The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. ln view of the aforementioned facts and circumstances and having regard to the well-settled principles of law enunciated by the Honourable Supreme Court in the decision referred supra, this Court is of the considered view that the essential ingredients necessary to constitute the offence under Section 420 of IPC are not made out against the petitioner-accused No.2. Hence, the continuation of the criminal proceedings against the petitioner-accused No.2 amounts to abuse of process of law and the same are liable to be quashed
13. Accordingly, this Criminal Petition is allowed and the criminal proceedings against the petitioner-accused No.2 in C.C.No.627 of 2018 (old C.C.No.45 of 2013) on the file of -11 the learned I Additional Judicial First Class lr, agistrate at Kothagudem, are hereby quashed As a sequel, pending miscellaneous a1t tlications, rf I any, shall stand closed SD/- T C.SULEKHA DEVI ASSIIJ;ANT REGISTRAR I/TRUE COPY// f \ To, at Kothag rdem The lAdditional Judicial First Class Magistrate' I Town Poli; : Station' Khammam 2 The Station House Officer , Kothagudem District for the I ate of Telangana' at Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court Hyderabad. (OUT) Advcc :te IOPUC] One CC to SRl. V- SATYANARAYANA PRASAD' One CC to Sri P.ANlMlREDDY,Advocate [OPUC] 6 Two CD CoPies J KUT,/PSi I DATED: 2010212026 CRLP.No.7533 ot 2024 J Lqt ( * 1L -h 'i ,) ?l f n Dc s I ,\TcY llll 1a l\) ( |J _|s *
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 7533 OF 2024
Between:
Adapa Rama Krishna, S/o Venkateswarlu, aged about 59 years, R/o. H.No.
12-7 -124, Ganeswara Rao Street, Kothapet, Guntur Occ. Business.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED No.2
AND
, The State of Telangana, through its Station House Officer, I Town P.S.,
Khammam District, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High Court of Telangana,
Hyderabad.
2. Bhukya Balu, S/o. Ramulu, aged about 65 years, R/o. Annaram Thanda,
Chandrugonda [\4andal, Khammam District, Occ. Farmer.
...RESPONDENT/ DEFACTO COMPLAINANT
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances stated in
the [Vlemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
call for the records, relating to C.C. No. 627 of 2018, on the file of the Court of the
I Additional Judicial lt/agistrate of First Class, Kothagudem and quash the same
against the petitioner/Accused No.2, in the interest of justice.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 482 oI Cr.P .C praying that in the circumstances stated in
the lVlemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay of all further proceedings in C.C. No 627 of 2018, on the file of the I Additional
Judicial [\/agistrate of First Class, Kothagudem, including the appearance of the
petitioner/Accused No.2, pendrng disposal of the above Criminal Petition.
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of Grounds
of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri VAJJHALA
SATYANARAYANA PRASAD Advocate for the Petitioner and Sri [vl.
RAIMACHANDRA REDDY, Addl. Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondent
No 1 and of Sri P. ANIMI REDDY, Advocate for the Respondent No. 2
The Court made the following ORDER :
--
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF *:LANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE JUVVP,I)I SRIDEVI
CRIM!NAL PET]TION No.7533 OF 1t t24
DATEDS#FEBRUARY 2026
Between
Adapa Rama Krishna
... Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana represented
by Public Prosecutor and one another
Respondents
ORDER
This Criminal Petition is filed by the pet I oner-accused
No.2 seeking to quash the proceedings a yainst him in
CC.No.627 of 2018 (oldC.C.No.45of 2013)or,thefileof the
learned I Additional Judicial First Class \4agistrate at
Kothagudem, registered for the offence under ]ection 42O of
the lndian Penal Code (for short 'lpC')
02 Heard Sri V. Satyanarayana Fr rsad, learned
counsel for the petitioner-accused; Sri M Ramachandra
Reddy, learned Additional public prosecutc,r for the State
and Sri P. Animi Reddy, learned counsel for the respondent
No.2 Perused the material on record.
03. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the
petitioner-accused No.2, along with the accused No.'l
,
allegedly started a business in the name and style of Amar
Cotton Oil Mills Private Limited at Guntur. lt is alleged that,
in connection with the said business, the accused persons
used to purchase cotton from farmers and traders in
Chandrugonda and Kothagudem Mandals. lt is the further
alleged that during the year 2009, the accused persons
purchased cotton from LW1 to LW1 1 and issued sixteen
cheques on different dates towards payment of the sale
consideration amounting to Rs.1 ,1 1 ,31 ,000/-. lt is alleged
that on 28.08.2009, when the respondent No 2 approached
the bank for withdrawal of the cheque amount, the bank
authorities, after verifying the account, issued a certificate
stating that there were insufficient funds in the account of the
account holder. lt is further alleged that some of the other
alleged victims also approached the said bank and faced a
similar situation with regard to dishonour of the cheques
issued to them. Hence, the respondent N:2 lodged a
complaint against the accused persons for the c ffence under
Section 42O of IPC
04 Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner-accused No.2 is nothing to do wl r the alleged
offence. lt is contended that no dishonest rr fraudulent
intention can be attributed to the petitioner-::cused No.2
from the inception of the transaction. All t-: allegations
leveled against the petitioner-accused No ll are civil in
nature. lt is further submitted that there is n,: incriminating
material on record to substantiate the allel ations made
against the petitioner-accused. The responderr No.2 instead
of filing the case under Section 138 of il-: Negotiable
lnstruments Act, filed the present false case rnder Section
420 of IPC The respondent No.2 did not arra) the company
as accused The dispute, if any, is purely civi n nature, and
the respondent No.2 is attempting to give a cr r rinal colour to
a civil dispute. lt is further submitted that I is Court vide
Order dated 13.07.2022 passed in CRL.p.No 2066 of 2013
quashed the proceedings against the accused No.1. The
contents of the charge sheet do not disclose the necessary
and essential ingredients required to constitute the offence
under Section 420 of the IPC
05. With the above submissions, learned counsel for
the petitioner-accused while praying for the quashment of
criminal proceedings relied upon a decision of the
Honourable Supreme Court in Sripati Singh (since
deceased) through his son Gaurav Singh v. The State of
Jharkhand and anothe/, wherein it was held at Paragraph
Nos.'11,12&22lhal'.
"!!. ln the background of what has been taken note
by us and the conclusion reached by the High Court,
insofar as the High Coud aniving at the conclusion
that no case punishable under Section 420 IPC can
be made out in these facts, we are in agreement with
such conclusion. Ihls is due to the fact that even as
per the case of the appellant the amount advanced by
the appellant is towards lhe buslness transaction and
a loan agreement had been entered into between the
parties. lJnder the loan agreement, the peiod for
repayment was agreed and the cheque had been
lssued fo ensure repayment. lt is no doubt true that
the cheques when presented for realisation were
Criminal Appeat Nos.1269-1270 of 2021 (Arrsing out of SLP(Criminal) No.252-253n020
-v
dishonoured. The mere dishonourment of the cl\ que
cannot be construed as an act on the paft oi the
respondent No.2 with a deliberate intention to c teat
and the mens rea in that regard cannot be gat red
from the point the amount had been received. tt the
present facts and circumstances. there is no sulrt :ient
evidence to indicate the offence under Sectiol 420
IPC is made out and therefore on that aspect, A.( see
no reason to inteiere with the conclusion react t d by
the High Courl.
12. Having arrived at the above conclusion an: also
having taken note of the conclusion reached t r the
High Courl as extracted above, it is noted thz I the
High Courl has itself arrived at the conclusion flt ,t the
instant case becomes a simpliciter case o, nonrefunding of loan which cannot be a basis for init ating
criminal proceedings. The conclusion to the ext ,nt of
holding that it would not constitute an offe t :e of
cheating, as already indicated above wout I be
justified. However, when the High Couft ltsr;, . has
accepted the fact that it is a case of non refunc ng of
the loan amount, the first aspect that there is a t >gatty
recoverable debt from the respondent No.2 , t the
appellant is primafacie estabtished. The onty q t >stion
that therefore needs consideration at our hanct: is as
to whether the contention putforth on be\ ilf of
respondent No.2 that an offence under Sectior, ,3g of
the N.l. Act is not made out as the dishonct. rment
alleged is of the cheques which were issuect L r way
of 'security' and not towards discharge of any c,t bt.
22. These aspects would primafacie indicate that
there was a transaction between the parties towards
which a legally recoverable debt was claimed by the
appellant and the cheque issued by the respondent
No.2 was presented. On such cheque being
dishonoured, cause of action had aisen for issuing a
notice and presenting the criminal complaint under
Sectlon 138 of N.l. Act on the payment not being
made. The further defence as to whether the loan had
been discharged as agreed by respondent No.2 and
in that circumstance the cheque which had been
issued as security had not remained live for payment
subsequent thereto etc. at best can be a defence for
the respondent No.2 to be put forth and to be
established in the tnal. ln any event, it was not a case
for the Coui to either refuse to take cognizance or to
discharge the respondent No.2 in the manner it has
been done by the High Court. Therefore, though a
criminal complaint under Section 420 IPC was not
sustainable in the facts and circumstances of the
instant case, the complaint under section 138 of the
N.l Act was maintainable and all contentions and the
defence were to be considered duing the course of
the trial."
06. On the other hand, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor appearing for the State-respondent No.1 as well
as the learned counsel for the respondent No.2 contended
that there are triable issues and factual aspects to be
examined by the learned trial Court and it is nr t a fit case to
quash the proceedings against the petitioner
: this juncture
and the matter is to be decided after conducli rg trial by the
learned trial Court and prayed to dismiss this Criminal
Petition
07. ln order to attract the provisions of iection 42O of
the lPC, it is a well-settled principle of law tt at there must
exist a dishonest or fraudulent intention ir deceive the
complainant right from the very inception of .l e transaction
Mere failure to fulfil a promise or mere non-rr: tayment of an
amount, in the absence of such initial dish:rest intention
would not constitute the offence of cheatitg punishable
under Section 420 of IPC
08. A careful perusal of the materie I available on
record demonstrates that the dispute essentiil ly arises out of
business transactions relating to purchase of cotton and
issuance of cheques towards payment. Er:n as per the
prosecution case, the gravamen of the allegz tion is that the
cheques issued towards payment were dislr noured due to
n'/
-)'
B
insufficiency of funds. Such allegations, in the absence of
specific material indicating fraudulent or dishonest intention
from the inception of the transaction, would at best give rise
to civil liability or proceedings under the Negotiable
lnstruments Act, but would not satisfy the essential
ingredients required to constitute the offence of cheating
under Section 420 of IPC
09. lt is also relevant to note that the company,
through which the alleged business transactions were carried
out, was not arrayed as an accused in the present case. ln
the absence of arraigning the company, and in the absence
of specific and clear allegations demonstrating the individual
role and culpable intention of the petitioner-accused No.2,
continuation of criminal proceedings against the petitioner
would amount to abuse of process of law
10. lt is further pertinent to note that the investigation
conducted after registration of the FIR and prior to filing of
the charge sheet constitutes a crucial stage in criminal
proceedings. The charge sheet is expected to reflect the
I
outcome of such investigation and must be s upported by
material evidence sufficient to prima facie r stablish the
alleged offences. However, in the pres€ r t case, to
substantiate the basic allegations against tf
= petitioner-
accused, no independent witness has been exil nined by the
lnvestigating Officer. Out of the nineteen witne sses cited in
the charge sheet, eleven are complainants and alleged
victims, two are panch witnesses for CDF prc< eedings, two
are panch witnesses for the alleged confessiorr rl statements
of the accused, and the remaining four are p rlice officials
Thus, there is no independent corroborativt: evidence to
support the prosecution verston against 1t e petitioneraccused No 2
11. The entire set of allegations revoh,, 's around the
alleged failure of the accused to repay the ar rounts due to
the complainant and other alleged victims lt is also an
admitted fact that the cheques were issued by 1 re accused in
favour of the complainant and others, whir: I prima facie
indicates that the accused had intended t
honour the
payments. lssuance of cheques, by itselt, indicates an
intention to discharge liability, which is against the allegation
of fraudulent intention at the inception of the transaction. As
the cheques were dishonoured, the complainant and other
alleged victims had a statutory remedy under the provisions
of the Negotiable lnstruments Act
12. ln view of the aforementioned facts and
circumstances and having regard to the well-settled
principles of law enunciated by the Honourable Supreme
Court in the decision referred supra, this Court is of the
considered view that the essential ingredients necessary to
constitute the offence under Section 420 of IPC are not made
out against the petitioner-accused No.2. Hence, the
continuation of the criminal proceedings against the
petitioner-accused No.2 amounts to abuse of process of law
and the same are liable to be quashed
13. Accordingly, this Criminal Petition is allowed and
the criminal proceedings against the petitioner-accused No.2
in C.C.No.627 of 2018 (old C.C.No.45 of 2013) on the file of
-11
the learned I Additional Judicial First Class lr, agistrate at
Kothagudem, are hereby quashed
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous a1t tlications, rf
I
any, shall stand closed
SD/- T C.SULEKHA DEVI
ASSIIJ;ANT REGISTRAR
I/TRUE COPY//
f
\
SECTION OFFICER
To,
at Kothag rdem
The lAdditional Judicial First Class Magistrate'
I Town Poli; : Station' Khammam
2 The Station House Officer , Kothagudem
District
for the I ate of Telangana' at
Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court
Hyderabad. (OUT)
Advcc :te IOPUC]
One CC to SRl. V- SATYANARAYANA PRASAD'
One CC to Sri P.ANlMlREDDY,Advocate [OPUC]
6 Two CD CoPies
J
KUT,/PSi
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2010212026
ORDER
CRLP.No.7533 ot 2024
J Lqt
(
*
1L
-h 'i
,)
?l f
ALLOWING THE CRL.PETITION
n
Dc s I ,\TcY
llll
1a
l\) ( |J
_|s
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review