Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010350222024
2026:CGHC:41105
NAFR
VISHAKHA
BEOHAR
Digitally
signed by
VISHAKHA
BEOHAR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 5378 of 2024
Order Reserved on 12.08.2026
Order Delivered on 22.09.2026
1 - Acc Limited A Limited Company Registered Under The
Companies Act. 1913, Having Its Registered Office At Adani
Corporate House, Shantigram. Near Vaishno Devi Circle, S.G.
Highway, Khodiyar, Ahmedabad 382421 And Its Manufacturing
Unit At Jamul Cement Works, Jamul District Durg (Chhattisgarh),
Through Its Authorised Signatory Sudipta Mondal
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Water
Resources Department Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Naya
Raipur
(Chhattisgarh)
2 - Engineer In Chief Water Resources Department Government
Of Chhattisgarh Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Naya Raipur
(Chhattisgarh)
3 - Chief Engineer Water Resources Department, Government Of
Chhattisgarh Mahanadi Godawari Kachar Raipur (Chhattisgarh)
4 - Superintending Engineer Water Resources Department,
Government Of Chhattisgarh, Shivnath Division Durg (C.G.)
5 - The Executive Engineer Tandula Water Resources Division,
Government
Of
Chhattisgarh
Durg
(C.G.)
6 - General Manager District Industries And Trade Centre Durg
(Chhattisgarh)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from the Case Information System)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
:-
Mr. Ashish Shrivastava, Senior Advocate
along with Mr. Rahul Ambast and Mr.
Ashutosh Shrivastava, Advocates
For State
:-
Mr. Shobhit Mishra, Dy. G.A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SB-Hon’ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
CAV Order
1. By way of the present writ petition, the petitioner-Company
has invoked the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, challenging the
demand notices dated 13.06.2024, whereby demands of
₹1,81,32,897/- towards the Captive Power Plant and
₹1,99,26,915/- towards the Cement Plant have been raised
towards alleged unauthorised use of water for the period from
01.04.2020 to 31.05.2024, along with levy of charges at three
times the normal rate and interest. The petitioner has also
questioned the inaction of the respondents in not considering
its applications dated 03.06.2020 and 10.03.2023 for
sanction/allotment of surface water, while simultaneously
treating the consumption as unauthorised and imposing
penal charges. It is contended that the impugned demands
are contrary to the order dated 11.01.2022 passed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in ACC Ltd. v. State of Chhattisgarh
& Others, in Civil Appeal No.316/2019 arising out of SLP(C)
No.24414/2019.
2. Following reliefs have been prayed in this petition:“10.1 That, this Hon'ble High Court may kindly be
pleased to call for the entire records of the
petitioner Company from the possession of the
respondents relating to issuance of impugned
letter/demand letter for its kind perusal;
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue appropriate writ quashing and
setting aside both the impugned memo/letter
dated 13.06.2024 (ANNEXURE P/1 & P/2) by
declaring the same to be illegal, arbitrary, void,
and inoperative in law as far as it relates to
charging @three times of water charges and
interest on delayed payments;
10.3 The Hon'ble High Court may be pleased to
issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing
the Respondents state to issue necessary order
OR execute an agreement with the Petitioner for
sanction of allotment of surface water pursuant to
the application dated 03.06.2020 & 10.03.2023
preferred by the Petitioner;
10.4 The Hon'ble High Court may be pleased to
issue a writ in the nature of mandamus forbearing
the respondents from raising any demand or Bill
for levy of water charge three times the rate &
along with interest in respect of use of water by
the petitioner; which gets collected in the natural
course in the worked out pits in the leased area in
the course of mining.
10.4 Any other relief/reliefs, which this Hon'ble
Court may think fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances
of
the
case,
with
cost
of
thepetition, may also please be granted to the
petitioner.”
3. Facts of the case in brief are that the petitioner-Company is
engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of cement
and clinker and operates its unit at Jamul Cement Works,
Jamul,
District
Durg,
Chhattisgarh.
For
ensuring
uninterrupted power supply to its manufacturing unit, the
petitioner has established a 25 MW Captive Power Plant at
the same premises. The petitioner also holds a mining lease
dated 12.06.1963 for extraction of limestone, which is the
basic raw material for manufacture of cement and clinker. In
the mined-out areas, certain ponds have naturally/self-formed
and the rainwater accumulated therein is utilized by the
petitioner for the requirements of its Cement Plant and
Captive Power Plant. The petitioner contends that such water
is neither supplied through any canal or irrigation system
established
by
the
Government
irrigation/agricultural
purposes.
authorities
demand
issued
nor
is
Earlier,
notices
it
used
for
the
respondent
dated
06.02.2013
demanding alleged water charges of ₹1,89,12,368/- in
respect of the Cement Plant and ₹1,55,39,922/- in respect of
the Captive Power Plant. The petitioner sought the basis and
relevant notifications for such demands and was supplied the
notifications dated 21.03.2006 and 31.05.2010. The petitioner
submitted representations contending that Sections 37 and
40 of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Act, 1931 and the aforesaid
notifications were not applicable, as the water being utilized
by it was not supplied from any Government canal or
irrigation source. Despite the representations, the authorities
threatened levy of penalty at three times the water charges
and insisted upon payment. Aggrieved by the aforesaid
action, the petitioner approached this Court by filing W.P.(C)
No.519/2013. By order dated 17.07.2014, this Court
observed that the demand had been raised for the first time
after several years without affording an opportunity of hearing
to the petitioner and directed the authorities to provide postdecisional hearing and decide the petitioner's representation
in accordance with law. The petitioner thereafter preferred
W.A. No.340/2014. During the pendency of the appeal, this
Court directed that no coercive steps be taken against the
petitioner in respect of the impugned demand. Subsequently,
issues relating to the validity and interpretation of Rules 71-A
and 73 of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules, 1974 arose,
whereafter the petitioner was permitted to challenge the said
provisions separately. Accordingly, the petitioner filed W.P.(C)
No.774/2015 challenging the validity of Rules 71-A and 73 of
the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules, 1974 and the consequential
demand of water charges. The said writ petition was
dismissed by this Court on 02.08.2019, upholding the validity
of the aforesaid provisions. The petitioner challenged the said
order before the Hon'ble Supreme Court by filing SLP(C)
No.24414/2019.
During
the
proceedings,
the
Hon'ble
Supreme Court, vide order dated 22.11.2021, directed the
State to recompute the water consumption for the relevant
period by associating representatives of the petitioner and
thereafter compute and communicate the water charges on
the basis of such assessment.
4. Pursuant thereto, the respondent authorities recomputed the
water
consumption
and
issued
a
revised
bill
dated
09.12.2021 for the period from 2010-11 to 2019-20. The
petitioner deposited the amount demanded pursuant to the
revised assessment. Thereafter, on 11.01.2022, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, while disposing of Civil Appeal No.316/2019
arising from SLP(C) No.24414/2019, considering the peculiar
facts and the dispute regarding water consumption by the
petitioner for its Cement Plant and Captive Power Plant,
directed the petitioner to pay the outstanding water
consumption charges within the stipulated period and
specifically directed that no penalty be imposed.
5. During the pendency of the proceedings before the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, the petitioner had already submitted an
application dated 03.06.2020 before the competent authority
seeking sanction/allotment of surface water for its Cement
Plant and Captive Power Plant. The petitioner requested that
its application be considered so that water could be utilized
upon obtaining the requisite allotment and further requested
waiver of the additional/penal charges. However, no decision
was communicated by the respondents. Subsequently, on the
instructions of the respondents, the petitioner submitted
another application in the prescribed format on 10.03.2023
seeking sanction/allotment of surface water. Despite the
same, no final decision was taken by the respondent
authorities. In the meantime, the petitioner continued to pay
water charges at the normal applicable rate. The petitioner
also submitted a representation dated 15.03.2024 against the
water charges bill dated 01.02.2024, requesting waiver of the
three-times charges in view of the order dated 11.01.2022
passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and pointing out that
its applications for allotment of surface water were still
pending consideration before the authorities. The said
representation also did not receive any effective response.
Subsequently, the petitioner received the impugned demand
notices dated 13.06.2024 issued by the Executive Engineer,
Tandula Water Resources Division, Durg, whereby an
amount of ₹1,99,26,915/- was demanded in respect of the
Cement Plant and ₹1,81,32,897/- in respect of the Captive
Power Plant for the period from 01.04.2020 to 31.05.2024.
The
demands
were
raised
by
treating
the
alleged
consumption as unauthorised and by applying three times the
normal rate of water charges, besides levying interest for the
alleged delayed payment. The petitioner submitted a
representation dated 28.06.2024 challenging the aforesaid
demands and specifically contended that the levy of threetimes charges was contrary to the order dated 11.01.2022
passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. It was further pointed
out that the petitioner had duly approached the department
for allotment of surface water but the applications remained
pending due to inaction on the part of the respondents.
Without prejudice to its rights and contentions, the petitioner
deposited the water charges at the normal rate for the
relevant period, while disputing the penal component. Earlier,
the aforesaid subsequent developments and the impugned
demand were sought to be brought on record in W.P.(C)
No.1598/2015. However, when the matter was taken up, the
petitioner sought permission to withdraw the said writ petition
with liberty to challenge the subsequent demand notices by
filing a fresh writ petition. The petition was accordingly
withdrawn with liberty. It is in the aforesaid factual
background that the petitioner has filed the present writ
petition, principally contending that the impugned demand
notices dated 13.06.2024, insofar as they impose water
charges at three times the normal rate along with interest, are
arbitrary and contrary to the directions of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court dated 11.01.2022. It is further contended that
the respondents, having failed to decide the petitioner's
applications
for
allotment
of
surface
water,
cannot
subsequently penalize the petitioner by treating the use as
unauthorised for the intervening period.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
demand dated 13.06.2024, whereby water charges have
been levied at three times the normal rate for the Cement
Plant as well as Captive Power Plant, is arbitrary, illegal and
contrary to the judgment dated 11.01.2022 passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in ACC Ltd. v. State of Chhattisgarh
& Others, Civil Appeal No.316/2022 arising out of SLP(C)
No.24414/2019. It is submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme
Court,
after
noticing
the
dispute
regarding
water
consumption, specifically directed that no penalty be imposed
and required the petitioner to pay only the outstanding water
consumption charges. It is contended that the respondents,
by the impugned demand for the subsequent period, are
seeking to impose the very same penal liability which had
already been disapproved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. It
is further submitted that Rule 73 of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation
Rules, 1974 permits charging at three times the volumetric
rate only in cases specifically contemplated therein, namely
unauthorised use of water or wastage of water. According to
the petitioner, the water in question was collected from
natural sources in mined-out pits and the petitioner had
already applied for allotment of surface water. Therefore, the
respondents
could
not
mechanically
treat
the
entire
consumption as unauthorised and levy three times the
normal rate.
7. Learned counsel submits that the impugned demand, insofar
as it seeks to impose penal charges, is also without
jurisdiction. Rule 193 of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules,
1974 specifically provides for imposition of penalty in case of
delayed payment of water rate and confers such power upon
the Canal Deputy Collector. The Executive Engineer,
therefore, could not have assumed such jurisdiction and
imposed an additional penal liability upon the petitioner. It is
further submitted that the respondents have illegally added
interest to the alleged water charges without there being any
substantive statutory provision authorising such levy under
the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Act, 1931 or the Rules of 1974.
Relying upon India Carbon Ltd. v. State of Assam, (1997) 6
SCC 479, V.V.S. Sugars v. Government of A.P., (1999) 4
SCC 192, J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. Commercial Taxes
Officer, (1994) 4 SCC 276 and Shree Bhagwati Steel
Rolling Mills v. Commissioner of Central Excise, (2016) 3
SCC 643, learned counsel submits that interest can be levied
only where the statute itself contains a substantive provision
authorising such levy. In the absence of such provision, the
demand of interest is wholly without authority of law.
8. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner had submitted an
application dated 03.06.2020 for allotment of surface water
and subsequently submitted the prescribed application dated
10.03.2023. Despite the applications remaining pending and
never having been rejected, the respondents have failed to
take a decision thereon, while simultaneously treating the
petitioner’s consumption as unauthorised and imposing penal
charges. It is contended that the respondents cannot take
advantage of their own inaction and penalise the petitioner
for non-allotment of water when the petitioner had duly
approached
the
competent
authority
for
regularisation/allotment. Learned counsel further submits that
there was no wilful default on the part of the petitioner. The
issue regarding levy and payment of water charges remained
the subject matter of proceedings before this Court and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, and the petitioner had continuously
contested the additional penal liability while making payment
of the principal water charges. In such circumstances, levy of
penalty and interest is unjustified.
9. It is also contended that the impugned demands were issued
without any prior show-cause notice or opportunity of hearing
and without following the procedure contemplated under
Rules 75 to 78 read with Rule 71-A of the Chhattisgarh
Irrigation Rules, 1974. The demand, therefore, violates the
principles of natural justice and Articles 14 and 265 of the
Constitution of India. In substance, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that the respondents, despite the specific
order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court not to impose penalty,
have again imposed water charges at three times the normal
rate and interest, while simultaneously failing to decide the
petitioner’s applications for allotment of surface water. The
impugned
demands
are,
therefore,
arbitrary,
without
jurisdiction and liable to be quashed.
10.Learned counsel appearing for the respondents/State,
opposing the writ petition, submits that the impugned demand
notices dated 13.06.2024 have been issued strictly in
accordance with the provisions of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation
Act, 1931, the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules, 1974 and the
notifications/circulars issued by the State Government from
time to time. It is submitted that the petitioner Company has
been using water from self-constructed groundwater/surface
water sources for its Cement Plant and 25 MW Captive
Power Plant for commercial and industrial purposes without
obtaining
the
requisite
permission/allotment
from
the
competent authority. In view of Section 26 of the Act, all rights
in the water of natural sources vest in the State Government,
while
Section
specifically
empowers
the
State
Government to regulate the supply of water for industrial
purposes and determine the charges payable therefor. It is
further submitted that the petitioner had been using such
water without obtaining valid permission and, therefore, the
water charges were liable to be recovered in accordance with
the applicable statutory provisions and rates prescribed by
the State Government. The demand for the period from
01.04.2020 to 31.05.2024 was calculated on the basis of the
actual quantity of water consumed by the petitioner, as
verified by the authorities, and after giving credit for the
amounts already deposited by the petitioner. The demand
raised in respect of the Captive Power Plant was
Rs.2,64,10,250/-, out of which Rs.82,77,353/- had already
been
paid,
leaving
an
outstanding
amount
of
Rs.1,81,32,897/-. Similarly, in respect of the Cement Plant,
the total demand was Rs.2,92,21,181/-, against which
Rs.92,94,266/- had been deposited, leaving Rs.1,99,26,915/outstanding.
11.Learned State counsel further submits that the order dated
11.01.2022 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil
Appeal No.316/2022 arising out of SLP (C) No.24414/2019
does not prohibit the respondents from recovering the
legitimate water consumption charges for the subsequent
period. It is contended that the Hon'ble Supreme Court had
directed that no penalty be imposed for the period then in
dispute, whereas the present demand pertains to the
subsequent period from April 2020 to May 2024. According to
the State, the amount described by the petitioner as penalty
at three times the rate is the rate applicable under the
statutory scheme for unauthorized use of water, and the
respondents have otherwise acted in accordance with the
applicable provisions. It is also submitted that the petitioner
cannot claim any right to use the water merely on the basis of
the mining lease, particularly when the earlier proceedings
between the parties had already recognized the requirement
of obtaining permission for appropriation and use of water
from the leased area. The petitioner had also not obtained
the requisite allotment of surface water from the competent
authority during the relevant period. The subsequent
application made by the petitioner for allotment of surface
water is still under consideration and mere pendency of such
application cannot be treated as a grant of permission or
confer any deemed right to use the water without payment of
applicable charges.
12.Learned State counsel submits that the petitioner itself had
earlier litigated the issue before this Court and thereafter
before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, and the State authorities,
pursuant to the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
dated 22.11.2021, had recomputed the water consumption
for the period April 2010 to March 2020 in association with
the petitioner. The petitioner thereafter deposited the principal
water charges, and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, vide order
dated 11.01.2022, merely waived the penalty for the period in
dispute and directed payment of the outstanding water
consumption charges. The said order, according to the State,
cannot be construed as conferring upon the petitioner a
perpetual exemption from payment of water charges or from
liability arising from subsequent unauthorized use. It is further
submitted that the levy of interest is consequential upon the
petitioner's failure to pay the water charges within the
prescribed period and that the petitioner cannot take
advantage of its own failure to make timely payment. The
State therefore submits that the impugned demands do not
suffer from want of jurisdiction, arbitrariness or violation of the
principles of natural justice and that no interference under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is warranted. On these
grounds, learned State counsel prays for dismissal of the writ
petition.
13.I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as
learned State counsel appearing for the respondents and
have perused the pleadings, documents placed on record
and the material available before this Court.
14.The principal challenge in the present petition is to the two
demand notices dated 13.06.2024 issued by respondent
No.5, whereby demands of Rs.1,81,32,897/- in respect of the
Captive Power Plant and Rs.1,99,26,915/- in respect of the
Cement Plant have been raised against the petitioner for the
period from 01.04.2020 to 31.05.2024. The petitioner does
not dispute the actual consumption of water as such, but
essentially questions the authority of the respondents to levy
charges at three times the normal rate by treating the use as
unauthorised and further questions the levy of interest on the
outstanding amount.
15.From the material placed on record, it is not in dispute that
the petitioner-company is operating its Cement and Clinker
manufacturing unit at Jamul, District Durg and is also
operating a 25 MW Captive Power Plant. It is also not in
dispute that the petitioner has been using water from the
sources situated in the mining/leased area for its industrial
activities. The earlier proceedings between the parties
disclose that the issue regarding levy of water charges on the
petitioner has been the subject matter of adjudication before
this Court as well as before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The
petitioner had earlier challenged the demand raised by the
authorities in WPC No.519 of 2013. The said petition was
disposed of by this Court on 17.07.2014 with a direction to
provide post-decisional hearing to the petitioner and to
decide its representations in accordance with law. Thereafter,
Writ Appeal No.340 of 2014 was preferred and, subsequently,
WPC No.774 of 2015 was instituted wherein the petitioner
also questioned the validity/applicability of Rule 71-A and
Rule 73(1) of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules, 1974. WPC
No.774 of 2015 was dismissed by this Court on 02.08.2019.
While doing so, this Court noticed, inter alia, the terms of the
mining lease and held that appropriation or use of water from
or collected in the leased land could be made only with the
written permission of the District Collector and that the
petitioner had not obtained such permission. The authority of
the State to levy water charges under the statutory provisions
was also noticed. The matter thereafter travelled to the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.24414 of 2019, which
was subsequently converted into Civil Appeal No.316 of
2022. During the proceedings before the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, the question of actual consumption of water for the
period from April, 2010 to March, 2020 was considered. By
order dated 22.11.2021, the respondents were directed to
recompute the water consumption in association with the
representatives of the petitioner and communicate the
amount of water consumption charges to the petitioner. The
question of penalty was kept open. Pursuant thereto, the
consumption was reassessed and the respondents quantified
the water charges for the aforesaid period. Thereafter, by
order dated 11.01.2022, the Hon'ble Supreme Court disposed
of the appeal with a specific direction that it was appropriate
not to impose any penalty and directed the petitioner to pay
the outstanding amount of water consumption charges within
the stipulated period.
16.The significance of the aforesaid order of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court cannot be lost sight of. The direction was in
the context of the dispute relating to the period up to March,
2020 and, therefore, the respondents could not treat the said
order as permitting them to recover, for the same period, any
amount by merely changing the nomenclature of the demand
from "penalty" to "interest". At the same time, the order dated
11.01.2022 does not amount to a declaration that the
petitioner is permanently exempted from payment of water
charges or that its subsequent use of water would
automatically become authorised.
17.The petitioner has principally relied upon the direction of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court that no penalty be imposed. The
respondents, on the other hand, contend that the impugned
demands are not penalties imposed pursuant to Rule 73 but
represent water charges calculated with reference to the rate
applicable to unauthorised use and that the amount
remaining unpaid has further been subjected to interest.
Thus, the real controversy is not merely one of nomenclature
but whether the respondents have correctly exercised the
statutory power while raising the impugned demands.
18.Section 26 of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Act, 1931 declares
the rights of the Government in respect of water in rivers,
natural streams, natural drainage channels, natural lakes and
other natural collections of water, subject to the statutory
exceptions. Section 40 further contemplates supply of water
for industrial, urban or other purposes not connected with
agriculture and provides that the conditions of supply and
charges are to be fixed in accordance with the Act and the
Rules
framed
thereunder.
Therefore,
the
petitioner's
contention that merely because the water was collected in
the mined-out area or was drawn from a self-constructed
source, the same automatically became the petitioner's
exclusive property and fell outside the regulatory framework
of the Irrigation Act, cannot be accepted in view of the earlier
adjudication between the parties. More particularly, this Court
in the earlier proceedings had already considered the
petitioner's rights under the mining lease and the requirement
of permission for appropriation/use of water. However, the
aforesaid conclusion does not by itself answer the legality of
the particular computation made in the impugned notices
dated 13.06.2024. The statutory authority is bound to
demonstrate that the particular rate and the particular
component of the demand have been imposed strictly in
accordance
with
the Act,
Rules
and
the
applicable
notifications/circulars. A demand raised by a statutory
authority must have a clear statutory foundation and cannot
be sustained merely on the assertion that the use was
unauthorised.
19.In this regard, Rule 73(1) of the Chhattisgarh Irrigation
Rules, 1974 provides for charging water used in an
unauthorised manner, otherwise than on cultivated land, at
thrice the prescribed volumetric rate. The respondents have
relied upon this provision for justifying the higher rate. The
petitioner, however, submits that its case does not fall within
the statutory expression of unauthorised use and that, in any
event, the order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court dated
11.01.2022 prohibits imposition of penalty.
20.Having considered the rival submissions, this Court is of the
view that the expression "penalty" and the statutory rate
applicable to unauthorised use cannot be treated as wholly
interchangeable without examining the statutory scheme and
the factual basis on which the demand has been calculated.
The mere description of an amount as "water charges"
cannot validate a demand which, in substance, imposes a
penal liability, nor can the earlier order of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court be circumvented by adopting a different
nomenclature.
21.The respondents have also relied upon the fact that the
petitioner had been using water for commercial and industrial
purposes without obtaining requisite permission/allotment.
That aspect gives the respondents authority to regulate the
use and recover lawful water charges. However, before
imposing a charge at three times the normal rate for the
subsequent period, the authority is required to clearly
establish the factual and statutory basis for treating the
particular consumption as unauthorised and to apply the
correct statutory provision and applicable rate. There is
another important aspect. The petitioner asserts that it had
approached the competent authority for allotment/permission
for surface water and that its application remained pending.
The respondents also admit that an application for allotment
of surface water was subsequently submitted and remained
pending
consideration.
Thus,
while
pendency
of
an
application by itself cannot confer a deemed statutory
permission upon the petitioner in the absence of a provision
creating such a deeming fiction, the competent authority was
nevertheless required to consider and decide the application
in accordance with law.
22.Consequently,
the
petitioner's
submission
that
the
application should automatically be deemed to have been
allowed merely because it was not rejected cannot be
accepted. At the same time, the respondents cannot
indefinitely keep the petitioner's application pending and
simultaneously proceed on the footing that the petitioner is an
unauthorised user, without taking a decision upon its request
for regularisation/allotment in accordance with the governing
statutory framework.
23.The petitioner has further challenged the levy of interest. On
this aspect, the legal position is well settled that interest on a
statutory liability cannot ordinarily be recovered unless there
is substantive statutory authority for such levy.
24.The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of J.K.
Synthetics Ltd. v. Commercial Taxes Officer, (1994) 4
SCC 276 has held as under:“16. It is well-known that when a statute levies a
tax it does so by inserting a charging section by
which a liability is created or fixed and then
proceeds to provide the machinery to make the
liability
effective.
It,
therefore,
provides
the
machinery for the assessment of the liability
already fixed by the charging section, and then
provides the mode for the recovery and collection
of tax, including penal provisions meant to deal
with defaulters. Provision is also made for charging
interest on delayed payments, etc. Ordinarily the
charging section which fixes the liability is strictly
construed but that rule of strict construction is not
extended to the machinery provisions which are
construed like any other statute. The machinery
provisions must, no doubt, be so construed as
would effectuate the object and purpose of the
statute and not defeat the same. (See Whitney v.
IRC [1926 AC 37 : 42 TLR 58] , CIT v. Mahaliram
Ramjidas [(1940) 8 ITR 442 : AIR 1940 PC 124 :
67 IA 239] , India United Mills Ltd. v. Commissioner
of Excess Profits Tax, Bombay [(1955) 1 SCR
810 : AIR 1955 SC 79 : (1955) 27 ITR 20] and
Gursahai Saigal v. CIT, Punjab [(1963) 3 SCR
893 : AIR 1963 SC 1062 : (1963) 48 ITR 1] ). But it
must also be realised that provision by which the
authority is empowered to levy and collect interest,
even if construed as forming part of the machinery
provisions, is substantive law for the simple reason
that in the absence of contract or usage interest
can be levied under law and it cannot be
recovered by way of damages for wrongful
detention of the amount. (See Bengal Nagpur
Railway Co. Ltd. v. Ruttanji Ramji [AIR 1938 PC 67
: 65 IA 66 : 67 CLJ 153] and Union of India v. A.L.
Rallia Ram [(1964) 3 SCR 164, 185-90 : AIR 1963
SC 1685] ). Our attention was, however, drawn by
Mr Sen to two cases. Even in those cases, CIT v.
M. Chandra Sekhar [(1985) 1 SCC 283 : 1985
SCC (Tax) 85 : (1985) 151 ITR 433] and Central
Provinces Manganese Ore Co. Ltd. v. CIT [(1986)
3 SCC 461 : 1986 SCC (Tax) 601 : (1986) 160 ITR
961] , all that the Court pointed out was that
provision for charging interest was, it seems,
introduced in order to compensate for the loss
occasioned to the Revenue due to delay. But then
interest was charged on the strength of a statutory
provision, may be its objective was to compensate
the Revenue for delay in payment of tax. But
regardless of the reason which impelled the
Legislature to provide for charging interest, the
Court must give that meaning to it as is conveyed
by the language used and the purpose to be
achieved. Therefore, any provision made in a
statute for charging or levying interest on delayed
payment of tax must be construed as a substantive
law and not adjectival law. So construed and
applying the normal rule of interpretation of
statutes, we find, as pointed out by us earlier and
by Bhagwati, J. in the Associated Cement Co.
case [(1981) 4 SCC 578 : 1982 SCC (Tax) 3 :
(1981) 48 STC 466] , that if the Revenue's
contention is accepted it leads to conflicts and
creates certain anomalies which could never have
been intended by the Legislature.”
25.In the matter of India Carbon Ltd. v. State of Assam,
(1997) 6 SCC 479, it has been held as under:“5. It was contended before the learned third
Judge that, there being no mention of interest in
the first part of Section 9(2) of the Central Act, the
appellants were not liable to pay interest as
aforestated. Reliance was placed upon the
judgment of this Court in Khemka & Co.
(Agencies) (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra
[(1975) 2 SCC 22 : 1975 SCC (Tax) 227 : (1975)
3 SCR 753] . The learned third Judge noted the
view taken by his two brother Judges on the first
question and found that there was unanimity on
the result, though for different reasons. He,
therefore, took the same view and held that
interest was payable by the appellants on
account of delay in payment of Central sales tax
even though no specific provision had been made
in the Central Act in this regard.
6. Our attention was invited to the Constitution
Bench judgment in J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. CTO
[(1994) 4 SCC 276] where it has been held that
provisions relating to the charging and levying of
interest in a statute are provisions of substantive
law. The relevant paragraph of the judgment may
be extracted: (SCC pp. 291-92)
“16. It is well known that when a statute levies a
tax it does so by inserting a charging section by
which a liability is created or fixed and then
proceeds to provide the machinery to make the
liability effective. It, therefore, provides the
machinery for the assessment of the liability
already fixed by the charging section, and then
provides the mode for the recovery and collection
of tax, including penal provisions meant to deal
with defaulters. Provision is also made for
charging interest on delayed payments, etc.
Ordinarily the charging section which fixes the
liability is strictly construed but that rule of strict
construction is not extended to the machinery
provisions which are construed like any other
statute. The machinery provisions must, no
doubt, be so construed as would effectuate the
object and purpose of the statute and not defeat
the same. (See Whitney v. IRC [1926 AC 37 : 42
TLR 58] , CIT v. Mahaliram Ramjidas [(1940) 8
ITR 442 : AIR 1940 PC 124 : 67 IA 239] , India
United Mills Ltd. v. Commr. of Excess Profits Tax
[AIR 1955 SC 79 : (1955) 27 ITR 20] and
Gursahai Saigal v. CIT [AIR 1963 SC 1062 :
(1963) 48 ITR 1] .) But it must also be realised
that
provision
by
which
the
authority
is
empowered to levy and collect interest, even if
construed as forming part of the machinery
provisions, is substantive law for the simple
reason that in the absence of contract or usage
interest can be levied under law and it cannot be
recovered by way of damages for wrongful
detention of the amount. (See Bengal Nagpur Rly.
Co. Ltd. v. Ruttanji Ramji [AIR 1938 PC 67 : 65 IA
66] and Union of India v. A.L. Rallia Ram [AIR
1963 SC 1685 : (1964) 3 SCR 164] .) Our
attention was, however, drawn by Mr Sen to two
cases. Even in those cases, CIT v. M. Chandra
Sekhar [(1985) 1 SCC 283 : 1985 SCC (Tax) 85]
and Central Provinces Manganese Ore Co. Ltd. v.
CIT [(1986) 3 SCC 461 : 1986 SCC (Tax) 607] ,
all that the Court pointed out was that provision
for charging interest was, it seems, introduced in
order to compensate for the loss occasioned to
the Revenue due to delay. But then interest was
charged on the strength of a statutory provision,
maybe its objective was to compensate the
Revenue for delay in payment of tax. But
regardless of the reason which impelled the
Legislature to provide for charging interest, the
Court must give that meaning to it as is conveyed
by the language used and the purpose to be
achieved. Therefore, any provision made in a
statute for charging or levying interest on delayed
payment of tax must be construed as a
substantive law and not adjectival law. So
construed and applying the normal rule of
interpretation of statutes, we find, as pointed out
by us earlier and by Bhagwati, J. in the
Associated
Cement
Co.
case
[Associated
Cement Co. Ltd. v. CTO, (1981) 4 SCC 578 :
1982 SCC (Tax) 3] , that if the Revenue's
contention is accepted it leads to conflicts and
creates certain anomalies which could never
have been intended by the Legislature.”
7. This proposition may be derived from the
above: interest can be levied and charged on
delayed payment of tax only if the statute that
levies and charges the tax makes a substantive
provision in this behalf.”
26.Further, in the matter of V.V.S. Sugars v. Government of
A.P., (1999) 4 SCC 192, it has been held as under:“6. This Court in India Carbon Ltd. v. State of
Assam [(1997) 6 SCC 479] has held, after
analysing the Constitution Bench judgment in
J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. CTO [(1994) 4 SCC 276]
that interest can be levied and charged on
delayed payment of tax only if the statute that
levies and charges the tax makes a substantive
provision
in
this
behalf.
There
being
no
substantive provision in the Act for the levy of
interest on arrears of tax that applied to
purchases of sugarcane made subsequent to the
date of commencement of the amending Act, no
interest thereon could be so levied, based on the
application of the said Rule 45 or otherwise.”
27.Also, in the matter of Shree Bhagwati Steel Rolling Mills
vs. Commissioner of Central Excise and Another (2016) 3
SCC 643, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:30. On merits, the matter is no longer res
integra. A Constitution Bench decision of this
Court in V.V.S. Sugars v. State of A.P. [V.V.S.
Sugars v. State of A.P., (1999) 4 SCC 192] has
held, following two earlier judgments of this
Court, as follows : (SCC p. 195, para 6)
“6. This Court in India Carbon Ltd. v. State of
Assam [India Carbon Ltd. v. State of Assam,
(1997) 6 SCC 479] has held, after analysing the
Constitution Bench judgment in J.K. Synthetics
Ltd. v. CTO [J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. CTO, (1994)
4 SCC 276] that interest can be levied and
charged on delayed payment of tax only if the
statute that levies and charges the tax makes a
substantive provision in this behalf. There being
no substantive provision in the Act for the levy of
interest on arrears of tax that applied to
purchases of sugarcane made subsequent to the
date of commencement of the amending Act, no
interest thereon could be so levied, based on the
application of the said Rule 45 or otherwise.”
31. Applying the Constitution Bench decision
[V.V.S. Sugars v. State of A.P., (1999) 4 SCC
192] stated above, it will have to be declared that
since Section 3-A, which provides for a separate
scheme for availing facilities under a compound
levy scheme, does not itself provide for the
levying of interest, Rules 96-ZO, 96-ZP and 96ZQ cannot do so and therefore on this ground
the appellant in Shree Bhagwati Steel Rolling
Mills has to succeed. On this ground alone
therefore
the
impugned
judgment
[Shree
Bhagwati Steel Rolling Mills v. CCE, 2006 SCC
OnLine P&H 1434 : (2007) 2 RCR (Civil) 241] is
set aside. That none of the other provisions of
the Central Excise Act can come to the aid of the
Revenue in cases like these has been laid down
by this Court in Hans Steel Rolling Mill v. CCE
[Hans Steel Rolling Mill v. CCE, (2011) 3 SCC
748] as follows : (SCC p. 751, para 13)
“13. On going through the records it is clearly
established that the appellants are availing the
facilities under the compound levy scheme,
which they themselves opted for and filed
declarations furnishing details about the annual
capacity of production and duty payable on such
capacity of production. It has to be taken into
consideration that the compounded levy scheme
for collection of duty based on annual capacity of
production under Section 3 of the Act and the
1997 Rules is a separate scheme from the
normal scheme for collection of Central excise
duty on goods manufactured in the country.
Under the same, Rule 96-ZP of the Central
Excise Rules stipulates the method of payment
and Rule 96-ZP contains detailed provision
regarding time and manner of payment and it
also contains provisions relating to payment of
interest and penalty in the event of delay in
payment or non-payment of dues. Thus, this is a
comprehensive scheme in itself and general
provisions in the Act and the Rules are
excluded.”
28.The respondents have referred to Rule 193 of the
Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules, 1974 and have sought to justify
the levy of additional liability on account of non-payment.
Rule 193, however, specifically identifies the authority
competent to impose the penalty for non-payment of canal
revenue within the prescribed period. Therefore, the
Executive Engineer cannot assume a power which the Rules
confer upon another statutory authority. The source and
extent of jurisdiction of the officer issuing the demand must
be traceable to the statute or the Rules.
29.In the present case, the impugned notices have been issued
by the Executive Engineer and the computation includes a
substantial
component
described
as
interest.
The
respondents have not satisfactorily demonstrated before this
Court the precise statutory provision under which the
Executive Engineer was competent to impose such interest
for the entire period from 01.04.2020 to 31.05.2024,
particularly when the earlier dispute regarding water charges
had remained subject matter of litigation and the Hon'ble
Supreme Court had specifically directed that no penalty be
imposed for the earlier disputed period.
30.It is also relevant that the impugned demands cover the
period commencing immediately after the period considered
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The respondents are, of
course, entitled to recover lawful charges for actual
consumption during the subsequent period, subject to the
applicable statutory rates. But the respondents cannot
mechanically apply the consequence of unauthorised use
and add interest without first determining the petitioner's
liability in accordance with the statutory procedure and by the
competent authority.
31.The contention of the petitioner regarding absence of notice
and opportunity of hearing also requires consideration.
Though in every case involving a mere arithmetical demand
of admitted statutory dues a prior hearing may not
necessarily be required, the present demand is not a simple
computation of undisputed charges. It involves determination
of whether the use was unauthorised, whether the enhanced
rate of three times is attracted, the period for which such
enhanced rate can be levied and whether interest is legally
recoverable. These are matters involving determination of
liability and civil consequences. Therefore, the principles of
natural justice require that the petitioner be given an effective
opportunity to place its objections before the competent
authority ahead a final demand on such basis is enforced.
32.The impugned notices dated 13.06.2024, therefore, cannot
be sustained in their present form to the extent they
mechanically include the three-times rate and interest without
a proper determination of the statutory liability. At the same
time, this Court is not inclined to hold that the petitioner is
wholly exempt from payment of water charges for the period
in question. The petitioner has admittedly consumed water
for its industrial units and its liability to pay lawful water
consumption charges cannot be denied merely because the
precise rate or additional component of the demand is under
challenge.
33.Accordingly, the appropriate course would be to remit the
matter to the competent authority for fresh determination. The
competent authority shall examine the actual quantity of
water consumed by the petitioner during the period from
01.04.2020 to 31.05.2024, the source of such water, the
applicable
rate
under
the
statutory
provisions
and
notifications/circulars prevailing during the relevant period,
and whether the conditions necessary for invoking Rule 73(1)
are in fact satisfied.
34.While undertaking such exercise, the authority shall also
examine the effect and scope of the order dated 11.01.2022
passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.316
of 2022, particularly the direction regarding non-imposition of
penalty, and shall ensure that the petitioner is not subjected
to any liability which is, in substance, a penalty contrary to
the said order.
35.The competent authority shall further determine the question
of levy of interest strictly in accordance with the statutory
provisions. If there is no substantive statutory authority for
charging interest for the relevant period and in the manner in
which it has been calculated, the same shall not be
recovered. Likewise, if any statutory provision is found
applicable, the liability shall be determined only by the
authority competent under such provision and after giving the
petitioner an opportunity of hearing.
36.The
application/representation
of
the
petitioner
for
allotment/permission for use of surface water shall also be
considered and decided by the competent authority in
accordance with law. The pendency of such application shall
not by itself be treated as deemed permission; however, the
same shall be decided independently and expeditiously and
its outcome shall be duly considered while determining the
petitioner's future liability.
37.Consequently, without expressing any final opinion on the
exact quantum of water charges payable by the petitioner,
the impugned demand notices dated 13.06.2024 (Annexures
P/1 and P/2) are set aside to the extent they impose the
enhanced three-times rate and interest without a proper
determination of the petitioner's statutory liability, and the
matter is remitted to the competent authority for fresh
consideration.
38.The petitioner shall submit its detailed objections along with
all relevant documents, including proof of payments already
made, within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of this order. Thereafter, the competent authority
shall afford an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner and
pass a reasoned and speaking order determining the actual
water charges, if any, payable by the petitioner, strictly in
accordance with the Chhattisgarh Irrigation Act, 1931, the
Chhattisgarh Irrigation Rules, 1974 and the applicable
notifications/circulars.
39.The entire exercise shall be completed preferably within a
period of three months from the date of submission of the
objections by the petitioner. Any amount already deposited by
the petitioner pursuant to the earlier assessment shall be duly
adjusted against the amount, if any, found payable upon such
fresh determination.
40.Needless to say, if any amount is found payable after such
determination, the petitioner shall be liable to pay the same
within the period stipulated by the competent authority,
subject to its remedies available in law.
41.With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition stands
disposed of.
42.No order as to costs.
sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Vishakha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review