Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.105 of 2025
Abdul Rahaman
S/O Abul Kashem of
Baghair Char,
Police Station-Jatrapur,
District-Sepahijala, Tripura.
---- Applicant(s)
AND
Alamgir Hossain @ Sagar Miah
S/O Abdul Rahaman of
Baghair Char,
Police Station- Jatrapur,
District-Sepahijala, Tripura.
----(Accused person in custody)
Versus
The State of Tripura.
----Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Subrata Sarkar, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Arpan Jamatia, Adv.
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
13/11/2025
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS is
filed for granting bail to the accused-in-custody namely Alamgir
Hossain @ Sagar Miah in connection with Jatrapur P.S. case
No.55 of 2024 under Sections 20(b)(ii)(B)/25/29 of NDPS Act.
Heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
Mr.
S.
Sarkar
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Arpan Jamatia appearing on
behalf of the accused-in-custody and also heard Learned P.P.,
Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of the State-respondent. As
ordered earlier, we have received from the Learned Trial Court
also Learned P.P. has produced the case diary.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel
first of all drawn the attention of the Court referring the
contents of the FIR and submitted that on the basis of suo
moto complaint submitted by one Amar Kishore Debbarma on
06.10.2024 to O/C, Jatrapur P.S. this present case has been
registered against the accused. But surprisingly in this case
nothing was recovered from the possession of the accused-incustody rather the contraband item was seized from an
abandoned house which was not belonging to the accused.
However, in course of investigation, the accused-in custody
approached for anticipatory bail before this Court earlier which
was rejected vide order dated 04.12.2024 in connection with
A.B. No.61 of 2024. After that challenging the order the
accused approached for bail before the Supreme Court of India
and the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India initially by order dated
15.01.2025 in Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No.345 of 2025
granted interim protection for six weeks and thereafter, by
order dated 02.05.2025, his prayer for anticipatory bail was
rejected. After that he has surrendered and he is in custody
for a period of around 106 days.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that even
if the prosecution case is true that the accused possessed
contraband items of 17.5 kg in that case, the same will come
under the category of intermediate quantity and as such the
restriction of the provision of Section 37 would not attract. It
was further submitted that the legislature has framed the law
in such a manner that the fundamental right of the accused is
not curtailed and more so, there are series of judgments of
different High Courts as well as the Apex Court that in a case
of intermediate quantity the accused is to be released on bail.
So, Learned Counsel urged for releasing the accused on bail in
any condition.
It was further submitted by Learned Senior Counsel
that as submitted by Learned P.P. representing the prosecution
that in this case the charge-sheet was submitted within time
and for that there is no legal bar to release the accused on bail
in the case at hand at this stage. To buttress his contention,
Learned Senior Counsel relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble
Apex Court of India in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1418 [titled as
Puranmal Jat vs. State of Rajasthan] wherein in para No.3,
Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“3. The allegations against the appellant relate to
commission of offences under the provisions of
Sections 8 and 15 of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (hereinafter
called “the Act”). Alleged recovery from him is
about 35 kgs. and 150 grams Doda Posh (Poppy
straw). The commercial quantity for poppy straw is
50 kgs. The appellant is in custody for over seven
months. Charge sheet has been submitted in the
case. The recovered contraband item having
weight less than the stipulated commercial
quantity, the restriction on grant of bail under
Section 37 of the Act does not apply in his case. We
do not think his continued detention pending trial
is necessary in the given circumstances.”
Referring
the
same
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that in view of the observation of the Hon’ble Apex
Court the accused is entitled to be released on bail.
He further relied upon another citation of the High
Court of Gujarat in Goganbhai Rambhai Shekh vs. State of
Gujarat reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Guj 817, wherein in
para No.4, the High Court of Gujarat observed as under:
“4. Having heard the learned advocate for the
applicant as also learned APP for the respondent State as also going through the FIR as also the
impugned order and papers of investigation, it
reveals that on prior information about cultivation
of plant of Ganja, the Police swung into action and
recovered six plants, as claimed in the FIR, of
Ganja weighing 5.05 kilograms. Since the applicant
who is said to be in possession of that cultivation
part of the filed, he is booked under “the NDPS
Act” and prosecuted. However, considering the
papers of investigation, it reveals that the quantity
even if presumed to be all parts of the plants to be
Ganja is less than the commercial quantity and
higher than the small quantity, therefore,
considering the provisions of “the NDPS Act”,
rigors of Section 37 would not be applicable in the
present case. At the same time, as coming out from
the record, the applicant is also not having any
other criminal antecedents, apart from the
antecedents of the very same nature, I deem it fit
to release the present applicant on bail.”
Referring the same, he submitted that considering
the facts and circumstances of the present case, the accused is
entitled to be released on bail in this case.
Finally,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
again
referred
another citation of the Hon’ble High Court of Jammu & Kashmir
in BA No.64 of 2024 (Crl.M.981/2024) titled as Arshid
Ahmad Ganie vs. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
(Home) in para No.7, the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir &
Ladakh observed as under:
“7. Having held that the quantity of the drug
allegedly recovered from the petitioner herein is of
intermediate quantity, the next question for
consideration of this Court would be as to whether
the petitioner becomes entitled to the concession
of bail at this stage by this Court. A reference in
this regard to the settled position of law would
become imperative, hereunder to the observations
and findings of the co-ordinate bench again in the
case supra, wherein at Paras 8,9,11,12 and 13
following has been held.
08. The settled position of law, as evolved by
the Supreme Court in a catena of judicial
dictums on the subject governing the grant of
bail, is that there is no strait jacket formula or
settled rules for the use of discretion, but, at
the time of deciding the question of 'bail or
jail' in non-bailable offences, the Court has to
utilize its judicial discretion, not only that, as
per the settled law, the discretion to grant
bail in cases of non-bailable offences has to
be exercised according to rules and principles
as laid down by the Code and various judicial
decisions. In bail applications, generally, it
has been laid down, from the earliest times,
that the object of bail is to secure the
appearance of the accused person at his trial
by reasonable amount of bail. The object of
bail is neither punitive nor preventative, but
the learned trial Court appears to have
applied it in the reverse. Deprivation of liberty
must be considered a punishment, unless it
can be required to ensure that an accused
person will stand his trial when called upon.
The Courts owe more than verbal respect to
the principle that punishment begins after
conviction, and that every man is deemed to
be innocent until duly tried and duly found
guilty. From the earliest times, it was
appreciated
that
detention
in
custody,
pending completion of trial, could be a cause
of great hardship. From time to time,
necessity demanded that some unconvicted
persons should be held in custody pending
trial to secure their attendance at the trial,
but, in such cases, 'necessity' is the operative
test. In this country, it would be quite
contrary to the concept of personal liberty
enshrined in the Constitution that any person
should be punished in respect of any matter,
upon which he has not been convicted or that,
in any circumstances, he should be deprived
of his liberty upon only the belief that he will
tamper with the witnesses, if left at liberty,
save in the most extraordinary circumstances.
Apart from the question of prevention being
the object of a refusal of bail, one must not
lose sight of the fact that any imprisonment
before conviction has a substantial punitive
content and it would be improper for any
Court to refuse bail as a mark of disapproval
of former conduct whether the accused has
been convicted for it or not or to refuse bail to
an un-convicted person for the purpose of
giving him a taste of imprisonment as a
lesson.
09. The expression 'judicial discretion' has
been very well explained by an eminent jurist
Benjamin Cardozo. In the words of Benjamin
Cardozo, "the Judge, even when he is free, is
still not wholly free. He is not to innovate at
pleasure. He is not a knight-errant roaming at
will in pursuit of his own ideal of beauty or of
goodness. He is to draw his inspiration from
consecrated principles. He is not to yield to
spasmodic
sentiment,
to
vague
and
unregulated benevolence. He is to exercise a
discretion informed by tradition, methodized
by analogy, disciplined by system and
subordinated to the primordial necessity of
order in the social life. Wide enough, in all
conscience, is the field of discretion that
remains." Even so, it is useful to notice the
tart terms of Lord Camden that "the discretion
of a Judge is the law of tyrants. It is always
known, it is different in different men; it is
causal, and depends upon constitution,
temper and passion. In the best, it is often
times caprice, in the worst, it is every vice,
folly and passion to which human nature is
liable."
11. To categorize the materials in terms of
quantity as small, medium and commercial is
to allow escape routes for those to whom the
rigor of section 37 of the NDPS Act does not
apply. Had the intention of the Legislators
been to treat those who are found to be in
possession of the small and medium quantity
of the drugs and Narcotic substances on par
with those from whom commercial quantity of
such substances is recovered, it could not
have pierced and scaled it in different
categories. The conflict between the human
tendencies and the rules of society is an
eternal one which cannot ever be solved or
ended to the entire satisfaction of idealistic
puritans. World of human society will always
remain imperfect. It creates a false ethical
self- importance on the part of the Courts who
sit in judgment to decide or determine such
cases not in accordance with the law, but by
sentimental proverbs.
12. Testing the instant application from the
above
perspective,
it
requires
to
be
recapitulated that the Pigor of Section 37 of
the NDPS Act does not apply to the instant
case. It also needs to be said that the case of
the applicant does not fall within the
parameters
of
the
offences
that
are
punishable with death or imprisonment of life.
Therefore, there appears to be no reasonable
ground for declining bail to the applicant. The
maxim of the law of bails, which has its
application to the case on hand where the
quantity of narcotics recovered from the
applicant falls within the scales of an
intermediary one, for which the punishment
provided is upto 10 years and a fine of rupees
one lac, is "bail and not jail". 13. Deprivation
of liberty is tantamount to punishment. The
principle that
punishment begins
after
conviction and that every man is deemed to
be innocent unless duly tried and duly found
guilty, has Its application to the facts of the
instant case in all the fours. The object of the
bail is to seek attendance and appearance of
the accused at the trial by a reasonable
amount of bail. Bail cannot be withheld as a
means of punishment. Prison hell destroys the
tender
sentiments
of
a
person.
The
applicant/applicant has been languishing in
the jail for so many months by now. The
applicant/ accused has to prepare for his
defence which is of an essence in a criminal
trial. The discretion has to be exercised on
well based foundations of law and one cannot
get swayed by sentiments. Temper and
passion have no role to play in exercising the
discretion for the grant of bail.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that this present case is squarely covered by the
said judgment and urged for releasing the accused on bail in
any condition.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. strongly opposed
the submission made by Learned Senior Counsel for the
accused
and
submitted
that
in
this
case
the
accused
approached for pre-arrest bail before this Court which was
rejected with an observation that there is no scope to grant
bail to any accused in a case of this nature. Learned P.P.
thereafter submitted that he approached for anticipatory bail
before the Hon’ble Apex Court which was also rejected but the
accused did never surrender rather he was arrested and was
produced under arrest before the Court, so, there is no scope
to release the accused on bail. It was further submitted by
Learned P.P. that the charge-sheet was submitted by I.O.
within time as such the accused as a matter of right cannot
claim for bail and further submitted that in this case the
prosecution has submitted prayer for holding custody trial of
the accused which is still pending for disposal and if at this
stage the bail is allowed then the purpose of the prayer of the
prosecution would be frustrated and urged for rejection of the
bail application. Learned P.P. also submitted that there are
materials in the C/D against the accused that the contraband items
was seized from his residence.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused
the record of the Learned Trial Court. In this case the
prosecution was set into motion on the basis of an FIR laid by
the informant, Amar Kishore Debbarma to O/C, Jatrapur P.S.
alleging interalia that on 06.10.2024 at about 1215 hours on
the basis of a secret information that some suspected dry
ganja was sealing/packing in the house of one Alamgir Hossain
for the purpose of smuggling to Bangladesh. The fact was
entered in Jatrapur P.S., GD Entry No.-16, dated 06.10.2024.
The matter was informed to the higher authority and SDPO
Sonamura and after that the informant along with staff arrived
in the house of Alamgir Hossain and cordoned the house, but
the house main door, other doors and windows were opened
and in the meantime, Addl. BDO of Kathalia R.D, Block
appeared and called the house owner but got no response and
found no family members were there. Thereafter, he arranged
two independent witnesses. Issued notice under Section 42 of
NDPS Act but that could not be served. He prepared pre-search
memo, house search memo in presence of witnesses and
thereafter, he conducted search in the dwelling house of
Alamgir Hossain in presence of witnesses and found 19 Nossky
colour plastic pouches and on measuring it was found that 17
kg and 500 grams of dry ganja in those packets. After that
those packets were seized after observing all formalities and
the suo moto complaint was made by the informant to O/C of
the concerned P.S. Accordingly, the case was registered. By
this time the accused was produced under arrest before the
Learned Trial Court on 28.07.2025 and since then he has been
lodging in custody and in the meantime, I.O. has laid chargesheet against the accused under Sections 20(b)(ii)(B)/25/29 of
NDPS Act.
Now for the sake of convenience, I would like to
refer herein below the relevant provision of Section 37 of NDPS
Act which provides as under:
“37. Offences to be cognizable and non-bailable.—
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974),—
(a) every offence punishable under this Act shall
be cognizable;
(b) no person accused of an offence punishable for
3 [offences under section 19 or section 24 or
section 27A and also for offences involving
commercial quantity] shall be released on bail or
on his own bond unless—
(i) the Public Prosecutor has been given an
opportunity to oppose the application for such
release, and
(ii) where the Public Prosecutor opposes the
application, the court is satisfied that there are
reasonable grounds for believing that he is not
guilty of such offence and that he is not likely to
commit any offence while on bail.”
From the aforesaid provision, it appears that the
restriction of Section 37 of NDPS Act would only apply in case
of the contraband items of commercial quantity. Here in the
case at hand the contraband itemrecovered by I.O. was 17.5
kg which was higher than smaller quantity but lesser than
commercial quantity. I have also perused the citations referred
by Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the accusedin-custody.
So, considering the facts and circumstances of the
case and the materials on record and also the citations referred
by Learned Senior Counsel for the accused-in-custody, it
appears to this Court that the restriction of Section 37 of NDPS
Act would not attract in this case and as such, I do not find any
scope to detain the accused furthermore in judicial custody,
since the investigation by this time completed.
Accordingly, the prayer filed on behalf of the
accused is allowed. The accused Alamgir Hossain @ Sagar Miah
may be enlarged on bail of his furnishing bail bond of
Rs.100,000/- with one surety of like amount who must be a
public servant, i.d. the accused shall remain in J/C as before
with the following terms and conditions:
(i) That the accused shall attend the Learned Trial Court once
in a week till completion of trial.
(ii) That the accused shall not leave the jurisdiction of the
concerned Court without prior permission of the Court.
(iii) That the accused shall not make any attempt to tamper
evidence on record of the prosecution during the period of bail.
In case of violation of the terms and condition of
bail, the prosecution shall be at liberty to move for cancellation
of bail to the concerned Learned Trial Court.
With this observation, this present bail application
stands disposed of.
Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court
along with a copy of this order.
Return back the Case Diary to IO through Learned
P.P. along with a copy of this order.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
DATTA
Date: 2025.11.13 17:21:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review