Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
Digitally
signed by
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR ALI
CGHC010376562024
2026:CGHC:39110-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
REVP No. 257 of 2024
1. Abhishek Steel Industries Private Limited, 535 Urla Industrial
Area, Urla Industrial Estate, Raipur, Chhattisgarh, Through Its
Director, Mr. Rishikesh Dixit, S/o Mr. Ghanshyam Das Dixit,
Aged About 46 Years, R/o Shivanand Nagar, Sector II, Behind
Balaji Traders, Raipur, Chhattisgarh, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
State
Insurance
Corporation
Through
The
Regional Director, Employees State Insurance Corporation,
Raipur, Chhattisgarh, Chhattisgarh
2. Recovery Officer, Employees State Insurance Corporation, 18
South Avenue, Chowbey Colony, Raipur, District Raipur (CG)
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Saurabh Agrawal, Advocate (through virtual
mode), with Mr. Aman Pandey, Advocate
For Respondents
:
Mr. Pranav Saxena, Advocate
DB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
& Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sachin Singh Rajput
Order on Board
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, J
03.09.2026
1. Petitioner has filed this petition under Rule 90 read with Rule
87 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh Rules, 2007 seeking of
the order dated 09.04.2024 passed in MA No.87/2016.
2. Facts of the case, in nutshell, are that petitioner herein
preferred an application under Section 75 read with 77 of the
Employees State Insurance Act, 1948 (for short ‘the Act of
1948’) before the Employees Insurance Court – cum – Labour
Court No.2, Raipur challenging the recovery orders dated
25.11.2005, 22.11.2005 and 22.11.2005 passed by the
Employees Insurance Corporation (for short ‘the Corporation’)
for
recovery
of
Rs.3,91,081/-;
Rs.4,94,679/-
and
Rs.1,54,58,216/- respectively payable towards employees
contribution by M/s Rajesh Strips Limited for the period from
16.08.1995 to 31.07.2001. It was pleaded in the application
that M/s Rajesh Strips Limited was declared sick under Section
3 (1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act
1985 (for short ‘SICA’) and petitioner has taken its one unit on
monthly rent of Rs.5,00,000/-. Petitioner sought for new code
from the Corporation enabling them to deposit contribution
under the Act of 1948, however, the Corporation instead of
allotting new code asked the petitioner to make their
contribution under the old code which was allotted to said
Rajesh Strips and accordingly, the petitioner was depositing
the contribution. Suddenly, the Corporation without giving any
relief to the petitioner has transferred entire liability of Rajesh
Strips to it and hence, the demand raised was bad in law.
3. The Employee Insurance Court, by the order dated 23.7.2016
dismissed the application on the grounds mentioned therein,
which was put to challenge by petitioner by filing a
miscellaneous appeal before this Court, which came to be
registered as MA No.87/2016. After considering the grounds
mentioned in the appeal, the arguments advanced by both the
parties as well as provisions of the Act of 1948, the Court has
dismissed the appeal holding that the Corporation can very
well fasten the liability to recover its dues.
4. Feeling dissatisfied with order dated 09/04/2024 passed by the
Court, petitioner has approached Hon’ble Supreme Court by
filing Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.43023/2024, which was
dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to file review petition
before the High Court. Given the liberty granted by Hon’ble
Supreme Court, petitioner has filed present review petition.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that while deciding
the appeal, the Court has not properly appreciated the scope
and ambit of Section 45A of the Act of 1956, which clearly
provides that no order under Section 45A of the Act shall be
passed by the Corporation in respect of the period beyond five
years from the date on which the contribution shall become
payable. In case at hand, demand raised by the Corporation
pertains to the year 1995 to 1999 and demand is raised in the
year 2005. Therefore, respondent/Corporation could not have
called upon the appellants to pay contribution beyond the
period prescribed under Section 45A of the Act of 1956.
6. He also submits that there are two pre-conditions which must
be satisfied before Section 45A can be invoked. Firstly, no
returns, particulars, registers or records in respect of a factory
or establishment are submitted, furnished or maintained in
accordance with the provisions of Section 44. Secondly, any
Inspector or other official of the corporation is prevented by the
employer in exercising his functions or discharging his duties
under Section 45.
In case at hand, erstwhile owner was
depositing the contribution from 1995 onward and an
inspection was carried out by the Corporation in the year 2001.
Hence, respondent Corporation has wrongly invoked Section
45A of the Act of 1956 in stead of making assessment by
taking recourse to Section 75 (2) (a) by making an application
to the ESI Court.
7. He further submits that the Court has proceeded on wrong
premise that notice was served upon the petitioner. In fact,
petitioner has never been served with a notice to show-cause
for determination under Section 45A of the Act of 1948 neither
he has been given opportunity of hearing before the orders
impugned were passed. Notice in connection with demand of
contribution of Rs.1,54,58,5216/- was issued to the Managing
Director of Ramesh Strips Ltd. and not the petitioner. Thus,
there is apparent error on the face of record.
8. He also contended that determination of quantum is contrary to
Section 93A of the Act of 1956 and the same is not based on
wages. The impugned demand is raised at the time when said
Rajesh Strips Ltd. was a sick company, which is in
contravention of Section 25 of the SICA which provides that
no recoveries can be made against a sick company without
prior permission of the BIFR.
9. Per
contra,
learned
counsel
appearing
on
behalf
of
respondent has supported the order under review and
submitted that the scope of review is limited and an order/
judgment is open to review only if there is a mistake or an error
apparent on the face of the record, which must be self-evident
and does not require elaborate arguments. Grounds raised in
instant review petition regarding invocation of Section 45A in
place of Section 75 (2) (a) of the Act of 1956 for making
assessment, non-fulfillment of pre-conditions of Section 45A;
bar of limitation under Section 77 (1A) (b) of the Act of 1956 if
recourse was taken to Section 75; determination of quantum is
not based on wages; determination of quantum is contrary to
Section 93A of the Act of 19856, impugned demand has been
raised at the time when Rajesh Strips Ltd. was a sick company
and application of provision of Section 22 of the SICA; were
not forming part of the application filed before the Employees
Insurance Court or miscellaneous appeal before this Court.
Thus, by raising new grounds on merits, petitioner is seeking
rehearing of the case in the garb of review petition, which is
not permissible.
10. Referring to other grounds raised in review petition and argued
during course of hearing, he submits that the same are mere
reproduction of the grounds of appeal, which were duly
considered and decided by this Court while deciding appeal on
merits. In substance, the review petition does not disclose any
ground which can be said to be a valid ground for exercising
review jurisdiction.
11.We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record of writ petition as also order under review.
12. It is well settled that review proceedings have to be strictly
confined to the ambit and scope of Order 47 Rule 1 of the
Code of Civil Procedure 1908 (for short ‘CPC’), according to
which, an order or judgment may be open to review inter alia if
there is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the
record. An error which is not self-evident and has to be
detected by a process of reasoning can hardly be said to be
an error apparent on the face of the record justifying the court
to exercise its power of review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. In
exercise of this jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC it is not
permissible for an erroneous decision to be 'reheard and
corrected'. A review petition has a limited purpose and cannot
be allowed to be 'an appeal in disguise.
13. In Parsion Devi and others vs. Sumitri Devi and others,
reported in 1997 (8) SCC 715, Hon’ble Supreme Court while
discussing the scope and ambit of review has held as under:"9. Under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC a judgment may be
open to review inter alia if there is a mistake or an
error apparent on the face of the record. An error
which is not self-evident and has to be detected by a
process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error
apparent on the face of the record justifying the Court
to exercise its power of review under Order 47, Rule 1
CPC. In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47,
Rule 1 CPC it is not permissible for an erroneous
decision to be "reheard and corrected". There is a
clear distinction between an erroneous decision and
an error apparent on the face of the record. While the
first can be corrected by the higher forum, the latter
only can be corrected by exercise of the review
jurisdiction. A review petition has a limited purpose and
cannot be allowed to be "an appeal in disguise"."
14. In case of State of West Bengal and others vs Kamal
Sengupta and another reported in (2008) 8 SCC 612, it was
observed thus:“15. The term `mistake or error apparent' by its very
connotation signifies an error which is evident per se
from the record of the case and does not require
detailed examination, scrutiny and elucidation either of
the facts or the legal position. If an error is not selfevident and detection thereof requires long debate and
process of reasoning, it cannot be treated as an error
apparent on the face of the record for the purpose of
Order 47 Rule 1 CPC or Section 22 (3) (f) of the Act. To
put it differently an order or decision or judgment cannot
be corrected merely because it is erroneous in law or on
the ground that a different view could have been taken
by the Court/Tribunal on a point of fact or law. In any
case, while exercising the power of review, the
concerned Court/Tribunal cannot sit in appeal over its
judgment/decision.”
15. In case of Asharfi Devi (dead) through Lrs Vs. State of
Uttar Pradesh and Ors, reported in (2019) 5 SCC 86, it was
held thus:“18. It is a settled law that every error whether factual
or legal cannot be made subject matter of review
under Order 47 Rule 1 of the Code though it can be
made subject matter of appeal arising out of such
order. In other words, in order to attract the provisions
of Order 47 Rule 1 of the Code, the error/mistake
must be apparent on the face of the record of the
case.”
16. In case of Shanti Conductors Pvt. Ltd. vs. Assam State
Electricity Board and others, reported in (2020) 2 SCC 677,
it was held thus:“25. …....The scope of review has been reiterated by
this Court from time to time. It is sufficient to refer the
judgment of this Court in Parsion Devi and Others Vs.
Sumitri Devi and Others, (1997) 8 SCC 715, wherein in
paragraph 9 following has been laid down:
“9. Under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC a judgment may
be open to review inter alia if there is a mistake
or an error apparent on the face of the record. An
error which is not self- evident and has to be
detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly
be said to be an error apparent on the face of the
record justifying the court to exercise its power of
review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. In exercise
of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC it is
not permissible for an erroneous decision to be
“reheard and corrected”. A review petition, it must
be remembered has a limited purpose and
cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in disguise”.”
17. Keeping in mind the above settled principles of law relating to
exercise of power of review of an order, the present review
preferred by the petitioner is to be considered.
18. Upon perusal of the judgment under review, we find that the
Court, while dismissing miscellaneous appeal of petitioner
herein, heard the learned counsel for the parties and taken into
consideration the material brought on record by respective
parties. Grounds raised in review petition and argument
advanced by learned counsel for petitioner referring to Section
45-A and Section 93A of the Act of 1956, were considered by
the Court in Para No.8 onward of the judgment under review
and it was concluded that the Corporation was justified in
fastening liability upon the petitioner under Section 93A of the
Act of 1956 and directing recovery of contribution amount of
ESI from the petitioner beyond five years from the date on
which the amount of ESI became payable. Therefore, the
aforementioned grounds would not come to the aid of the
petitioner as it would amount to re-appreciation of evidence on
record which would not be available to be done even in appeal
much less in exercising review jurisdiction.
19. A review petition is not intended to be a re-hearing of the
proceeding nor is the petitioner entitled to deem it to be a
second
opportunity
for
advancing
stale
and
rejected
arguments, which have been heard at length after due
consideration by the Division Bench. A judgment / order may
be wrong, erroneous, incorrect, legally untenable, etc. but
nevertheless remains a valid judgment in the eyes of law
against which the only course available for the aggrieved party
is to go in appeal against the same. In the case of Surendra
Kumar Vakil & Ors. Vs. Chief Executive Officer, MP and
Ors., reported in (2004) 10 SCC 126, Hon'ble Supreme Court
has held thus:“10........A point that has been heard and decided
cannot form a ground for review even if assuming
that the view taken in the judgment under review is
erroneous.”
20. So far as other grounds urged in review petition, that is to say,
grounds relating to alleged wrongful invocation of Section 45A
instead of Section 75 (2)(a); alleged non-service of notice;
alleged non-satisfaction of pre-conditions under Section 45A;
assessment allegedly not based on wages under Section 39;
alleged infirmity under Section 93A on account of two units;
alleged bar under Section 22 of the SICA, are concerned,
during course of arguments, learned counsel for petitioner
submits that he is pressing this review petition only on the
ground relating to Section 45A and 93A of the Act of 1956.
Even, it is not the case of petitioner that aforementioned
grounds were raised in memo of appeal but the same were
entirely overlooked and left completely unconsidered while
arriving at its conclusion. Appeal was preferred proposing
following substantial questions of law:“A. Whether a demand, recovery and order dated
13.12.2005
determining
employees
employers
contribution on the basis of balance sheet and other
assets and not on the record of wages paid / period is
sustainable in law?
B. Whether the determination for a period 01.04.1998
to 31.03.1999 initiated vide notice dated15.02.2005 is
maintainable under Section 45A.
C. Whether the orders determining the liability is legal
and sustainable against the appellant without there
being any notice under Section C-18?”
21. In the case of Collector of 24 Parganas and others vs Lalith
Mohan Mullick and others, reported in 1988 (Suppl) SCC
578, Hon'ble Supreme Court, on the issue of new grounds
being raised in review petition, held as under: "So far as this ground is concerned, it was not raised
before this Court when the appeal was heard on
merits. It does not appear to have been raised even
before the High Court. The new ground cannot be
taken into consideration for the purposes of the
review application, apart from the fact that it would
also involve investigation of new facts which were not
on record till the point of time when the appeal was
disposed of by this Court on 13-2-1986. We see no
reason to entertain this review petition which
accordingly fails and is dismissed."
22. In case of Nehali Panjiyara & ors vs Shyama Devi & ors,
reported in (2002) 10 SCC 578 Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that entirely new grounds, not raised earlier during
regular hearing, cannot be raised for the first time in review. It
was observed thus:
"2. The review petition raises entirely a new point about
the extinction of the legal heirs in the line of
descendants of the estate represented by Gurudayal
Panjiara and Kunjlal Panjiara prior to the institution of
the suit and that the said estate stood inherited in
amongst the descendants of only Matuki Panjiara and
Ashrafi
Panjiara.
Such a
contention
was never
canvassed before any of the courts below. Not only
that, there was no issue sought for on this point even
before the trial court. In second appeal the only dispute
raised was regarding suit properties Items 2 to 8. The
High Court confirmed the decision about their partibility
in the light of the findings reached by the lower
appellate court which has noted in para 49 of its
judgment that defendant 2nd party admitted the
plaintiff's claim for Items 2 to 8 of the schedule.
3. Consequently, no case is made out for our
interference in the review proceedings on the
aforesaid new contention."
23. Cumulative effect of above discussion is that the grounds
pressed into service by learned counsel for petitioner during
course of hearing of this review petition and pleaded in this
review petition, are either new grounds, which are being raised
for the first time, or repetition of the grounds that were already
pleaded in memo of appeal, considered and decided by this
Court while deciding appeal.
24. In light of above decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court on the
scope and ambit of review and in the given facts of the case,
we do not find any good ground to exercise review jurisdiction
under Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC. Accordingly, the review petition
being sans merit is liable to be and is hereby dismissed. No
order asto costs.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
roshan/-
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review