Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010175392025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4534/2025
AFRUJA BEGUM @ AFRUZA BEGUM @ AFRUZA KHATUN
D/O ADADUL HOQUE @ AZADUL HOQUE, W/O NUR ALOM @ NOOR ALOM
@ NUR ALAM ISLAM, VILL- KALOGHAT (THAKURANBARI), P.O. AND P.S.MANKACHAR, DIST- SOUTH SALMARA MANKACHAR, ASSAM, PIN-783131
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 6 ORS.
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
DEPARTMENT OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW DELHI, INDIA
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF
ASSAM
DEPARTMENT OF HOME
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
3:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
SOUTH SALMARA MANKACHAR
ASSAM
4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
DHUBRI
ASSAM
5:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NIRVACHAN SADAN
ASHOKA ROAD
NEW DELHI
Page No.# 2/11
6:THE NATIONAL REGISTER OF CITIZEN
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE STATE CO-ORDINATOR
ACHYUT PLAZA
BHANGAGARH
KAMRUP (M)
ASSAM
7:DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
SOUTH SALMARA MANKACHAR
P.O. AND P.S.- HATSINGIMARI
DIST- SOUTH SALMARA MANKACHAR
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A Z AHMED,
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., SC, NRC,SC, F.T,SC, ECI,GA, ASSAM
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
ORDER
Date : 20-01-2026
(K.R. Surana, J)
Heard Mr. A.Z. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner as well as Mr. J.
Payeng, learned standing counsel for the FT, Ms. K. Bhattacharyya, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of Ms. S. Katakey, learned standing counsel for the
ECI, Mr. D.J. Das, learned CGC, Mr. G. Sarma, learned standing counsel for the
NRC and Mr. H.K. Hazarika, learned Junior Govt. Advocate.
2.
By filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner has assailed the opinion dated 16.04.2024 passed by the
learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal, South Salmara at Hatsingimari, in F.T.
Case No.585/18, arising out of Ref. F.T. Case No.651/MKCR/10 and F.T. Case No.
256/2018, arising out of Ref. F.T. Case No. 372/MKCR/10. By the said opinion,
Page No.# 3/11
the petitioner was declared to be a foreigner who had entered illegally into India
(Assam) on or after 25.03.1971.
3.
From visit of notice of the proceedings, the petitioner had filed her
written statement in F.T. Case No.585/2018, amalgamated with F.T. Case
No.256/2018, amongst others, claiming that she is the daughter of Adadul
Hoque @ Azadul Hoque (father) and Osefa Khatun (mother) and granddaughter
of Asmatullah. Her grandfather had 2 (two) sons, namely Adadul Hoque and
Giyasul Hoque. Her father had 3 (three) wives, namely Gulesthan Banu, Osefa
Khatun and Fatema Khatun. She has 8 (eight) brothers and sisters, namely
Gulzar Hussain, Anjura Begum, Aktar Banu Begum, Rubel Miah, Arjuara Begum,
Rofik Miah, Alima Begum and Fojlur Rahman. In the year 1995, she was married
to Nur Alom and shifted to her matrimonial home at Village 1 No. Sahapara
under Mankachar Police Station under the erstwhile Dhubri district and after a
year her husband shifted his residence to Kaloghat under Thakuranbari Gaon
Panchayat on their inherited land and since then they have been living there.
She has been blessed with 5 (five) sons and daughters. The petitioner claims
that the name of her father has been recorded in the Electoral Roll of 1960 and
in 1966 the name of her father was recorded along with her step mother
Gulesthan Banu and her paternal uncle Giyasul Hoque. The name of her father
appears in the Electoral Roll of 1977 along with her above named stepmother as
well as Osefa Khatun, her own mother. The name of her father also appeared in
the Electoral Roll of 1997 and 2017 along with petitioner’s other stepmother
namely Fatema Khatun. Her father also has an EPIC issued by the Electoral
Registration Officer. The petitioner has also referred to a Panchayat Relation
Certificate dated 05.07.2015 issued by the Secretary, Jhograrchar Gaon
Panchayat. To refer to her inheritance of land, the petitioner has relied on the
Page No.# 4/11
copy of Chitha, Electronic as well as Manual and the Land Holding Certificate.
The petitioner also claims that the names Afruja Begum, Afruza Begum and
Afruza Khatun are her names and that her grandfather used to write his name
as Asmat Ullah, but in the Electoral Roll of 1966 and 1977, his name is recorded
as Asmatullah. Similarly, her father appears as Adadul Hoque in all the relevant
documents and papers such as Electoral Roll of 1960, 1977, 1997, 2008, 2017
and his EPIC but in Electoral Roll of 1966 his name appears as Azadul Hoque.
The petitioner also claims that her stepmother, Gulesthan Banu is known by
three aliases (i.e. Golesthan Banu, Golisthan Banu and Gulisthan Banu) and her
husband is also known by three other aliases (i.e. Nur Alom, Noor Alom, Nur
Alam).
4.
In support of her defence, the petitioner has examined herself as DW-
1 and she has also examined her father as DW-2 and the Lat Mandal of
Mankachar Circle was examined as DW-3 and one Abdur Hafizur Rahman, the
Secretary of Jograrchar Gaon Panchayat as DW-4.
5.
The petitioner, by reiterating the statement made in the written
statement has exhibited the following documents (1) Voter List of 1960 (Ext.1),
(2) Voter List of 1966 (Ext.2), (3) Voter List of 1977 (Ext.3), (4) Voter List of
1997 (Ext.4), (5) Voter List of 2008 (Ext.5), (6) Voter ID Card (Ext.6), (7) Voter
List of 2017 (Ext.7), (8) Panchayat Relation Certificate (Ext.8), (9) Manual
Chitha Copy (Ext.9), (10) Computerized Chitha Copy (Ext.9), (11) Land Holding
Certificate (Ext.10), (12) Affidavit (Ext.11), (13) Affidavit dated 27.10.2021 to
explain discrepancy in the name (Ext.12), (14) Notice to DW-4 (Ext.17), (15)
Notice to DW-3 (Ext.13), (16) Authorization letter (Ext.14), (17) Original Chitha
Book (Ext.15), (18) Concerned page of Draft Chitha (Ext.16).
Page No.# 5/11
6.
All the said four witnesses have been cross-examined and discharged.
7.
The learned Tribunal, after appreciating the pleadings and evidence
found that the main document of the petitioner to connect her to her projected
father where the Gaon Panchyat Certificate dated 05.07.2015 (Ext.8), the
certified copy of the Manual Chitha (Ext.9) and Computerized Chitha copy
(Ext.10) and the Land Holding Certificate dated 10.05.2012 (Ext.11). In so far
as Ext.8 is concerned, the said DW-4 stated that he had no personal knowledge
about the petitioner as he did not issue the certificate. He further disclosed that
he had not found the Certificate Book as well as Registered Book of Ext.8 and
that the said Certificate was issued on the basis of application dated 05.07.2015
by Adadul Hoque and that he could not identify the signature of the Block
Development Officer appearing in the said certificate. In respect of Ext.9, 10
and 11, DW-3 in his cross-examination has stated that Ext.16 was prepared
after 1980 and that the name of Asmatullah, co-pattadar No.4 was recorded in
the Chitha, but there was no remarks regarding his entry in the records of rights
and no mutation case was registered and it is also not mentioned whether the
names of co-pattadar from Sl. No. 8 to 17 had been recorded as per the law of
inheritance or other reasons. It may also be stated that mutation of the name of
the petitioner was done on 13.08.2019 and it could not be said how the name
of the petitioner was recorded as one of the Pattadars and that there is no note
in respect of inclusion of their entry. Accordingly, the learned Tribunal did not
find the link of the petitioner with her projected father on the basis of Ext.9,
Ext.10 and Ext.11. and those documents were held to be untrustworthy and not
acceptable. In respect of the Electoral Rolls which were exhibited as Ext.1 to
Ext.5 and Ext.7. Ext.4, Ext.5 and Ext.7 disclosed the name of the projected
father as well as two projected stepmothers and accordingly the learned
Page No.# 6/11
Tribunal arrived at a conclusion that the documents did not show any linkage of
the petitioner with her projected father. The EPIC (Ext.6) was discarded for
being not proved in accordance with law. The learned Tribunal recorded the
disclosures
made
by
DW-2
in
his
cross-examination
and
as
several
contradictions came out of the said cross-examination, including the identity of
the mother of the petitioner remaining unsolved, the evidence of the DW-2 was
found to be insufficient and not trustworthy to prove that the petitioner was a
citizen of India or that she is the daughter of Adadul Hoque.
8.
Resultantly, the learned Tribunal held that the petitioner was unable
to discharge her burden to prove that she was born out of genuine Indian
parents and had acquired citizenship of India. Resultantly, the case was
disposed of upon contest by answering the reference in the affirmative on the
prayer that the petitioner to be a foreigner of post-stream 25.03.1971.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to the documents
annexed to the writ petition to project that the evidence of the petitioner was
discarded merely because of some discrepancies in the names of the petitioner’s
projected father, grandfather and mother ignoring the evidence on record. It is
submitted that the petitioner and her father are illiterate and that the father of
the petitioner, being a senior citizen of more than 83 years had made some
inadvertent mistake in answering the queries put to them; yet, the evidence of
the petitioner remained unshaken to show that she is the daughter of Adadul
Hoque and the granddaughter of Asmatullah.
10.
It is stated that after the hearing proceeded for about 35 minutes, the
learned counsel for the petitioner had made a submission to fix the matter for a
final hearing on another date as he was not fully prepared and he was only
Page No.# 7/11
prepared to argue on the prayer for interim bail for the petitioner. However, as
the Court had already spent about 35 minutes of time in hearing the learned
counsel for the petitioner, the said prayer was rejected and the Court proceeded
with the matter, moreso, because in the course of his submissions, the learned
counsel for the petitioner had entered into the merits and had referred to all the
documents exhibited by the petitioner before the learned Tribunal. Therefore,
having spent considerable time in hearing the matter, the prayer for
adjournment or deferment of the hearing to another date was refused and the
Court had proceeded to hear and dispose of the matter on merit.
11.
Per contra, the learned standing counsel for the FT matters has
opposed any interference with the impugned opinion and has made his
submission in the impugned opinion and in connection with the proof of the
documents and contents, specifically with regard to the Gaon Pachayat
Certificate. The learned standing counsel for the FT matters has referred to the
case of Rupajan Begum v State of Assam and ors., (2018) 1 SCC 579. It is
submitted that in the said case, the Supreme Court of India laid down the law to
the effect that the Gaon Panchayat Certificate was only to establish the shifting
of a married woman to the place of residence of her husband. However, it was
made clear that the said document is not proof of citizenship and that in order
to prove the said certificate, it was the onus was on part of the petitioner to
prove the authenticity of the said Certificate as well as the authenticity of the
evidence of the Certificate. Accordingly, it is submitted that as the Gaon
Panchayat Certificate was not proved by bringing the original records and that
the gift of land was not proved in accordance with law, there was no merit in
Page No.# 8/11
the defence of the petitioner. In the written statement and the evidence-onaffidavit, the petitioner claims Osefa to be her mother. However, in her crossexamination she stated that her mother is Gulisthan Banu. The father of the
petitioner, in his cross-examination, stated that Gulesthan Bibi is not her mother
but her mother is Osepha.
12.
In the present case in hand, in her cross examination the petitioner
has stated that she has not submitted any documents in her own name to
defend her case and that she had submitted the land documents and the
Panchayat documents in the name of her father. She stated that her father had
applied for a Panchayat certificate but she did not know when the same was
brought from the office. She had restated that the name of her mother is
Gulisthan Banu and that her mother has 7 sons and daughters and that Fatema
Khatun is her stepmother who has only one son. In contradiction to the stand
taken by the DW-1 in her evidence-on-affidavit, written statement as well as
cross-examination, the projected father of the petitioner, appearing as DW-2,
made a positive statement that Gulisthan Bibi is not the own mother of the
petitioner and that Osepha is the name of the mother of the petitioner. He
stated that he did not remember when he gifted his portion of land to his
daughter along with the brothers and sisters. If the projected father of the
petitioner has gifted his portion of land to the petitioner, in the absence of any
entry in the chitha, it cannot be said that the father of the petitioner had title
over the land during the time of gift, as the gift is an unregistered gift and in
the absence of any entry as to the date of gift, the entries made in the draft
chitha, in the opinion of the Court, being only a document in “draft” stage, has
not attained finality and thus, would not prove or establish that the petitioner is
the daughter of Adadul Hoque, DW-2. DW-2, who is the father of the petitioner,
Page No.# 9/11
categorically stated in his cross-examination that Gulisthan Bibi is not the own
mother of the petitioner but her mother is Osepha. The evidence of the
petitioner to the effect that her mother is Gulesthan Bibi is contrary to that of
her projected father. It is hard to believe that a father would forget who had
given birth to his daughter. It may be mentioned that in the cross-examination,
DW-2 had forgotten who was the mother of the petitioner, but in course of
cross-examination he remembered that Osepha is the mother of the petitioner.
Therefore, firstly, the land which has been recorded in the name of the
petitioner in the “Draft Chitha” was not by way of inheritance and therefore,
does not prove that the petitioner is the daughter of the person projected as her
father. As far as the evidence of DW-3 is concerned, who is the Lat Mandal,
stated that there were no remarks of any entry in the records with regard to the
co-pattadar No.4 namely, Asmatullah. Therefore, there is a disruption in the link
of the petitioner with her projected grandfather. The said DW-3 had
categorically stated that there is no mention as to whether the names of copattadar Nos.8 to 17 have been recorded in the law of inheritance. Therefore,
on a date when the order of mutation was passed and recorded in the “draft
chitha”, the father of the petitioner did not have any existing right over the land,
but when in the cross-examination DW-2 stated that he had gifted his portion of
land to his daughter on the date when the order was passed, the projected
father of the petitioner merely had a contingent right over the land. However,
the Court hastens to state here that it is not deciding on the issue of right, title
and interest of the petitioner over the land in question. The discussion is only
limited to finding out as to whether the petitioner has been able to link herself
with her projected father and grandfather. It is in this regard that the Court is
inclined to hold that the petitioner has failed to establish the same.
Page No.# 10/11
13.
In so far as the evidence of DW-4 is concerned, in his cross-
examination he has categorically stated that he did not find the Certificate Book
as well as the Register Book of Ext.8. Therefore, the Gaon Panchayat Certificate
(Ext.8) is found to be not in accordance with law, which requires production of
the original record. Moreover, the said witness could not identify the signature
appearing in the said Certificate.
14.
Resultantly, owing to the discrepancy in the name of the mother of the
petitioner as well as the lack of direct evidence to show that the petitioner is the
daughter of DW-2, the evidence of DW-2 as projected father does not inspire
confidence with regard to the proof of relationship between the petitioner and
DW-2 as daughter and father respectively.
15.
The DW-2 claims Osepha to be the mother of the petitioner, whose
name appears in the Voter list of 1977. However, it may be mentioned that only
in the cross-examination of the DW-1, the petitioner disclosed her age to be 41
years, which was never disclosed in the written statement or evidence-onaffidavit. The said cross-examination to place on 04.01.2022. Therefore, the
petitioner was born between 1980 and 1981. But the existence of her projected
mother, as stated by the DW-2, had no existence beyond the Voter list of 1977.
16.
Accordingly, the pleadings, evidence and exhibited documents Nos.1 to
17 have failed to establish that the petitioner is a citizen of India and was born
out of Indian parents.
17.
Resultantly, the challenge to the impugned opinion dated opinion dated
16.04.2024 passed in F.T. Case No.585/18, arising out of Ref. F.T. Case
No.651/MKCR/10 and F.T. Case No. 256/2018, arising out of Ref. F.T. Case
Page No.# 11/11
No.372/MKCR/10 fails. The consequences of the said opinion shall follow.
18.
The writ petition stands dismissed.
19.
The Registry shall send back the records of FT Case No.585/2018 and
FT Case No.256/2018 to the learned Tribunal along with a copy of the order to
be made a part of the said learned Tribunal.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review