Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 427 of 2022
Date of Decision: 05.05.2023
Adarsh Saraswati Mahila Shiksha
and Gramin Vikas Samiti
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. F. Hasan, Adv.
Ms. M. Rahman, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Sahay, Adv. with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner, a registered society engaged in the
implementation of Jal Jeevan Mission activities is before this Court,
challenging the impugned termination notice dated 27.09.2022, issued
by the respondent No. 2, terminating the letter of award dated
01.07.2021, issued to the petitioner as an Implementation Support
Agency, under Jal Jeevan Mission, Meghalaya.
2.
Mr. F. Hasan, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that,
the petitioner was awarded contract for 5 (five) districts, and though the
schedule of completion of the works was adhered to, with regard to
Phase I of the project, the respondent No. 2, vide letter dated
02.07.2022, had communicated that the petitioner had failed to
complete the works within the stipulated time period and had directed
the petitioner to complete the Phase I activities within 15 (fifteen) days
from the date of issuance of the said letter. He further submits that, the
works of the petitioner was completed, as per the requirement of the
respondents, but however, the respondents cancelled the work awarded
to the petitioner, on the pretext of failure to complete the project within
the stipulated timeframe.
3.
Learned counsel submits that the impugned order is a non-
speaking order because it does not give a complete picture, with regard
to the basis of cancellation, nor does it reveal the reasons as to why the
respondents have arrived at a decision to cancel the contract. It is
submitted that, the impugned order being a non-speaking order is
unsustainable in law, and being arbitrary, is violative of the
fundamental rights. Referring to the affidavit filed by the State
respondents, the learned counsel submits that, wild allegations have
been made against the petitioner regarding corrupt practices, such as,
offering of bribe to the District Project Manager, which allegation
however, does not find place, or mentioned in the impugned order. The
learned counsel, has then taken this Court to the terms of reference
contained in the document dealing with selection of Implementation
Support Agencies (ISA) under Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM), and submits
that, it is given therein that the empanelment is valid for 3 (three) years,
which can be extended depending on the requirement of the services,
and that for new schemes, each ISA would be responsible for the entire
project circle of maximum 18 (eighteen) months to 40-60 villages at a
time.
4.
The learned counsel then submits that as per the agreement,
the work is to be completed within 18 (eighteen) months subject to
extension, in four phases, that is, pre planning phase, planning phase,
implementation phase and O & M Phase, which includes testing and
trial runs, handing over of schemes etc. He submits that, each phase
was required to be completed within the time allotted for each phase,
namely Phase I – (2 months), Phase II – (3 months), Phase III – (10
months) and Phase IV - (3 months). It is further submitted that, upon
submission of Phase – I report, the District Authorities had conducted
field verification on the Phase – I deliverables and recommended
release of bills of the petitioner, but that before the said payment could
be released to the petitioner, the termination order was issued.
Thereafter, he submits representations were filed requesting for
revocation of the termination order, and for release of the payment for
the Phase – I work, and it is contended that, the petitioner had already
completed 100% of the Phase – I work; and for other ISA’s under Jal
Jeevan Mission, time was extended for implementation of the work.
5.
The learned counsel submits that, Para – 18 of the terms and
conditions prescribes the penalty (Liquidated Damages) for noncompletion of works within the timeframe. It is submitted that, the right
to terminate the contract would arise only when there was failure to
complete the whole work after 10 (ten) weeks from the actual date of
completion. In the petitioner’s case, he submits the actual date of
completion as per the agreement dated 08.07.2021, would expire on
January, 2023, and as such, the termination of the contract by the
respondent No. 2, before the expiry of such time is arbitrary and illegal.
It is has been contended that, hostile discrimination has been shown
towards the petitioner, as different treatment has been given to other
similarly situated societies, who are also carrying on the same nature of
work on the same conditions. He lastly submits that, the respondents
cancelled the contract, without affording the petitioner opportunity to
show cause or to be heard, and as such, for the violation of Natural
Justice, the impugned cancellation order is liable to be set aside and
quashed.
6.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel for the State respondents has
submitted in reply, that the writ petition should be dismissed at the
threshold itself, as the writ petitioner has come before this Court with
unclean hands. The petitioner, he submits has not placed the entire
correct facts before this Court, and has even indulged in corrupt
practices and offered bribes to the District Project Manager, Jal Jeevan
Mission, in course of the execution of the project works, which form
the subject matter of the instant proceedings. He further submits, the
action of the petitioner has resulted in the initiation of criminal
proceedings, for which an FIR has been registered before the
Superintendent of Police, South West Garo Hills on 20.10.2022. The
concealment of this fact before this Court he submits, amounts to the
commission of fraud on this Court, as this Court was persuaded to pass
orders, whereby the respondents have been restrained from awarding
the pending contract works, if the same has not already been allotted to
others.
7.
Learned counsel submits that, the documents filed by the
petitioner are selective, with a view to mislead this Court, to prevent it
from examining the true and correct facts of the case. He submits,
copies of complaints received between November and December, 2021,
on account of unsatisfactory work have not been placed, nor has the
default of the petitioner in attending to follow up meetings to review
the progress of work been disclosed. It is submitted that, the petitioner
also has failed to disclose that on 18.01.2022, a show cause had been
issued for slow progress of work, and the admission of the petitioner to
the delays, by letter dated 21.01.2022. The instances of further
concealment, have been narrated by the learned counsel, who submits
that, the concealment by the petitioner is with a view to fraudulently
mislead this Court, to exercise jurisdiction in favour of the petitioner
which the facts of the case, do not otherwise warrant.
8.
It has been contended by the learned counsel that, the
petitioner has failed to disclose the existence of any enforceable right in
its favour, and there being no violation of any right, the prayer of the
writ petitioner is unsustainable. It is further submitted that, the writ
petition has been filed in a matter arising out of a contract, and it is a
well settled principle that, where the relationship is governed purely in
terms of a contract between the parties, the same is in the realm of
private law, and no writ would lie in such matters. Learned counsel
submits that, as per the settled position of law, Courts shall refuse to
exercise its writ jurisdiction in such matters, especially if there is no
element of public law, the presence of a particular mode of settlement
provided in the contract, the presence of serious disputed questions of
fact and money claims, aspects which have been consistently reiterated
in various judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
9.
It has been further submitted that the writ petition is also
unsustainable on merits, as the first relief prayed for is of specific
performance after the termination has already taken place, the second
relief prayed for extension of time, will amount to altering the terms of
the contract, and the final relief prayed for release of payments which
have not been made on account of numerous reasons, such as,
incomplete bills, vouchers, etc., which are yet to be verified, is also
unsustainable. In conclusion, learned counsel submits that, even
otherwise, as per clause 18 of the agreement, the same was liable to be
terminated, as the work of Phase I itself, was delayed beyond 10 (ten)
weeks, of the 2 (two) months period allowed, and the writ petition apart
from not being maintainable, has not disclosed any enforceable legal
right. As such he submits, the same should be dismissed with heavy
costs for concealment of correct facts and for approaching this Court
with unclean hands.
10.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties, an examination
of the nature of dispute raised by the writ petition, and in consideration
of the objections as to maintainability of the writ petition put forward
by the respondents, this Court deems it necessary to first address the
matter on the point of maintainability.
11.
The relationship of the parties, it is noted is governed purely
by a contract and the terms contained therein (Annexure – 2 to the writ
petition), which was entered into by the petitioner and the respondent
No. 2 on 08.07.2021 (Annexure – 4 to the writ petition). A perusal of
the terms and conditions and the agreement dated 08.07.2021, leaves no
room for doubt that the writ petitioner had agreed and undertaken to
perform and fulfill all the operations and obligations with the execution
of the said contract, as per the terms and conditions contained in the
Empanelment of Implementation Support Agencies for Support
Activities under the Jal Jeevan Mission in the State of Meghalaya. The
terms and conditions contained in the said document have clearly
provided for the details, such as, the scope of work, its commencement,
period allowed for completion of contract, jurisdiction with regard to
disputes, if any, and also for penalty (Liquidated Damage) if the
progress of work is not found satisfactory.
12.
As the relationship is governed purely in terms of the contract
as discussed above, in such cases contractual obligations are therefore
matters of private law and a writ would not lie to enforce any civil
liability arising out of such contracts. The instant case is also not a case
of enforcement of a statutory contract just because it is for construction
of a public utility, as can be discerned from the terms and conditions of
the contract. Without referring to any particular decision, but from the
various judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, down the years, the
law is well settled that in pure contractual matters, extra ordinary
jurisdiction under Article 226 is not invoked, unless exceptional
circumstances are present, which might come into the realm of public
law, which is clearly not the situation in the present case.
13.
The writ petitioner has also raised questions of disputed facts
in the form of bills that have been claimed, which are yet to be verified
and subject to the extent of work completed, which disputes formed the
basis of the termination of the contract. The correctness of the
termination therefore, having to be adjudged against these factors, the
dispute cannot be resolved or adjudicated in a writ proceeding such as
the present one.
14.
On the other aspects, this Court finds force in the submission
of the respondents that, the writ petition is unsustainable on merits, as
relief of specific performance is being sought after the termination of
the agreement, apart from the writ petitioner seeking extension of the
stipulated time for execution of the contract, as this will amount to
altering the terms thereof.
15.
The allegation of the petitioner that the termination order is
non-speaking and that, adequate opportunity was not afforded before
terminating the contract deserves no consideration, as the writ
petitioner has not demonstrated any enforceable right, or any violation
thereof, to warrant any interference in exercise of powers under Article
226 of the Constitution.
16.
Without delving into the other contentions and the events that
have been put forward by the respondents such as, the charges of
corrupt practices, the institution of criminal cases, and other documents
illustrating the breach of agreement and the default of the writ
petitioner in the execution of the contract, this writ petition fails on the
ground of maintainability itself.
17.
Accordingly, for the foregoing reasons and discussions, this
writ petition stands dismissed and disposed of.
18.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
05.05.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review