Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No. 1/9
GAHC010211282025
2026:GAU-AS:2730
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Writ Petition (C) no. 5487/2025
Abdul Salam Prodhani, Son of Moynal Hoque Prodhani,
Resident of Village – Dharmasala Part-III, Post Office –
Dharmasala, Police Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri,
Assam.
………………Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Assam, Represented by the Commissioner
and Secretary to the Government of Assam, Panchayat
and Rural Development Department, Dispur, Guwahati –
6, Dispur, Guwahati – 781006.
2. The District Commissioner, Dhubri, Post Office – Dhubri,
Police Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri, Assam, Pin –
783300.
3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad Dhubri, Police
Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri, Assam, Pin – 783300.
4. The President, Dharmasala Anchalik Panchayat, Post Office
– Dharmasala, Police Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri,
Assam, Pin – 783324.
5. The Executive Officer, Dharamsala Anchalik Panchayat,
P.O. Dharmasala, P.S. Dhubri, Dist. Dhubri, Assam, Pin –
783324.
Page No. 2/9
6. The President, Dharmasala Gaon Panchayat, Post Office –
Dharmasala, Police Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri,
Assam, Pin – 783324.
7. The Secretary, Dharmasala Gaon Panchayat, Post Office
Dharmasala, Police Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri,
Assam, Pin – 783324.
8. Sri Mahibul Hogue, Son of Sekendar Ali, Resident of Village
– Kachuarkash, Part-I, Post Office – Dharmasala, Police
Station – Dhubri, District – Dhubri, Assam, Pin – 783324.
……………….Respondents
Advocates :
Petitioner
: Mr. H.R.A. Choudhury, Senior Advocate
Mr. M. Ahmed, Advocate
Respondent nos. 1, 3, 5 & 7
: Ms. N. Borah, Standing Counsel, P&RD Department
Respondent no. 2
: Ms. U. Das, Additional Senior Government Advocate
Date on which judgment is reserved
: NA
Date of pronouncement of Judgment
: 20.02.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment ? : No
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced ? : Yes
Page No. 3/9
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANISH CHOUDHURY
JUDGMENT & ORDER
This writ petition is preferred to assail an Order of Settlement dated 30.08.2025
whereby a market, ‘Hadurhat Dharmasala Dainik Bazar Dharmasala Part-III’
[‘the Market’, for short] has been settled in favour of the respondent no. 8 at his
offered bid value of Rs. 2,35,730/-, disqualifying the bid of the petitioner, who
also offered the same bid value of Rs. 2,37,730/-.
2.
A Tender Notice was published by Dharmasala Gaon Panchayat on 02.06.2025
inviting bids for settlement of the Market for the Panchayat Year : 2025-2026
for the period from 01.07.2025 to 30.06.2026. In the Tender Notice, the
Government value of the Market was fixed at Rs. 2,14,300/- and the earnest
money deposit [EMD] to be deposited by the bidders along with their bids was
fixed at 10% of the Government value, that is, @ Rs. 21,430/-.
3.
In response to the Tender Notice, eleven nos. of bidders submitted their bids.
The petitioner and the respondent no. 8 were among the eleven participant
bidders. After opening of the bids, the Bid Evaluation Committee of Dharmasala
Gaon Panchayat consisting of the Members of the Development Committee; the
President; and the Secretary; examined the bids with regard to the essential
documents prescribed in the Tender Notice and the Bidding Document. Upon
evaluation of the bids, the Committee accepted the bid of the respondent no. 8
as the valid one for settlement. The bid of the petitioner was not accepted.
Thereafter, the Order of Settlement dated 30.08.2025 came to be passed.
4.
I have heard Mr. H.R.A. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. M.
Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner; Ms. N. Borah, learned Standing
Counsel, Panchayat and Rural Development [P&RD] Department for the
respondent nos. 1, 3, 5 & 7; and Ms. U. Das, learned Additional Senior
Government Advocate, Assam for the respondent no. 2.
Page No. 4/9
5.
As per Order dated 11.02.2026 of the Lawazima Court, the other respondents
have not entered appearance despite service of notices.
6.
Two points have been urged on behalf of the petitioner to contend that the bid
of the petitioner ought to have been accepted instead of accepting the bid of
the respondent no. 8. Firstly, according to the petitioner, the respondent no. 8
did not submit any Police Verification Report along with his bid and to canvas
the point, the petitioner has placed reliance on a Comparative Statement
annexed as Annexure-III to the writ petition; and secondly, both the petitioner
and the respondent no. 8 had offered the same bid value, that is, Rs.2,35,730/and also offered the earnest money in the form of demand draft for the amount
of Rs. 21,430/-. But, only the bid of the respondent no. 8 was accepted. The bid
of the petitioner was not accepted on the untenable ground that there was
mismatch between the name of the bidder and the name of the person reflected
in the demand draft.
7.
Ms. Borah, learned Standing Counsel, Panchayat and Rural Development
[P&RD] Department has submitted that neither of the two points urged by the
petitioner has merit. The Comparative Statement relied upon the petitioner to
supplement his first point was not the final Comparative Statement. The final
Comparative Statement was prepared after detail evaluation of the bids and the
documents accompanying them by the Members of the Development Committee
of the Gaon Panchayat, the President and the Secretary of the Gaon Panchayat,
which was the Bid Evaluation Committee. It was in the final Comparative
Statement, all of them had subscribed signatures and seals, wherever
applicable. As per the final Comparative Statement, the respondent no. 8 had
duly submitted Police Verification Report with his bid. As regards the second
point urged on behalf of the petitioner, Ms. Borah has submitted that the
earnest money was deposited by the respondent no. 8 by way of demand draft
in his own name. Though the earnest money was deposited by the petitioner by
a demand draft, but the same was in a third person’s name.
Page No. 5/9
8.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and
have also gone through the materials brought on record.
9.
As per Clause 4 of an Executive Order bearing no. E-511528/55 dated
20.05.2025 issued by the Panchayat and Rural Development Department,
Government of Assam, no settlement of haats / ghats / fisheries / pounds, etc.
would be awarded to a lessee who is involved in any kind of heinous crimes,
extortion etc. By incorporating Clause 18 in the Tender Notice, it has been made
mandatory for every bidder to submit a certificate regarding his antecedents
from the jurisdictional Police Station. When the Comparative Statement
submitted by the petitioner, annexed as Annexure-III to the writ petition, is
looked at, it can be noticed that the said Comparative Statement bears three
signatures namely, [i] Executive Officer, Dharmasala Anchalik Panchayat,
Dharmasala; [ii] Assistant B.D.O. [W&C], Gauripur Development Block,
Dharmasala; and [iii] Gaon Panchayat Secretary, Dharmasala Gaon Panchayat.
In the said Comparative Statement, it was shown that the respondent no. 8 did
not submit the Police Verification Report.
10.
Au contraire, when the Comparative Statement annexed to the affidavit-inopposition of the respondent no. 8 is looked at, it is noticed that it bears
signatures of the three Members of the Development Committee, as well as the
signatures of the Secretary and the President of the Gaon Panchayat with their
seals. In addition, it also bears signature and seal of the President of the
jurisdictional Anchalik Panchayat, Dharmasala Anchalik Panchayat. Taking note
of the above aspects, the claims of the respondents in the Panchayat and Rural
Development Department that the Comparative Statement annexed by the
petitioner, wherefrom the petitioner has sought to draw support, is not the final
Comparative Statement and it is the Comparative Statement which is annexed
to the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent no. 8 is the final Comparative
Statement are to be accepted. As per sub-section [2] of Section 105 of the
Assam Panchayat Act, 1994, as amended, the powers of examination and final
Page No. 6/9
acceptance of bids is vested in the Standing Committee of the Gaon Panchayat
which consists of the Members of the Development Committee. By the Assam
Panchayat [Amendment] Act, 2025, the State Government has transferred the
Government markets which have settlement value of less than Rupees 5 [five]
lakhs in a year to the Gaon Panchayat within the jurisdiction of which the
market is situated. As per the final Comparative Statement, both the petitioner
and the respondent no. 8 had submitted the Police Verification Report. Thus,
the point urged as regards non-submission of the Police Verification Report by
the respondent no. 8 is found without merit.
11.
Admittedly, both the petitioner and the respondent no. 8 had offered the same
bid value of Rs. 2,35,730/- and offered the same earnest money of Rs. 21,430/in the form of demand draft. The submission of the demand draft by the
respondent no. 8 in his own name vis-à-vis the submission of the earnest
money by the petitioner through a demand draft drawn by a third person had
made a difference for the settlement authority to accept the bid of the
respondent no. 8 and to reject the bid of the petitioner.
12.
The scope of judicial review in matters relating to award of contracts by the
State or its instrumentalities / agencies is well settled. Submission of a tender in
response to a tender notice amounts to making of an offer which the State or its
instrumentalities / agencies are no obligation to accept. A bidder participating in
a tender process cannot insist that its tender should be accepted because its
tender is the highest or the lowest depending upon whether the contract is for
sale of public property or for execution of works. All that a participant bidder is
entitled to is a fair, equal and non-discriminatory treatment in the matter of
evaluation of its tender. Award of a contract being a commercial transaction, is
determined on the basis of the relevant considerations for such commercial
decision.
13.
Evaluation of tenders and award of contracts being commercial functions,
principles of equity and natural justice are not applicable stricto senso. When a
Page No. 7/9
participant bidder assails award of contract to a rival participant bidder, the
issues to be considered by the constitutional court are explained by the
Supreme Court of India in Jagadish Mandal vs. State of Orissa, [2007] 14 SCC
517, in the following manner :-
22.…… Therefore, a court before interfering in tender or contractual
matters in exercise of power of judicial review, should pose to itself
the following questions :
[i] Whether the process adopted or decision made by the authority is
mala fide or intended to favour someone;
or
Whether the process adopted or decision made is so arbitrary and
irrational that the court can say : ‘the decision is such that no
responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance with
relevant law could have reached’;
[ii] Whether public interest is affected.
If the answers are in the negative, there should be no interference
under Article 226.
14.
In so far as public revenue is concerned, it cannot be said that by granting the
settlement of the Market in favour of the respondent no. 8, there has been loss
of public revenue as both the petitioner and the respondent no. 8 had offered
the same price, Rs. 2,35,730/-. On that count, this Court does not find
involvement of any public element to interfere with the decision of the
respondent authorities in settling the Market in favour of the respondent no. 8.
The petitioner has not been able to show that in what other manner public
interest has been affected for settling the Market in favour of the respondent
no. 8.
15.
The law is well settled that the decision-making process adopted by the
Settlement Authority in accepting or rejecting the bid of a bidder should not be
Page No. 8/9
interfered with lightly. Interference is permissible only if the decision-making
process is mala fide or is intended to favour someone. A mere disagreement
with the decision-making process or the decision of the tendering authority is
not a reason for a constitutional court to interfere and the court has to exercise
restraint and caution. The tendering authority who floats the tender and has
prepared the tender documents, is the best Judge as to how the documents
have to be interpreted. If two interpretations are possible then the
interpretation of the tendering authority is to be accepted, unless the
interpretation of the tendering authority is fraught with arbitrariness,
irrationality, bias, mala fide or perversity. As explained above, it is only when
the decision is such that no responsible authority acting reasonably and in
accordance with relevant law would have reached such a decision then only an
interference is called for.
16.
Turning back to the facts of the case, it is found that it is the case of the
petitioner that he submitted the earnest money at Rs. 21,430/- in the form of a
demand draft along with his bid. It is the contention of the respondent
authorities that the demand draft which was submitted by the petitioner
towards deposit of earnest money was not in his name. The demand draft was
drawn by one Mohibul Pradhani. The petitioner has sought for clarify that
Mohibul Pradhani is an elder brother of the petitioner. It has been contended
that such submission of the demand draft for the earnest money in the name of
Mohibul Pradhani on behalf of the petitioner could not have made any difference
for acceptance of the bid of the petitioner vis-à-vis acceptance of the bid of the
respondent no. 8 and therefore, the respondent authorities ought to have
adopted the process of lottery to break the deadlock.
17.
Admittedly, the bid of the petitioner and the respondent no. 8 was accompanied
by a demand draft each for the amount of Rs. 21,430/- towards earnest money
deposit. The object behind calling for deposit of earnest money in a tender
process
has
been
explained
in
Mega
Electricals
Dihand
Edutech
Infrastructure Private Limited and others vs. State of Assam and others,
Page No. 9/9
2012 [4] GLT 723, to the effect that the earnest money represents a guarantee
that the contract will be fulfilled by the tenderer and it evinces the earnestness
to bind the tenderer in bargaining as the process of contract goes through. The
meaning ascribed to the word, ‘earnest’ in the Oxford Dictionary of English,
Third Edition [of a person] is – sincere and serious in intention, a thing intended
or regarded as a sign or promise of what is to come.
18.
If in the case in hand the settlement authority had accepted the bid of the
respondent no. 8 for the reason that the submission of the earnest money by
the respondent no. 8 by a demand draft in his own name was intended for by
the respondent authorities, then such a decision of the settlement authority
cannot, by any stretch, be considered as an arbitrary or irrational decision
creating a situation for exercise of the power of judicial review for interference.
If the fact of submission of the earnest money by the petitioner by a demand
draft drawn by a third party had, according to the respondent authorities,
rendered the bid of the petitioner non-responsive then such an interpretation is
to be respected and accepted as it would not fall in the category of decisions no
responsible authority acting reasonably could have reached. Therefore, the
challenge raised on that count by the petitioner also fails.
19.
In view of the discussion made above and for the reasons assigned therein, the
writ petition is found to be unmerited and the same is accordingly dismissed.
There shall, however, be no order as to cost.
Konwar
Date: 2026.02.23 19:42:20
+05'30'
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review