Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 05 of 2023
Abdul Wahid through his L.Rs :
1a. Md. Taj Uddin (Son)
of West Batarashi, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
1b. Mst. Salma Khatun (Daughter),
wife of Jair Uddain @ Jair Ali
of Durgapur, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar, District- North Tripura
1c. Mst. Howarun Nechha,
wife of Late Abdul Wahid
of West Batarashi, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
1d. Md. Abdul Kadir,
Son of Late Abdul Wahid
of West Batarashi, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
Abdul Matilib through his L.Rs :
2a. Md. Sonai Mia (Son)
2b. Md. Nazrul Islam (Son)
2c. Md. Rahel Uddin (Son)
2d. Md. Fakrul Islam (Son)
2e. Rayna Bagam (Daughter)
wife of Abdul Hasib
2f. Mst. Astarun Nessa (Wife)
all Sl. No.1 to 6 are residents of
Village West Batarashi, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
2g. Mst. Bagam Bibi (Daughter)
wife of Inus Mia
of Village & P.O. Bhagyapur,
P.S. Dharmanagar
2h. Mst. Rashna Begam (Daughter),
wife of Abdul Ajid
of Village Latugaon, P.O. Dhupirband,
Lal Bherra, PS. Dharmanagar,
District- North Tripura
2i. Restana Bagam (Daughter),
wife of Rakman Ali
of Village & P.O. Churaibari,
District- North Tripura
*** In compliance with the Hon’ble Court’s order dated 20.07.2023
passed in I.A. No.02/2023 in C/W RFA 05/2023, the legal
representatives of appellant No.(3) Lt. Md. Abdul Awal Ali has been
substituted as follows :
3. ***
wife of late Hazi Manajir Ali
3(a) Ms. Hasnara Begam,
wife of late Md. Abdul Awal Ali,
3(b) Md. Sahajhan Ali
3(c) Md. Jamal Ahmed
3(d) Md. Joynal Abedin
all are sons of Late Md. Abdul Awal Ali
3(e) Ms. Khalida Parvin,
daughter of Late Md. Abdul Awal Ali
all are residence of West Batarashi,
P.O. Rajbari, P.S. Dharmanagar, North Tripura
4a. Sarful Alam
4b. Tahid Alam
4c. Jahangir Alam
son of Late Liakat Ali
4d. Mst. Mehonoma Khanam
4e. Mst. Ambia Khanam,
daughters of Late Liakat Ali
4f. Mst. Laili Begam,
wife of Late Liakat Ali
all of Village-Batrashi, P.O. Rajbari, Dharmanagar
5. Md. Burkan Uddin,
son of Late Hazi Manajir Ali
6. Mst. Khudeja Khanam,
wife of Md. Abdul Jalil,
daughter of Late Hazi Manajir Ali
all of Village & P.O. West Batarashi,
Rajbari, P.S. Dharmanagar, North Tripura District
7. Mst. Ayesa Begam,
wife of late Abdul Noor,
daughter of Late Hazi Manajir Ali
of Village & P.O. Latugaon, P.S. Dharmanagar,
District- North Tripura
8. Mst. Amina Khatun,
wife of Md. Farid Uddin,
daughter of Late Hazi Manijir Ali
of P.O. South Padmabil, P.S. Dharmanagar,
District- North Tripura
----Appellant(s)
Versus
Abdul Haque through his L.Rs :
1a. Mst. Kabutar Nechha (Wife)
1b. Md. Sahab Uddin (Son)
1c. Md. Siraj Uddin (Son)
1d. Mst. Samena Begam (Daughter-in-law)
1e. Md. Abu Mahammad Dilwar Hussain (Grandson)
1f. Md. Abu Saleh
1g. Md. Altar Hussain (Grandson)
1h. Mst. Mina Begam (Daughter-in-law)
1i. Md. Azhar Uddin (Grandson)
1j. Mst. Farida Parvin (Granddaughter)
all of Village-West Batarashi, P.S. Rajbari,
P.S. Dharmanagar, District-North Tripura
2. Mst. Kakala Bibi,
wife of Md. Faijul Haque,
daughter of Late Hazi Mafachil Ali
3. Mt. Rabia Begam,
wife of Abdul Machabbir,
daughter of Late Hazi Mafachil Ali
Abdul Kaiyum through L.Rs :
4a. Md. Maklurchhur Rahaman (son)
of Matarashi, P.O. Rajbari, Dharmanagar,
North Tripura
4b. Mst. Sayena Begam,
wife of Md. Jiyabuddin (Daughter),
resident of Village & P.O. Dhupirban,
Lalcherra, Dharmanagar
4c. Mst. Piyara Begam,
wife of Md. Jalal Uddin (Daughter)
of Village-Durgapur, P.O. Rajbari, Dharmanagar
5. Md. Abdul Sukkur,
son of Late Hazi Matachim Ali
Abdul Jalil through his L.Rs :
6a. Mst. Saharun Bibi (Wife)
6b. Md. Alkachhur Rahaman
6c. Md. Ruful Amin
6d. Md. Elkachhur Rahaman
all are sons of Late Abdul Jalil
6e. Mst. Neharun Nechha,
wife of Md. Arab Ali,
resident of Irani, P.O. Baburbazar, Kailasahar
6f. Mst. Ristana Begam,
wife of Md. Sahidul Alam,
resident of Irani, P.O. Baburbazar, Kailasahar
6g. Mst. Hena Begam,
wife of Md. Abdul Mannan
of Village-Chowkidar Para,
P.O. Pipracherra, Damcherra
6h. Mst. Dilwara Begam,
wife of Md. Alam Miah
of Village-Batrashi, P.O. Rajnbari, Dharmanagar
7. Md. Ishad Ali,
son of Late Hazi Matichim Ali
of West Batarashi, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
8. Md. Sainul Haque
of Batrashi, P.O. Rajbari,
Dharmanagar
9. Mst. Anwara Begam & Anu,
wife of Late Abdul Hannan,
daughter of Late Hazi Matachim Ali
of P.O. Chandrapur, Sabajpur, P.S. Dharmanagar,
District-North Tripura
10. Md. Manik Mia,
son of Late Hazi Matachim Ali
of P.O. Kalacharra, Dharmanagar,
District-North Tripura
11. Mst. Najama Begam,
wife of Asab Ali,
daughter of Late Hazi Matachin Ali
of Bisnupur, P.S. Kadamtala,
District-North Tripura
12. Mst. Perbeen Nessa,
wife of Abdul Kader,
daughter of Late Kabirun Nessa,
granddaughter of Late Matachin Ali,
resident of Durgapur, P.S. Dharmanagar,
North Tripura
13. Mst. Phatema Begam,
wife of Najrul Islam,
daughter of Late Kabirun Nessa,
granddaughter of Late Matachin Ali,
resident of Paschim Batarashi,
P.S. Dharmanagar, North Tripura
14. Mst. Jasmin Begam,
wife of Md. Bilayet Hossain,
daughter of Late Kabirun Nessa,
granddaughter of Late Matachin Ali,
resident of Paschim Batarashi,
P.S. Dharmanagar, North Tripura
15. Md. Abad Uddin,
son of Late Kabirun Nessa,
grandson of Late Matachin Ali,
resident of Paschim Batarashi,
P.S. Dharmanagar, North Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Datta, Adv.
Mr. G.K. Nama, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
21.05.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
20.06.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule
1 of the CPC as preferred by the appellant challenging the order dated
10.01.2023 passed by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar in connection with Case No.TS(P)03 of 2012
between Md. Abdul Wahid through his legal heirs and others, Plaintiffs
and Abdul Haque through his legal heirs and others, defendants whereby
the Learned Trial Judge dismissed the suit for default.
2.
Heard Mr. Sankar Deb, Learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Datta, Learned counsel appearing for the appellants as well as Mr.
G.K. Nama, Learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
3.
Before proceeding further with this appeal, let us discuss
about the subject matter of the instant appeal for convenience. The
predecessor in interest of the appellant Nos.1a to 1d to 2a to 2i and 3, 4,
5, 6, 7 and one Md. Liyakat Ali filed the partition suit being No.T.S.(P)03
of 2012 against the respondents or their predecessor in interest in the
Court of Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dharmanagar, North
Tripura seeking partition of the properties as mentioned in Schedule A of
the plaint. Md. Liyakat Ali, the original plaintiff died about three years
back. He was unmarried and as such, his share fell to the other plaintiffs.
Hence, his name was not arrayed in the present appeal. Subsequently,
written statement was filed on behalf of the defendant No.1 but no other
defendants filed any separate written statement. Issues were framed
and the parties adduce evidence and the Learned Trial Judge by a
judgment dated 20.06.2016 decreed the suit. Abdul Haque, the
predecessor-in-interest of the respondent Nos. 1a to 1i (since dead)
preferred RFA 19 of 2016 before the High Court challenging the
correctness and validity of the said decree. Apart from said Abdul Haque,
the predecessor-in-interest of the respondent Nos.1a to 1i, (since dead)
no other defendants challenged the said decree, even though, other
defendants in the suit were arrayed as defendant respondents. The
Hon’ble High Court by an order dated 12.11.2021 disposed of the appeal
and the connected I.A. by order dated 12.11.2021. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the relevant portion of
the order dated 12.11.2021 in I.A. No.09 of 2021 arising from RFA 19 of
2016 which runs as follows :
“I have gone through the application. The applicantappellants have submitted some documents which
appear to be relevant for rendering equitable justice to
the parties to the lis and in the opinion of this court, it
would be convenient to remit the matter back to the
learned trial court to take consideration of those
documents and decide the case afresh.
Accordingly, this court remits the present appeal
before the learned trial court. The applicant-appellants
are directed to submit all the documents, in original,
before the learned trial court within a period of 3 (three)
weeks. Registry is directed to send the case record to the
learned trial court within a period of 7 (seven) days. The
learned trial court after receipt of the records, shall
notify the parties. The learned trial court also shall
consider any application for amendment, if so filed, by
the applicant-appellants.
With
the
aforesaid
direction,
the
instant
Interlocutory Application stands disposed of.”
And also for the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the operative portion of the order passed by the Hon’ble
High Court in RFA 19 of 2016 on 12.11.2021 which runs as follows :
“In view of the order passed today in I.A. 9 of 2021, this
instant appeal stands disposed of.
Pending application (s), if any, also stands disposed
of.”
4.
According to the appellants, in terms of the said order of the
Hon’ble High Court disposing the appeal on 12.11.2021 the suit was
remanded back to the Trial Judge and the Learned Trial Judge by an
order passed on 23.12.2021 recorded that in view of the fact that the
suit is remitted, fixed on 18.01.2022 for original record/order and on
16.03.2022, Court recorded the receipt of the original record and
ordered the issuance of notice to the parties and on 04.04.2022 the
parties entered into appearance before the Learned Trial Judge.
However, the Learned Trial Judge also ordered that necessary steps were
required to be filed and list of documents submitted by the legal heirs of
defendant No.1, Abdul Haque under Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) of CPC was
filed. On 07.06.2022, the plaintiffs filed a petition under Order VII Rule
14 read with Section 151 of CPC. Subsequently, adjournment petition
was filed on behalf of the defendants was rejected by an order dated
12.07.2022 passed in T.S(P) No.3 of 2012 by Learned Civil Judge(Sr.
Div.), North Tripura, Dharmanagar. The operative portion of the said
order dated 12.07.2022 also runs as follows :
“From the record it is revealed that as per the order of
the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura 12.11.2021 passed in
RFA No.19 of 2016, this record was remitted back with a
direction to the applicant-appellants to submit all the
documents in original before this court within a period of
3 weeks but the answering defendants have submitted
recently mostly photostat copies including coloured
potostat copied before this court apart from any
documents submitted earlier. There is also no prayer for
amendment submitted till date. However at this stage
this court is not going into the genuineness, admissibility
and mode of proof of the documents submitted by the
answering
defendants
and
considering
that
the
defendant bases or relies upon the documents in his
possession or power at this stage, the petition of the L.Rs
of defendant No.1 under Order-VIII Rule 1A(3) of CPC is
allowed and the documents submitted are taken on
record.
As the prayer of the plaintiffs, the plaintiffs have
submitted certain documents by firisti on 07.06.2022
which as per the application under Order-VII Rule 14 of
CPC read with section 151 of CPC is very much essential
for proper adjudication of the suit and thereby the prayer
of the plaintiffs for receiving such documents in evidence
is also allowed. Thus both the petitions are allowed and
disposed off accordingly.
The parties are provided a final opportunity for
submission of any other documents in connection with
this case.”
5.
Further, according to the plaintiffs, on 16.08.2022 an
application under Order XXII Rule 10A of CPC was filed on behalf of the
defendant stating that they have filed Civil Misc. Case No.29 of 2022
before the Court of Learned District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
The defendant petitioner filed a petition for issuance of notices to the
survivors and legal heirs of the defendants, the plaintiff respondent No.4
and defendant proforma respondent Nos.11 and 13. The said petition
was rejected and directed the petitioners to take steps. But by an order
passed on 10.01.2023 the Learned Trial Judge dismissed the said
petition in Civil Misc. Case No.29 of 2022 disposing of the said petition
for non-prosecution.
6.
It was further submitted that while the petition under
Section 24 of CPC was pending before the Learned District Judge, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar which was disposed of on 16.01.2023 the Learned
Trial Judge by an order dated 10.01.2023 dismissed the suit for default.
Being aggrieved by the said order dated 10.01.2023 the present
appellants preferred this appeal before the High Court.
7.
In course of hearing, Mr. Sankar Deb, Learned senior
counsel appearing for the appellants drawn the attention of the Court
that the order dated 10.01.2023 dismissing the suit was a decree as per
Section 2(2) of CPC, so there is scope for filing an appeal. Learned
Senior Counsel firstly drawn the attention of the Court referring the said
order dated 12.01.2021 passed by this Court in connection with Case
No.I.A.09 of 2021 arising out of RFA 19 of 2016 and submitted that in
pursuance of the order of the Court necessary step was taken from the
side of the appellants. Accordingly, the suit was posted for step by
plaintiffs on 10.01.2023 but on that day, Learned counsel of both the
parties were present but the plaintiff could not take required step and for
that the Learned Court below came to the observation that the plaintiff is
not interested to proceed with the suit and ultimately dismissed the suit
for default.
8.
At the time of hearing, Learned senior counsel further drawn
the attention of the Court referring Civil Misc. Case No.29 of 2022 and
Civil Misc. Case No.40 of 2022 and also referred the order of the Learned
Trial Judge dated 12.07.2022, 19.07.2022, 02.08.2022, 16.08.2022,
23.08.2022, 27.09.2022, 21.11.2022, 13.12.2022 and submitted that
there was no wilfull negligence on behalf of the appellant to take proper
steps. But the Learned Trial Judge arbitrarily dismissed the suit without
any ground. So, finally, Learned Senior Counsel by referring some
citations drawn the attention of the Court to allow the appeal and to set
aside the order dated 10.01.2023 passed by the Learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, North Tripura, Dharmanagar with further approach to
remand back the suit to the Learned Trial Judge for completion of trial of
the said partition suit.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. G.K. Nama, Learned counsel
appearing for the respondents at the very first instance drawn the
attention of the Court that the appeal is not at all maintainable because
referring the contents of the order, Learned counsel for the respondents
submitted that on bare perusal of the order it is crystal clear that the
said order was not a decree and as such, there was no scope to prefer
any appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC. Rather,
the appellant could approach to the Learned Trial Judge under Order IX
Rule 9 of CPC but without resorting to the said provisions of law, there is
no scope to entertain this appeal by this Court.
10.
Finally, Learned counsel for the respondents referred one
citation of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Firdous Omer (Dead) by L.R.S.
and Others versus Bankim Chandra Daw (Dead) by L.R.S. and
Others reported in (2006) 6 SCC 569 and submitted that in view of
the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the given
case since the suit was dismissed for default by the Learned Trial Court
and it is not a decree. So, this present appeal is not maintainable.
11.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and gone
through the record of the Learned Court below including the order
impugned. For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein
below the relevant provision of Order IX Rule 8 and Order IX Rule 9 of
CPC which provides that :
Order IX Rule 8
“8. Procedure where defendant only appears.- Where the
defendant appears and the plaintiff does not appear
when the suit is called on for hearing, the Court shall
make an order that the suit be dismissed, unless the
defendant admits the claim, or part thereof, in which
case the Court shall pass a decree against the defendant
upon such admission, and, where part only of the claim
has been admitted, shall dismiss the suit so far as it
relates to the remainder.”
Order IX Rule 9
“9. Decree against plaintiff by default bars fresh suit.-(1)
Where a suit is wholly or partly dismissed under Rule 8,
the plaintiff shall be precluded from bringing a fresh suit
in respect of the same cause of action. But he may apply
for an order to set the dismissal aside, and if he satisfies
the Court that there was sufficient cause for his nonappearance when the suit was called on for hearing, the
Court shall make an order setting aside the dismissal
upon such terms as to costs or otherwise as it thinks fit,
and shall appoint a day for proceeding with the suit.
(2) No order shall be made under this rule unless notice
of the application has been served on the opposite
party.”
Order IX Rule 8 provides that if the defendant appears and
the plaintiff does not appear when the suit is called on for hearing, and
then the Court shall make an order that the suit be dismissed and
against that order of dismissal there is a scope for seeking relief under
Order IX Rule 9 of CPC as mentioned above.
12.
According to Learned counsel for the appellants, the case
was posted for step by the plaintiffs, all though, on that date, the
Learned counsel for the plaintiffs as well as for the defendants were
present but as no step was taken, so the suit was dismissed for default
by the Learned Trial Court.
Learned Senior Counsel in this regard also referred the provision of
Order III Rule 1 of CPC which provides as under :
Order III Rule 1
“1. Appearances, etc., may be in person, by recognized
agent or by pleader.-Any appearance, application or act
in or to any Court, required or authorized by law to be
made or done by a party in such Court, may, except
where otherwise expressly provided by any law for the
time being in force, be made or done by the party in
person, or by his recognized agent, or by a pleader
[appearing, applying or acting, as the case may be,] on
his behalf :
Provided that any such appearance shall, if the Court so
directs, be made by the part in person.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
senior
counsel
further
submitted that since the Learned counsel for the plaintiffs was present
on that date before the Learned Trial Court but due to some unavoidable
circumstances, the appellant could not take any proper step. Even, there
was no such prayer from the side of the appellants that they were
unable to take any appropriate step. So, Learned Trial Court below
dismissed the suit.
13.
On bare perusal of Order III Rule 1 of CPC it appears that in
absence of party, he or she may be represented by his/her engaged
counsel. Here in the given case although Learned counsel for the
appellants was present, but no step was taken by the appellants before
the Learned Trial Court.
14.
In course of hearing, Learned senior counsel for the
appellants referred few citations which provides as under :
In United Bank of India, Calcutta versus Abhijit Tea Co.
Pvt. Ltd. and Others reported in (2000) 7 SCC 357 the Hon’ble Apex
Court observed in para-16 observed as under :
“16. But, it is now well settled that an order of remand by
the appellate Court to the trial Court which had disposed
of the suit revives the suit in full except as to matters, if
any, decided finally by the appellate Court. Once the suit
is revived, it must, in the eye of the law, be deemed to be
pending - from the beginning when it was instituted. The
judgment disposing of the suit passed by the Single
Judge which is set aside gets effaced altogether and the
continuity of the suit in the trial court is restored, as a
matter of law. The suit cannot be treated as one freshly
instituted on the date of the remand order. Otherwise
serious questions as to limitation would arise. In fact, if
any evidence was recorded before its earlier disposal, it
would be evidence in the remanded suit and if any
interlocutory orders were passed earlier, they would
revive. In the case of a remand, it is as if the suit was
never disposed of (subject to any adjudication which has
become final, in the appellate judgment). The position
could have been different if the appeal was disposed of
once and for all and the suit was not remanded.”
Further, in P. Kiran Kumar versus A.S. Khadar and
Others reported in (2002) 5 SCC 161 the Hon’ble Apex Court in para12 observed as under :
“12. Explanation was added to Order 9 Rule 13 with
effect
from
1-2-1977
by the
Code
of
Civil
Procedure (Amendment)
Act,
1976.
Prior
to
its
enactment a defendant burdened by an ex parte decree
could apply under Order IX Rule 13 for setting aside the
ex parte decree. He could also file an appeal
under Section 96 against the ex parte decree. The mere
fact of filing the appeal did not take away the jurisdiction
to entertain and dispose of an application for setting
aside an ex parte decree. Only in the cases in which the
trial court decree merged with the order of the appellant
court by reversal, confirmation or varying it, the trial
court was precluded from setting aside the ex parte
decree. Where the trial court decree did not merge with
the appellate court order the trial court was at liberty to
proceed with the application for setting aside the exparte decree. Such instances arose when the appeal was
dismissed in default or where it was dismissed as having
abated by reasons of omission by the appellant to
implead the legal representatives of a deceased
respondent or where it was dismissed as barred by
limitation. Explanation was added to discourage the two
pronged attacks on the decree i.e. by preferring an
application to the trial court under Order 9 Rule 13 for
setting aside the decree and by filing an appeal to the
superior court against it. The legislative attempt
incorporating the Explanation to Order 9 Rule 13 is to
confine the defendant, to either one of the remedies
made available to him and not both. Dismissal of the
appeal on any ground, apart from its withdrawal
constituted a bar on the jurisdiction of the trial court to
set aside the ex-parte decree. With the introduction of
the explanation, no application to set aside the ex-parte
decree would be maintainable where the defendant filed
an appeal and the appeal was disposed of on any ground,
other than the ground that the appeal have been
withdrawn by the appellant.”
In Venkata Reddy and Others versus Pethi Reddy
reported in AIR 1963 SC 992 the Hon’ble Apex Court in para-6
observed as under :
“6…………… Therefore, if the reason given by the High
Court is accepted it would mean that no finality attaches
to decree at all. That is not the law. A decision is said to
be final when so far as, ,the Court rendering it is
concerned, it is unalterable except by resort to such
provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure as permit its
reversal, modification or amendment. Similarly, a final
decision would mean a decision which would operate as
resjudicate between the parties if it is not sought to be
modified or reversed by preferring an appeal or a
revision or a review application as is permitted by the
Code. A preliminary decree passed, whether it is in a
mortgage suit or a partition suit, is not a tentative decree
but must, in so far as the matters dealt with by it are
concerned, be regarded as conclusive. No doubt, in suits
which contemplate the making of two decrees--a
preliminary decree and a final decree-the decree which
would be executable would be the final decree But the
finality of a decree or a decision does not necessarily
depend upon its being executable. The legislature in its
wisdom has thought that suits of certain types should be
decided in stages and though the suit in such cases can
be regarded as fully and completely decided only after a
final decree is made the decision of the court arrived at
the earlier stage also has a finality attached to it. It
would be relevant to refer to S. 97 of the Code of Civil
Procedure which provides that where a party aggrieved
by a preliminary decree does not appeal from it, he is'
precluded from disputing its. correctness in any appeal
which may be preferred from the final decree. This
provision thus clearly indicates that as to the matters
covered by it, a preliminary decree is regarded as
embodying the final decision of the court passing that
decree.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel drawn the
attention of the Court that in view of the principles laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted cases the appellants have rightly
preferred this appeal before this High Court, there is no ambiguity on
that. So, the Court may allow the appeal setting aside the order of the
Learned Trial Court and remand back the same for holding the rest
portion of the trial.
15.
On the other hand, Learned counsel for the respondents
apart from his vital submission referred one citation in Firdous Omer
(supra). In paras-11, 12 & 14 the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as
under :
“11. Afterall, a dismissal of the suit for non- prosecution
or for non-appearance of the plaintiff is not a decree as
specified by the Section 2(2) of the Code itself. Hence it
is not appealable as a decree. Of course, the Calcutta
High Court seems to have taken the view that the order
of dismissal would amount to a judgment and hence
appealable under clause 15 of the Letters Patent. We do
not think it necessary to decide for the purpose of this
case, whether dismissal of a suit for default on the part
of the plaintiff would amount to a judgment within the
meaning of clause 15 of the Letters Patent. We leave that
question open for the present.
12. We also feel that the view of the Calcutta High Court,
no doubt, backed by the procedure followed in that court
and the practice of that court that once the order of
dismissal is drawn up, completed and filed, the court
loses its power to restore the suit in an appropriate case,
seems to deprive the court of a power which every court
has, of restoring a suit so as to enable the parties to
contest the same on merits. It is even possible to argue,
that the power to dismiss a suit for default, carries with
it the power to restore that suit. That apart, in view of
the power available under Section 5 of the Limitation Act
to extend the period of limitation for making an
application for restoration of the suit, the rigid view
adopted cannot be said to survive. May be, the view that
the order was a judgment and it was appealable under
clause 15 of the Letters Patent, also induced the theory
of the trial judge becoming functus officio on the order of
dismissal being drawn up, completed and filed. After all,
law of procedure is the handmaid of justice and Rule 35
of Chapter X of the Original Side Rules itself must be
taken to confer a power on the trial judge to restore a
suit which he had dismissed for default if sufficient cause
in that behalf is shown especially in the context
of Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963. The fact that the
records have been consigned to the record room cannot
interfere with the power of the court to do justice in a
cause. We are therefore inclined to hold that the position
adopted by the Calcutta High Court that on the expiry of
the 30 days from the date of dismissal of a suit for
default and on the order of dismissal being drawn up,
completed and filed, the court becomes functus officio is
not sustainable.
14. Thus, though on law, we are inclined to disagree with
the High Court that the suit could not be restored, we
decline to interfere with its decision for the reason
mentioned above. We dismiss the appeal. In the
circumstances, we make no order as to costs.”
Referring the same, Learned counsel submitted that in view
of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court there is no scope to allow
this appeal as the same is not maintainable.
16.
After prolong hearing of both the sides and after going
through the relevant case record and the principles of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted cases it appears to this Court
that all though, Learned counsel for the appellants was present on that
date but no step was taken inspite of providing opportunity to the party
by the Learned Trial Court below and hence, the suit was dismissed by
the Learned Trial Court. So, for the dismissal of the suit for nonprosecution, in my considered view, there is no scope to entertain this
appeal filed under Section 96 of CPC by the appellants.
17.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is hereby
disposed of being devoid of merit. However, the appellants shall be at
liberty to approach the concerned Court for restoration of the suit and
the Learned Court below shall dispose of the matter in accordance with
law without being biased by the order of the Court.
With this observation, this appeal stands disposed of.
Pending application/s, if any, also stands disposed of.
A copy of this order be communicated to Learned Court
below for information and compliance.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.06.21 13:00:57 +05'30'
Sabyasachi. B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review