Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.36 of 2022
Abul Kalam Azad,
S/o. Lt. Abdul Majid,
Resident of West Bank of Jagannath Dighi,
P.S- R. K. Pur, Udaipur,
District-West Tripura.
------ Plaintiff Appellant
Versus
1. Ali Aswab Miah,
S/o. Lt. Abdul Majid,
Resident of village Fotamati
P.S – R. K. Pur, Udaipur
District- Gomati Tripura.
2. Smt. Fatema Begum,
W/o- Amir Hossen,
Resident of West Bank of Jagannath Dighi
P.S- R. K. Pur, Udaipur,
District- Gomati, Tripura.
3. Sri Rahamat Ullah Miah
S/o Iddris Miah
4. Ebadulla Miah,
S/o Iddris Miah
Resident of village Fotamati
P.S- R. K Pur, Udaipur
District- Gomati Tripura
------ Defendant-Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Adv,
Mr. D. Debnath, Adv,
Mr. S. Sarkar, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee, Adv,
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
12.09.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
19.09.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is directed challenging the judgment dated
12.05.2022 and decree dated 18.05.2022 delivered by Learned
Addl. District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur in connection with
T.A. No.2 of 2018. By the said judgment, Learned 1st Appellate
Court has upheld the judgment dated 18.01.2018 and decree
dated 31.01.2018 delivered by Learned CJM cum Civil Judge(Sr.
Div.), Gomati District, Udaipur in connection with T.S.(P) No.5
of 2017.
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. D. R. Chowdhury
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. D. Debnath and Learned
Counsel Mr. S. Sarkar for the appellant and also heard
Learned
Counsel
Mr.
Suman
Bhattacharjee
for
the
respondent-defendants.
3.
Before proceeding with the merit of this appeal let us
discuss about the subject matter of the dispute amongst the
rival parties before the Learned Trial Court. The present
appellant as plaintiff filed one suit before the Court of Learned
Civil Judge(Sr. Div.), Gomati JudicaiDistrict, Udaipur for a
decree of partition which was numbered as T.S(P) No.5 of 2017.
4.
The gist of the case of the appellant, in short, was that,
one Abdul Majid being the sole owner and possessor of land
measuring 1.88 acres as described in schedule ‘C’ of the plaint
which was within the land as mentioned in schedule ‘A’ of the
plaint sold to the plaintiff i.e. the appellant herein and
defendant Nos.1 and 2 i.e. respondent Nos.1 and 2 herein by a
registered sale deed vide No.1-710 dated 07.03.1994 and
delivered possession of the same to them. Since after the
purchase, the plaintiff and the defendant Nos.1 and 2 were in
possession of the said land as joint owners and possessors in
equal share i.e. 1/3rd share each which is the suit land of that
suit. According to the plaintiff, keeping him in dark, the
defendant No.1 in connivance with revenue staff obtained a
separate khatian No.933 in his name as sole owner and
possessor in respect of hal C.S. plot No.2182 land measuring
0.34 acres and hal plot No.2181 land measuring 0.64 acres in
total land measuring 0.98 acres which are the part of the land
as mentioned in schedule ‘C’ of the plaint. The plaintiff on so
many occasions requested the defendant Nos.1 and 2 for
amicable partition of the suit land but they refused. And lastly
on 03.05.2017 the plaintiff demanded for amicable partition of
the suit land. That time, the defendant No.1 disclosed that he
had managed to record the Hal Plot Nos.2182 and 2181 land
measuring 0.98 acres in his sole name which was recorded
under khatian No.933 and as such, said defendant No.1 refused
to make amicable partition of the suit land. Thereafter, the
present plaintiff filed the suit praying for a preliminary decree
by declaring that the plaintiff and the principal defendant Nos.1
and 2 are the owners of 1/3rd share over the suit land which is
described in the schedule ‘C’ of the plaint.
5.
On receipt of summons, the defendant Nos.1 and 2
appeared before the Learned Court and contested the suit by
filing their joint written statement denying the plea of the
plaintiff in his plaint and also pleaded that the suit was not
maintainable. The answering defendants further asserted that
the land as mentioned in schedule ‘C’ of the plaint purchased by
the plaintiff and the defendant Nos.1 and 2 jointly by a
registered sale deed bearing No.1-710 dated 07.03.1994 from
their father Abdul Majid(since dead). It was further asserted
that on 07.07.1994 there was an oral amicable settlement
amongst themselves that northern portion of land measuring
0.29 acres out of 0.64 acres of land appertaining to R.S. plot
and No.2181 and the entire 0.34 acre of land appertaining to
R.S. plot No.2182 of the said purchased land was allotted to the
defendant No.1 and the plaintiff has got the rest southern
portion of land measuring 0.35 acre appertaining to RS plot
No.2181. On the same day, the plaintiff considering the poverty
of the defendant No.1 verbally gifted the said southern portion
of land measuring 0.35 acre in favour of defendant No.1 in
presence of Amir Hossen, Abdul Jalil Miah, Ali Assam Miah and
Iddris Miah. Accordingly, the defendant No.1 accepted the same
and took possession as delivered by plaintiff in favour of said
defendant No.1 in presence of defendant No.2 and others and
thereby defendant No.1 became the owner in possession of
0.98 acre out of said 1.88 acres of land and accordingly, the
said land measuring 0.98 acre was mutated in his name under
khatian No.933. It was further submitted that the plaintiff never
raised any objection before the revenue authority against the
said mutation and since then the defendant No.1 has been
possessing the entire land under khatian No.933. It was the
plea of the answering defendant Nos.1 and 2 that the plaintiff
disobeying/suppressing the fact of oral gift filed the suit to grab
the land gifted to the defendant No.1. Hence, the answering
defendants by their written statement prayed for dismissal of
the suit with costs.
6.
The pro-defendant Nos.3 and 4, inspite of receipt of
summons did not contest the same as such by order dated
18.07.2017 the suit proceeded ex parte against them.
7.
Learned Court below upon the pleadings of the parties
framed the following issues by order dated 01.09.2017:
i) Whether the suit is maintainable?
ii) Whether C schedule land of plaint is the joint
property of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 & 2?
iii) Whether C schedule land of plaint is partitioned
amicably among the plaintiff and defendant No.1 & 2?
iv) Whether plaintiff is entitled to the relief as prayed for
and/or any other relief or reliefs in this case?
8.
In order to prove the issues both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record. The present
appellant as plaintiff adduced three witnesses including himself
and relied upon some documentary evidence which was marked
as exhibits. On the other hand, the contesting defendants have
adduced three witnesses and relied upon some documents
which
were
also
marked
as
exhibits.
For
the
sake
of
convenience, the name of the witnesses of the contesting
parties and their exhibits are mentioned herein below:
Plaintiff‟s witnesses:
i) PW-1 : Abul Kalam Azad
ii) PW-2 : Shri Subhasis Bandopadhyay
iii) PW-3 : Mrs. Nabanita Majumder
Plaintiff‟s Exhibits:
i) Exbt.-1 : Computerized khatian No.933.
ii) Exbt.-2 : Computerized khatian No.1130.
iii) Exbt.-3 : Computerized khatian No.49/1.
iv) Exbt.-4 : Computerized khatian No.49/2.
v) Exbt.-5 : Letter dated 13.05.17 issued by
SDO (Sub-divisional Magistrate).
vi) Exbt.-6 : Certified copy of khatian No.41/1.
vii) Exbt.-7 : Certified copy of khatian No.41/2.
viii) Exbt.-8 : Authenticated copy of mutation.
ix) Exbt.-9 : Authenticated copy of khatian
No.933.
x) Exbt.-10 : Authenticated copy of another
khatian No.933.
xi) Exbt.-11 : Authenticated copy of thumb
impression register dated 10.01.1994.
xii) Exbt.-12 : Authenticated copy of sale deed
No.1-70, dated 10.01.1994.
xiii) Exbt.-13 : Certified copy of sale deed No.1709, dated 07.03.1994
xiv) Exbt.-14 : Certified copy of sale deed No.1710, dated 07.03.1994.
Defendant‟s witness:
i) DW-1 : Fatema Begam.
ii) DW-2 : Amir Hossen
iii) DW-3 : Jalil Miah.
Defendant‟s Exhibits:
i) Exbt.-A: Certified copy of khatian No.933.
ii) Exbt.-B : Original sale deed No.1-710.
iii) Exbt.-C : Certified copy of plaint of TS 06 of
2017.
9.
Finally, on conclusion of trial, the Learned Court below
dismissed the suit of the appellant-plaintiff by judgment dated
18.01.2018 and consequential decree dated 31.01.2018. For
the sake of convenience, the operative portion of the judgment
dated 18.01.2018 runs as follows:
Order
In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is
dismissed on contest without cost.
The suit is disposed of on contest without
cost.
Make necessary entry in the relevant Trial
Register.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up before
me for signature within 15(fifteen) days from
today latest on 02-02-2018.
The record shall be consigned to the Record
Room.
10.
Challenging that judgment and decree, the plaintiff as
appellant has preferred first appeal under Section 96 of CPC
before the Court of Learned District Judge, Gomati District,
Unakoti and the case was endorsed to the court of Learned
Addl. District Judge, Gomati, Udaipur for disposal in accordance
with law. However, Learned 1st Appellate Court after hearing
both the sides by judgment dated 12.05.2022 and decree dated
18.05.2022 dismissed the appeal by upholding the judgment
and decree of the Learned Trial Court i.e. Learned Civil
Judge(Sr. Div.), Gomati District, Udaipur. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the operative
portion of judgment dated 12.05.2022 which is as follows:
Order
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court
finds no error or irregularity in the impugned
judgment dated 18-01-2018 and decree dated
31-01-2018, passed by the Learned Trial
Court in TS(Partition) 05 of 2017 whereby the
suit of the plaintiff i.e. the present appellant
has been dismissed without cost which is
accordingly confirmed and upheld by this
Appellate Court. Hence, this Appeal is hereby
dismissed being no merits.
Parties are directed to bear their own costs.
Thus the appeal is hereby disposed of on
contest.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send back the L.C. Record along with a
certified copy of this judgment and decree.
11.
Being dissatisfied with the judgment of the Learned 1st
Appellate Court the plaintiff again preferred this appeal under
Section 100 of CPC before the High Court. At the time of
admission of the appeal by order dated 29.07.2022 this High
Court formulated the following substantial questions of law:
“A Whether the Learned Courts below failed
to appreciate that before legal partition the
transfer/gift of the joint property to the
Defendant No.1-Respondent by alleged oral
gift by specific portion was/is not a valid
transfer/gift made by the Plaintiff-Appellant?
B. Whether the plea raised by the DefendantRespondent No.1 that before making the
alleged oral gift of the 1/3rd share of the
Plaintiff-Appellant in the suit land being the
joint properties was amicably partitioned by
way of oral family arrangement can be legally
considered where the family arrangement
must be nature of a Deed and must be
registered also should be registered before
giving affect of the Partition by oral and
unregistered family arrangement?
C. Whether the Learned Courts below ought
to have disbelieved the story of oral gift and
Partition by family arrangement of the 1/3rd
share of the suit land of the PlaintiffAppellant to the Defendant-Respondent No.1
and to grant the decree of Partition of
schedule-A of the joint property.”
12.
At the time of hearing of argument of this case,
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. D. R. Chowdhury assisted by
Learned Counsel Mr. D. Debnath and Learned Counsel Mr. S.
Sarkar first of all drawn the attention of the Court that both the
Learned Courts below committed serious error in delivering the
judgment for which both the judgments are perverse. According
to Learned Senior Counsel, from the contents of the written
statement submitted by the respondent Nos.1 and 2 i.e. the
defendants of the original suit, it is found that there was no
valid partition or family arrangements by registered instrument
of the suit properties amongst the rival parties. So, the
judgment and decree of the Learned 1st Appellate Court
affirming the judgment of the Learned Trial Court cannot be
sustained in the eye of law. Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that under Mohammedan law oral gift is valid but
until and unless there is any specific boundary or family
arrangements by which the land can be identified, there was no
scope to dismiss the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiff by the
Learned Trial Court. Learned Senior Counsel further referred the
provision of Section 17(2)(a) of the Indian Registration Act and
submitted that in absence of any valid registered document,
there was no scope on the part of the Learned Trial Court to
believe the story projected by the respondent Nos.1 and 2
before the Learned Trial Court but the Learned Trial Court did
not consider the fate of alleged oral gift and dismissed the suit
of the appellant-plaintiff.
13.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
Learned
Counsel
Mr.
D.
Debnath assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. D. Debnath and
Learned Counsel Mr. S. Sarkar referring the Ext.9 and Exbt.12
submitted that the alleged khatian No.933 as relied upon by the
respondent No.1 is nothing but a forged and concocted
document. Again, referring the relevant MR case Learned Senior
Counsel further drawn the attention of the Court that the
concerned revenue authority based on fabricated document
recorded a portion of suit land in favour of respondent No.1 for
which on the basis of fabricated khatian there was no scope to
place any reliance upon said Ext.-9 by the Learned Trial Court
but the Learned Trial Court did not consider the factual aspects
and relied upon the oral testimonies and the said fabricated
documents i.e. Exbt.-9 and Exbt.-12 as referred by the
respondent-defendant No.1 before the Learned Trial Court.
Finally Learned Senior Counsel submitted that in absence of
valid partition, there was no scope to transfer any property
showing any specific identical portion or in absence of any
specific family arrangements by a registered arrangement,
there was no scope to place any reliance upon the defence of
defendant No.1 i.e. respondent No.1 herein but the Learned
Courts below did not consider those aspects and ultimately
dismissed the lawful claim of the appellant-plaintiff and urged
for allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgment and
decree of the Learned 1st Appellate Court.
14.
Learned Counsel for the contesting respondents, Mr.
Suman Bhattacharjee at the time of hearing of argument
strongly resisted the submission made by Learned Senior
Counsel, Mr. D. R. Chowdhury and submitted that in the given
case both the Courts below gave concurrent findings and there
is no infirmity or perversity in the judgment of the Learned
Courts below and the Learned Trial Court after considering the
oral and documentary evidence on record of the contesting
parties rightly dismissed the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiff
which was later on affirmed by Learned 1st Appellate Court.
Learned Counsel, Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee further submitted
that before the Learned Trial Court the present appellant failed
to project their case which has been raised before this Court at
the time of hearing of argument by the Learned Senior Counsel.
So, simply by mere suggestions the appellant-plaintiff could not
create any doubt to disbelieve the case of the respondent No.1
and Learned 1st Appellate Court after hearing arguments of both
the sides rightly upheld the judgment and decree of the
Learned 1st Appellate Court and submitted that the substantial
questions of law are related to facts only and here, in the
second appeal, there is no scope to consider the facts laid
before the Learned Trial Court and submitted that the present
appellant has got no merit in the appeal and urged for dismissal
of this appeal with costs.
Both the parties have referred few citations at the time
of hearing of argument.
15.
Admittedly in this case, there is no dispute on record
that the suit land measuring 1.88 acres as mentioned in
schedule ‘C’ of the plaint was originally belonged to one Abdul
Majid
i.e.
the
predecessor
of
appellant-plaintiff
and
the
respondent Nos.1 and 2 and said Abdul Majid during his lifetime
by
a
registered
deed
of
sale
vide
No.1-710
dated
07.03.1994(Exbt.-12) sold said land measuring 1.88 acres to
the present appellant and the respondent No.2 for valuable
consideration and delivered possession of the same to them. It
was the further case of the parties that after purchase they
jointly became the owners in possession of the said land
measuring 1.88 acres in equal share i.e. owner of 1/3rd share
each over the suit land. It was the case of the appellant that no
legal or amicable partition or family arrangement was made
amongst the appellant-plaintiff and the respondent Nos.1 and 2
over the suit land but the respondent No.2 in connivance with
the Revenue Authority vide MR case No.276/95 managed to
record the land of the appellant-plaintiff by creating a separate
khatian bearing No.933 in the name of defendant No.1 as sole
owner and possessor in respect of 0.34 acre of land in CS plot
No.2182 and 0.64 acre of land in hal plot No.2181 in his name
which is the part of land as mentioned in schedule ‘C’ of the
plaint i.e. the suit land.
16.
On the other hand, according to the respondent Nos.1
and 2 that after purchase of the suit land, the appellant-plaintiff
and the respondent Nos.1 and 2 possessed the said undivided
land by cultivating and also by rearing fish in the pond and
enjoyed usufructs therefrom and after 3/4 months of their
purchase on 07.07.1994, an oral amicable settlement among
themselves in respect of said purchased land was made and as
per amicable settlement, land measuring 0.29 acres out of 0.64
acres appertaining to R.S. plot No.2181 and the entire 0.34
acre appertaining to R.S. plot No.2182 of the said purchased
land was allotted to the defendant No.1 and the appellantplaintiff got the rest portion of land measuring 0.35 acres
appertaining to R.S. Plot No.2181 out of his share over the
purchased land and on the same day, the appellant-plaintiff
considering the poverty of the defendant No.1 verbally gifted
the said southern portion of 0.35 acres of land in favour of the
defendant No.1 in presence of Amir Hossen, Abdul Jalil Miah, Ali
Assam Miah and Iddris Miah and the respondent-defendant
No.1 accepted the same and took possession over the same
land which he made in presence of the respondent-defendant
No.2. Thus,
the
defendant
No.1 became the owners
in
possession of 0.98 acres out of 1.88 acres of land and which
was recorded and mutated in khatian No.933 in the name of
respondent-defendant No.1. Now here in this appeal, we are to
decide as to whether the said alleged oral transfer of land by
way of gift measuring 0.35 acres was valid or not in the eye of
law. Now let us examine the legal position in this case.
17.
Chapter XI of Mulla’s Principles of Mahomedan Law
deals with gifts. In Section 138, gift is defined which says:
“138. Hiba or gift A hiba or gift is “a transfer
of property, made immediately, and without
any exchange,” by one person to another, and
accepted by or on behalf of the latter.
„Gift‟ or „Hiba‟ literally means the giving away
of such a thing from which the person in
whose favour the gift is made may draw
benefit. The definition of Hiba or Gift has been
given in Kanz al Daquiq in the following
words: “Hiba is the making of another person
owner of the corpus of property without
taking its consideration from him.”
Thus, gift is the transfer of movable or
immovable property with immediate effect
and without consideration by one person
called the donor to another person called the
donee and the acceptance of the same by one
himself or by some one authorized on his
behalf, provided that making the gift must
totally renounce all his title and rights in the
property gifted away of his independent free
will.”
From the above definition, it appears that the gift is a
transfer of movable or immovable property with immediate
effect and without consideration by one person called the donor
to another person called the donee and the acceptance of the
same by one himself or by someone authorized on his behalf,
provided that making the gift must totally renounce all his title
and rights in the property gifted away of his independent free
will.
18.
Again in Section 147 prescribes that writing is not
necessary in gift which provides as under:
“147. Writing not necessary Writing is not
essential to the validity of a gift either of
movable or of immovable property. In Kamarun-nissa Bibi v. Hussaini Bibi:(1880) 3 All.
266, the Privy Council upheld a verbal gift.”
From the above, it appears that under Mahomedan law,
writing is not essential for the validity of a gift either movable
or immovable property. There are three essentials of a gift
under Mahomedan Law, namely (1) a declaration of gift by the
donor; (2) an acceptance of the gift, express or implied, by or
on behalf of the donee, and (3) delivery of possession of the
subject of the gift by the donor to the donee. If these conditions
are fulfilled, the gift is complete. Here in the given case
according to the respondent-defendant Nos.1 and 2 that the
appellant-plaintiff gifted his share of property in favour of
respondent-defendant No.1 in presence of Amir Hossen, Abdul
Jalil Miah, Abdul Asad Miah and Iddris Miah, etc.
19.
In course of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant referred few citations. In Smt. Chanderwati v.
Lakhmi Chand and others bearing case No.LPA No.14 of
1975 dated 24.02.1987 reported in AIR 1988 Delhi 13 in
para No.8 Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“8. A half-hearted argument is addressed by Mr. S.
N. Mehta, the learned counsel for the appellant that
the document marked „A‟ is merely a recital of the
past transaction/oral partition by metes and
bounds. In our view, the plaintiffs did not make out
a case in the plaint that first oral partition had taken
place and possession was taken by metes and
bounds including the passage before the execution
of the document marked „A‟. The document in the
recital itself says that “the same has now been
mutually divided by the parties between themselves
in equal shares, in the manner hereinafter stated”.
No oral evidence was led and no finding of any of
the courts below is recorded that any earlier oral
partition had taken place or the plaintiffs were
given possession of the passage prior to the
execution of the document marked „A‟. The
allotment of the passage in dispute to the share of
the plaintiffs‟ predecessor-in-interest was by virtue
of a written document and that document is
inadmissible in evidence for want of registration. A
partition
of
immovable
property
between
coparceners or co-owners may be made orally and
is not required to be in writing. A document which
merely acknowledges or makes an admission, as to
prior partition, is not compulsorily registerable. But
if there is an instrument effecting a partition of
immovable property, as in the present case, it falls
under S.17(1)(b) of the Registration Act and is
compulsorily registered under that clause. An
unregistered document of partition is not admissible
in evidence to prove any of the terms contained in
the document. An unregistered partition deed is not
admissible to show the respective shares of the
parties as declared by the document. There is no
doubt in our mind that the document marked „A‟
was itself a deed of partition and not a record of
earlier oral partition by metes and bounds. It is
clear that document marked „A‟ was intended to be
a document which was binding on them as a
partition deed and which was to be the sole
evidence of the terms of such partition. Document
marked „A‟ being unregistered cannot be used for
establishing as is claimed that the passage on the
right side of the left piller of the outer gate shall
form part of the share of the plaintiffs and the same
being 7‟-4” in width shall run into 44‟ in length
where it will form the shape of English letter „L‟
upto its joining the last wall.”
Relying upon the aforesaid citation, Learned Senior
Counsel Mr. D. R. Chowdhury for the appellant submitted that
in the given case, there was no registered deed of partition or
family arrangements by showing any specific boundary or clear
description of the land. So, the contention of the respondent
No.1 i.e. the oral gift was not legally sustainable but the
Learned Court below did not consider the same.
20.
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. D. R Chowdhury further
referred another citation of this High Court reported in 2013(1)
TLR 335 (Parimal Ch. Saha and Ors. v. Snehalata Saha
and Ors.) bearing case No.RSA No.26 of 2010 dated
22.12.2011 wherein para No.13, this High Court observed as
under:
“13. According to law, in a joint property, the right
of all co-owners extends to the whole property until
and unless it is partitioned by metes and bounds.
While the joint ownership is an admitted fact and
the plaintiffs claimed that it was not partitioned, the
first party defendant, who has been claiming family
partition of the suit land, burden lies on him to
prove that it was amicably partitioned between the
brothers. This burden absolutely lies on the first
party defendant alone and the plaintiffs are not
required to disprove it. The first appellate court has
drawn presumption stating that plaintiffs did not
adduce evidence to show that they have also shared
money for construction of hut on the suit land.
Legally there cannot be such burden on the
plaintiffs to prove the fact.
For the argument sake, if it is taken that the first
party defendant constructed the hut, it should be
presumed that it belonged to all the co-sharers, if
the first party defendant cannot prove that there
was a partition between the co-sharers. The first
party defendant though claimed that there was a
partition effected amicably, no date and time is
mentioned, even there is nothing as to how the
partition was effected and who has measured the
suit land and in presence of whom. If there was any
such oral partition between the brothers, on which
part the share of other co-owners were located? In
the absence of any written document of such
amicable family arrangement, party defendant was
liable to adduce very cogent evidence to prove such
partition.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the subject matter of the present appeal is
almost similar to the facts as mentioned in the aforenoted case
of this High Court and urged for taking note of the citation in
deciding the appeal, because in the case at hand, there was no
such evidence on record from the side of respondent No.1 that
the same arguments have been followed in this case.
21.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the contesting
respondents in course of hearing relied upon few citations. In
Ripudaman Singh v. Tikka Maheshwar Chand reported in
(2021) 7 SCC 446 bearing case No.Civil Appeal No.2336 of
2021 dated 06.07.2021 wherein in para No.11, Hon’ble the
Apex Court observed as under:
“11. The question whether such settlement between
the members of the family would require
registration or not has come up for consideration
before this Corut in a judgment reported in Kale v.
Director of Consolidation:(1976) 3 SCC 119 which
reads as under: (SCC pp.125-27, paras 9-10)
“9. … The object of the arrangement is to
protect the family from long-drawn litigation
or perpetual strifes which mar the unity and
solidarity of the family and create hatred and
bad blood between the various members of
the family. Today when we are striving to
build up an egalitarian society and are trying
for a complete reconstruction of the society,
to maintain and uphold the unity and
homogeneity of the family which ultimately
results in the unification of the society and,
therefore, of the entire country, is the prime
need of the hour. A family arrangement by
which the property is equitably divided
between the various contenders so as to
achieve an equal distribution of wealth
instead of concentrating the same in the
hands of a few is undoubtedly a milestone in
the administration of social justice. That is
why the term “family” has to be understood in
a wider sense so as to include within its fold
not only close relations or legal heirs but even
those persons who may have some sort of
antecedent title, a semblance of a claim or
even if they have a spes successionis so that
future disputes are sealed for ever and the
family instead of fighting claims inter se and
wasting time, money and energy on such
fruitless or futile litigation is able to devote its
attention to more constructive work in the
larger interest of the country. The courts
have, therefore, leaned in favour of upholding
a family arrangement instead of disturbing
the same on technical or trivial grounds.
Where the courts find that the family
arrangement suffers from a legal lacuna or a
formal defect the rule of estoppel is pressed
into service and is applied to shut out plea of
the person who being a party to family
arrangement seeks to unsettle a settled
dispute and claims to revoke the family
arrangement under which he has himself
enjoyed some material benefits. …
*
*
*
10. In other words to put the binding effect
and the essentials of a family settlement in a
concretised form, the matter may be reduced
into the form of the following propositions:
„(1)-(3)
*
*
*
(4) It is well-settled that registration
would be necessary only if the terms of
the family arrangement are reduced into
writing. Here also, a distinction should be
made between a document containing
the terms and recitals of a family
arrangement made under the document
and a mere memorandum prepared after
the family arrangement had already been
made either for the purpose of the record
or for information of the court for making
necessary mutation. In such a case the
memorandum itself does not create or
extinguish any rights in immovable
properties and therefore does not fall
within the mischief of Section 17(2) of
the Registration Act and is, therefore, not
compulsorily registrable;
(5) The members who may be parties to
the family arrangement must have some
antecedent title, claim or interest even a
possible claim in the property which is
acknowledged by the parties to the
settlement. Even if one of the parties to
the settlement has no title but under the
arrangement the other party relinquishes
all its claims or titles in favour of such a
person and acknowledges him to be the
sole owner, then the antecedent title
must be assumed and the family
arrangement will be upheld and the
courts will find no difficulty in giving
assent to the same;
(6) Even if the bona fide disputes,
present or possible, which may not
involve legal claims are settled by a bona
fide family arrangement which is fair and
equitable the family arrangement is final
and binding on the parties to the
settlement‟ ” ”
(emphasis in original)
Learned Counsel further referred another citation of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court reported in (1976) 3 SCC 119
(Kale and Others v. Deputy Director of Consolidation and
others) bearing case No.Civil Appeal No.37 of 1968 dated
21.01.1976 wherein in para Nos.7 and 10, Hon’ble the Apex
Court and Hon’ble Sarkaria, J observed as under:
“7. In support of the appeal Mr. Garg appearing for
the appellants submitted two points of law before
us. In the first place he argued that the grounds on
which the courts below have not given effect to the
family arrangement arrived at between the parties
in 1956 culminating in the mutation in 1957 are not
legally sustainable. The High Court took an
erroneous view of the law in rejecting the
compromise on the ground that it was registered. It
was argued an oral family arrangement had already
taken place earlier and a petition before the Naib
Tahsildar was merely for the information of the
court for the purpose of mutation of the names of
the parties in pursuance of the compromise and,
therefore, no question of registration of the
compromise in this case arose. Secondly it was
contented that even if the compromise was
unregistered it would undoubtedly operate as a
clear estoppel against the respondents Nos.4 and 5
who having taken benefit thereunder and having
remained in possession of the lands for more than
seven years cannot be allowed to revoke the
compromise.
10. In other words to put the binding effect and the
essentials of a family settlement in a concretised
form, the matter may be reduced into the form of
the following propositions:
(1) The family settlement must be a bona fide
one so as to resolve family disputes and rival
claims by a fair and equitable division or
allotment of properties between the various
members of the family;
(2) The said settlement must be voluntary and
should not be induced by fraud, coercion or
undue influence;
(3) The family arrangement may be even oral
in which case no registration is necessary;
(4) It is well-settled that registration would be
necessary only if the terms of the family
arrangement are reduced into writing. Here
also, a distinction should be made between a
document containing the terms and recitals of a
family arrangement made under the document
and a mere memorandum prepared after the
family arrangement had already been made
either for the purpose of the record or for
information of the court for making necessary
mutation. In such a case the memorandum
itself does not create or extinguish any rights
in immovable properties and therefore does not
fall within the mischief of Section 17(2) of the
Registration
Act
and
is, therefore,
not
compulsorily registrable;
(5) The members who may be parties to the
family
arrangement
must
have
some
antecedent title, claim or interest even a
possible claim in the property which is
acknowledged by the parties to the settlement.
Even if one of the parties to the settlement has
no title but under the arrangement the other
party relinquishes all its claims or titles in
favour of such a person and acknowledges him
to be the sole owner, then the antecedent title
must be assumed and the family arrangement
will be upheld and the courts will finds no
difficulty in giving assent to the same;
(6) Even if the bona fide disputes, present or
possible, which may not involve legal claims
are settled by a bona fide family arrangement
which is fair and equitable the family
arrangement is final and binding on the parties
to the settlement.
Sarkaria, J.(concurring)- I am at one with my
learned Brother that this appeal should be
allowed with no order as to costs and that the
order dated January 22, 1965 of respondent
No.1 quashed, the order dated November 28,
1964, of the Settlement Officer restored, and
the revenue authorities directed to attest the
mutation in accordance with the antecedent
family arrangement which had been orally
arrived at between the parties and acted upon
for several years. I further agree that the
family settlement arrived at by the parties was
oral, and the petition filed by them on August
7, 1956 before the Assistant Commissioner,
was merely an information of an already
completed oral transaction. In other words, the
petition was only an intimation to the revenue
court or authority that the matters in dispute
between the parties had been settled amicably
between the members of the family, and no
longer required determination and that the
mutation be effected in accordance with that
antecedent family
settlement.
Since the
petition did not itself create or declare any
rights in immovable property of the value of
Rs.100 or upwards, it was not hit by Section
17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, and, as such,
was not compulsorily registrable. The rest of
the reasoning in the judgment of my learned
Brother has also my concurrence except that I
will reserve my opinion with regard to the
alternative proposition, whether this petition –
assuming it was compulsorily registrable under
Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act – could
be used to raise an estoppel against any of the
parties thereto. Decision of this point, in my
opinion, is unnecessary for the disposal of this
case.”
Thereafter, Learned Counsel referred another citation of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court. In Radha Sundar Dutta v. Mohd.
Jahadur Rahim and others bearing case No.Civil Appeal
No.108 of 1954 dated 18.09.1958 reported in AIR 1959 SC
24 wherein in para No.11, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“11. Now, it is a settled rule of interpretation that if
there be admissible two constructions of a
document, one of which will give effect to all the
clauses therein while the other will render one or
more of them nugatory, it is the former that should
be adopted on the principle expressed in the maxim
“ut res magis valeat qual pereat”. What has to be
considered therefore is whether it is possible to give
effect to the clause in question, which can only be
by construing Exhibit B as creating a separate
„Patni‟, and at the same time reconcile the last two
clauses with that construction. Taking first the
provision that if there be other persons entitled to
the Patni of lot Ahiyapur they are to have the same
rights in the land comprised in Exhibit B, that no
doubt posits the continuance in those persons of the
title under the original „Patni‟. But the true purpose
of this clause is, in our opinion, not so much to
declare the rights of those other persons which rest
on statutory recognitioin, but to provide that the
grantees under the document should take subject to
those rights. That that is the purpose of the clause
is clear from the provision for indemnity which is
contained therein. Moreover, if on an interpretation
of the other clauses in the grant, the correct
conclusion to come to is that it creates a new „Patni‟
in favour of the grantees thereunder, it is difficult to
see how the reservation of the rights of the other
„Patnidars‟ of lot Ahiyapur should such there be,
affects that conclusion. We are unable to see
anything in the clause under discussion, which
militates against the conclusion that Exhibit B
creates a new Patni.”
Referring all the citations, Learned Counsel submitted
that since the respondent-defendant No.1 has been able to
prove that the appellant-plaintiff made oral transfer after
observing all formalities in respect of his share in his favour so
in view of the principles of the said citations, no writing was
required for showing partition or for showing any family
arrangement and as such, the Learned Trial Court rightly
dismissed the suit which was rightly affirmed by the Learned 1 st
Appellate Court.
22.
He further submitted that the contesting respondents
by adducing oral evidence on record have been able to establish
the fact of oral transfer by the present appellant as plaintiff in
his favour which was duly recorded in his favour by the
mutation authority and even the present appellant did not
challenge the order of mutation to any other forum. So,
according to Learned Counsel there was no perversity or
infirmity in the judgment of the Learned 1st Appellate Court and
as such, he urged for dismissal of appeal with costs.
23.
I have gone through the aforesaid citations referred by
the parties and also gone through the records of the learned
Courts below including the evidence on record of the parties. It
appears that to substantiate the issues before the Learned Trial
Court, the appellant-plaintiff has adduced three witnesses
including the appellant himself and relied upon some documents
which were marked as Exbt.1 to Exbt.14. The appellant, as PW1 in course of his examination-in-chief by way of affidavit tried
to support his version in the plaint. The Contesting respondentdefendants by the art of cross-examination of the said witness
could not discard his evidence. Other witnesses of the appellant
according to this Court are not relevant for the subject matter
of the dispute. Similarly, the respondent Nos.1 and 2 have
adduced three witnesses including respondent No.2 Fatema
Begum. Respondent No.2 did not turn up before the witness
box. DW-1 in her examination-in-chief by way of affidavit tried
to support her version in the written statement filed by them
before the learned Trial Court and other witnesses i.e. DW-2
and
DW-3
Amir
Hossen
and
Abdul
Jalil
Miah
in
their
examination-in-chief by way of affidavit also tried to support
the
defence
story
of
the
contesting
respondents.
Those
witnesses were also duly cross-examined by the appellant.
Although they stated that in their presence the appellant gifted
southern portion of land measuring 0.35 acre in favour of the
respondent-defendant No.1 but from their evidences I do not
find any material to substantiate that the appellant-plaintiff
made any oral gift in favour of respondent No.1 because the
contesting respondents by their defence story failed to satisfy
the requirements of Section 147 i.e. principles of Mahomedan
law as stated above.
Furthermore, there is also no evidence on record form
the side of contesting respondent No.1 about the time when the
oral partition and gift was effected and who measured the land
and also in presence of whom. There is also no evidence on
record that from the side of the appellant who were present and
there was no independent witness in this regard and also the
witnesses of the respondent No.1 are also related to each other
and which part the share of other co-sharers are located along
with specific boundary so as to identify the land.
24.
In this regard, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India
reported in (2019) 2 SCC 727 (Jamila Begum (Dead)
through Legal representatives v. Shami Mohd. (Dead)
through legal representatives and another) bearing case
No.Civil Appeal No.1007 of 2013 dated 14.12.2018 in para
No.23 made the following observation:
“23. Under the Mohammedan law, no doubt, making
oral gift is permissible. The conditions for making
valid oral gift under the Mahommedan law are:- (i)
there should be wish or intention on the part of the
donor to gift; (ii) acceptance by the donee; and (iii)
taking possession of the subject-matter of the gift
by the donee. The essentials of a valid and complete
gift under Mohammedan law have been succinctly
laid down in Abdul Rahim v. Sk. Abdul Zabar:(2009)
6 SCC 160 as under: (SCC pp.165-66, paras 13-14)
“13. The conditions to make a valid and
complete gift under the Mahommedan law are
as under:
(a) The donor should be same and
major and must be the owner of the
property which he is gifting.
(b) The thing gifted should
existence at the time of hiba.
be
in
(c) If the thing gifted is divisible, it
should be separated and made distinct.
(d) The thing gifted should be such
property to benefit from which is lawful
under the Shariat.
(e) The thing gifted should not be
accompanied by things not gifted i.e.
should be free from things which have
not been gifted.
(f) The thing gifted should come in the
possession of the done himself, or of his
representative, guardian or executor.
14. It is also well settled that if by reason of a
valid gift the thing gifted has gone out of the
donee‟s ownership, the same cannot be
revoked. The donor may lawfully make a gift
of a property in the possession of a lessee or a
mortgagee. For effecting a valid gift, the
delivery of constructive possession of the
property to the done would serve the purpose.
Even a gift of a property in possession of
trespasser is permissible in law provided the
donor either obtains and gives possession of
the property to the donee or does all that he
can to put it within the power of the donee to
obtain possession.” ”
From the aforesaid principles, it appears that if the
thing gifted is divisible it should be separated and made distinct
but here in the given case, there is no such evidence on record
from the side of the contesting respondents that the land which
according to respondent No.1 gifted to him orally by the
appellant was duly separated and it was duly identified and
admitted by the appellant.
25.
Situated thus, it appears that the story as projected by
the respondent-defendant No.1 regarding transfer of land
measuring 0.35 acre by way of oral gift is not believable and
cannot be accepted in the eye of law. Another interesting thing
is that as per Exbt.-9, the disputed land which the appellant
claimed was recorded in the name of respondent No.1 under
khatian No.933 which was marked as Exbt.-9 and on perusal of
Exbt.-9, it appears that the land was mutated in his favour vide
No.MR. case No.276 of 1995 and on perusal of Exbt.-8, it
appears that land of old khatian No.49 was recorded in his
favour on the basis of title deed vide No.1-70 dated 07.03.1994
and said deed also has been marked by Exbt.-12 by the
Learned Trial Court but on perusal of Exbt.-12, it appears that
the sale deed was executed by one Srimanta Kumar Majumder
in favour of Phani Bhushan Adhikari and those persons are not
the relevant persons for decision of the suit and the land shown
in the said deed is in no way connected with the present subject
matter of dispute. So, it is surprising as to how the settlement
authority on the basis of said Exbt.-12 mutated the land in
favour of respondent No.1 vide MR case No.276 of 1995. In
course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for the
contesting respondents failed to give any counter on this point
as alleged by the Learned Counsel for the appellant although
Learned Counsel took the plea that that order was not
challenged.
26.
Admittedly, it is the settled position of law that khatian
does not confer any title on land but on perusal of said Exbt.-9,
it appears that the settlement authority or revenue authority
without any basis mutated the land in favour of the respondentdefendant No.1. Learned Trial Court below at the time of
delivery of judgment did not consider all those aspects and
accordingly dismissed the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiff
which in my considered view was perverse and the Learned 1st
Appellate Court also in the same line without considering all
those relevant facts as mentioned above upheld the judgment
of the Learned Trial Court which in my considered view Learned
1st Appellate Court committed serious error in deciding the
appeal and in my considered view, this is a fit case which be
remanded back to the Learned Trial Court for retrial of the
matter and to deliver a fresh judgment on the basis of issues
framed. The substantial questions of law in my considered view
leans in favour of the present appellant of this case.
27.
In the result, the judgment dated 12.05.2022 and
decree dated 18.05.2022 delivered by Learned 1st Appellate
Court in connection with T.A. No.2 of 2018 affirming the
judgment dated 18.01.2018 and decree dated 31.01.2018
delivered by Learned CJM cum Civil Judge(Sr. Div.), Gomati
District, Udaipur in connection with T.S.(P) No.5 of 2017 is
hereby set aside. The suit is remanded back to the Learned
Trial Court with a direction to rehear the suit afresh with the
observation that the alleged transfer of property by oral gift was
not made in accordance with the principles of Mahomedan Law
and to deliver a fresh judgment after taking evidence of both
the sides afresh, if required, on the basis of issues framed
within a period of 6(six) months from the date of receipt of
copy of this judgment. The parties shall appear before the
Learned Trial Court i.e. Learned CJM cum Civil Judge (Sr. Div.),
Gomati District, Udaipur on 07.10.2024 for further proceeding.
28.
With this observation, this appeal is disposed of on
contest with costs in favour of the present appellant.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
judgment.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.09.20
17:59:45 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review