated in the case
of Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi Nath, (2015) 5 SCC 423,
wherein the Supreme Court clarified that the power under
Article 227 has not been expanded and is intended only
to ensure that subordinate courts act within the limits of
their jurisdiction and that interference is warranted only in
cases of patent perversity, gross miscarriage of justice, or
jurisdictional error.
15. From the record, it is not in dispute that the
Respondent No. 1/Bank deducted the crop insurance
premium from the accounts of the complainant/farmers
and remitted the same to the petitioner/ Insurance
Company. Equally undisputed is the fact that the
particulars of the complainants were not uploaded on the
NCIP, resulting in the denial of insurance coverage. The
petitioner has attempted to contend that in the absence of
portal entry, no contract of insurance ever came into
existence and, therefore, the entire liability must rest
upon the Respondent No. 1/Bank alone. However, the
Consumer Commissions below have not ignored this
omission on the part of the Respondent No. 1/Bank;
rather, they have specifically recorded a finding that the
Respondent No. 1/Bank was negligent in failing to upload
the requisite particulars despite repeated extensions
granted by the Central Government. At the same time,
the State Commission has also found that the petitioner
retained the premium amount without either extending
the benefit of insurance or refunding the premium within
the stipulated period prescribed under the applicable
Government notifications. Thus, the finding of joint
negligence is founded upon an appreciation of the
obligations cast upon both implementing agencies under
the Scheme and cannot be said to be either arbitrary or
unsupported by the record.
16. This Court also finds no substance in the submission
that the State Commission misapplied the Government
Notification dated 08.07.2019 and the communication
issued by the Ministry of Agriculture dated 08.11.2019.
The State Commission has taken note of the fact that
even after reconciliation of the premium, the petitioner
neither refunded the premium amount within the
prescribed time nor ensured that the discrepancy was
resolved,
despite
retaining
the
premium
for
a
considerable period. It is reflected from paragraph 8 of
the order dated 01.10.2025 passed by the learned
National Commission that the premium was deducted on
30.07.2019 and it was refunded on 28.05.2020, i.e. after
about 10 months. It is relevant here to reproduced the
paragraph
of
the
order
passed
by
National
Commission, which reads as under:“8. Opposite party No. 1 bank reiterating its
submissions made before the District Commission
has argued that due to Aadhar mismatch in the
PMFBY portal the opposite party No. 2 insurance
company rejected the proposal of insurance and
returned the premium on 28.05.2020 after about
one year from the date of deduction. Learned
district commission has based the impugned order
upon
notification
dated
24.05.2017
of
CG
Government, whereas the premium was deducted
on 30.07.2019 and at that time notification No.
3700/
F-02/13/
PMFBY/
2019/
14-2
dated
08.07.2019 was already issued and effective. As
per condition No. 27of the notification of the year
2019 if the concerned bank fails to provide
information/documents for rectification of defects, it
was obligatory for the insurance company to refund
the premium within three weeks, failing which the
liability to pay compensation shall lie with the
insurance company. In the instant case premium
was deducted on 30.07.2019 and it was refunded
on 28.05.2020 i.e. after about one year. The
insurance company used the amount of premium
during that period and refused the same after
payment of compensation to other farmers. It is
prayed that this appeal be allowed and the liability
of payment of compensation be shifted upon the
opposite party No. 2 insurance company.”
17. The National Commission has also considered the
notification dated 08.07.2019 issued by the State
Government, and para 16 of the order passed by the
National Commission is as under:“16. Learned counsel for the opposite party No.1
Bank has drawn our attention towards Condition
No.27 of Notification No.3700/ F-02/13/ PMFBY/
2019/14-2 dated 08.07.2019 under which the
Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana for Kharif &
Rabi crop of 2019-20 were implemented in all the
27 districts of Chhattisgarh. Condition No.27 of the
said notification envisages that: -
यदि वित्तीय संस्था द्वारा नियत समय सिमा में जानकारी दस्तावेज
उपलब्ध नहीं कराई जाती है तो बिमा कं पनी द्वारा समबन्धित
प्रीमियम राशि तीन सप्ताह के भीतर बैंको को अनिवार्य रूप से
वापस किया जाना होगा अन्यथा कृ षको को नियमानुसार दवा
प्रतिपूर्ति को सम्पूर्ण दायित्व बिमा कं पनी की होगी"
******* From bare reading of Condition No.27 of the
relevant notification of 2019 which was applicable for
Kharif and Rabi season of 2019-20 it clearly appears that
in case of failure of the Bank/ Financial Institution in
providing information/ documents it was obligatory for the
concerned insurance company to refund the premium
within three weeks otherwise the liability of payment of
claim compensation, as per rule, would be of the
concerned insurance company. Thus, the opposite party
No.2 insurance company was duty bound to refund the
premium within three weeks at least from the final
extended cut-off date of entry in the portal or maximum
after three weeks from 18th November 2019 but the
opposite party No.2 insurance company kept the
premium till 28.05.2020. But at this juncture the
negligence and deficiency in service committed by the
opposite party No.1 Bank in not entering the correct
information of the farmers in the concerned portal even
after time extensions till 14.11.2019 also cannot be
brushed aside, hence in our considered view both the
opposite parties are jointly and severally liable for
payment of compensation under the crop insurance in
question.
18. The National Commission has concurred with the
said finding by observing that the PMFBY is a welfare
scheme
requiring
coordinated
functioning
of
all
implementing agencies and that the omission on the part
of one agency cannot absolve the other from discharging
its corresponding obligations under the Scheme. These
are findings of fact based upon the interpretation of the
Scheme
Guidelines
and
the
Government
communications.
19. It is equally significant that the petitioner does not
dispute that the complainants were otherwise eligible
farmers and that similarly situated farmers received
compensation under the PMFBY. The only reason for
denial of the benefit to the complainants was the failure of
the implementing agencies to complete the procedural
requirements contemplated under the Scheme. The
object of the PMFBY is to provide financial protection to
farmers against crop loss arising from natural calamities.
Being a beneficial social welfare scheme, its provisions
cannot be construed in a manner that defeats its object or
leaves an innocent farmer remediless because of lapses
attributable to the implementing agencies. The Consumer
Commissions have, therefore, rightly concentrated on
ensuring that the beneficiaries of the Scheme are
compensated and have left the question of inter se
adjustment of liability between the Respondent No.
1/Bank and the petitioner/Insurance Company to be
worked out in accordance with law. Such an approach is
consistent with the beneficial object of the Scheme and
cannot
be
characterised
as
suffering
from
any
jurisdictional infirmity.
20. Since the petitioner/Insurance Company is claiming
the benefit of Clauses 17.2 and 35.5.13 of the
Operational Guideline of PMFBY, it is necessary to take
notice of the said provisions here, which are as under:“17.2 Consolidated declaration/ formats to be
uploaded/entered
electronically
by
Nodal
Banks/Branches shall contain details about total
insured area of the farmers, number of Loanee and
Non-loanee
farmers
enrolled,
Total
Premium
Amount remitted, premium remittance Unique
Transaction Reference (UTR no.) and Date of
remittance as per the format provided on the NCIP.
Banks are required to upload the insured farmers'
data mandatorily on the National Crop Insurance
Portal. No other platform shall be used for
uploading/submission of farmers' data. Those
farmers whose data is uploaded on the NCIP shall
only be eligible for Insurance coverage and
accordingly the premium subsidy will also be
released. In cases where farmers are denied crop
insurance due to incorrect/partial/non-uploading of
their
details
on
portal,
concerned
Banks/
Intermediaries shall be responsible for payment of
claims(if any).
35.5.13 Banks should ensure that farmers are not
deprived of any benefit under the Scheme due to
errors/omissions/commissions of the concerned
branch/PACS, and in case of such errors, the
concerned agencies shall have to make good of all
such losses.”
21. The submission of the petitioner/Insurance Company
that Clause 17.2 and Clause 35.5.13 of the PMFBY
Operational
Guidelines
completely
exonerate
the
Insurance Company also does not merit acceptance in
the
facts
of
the
present
case.
The
Consumer
Commissions have not ignored the statutory obligations
of the Respondent No. 1/Bank under the Guidelines;
rather, those obligations have been expressly recognised.
However, the finding of joint liability has been recorded
after
considering
the
entire
Scheme,
the
State
Government notification and the conduct of the petitioner
in retaining the premium without timely refund. Such a
composite appreciation of the material cannot be
substituted by this Court merely because the petitioner
seeks a different interpretation of certain clauses of the
Guidelines.
22. The submission advanced on behalf of the petitioner
that, in view of Clause 35.5.13 of the PMFBY Operational
Guidelines, it should be granted liberty to recover the
amount of compensation from the Respondent No.
1/Bank, also does not merit acceptance. Clause 35.5.13
undoubtedly provides that where a farmer is deprived of
insurance benefits on account of any error, omission or
negligence attributable to the concerned implementing
agency, such agency shall be responsible for making
good the resultant loss. However, the said provision
cannot be invoked by the petitioner to absolve itself of its
own independent deficiency in service. The concurrent
findings recorded by the State Commission and affirmed
by the National Commission clearly establish that
although the petitioner had received the premium amount
on 30.07.2019, it retained the same until 28.05.2020
without either extending insurance coverage to the
complainants or refunding the premium within the
prescribed period, despite being aware that the requisite
particulars had not been uploaded on the portal. Such
prolonged retention of the premium without extending any
corresponding
benefit
constituted
an
independent
deficiency in service on the part of the petitioner/
Insurance
Company.
Once
the
petitioner/Insurance
Company itself is found to have contributed to the
deprivation of the complainants' legitimate claim under
the Scheme, it cannot seek the protection of Clause
35.5.13 to shift the entire liability upon the Respondent
No. 1/Bank. The benefit of the said clause is available
only to an agency that is free from blame and has
suffered liability solely because of the default of another
implementing agency; it cannot be extended to a party
whose own negligence has concurrently caused the loss.
Consequently, no liberty, as sought by the petitioner,
deserves to be granted under Clause 35.5.13 of the
Operational Guidelines of PMFBY.
23. In the present case, this Court finds that the State
Commission
and
the
National
Commission
have
assigned cogent and plausible reasons for fastening joint
and
several
Company
liability
and
considering
the
the
upon
the
Respondent
relevant
petitioner/Insurance
No.
Scheme
1/Bank
after
Guidelines,
Government notifications and the evidence on record.
The findings are neither shown to be perverse nor
contrary to any statutory provision. Consequently, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned
order passed by the learned National Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission affirming the order of the State
Commission does not call for interference.
24. Accordingly, both the writ petitions, being devoid of
merit, deserve to be and are hereby dismissed.”
7.
Since WP(227) No. 845 of 2026 and the connected batch of petitions
have already been dismissed by this Court vide order dated
17.07.2026, and the issues involved in the present writ petitions are
identical to those involved in WP(227) No. 845 of 2026, this Court
finds no reason to take a view different from the one taken in the
aforesaid judgment.
8.
In view of the aforesaid and considering that the controversy involved
in the present writ petitions stands squarely covered by the judgment
of this Court rendered in WP(227) No. 845 of 2026 (Agriculture
Insurance Company of India Ltd. v. Branch Manager and another)
and the connected batch of petitions decided on 17.07.2026, this
Court finds no reason to take a different view. The impugned order
passed by the learned National Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission does not suffer from any jurisdictional error, patent
perversity or manifest illegality warranting interference in exercise of
supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Accordingly, all the writ petitions, being devoid of merit, are hereby
dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Sumit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review