Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WA No.161 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Smt. Ratna Roy, D/o Late Surja Kumar Roy, R/O Chandrapur Nath Para, P.O.Reshambagan, P.S.- East Agartala, Pin- 799008.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.- NCC, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S.- NCC, District- West Tripura, Pin-799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.185 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Killal Chandra Laskar, S/O Late Jaladhar Chandra Laskar, R/O Motor Stand, Sanitala,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, Pin 799001.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S.-NCC, District- West Tripura, Pin-799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.186 of 2022
1.Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala P.S. West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin
799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. West Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin
799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Smt. Gita Deb (Ganguly), W/O- Late Biswanath Ganguly, R/O- Kunjaban Colony, P.OAbhoynagar, P.S- East Agartala, Pin-799002.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.187 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Sekhar Bhattacharjee , S/O Late Sahsi Mohan Bhattacharjee, R/O West Bhati
Abhoynagar Pashchim Para, Barjala Road, P/O- Abhoynagar, P.S. West Agartala, Pin799002.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.188 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Smt.Santi Rani Kalai, W/O Sri Padmaohan Kalai Singh, R/O- Bijoy Kumar School Road,
Krishnanagar, P.O Agartala, P.S West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.189 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Salil Deb, S/O - late Pulin Behari Deb, R/O- Joynagar, H.G. Basak Road, Battala, POAgartala, PS- West Agartala, Pin 799001.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, PO-Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin
799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, PO
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.190 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Bijoy Choudhuri, S/O- Late Ramendra Kumar Choudhuri, R/O Radhamadhav Sarani,
Dhaleshwar, P.O. Dhaleswar, P.S East Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin 799007.
2. The State of Tripura represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.191 of 2022
1.Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O.- Agartala P.S- West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Bhaskar Debbarma, S/O late Prabhat Chandra Debbarma, R/O- Old Kalibari Lane,
Krishna Nagar, P.O- Agartala, P.S- West Agartala, District- WestTripura, Pin-799001.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S- NCC, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.192 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Pranab Nandi, S/O- late Pankaj Behari Nandi, R/O- Bankim Sarani, Old T.G. Road,
Ramnagar, P.O Agartala, P.S- West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S- NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.193 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Jalal Ahmed, S/O Late Maijja Miah, R/O- Masjid Road, Santipara, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
East Agartala, Pin 799001.
2. The State ofTripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District- West Tripura,
Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.194 of 2022
1.Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O.- Agartala P.S- West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Dibakar Choudhury, S/O- late Dhananjoy Choudhury, R/O. Ramnagar Road No. 2,
P.O- Ramnagar, P.S- West Agartala, Pin-799002.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S- NCC, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.195 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Krishna Gopal Dey, S/O Late Surya Kumar Dey, R/O-Krishnanagar, Natunpalli, P.O
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin-799001.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.196 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
,1. Sri Dipak Kumar Nandi, S/O- Late Ramesh Chandra Nandi, R/O 278, Amader Club Road,
Bardowali, A.D Nagar, P.O and P.S A.D Nagar, District-West Tripura, Pin-799003.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.197 of 2022
1.Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O.- Agartala P.S- West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Milan Chakraborty, S/O- Late Jagadish Chakraborty, R/O- Madhya Badharghat, Milan
Chakra, P.O- A.D Nagar, P.S- A.D. Nagar, Pin-799003.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- NCC, District- West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. Of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S- NCC, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.198 of 2022
1.Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O.- Agartala, P.S- West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Smt. Geeta Paul (Biswas), W/O- Sri Arabinda Biswas, R/O- Natun Palli, Near
Chatrasangha Club, Krishnanagar, P.O- Agartala, P.S- West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. Of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- NCC, District- West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S- NCC, District- West Tripura, Pin-799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.199 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Nitai Majumder, S/O- late Ram Kali Majumder, R/O Vill-West Pratapgarh, Near
United Club, P.O and P.S.-A D Nagar, District West Tripura, Pin-799003.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.- NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.200 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Shimal Chandra Saha, S/O late Jagyeshwar Saha, R/O Town Pratapgarh, Ramthakur
Road, Near Udayaman Sangha, P.O Agartala College, P.S. East Agartala, Pin 799004.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.201 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Nitai Dey, S/o Late Barda Charan Dey, R/O Ward No 14, Lake Road, Near Debendra
Medical Hall, Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West Tripura, Pin-799001.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.202 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Dilip Acharjee, R/O Mantribari Road Extension, Town Bordowali, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
West Agartala, Pin-799001.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.203 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Subhash Chandra Biswas, S/O late Joy Chandra Biswas, R/O Joynagar, Madhya Lane,
Near Yuva Samaj Club, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, Pin-799001.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.204 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Gopal Chandra Sen, S/O late Basanta Kumar Sen, R/O West Lane of Shivnagar,
Gedumiah Masjid, P.O Agartala College, PS- East Agartala, Pin799004.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P O
Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.205 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Smt Suchitra Paul (Saha), W/O Sri Rabindra Chandra Saha R/O Ramnagar Raod No 8,
P.O. Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799001.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.206 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Raghunath Sarkar, S/O Late Kanan Ded Sarkar, R/O Melarmath, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin 79900.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. NCC District-West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O
Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.207 of 2022
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Badal Kumar Choudhuri, S/O Late Bidhu Bhusan Choudhuri, C/O Ashok Kumar
Choudhuri R/O Vill and P.O. Shyam Sundar Para, East Pratapgarh, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799004.
2. The State of Tripura represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura,
Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
WA No.29 of 2023
1. Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner, City Center
Complex, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, City Center Complex,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh, S/O Lt. Sachindra Ch. Ghosh Resident of Durga Chowmuhani,
Pragati Road, Opposite of Basanti Clinic, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District-West
Tripura, Pin 799001.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin 799006.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S NCC, District-West Tripura, Pin 799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
For Appellants(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Bhoumik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate,
Mr. Ankur Saha, Advocate.
Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General,
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate,
Mrs. Ayantika Chakraborty, Advocate.
WP(C) No.599 of 2023
1. Smt. Rubi Dutta Deb,W/o- Chandra Sekhar Deb, R/o- Ward No. 18, Jail Ashram Road,
West side of Bharat Tirtha Club, P.O. - Dhaleswar, Agartala, Tripura, Pin - 799007.
2. Sri Ashim Baran Datta, S/o- Lt. Monoranjan Datta, R/o- Bardowali, P.O.- AD Nagar,
Agartala, West Tripura.
3. Sri Chandra Sekhar Deb, S/o- Lt. Monmohan Deb, R/o- Jail Ashram Road, West side of
Bharat Tirtha Club, Agartala, Tripura, Pin – 799007.
4. Sri Nishi Kanta Sinha, S/o- Lt. Krishnadhan Sinha, R/o- South Dhaleshwar, Opposite of
Sabyasachi Club, P.O.- Agartala College, South Dhaleshwar, Jogendranagar, West Tripura,
PIN- 799004.
5. Sri Jiban Kumar Saha, S/o- Lt. Sukhlal Saha, R/o- Town Pratapgarh, Road No.- 1, West
Tripura, Pin- 799001.
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura to be represented by the Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin 799010.
2. The Secretary, Department of Urban Development Department, Govt. of Tripura, New
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Municipal Commissioner, Agartala Municipal Corporation, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. Agartala Municipal Corporation, to be represented by the Municipal Commissioner,
Agartala Municipal Corporation, Agartala, West Tripura.
5. The Chief Executive Officer, Agartala Municipal Corporation, Agartala, West Tripura.
..…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate,
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Bhoumik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate,
Mr. Ankur Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Date of hearing and judgment : 19thFebruary, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting : YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Bhoumik, learned counsel together with Mr. S. Dey
and Mr. Ankur Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also heard
Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General and Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned
senior counsel assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents.
[2]
Whether the employees of Agartala Municipal Corporation (AMC,
for short) are covered by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (the Act of 1972,
for short) or not is the question raised in these appeals. It appears to be second
round of litigation on this issue as it appears from the subsequent narrative. One
Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh, a retired employee of AMC, had approached the Writ
Court in WP(C) No.1091 of 2017 seeking a direction upon the respondents to
pay his gratuity on the basis of his last pay drawn inclusive of basic salary and
Dearness Allowance (DA) and by applying revised ceiling of Rs.10,00,000/-
for payment of gratuity. He prayed that the deficient amount of gratuity be paid
with interest from the date of retirement till actual payment (he retired on
superannuation with effect from 31st December, 2015 as a Head Clerk). The
learned Writ Court upon consideration of the rival case of the parties, relevant
provisions of „the Act of 1972‟, a judgment rendered in case of Bhupati
Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others, reported in (2020) SCC Online
Tri 84 and also the decision of the Apex Court in case of Nagar Ayukt Nagar
Nigam, Kanpur versus Mujib Ullah Khan and another, reported in (2019) 6
SCC 103 directed the AMC to calculate the gratuity in terms of Section 4(2) of
the Act payable to the petitioner by taking into account his basic salary and DA.
The gratuity so calculated would be paid by applying the revised ceiling of
Rs.10,00,000/-. After deducting the gratuity already paid, remaining amount
would be paid within a period of 4(four) months from the date of judgment
along with simple interest @ 6% per annum upon completion of 1(one) month
from the date of superannuation till actual payment. It would be pertinent to
mention here that it was pointed out before the learned Writ Court that AMC
had adopted CCS (Pension) Rules with effect from 1st January, 1992 by virtue
of the notification dated 21st December, 1991. The learned Writ Court also took
into consideration the Central Government notification dated 8 th January, 1982
providing that specified local bodies in which 10 or more persons are employed
or were employed in any day preceding 12 months would be covered by the
Act. In view of the overriding effect of Section 14 of „the Act of 1972‟, and the
decision in Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (supra) employees of the
municipalities would be governed by the said Act, notwithstanding any
statutory provision contained to the contrary in the State Act. Paragraph-8 to 14
of the decision in Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (supra) was also
noticed. The learned Court was also apprised that the ceiling limit of
Rs.10,00,000/-,
earlier
enforced
since
24.05.2010
was
enhanced
to
Rs.20,00,000/- by virtue of the Central Government notification dated
29.03.2018 which was also taken note of in case of Bhupati Debnath (Supra).
The Corporation being dissatisfied approached the Appellate Court in case of
Agartala Municipal Corporation versus Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh and others
in Writ Appeal No.185 of 2020. The Appellate Court also considered the
aforesaid provisions of „the Act of 1972‟, the notification dated 08.01.1982 and
the decision in case of Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (supra) and
refused to interfere in the decision of the learned Single Judge. It was also held
that the writ petitioner was not an employee of the Central Government or State
Government but of a local body covered within the definition of employee
under Section 2(e) of the Act. We have been informed that the decision of Sri
Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) has been complied by the Corporation. Sri Samir
Kumar Ghosh, however, once again approached the learned Writ Court in
WP(C) No.204/2021 with a grievance that though the gratuity to the ceiling
limit of Rs.10,00,000/- has been paid in terms of the judgment rendered earlier
but the computation of the amount of Rs.7,18,608/- paid to him did not count
his entire length of service in quantifying his gratuity. The learned Writ Court
at this instance directed the AMC to recalculate the gratuity amount after
considering the total length of his service i.e. 40 years under the Corporation
and to pay the remaining gratuity amount, if any, according to his entitlement,
within a period of 3(three) months from the date of order. The Corporation has
assailed this order in WA No.29 of 2023.
[3]
Another batch of writ petitions led by WP(C) No.126 of 2021 in
case of Bhaskar Debbarma versus Agartala Municipal Corporation and
others were decided by the learned Writ Court vide judgment dated 27.06.2022.
These writ petitioners had approached this Court for a direction upon the
respondents to make the full and final payment of gratuity with interest @ 9%
per annum with effect from the date on which gratuity became payable till the
date of payment after adjusting lump sum amount of Rs.4,00,000/- already
paid. Other ancillary prayers were also made for payment of interest. The
petitioner, Bhaskar Debbarma was treated as the lead case by the learned Writ
Court to decide the batch of writ petitions. Bhaskar Debbarma pleaded that he
is entitled to get Rs.9,83,578/- as full and final payment of gratuity along with
interest as per enhanced ceiling limit of gratuity of Rs.10,00,000/- as per the
amendment to the Payment of Gratuity Act. He also contended that he was paid
Rs.4,00,000/- earlier as full and final payment of gratuity though his claim was
higher. The respondents took a plea that the State had promulgated relevant
rules limiting the payment of gratuity under the Pension Rules and had passed
the Payment of Gratuity (Tripura Amendment) Bill, 2021 regulating the
provisions relating to the payment of gratuity. The said bill, however,
necessitated the assent of the President of India as it was a State amendment.
They denied the claim of the petitioner of enhanced gratuity of Rs.10,00,000/under „the Act of 1972‟. On this occasion, the learned Writ Court again
considered the decisions rendered earlier in case of Bhupati Debnath versus
State of Tripura & others in WP(C) No.1054 of 2019 decided on 13.02.2020;
Mamat Singha Roy versus State of Tripura & another in WP(C) NO.1057 of
2019 decided on 13.02.2020; Samir Kumar Ghosh versus State of Tripura &
others in WP(C) No.1091 of 2017 decided on 29.05.2020; Nagar Ayukt Nagar
Nigam, Kanpur versus Mujib Ullah Khan and another, reported in (2019) 6
SCC 103 and also the decision of the appellate Court in case of Agartala
Municipal Corporation versus Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh & others in WA
No.185 of 2020 decided on 29.01.2021 and directed the respondents to
calculate the gratuity of the petitioners considering the revised ceiling limit of
Rs.10,00,000/- which came into force with effect from 24.05.2010 and pay the
remaining gratuity with a simple interest @ 6% per annum for the period after
expiry of statutory period of one month from their respective dates of
retirement. The learned Court has also made it clear that the gratuity has to be
paid considering the last basic pay which includes DA as defined under Section
2(s) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The respondents were given liberty
to examine and determine the claims of each of the 9(nine) petitioners.
[4]
Another batch of writ petitions led by the case of Smt. Ratna Roy
versus the State of Tripura and others in WP(C) No.218 of 2021 came to be
decided by the learned Writ Court vide judgment dated 27.06.2022. The lead
case of Smt. Ratna Roy (supra) was evidenced by the learned Writ Court while
deciding the issue raised herein that petitioner had also sought full and final
payment of gratuity with interest @ 9% per annum with effect from the date on
which gratuity became payable till its payment after adjusting lump sum
amount of Rs.3,51,750/- and coupled with interest @ 9% per annum. The
learned Writ Court issued similar direction in case of Smt. Ratna Roy (supra)
by directing the respondents to count 50% of the service rendered by the
petitioners till their regularization in service along with the regular service
period rendered by them for determining the qualifying service years for
calculation of death-cum-retirement gratuity. It also directed the respondents to
calculate the gratuity of the petitioners considering the revised ceiling limit of
Rs.10,00,000/- against those petitioners, who retired on or after the date on
which the revised ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/- came into force with effect
from 24.05.2010 and Rs.20,00,000/- against those petitioners who retired from
service on or after 29.03.2018 when the revised ceiling of Rs.20,00,000/- came
into force. The remaining amount of gratuity was directed to be paid with
simple interest @ 6% per annum for the delayed period after expiry of statutory
period of one month from their respective dates of retirement. Respondents
were granted liberty to examine and determine the claim of each of the
15(fifteen) petitioners in such manner.
[5]
Therefore, the instant batch of cases led by Writ Appeal
No.161/2022 in case of Agartala Municipal Corporation & another versus
Smt. Ratna Roy & others and connected cases arise out of two judgments
rendered in the batch of cases by the learned Writ Court i.e. (1) Sri Bhaskar
Debbarma versus Agartala Municipal Corporation & others in WP(C) No.126
of 2021; (2) Smt. Ratna Roy versus the State of Tripura & others in WP(C)
No.218 of 2021 along with other analogous cases and in case of Sri Samir
Kumar Ghosh versus the State of Tripura & others in WP(C) No.204 of 2021
dated 09/01/2023.
[6]
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel for the appellant-Corporation
has referred to the brief facts of the case of each of the petitioners which shall
be later referred to in the form of a tabular chart and inter alia made the
following submissions:
[6.1]
The learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that CCS
(Pension) Rules 1972 was made applicable to Agartala Municipal Corporation
vide notification bearing No.F.14(6)-LSG/83 dated 21.12.1991 issued by the then
Local Self-Government Department, Govt. of Tripura. A perusal of the said
notification would show that the then Local Self Government Department, Govt.
of Tripura applied the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted in the Sate of
Tripura) for the Officers and employees of Agartala Municipal Corporation. The
respondent No.1 did not even challenge the adoption Notification dated
21.12.1991 and the learned Single Judge has most erroneously held that the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 will have application to the employees of Agartala
Municipal Corporation.
[6.2]
The learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that under
Section 5 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 the State Govt. has the power to
exempt an organization from the purview of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. Even
in the Counter Affidavit filed by the State, the State took a stand that the Payment
of Gratuity Act, 1972 will not apply to the Agartala Municipal Corporation as CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 has been adopted for Agartala Municipal Corporation. State
has taken the stand that adoption of CCS (Pension) Rules, for the employees of the
Agartala Municipal Corporation is a conscious decision in view of under Section 5
of the said Act. The adopted CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 was further modified by
the Urban Development Department, Govt. of Tripura by enacting Rule under
Section 274 of Tripura Municipal Act, 1994 which was called as the Tripura State
Govt. Pensioners and Family Pensioners (Revision of Pension) Rules, 1999 as
notified vide Notification dated 14.08.2003. The appellants highlight that Rule 50
of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 deals with Payment of Gratuity and the ceiling limit
of payment is revised time to time as per Tripura State Civil Services (Revised
Pension) Rules. The notification dated 14.08.2003 was not challenged in WP(C)
No.1091/2017 in the case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh Vs. the State of Tripura and
others and the Hon‟ble Court also did not consider this aspect of exemption of
AMC from the purview of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 by a process for
adoption and subsequent framing of Rules.
[6.3]
Learned Single Judge of this Hon‟ble High Court is also not
correct in holding that the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and TSCS (Revised
Pension) Rules, 2009 has no application to AMC in view of Section 14 of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 without considering that once the State has
exercised the power of exemption under Section 5 of the Payment of Gratuity Act,
1972, Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 including Section 14 of the Act would not
apply to AMC.
[6.4]
That, Hon‟ble Apex Court in the judgment reported in (1998) 7
SCC 221 titled Municipal Corporation of Delhi versus Dharam Prkash Sharma
and another held that mere fact that Gratuity is provided for under the Pension
Rules will not disentitle the petitioner to get the payment of gratuity under the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 in view of the overriding provisions contained in
Section 14 of the Act. Section 5 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 has
conferred authority on the appropriate Government to exempt any establishment
from the operation of the provisions of the Act if in the opinion of the Government
the employees are in receipt of gratuity or pensionary benefit not less favourable.
Again, the Hon‟ble Apex Court in a judgment reported in (2010) 2 SCC 44 in
pargraph-19 held that Payment of Gratuity to an employee cannot be taken away
except in accordance of the provisions of the act where-under an exemption from
such payment may be granted only by the appropriate Government under Section 5
of the Act. Therefore, the proposition that the appropriate Government may
exempt an establishment from the purview of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is
thus well established.
[6.5]
The learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition filed
by the respondent No.1 relied on the earlier judgment of the learned Single Judge
of this Hon‟ble High Court rendered in the case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh
versus the State of Tripura & others in WP(C) No.1091/2017 as upheld by the
learned Division Bench of this Hon‟ble High Court in W.A. No.185/2020. A
perusal of the said judgments passed by the learned Single Judge of this Hon‟ble
High Court and the learned Division Bench of this Hon‟ble Court would show that
at the time when those judgments were delivered the aforesaid grounds that
already CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 has been adopted for Agartala Municipal
Corporation and by a process of adoption Agartala Municipal Corporation has
been exempted from the purview of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and existence
of other Rules regulating the Payment of Gratuity of employees of Agartala
Municipal Corporation was not considered by the Hon‟ble High Court. Therefore,
the decision of this Hon‟ble High Court in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh
(supra) as upheld by the learned Division Bench in W.A. No.185/2020 is a
judgment per incuriam as the said judgment does not consider the vital aspect of
exemption of Agartala Municipal Corporation and exercise of power under Section
5 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
[6.6]
He has placed reliance on the case of A.R. Antulya versus
R.S. Nayak reported in (1988) 2 SCC 602 and Sandeep Kumar Bafna versus the
State of Maharashtra reported in (2014) 16 SCC 623. In the instant case the
learned Single Bench as well as the learned Division Bench of this Hon‟ble High
Court while rendering the judgment in Samir Kumar Ghosh’s (supra) case failed
to consider important statutory provisions including adoption of CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972 for Agartala Municipal Corporation, existence of Rules framed under
Section 274 of the Tripura Municipal Act, 1993 modifying the adopted CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 for the employees of Agartala Municipal Corporation.
[6.7]
In the present cases, the writ petitioners, barring few, filed their
respective writ petition after inordinate delay from the date of their retirement.
There is no explanation in the writ petition regarding such delay caused in filing of
the writ petition. Therefore, those writ petitions must be held to be barred by
doctrine of delay and latches.
[6.8]
All the writ petitioners, barring few, filed their respective writ
petitions after 3(three) years from the date of retirement. In some cases there is a
delay of 8/9 years in approaching the Hon‟ble Court. Further, for the delay caused
in filing of the writ petition, explanation should be given to the satisfaction of the
Hon‟ble Court.
[6.9]
That, Payment of Gratuity is a one-time financial benefit given
to the employees on superannuation or death or resignation as the case may be and
there is no continuous cause of action in case of Payment of Gratuity. No recurring
loss is suffered by the employees and therefore the writ petitioners ought to have
approached the Hon‟ble Court immediately after their retirement.
[6.10]
That, the petitioners are also estopped from claiming gratuity
under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 having accepted the gratuity extended to
the writ petitioners under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. The appellants submit
that before the date of retirement of the writ petitioners, gratuity was sanctioned in
favour of the writ petitioners under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and 75% of the
gratuity was also paid to the writ petitioners. The remaining amount of gratuity
was also paid to the writ petitioners after settlement of other retiral benefits. The
writ petitioners thus accepted gratuity under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and
were in deep slumber for considerable years. The Hon‟ble Apex Court in a
judgment reported in (1974) 1 SCR 304 titled Parameshwai Prasad Gupta versus
Union of India held that the rules of the company expressly purport to bind all the
employees of the company. In Punjab and Sind Bank and another versus S.
Ranveer Singh Bawa and another, (2004) 4 SCC 484 the Hon‟ble Apex Court
applied the law of estoppel on an employee of the bank who opted for VRS and
thereafter utilized the payments made to the employee by holding that the
employee cannot resile from the VRS opted by the employee.
[6.11]
That, under Rule 7 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 an
employee is who is eligible for Payment of Gratuity under the Act is to apply
within 30 days from the date from which the gratuity became payable in „I‟ to the
employer. The first proviso to Rule 7(1) provides that in case of superannuation or
retirement the employee may apply to the employer before 30 days of the date of
superannuation or retirement. In the present cases none of the writ petitioners
made any application to the employer for payment of gratuity before 30 days of
the date of superannuation or retirement. Also, there is a provision for appeal
under Rule 18 of the Rules to the appellate authority against the decision taken by
the controlling authority under Rule 17 of the Rules. The writ petitioners herein
did not exhaust the said alternative remedy provided by the Payment of Gratuity
Rules, 1972 and has approached the Writ Court.
[7]
Learned counsel for the appellant-Corporation, has therefore
contended that the State of Tripura has adopted CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 to
AMC vide notification dated 21.12.1991 which is in the nature of an exemption
under Section 5 of the Act of 1972. The Urban Development Department,
Government of Tripura has framed the Tripura State Government Pensioners
and Family Pensioners (Revision of Pension) Rules, 1999 which have been be
adopted for the employees of the AMC. By the said notification the provisions
of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 stood modified to the extent provided
thereunder. AMC has, thereafter, been paying gratuity to its employees under
the said Rules as per the rate of gratuity, the ceiling limit and the qualifying
service. Learned counsel for the appellant-Corporation has also contended that
the petitioners did not challenge the notification dated 21.12.1991 whereby the
State Government adopted CCS(Pension) Rules 1972 for AMC neither did they
challenge the notification dated 14.08.2003 by which specific Rules for AMC
for payment of gratuity to its employees of the AMC were framed. These
aspects were not considered by the learned Writ Court in WP(C) No.
1091/2017 in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra). The learned Division
Bench also did not consider these issues in Writ Appeal No.185/2020 in case of
Agartala Municipal Corporation (supra). In substance, it is the stand of the
AMC that by adoption of CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972 a conscious decision was
taken to exempt the Corporation from applicability of the Act of 1972 in
exercise of the powers under Section 5 by the appropriate government i.e. the
State Government in the instant case. The decision in case of N. Mani Vs.
Sangeetha Theatre and others rendered in (2004) 12 SCC 278 (paragraph- 8
and 9) is
also relied upon by the appellant-Corporation to buttress the
submission.
[8]
Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General has at the outset taken a
novel plea which was neither raised before the Writ Court or in appeal by the
appellant-Corporation that by enactment of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
which according to him is under entry 24, list-III of the Schedule-7 of the
Constitution of India, the field of legislation to enact an appropriate law
governing the payment of gratuity to employees under its corporation and local
bodies for the State legislature have been completely ousted. In support of his
submission, he has referred to two decisions (1) M. P. Vidyut Karmachari
Sangh versus M.P. Electricity Board, reported in (2004) 9 SCC 755
(paragraph-19); (2) Government of NCT of Delhi versus Union of India,
reported in (2023) 9 SCC 1 (paragraph-92). He has also canvassed that the
notification dated 21.12.1991 which applies the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 to
the employees of the AMC is a conscious decision of the State Government to
exempt the Corporation from the applicability of „the Act of 1972‟. It is also
submitted that the Central Legislature has in a blanket manner notified all local
bodies falling within the jurisdiction of the different States like the AMC
without devolution of any financial support to this Corporation to bear the
statutory liability of payment of gratuity which is enhanced from time to time
by the notification of the Central Government. However, learned Advocate
General has not questioned the statutory exercise of power by the Central
Government to notify local bodies like municipalities as covered under the
provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 vide notification dated 8th January,
1982. He has also added that the Corporation may not have enough financial
resources to bear the burden of the enhanced ceiling of gratuity with interest
thereupon in terms of Section 7 of „the Act of 1972‟ in individual cases which
may range much above the actual gratuity payable to such employees.
In substance, the submissions of the appellants and the State are
that employees of AMC are not covered by the provisions of „the Act of 1972‟
as there is a conscious exercise of power by the State Government to exempt
the AMC from the applicability of „the Act of 1972‟ by virtue of the
notification dated 21.12.1991 whereunder the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 were
applied to the employees of the AMC.
[9]
On part of the writ petitioners, Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior
counsel has inter alia made the following submissions:
[9.1]
The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, has been enacted by the
Parliament and it extends to whole of the India. Section 1(3) of the Act lays down
as to whom the Act will be applicable. Section 1(3)(c) of the Act is quoted herein
below;
“It shall apply to such other establishments or class of
establishments, in which ten or more employees are employed,
or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months,
as the Central Government may, by notification, specify in this
behalf.”
[9.2]
That, in terms of Section 1(3)(c) of the Act, 1972, Central Govt. has
published Notification on 08.01.1982 and the said notification is as follows:
“S.O. No.239….In exercise of the powers conferred by clause
(c)of Sub-Section (3) of Section 1 of the Payment of Gratuity
Act, 1972 (39 of 1972), the Central Government hereby
specified “local bodies” in which ten or more persons are
employed, or were employed, on any day of the preceding
twelve months, as a class of establishments to which the said
Act shall apply with effect from the date of publication of this
notification in the Official Gazette.”
[9.3]
The said Notification issued by the Central Govt. was published in
Official Gazette on 08.01.1982. In view of this, Employees of the all Local Bodies
in which 10 or more persons are employed / were employed fell within the
purview of such other establishment or class of establishment as mentioned in
Section 1.(3)(c) of the Act to which the Act is applicable.
[9.4]
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Case of Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam,
Kanpur Vs. Mujib Ullah Khan and another reported in (2019) 6 SCC 103, has
taken note of the Gazette Notification dated 08.01.1982, issued by the Central
Govt. and has held that local bodies, wherein 10 or more employees are employed,
or were employed are covered by the Act, 1972. The said act is applicable to such
local bodies and employees of those local bodies will be governed by the Act,
1972, so far the payment of gratuity is concerned. Para 11 of the said report of
Hon‟ble Supreme Court has been relied upon:
[9.6]
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid Judgment relying on the
section (1)(3)(c) of the Act, 1972 and Gazette Notification, dated, 08.01.1982 and
section 14 of the Act, 1972, has unambiguously held, that, the Employees of the
Municipalities will be governed by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and State
Act or any other Act would not be applicable to the employees of the
Municipalities.
[9.7]
In Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (supra) the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court repelled the entire argument of the Appellant that the State Act
confers restrictive benefit of gratuity than what is conferred under the Central Act.
Such argument was held as not tenable in view of Section 14 of the Act and that
liberal payment of gratuity is in fact in the interest of the employees. Thus, the
gratuity would be payable under the Act. Such is the view taken by the Controlling
Authority.
[9.9]
That, in Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) a plea was taken by the AMC
that the Petitioner is not governed by the Act, 1972, since the AMC has adopted
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 & limit of gratuity shall be Rs. 4 lakhs as applicable
under the CCS (Pension) Rules at the relevant time. AMC also took the plea that
as per Finance Department Notification dated 05.05.2009, there was a ceiling of
Rs. 4 lakhs for payment of Gratuity. Such ceiling was revised to Rs. 10 lakhs by
Notification, dated, 11.07.2017. As Samir Ghosh, the Petitioner therein, retired
before the said date, pre-revised ceiling of Gratuity Rs 4 lakhs has been applied in
his case.
[9.10] The learned Single Judge relying on the judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in Nagar Nigam, Gorakhpur (supra) held that payment of gratuity is to be
made to Samir Kumar Ghosh, the Petitioner, a retired employee of AMC, in terms
of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, notwithstanding adoption of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 by the AMC. The learned Single Judge also referred to the
Judgment of the Hon‟ble High Court of Tripura passed in Bhupati Debnath
[WP(C) 1054/2019], wherein after making elaborate discussion of the different
provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, the Hon‟ble High Court held that
in terms of Section 4 of the Act, so far payment of gratuity, its computation and
ceiling limit (up to which such amount can be made), as referred to in Section 4 of
the said Act, the term “appropriate Act” has no bearing.
[9.12] The Judgment, dated, 29.05.2020, passed in WP(C) 1091/2017 (Samir
Kumar Ghosh Vs. Agartala Municipal Corporation & Others), has been affirmed
by the Division Bench of the Hon‟ble High Court vide Order dated 29.01.2021
passed in W.A No 185/2020 [Agartala Municipal Corporation Vs Samir Kumar
Ghosh and 2 others]. The Division Bench of the Hon‟ble High Court in W.A.
185/2020, has also relied on the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court passed in
Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam, Kanpur vs. Mujib Ullah Khan and Another [(2019) 6
SCC 103].
[9.14] The issue has already been settled by the Order dated, 29.01.2021, passed
by the Division Bench of the Hon‟ble High Court in W.A. 185 of 2020. Agartala
Municipal Corporation has already acted in compliance with the direction given by
the learned Single Judge vide Judgment, dated 29.05.2020 in WP(C) 1091/2017,
affirmed by the learned Division Bench.
[9.15] It has been well settled by numerous decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court
[(2004) 11 SCC 26{Para 339 & 340}] that the Co-ordinate Bench of the same
High Court cannot disagree or overrule the Judgment, dated29.01.2021, passed by
a Same Co-ordinate Bench in WA 185/2020.
[9.17] That, so far Agartala Municipal Corporation is concerned, there is no
exemption obtained under Section 5 of the Act, 1972. Adoption of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972, by the Agartala Municipal Corporation under no stretch of
imagination, can be held as obtaining of exemption under Section5 of the Act,
1972. Moreover, exemption under Section 5 of the Act is available only when the
employees of the concerned establishment, factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port,
railway company or shop are in receipt of gratuity or pensionary benefits not less
favourable than the benefits conferred under the Act. As evident from the Counter
Affidavit of Agartala Municipal Corporation, the benefits available to the
employees of the municipality under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 is less
favourable than the benefits conferred under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
For this simple and obvious reason, Section 5 cannot be invoked. Even assuming
by giving imagination a wild run, that, Notification adopting CCS (Pension) Rules,
falls under Section 5; then also Section 5 cannot be invoked, as admittedly, the
benefits given under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, are not more favourable than
the benefit conferred under the Act, 1972.
[9.18] The averment that, the Judgment of the L‟d Division Bench in WA
185/2020 and the learned Single Judge in WP(C) 1091/2017 are per incuriam is
utterly vexatious and offensive. Both the learned Single Judge and the Hon‟ble
Division Bench have taken note of CCS (Pension) Rules and its adoption by
Agartala Municipal Corporation and the Tripura State Govt. Pensioners and
Family Pensioners (Revision of Pension) Rules, 1990. After taking note of such
Rules, the Hon‟ble Division Bench & the learned Single Judge decided both the
Writ Petition and Writ Appeals.
[9.19] There is no requirement of challenging the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 or
TSCS (RP) Rules, 1999 or TSCS (RP) Rules, 2009, as those rules are not
applicable to the Employees of Agartala Municipal Corporation. However, in
some of the Writ Petitions, the aforesaid Rules have been challenged [WA
161/2022, WA 185/2022, WA 186/2022, WA 187/2022, WA 190/2022, WA
192/2022, WA 195/2022, WA 197/2022, WA 198/2022, WA 199/2022, WA
201/2022, WA 203/2022, WA 206/2022, WA 207/2022]. It is also settled law so
far as delegated legislation is concerned, notwithstanding no challenge to the rule,
High Court can quash the rule and held it is inapplicable.
[9.20] That, in Counter Affidavit filed by the Appellants (AMC), it is not
contended, that, Judgments of the learned Single Judge in WP(C)1091/2017 & the
Hon‟ble Division Bench in WA 185/2020 are Judgments per incuriam. For the
first time, this contention has been made.
[9.21] Gratuity is a statutory right. Against statutory right, there cannot be any
estoppel. Gratuity cannot be bartered away or contracted out. There is also no
estoppel against statutory right. The Writ petitioners were not in a bargaining
position. Statutory right cannot be defeated by taking the plea of delay or latches.
For the so called delay, no third party right has matured.
[9.22] In Allahabad Bank and Ors. Vs. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Emps.
Assn. and Ors .[(2010) 2 SCC 44] the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India, vide Para
23 has held, that, Right to Gratuity is a statutory right. In Paras 30 & 31of the
Judgment the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that no establishment can decide
for itself that employees in such establishments were in receipt of gratuity or
pensionary benefits not less favourable than the benefits conferred under the Act.
Sub-section (5) of Section 4 protects the rights of an employee to receive better
terms of gratuity from its employer under any Award or agreement or contract as
the case may be.
[9.25]
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Municipal Corporation of
Delhi versus Dharam Prakash Sharma and Ors. [(1998) 7 SCC 221], has held that
the Payment of Gratuity Act being a special provision for payment of gratuity,
unless there is any provision therein which excludes its applicability to an
employee who is otherwise governed by the provisions of the Pension Rules, it is
not possible to hold that the respondent is not entitled to the gratuity under the
Payment of Gratuity Act. The only provision which was pointed out is the
definition of "employee" in Section 2(e) which excludes the employees of the
Central Government and State Governments receiving pension and gratuity under
the Pension Rules but not an employee of the MCD. The MCD employee,
therefore, would be entitled to the payment of gratuity under the Payment of
Gratuity Act. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid Judgment also held that
beneficial legislation is to be given liberal construction having regard to the
directive principle of state policy. Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is a welfare
legislation deserving liberal interpretation.
[10]
Learned senior counsel for the writ petitioners has contested the
instant appeals as being a forced upon litigation upon the employees of the
AMC once again when none of the issues raised herein were res integra or not
considered by the learned Court earlier in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh
(supra). Learned senior counsel for the writ petitioner has specifically drawn
the attention of this Court to the decision in case Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh
(supra) dated 29.05.2020 where there is a reference of the 1991 notification
which has been also dealt with at paragraph Nos.6 and 7 of the said judgment.
It is further submitted that the learned Writ Court being conscious of the
payments already made under the Pension Rules, directed the respondentCorporation to deduct the amount already paid from the enhanced ceiling of
Rs.10,00,000/- payable to the petitioner. It should carry interest if not paid
within 30 days from the date of retirement of the employee. Learned senior
counsel for the writ petitioners has countenanced the contention of the
appellant-Corporation that the acceptance of gratuity under the Pension Rules
amounted to estoppel against the employees. He has submitted that the
Corporation owes a statutory obligation to make payment under the central
legislation and any payment accepted under the Pension Rules by any of these
retired employees could not operate as an estoppel since estoppel does not
operate against a statute. He has referred to the decision of Allahabad Bank
and another versus All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association,
reported in (2010) 2 SCC 44 (paragraphs- 2, 14 and 21 in particular) in support
of the aforesaid submission. Writ petitioners have also contested the plea that
none of these employees had opted for being governed by the Pension Rules,
1972 as has been projected by the appellants. He submitted that the pleadings
lack specific averments to that effect.
[11]
Learned senior counsel for the writ petitioners has also
countenanced the point of delay in approaching the Court for release of gratuity
under „the Act of 1972‟. In support of this submission, they have also relied
upon a decision of Single Bench of Bombay High Court presided over by
Hon‟ble Dr. D. Y. Chandrachud, J (as His Lordship then was) in Writ Petition
No.564 of 2005 in case of H. Jayarama Shetty Vs. the Sangli Bank Ltd.
Paragraph-11 of the judgment has been specifically referred to which postulates
that filing of an application before the employer under Section 7 of the Act of
1972 is not a condition precedent. It is a procedural provisions on filing of
which the limitation under the Rules is triggered from the date of filing of the
application but it obviously cannot defeat the claim of the employees. Learned
senior counsel for the writ petitioners has summarized the submissions to the
effect that the entire premise of the appellants case based upon notification
dated 21.12.1991 is untenable in law as there has been no conscious application
of mind required by the appropriate government to exempt the AMC from the
applicability of „the Act of 1972‟ that the existing scheme or Pension Rules
have better terms of gratuity or were no less favorable than what was provided
under „the Act of 1972‟. Based on these submissions, learned senior counsel for
the writ petitioner has prayed for rejection of the instant appeals.
[12]
We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and taken
note of the rival submissions of the parties. We have also gone through the
decisions cited above, some of which have been referred to in the forgoing
paragraphs of this judgment. Before we proceed to deal with the challenge to
answer the issue raised herein, the bare details of the respective writ petitioners
as are borne out from the pleadings have been tabulated in the form of chart and
are being furnished hereunder:
W.A./ W.P. (C) No.
W.A. 161 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 218 of
Details of Writ Petitioners
Against Judgment & Order
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Ratna Roy
W.A.185 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 175 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Killal Chandra Laskar
Date of Joining- 20.10.1981
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 31.10.2011
Total Period of Service- 30 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 17,350/D.A.- Rs. 4,685/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 2,60,250/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.3,81,375/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Note: Name of the respondent in the WP(C) 126 is
reflected as Kajal Chandra Laskar
W.A. 186 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 176 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Gita Deb (Ganguly)
W.A. 187 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 174 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Sekhar Bhattacharjee
W.A. 188 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 130 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Santi Rani Kalai
W.A. 189 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 131 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Salil Deb
W.A. 190 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 172 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Bijoy Choudhuri
W.A. 191 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 126 of
AMC v. Bhaskar Debbarma
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
Date of Joining- 03.05.1988 (as DRW).
Regularized- 01.11.2000
Date of Retirement- 31.12.2018
Total Period of Service- 24 years.
Basic Pay- Rs. 28,570
D.A.Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.3,95,584/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Paid – Rs.3,51,750/-
Date of Appointment- 04.10.1980 (MR
Worker)
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 31.01.2015 (UDC)
Total Period of Service- 35 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 20,090/D.A.- Rs. 13,862/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 3,31,485/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.6,85,569/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 16.08.1974 (as Tax
Collecting Sarkar)
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 31.01.2011
Total Period of ServiceTotal Period of Service- 37 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 19,520
D.A.- Rs. 4685
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.5,16,683/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Amount sanctioned- Rs.3,22,080/Date of Joining- 20.10.1981 (Upper Division
Clerk)
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 31.07.2012 (as office
Superintendent)
Total Period of ServiceBasic Pay- Rs. 21,770
D.A.- Rs. 7620
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.5,25,628/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Sanctioned – Rs.3,37,435/Date of Joining- 11.07.1988 (joined as Muster
Roll worker/ DRW)
Regularized- 01.11.2007
Date of Retirement- 30.06.2015
Total Period of Service- 17 yars.
Basic Pay- Rs. 10,280
D.A.- Rs. 7093
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.1,70,389 (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Sanctioned – Rs.89,632/Date of Joining- 03.06.1976 (joined as Muster
Roll worker)
Regularized- 01.01. 1979 (as LDC)
Date of Retirement- 31.10.2011
Total Period of ServiceBasic Pay- Rs. 17,600
D.A.- Rs. 4752
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.4,25,547/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 20.10.1981(as LDCtemporary basis)
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 30.09.2016 (as Office
Superintendent- superannuation)
Total Period of Service- 35 years.
Basic Pay- Rs. 25400
D.A.- Rs. 21082
W.A. 192 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 179 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Pranab Nandi
W.A. 193 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 132 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Jalal Ahmed
W.A. 194 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 127 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Dibakar Choudhury
W.A. 195 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 169 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Krishna Gopal Dey
W.A. 196 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 134 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Dipak Kumar Nandi
W.A. 197 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 125 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Milan Chakraborty
W.A. 198 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 178 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
Date of Joining- 18.11.1981 (as UDC)
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 31.01.2016
Total Period of Service- 35 years.
Basic Pay- Rs. 26,910
D.A.- Rs. 1,99,13
Amount sanctioned till date - Rs.4,00,000 /Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.9,45,464/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 04.08.1976
Regularized- 28.02.1979
Date of Retirement- 30.04.2015
Total Period of Service- 36 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 12,920/D.A.- Rs. 8,915
Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 2,13,180 /Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.4,53,496/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 01.04.1976
Regularized- 28.02. 1979
Date of Retirement- 31.10.2011
Total Period of Service- 33 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 17,600/D.A.- Rs. 4,752/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 2,90,400/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.4,25,547/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 04.02.1977
Regularized- 04.10.1980
Date of Retirement- 31.01.2017
Total Period of Service-40 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 24,610/D.A.- Rs. 21,657/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs.4,00,000/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.10,67,700/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Nitai Majumder
W.A. 200 of 2022
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
Date of Joining- 26.11. 1987
Regularized- 27.01.2004
Date
of
Retirement31.01.2015
(Superannuation)
Total Period of ServiceBasic Pay- Rs. 20,820/D.A.- Rs. 14366/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.3,85,692/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Received amount till date – Rs.1,97,790/Date of Joining- 01.06.1976 (as Muster Roll
Worker)
Regularized- 01.01.1979 (to post of Work
Assistant)
Date of Retirement- 30.06.2014
Total Period of Service- 35 years.
Basic Pay- Rs. 19,850
D.A.- Rs. 11,315
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.6,29,293/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Received amount – Rs.3,27,525/-
AMC v. Geeta Paul (Biswas)
W.A. 199 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 171 of
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.9,83, 578 (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Sanctioned – Rs.4,00,000/-
Date of Joining- 11.04.1988
Regularized- 26.10.1990
Date of Retirement- 31.10.2019
Total Period of Service- 30 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 49,200/D.A.- Rs. Not mentioned.
Amount sanctioned till date- Rs. 5,35,050/(Paid)
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.8,51,538/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 01.04.1973 (MR worker)
Promotion- 20.09.1978 (Driver)
Date of Retirement- 31.10.2014
Total Period of Service- 38 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 19,870/D.A.- Rs. 12,717/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 3,27,855/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.7,14,407/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 03.05.1988
AMC v. Shimal Chandra Saha
Regularized- 26.10.1990
Date of Retirement- 31.01.2012
Total Period of Service- 23 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 12,280/D.A.- Rs. 3,684/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 1,38,150/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.2,11,830/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
W.A. 201 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 415 of
Date of Joining- 01.01.1979 (LDC)
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 30.04.2015
Total Period of Service- 36 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 23,510/D.A.- Rs. 16,222/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 3,87,915/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.8,25,203/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 21.08.1974
Regularized- 21.06.1978
Date of Retirement- 30.04.2016
Total Period of Service- 41 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 19,000/D.A.- Rs. 15,010/Amount sanctioned till date - Rs.
Received amount till date- Rs. 3,13,500/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.8,04,467/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Along with W.P.(C) No. 128 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Nitai Dey
W.A. 202 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 129 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Dilip Acharjee
W.A. 203 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 177 of
W.P. (C) No. 126 of 2021
AMC v. Subhash Chandra Biswas
W.A. 204 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 133 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
Date of Joining- 28.02.1979
Regularized
Date of Retirement- 30.09.2015
But in the writ petition before the Ld. Judge- 30.09.2015
Total Period of Service- 36 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 27,460
D.A.- Rs. 20,320
Received amount till date- Rs. 4,00,000/
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.9,92,353/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
AMC v. Gopal Chandra Sen
W.A. 205 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 135 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Suchitra Paul (Saha)
W.A. 206 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 173 of
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
AMC v. Raghunath Sarkar
(husband)
Date of Joining- 11.02.1977
Regularized- 04.10.1980
Date of Retirement- 30.06.2015
Total Period of Service- 36 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 23,190
D.A.- Rs. 16,001
Received amount received till date- Rs.
3,82,635/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.8,13,966/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 23.04.1976 (mentioned in
W.P. (C) no.135 of 2021)
Regularized- 01.01.1979
Date of Retirement- 30.09.2015
Total Period of Service- 37 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 24,300/D.A.- Rs. 17,982/Received amount received till date- Rs.
4,00,000/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.9,02,558/(as provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Date of Joining- 27.10.1988
Regularized- 01.09.2000
Date of Retirement- 31.07.2014
Death of the employee- 30.08.2017 (Wife)
Total Period of Service- 20 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 9,700/D.A.- Rs. 6,208/Received amount received till date- Rs.
77,600/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.1,83,553/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
W.A. 207 of 2022
Along with W.P.(C) No. 170 of
AMC v. Badal Kumar Choudhuri
W.P. (C) No. 218 of 2021
Date of Joining- 03.05.1988
Regularized- 26.10.1990
Date of Retirement- 31.04.2014
Total Period of Service- 25 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 14,150/D.A.- Rs. 8,066/Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.3,20,423/- (as
provided by the Single Judge Bench)
Sanctioned amount – Rs.1,76,875/-
W.A. 29 of 2023
Along with W.P.(C) No. of 2021
W.P. (C) No. 204 of 2021
AMC v. Samir Kumar Ghosh
W.P.(C) No. 599 of 2023
Rubi Dutta Deb v. The State of
Tripura
[13]
Under Article- 226 of
Constitution Of India
Date of Joining- 01.01.1976
RegularizedDate of Retirement- 31.12.2015
Total Period of Service- 40 years
Basic Pay- Rs. 25,030/D.A.- Rs.18,522/Received
amount till date as gratuityRs. 8,14,190/-
Petitioner no.1- Smt. Rubi Datta Deb
Date of Joining- 01.03.1979 (LDC)
Regularized
Date of Retirement- 31.10.2016 (UDC)
Total Period of Service- 37 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 24,610/
D.A.- Rs. 20,426/
Amount sanctioned till date- Rs. 3,00,000/
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs.9,61,345/(Claim by petitioner based 9% p.a.)
Petitioner no.2- Ashim Baran Datta
Date of Joining- 01.01.1979 (LDC)
Regularized
Date of Retirement- 29.02.2016 (Head
Clerk)
Total Period of Service- 37 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 24,300/
D.A.- Rs. 17,982/
Amount sanctioned till date - Rs. 3,00,000/
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs. 9,02,558/(Claim by petitioner based 9% p.a.)
Petitioner no.3- Chandra Sekhar Deb
Date of Joining- 22.04.1976 (LDC)
Regularized
Date of Retirement- 31.01.2012 (Head
Clerk) mentioned writ petition
Note: Annexure-24 mentions 31.07.2012
Total Period of Service- 36 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 19,650/
D.A.- Rs. 6,878/
Amount sanctioned till date- Rs. 2,43,169/
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs. 5,50,966/(Claim by petitioner based 9% p.a.)
Note: No annexure could be found in the case of this
petitioner except for Annex-12 i.e., the sanctioned order
of gratuity.
Petitioner no.4 Nishi Kanta Sinha
Date of Joining- 01.01.1979 (LDC)
Regularized- 28.02.2012
Date of Retirement- 28.02.2012 (mentioned
in W.P)
Note: Annexure-25 mentions 31.08.2012
Total Period of Service-33 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 18,130/
D.A.- Rs. 6,346/
Amount sanctioned till date- Rs. 2,24,359/
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs. 4,65,985/(Claim by petitioner based 9% p.a.)
Petitioner no.5- Jiban Kumar Saha
Date of Appointment- 01.01.1979
Regularized
Date of Retirement- 31.03.2010
Total Period of Service- 32 Years
Basic Pay- Rs. 17,080/
D.A.- Rs. 4,099/
Amount sanctioned till date- Rs. 68,321/
Entitled amount of gratuity- Rs. 3,90,996/(Claim by petitioner based 9% p.a.)
The basic premise of challenge in this round of litigation by the
Corporation which has earlier followed and complied with the decision
rendered by the Writ Court in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) in
WP(C) No.1091/2017 as upheld in Writ Appeal No.185 of 2020 is based on the
notification dated 21.12.1991 issued by the State Government. It is their case
that this notification applying the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, is a conscious
exercise of power under Section 5 by the appropriate government i.e. the State
Government to exempt the AMC from the applicability of „the Act of 1972‟.
For better appreciation, the notification dated 21.12.1991 is extracted in extenso
hereinafter:
“Government of Tripura
Local Self Government Department
No.F.14(6)-LSG/83
Dated, Agartala, the 21.12.1991.
Notification
Whereas the Agartala Municipality has proposed for the approval
of the State Government to the adoption of the Central Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted in the State of Tripura) for the officers and
employees of the Agartala Municipality;
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section
(1) of Section 69 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932, as extended to Tripura,
the State Government is hereby pleased to approve the Central Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted in the State of Tripura), as amended uptodate and as may be amended by the Government of Tripura in future, for
being adopted and applied for the officers and employees of the Agartala
Municipality subject to the notifications, and terms and conditions as
specified hereinafter, namely:1.
(1) Whenever an expression mentioned in column 1 of the Table
given hereunder occurs in the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1972 (as adopted in the State of Tripura) (hereinafter
referred to as the Principal Rules), then, unless the context
otherwise requires, there shall be substituted therefore the
expression set opposite to it in column 2 of the said Table, and
there shall also be made in any sentence in which that expression
occurs such consequential amendment as Rules of grammar may
require:T A B L E
(i)
Governor
Commissioner
of
Municipality at a
meeting.
(ii)
(iii)
Government
Tripura.
State Government.
(iv)
State of Tripura.
Agartala Municipality.
(v)
Government.
Agartala Municipality.
(vi)
State Service.
Service of the Agartala Municipality.
(vii)
Civil Service.
Service of the Agartala Municipality.
(viii)
Consolidated Fund.
Municipal Fund.
(ix)
Finance Department.
Commissioners of the Agartala
Municipality in a duly convened
meeting.
(x)
Government Servant.
Officer and employee of the Agartala
Municipality.
of
the
Agartala
duly convened
Agartala Municipality.
Agartala Municipality.
(2) In the Principal Rules, the words “Tripura Public
Service Commission” wherever they occur shall be
deleted.
2.
In the Principal Rules, for sub-rule (2) of rule-1, the
following sub-rule shall be substituted, namely :“(2) They shall be deemed to have come into force on
and from the first day of January, 1992”.
3. In the Principal Rules, in sub-rule (1) of rule 3, (a) for clause (a), the
following clause shall be substituted, namely:“(a)
„Audit Officer‟ means the authority who authorizes
disbursement of pay and allowances of the officers and
employees of the Agartala Municipality;”;
(b)
for clause (j), the following clause shall be substituted,
namely:“(j) „Head of Department‟ means the Chairman of the
Agartala Municipality;”;
(c)
for clause (k), the following clause shall be substituted,
namely :“(k) „Head of Office‟ means the Executive Officer of the
Agartala Municipality;”; and
(d)
for clause (r), the following clause shall be substituted,
namely :“(r) „Treasury‟ shall include a sub-treasury or, in the fund
of the Municipality is kept in a Bank, the Bank in which
the fund is kept in accordance with rules;”;
4.
The Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted in
the State of Tripura) and as modified and approved for adoption by this
Notification in its application to the officers and employees of the Agartala
Municipality may be called the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972
(as adopted for the Agartala Municipality).
5.
The officers and employees who enter the service of the Agartala
Municipality on or after the date of commencement of the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted for the Agartala Municipality)
shall automatically come under the purview of these Rules.
6.
(1) Every officer and employee of the Agartala Municipality shall
have the right to exercise option as to whether he will come under the Central
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted for the Agartala
Municipality) or will continue to be governed by the Agartala Municipal
Provident Fund Rules, 1967. The option shall be exercised within ninety days
from the date of issue of notice by the Agartala Municipal Authority,
provided that in the case of an officer and employee who is on leave or on
deputation or on foreign service or under suspension on the date of issue of
the notice in this regard, the said option shall be exercised not later than
ninety days of the date of his return from such leave, deputation, foreign
service or resumption of duty after suspension as the case may be.
(2) An officer and an employee of the Agartala Municipality shall
opt either(a) to retain the Contribution of the Agartala Municipality with
interest thereon under the Agartala Municipal Provident Fund Rules, 1967; or
(b)
to refund to the Agartala Municipality the monetary
benefits referred to in clause (a) or to forgo the same if they have not been
paid to him and count, in liew thereof, the service for pension for which the
aforesaid monetary benefits may have been payable.
(3)
The officer or employee who exercises option under
clause (a) to retain the monetary benefits referred to therein, shall not be
entitled to count his service for pension for which such monetary benefits
have been paid.
(4)
In case an officer or an employee does not exercise
option within the specified period of ninety days, he shall automatically come
under these Rules.
(5)
The option under sub-para (1) and sub-para (2) shall be
exercised in the prescribed form appended to this Notification and shall be
submitted to the Municipal Authority.
(6)
The option once exercised shall be final.
7.
The Establishment Branch of the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura shall be responsible for checking and authorizing
payment of retirement benefits to the officers and employees of the Agartala
Municipality.
8.
The power of interpretation of the Central Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1972 (as adopted for the Agartala Municipality) shall vest in
the Finance Department of the Government of Tripura.
By Order of the Governor,
Sd/SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA.”
[14]
Section 5 of the Payment of Gratuity Act 1972 is quoted
hereunder:
“Power to exempt
(1) The appropriate Government may, by notification, and subject to such
conditions as may be specified in the notification, exempt any establishment,
factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway company or shop to which
this Act applies from the operation of the provisions of this Act if, in the
opinion of the appropriate Government, the employees in such establishment,
factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway company or shop are in
receipt of gratuity or pensionary benefits not less favourable than the benefits
conferred under this Act.
(2) The appropriate Government may, by notification and subject to such
conditions as may be specified in the notification, exempt any employee or
class of employees employed in any establishment, factory, mine, oilfield,
plantation, port, railway company or shop to which this Act applies from the
operation of the provisions of this Act, if, in the opinion of the appropriate
Government, such employee or class of employees are in receipt of gratuity
or pensionary benefits not less favourable than the benefits conferred under
this Act.
(3) A notification issued under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) may be
issued retrospectively a date not earlier than the date of commencement of
this Act, but no such notification shall be issued so as to prejudicially affect
the interests of any person”.
[15]
The notification dated 21.12.1991 has been issued in exercise of
the powers conferred under sub-section (1) of Section 69 of the Bengal
Municipal Act, 1932 as extended to Tripura whereby the State Government has
approved the adoption and application of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 as
amended up to that date to the officers and employees of the Agartala
Municipality subject to the modifications, and terms and conditions as specified
thereinafter. A notification under Section 5 of „the Act of 1972‟ by the
appropriate government contemplates a conscious decision to exempt any
establishment from the operation of the provisions of the Act if in the opinion
of the appropriate government the employees in such establishment are in
receipt of gratuity or pensionary benefits not less favourable than the benefits
conferred under this Act. For a notification to satisfy the ingredients of Section
5 of „the Act of 1972‟, the relevant factor which is to be taken into
consideration is whether the officers and employees of the AMC were in receipt
of gratuity or pensionary benefits which were not less favourable than the
benefits conferred under the Act of 1972. An argument has been raised that
mere non mentioning of such a provision in the notification could not denude
the appropriate government from a valid exercise of power under „the Act of
1972‟ to exempt the AMC, but a bare perusal of this notification leaves no
element of doubt that the adoption of Pension Rules to the employees of AMC
under Section 69 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932 is not an exercise of
exemption by the State Government under Section 5 of „the Act of 1972‟. No
such consideration either is evident from perusal of the notification.
[16]
The power of the State Government to issue such an exemption
notification is not in dispute. That the Central Government under Section
2(3)(c) has the power to notify such establishments as are covered by the
provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is also not in dispute. The relevant
notification of the Central Government dated 8th January, 1982 has also been
referred to by the appellate Court in Case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra)
and is extracted hereunder:
“S.O. No.239….In exercise of the powers conferred by clause © if subsection (3) of Section 1 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (39 of 1972),
the Central Government hereby specified “local bodies” in which ten or more
persons are employed, or were employed, on any day preceding twelve
months, as a class of establishments to which the said Act shall apply with
effect from the date of publication of this notification in the Official Gazette.”
[17]
This proposition finds further force from the decision of the Apex
Court in case of Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (Supra) which has also
been relied upon by the learned writ court and the Appellate Court in case of
Samir Kumar Ghosh Vs. Agartala Municipal Corporation (supra). The
relevant paragraphs of the decisions in case of Nagar Ayukt Nagar Nigam,
Kanpur (supra) are being reproduced hereunder:
“7. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent pointed out that the
Central Government has published a notification in terms of Section
1(3)(c) of the Act on 08.01.1982 to extend the applicability of the Act to the
Municipalities. Thus, the Act is applicable to the Municipalities. The relevant
provisions of the Act read as under:
“1. Short title, extent, application and commencement.(1)
This Act may be called the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
(2) It extends to the whole of India:
Provided that in so far as it relates to plantations or ports, it shall not extend
to the State of Jammu and Kashmir.
(2)
It shall apply to(a)
every factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port and railway
company;
(b)
every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the
time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State, in
which ten or more persons are employed, or were employed, on any day of
the preceding twelve months;
(c)
such other establishments or class of establishments, in which ten
or more employees are employed, or were employed, on any day of the
preceding twelve months, as the Central Government may, by notification,
specify in this behalf.”
8. A perusal of the above provisions would show that the Act is applicable to
(1) every factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port and railway company; (2)
every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being
in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State, in which ten or
more persons are employed, the said provision has two conditions, viz. (i) a
shop or establishments within the meaning of a State law and (ii) in which ten
or more persons are employed; and (3) the establishments or class of
establishments which Central Government may notify.
9.
The appellant is not covered by clauses (a) and (b) of Section
1(3) of the Act. Clause (a) is not applicable on the face of the provisions, but
even clause (b) is not applicable in view of Section 3 (1) (c) of the 1962 Act
as such Act is not applicable to the offices of the Government or local
authorities. The Local Authorities means a municipal committee, district
board etc or entrusted with the control or management of a municipal or local
fund in terms of Section 3(31) of the General Clauses Act, 1897.
10.
In terms of the above said Section 1(3)(c) of the Act, the Central
Government has published a notification on 08.01.1982 and specified Local
Bodies in which ten or more persons are employed, or were employed, on
any day of the preceding twelve months as a class of establishment to which
this Act shall apply. The said notification dated 08.01.1982 reads as under:“ New Delhi, 8th January, 1982
NOTIFICATION
S.O. No. 239….-In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (c) of subsection (3) of section 1 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (39 of 1972),
the Central Government hereby specified „local bodies‟ in which ten or more
persons are employed, or were employed, on any day preceding twelve
months, as a class of establishments to which the said Act shall apply with
effect from the date of publication of this notification in the Official Gazette.
Sd/.
(R. K. A. Subrahmanya)
Additional Secretary
(F. No. S-70020/16/77-FPG)”
11.
We find that the notification dated 08.01.1982 was not referred to
before the High Court. Such notification makes it abundantly clear that the
Act is applicable to the local bodies i.e., the Municipalities. Section 14 of the
Act has given an overriding effect over any other inconsistent provision in
any other enactment. The said provision reads as under:
“14. Act to override other enactments, etc. – The provisions of this Act or
any rule made thereunder shall have effect notwithstanding anything
inconsistent therewith contained in any enactment other than this Act or in
any instrument or contract having effect by virtue of any enactment other
than this Act.”
12.
In view of Section 14 of the Act, the provision in the State Act
contemplating payment of Gratuity will be inapplicable in respect of the
employees of the local bodies.
13. Section 2(e) of the Act alone was referred to in the judgment reported
as MCD. The said judgment is in the context of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972
which specifically provides for payment of Pension and Gratuity. The Act is
applicable to the Municipalities, therefore, it is wholly inconsequential even
if there is no reference to the notification dated 08.01.1982.
14. The entire argument of the appellant is that the State Act confers
restrictive benefit of gratuity than what is conferred under the Central Act.
Such argument is not tenable in view of Section 14 of the Act and that liberal
payment of gratuity is in fact in the interest of the employees. Thus, the
gratuity would be payable under the Act. Such is the view taken by the
Controlling Authority.”
[18]
In the said case, the Apex Court had taken note of the overriding
provisions under Section 14 of the Act of 1972 and held that the provisions of
the State Act contemplating payment of gratuity will be inapplicable in respect
of the employees of the local bodies i.e. the Municipal Corporation, Kanpur. It
was pleaded on behalf of the Municipal Corporation, Kanpur that in terms of
Section 3 of the U.P Dookan Aur Vanijya Adhishthan Adhiniyam, 1962, the
Act of 1972 was inapplicable to government or local bodies. We find that
reference to the notification dated 21.12.1991 has been made in the decision of
the learned Writ Court in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) in WP(C)
No.1091/2017 dated 29.05.2020. On challenge, the Appellate Court affirmed
the judgment in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) and the same stood
complied by the Corporation. Whether still it is open for the Corporation to
contend that the decision in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) is per
incuriam as it failed to take into account the notification dated 21.12.1991, is a
moot question. However, on being raised in this batch of writ appeals, we have
considered it proper to examine this contention in greater detail as apparently
the decision in case of Sri Samir Kumar Ghosh (supra) in so many words did
not proceed to hold that the notification dated 21.12.1991 was not in the nature
of an exemption under Section 5 of „the Act of 1972‟. In this regard, we deem
it proper to rely upon the case of Municipal Corporation of Delhi versus Dharam
Prakash Sharma and another, (1998) 7 SCC 221 wherein the Apex Court had the
occasion to consider whether an employee of the Municipal Corporation of
Delhi (MCD) would be entitled to payment of gratuity under the Payment of
Gratuity Act when the MCD had adopted the provisions of the CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972, whereunder there was a provision both for payment of pension as
well as of gratuity. The question has been answered at paragraph-2 of the
judgment which is extracted hereunder as it answers any doubt about the
applicability of CCS (Pension) Rules 1972 to the employees of AMC in the
absence of a notification by the State Government in exercise of the powers
under Section 5 of the Act of 1972. The paragraph-2 of the said judgment is
extracted hereunder:
“2. The short question that arises for consideration is whether an employee of
the MCD would be entitled to payment of gratuity under the Payment of
Gratuity Act when the MCD itself has adopted the provisions of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as "the Pension Rules"),
whereunder there is a provision both for payment of pension as well as of
gratuity. The contention of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant in
this Court is that the payment of pension and gratuity under the Pension
Rules is a package by itself and once that package is made applicable to the
employees of the MCD, the provisions of payment of gratuity under
the Payment of Gratuity Act cannot be held applicable. We have examined
carefully the provisions of the Pension Rules as well as the provisions of
the Payment of Gratuity Act. The Payment of Gratuity Act being a special
provision for payment of gratuity, unless there is any provision therein which
excludes its applicability to an employee who is otherwise governed by the
provisions of the Pension Rules, it is not possible for us to hold that the
respondent is not entitled to the gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act.
The only provision which was pointed out is the definition of "employee"
in Section 2(e) which excludes the employees of the Central Government and
State Governments receiving pension and gratuity under the Pension Rules
but not an employee of the MCD. The MCD employee, therefore, would be
entitled to the payment of gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act. The
mere fact that the gratuity is provided for under the Pension Rules will not
disentitle him to get the payment of gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity
Act. In view of the overriding provisions contained in Section 14 of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, the provision for gratuity under the Pension Rules
will have no effect. Possibly for this reason, Section 5 of the Payment of
Gratuity Act has conferred authority on the appropriate Government to
exempt any establishment from the operation of the provisions of the Act, if
in its opinion the employees of such establishment are in receipt of gratuity
or pensionary benefits not less favourable than the benefits conferred under
this Act. Admittedly MCD has not taken any steps to invoke the power of the
Central Government under Section 5 of the Payment of Gratuity Act. In the
aforesaid premises, we are of the considered opinion that the employees of
the MCD would be entitled to the payment of gratuity under the Payment of
Gratuity Act notwithstanding the fact that the provisions of the Pension Rules
have been made applicable to them for the purpose of determining the
pension. Needless to mention that the employees cannot claim gratuity
available under the Pension Rules.”
[19]
The Apex Court has held that the mere fact that the gratuity is
provided for under the Pension Rules will not disentitle the employee to get the
payment of gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act in view of the
overriding provisions of Section 14 of the Payment of Gratuity Act. The
provision of gratuity under the Pension Rules will have no effect. The Apex
Court further held that possibly for this reason Section 5 of the Payment of
Gratuity Act has conferred authority on the appropriate Government to exempt
any establishment from the operation of the provisions of the Act, if in its
opinion the employees of such establishment are in receipt of gratuity or
pensionary benefits not less favourable than the benefits conferred under this
Act. i.e. „the Act of 1972‟. In the present case also the appropriate Government
that the State Government has not invoked the power under Section 5 of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 to exempt the AMC from the cover of „the Act
of 1972‟ as held hereinabove.
[20]
That, the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is a beneficial piece of
legislation is no longer a matter of dispute or construction. The Apex Court in
Case of Allahabad Bank and another versus All India Allahabad Bank
Retired Employees Association reported in (2010) 2 SCC 44 has also held so at
paragraph-16 of the judgment which is extracted hereunder:
“16. We shall proceed to examine the point urged by the learned counsel for the
appellant. Remedial statutes, in contradistinction to penal statutes, are known as
welfare, beneficent or social justice oriented legislations. Such welfare statutes
always receive a liberal construction. They are required to be so construed so as to
secure the relief contemplated by the statute. It is well settled and needs no
restatement at our hands that labour and welfare legislation have to be broadly and
liberally construed having due regard to the Directive Principles of State Policy. The
Act with which we are concerned for the present is undoubtedly one such welfare
oriented legislation meant to confer certain benefits upon the employees working in
various establishments in the country”.
[21]
As held therein, „the Act of 1972‟ is a beneficent or social justice
oriented legislation which deserves a liberal construction as it is intended to
secure the relief contemplated by the statute in favour of a whole class of
employees having regard to the Directive Principles of State Policy. It is not for
the AMC to decide whether the provisions of Pension Rules, 1972 or the
provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 are less or more favourble to the
employees. The responsibility is upon the State Government. The State
Government had the power to exempt the Corporation in exercise of the powers
under Section 5 of the Act of 1972. We find that no such exercise has been
done. The decision in case of Allahabad Bank and another (supra) also
reiterates the well settled position that obligation to pay gratuity in absence of
exemption from appropriate government continues to exist even if pension is
being paid by the establishment under an existing scheme and even if it is more
attractive than the benefits admissible under the Act by virtue of non obstante
provision of Section 14 which has an overriding effect. It is for the appropriate
government to form requisite opinion that employees were in receipt of gratuity
or pensionary benefits which were more favourable than benefits conferred
under the Act and, therefore, the establishment must be exempted from the
operation of the provisions of the Act. The basic premise on which these
appeals are based, therefore, fails. We have no doubt that in the absence of an
exemption notification by the State Government under Section 5 of the Act of
1972, AMC has a statutory obligation to pay gratuity under the Act of 1972. It
is not for the AMC to compare whether the terms of gratuity under the Pension
Rules are less or more favorable than what is provided under the Act of 1972
and the notifications enhancing the ceiling of gratuity from time to time issued
by the Central Government.
[22]
Having held so, the next ancillary questions which have been
raised by the appellant-Corporation also need to be answered hereinafter. The
appellants contend that some of the writ petitioners have accepted gratuity
under the Pension Rules, 1972 and, therefore, they are estopped from seeking
benefits under the Act of 1972. Appellants also contend that many of these writ
petitioners have superannuated long back in the year 2011/2012/2015/2018 but
have approached the Writ Court for payment of Gratuity under the Act of 1972
as per the enhanced ceiling limit even after accepting the benefit of gratuity
under the Pension Rules. A party, who does not approach the Court in time,
does not deserve to be granted the relief. It is also contended that under Section
7 of the Act of 1972 the employee has to first make an application before the
employer within such time as may be prescribed in the form. The Rule 7
provides that such an application is to be made within 30 days from the date on
which the gratuity becomes payable. The proviso thereto provides that if the
gratuity is claimed upon superannuation or retirement the same application
ought to be made 30 days before the date of superannuation or retirement. It is
pointed out that under Section 7(2) and (3) of the Act, the employer has to
determine the amount of gratuity as soon as gratuity becomes payable and give
a notice in writing to the person to whom the gratuity is payable and also to the
controlling authority specifying the amount of gratuity so determined. The
employer has to arrange to pay the amount of gratuity within 30(thirty) days
from the date it becomes payable to the person to whom the gratuity is payable.
If the gratuity is not paid as contemplated under Section 7 sub-section 3 within
the period specified therein the employer shall have to pay gratuity from the
date on which the gratuity becomes payable to the date on which it is paid with
simple interest at the rate not exceeding the rate notified by the Central
Government from time to time for re-payment of long term deposits. However,
the employer can seek permission in writing from the controlling authority for
exemption from payment of interest if the delay in payment is due to the fault
of the employee. It is argued by learned counsel for the Corporation that none
of the writ petitioners have approached the employer in a prescribed format for
payment of gratuity. As such, interest, if any, on the delay in payment of
gratuity should not be allowed in favour of such petitioners. Learned counsel
for the Corporation has also sought to distinguish the decision of the Apex
Court in case of Allahabad Bank and another (supra) relied upon by the writ
petitioners.
[23]
We have conferred anxious consideration to the arguments
advanced on behalf of the Corporation, A statutory obligation is cast upon an
establishment covered under Section 2(3) (c) of the Act of 1972, like the
Corporation herein, to make payment of gratuity to its employees. The
Corporation is exempted from making such payment under the Act of 1972
only if the appropriate Government i.e. the State Government in this case by a
conscious exercise of power under Section 5 of the Act of 1972 exempted the
Corporation from the applicability of the Act of 1972. We have held that there
is no such exemption granted by the State Government in favour of the
Corporation.
[24]
The aforesaid position is further reinforced from the decisions
referred to hereinabove specifically in case of Municipal Corporation of Delhi
Versus Dharam Prkash Sharma and another and in case of Nagar Ayukt
Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (supra). Such position is also strengthened by the
decision rendered in case of Allahabad Bank and another (supra) which we
have referred to hereinbefore. If there is no exemption notification under the
Act of 1972, the Corporation was under a statutory liability to pay gratuity in
terms of the Act of 1972 and not under the provisions of the CCS (Pension)
Rules under which payments have been made to some of the writ petitioners.
This Court is of the opinion that non filing of an application under Rule 7 in
terms of Section 7 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 could not absolve the
Corporation of the liability to make payment of gratuity under the Act of 1972
to its employees. In this regard we may profitably refer to the opinion of the
Bombay High Court in case of H. Jayarama Shetty (supra) at paragraph-11
which is extracted hereunder:
“11. The rules which were framed in 1972 must be read in a manner which is
consistent with the statutory provisions of Section 7 particularly after the
amendments that were introduced by Amending Act 25 of 1984 (with effect
from 1st April 1984) and by Amending Act 22 of 1987 (with effect from 1st
October 1987). The provisions of Section 7 emphasise that the obligation is
that of the employer to determine and to make arrangements for the payment
of gratuity and upon his failure to do so, to pay interest at the rate which is
statutorily prescribed. Even if the period that is prescribed in the Rules is
taken into consideration, the Rules themselves lay down that the delay on the
part of the employer, if any, can be condoned if sufficient cause is shown. A
breach of the employer to comply with his obligation under section
7 provides a recurring and continuous cause of action. The Act is a piece of
social welfare legislation and the employer cannot be permitted by reason of
his own default in complying with his obligation to defeat the just entitlement
of the employee. Finally, it may be noted that the employer has to determine
and pay gratuity whether or not an application is filed to him. The filing of an
application before the employer is not a condition precedent. Rule 7 makes
procedural provisions for such an application. On receipt of an application
under Rule 7, the employer has to issue a notice under Rule 8 either
admitting the claim or to specify the reasons why he holds the claim
inadmissible. It is thereafter that time is prescribed in Rule 10 for an
application to the Controlling Authority. The making of an application under
Rule 7 therefore invokes a chain of events in Rules 8 and 10. Once the
making of an application to the employer is not mandatory under the
provisions of Section 7(2) of the substantive provisions of the act, the
limitation under the Rules which is triggered upon the filing of the
application under Rule 7 can obviously not defeat the claim of the
employee”.
[25]
The learned Court held that rules have to be read in a manner
which is consistent with the statutory provisions of Section 7 particularly after
the amendments that were introduced by Amending Act 25 of 1984 and by
Amending Act 22 of 1987. A breach of the employer to comply with his
obligation under section 7 provides a recurring and continuous cause of action.
If that be so, mere delay in approaching the Court on the part of any of the writ
petitioners cannot defeat their statutory right to receive gratuity under the Act
of 1972 nor can absolve the Corporation from discharging its statutory
obligation to make payment of gratuity in terms of the Act of 1972. Since there
is no exemption under Section 5 of the Act of 1972 in favour of the AMC by
the State Government, any payment made by the Corporation under the Pension
Rules and accepted by individual writ petitioners would not absolve the
Corporation from the liability to make payment of the due amount of gratuity to
such employee after adjusting the amount already paid. There cannot be
estoppels against the mandate of the statute, i.e. the Act of 1972.
We find that the learned Writ Court in case of Sri Samir Kumar
[26]
Ghosh (supra) had, at the first instance, also taken such a view that payments
made, if any, in favour of the employees were to be made after deducting the
gratuity already paid with the revised ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/- in that
case. The position in law is quite clear that employees retiring after 24.05.2010
would be entitled to the enhanced ceiling limit of gratuity of Rs. 10,00,000/and those retiring after 29.03.2018 would be entitled to the revised ceiling limit
of gratuity of Rs.20,00,000/- . Therefore, the AMC is required to calculate the
admissible gratuity in terms Section 4(2) of „the Act of 1972‟. The Corporation
shall determine the admissible dues under the head of gratuity in such manner
in the cases of individual writ petitioners on the basis of the last wages of the
employee in terms of Section 2(s) read with Section 4(2) of „the Act of 1972‟.
The Corporation shall make payment of admissible gratuity to the individual
writ petitioners after deducting the amount already paid within a period of
5(five) months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment along with
simple interest @ 6% per annum upon completion of one month from the date
of superannuation till actual payment.
[27]
In the result, the writ appeals are dismissed. The case of the writ
petitioners in Writ Petition No.599 of 2023 shall also be governed by the
judgment in the batch of these writ appeals.
Pending application(s) if any, also stands disposed of.
(S. D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Munna S
MUNNA SAHA SAHA
Date: 2024.03.14 16:22:47
+05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review