The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. Accordingly, Crl.A.No.32 of 2022 and Crl.A.No.33 of 2022 are allowed in part by setting aside the judgment and order dated November 14, 2019 insofar as they convicted Ajay and Acquit for having committed murder, but their conviction under Sections 364A and 34 of the Penal Code for the common motive of kidnapping for ransom is affirmed.
20. Accordingly, the punishment under Section 302 is set aside insofar as it relates to the charge under Section 302 of the Penal Code. The conviction under Section 364A read with Section 34 of the Penal Code is upheld.
21. However, since the sentences in respect of the two distinct offences were to run concurrently, notwithstanding the acquittal in respect of the charge under Section 302 of the Penal Code, the sentence of rigorous imprisonment for life together with fine of Rs.1 lakh under Section 364A is sustained. The additional fine of Rs.1 lakh for murder is set aside.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial Nos.01 & 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.A.No.32/2022 with
Crl.A.No.33/2022
Date of order: 28.08.2023
State of Meghalaya
State of Meghalaya
Ajay N. Sangma
Vs.
Acquit R. Marak
Vs.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Mr. M. Sharma, Legal Aid Counsel
For the Respondents
: Mr. K. Khan, AAG with
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl.PP
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
ORDER: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The two appeals are directed against a judgment and the
immediate order of sentencing of November 14, 2019 by which both the
appellants have been convicted under Sections 364A and 302 of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 read with Section 34 thereof.
2.
Appellant Ajay N. Sangma has been sentenced to rigorous
imprisonment for life together with a fine of Rs.1 lakh. In default of
payment of the fine, the convict is to undergo simple imprisonment for a
further year running concurrently with the period of conviction.
3.
Appellant Acquit R. Marak has also been similarly punished for
his role in the matter.
4.
On October 23, 2015, the father of a 16-year-old boy lodged a
complaint with the Pillangkata Police Outpost in Ri-Bhoi district to the
effect that on October 21, 2015 his son went out of their house along
with the appellant in the first matter, who was a resident of Chibra
village, but did not return. The first information report also narrated that
on October 22, 2015 at about 11 am he received a phone call from an
unknown number, 7085686169, demanding a ransom of Rs.10 lakh for
the release of the complainant’s son. The complainant specified that the
callers spoke to the complainant in Garo and Assamese languages and
warned the complainant against reporting the matter to the police.
5.
According to the investigating officer, inquiries revealed that the
appellant in the first matter, Ajay, came looking for the victim on
October 21, 2015 and after the victim came out of his house and spoke
to Ajay for some time, the two of them got into a car and drove away
towards Guwahati. The IO also revealed that he visited the village of
Ajay but discovered that Ajay had not been in the village for several
days. The IO claimed that he had informed the neighbouring police
stations in Assam of the incident so that they could keep a watch out for
both the missing boy and for Ajay.
6.
According to the IO, he received information on October 29,
2015 that Ajay was in a line hotel within the jurisdiction of Krishnai
Police Station in Assam. Upon seeking further information from the
officials at the Krishnai Police Station, the IO came to learn that Ajay
had been rescued from a nearby jungle and brought to a line hotel in
Krishnai on October 27, 2015. Upon the local police personnel
questioning Ajay, Ajay revealed that he was in the jungle with the
missing boy in the morning of October 27, 2015 when they were
attacked by ultras and in their individual bids to escape, they got
separated. According to Ajay he was shot at by an AK-47 as a result
whereof he sustained a bullet tear on his jacket. Ajay claimed that he
pretended to have been hit and lay motionless on the ground, which
prompted his assailants into believing that he had been shot dead.
7.
Tests conducted on the relevant jacket, however, revealed no
residue or trace of any bullet nor was any bullet discovered. The IO
narrated that he led Ajay to some place where the other appellant,
Acquit Marak, was found accidentally and was arrested since Ajay
informed the IO that Acquit used to cook for them while they were in
the jungle with the boy.
8.
Acquit Marak apparently told the IO that he was coerced into
supplying food to all the persons who had kept the boy confined. He
also told the IO that he was subsequently required to stay in the same
jungle and move with the rest of the team since they did not stay put in
one place, lest they be discovered. Acquit claimed that he had nothing
to do with the matter except cooking, though he admitted that he had
seen the victim alive.
9.
It is the further testimony of the IO at the trial that Ajay and
Acquit made contradictory statements as a result whereof both were
questioned together and they confessed that the boy had been killed and
had indicated that they would lead the police to where the body of the
boy was buried. Much emphasis has been laid on the IO’s statement to
the effect that the then accused had confessed to the IO of having
kidnapped the victim and having kept him in solitary confinement for
several days. According to the IO, several persons, probably nine in
number, were involved in the entire operation of kidnapping the boy for
ransom. Of the others, one was arrested for a short while; but he
absconded upon securing bail, while the others could not be
apprehended at all.
10.
Much of what the IO has asserted from the witness box has to be
disregarded in view of Section 25 of the Evidence Act, 1872. Further, as
noticed in greater detailed later herein, there is no independent witness
account of either convict leading to where the body of the victim was
buried. Indeed, the father of the victim contradicted the investigating
officer’s version as to which convict led the police to the place where
the victim’s body was buried.
11.
The IO described how Ajay led them to where the dead body
was buried and how the dead body was exhumed. This was on
November 3, 2015 whereupon an inquest was held and the dead body
was identified as the victim’s by the FIR-maker father of the victim.
The body was found in a state of decomposition and the post-mortem
report of November 4, 2015 revealed that the death may have taken
place some seven or eight days before the post-mortem examination
was conducted on the body.
12.
According to the State, in view of the extent of the
decomposition of the body and the medical evidence in such regard, it
can be safely be presumed that the boy was alive till on or about
October 27-28, 2015. The State also refers to Acquit claiming to have
seen the boy alive. According to the IO, Ajay claimed that the ransom
money had been received but for reasons not understood by Ajay, Ajay
was not paid his share of Rs.10,000/-. Ajay claimed that he did not raise
a protest at the relevant point of time. However, it is evident that the
yarn that Ajay spun of being tracked down by ultras or being shot at
was a figment of his imagination since the forensic analysis of Ajay’s
jacket with the alleged bullet hole therein did not reveal the remains of
anything remarkable.
13.
Though the body of the victim was exhumed from a forest near
Dudhnoi on November 3, 2015, there was neither any recording of any
statement by either accused nor any independent witness to demonstrate
that one or the other of them had led the police team to where the body
of the victim was buried. What appears from the evidence is that both
the accused or either of them may have revealed where the group may
have kept the young boy in custody and the police scouted the area to
ultimately discover the body, but not at the behest of either Ajay or
Acquit. Since there is no evidence in such regard, it cannot be accepted
that either Ajay or Acquit led the police to the place where the body was
interred. In the absence of Ajay being linked to the discovery of the
body or the knowledge that the victim had already expired, no charge of
murder can stick against Ajay. Even if it is accepted that Ajay’s story
that he met with ultras on the morning of October 27, 2015 or that they
shot at Ajay during such time is imaginary, it does not necessarily
follow that Ajay murdered the boy or that Ajay was involved in the
commission of such offence.
14.
Indeed, what such dishonest statement of Ajay reveals is that
Ajay may have been apprehensive that the victim would be discovered
and if the victim had claimed that he had been abducted by Ajay, that
would have reflected poorly on Ajay. In such circumstances, Ajay may
have made up a story of him and the victim having been kidnapped by
extremists, but such false story would not lead to any inference of his
involvement in the death of the abducted boy.
15.
The father of the victim identified the body but, according to
such father, it was Acquit not Ajay who led the police to the body.
Apart from such anomaly, since the IO claimed that it was Ajay who led
the police team to the body, it is evident that the boy must have died on
or about October 27-28, 2015, by which time Ajay had already come
away.
16.
From the impugned judgment, there does not appear to be any
basis for holding Ajay or even Acquit guilty of murder. Indeed, it is
evident that neither Ajay nor Acquit may have been a part of the group
as of October 27 or October 28 when the boy may have been killed. In
the light of Acquit only claiming to have been the cook and Ajay
confirming such position, Acquit cannot be seen to have had a big role
in the entire operation. On the basis of the material before the trial court,
neither Ajay nor Acquit could have been found guilty of having
committed murder. At any rate, no motive in such regard has been
attributed to either. As to the charge pertaining to kidnapping for
ransom, it appears that the same has been made out in view of the FIRmaker’s assertion that he had received a phone call and a corroboration
of the situation by the accused to the extent, at least that of Ajay having
lured the victim from home and Acquit having seen the boy in the
company of the group for which Acquit was apparently forced to cook.
17.
Even if the charge of murder against both Ajay and Acquit is set
aside on the ground of insufficient evidence, the case under Sections
364A and 34 of the Penal Code has been adequately made out. There is
evidence of Ajay driving away with the victim, evidence of someone or
the other contacting the father for ransom money and the assertion by
Ajay that the money may have been paid though Ajay’s share was not
made over to him.
18.
Whether or not any ransom was actually paid, there is no
denying the fact that the victim was kidnapped. In the light of the
father’s assertion as to the phone call demanding ransom, it further
appears that the victim may have been kidnapped for ransom. As such,
even though the charge under Section 302 of the Penal Code may not
stick in the present case, the punishment awarded to either appellant for
kidnapping for ransom would have to be left untouched.
19.
Accordingly, Crl.A.No.32 of 2022 and Crl.A.No.33 of 2022 are
allowed in part by setting aside the judgment and order dated November
14, 2019 insofar as they convicted Ajay and Acquit for having
committed murder, but their conviction under Sections 364A and 34 of
the Penal Code for the common motive of kidnapping for ransom is
affirmed.
20.
Accordingly, the punishment under Section 302 is set aside
insofar as it relates to the charge under Section 302 of the Penal Code.
The conviction under Section 364A read with Section 34 of the Penal
Code is upheld.
21.
However, since the sentences in respect of the two distinct
offences were to run concurrently, notwithstanding the acquittal in
respect of the charge under Section 302 of the Penal Code, the sentence
of rigorous imprisonment for life together with fine of Rs.1 lakh under
Section 364A is sustained. The additional fine of Rs.1 lakh for murder
is set aside.
22.
Several judgments have been cited on behalf of the appellants,
including the ones reported at AIR 2022 SC 5535 (S. Kaleeswaran v.
State by the Inspector of Police, Pollachi Town East Police Station,
Coimbatore), AIR 2023 SC 634 (Munna Lal v. State of Uttar Pradesh)
and 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 926 (Rahul v. State of Delhi Ministry of Home
Affairs) and 2023 SCC OnLine SC 50 (Boby v. State of Kerala) to
demonstrate the flimsy charge of murder.
23.
In view of the facts as they presented themselves and the
evidence not sustaining the charge of murder, the law on such aspect of
the matter as cited on behalf of the appellants has not been referred to in
any great detail.
24.
Let copies of this judgment and order be immediately made
available to the appellants free of cost.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
28.08.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review