Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 50 of 2019
Date of Decision: 17.05.2023
Shri. Abhishek Kumar
Vs.
North Eastern Electric Power
Corporation Ltd. (NEEPCO)
& Ors.
Coram:
Hon‟ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. P. Biswakarma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. V. K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. V. Kumar, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner being aggrieved with the downgrading in
his Annual Performance Appraisal Report (APAR), grading of the first
and second part from „Very Good‟ to „Good‟ for the period 01.04.2015
to 27.07.2015, and from „Outstanding‟ to „Good‟ for the period
28.07.2015 to 31.03.2016, has preferred the instant writ petition and
has also assailed the promotion order dated 18.04.2017, to the extent
that promotion be given w.e.f. 01.01.2016 with all consequential
benefits.
2.
The brief facts surrounding the case are that, the petitioner
who is presently holding the post of Senior Manager was posted under
the HR Department, during the period 01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015, and
thereafter was posted to the Vigilance Wing of the respondent
Corporation w.e.f. 28.07.2015. The APAR for the assessment year
2015-16 of the petitioner, therefore consisted of two periods, the first
being from 01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015, when the petitioner was in the
HR department with the General Manager (HR) as the Reporting
Officer and Director (Personnel) of the respondent Corporation being
the Reviewing and Accepting Authority of the petitioner. For the
second period, from 28.07.2015 to 31.03.2016, when the petitioner was
posted in the Vigilance Wing of the respondent Corporation, the
General Manager (E/M) was the Reporting Authority and the Chief
Vigilance Officer was the Reviewing and Accepting Authority of the
APAR of the petitioner.
3.
The grading of the APAR for the periods described above, the
consequent downgrading and the non-consideration of the APAR,
especially for the latter period that is, 28.07.2015 to 31.03.2016, by the
respondents which led to the supersession of the petitioner by his
juniors, are the main points in issue before this Court, along with the
other attendant facts and circumstances.
4.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms.
P. Biswakarma, learned counsel for the petitioner has opened his
submissions by contending that, the petitioner had been subjected to
discrimination and hostile treatment by the respondent Corporation,
which has resulted in his supersession in service by his juniors. The
main ground he submits rest upon the non-communication of the
downgrading from „Outstanding‟ to „Good‟ for the second period of
APAR, that is, 28.07.2016 to 31.03.2016, which he asserts was never
supplied or disclosed to him, not only prior to the convening of the
DPC meeting, but also denied despite filing of RTI application on
24.07.2017. The learned Senior counsel has referred to the RTI
application (Annexure – 18) and RTI appeal dated 22.06.2017
(Annexure – 20), which he submits the denial of information is in
violation of Rule 6.4.3 of the NEEPCO Promotion Policy, 1997 and the
settled position of law rendered in the following judgments:-
i)
Dev Dutt vs. Union of India & Ors., (2008) 8 SCC 725
ii)
Union of India & Ors. vs. Joseph K.S. [MC(WA) No.
64/2021] decided on 17.03.2022 by High Court of
Meghalaya.
5.
The learned Senior counsel then submits that, the harassment
and victimization of the petitioner was because he was posted in the
Vigilance Wing, but which however, should not have been the case,
inasmuch as, the Government of India, Central Vigilance Commission
to prevent such instances had issued a Circular being No. 16/3/06 on
28.03.2006, whereby it has been provided that, the ACR of personnel
working in the Vigilance Department will be written by the CVO and
reviewed by appropriate authority prescribed under the relevant
conduct rules. It has been further submitted that, the respondent
Corporation cannot take recourse to the All India Service (Performance
Appraisal Report) Rules, 2007, as the same are not applicable to the
respondent Corporation which has its own independent Promotion
Policy Rules, 1997. This argument he submits is in view of the fact
that, the Chief Vigilance Officer, who was the Reviewing Officer, had
accepted the APAR on 14.10.2016, that is, after more than 1(one)
month of being transferred from the post of CVO to Tripura, which was
a ground taken by the respondent Corporation, to treat the said APAR
for this period as unenforceable under Clause 6 of the All India Service
(Performance Appraisal Report) Rules, 2007. He further submits that,
even if the said rules are applicable, the CVO was only transferred on
05.07.2016, but still in service, had also written the APAR for four
officers including the petitioner, and the others apart from the writ
petitioner‟s APAR were accepted, which shows that treating the second
period of APAR as unenforceable is not only unreasonable, but
arbitrary.
6.
The learned Senior counsel submits that, under Rule 6.4.3 of
the NEEPCO Promotion Policy, 1997, the second APAR should have
been accepted as it is of the longer period for the assessment year 201516, and the consideration of the first period only which is shorter by the
respondent Corporation is contrary in its own rules, and as such, bad in
law. It is also been argued that, the petitioner‟s case for promotion did
not receive proper consideration, as it was not considered on merit for
promotion w.e.f. 01.01.2016, in view of the fact that, there was no
rejection on merit by the DPC, in its first sitting on 03.02.2017, but the
non-finalization was due to the fact that, the DPC was not properly
constituted, and as such, in the review DPC held on 17.04.2017, this
anomaly should have been corrected. To further buttress his points, the
learned Senior counsel submits that, had his case for promotion been
rejected on merit by the DPC in its first sitting, as per the Rules 7B and
24, he would not been entitled to be considered again for promotion in
the review DPC dated 17.04.2017. Hence, he submits there is no denial
that, the petitioner is entitled for promotion w.e.f. 01.01.2016, and not
from 01.07.2016, as allowed by the respondent Corporation.
7.
The learned Senior counsel submits that, the writ petitioner
was entitled to higher grading/points, as per Rule 6.4.3 of the NEEPCO
Promotion Policy, 1997, as his APAR grades for the year 2013-14 is
„Very Good‟, 2014-15 „Outstanding‟ and 2015-16 „Outstanding‟, which
was however denied by the respondents, by treating the second APAR
written by the CVO as non-enforceable and merely treated the entire
2015-16 as only „Good‟, as revealed by the RTI reply. He submits that,
had the initial entries not been downgraded, the grading/points would
have been much higher. Apart from other submissions made, such as,
the improper constitution of the meeting in arriving at a decision, due to
the absence of independent Directors and the fact that, no resolution
was adopted by the Board, with regard to the promotion order dated
18.04.2017, the impugned order was vitiated and liable to be interfered
with.
8.
Mr. V.K. Jindal, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. V.
Kumar, learned counsel for the respondent Corporation submits that,
for the period commencing 01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015, the petitioner
was posted at HR Department of the respondent Corporation and
during this period the General Manager (HR) was the Reporting Officer
and the Director (Personnel) was the Reviewing and Accepting
Authority. It is submitted that, the Reporting Officer for the said period
01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015 had graded the petitioner as „Very Good‟ and
had allotted 67.1 marks, with the remark “Needs supervision.
Generally,
a
good
Officer”,
which
on
perusal
by
the
Reviewing/Accepting Officer was moderated on an independent
assessment to „Good‟ and allotted 57 marks. It is submitted that, the
moderation in the grade made by the Director (Personnel) was well
within his rights, as per Rule 6.4.3 of the Rules of 1997, and that the
APAR being for the period of less than 3(three) months was not
required to be communicated to the petitioner.
9.
For the second period of the APAR, that is, 28.07.2015 to
31.03.2016, while the petitioner was posted at the Vigilance Wing, the
learned Senior counsel submits that the General Manager (E/M) was
the Reporting Officer and the Chief Vigilance Officer was the
Reviewing/Accepting Authority, and that, in the event of inconsistency
between the assessment of the Reporting Officer and the Reviewing
Officer, the CMD of the respondent Corporation was required to
resolve the issue, as per the Circular No. 16/3/06 dated 28.03.2006. It is
submitted that, the petitioner initiated the APAR for the second part
only on 26.09.2016, after expiry of 6 (six) months of the assessment
year 2015-16, that too at a time when the Reviewing/Accepting Officer
(CVO) had already been transferred on 04.07.2016, and the CVO on
17.10.2016, 1(one) month after demitting office as CVO, made his own
assessment and upgraded the grading of the writ petitioner from „Very
Good‟ to „Outstanding‟, and had remarked therein that, the Reporting
Officer had under assessed the Officer reported upon.
10.
It has further been submitted that, the CMD on the APAR
being forwarded to him, then on 14.10.2016, accepted only the marks
awarded by the Reporting Officer, and declined to accept the marks and
grading of the Reviewing/Accepting Authority, in pursuance to Rule 6
of the All India Service (Performance Appraisal Report) Rules, 2007.
This he contends, was in view of the fact that, the said Appraisal Report
Rules
provided
that,
it
shall
not
be
competent
for
the
Reviewing/Accepting Authority to review any Performance Appraisal
Report, after 1(one) month from the date of demitting office.
Accordingly, he submits, the assessment and upgradation by the CVO
was treated as unenforceable, as he had been transferred and had
reviewed the APAR of the petitioner after 1(one) month demitting
office. He therefore submits that, the allegation of the writ petitioner
that the downgrading was done without competency is incorrect and as
the said period that is, 28.07.2015 to 31.03.2016, being treated as
unenforceable, the APAR of the petitioner for the period under HR
Department that is, 01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015, was only taken into
consideration by the DPC.
11.
On the claim of the petitioner that, his promotion from the
post of Manager (HR) to Senior Manager (HR), be treated to be w.e.f.
01.01.2016 notionally with all financial benefits, it is submitted that,
the petitioner is not entitled to the same, as he was not recommended
by a second DPC, having not secured the requisite marks in the
interview, after the first DPC had been annulled on his objection due to
irregular constitution. The learned Senior counsel submits that, the
denial of promotion as alleged by the petitioner to be due to the
downgrading of his APAR, is factually incorrect, inasmuch as,
promotion of Executives is based on many other parameters, and not
confined to the APAR, which is just one of the parameters. It is further
submitted that, the contention of the writ petitioner that, the third DPC
that was constituted, wherein he was recommended for promotion is a
Review DPC is incorrect, as a Review DPC is constituted only under
Rule 23 of the NEEPCO (Promotion Policy Rules), 1997, and as such,
the third DPC was a fresh DPC and there was no violation of the Rules,
1997, in constituting the same.
12.
The learned Senior counsel on the other grounds set up by the
petitioner that is, being placed junior to similarly situated executives
submits that the same is not sustainable, as on not being recommended
for promotion by the second DPC, the petitioner did not assail the
promotion orders emanating therefrom, and as such, he being promoted
on a later date is bound to be placed below earlier similarly situated
executives in the inter-se seniority list in the cadre. The learned Senior
counsel has referred to the case of A.K. Soumini vs. State Bank of
Travancore and another reported in (2003) 7 SCC 238, to support his
arguments of the non-entitlement of the petitioner to retrospective
service benefits. The learned Senior counsel then concludes his
arguments by submitting that, the petitioner was rightly promoted to the
post of Senior Manager (HR) w.e.f. 01.07.2016, with financial benefits
from the date of joining the said post vide promotional order on
18.04.2017, and as such, there has been no deprivation of his rights, nor
has any rule been violated.
13.
Heard the learned counsels for the parties.
14.
Before adverting to the facts in detail, it can be easily
discerned that the entire subject matter in controversy, is the
consideration and non-consideration of the relevant APAR of the writ
petitioner for the period of 2015-2016, by the respondent Corporation.
As has been noted earlier, the petitioner was posted for the first period
of over 3(three) months of the relevant assessment year, from
01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015 in the HR Department. A perusal of the
APAR for this period reflects that the petitioner was graded „Very
Good‟ by the Reporting Officer, though with a remark “Needs
supervision. Generally, a Good Officer”. However, the Reviewing
and Accepting authority i.e. the Director of Personnel, downgraded the
grading given by the Reporting Officer from „Very Good‟ to „Good‟.
In the reviewing column, it was remarked as follows:“He has sharp declining trend in his performance. An
average performer who needs to be constantly monitored &
supervised. Work endorsed directly by DP could not be done
by him in time.”
In the column where the grade was moderated it has been
remarked as follows :“The rating “VG, 67” given by GM is on higher side which
contradicts his remarks “Needs Supervision”. Hence rated
“Good 57” Director Personnel.”
Thus, the grading of the petitioner for the first period was
„Good‟ on being downgraded from „Very Good‟.
15.
For the second period i.e. from 28.07.2015 to 31.03.2015, the
petitioner who was posted in the Vigilance Department, was graded as
„Very Good‟, by the Reporting Officer, but the Reviewing and Accepting
authority at that point of time the CVO, upgraded the grading of „Very
Good‟ to „Outstanding‟. In the reviewing column it was recorded as
follows:“The reporting officer has under-assessed the officer
reported upon. I had personally supervised the work and
conduct of the officer reported upon- the reporting officer
was generally out of the picture. OUTSTANDING officer
with 90 POINTS; Has „INTEGRITY‟; KNOWLEDGE, and
DILIGENCE with CAPACITY TO TAKE A PRINCIPLED
STAND”.
The above was thereafter accepted.
16.
It appears that the above upgradation was not accepted by the
CMD, who instead accepted the marks awarded by the Reporting Officer,
citing the ground that the same was as per the All India Service
(Performance Appraisal Report) Rules, 2007 meaning thereby the
petitioner remained at the grade „Very Good‟. Added to this state of
affairs, the DPC that sat to consider promotions as per the stand of the
respondent Corporation, did not take this second APAR into consideration,
but considered only the first period of APAR for this purpose. Another
significant fact as has been pleaded, which has not only not been denied,
but in fact admitted by the respondents, is that the APAR for the entire
assessment year was never communicated to the petitioner.
17.
This Court while going through the materials as placed has noted,
that as submitted by the petitioner the respondent Corporation, is governed
by its own Promotion Policy and Rules, 1997 which is applicable to all
employees of the Corporation, including the petitioner. Rule 6.4.3 deals
with the APAR i.e. the Annual Performance Appraisal Report. Para 3 of
the said Rule reads as follows:“Annual Performance Appraisal Report for any period of
less than 3(three) months in an appraisal year will not be
taken into consideration for the purse of promotion.
However, where two or more reports are written in any
appraisal year by reason of an employee being posted under
deferent Reporting/Reviewing/Accepting officers a single
rating for a year will be determined by the Departmental
Promotion Committee.”
18.
With regard to adverse remarks in the Performance Appraisal, it
has been laid down as follows:“ADVERSE
APPRAISAL
REMARKS
IN
A
PERFORMANCE
When adverse remarks in the appraisal reports of the
employee concerned have not been communicated to him,
this fact should be taken note of by the DPC while assessing
the suitability of the employee for promotion.
In case where a decision on the representation of an
employee against adverse remarks has not been taken or
time allowed for submission of representation is not over, the
DPC may at their discretion defer the consideration of the
case until a decision on the representation is finally taken.
Employees whose latest performance appraisal or special
Report contains adverse remarks will not be considered for
promotion and the DPC may keep this aspect in view while
assessing the suitability and recommending for promotion.”
19.
The respondent Corporation, however, it is noted have taken
recourse to the All-India Service (Performance Appraisal Report) Rules,
2007, to validate their action of treating the APAR for the second period as
unenforceable, on the ground that the Reviewing authority (CVO) had
reviewed the APAR, 1(one) month after being transferred. The
applicability of these Rules have also been challenged by the writ petitioner
on the ground that firstly, the Review and Acceptance by the said CVO,
with regard to other vigilance staff was promptly accepted and it is also
noted further that, at that point of time the writ petitioner was under
suspension, and as such, the APAR could be submitted earlier, and it was
only after this Court set aside the suspension and transfer vide common
judgment dated 18.08.2016, passed in WP(C) No. 199 of 2016 and WP(C)
No. 200 of 2016, that effective steps could be taken. It is also noted that the
APAR of the writ petitioner was forwarded by the Reporting Officer, along
with that of the other Vigilance Officers to the then CVO, but that, only the
case of the writ petitioner was taken to be unenforceable by application of
the said Appraisal Rules, 2007. The relevant rule i.e. Rule 6 (4) relied upon
by the respondent is reproduced hereinbelow:“6. Review of the performance appraisal report.- (1) The
reviewing authority shall record his remarks on the
performance appraisal report, within the timeframe specified
in the Schedule 2.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rules (1) and
(2), it shall not be competent for the reviewing authority or
the accepting authority to review any such performance
appraisal report(a) Where the authority reviewing the performance appraisal
report is a Government servant, after one month of his
retirement from service, and
(b) In other cases, after one month of the date on which he
demits office.”
20.
Even if the All India Service (Performance Appraisal Report)
Rules, 2007 are said to be applicable, the manner in which the same has
been applied has no doubt raised many questions as to the bonafides of the
respondents. This observation is made in view of the fact that, firstly, the
said APAR for the period that was treated as unenforceable, was never
disclosed to the writ petitioner. Secondly, in the said APAR the Reporting
authority is still with the respondent Corporation, and the then CVO who
was transferred was also still in Government service, and had not demitted
office to come within the said meaning of Rule 6(4)(b) of the Appraisal
Rules, 2007. Thirdly, the manner in which the CMD disregarded the
upgradation and remarks of the CVO, while downgrading from
„Outstanding‟ to „Good‟ and that too without communication of the same
to the writ petitioner, to allow him an opportunity to represent against, is
clearly arbitrary and unsustainable in law.
21.
With the second period of APAR being treated as unenforceable,
it was incumbent upon the respondent authorities to communicate the first
period of APAR to the writ petitioner, instead of hiding behind the excuse
that the same being of 3(three) months duration, was not necessary to be
communicated, when infact the DPC itself, had taken this period of APAR
i.e. from 01.04.2015 to 27.07.2015 into account, while considering the
promotion of the writ petitioner. This action itself militates against the
Promotion Policy and Rules of the respondent Corporation itself, which as
quoted hereinabove, Rule 6.4.3 has clearly stipulated that when adverse
remarks in the appraisal reports of the employee concerned have not been
communicated to him, this fact should be taken note of by the DPC while
assessing the suitability of the employee for promotion and further, in case
where a decision on the representation of an employee against adverse
remarks has not been taken, or time allowed for submission of
representation is not over, the DPC may at their discretion defer the
consideration of the case until a decision on the representation is finally
taken.
22.
With all these incongruities, lapses and patent illegalities, that
have occurred in the exercise of assessment of the writ petitioner in the
APAR by the respondent Corporation, this Court need not go any further to
touch the other issues as raised, as to whether the writ petitioner was
subsequently promoted by a fresh DPC, or whether the same was done by
way of a review DPC. The glaring facts that have emerged from the entire
sequence of events, will surely call for interference by this Court and for
appropriate directions to be issued to the respondent Corporation to
undertake corrective measures. Without alluding to the precedents in law
both of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court and of this Court on this point, the
position of law being well settled, this writ petition is allowed with the
following directions:(i)
the respondents shall formally communicate the APAR for
both periods of the assessment year 2015-16, to the writ petitioner,
within a period of 2(two) weeks of this order.
(ii)
the writ petitioner shall thereafter be allowed to represent
against the same, within a period of 4(four) weeks thereafter, of
formal receipt of the APAR.
(iii)
the respondents on receipt of the representation shall decide on
the same within 2(two) weeks thereafter.
23.
It is further directed that, should the entries be upgraded in
consideration of the representation and also taking into account the
petitioner‟s earlier APARs, the respondent authorities shall constitute a
review DPC for consideration of the petitioner‟s promotion w.e.f.
01.01.2016, along with all consequential reliefs. It is also directed that
before such exercise, a reasoned determination shall be undertaken by the
DPC, as to which single rating for the assessment year will be applied in
the consideration of the said promotion, in accordance with Rule 6.4.3 of
the Promotion Policy and Rules (NEEPCO). The entire exercise shall be
completed within a period of 6(six) months, from the date of receipt of the
representation from the writ petitioner.
24.
For the foregoing reasons and as ordered above, the writ
petition stands allowed to the extent indicated above, and is accordingly
disposed of.
25.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
17.05.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review