Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010249032025
2026:GAU-AS:825
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
WP(C) NO.6506 OF 2025
1.
Abu Ansar Azad
S/o Late Noor Ali
Vill- Dullavpur, P.O. Anipur
P.S.- R.K. Nagar, DistrictKarimganj, Assam, PIN- 788734.
2.
Niloy Das
S/o Late Niranjan Das,
Vill- Arengabad, P.O. Chargola
Bazar, P.S. – Badarpur,
District- Karimganj, Assam,
PIN- 788720.
3.
Abdul Ahad,
S/o Late Abdul Mazid,
Vill- Telidighirpar, P.O. Marjat
Kandi, P.S. – Badarpur,
District- Karimganj, Assam,
PIN- 788710.
4.
Mustafa Mahmoor Khan
S/o Late Abdur Raquib Khan,
Vill- Ratanpur, P.O. Kaliganj
Bazar, P.S & Dist- Karimganj
PIN- 788720.
5.
Pranoy Kumar Sinha
S/o Late Radha Mohan Sinha,
Vill- Langtarpar, P.O. Muliala
Dist- Karimganj, Assam
PIN- 788750.
6.
Akhtar Hussain Choudhury,
S/o
Late
Amirul
Islam
Choudhury, Vill- Tilaiya,
P.O.- Sadarashi,
Dist- Karimganj, Assam,
PIN- 788709.
…….Petitioners
-Versus1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Chief
Secretary to the Government of
Assam, Dispur, Guwahati - 6.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary
to the Govt. of Assam,
Personnel
(B)
Department,
Dispur, Guwahati- 6.
3.
The Deputy Secretary to the
Govt. of Assam, Personnel
Department, Dispur, Guwahati-6
…….Respondents
–BEFORE–
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Petitioner(s)
:Ms. S.B. Choudhury, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:Ms.
M.
Bhattacharjee,
learned
Additional Senior Government Advocate
for the State respondents.
Date of Hearing
: 22.01.2026.
Date of Judgment
: 22.01.2026.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Ms. S. B. Choudhury, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioners. Also heard
Ms. M. Bhattacharjee, learned Additional Senior
Government Advocate appearing for the State
respondents.
2.
By way of the instant writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners have put to challenged the impugned
Executive Order dated 30.08.2025, issued by the
respondent No. 2, so far as Column B(ii) is
concerned, primarily on the ground that the said
executive stipulation allegedly supersedes and
overrides judicial orders and therefore, is bad in
law.
3.
Ms. S. B. Choudhury, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners, submits that after
the order dated 03.04.2025 passed by the coordinate bench of this court in Abdul Kadir
Bokshi vs The State of Assam and 4 Ors. in
WP(C) No. 342/2025, another order was
passed by this court in Abul Kalam Azad Vs.
The State of Assam and Ors. in WP(C) No.
2888/2025,
directing
consideration
of
petitioners case for compassionate appointment
and hence, any cut-off date under Column B(ii) of
the
executive
order
is
arbitrary
and
unenforceable.
Per
4.
contra,
Ms.
M.
Bhattacharjee,
learned Additional Senior Government Advocate
appearing for the State respondents, submits that
the executive order is a policy decision framed for
bringing
uniformity
and
consistent
decision
making by the competent authorities in view of
judicial pronouncements, including of the Apex
Court
and
this
court,
and
therefore,
no
interference is called for.
5.
Having heard the learned counsels
appearing for the parties and having perused the
material placed on record, it is apparent that the
government has issued a standard operating
procedure
appointment
for
disposal
cases
which,
of
compassionate
inter-alia,
makes
categorization of cases and prescribes a uniform
mechanism for consideration, which reads as
under:
Cases, Guidelines & Judgments and Timelines for
disposal
A
B
C
Types of cases
Guidelines
D
of
State
Time
frame
for disposal
Government
and
Judgments
passed
by
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court of India
and
Hon’ble
Gauhati
High
Court
applicable for
disposal
of
such cases
i)
All
a) O.M. No.
For DLC/SLC
documents/inform
ABP.50/2006/
within 1 (one)
ation received in
Pt-182
Month
respect of cases
01.06.2015.
of compassionate
appointment from
the
petitioners
who
have
challenged
the
Office
Memorandum No.
ABP. 104/2024/90
dated
b) Para 7 of
the
Order
dated
03.08.2006 in
WP(C)
3875/2005
(Achyut
No.
from
the date of
receipt of the
proposal from
Personnel
Department &
for SLC within
(one)
Month
from
the date of
dated 18.09.2024,
Ranjan
including
those
Vs.
similar
cases
Ors.)
which have been
disposed
of
the
Hon’ble
Gauhati
by
High
Court citing the
judgment
and
order
dated
03.04.2025
passed
by
Hon’ble
Gauhati
High
the
Court
WP(C)
c)
Das
SOA
&
of
such proposal
with
State
West
receipt
of
Bengal
recommendat
ion from DLC
Vs. Debabrata
Tiwari
and
others
(Civil
Appeal
No.
88428855/2022)
in
No.
342/2025,
pursuant to the
Notice
dated
30.08.2025 issued
by the Personnel
Department
and
subsequently
forwarded by the
Personnel
Department
the
respective
DLCs/SLCs,
be
to
shall
considered
and disposed of
by the concerned
DLCs/SLCs
on
merit by taking
into consideration
the
criteria
specified in Para 4
of this standard
operating
procedure
and
guidelines
and
judgments
as
mentioned
in
Column C & D of
this clause.
ii)
Applications/cases
a) O.M. No.
pending
ABP/104/2024
before
DLCs/SLCs
/90
wherein OM No.
18.09.2024.
ABP. 104/2024/90
dated 18.09.2024
has not been put
to
challenge
before
Hon’ble
Gauhati
High
court
as
on
03.04.2025
but
after 03.04.2025
b)
dated
State
West
of
Bengal
Vs. Debabrata
Tiwari
and
others
(Civil
Appeal
No.
88428855/2022).
shall be dealt only
c) Final Order
in terms of OM
passed by the
No.
Hon’ble Court
ABP.
104/2024/90
in
dated 18.09.2024
and
shall
disposed
relevant
case.
be
and
intimated to the
applicants by the
respective
DLCs/SLCs as the
case may be. The
order
dated
03.04.2025
passed in WP(C)
No.
342/2025
shall not apply as
precedent
for
cases
are
that
filed on or after
04.04.2025
challenging
the
OM
ABP.
No.
104/2024/90
dated 18.09.2024.
6.
It is the specific contention of the
petitioners
that
though
they
have
applied
pursuant to the applications being called in terms
of the aforesaid executive order, however, in view
of the stipulations made in Column B(ii) of the
said above extracted categorization of cases of
the executive order, the petitioners application for
compassionate appointment is likely not to be
considered. It is on this premise that the present
writ petition has been filed.
7.
Upon
careful
consideration
of
the
impugned executive order, it is apparent that the
Government
of
Assam
in
the
Personnel
Department has issued an Office Memorandum
dated 18.09.2024 for dealing with matters of
compassionate appointment considering the fact
that the scheme of compassionate appointment
has
already
been
superseded
by
the
compassionate family pension scheme with effect
from 01.04.2017 and in consonance with the
judgment and order passed by the Apex Court in
the case of State of West Bengal vs.
Debabrata Tiwari and Ors in Civil Appeal No.
8842-8855/2020. It is further apparent that
accordingly
in
light
of
various
judicial
pronouncements, particularly in the case of
Abdul Kadir Bokshi (supra) passed by the coordinate bench of this court by judgment and
order dated 03.04.2025 and similar matters, the
State government issued the impugned Executive
Order dated 30.08.2025, whereby a standard
operating procedure has been formulated for
ensuring
uniformity and effective disposal of
matters
relating
compassionate
to
ground
by
appointment
on
structuring
how
matters are to be processed after issuance of the
Office Memorandum dated 18.09.2024. It also
reiterates settled parameters of compassionate
appointment
including
immediacy
and
that
compassionate appointment is not a vested right
but an exception/welfare measure.
8.
It further appears that by issuing the
impugned
executive
order,
the
respondent
authorities are complying with the judgment and
order passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of State of West Bengal vs. Debabrata
Tiwari and Ors (supra).
9.
It is worth mentioning that pursuant to
a direction passed by this court on 19.01.2026,
an additional affidavit has been filed on behalf of
the petitioners on 20.01.2026, wherein it appears
that the father of the petitioner No. 1 expired on
19.10.1997. Similarly, the fathers of the petitioner
Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 expired on 07.11.2016,
07.12.2014,
29.12.2006,
02.05.2008
and
31.12.2011 respectively. It further appears that
the petitioner Nos. 2, 3 and 5 immediately upon
the death of their fathers filed applications for
compassionate appointment, i.e. on 04.06.2017,
13.02.2015
and
21.07.2018
respectively.
However, the remaining petitioner Nos. 1, 4 and
6 upon attaining majority after the lapse of
several
years,
compassionate
04.06.2017
and
filed
their
appointment
12.10.2019
applications
on
for
16.03.2001,
respectively.
It
further appears that their cases have not been
finalized till date. However, the relief sought in
the writ petition is to set aside and quash the
impugned Executive order dated 30.08.2025.
10.
It is well settled that the scope of
judicial review in matters of policy is limited. A
writ
court
does
not
sit
in
appeal
over
governmental policy choices. Unless a policy is
shown to be unconstitutional, or manifestly
arbitrary/irrational,
or
discriminatory
without
reasonable classification, or contrary to statute,
the court ought not to interfere with such
executive
decisions.
In
Balco
Employees’
Union (Regd.) vs. Union of India and Ors.
reported in (2002) 2 SCC 333, the Apex Court
held that economic and administrative policies fall
within the executive domain, and courts do not
interfere unless the policy is unconstitutional,
contrary to statute, or manifestly arbitrary. It is
further well settled that public policy decisions
involving administrative choices are not open to
judicial review merely because another view is
possible. Moreover, the government is entitled to
change policy in the public interest, and courts
cannot strike down a policy merely because it
may cause hardship. In matters of compassionate
appointment, it is further settled that the scheme
is not a source of recruitment, and appointments
can be made only in accordance with the
policy/rules applicable.
11.
Undoubtedly, a judicial order binds
parties and authorities in terms of the direction
issued therein. However, a court’s order directing
“consideration in accordance with law” does not
freeze the legal framework or prevent the state
from issuing a general policy applicable to all
similarly
situated
cases.
The
orders
dated
03.04.2025 and 04.06.2025 passed by the Coordinate bench of this Court relied upon by the
petitioners direct consideration of cases; they do
not confer a vested right to appointment dehors
policy. Hence, this Court is unable to accept the
submission of the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners that Column B(ii) of the impugned
executive order has the effect of overriding
judicial orders. The executive cannot nullify a
binding judicial direction, nor can it take away
relief specifically granted by a court. However, at
the same time, the government is not precluded
from issuing general executive instructions laying
down a uniform standard operating procedure for
decision
making,
compassionate
particularly
appointment,
in
areas
where
a
like
large
number of claims arise and consistency is
required. A bare perusal of the impugned
executive order and the standard operating
procedure in question, it is evident that the state
has attempted to classify cases and regulate
timelines/consideration
compassionate
mechanisms
appointment
matters.
for
Such
structuring cannot, by itself, in the considered
opinion of this court be termed as “superseding”
judicial orders. Therefore, the issuance of uniform
standard operating procedure cannot be set to
supersede judicial order.
12.
Further, the order dated 03.04.2025
passed by the co-ordinate bench of this court
itself clarifies that it shall not operate as
precedent for cases filed on/or after 04.04.2025
and shall apply only to cases pending as on
03.04.2025. Similar clarification appears in the
subsequent order dated 04.06.2025 of this court
as well, where the writ petition was disposed of
directing
consideration
in
light
of
those
observations. Thus, what flows from the judicial
orders
is
a
direction
for
consideration
as
permissible in law. The executive
standard
operating
read
procedure
cannot
be
as
obliterating the authorities’ obligations to consider
such cases in accordance with law.
13.
The
petitioners
grievances
are
essentially that the executive order draws a line
for application of Column B(ii) and since the
petitioners case was covered by a later order of
the co-ordinate bench of this court dated
04.06.2025, such cut-off is bad. This court is of
the unhesitant view that fixing a cut-off date or
categorizing cases for administrative uniformity is
not per se illegal. Unless it is shown that the cutoff date is wholly capricious, discriminatory or
without rational basis, the same cannot be
interfered
with
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India. In State of Bihar vs.
Ramjee Prasad reported in (1990) 3 SCC 368
and Government of Andhra Pradesh and
Ors. vs. N. Subbarayudu and Ors. reported in
(2008) 14 SCC 702, it has been held by the
Apex Court that the cut-off dates are within
executive wisdom unless shown to be capricious
or irrational.
14.
In the present case, the government’s
action is supported by rational administrative
considerations
namely;
ensuring
a
uniform
disposal mechanism across DLC/SLC, dealing with
a
large
volume
of
litigation
arising
from
challenges to the Office Memorandum dated
18.09.2024
and
bringing
the
processing
mechanism in tune with judicial pronouncements.
The impugned classification under Column B(ii) is
thus founded on uniformity in decision making,
harmonization
with
judicial
directions
and
administrative feasibility. Hence, the classification
has a rational nexus with the object sought to be
achieved. Therefore, Column B(ii) cannot be
struck down merely because the petitioners case
refers to a later order of this court dated
04.06.2025.
Even
otherwise,
compassionate
appointment is not a vested right. It is a
concession/welfare measure to meet immediate
hardship and has to be strictly in terms of
policy/rules. The policy itself highlights the criteria
of immediacy and notes that compassionate
appointment
cannot
be
claimed
after
a
considerable lapse of time unless permissible
under applicable norms.
15.
For the reasons above, this court finds
no ground to interfere with the Executive Order
dated 30.08.2025 so far as Column B(ii) is
concerned.
16.
The writ petition is devoid of merit and
is accordingly dismissed.
17.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review