The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. 12.2010 found that the award holder was directed to vacate and deliver possession of acquired land before the evening of 13.01.2009. The learned advocate for the award holder had also added that they had vacated the land as per letter dated 23.12.2008. Having regard to the aforesaid findings recorded by the learned Executing Court, the judgment-debtor/petitioner was directed to make payment of an amount of Rs.22,80,194/- as per the calculation submitted by the award holder. This was challenged in CRP No.62 of 2022 by the judgment-debtor/petitioner. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, the petition was disposed of by the following order : “This is a petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the order dated 13.06.2022 passed in EXE(M) 02 of 2018 by the learned L.A. Judge, West Tripura, Agartala, (Court No.2) whereby the learned L.A. Judge, directed the petitioner to make the payment of Rs.22,80,194/- by the next date which is fixed on 18.07.2022. Heard learned counsels appearing for both parties. The order dated 13.06.2022 is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the Court below. The Court below is directed to consider the possession certificate issued under Section 16 of the L.A. Act 1894 by the concerned authorities on 23.12.2010 and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible. It is needless to ob…
12. 08.2022 passed by this Court in CRP No.62 of 2022 and the present impugned order. This Court has also taken note of the computation furnished by the decree holder which is part of the petition filed on 19.02.2022 before the Executing Court. It appears therefore that earlier the issue of effective date of taking over of possession came before this Court in CRP No.62 of 2022 when after hearing learned counsel for the parties the Coordinate Bench of this Court set aside the order dated 13.06.2022 and remanded the matter to the court below with a direction to consider the possession certificate issued under Section 16 of the LA Act, 1894 by the concerned authorities on 23.12.2010 and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law after hearing the claimant, as expeditiously as possible. Now the learned Executing Court also seems to have arrived at a conclusion that the effective date of possession is 23.12.2010 as evident from the impugned order extracted hereinabove. If that be so, the calculation submitted by the judgment-debtor and prepared by the Land Acquisition Officer and Land Acquisition Collector, West Tripura, Agartala dated 19.03.2021 enclosed to the petition dated 19.02.2022 filed by the judgment-debtor before the Executing Court ought to have been taken into consideration by the learned Executing Court before asking for a fresh calculation sheet taking the date of hand…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
CRP No.27 of 2023
Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by its Municipal Commissioner,
City Centre Complex, Paradise Chowhumani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799001.
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri Samar Kumar Bhaumik, son of late Jamini Kumar Bhaumik, residence
of Village Shymali Bazar, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura, Pin - 799006.
2. The Land Acquisition Collector, Agartala, West Tripura, Office of D.M. &
Collector, West Tripura, Agartala, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin - 799001.
......Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: None.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
05/07/2023
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India by the judgment-debtor in Misc. LA No.20 of 2011 seeks to challenge
the order dated 20.12.2022 passed by the learned Additional District Judge,
Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in Case No. Ex(M) 02 of 2018. The
operative part of the judgment passed by the reference Court of Land
Acquisition Judge, Court No.3, West Tripura, Agartala is as under :
“In the result, the petition under Section 18 of the L.A. Act as referred by
the L.A. Collector, West Tripura, Agartala is allowed. The referringclaimant is entitled to get a compensation for the acquired land @
Rs.2,50,000/- per kani for till class of land. The Compensation shall be
added with 30% solatium under Section 23(2) of the L.A. Act and 12%
under Section 23(i)(A) of the L.A. Act from the date of Notification under
Section 4 of the said Act till the date of taken over possession or award
whichever is earlier. The interest on the amount of compensation and
solatium shall be @ 9% per annum from the date of possession till one
year and @15% per annum from the date of expiry of one year till the
date of payment of the enhanced amount of compensation. The amount
already paid shall be adjusted against the compensation awarded. Prepare
award accordingly. The case is thus disposed of on contest.”
[2]
During course of the execution proceedings, it appears that a
dispute arose as to the actual date of possession. The land looser/ judgmentdebtor claimed it to be 23.12.2007 but subsequently they claimed it to be
from 13.01.2009. The judgment-debtor/petitioner filed a petition before the
Executing Court on 19.02.2022 indicating the date of possession as
23.12.2010 and a calculation of the admissible compensation comprising the
land value, solatium, 12% additional compensation, interest @ 9% with
effect from 23.12.2010 and 15% interest with effect from 23.12.2011 till
30.04.2019 totaling Rs.1,02,25,078/-. The detailed information in regard to
preparation of the decretal award prepared by the Land Acquisition Officer,
West Tripura Agartala and counter signed by the Land Acquisition
Collector, West Tripura were enclosed showing the aforesaid calculation. It
appears that aggrieved by an order dated 13.06.2022 passed by the
Executing Court, the judgment-debtor/petitioner herein approached this
Court in CRP No.62 of 2022. By order dated 13.06.2022, the learned
Executing Court on the objection of the award holder that the date of taking
over of possession is 23.12.2007, and also considering the calculation
submitted by the judgment-debtor based on the date of possession i.e.
23.12.2010 found that the award holder was directed to vacate and deliver
possession of acquired land before the evening of 13.01.2009. The learned
advocate for the award holder had also added that they had vacated the land
as per letter dated 23.12.2008. Having regard to the aforesaid findings
recorded by the learned Executing Court, the judgment-debtor/petitioner was
directed to make payment of an amount of Rs.22,80,194/- as per the
calculation submitted by the award holder. This was challenged in CRP
No.62 of 2022 by the judgment-debtor/petitioner. After hearing learned
counsel for the parties, the petition was disposed of by the following order :
“This is a petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
challenging the order dated 13.06.2022 passed in EXE(M) 02 of 2018 by
the learned L.A. Judge, West Tripura, Agartala, (Court No.2) whereby the
learned L.A. Judge, directed the petitioner to make the payment of
Rs.22,80,194/- by the next date which is fixed on 18.07.2022.
Heard learned counsels appearing for both parties.
The order dated 13.06.2022 is set aside and the matter is remanded back
to the Court below. The Court below is directed to consider the
possession certificate issued under Section 16 of the L.A. Act 1894 by the
concerned authorities on 23.12.2010 and pass appropriate orders in
accordance with law as expeditiously as possible. It is needless to observe
that the claimant shall also be heard before passing the order.
With the above observation and direction, this instant revision petition is
disposed of. Consequently, pending application(s), if any, also stands
disposed of.”
[3]
Evidently, the learned Executing Court was directed to consider
the possession certificate issued under Section 16 of the L.A. Act 1894 by
the concerned authorities on 23.12.2010 and pass appropriate orders in
accordance with law as expeditiously as possible also after hearing the
claimant. The impugned order has been passed thereafter.
[4]
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Executing
Court has on the instant occasion accepted that the possession was taken
over on 23.12.2010. However, once again the parties have been directed to
file fresh calculation sheet taking the date of handing over and taking over of
possession of the acquired land as 23.12.2010. The operative part of the
order dated 20.12.2022 reads as under :
“In view of the observation of the Hon‟ble High Court the award-holder
was allowed to file their say in writing. Accordingly, the award-holder
has filed an additional written objection contending, inter alia, that the
word “consider” in the direction given by the Hon‟ble High Court is to be
interpreted as the Apex Court in several decisions observed that to
„consider‟ means their should be active application of mind and further
observed the term „consider‟ postulates consideration of all the aspects
and, therefore, it is manifested careful thinking or due application of mind
regarding the necessity to obtain and examine the documents in question
in sine quo non for the making of the order.
Learned Advocate for the JD-requiring department, however, contended
that entire award has been satisfied and nothing remains to be paid to the
award-holder.
On perusal of the order it appears the possession certificate was issued
showing taking over of possession on 23.12.2010. But the award-holder
was directed to vacate the possession on 13.01.2009 and accordingly, the
award-holder stated to have vacated the possession on 13.01.2009 and
thereby calculated the amount of compensation taking the date of handing
over possession on 13.01.2009. In the above context, if we dual upon the
direction so given by the Hon‟ble High Court we left with no option but
to hold that the possession was taken over on 23.12.2010.
In this view of the above, the parties are required to file fresh calculation
sheet taking the date of handing over and taking over of possession of the
acquired land as 23.12.2010.”
[5]
Learned counsel for the petitioner, therefore, submits that if the
payments had been made reckoning the date of taking over of possession as
on 23.12.2010 and computation to that effect duly signed by the Land
Acquisition Officer and Land Acquisition Collector, West Tripura, Agartala
had been duly submitted by the judgment-debtor enclosed to the petition
under Order XXI Rule 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure read with Section
151 of CPC on 19.02.2022, there is no occasion for the learned Executing
Court to ask for a fresh computation. As a matter of fact, if the date of
possession is now not in dispute as per the impugned order itself, the total
amount payable under the award together with land value, solatium, interest
etc. has already been paid to the tune of Rs.1,02,25,078/- by 03.07.2019.
Learned Executing Court has been unnecessary insisting upon fresh
calculation for execution of the award when all the materials are before it
and the date of taking over of possession is also not in dispute. Therefore,
the petitioner had to approach this Court.
[6]
This Court has taken note of the submission of learned counsel
for the judgment-debtor/petitioner and referred to the award, and the orders
passed by the Executing Court earlier on 13.06.2022, the order dated
12.08.2022 passed by this Court in CRP No.62 of 2022 and the present
impugned order. This Court has also taken note of the computation furnished
by the decree holder which is part of the petition filed on 19.02.2022 before
the Executing Court. It appears therefore that earlier the issue of effective
date of taking over of possession came before this Court in CRP No.62 of
2022 when after hearing learned counsel for the parties the Coordinate
Bench of this Court set aside the order dated 13.06.2022 and remanded the
matter to the court below with a direction to consider the possession
certificate issued under Section 16 of the LA Act, 1894 by the concerned
authorities on 23.12.2010 and pass appropriate orders in accordance with
law after hearing the claimant, as expeditiously as possible. Now the learned
Executing Court also seems to have arrived at a conclusion that the effective
date of possession is 23.12.2010 as evident from the impugned order
extracted hereinabove. If that be so, the calculation submitted by the
judgment-debtor and prepared by the Land Acquisition Officer and Land
Acquisition Collector, West Tripura, Agartala dated 19.03.2021 enclosed to
the petition dated 19.02.2022 filed by the judgment-debtor before the
Executing Court ought to have been taken into consideration by the learned
Executing Court before asking for a fresh calculation sheet taking the date of
handing over and taking over of possession of the acquired land as
23.12.2010 itself.
[7]
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Executing
Court has been insisting upon fresh calculation pursuant to the impugned
order and the next date is on 06.07.2023. The execution proceedings should
be brought to an end once an award has been duly satisfied and there
apparently does not appear to be any doubt about the effective date of taking
over of possession of the acquired land i.e. 23.12.2010. He has also referred
to the decision of the Apex Court in case of Rahul S Shah Versus Jitendra
Kumar Gandhi and others reported in Civil Appeal No.1659-1660 of 2021
dated 22.04.2021 and submitted that the Apex Court has directed the
Executing Court to dispose of the execution proceedings within 6(six)
months from the date of filing which may be extended only by recording
reasons in writing for such delay. He submits that therefore the Executing
Court may be directed to stick to the provisions of Order XXI of CPC
regarding execution of decree/award and the ratio rendered by the Apex
Court in case of Rahul S Shah (supra) by disposing of the execution petition
as expeditiously as possible as it is pending since 2018.
[8]
Having regard to the chronology of facts borne from record
taken note above and the orders passed by the L.A. Court and the Executing
Court on different occasions including the present one as also the order
passed by this Court in CRP No.61 of 2022, this Court is of the view that the
instant petition can be disposed of with a direction upon the Executing Court
to consider and take a decision on the issue of due execution of the award
taking into account also the computation prepared under the signature of
Land Acquisition Officer and Land Acquisition Collector, West Tripura,
Agartala already submitted by the judgment-debtor dated 19.03.2021
reckoning the date of possession as 23.12.2010 and after hearing the parties
on this issue. Let it be made clear that the Court has not expressed any
opinion on the issue of satisfaction of the award by the judgment-debtor and
observations if any made hereinabove are only intended to effectively ensure
that the Executing Court takes a firm decision in a timeframe after hearing
the parties and taking into account the materials already on record as regards
the proper execution of the award in question.
[9]
The instant petition is disposed of with the aforesaid
observations. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
Dipesh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review