Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/16
GAHC010248272022
2026:GAU-AS:14087
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7806/2022
ABDUR RAHMAN AND ANR.
S/O ABDUL MOZID,
VILL.- UTTAR KHATOWAI,
P.O.- UTTAR KHATOWAI,
P.S.- RUPAHI,
DIST.- NAGAON, ASSAM, PIN- 782124.
2: ON THE DEATH OF MD. WAIZ UDDIN HIS LEGAL HEIRS
2.1) JAYGUN NESSA
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
W/O - LATE WAIZ UDDIN
VILL.- KARAYGUARI
PUB-SALPARA
P.O.- PUB-SALPARA
P.S.- RUPAHI
DIST.- NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782125.
2.2: SRI HUSANE MUBARAK
S/O- LATE WAIZ UDDIN
VILL.- KARAYGUARI
PUB-SALPARA
P.O.- PUB-SALPARA
P.S.- RUPAHI
DIST.- NAGAON
Page No.# 2/16
ASSAM
PIN- 782125.
2.3: AJAHAR UDDIN
S/O- LATE WAIZ UDDIN
VILL.- KARAYGUARI
PUB-SALPARA
P.O.- PUB-SALPARA
P.S.- RUPAHI
DIST.- NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782125.
2.4: AZIMUL HOQUE
S/O- LATE WAIZ UDDIN
VILL.- KARAYGUARI
PUB-SALPARA
P.O.- PUB-SALPARA
P.S.- RUPAHI
DIST.- NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782125.
2.5: EKRAMUL HOQUE
S/O- LATE WAIZ UDDIN
VILL.- KARAYGUARI
PUB-SALPARA
P.O.- PUB-SALPARA
P.S.- RUPAHI
DIST.- NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782125
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS.
Page No.# 3/16
REP. BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, PUBLIC
WORKS DEPTT., DISPUR, GUWAHATI- 6, DIST.- KAMRUP.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
FINANACE DEPTT.
GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 6
DIST.- KAMRUP.
3:THE UNDER SECRETARY
GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT. (AUDIT BRANCH)
DISPUR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM.
4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT. (ROADS)
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI
DIST.- KAMRUP.
5:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
NAGAON.
6:THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
PWD NAGAON ROAD CIRCLE
NAGAON
ASSAM.
7:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
KALIABOR RURAL ROAD DIVIDION
JAKHALABANDHA
NAGAON
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. T SK, Ms. R. R. BORAH,MR. I ALAM
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, SC, FINANCE,SC, PWD
Page No.# 4/16
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
10.09.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment :
23.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
:
No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
Judgment & Order (CAV)
Heard Mr. I. Alam, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. R.
Dhar, learned Standing Counsel, PWD, appearing for respondent Nos. 1, 3, 4, 6
& 7, and Mr. R. Borpujari, learned Standing Counsel, Finance Department,
appearing for respondent No. 2.
It may be noted that during the pendency of the writ petition, petitioner No.
2, Md. Waiz Uddin, expired on 25.12.2024. His legal heirs were substituted in
his place vide order dated 03.03.2025 passed in I.A.(Civil) No.328/2025 and
were brought on record as petitioner Nos. 2(a) to 2(e).
2.
By filing this writ petition, the petitioners have prayed for a direction to the
respondent authorities to correct their dates of birth in the relevant service
records, namely, 28.02.1972 in respect of petitioner No. 1 and 31.10.1970 in
respect of late petitioner No. 2, Md. Waiz Uddin, and to accordingly correct their
dates of superannuation as 20.02.2032 and 31.10.2030 respectively, and to
release the salaries and other admissible service benefits withheld from them,
on the ground that their dates of birth have been incorrectly recorded in the list
Page No.# 5/16
of regularized Muster Roll Workers prepared by the PWD (Audit), wherein their
dates of
superannuation were shown as 28.02.2017 and 31.10.2016
respectively, despite the aforesaid correct dates of birth having been recorded in
their service books and the petitioners having been allowed to continue in
service.
3.
The case of the petitioners in a nutshell is that petitioner No. 1 was initially
engaged as a Muster Roll Worker on 13.08.1991 and petitioner No. 2 was
engaged on 01.01.1992 under the Kaliabor Rural Road Division, PWD,
Jakhalabandha, Nagaon District. Their services were subsequently regularized
with effect from 20.07.2005 pursuant to Government letter dated 30.09.2005
and Finance Department letter dated 22.08.2005, the petitioners having been
engaged prior to 01.04.1993. Following their regularization, the petitioners
joined their respective posts and continued in service under the said Division.
4.
At the time of their engagement and thereafter upon regularization, the
petitioners furnished the necessary documents relating to their service
particulars. Their service books were accordingly prepared, wherein the date of
birth of petitioner No. 1 was recorded as 28.02.1972 and that of petitioner No. 2
as 31.10.1970. The petitioners state that the said entries continued to remain in
their service records and were periodically attested by the departmental
authorities. Identity cards were also issued to the petitioners reflecting the
aforesaid dates of birth.
5.
It is stated that discrepancies were noticed in the names and dates of birth
of certain regularized Muster Roll Workers. In connection with such
discrepancies, the department initiated steps for correction and modification of
the relevant particulars. By letter dated 28.05.2008, a report and proforma of
details containing the particulars of the concerned workers, along with
Page No.# 6/16
supporting documents, were forwarded for necessary correction. The matter
thereafter remained under consideration at different levels of the department.
6.
Subsequently, a list of the regularized Muster Roll Workers was prepared by
the PWD (Audit), wherein the dates of superannuation of the petitioners were
shown as 28.02.2017 and 31.10.2016 respectively. The petitioners state that the
said dates were incorrect and did not correspond with the dates of birth
recorded in their service books. Despite the discrepancy, the petitioners were
permitted to continue in service. Their salaries, however, were stopped. The
petitioners also rely upon their Provident Fund records, wherein their dates of
birth were reflected as 28.02.1972 and 31.10.1970 respectively.
7.
The petitioners further state that, in view of the discrepancy in their service
particulars, an enquiry was undertaken through the Deputy Commissioner,
Nagaon, pursuant to letter dated 06.06.2016. In the course of the said enquiry,
ossification tests were conducted on 21.08.2018, pursuant to which the age of
the petitioners was assessed to be between 40 and 50 years. The report of the
ossification test was submitted on 10.09.2018. Thereafter, the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Nagaon, directed production of the service books of the
petitioners for verification of their dates of birth.
8.
Upon verification of the relevant records, the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Nagaon, submitted a report dated 01.12.2018 recording the date
of birth of petitioner No. 1 as 28.02.1972 and that of petitioner No. 2 as
31.10.1970 and forwarded the same for necessary correction of their service
particulars. Thereafter, the Under Secretary, PWD (Audit), by letter dated
04.03.2019, sought further verification and point-wise comments along with the
relevant supporting documents. In response thereto, the Executive Engineer,
Kaliabor Rural Road Division, by letter dated 04.04.2019, furnished the
Page No.# 7/16
necessary clarification and certified, on the basis of the office records, that the
entries appearing at Sl. Nos. 129 and 131 related to the same persons, namely,
the petitioners, whose names and dates of birth had been proposed for
correction. The said clarification was accordingly forwarded to the higher
authorities for necessary action.
9.
It is the case of the petitioners that despite the aforesaid verification and
the dates of birth recorded in their service books, the necessary correction was
not carried out and their salaries remained withheld. The petitioners had earlier
instituted W.P.(C) No.4160/2019 questioning the action of the authorities. The
said writ petition was subsequently withdrawn by order dated 29.11.2022 with
liberty to the petitioners to take appropriate steps, as certain inadvertent clerical
mistakes had occurred in the translated copy of the relevant document. It is in
the aforesaid background that the present writ petition has been filed seeking
correction of the dates of birth and consequential dates of superannuation of
the petitioners and release of the salary and other admissible benefits due to
them.
10. Mr. I. Alam, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the dates of
birth of the petitioners, i.e. on 28.02.1972 in respect of petitioner No. 1 and
31.10.1970 in respect of petitioner No. 2, are recorded in their respective
service books. Learned counsel submits that the process for correction of the
particulars was initiated by the department itself by letter dated 28.05.2008 and
that the petitioners' case was included in the said process. It is submitted that
the subsequent enquiry conducted through the district administration also
verified the dates of birth recorded in the service books.
11. Learned counsel submits that the proposal for correction did not originate
in the year 2016, as stated by the Finance Department, but had its origin in the
Page No.# 8/16
departmental letter dated 28.05.2008. It is submitted that the petitioners had
not themselves approached the authorities seeking alteration of their dates of
birth and that the subsequent enquiry and verification were undertaken
pursuant to the departmental process. Learned counsel further submits that the
report dated 01.12.2018 of the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon,
recorded the same dates of birth as those entered in the service books.
12. Learned counsel places reliance upon the judgment of this Court in Mohan
Chandra Das v. The Director, State Transport, Assam & Anr., reported
in ALR 1969 Assam and Nagaland 259, and submits that the date of birth
recorded in the service book is required to be accepted prima facie unless
altered after following the procedure prescribed under S.R. 8(c). It is submitted
that where such entry is disputed, the competent authority is required to hold
an enquiry and afford reasonable opportunity to the employee.
13. Learned counsel also places reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Hari Singh v. State of Bihar, (2000) 10 SCC 284, and
submits that an employee cannot be prematurely retired by treating a date of
birth different from the one recorded in the service book as correct without
putting the employee on notice. It is submitted that in the said case, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court set aside the alteration of the date of birth and the
consequential premature retirement of the employee.
14.
Learned counsel further submits that the petitioners were permitted to
continue in service even after the incorrect dates of superannuation reflected in
the PWD (Audit) list and had continued to discharge their duties. Having
accepted their services, the respondents could not withhold their salaries for the
period during which the petitioners actually worked. It is submitted that the
petitioners had continued to render service and that the process for correction
Page No.# 9/16
of their dates of birth had been initiated by the department itself. Learned
counsel accordingly submits that the petitioners are entitled to the reliefs sought
in the writ petition.
15.
Mr. R. Dhar, learned Standing Counsel, PWD, appearing for respondent
Nos. 1, 3, 4, 6 & 7, submits that the services of the petitioners were regularized
vide Government letter dated 30.09.2005 and, on the basis of their school
certificates, their dates of birth were recorded as 28.02.1972 and 31.10.1970
respectively. Learned Standing Counsel submits that certain anomalies in the
names and dates of birth of some regularized employees were noticed and the
department initiated the process for correction by letter dated 28.05.2008. It is
also submitted that most of the office records, including the records relating to
the employees, were completely damaged in the flood at Jakhalabandha on
13.08.2017.
16.
Learned Standing Counsel further submits that, in continuation of the
aforesaid process, a proposal for correction and modification of the names and
dates of birth of the concerned employees was forwarded on 24.12.2015 and,
pursuant to the communication dated 01.04.2016, verification was undertaken
through the Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon, who submitted his report dated
01.12.2018. The said report was forwarded to the PWRD (Audit) Branch on
27.12.2018, following which further clarification was sought on 04.03.2019 and
the department furnished its reply on 04.04.2019. It is submitted that the
Finance Department, vide endorsement dated 31.05.2019, regretted its inability
to consider the proposal for correction of the dates of birth, which was
thereafter communicated by the Under Secretary, PWRD (Audit Branch), vide
communication dated 20.06.2019. Learned Standing Counsel further submits
that, as the matter is sub judice, no direction had been received from the
Page No.# 10/16
Government for release of the salary of the petitioners.
17. Mr. R. Borpujari, learned Standing Counsel, Finance Department, for
respondent No. 2, submits that under S.R. 8(c) of the Fundamental Rules and
Subsidiary Rules, a request for change of date of birth is required to be made
within three years of actual superannuation. Learned Standing Counsel submits
that the petitioners had superannuated on 16.02.2017 and 31.10.2016
respectively, whereas the proposal for correction was received by the Finance
Department only on 08.02.2019. It is submitted that, as the proposal had been
processed by the PWD from the year 2016, the Finance Department regretted
its inability to consider the same under S.R. 8(c).
18. I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties and have perused the materials available on record.
19. Upon consideration of the materials available on record, it is noticed that
the same discloses that the dates of birth of the petitioners were recorded in
their respective service books as 28.02.1972 in respect of petitioner No. 1 and
31.10.1970 in respect of petitioner No. 2. The affidavit-in-opposition filed by
respondent No. 4 also confirms that the said dates of birth were recorded in the
service particulars on the basis of the school certificates submitted by the
petitioners. Thus, the dates of birth relied upon by the petitioners are supported
by the service records maintained by the department itself.
20. The record further reveals that discrepancies in the names and dates of
birth of certain regularized Muster Roll Workers were noticed by the department
and, accordingly, the department initiated the process for correction and
modification of such particulars by letter dated 28.05.2008. The petitioners'
particulars were included in the said process. The correction proceedings,
Page No.# 11/16
therefore, cannot be said to have originated from any request made by the
petitioners at the fag end of their service.
21. In continuation of the aforesaid process, the department forwarded a
proposal for correction and modification of the names and dates of birth of the
concerned
employees
by
letter
dated
24.12.2015.
Pursuant
to
the
communication dated 01.04.2016 issued by the Under Secretary, PWRD (Audit)
Branch, the matter was taken up with the Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon, for
verification. An enquiry was accordingly undertaken. In the course thereof,
ossification tests were conducted on 21.08.2018, the report whereof was
submitted on 10.09.2018, and the age of the petitioners was assessed to be
between 40 and 50 years.
22. The service books of the petitioners were produced for verification and the
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner,
Nagaon,
submitted
the
report
dated
01.12.2018, recording the date of birth of petitioner No. 1 as 28.02.1972 and
that of petitioner No. 2 as 31.10.1970. The said report was forwarded by the
department to the PWRD (Audit) Branch on 27.12.2018. The Under Secretary,
PWRD (Audit) Branch, thereafter sought further verification and point-wise
comments by letter dated 04.03.2019, to which the Executive Engineer, Kaliabor
Rural Road Division, furnished a reply dated 04.04.2019. The Executive Engineer
certified, on the basis of the office records, that the entries at Sl. Nos. 129 and
131 related to the same persons whose names and dates of birth had been
proposed for correction.
23. The aforesaid sequence of events clearly negates the stand of the Finance
Department, in view of the fact that the department had initiated the process
for correction in 2008, the process was subsequently pursued through the
departmental authorities, and verification was undertaken through the district
Page No.# 12/16
administration. The enquiry ultimately resulted in a report recording the very
dates of birth which were already reflected in the service books. There is no
material on record to show that, upon such verification, the dates of birth
recorded in the service books were found to be incorrect.
24. In Mohan Chandra Das (Supra), this Court considered the provisions of
S.R. 8(c) of the Fundamental Rules and Subsidiary Rules in relation to alteration
of the date of birth recorded in the service book. The Court held that the date of
birth recorded in the service book has to be accepted prima facie unless the
same is altered after following the prescribed procedure. Where the recorded
date of birth is disputed and there is prima facie material supporting the claim,
an enquiry is required to be held in accordance with the rule and the principles
of natural justice are required to be followed.
25. The principle laid down in Mohan Chandra Das (Supra) is applicable to
the facts of the present case. The dates of birth recorded in the service books of
the petitioners were subjected to verification through the district administration.
The verification report dated 01.12.2018 recorded the same dates of birth as
those entered in the service books. No contrary finding has been placed before
this Court showing that the said entries were found to be incorrect after
following the procedure contemplated under S.R. 8(c).
26.
The objection raised by the Finance Department is with reference to S.R.
8(c) of the Fundamental Rules and Subsidiary Rules. The Finance Department
has stated that a request for change of the date of birth made within three
years of the date of actual superannuation should be entertained. It has further
stated that the dates of superannuation of the petitioners were 16.02.2017 and
31.10.2016 respectively, whereas the proposal for correction of their names and
dates of birth was received in the Finance Department on 08.02.2019.
Page No.# 13/16
27. The stand taken by the Finance Department cannot be accepted in the
facts of the present case. The receipt of the proposal in the Finance Department
on 08.02.2019 cannot be regarded as the relevant date of commencement of
the process for correction of the dates of birth. The records placed before the
Court clearly show that the process had commenced as early as 28.05.2008
with the issuance of the departmental letter. The subsequent proposal dated
24.12.2015 and the verification undertaken pursuant to the communication
dated 01.04.2016 were part of the same and continuing process.
28. It is noted that petitioners had not approached the authorities for alteration
of their dates of birth immediately before their alleged dates of superannuation.
The issue had already been taken up by the department years earlier because
discrepancies had been noticed in the particulars of regularized Muster Roll
Workers. The time taken thereafter in processing the departmental proposal,
conducting verification and obtaining the report of the district administration
cannot be prejudicially attributed to the petitioners.
29. In such circumstances, the limitation contemplated under S.R. 8(c) cannot
be applied merely by taking the date on which the proposal happened to finally
reach the Finance Department. To do so would be to disregard the fact that the
department itself had initiated the process for correction in 2008. The
subsequent receipt of the proposal by the Finance Department was only a stage
in the departmental process already set in motion years back.
30. There is also a discrepancy in the records regarding the date of
superannuation of petitioner No. 1. While the PWD (Audit) list reflects his date
of superannuation as 28.02.2017, the Finance Department has stated in its
affidavit-in-opposition that the same was 16.02.2017. Both dates, however,
require consideration in the context of the date of birth recorded in his service
Page No.# 14/16
book as 28.02.1972.
31.
More importantly, the petitioners were permitted to continue in service
even after the incorrect dates of superannuation reflected in the PWD (Audit)
list. Their continuation in service has not been disputed by the respondents. The
only explanation offered for non-release of salary is that the matter was sub
judice and that no direction had been received from the Government for release
of salary. There is, however, nothing on record to suggest that the petitioners
did not discharge their duties during the period for which salary has been
claimed.
32. Once the petitioners were permitted to continue in service and actually
discharged their duties, the salary payable for such period cannot be withheld
merely because the departmental process for correction of their service
particulars remained pending. The respondents cannot permit the petitioners to
continue to render service and thereafter deny payment for the service actually
rendered by them on the ground that the correction of the relevant records had
not been completed.
33.
The fact that substantial office records were damaged in the flood at
Jakhalabandha on 13.08.2017 does not alter the position either. The service
particulars and school certificates relied upon for recording the dates of birth
were available, and the dates of birth were subsequently verified through the
district administration. The damage to some of the records, therefore, cannot
displace the service-book entries which have otherwise remained supported by
the available records and the subsequent verification.
34. The materials on record, therefore, clearly establish that the dates of birth
of the petitioners were recorded in their service books as 28.02.1972 and
Page No.# 15/16
31.10.1970 respectively, that the department itself initiated the process for
correction of the relevant particulars in 2008, and that the subsequent
verification did not result in any finding that those dates of birth were incorrect.
The Finance Department declined to consider the proposal mainly on the ground
that the proposal reached it on 08.02.2019 after the dates of superannuation
relied upon by it. Such approach does not take into account the departmental
process which had commenced much earlier.
35.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds that the claim of the
petitioners for correction of their dates of birth is supported by the service
records as well as the subsequent verification undertaken by the authorities.
There is no material on record to establish that the dates of birth recorded in
the service books are incorrect. The petitioners are, therefore, entitled to
correction of their dates of birth in the relevant service records. Consequently,
the endorsement dated 31.05.2019 of the Finance Department, declining to
consider the proposal for correction of the dates of birth, as communicated by
the
Under
Secretary,
PWRD
(Audit
Branch),
Dispur,
Guwahati,
vide
communication dated 20.06.2019, cannot be sustained and is set aside.
36. Accordingly, the respondent authorities are directed to correct the date of
birth of petitioner No. 1 as 28.02.1972 and that of late Md. Waiz Uddin,
petitioner No. 2, as 31.10.1970 in their respective service records and other
relevant departmental records, including the PWD (Audit) records.
37.
Consequent upon such correction, the respondent authorities shall
determine the date of superannuation of petitioner No. 1 and, in respect of late
Md. Waiz Uddin, the date of his lawful superannuation, in accordance with the
applicable service rules and the corrected dates of birth, and shall make
necessary corrections in the relevant records.
Page No.# 16/16
38. The respondent authorities shall further calculate and release the salary
and other admissible service benefits due to petitioner No. 1 and, in respect of
late Md. Waiz Uddin, to his legal heirs, for the period during which the
petitioners continued in service and actually discharged their duties. The arrears
shall be calculated and released within a period of three months from the date
of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
39. The writ petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms. No order as to
costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review