Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 13
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP(C)No. 1696/2019
01. Abdul Mateen Gupkari,
S/O. Abdul Rehman Gupkari
02. Naseema Bano
W/O Abdul Rehman Gupkari
03. Mariya Jan
D/O. Abdul Rehman Gupkari.
All residents of 16-Gupkar Road
Srinagar, at present Naseem Bagh,
Srinagar.
Through:
…Petitioner(s)
Mr. Sheikh Mushtaq, Advocate.
Vs.
1. State of J&K through
Commissioner/Secretary to Govt,
Revenue Department, Civil Secretariat
Srinagar/Jammu.
2. 2. Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir.
3. Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar.
4. Assistant Commissioner (Revenue)
Srinagar.
5. Tehsildar Shalteng Srinagar.
6. Naib Tehsildasr Shalteng Srinagar.
7. Patwari Shalgeng Parimpora.
8. Station House officer, Qamerwari
Srinagar.
9. District Police Officer Qamerwari
Srinagar.
10. Sub District Police Officer, Qamerwari
Parimpora Srinagar.
11. Ghulam Hassan Mir S/O. Ghulam Rasool
Mir
R/O. Barthana Qamarwari Srinagar.
12. Tariq Hajam S/O. Mohd Ramzan
13. R/O. Barhana Qamarwari Srinagar.
14. Mohammad Sidiq Matta S/O Late Ashoor
Matta R/O. Qamarwari Barthana
Qamarabad.
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Ms. Raheela Khan, AC, vice Mr. A.R. Malik, Sr. AAG,
for 1 to 7
Mr. Hakeem Suhail Ishtiyaq, Adv, for 13.
Mr. Hilal A Wani, Adovdate
Mr. I. Sofi,Advocate.
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
15.09.2026
Oral:
01. The petitioners through the medium of the instant petition
have sought the following reliefs:I.
“Writ of Mandamus, Commanding the officials Respondents
to immediately stop the conversion of the land of the
petitioners and stop issuing revenue extracts in favour of the
private
respondents
who
have
manipulated
certain documents for depriving the petitioners of their
property rights.
II.
A Writ of Mandamus, Commanding the respondents to remove
the
encroachments
made
over
the
property
of
the petitioner with further direction to the SHO concerned to
stop all illegal constructions being raised for conversion
of
the
nature
of
the
land
in
violation
of
the law.
III.
A
Writ
of
Mandamus,
commanding
the
respondent
particularly respondent No.2 to conduct thorough enquiry into
the
matter
conclusion
and
for
respondents
take
taking
for
the
enquiry
appropriate
making
to
action
conversion
of
its
logical
against
the
the
land.”
02. The petitioners have a common cause of action, common
question of fact of law, common grounds of challenge and
substantially common reliefs to seek and, accordingly, they
came with the institution of the instant petition jointly in order
to avoid multiplicity of litigation and the possibility of
conflicting verdicts.
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
03. The petitioners 1 to 3 and Abdul Rehman Gupkari (Father
of petitioners 1 and 3 and husband of petitioner no. 2)
claimed to have purchased land measuring 42 Kanals
situated at Estate Barthana Qamarwari, Srinagar, falling under
following Khasra Nos’:i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
x.
xi.
xii.
xiii.
294/210
299/210
300/210
302/210
595/204/210
315/210
319/210
320/210
876/328/210
329/210
335/210
440/208
916/230/208
04. The aforesaid land, as per the pleadings, was purchased by the
petitioners and deceased Abdul Rehman Gupkari in 90’s and
with the outbreak of militancy in the State, they had to
face difficulties to keep the watch and ward over
the
said property and in view of the law and order problem
in the State at that point of time, Abdul Rehman
Gupkari in his life time had executed an agreement in
the year 2001, appointing private respondent no. 11 as
Chowkidar in terms of an agreement executed and
registered on 29th November, 2011 before the Sub
Registrar, Srinagar.
05. It is pleaded in the instant petition that since the
militancy in the State was on peak, the petitioners could
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
not look after the land and taking advantage of the
same, the private respondents had illegally managed to
sell the land property by obtaining revenue extracts from
the concerned Revenue Authorities in violation of the
law. It is further pleaded that the land in question was
recorded as agricultural land and any conversion thereof
was strictly prohibited in terms of the relevant provisions
of the law.
06. It is argued by learned counsel for the petitioners that
the private respondents in collusion with the Revenue
Authorities have obtained revenue extracts for selling the
aforesaid land fraudulently by changing its nature and,
accordingly, the private respondents in collusion with
the Revenue Authorities have converted the nature of the
land by raising constructions over the same. The
petitioners, upon coming to know of the illegal acts
committed by the respondents, have brought this aspect
of the matter to notice of the Higher Authorities
including Divisional Commissioner as well as the
concerned Revenue Authorities. However, the efforts
made by the petitioners have not yielded any response or
result,
inasmuch
as,
the
Revenue
Authorities
in
collusion with the private respondents managed to sell
the land in question in stark violation of the law.
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
07. It is further submitted that petitioners have repeatedly
represented
before
the
Divisional
Commissioner,
Kashmir, complaining against the privates respondents,
who, in league with the Revenue Authorities,
have
managed to get the revenue record changed with a view
to sell the same.
08. It is borne out from the record that the Naib Tehsildar,
Zainakote, taking cognizance of the complaint, in terms
of Order dated 6th January, 2016, directed the Patwari
Halqa (respondent no. 7) to submit requisite report along
with the revenue extracts by treating the matter as
urgent.
09. Furthermore, the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, in
terms of the Communication dated 16th November, 2016,
directed the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, to enquire
into the matter, but nothing was done so far, as pleaded
by
the
petitioners
in
the
instant
petition
and
subsequently the Deputy Commissioner in term of
Communication dated 19th November, 2016 directed the
Assistant Commissioner Nazool Srinagar to conduct indepth enquiry into the matter and furnish the findings
within a period of 15 days time.
10. Accordingly, the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, vide
Communication
dated
16th
November,
again
directed the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar to furnish
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
the factual report within a period of two days by treating
the matter as urgent, who, in turn, vide Communication
dated 23rd November, 2017 furnished the report before
the Divisional Commissioner Kashmir, reporting therein
that the enquiry in the matter is yet to be completed and
expressed inability to complete the same in view of the
fact that the lower
rung revenue officials are not
cooperating/responding to the enquiry being conducted
in the matter. The report, it is stated, itself highlights the
vast
and
a
deep
conspiracy
between
the
private
respondents and the revenue officials to illegally change
the nature of the land with the intention to sell out the
same without any authority under law.
11. Feeling aggrieved of the illegal acts committed by the
officials of Revenue Department as well as private
respondents, the petitioners have challenged the same
through the medium of the instant petition.
12. It is specifically pleaded in the instant petition that the
respondents, with the active help of Revenue Authorities,
have caused conversion in the nature of the land which
is strictly prohibited in
terms of the provisions of the
law, besides this, it is also pleaded by the petitioners
that this Court, in numerous writ petitions, from time to
time, has issued directions for preventing/stopping the
conversion of agricultural land and the action of the
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
respondent with respect to the conversion of the
agricultural land is, therefore, not only illegal and
contrary to the applicable law, but is also in clear
violation and disregard of the directions issued by this
Court from time to time.
13. It is pleaded by the petitioners in the instant petition
that in view of the conversion of their land by the private
respondents with the aid and assistance of Revenue
Authorities, the matter assumes great significance and
prayed that appropriate directions deserved to be issued
for stopping conversion of their land. It is further
pleaded that they are being deprived of their property
without any authority of law as the right to property
being a fundamental right, therefore, they cannot be
deprived of the same in the aforesaid manner.
14. It is the specific case of the petitioners that the Revenue
Authorities have been issuing revenue extracts in favour
of the private respondents, depicting the nature and
character of the land contrary to the existing revenue
record and, therefore, the nature and character of the
land, which stands recorded as agricultural land, has
been illegally altered and manipulated. It is further
submitted by the petitioners that in terms of the relevant
provisions of the applicable Agrarian Reforms Law, the
nature and character of Agricultural land cannot be
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
altered or the land cannot be put to any use other than
that which is permissible under law and in that view of
the
matter,
constitute
a
the
acts
of
the
private
respondents,
violation
of
the
statutory
provisions
governing the use and conversion of agricultural land. In
furtherance
to
aforesaid
illegal
acts,
the
private
respondents have fraudulently executed sale deeds in
respect of the land belonging to the petitioner that too
with the aid and assistance of certain revenue officials,
as such, the said officials have not only manipulated the
entries in the revenue records but have also illegally
altered
the
ownership
column
thereof,
thereby
facilitating the creation of a false and misleading record
in respect of the subject land.
15. In the instant petition, the petitioners have pleaded that
the enquiry initiated by the Divisional Commissioner,
Kashmir, has not been taken to its conclusion and no
action has been taken against the revenue officials who
have committed illegal acts and managed to change the
nature of the land with a view to enable the private
respondents to sell the land of the petitioners illegally. It
is further pleaded by the petitioners that the documents
placed on record pertaining to the enquiry initiated by
the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, is an eye opener
to the fact that the Revenue Authorities have flouted the
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
law at their pleasure. The petitioners, accordingly,
pleaded
that
the
erring
officials
and
the
private
respondents, therefore, in view of the flagrant violation of
the law need to be dealt with strictly for ensuring that
common people do not suffer loss of the property at the
hands of unscrupulous revenue officials. The change of
nature of the land is strictly prohibited under law and
for all practical purposes, the agriculture land shall
always remain agricultural in nature and any change
caused on the same by execute sale deeds illegal,
without authority is a fraud and, therefore, the same are
vitiated and rendered void.
16. Per
contra,
objections
stand
filed
on
behalf
of
respondents 1 to 7 and 13, in which, the respondents
have taken a specific stand that they, pursuant to the
directions of competent Authority, a detailed and
comprehensive demarcation of the land under reference
was conducted by a team of Revenue Officers/Officials
headed by Tehsildar Eidgagh Srinagar and a detailed
demarcation report was prepared after due verification of
revenue
record, spot
inspection
and
measurement
through Electronic Total Station (ETS).
17. The further stand of the respondents is that as per the
Jamabandi
for
the
year
1992-93,
the
total
land
measuring 62 Kanals 18 Marlas 36 Square feets is
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
jointly
recorded
in
the
name
of
Abdul
Rehman
(Applicant) and his legal heirs (Petitioners), Abdul Rahim
(non-applicant) and his legal heirs, and the said entries
stand intact and unaltered. The recorded share of the
petitioners’ side (Abdul Rehman applicant therein) is 31
Kanals 10 ½ Marlas 5 Squre feets, whereas the recorded
share of the non-applicant side (Abdul Rahim) is 32
Kanals 19 Marlas, thereby constituting the entire estate.
18. In the reply filed by the respondents, a further stand has
been taken by the respondents that during the course of
demarcation, the team first reconciled the old revenue
record
with
the
modern
Electronic
Total
Station
measurement and found that the total land existing on
spot corresponds substantially with the recorded area,
with only a mirror variation of about 2.48%, which is
technically acceptable and attributable to differences
between
conventional
chain
measurement
and
Electronic Total Station measurement and thereafter, the
demarcation team physically identified and mapped the
entire estate on spot and record that the land has
presently
assumed
the
character
of
a
developed
residential colony with approximately fifty-five plots
carved out and internal roads laid out for access and
connectivity.
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
19. The further stand of the respondents is that total area
under
roads,
as
measured
and
recorded
in
the
demarcation report comes to 10 Kanals 6 Marlas and 12
Square feets, which serves the entire layout of the colony
and benefits all the plot holders irrespective of their
original share.
The demarcation report specifically and
unequivocally records the entire area of roads measuring
10 Kanals 6 marlas 12 Square feets which has been
deducted from the share of the petitioners, instead of
being proportionately distributed between both cosharers in accordance with their respective recorded
shares. The demarcation report further clarified that as
per the principle of proportionate deduction, the road
area ought to have been apportioned between the two cosharers in the ratio of their respective record shares, but
in the present layout the burden of the entire road area
has fallen upon the petitioner’s share.
20. The respondents have also stated in the reply that with
regard to alienations, the demarcation report clearly
records that the non-applicant side has alienated 100%
of its recorded share, i.e., 32 Kanals 19 Marlas, through
different sale transactions executed in favour of third
parties and, thus, has fully exhausted its entitlement.
Insofar as, the grievance projected by the petitioners that
order of illegal conversion of agricultural land has been
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
passed by the respondents and revenue entry has been
altered
without
authority
of
law,
is
without
any
justification as no such order has been passed nor any
entry has been made for
any purpose and the
ownership column in the revenue records continues to
reflect the joint names of the recorded co-sharers.
21. The respondents have also taken a stand in their reply
that the allegations of fraud, collusion and manipulation
levelled in the writ petition are not borne out by the
findings of the detailed demarcation report, which was
prepared after objective measurement and verification of
records and the enquiry report reveals that the real
controversy pertains to the manner in which the area
under roads has been deducted and whether the same
requires proportionate adjustment between the cosharers, which is essentially a matter of inter se civil
adjustment and accounting between co-sharers. It is
further stand of the respondents that they neither
dispossessed the petitioners nor apportioned their land,
and no act attributable to the answering respondents
has resulted in deprivation of property, rather, the
factual position shows private alienations and internal
adjustments between co-sharers. The respondents have
acted
promptly
and
in
accordance
with
law
by
conducting demarcation, placing the factual position on
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
record, and identifying the precise extent of alienations
and road deductions, thereby discharging their statutory
duties fairly and transparently.
22. The respondents have further stated in the reply that in
view of the detailed findings recorded in the enquiry
report, the dispute, if any, is confined to proportionate
adjustment of road area and consequences of alienations
by the respective co-sharers, which are matters requiring
adjudication by a competent civil forum and cannot be
resolved in writ jurisdiction and the demarcation report
conclusively establishes that the entire share of 32
Kanals 19 Marlas belonging to the non-applicant has
been sold and 18 Kanals 11 Marlas out of 31 Kanals-10
1/2 Marlas and 5 Square Feets belonging to the
petitioners' have been sold and that the entire road area
of 10 Kanals-6 Marlas and 12 Square Feets has been
deducted from the petitioners' share, which forms the
core factual position emerging from the enquiry, as such,
in the light of the above factual and objective findings
recorded
in
the
demarcation
report,
no
illegality,
arbitrariness or jurisdictional error on the part of
Respondent Numbers 1 to 6 is made out. Accordingly,
the respondents prayed that the instant petition in view
of the aforesaid fact position be dismissed in limini, as
the detailed enquiry report clearly clarifies the factual
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
matrix
and
does
not
disclose
any
unlawful
act
attributable to respondents 1 to 6.
23. The respondents no. 13 has also filed reply affidavit, in
which, he has almost reiterated the same stand as taken
by the respondents 1 to 7 in their reply. In addition, the
respondent no.
13 has taken
a stand that
on the
application of the petitioner number 1, a committee
came to be constituted, headed by sub Divisional
Magistrate Srinagar west, to enquire into the matter
upon the order of the Divisional commissioner Kashmir
dated 23/09/2020 and finally a report came to be
submitted
which
made
it
clear
that
petitioner's
father(Abdul Rehman Gupkari) and his uncle (Abdul
Rahim Gupkari) were having in total 64 kanals,9 Marlas
of land, out of which petitioner's were having 31 Kanals
and 10 Marlas of land, the report further clarifies that
out of the said land petitioners have sold 18 Kanals, 11
Marlas of land through registered sale deeds to 24
person's, and uncle of the petitioner no. 1 has sold 32
Kanals, 14 Marlas to 22 different persons through
registered sale deeds. The vendees, now habitants have
further divided the area into more than 100 small plots
and every plot has its independent approach road, as
such, the during the development of the land into
residential colony land measuring 7 kanals,7 Marlas had
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
come under the construction of access roads having 12
to 14 feet width. It is further stand of the respondent no.
13 that the statements and grounds raised in the writ
petition are purely baseless wherein petitioners have
raised infinite disputed facts, petitioners have sold their
land through registered sale deeds and those deeds were
nowhere challenged, a report came to be furnished by an
enquiry team constituted upon the orders of the
Divisional
commissioner
Kashmir,
headed
by
Sub
Divisional Magistrate Srinagar, that report is also
nowhere challenged, therefore, the instant case is
nothing, but abuse of the process of law, wherein
petitioners
after
selling
their
land
after
taking
considerations, executing sale deeds, are only harassing
the lawful owners of the land, by pleading infinite
disputed facts. Thus, it has been pleaded by the
respondents that the instant writ petition deserves to be
dismissed.
24. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record.
25. When the learned counsel for the petitioners was
confronted with the argument advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the respondents that once the sale
deed was executed by the petitioners with regard to the
land in question, which sale deed was intact, then how
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
and under what circumstances the instant petition is
maintainable, learned counsel for the petitioners fairly
submits that insofar as the land sold to the private
respondents and other persons who are not parties in
the instant petition, is concerned, he has no grievance
and, therefore, he would have no objection if the relief
which he has claimed for stopping the construction over
the said land is not allowed. Therefore, the statement
made by learned counsel for the petitioners is taken on
record.
26. Mr. Sheikh Mushtaq, learned counsel for the petitioner,
in the same breath, submits that
insofar as the issue
involved with regard to the encroachment of remaining
land is concerned, the writ petition survives and
therefore, an enquiry is required to be conducted by the
competent Authority with a view to arrive at a subjective
satisfaction as to
whether the remaining land is the
proprietary land of the petitioners and whether the same
has been encroached or not.
27. The
grievance projected by the learned counsel for the
petitioners seems to be genuine which is supported by
the report submitted by the Sub Divisional Magistrate
(SDM), Srinagar, which has been enclosed with the
application being CM No. 1359/2022 filed by the
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
respondent no.13. For facility of reference paras 3 to 7
are reproduced as under:3. That the petitioners have sold their land of 31 kanals and 10
marlas under Khasra No.208 and 210 estate Barthana Srinagar
to different persons which was a single parcel of land and the
persons have constructed structures over the land by lawful
means and few left over portion of the land might have come
under the development of the approach roads to the colony.
The statement made in the writ petition that the petitioners
along with their father is the owner of 42 kanal is a sham and a
fraudulent statement dehors to the record and the multiple
reports prepared by the official Respondents on the request of
nonetheless but petitioners.
4. That the rpplicant/respondent No.13 has purchased a land
measuring 1 kanal & 10 marlas under survey No.210 mouza
Berthana Srinagar, vide sale deed executed on 30.12.2020 from
petitioner No.1 and his father Abdul Rehrnan Gupkari (father).
The land measuring 2 Kanals under survey No.208 was sold to
applicant/respondent No.13 by the father of petitioner No.1
Abdul Rehman Gupkari (1073/753/440/208) vide sale deed
dated
24.04.2010. Further, petitioner No.1. executed a sale against
power of attorney duly registered in favour of applicant/
respondent No.13 with specific powers of sale and gift for land
measuring more 2. kanals under survey No.210 (812/299/210),
which was lawfully, acted upon by the applicant creating lawful
interest in favour of third parties in the year 2012. Also, the wife
of applicant/respondent No.13 Mst, Zubaida is owner in
possession of land measuring 2 Kanals & 10 Marlas under
survey
No.210 (805/298/210) which is purchased from different owners
of
land other than petitioners, out of said land, she has executed
sale deed in favour of Naseer Ahmad Khanday and Ghulam
Hassan on 06.10.2021 for land measuring 10 1/2 Marlas and is
left
with one kanal and 19 ½ Marlas of land in her possession and
ownership. Since the land under survey numbers as mentioned
in writ petition consists of land measuring more than 200 kanals
of land belongs to multiple persons as its owners and the order
of status-quo has caused immense hardships to the applicant
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
and other lawful owners of the land at the same time petitioners
have no land left in any of the survey numbers in Estate
Barthana Srinagar, thus cannot maintain a cause , much less the
relief sought as against the applicant/respondent No.13. who
had lawful authority to exercise his all rights attached with the
land and in no stretch of imagination be termed as encroacher
of the land of petitioners.
The necessary sale deeds, sale agreements; power of
attorney and revenue extracts authenticated the stand of the
Applicant/Respondent No.13
are
annexed
as
Annexure-Ill,
collectively.
5. That the ex-parte order dated 16.09.2020 is prejudicial to the
rights of applicant and harshly in operation as against the
owners in possession of the land under survey No.208, 209 &
210 Estate Barthana Srinagar, thus is required to be vacated in
view of the submissions hereinabove made and also in sequel to
the deliberate suppression of material facts made by the
petitioners,
who
have
now
gone
to
office
of
Divisional
Commissioner Kashmir with the same cause as agitated in the
instant writ petition and despite order of status-quo has issued
notices to the lawful occupants including the applicant and his
family members seeking forcible unlawful eviction as the
petitioner have filed series of miscellaneous petitions including
one seeking registration of FIR and restoration of possession
before this Hon'ble Court in the pending writ petition which has
become a source of unwarranted harassment to the lawful
owners, occupants and possessors who is not in a position of
even getting the revenue extracts! Fard issued for various
collateral lawful purposes despite having lawful right due to the
ex-parte order of status-quo passed by this Hon'ble Court. The
issuance of Fard or any lawful change under survey No.208, 209
and 210 is completely under the status-quo order implication,
even the petitioners have persuaded the office of Divisional
Commissioner Kashmir to issue a communication to the SSP
Srinagar to take penal action against the applicant and his family
members including revenue officials for issuance of any revenue
extracts for entire land under survey No.208, 209 & 210 which
as
submitted is not less than 200 Kanals used these survey
numbers
when at the same time team constituted has clearly and
minutely submitted report to Divisional Commissioner Kashmir,
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
that petitioners and deceased Abdul Rehman Gupkari has sold
their entire land to various persons including applicant and his
family and some portion of land has come under approach
roads which leads to the houses developed over the land sold
by Abdul Rehman and his brother Abdul Rahim approximately.
64 Kanals. The communication of Divisional Commissioner to SSP
Srinagar prejudicial to the applicant dated 04.08.2021 is
enclosed
as Annexure-IV.
6. That the petitioners being day dreamers are trying to created
castles in the vacuum without any lawful justification by bringing
a cause without availability of any right. The continuation of the
ex-parte order is very harsh and unwarranted apart from being a
tool of harassment for the applicant, his family and similarly
situated hundreds of persons, occupants of approximately 200
Kanals of land under survey No.208, 209 & 210.”
28.
In addition, Mr. Sheikh Mushtaq, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners has drawn the attention of
this Court to the recommendation of the Enquiry
Committee,
a perusal whereof reveals that the land
measuring 12 Kanals 19 Marals and 136 Square feets
remains in the ownership of the petitioners as per the
record. The committee has also concluded that the land
measuring 7 Kanal and 7 Marlas out of the total land
measuring 64 Kanals 9 Marlas and 136 Sft’s comes
under the access roads for residential plots on spot.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that
although
the
report
has
been
submitted
by
the
competent Authority, but till date the finding of the said
report has not been brought to its logical conclusion and
the action in terms of the aforesaid report has not been
taken, with the result the petitioners continue to suffer.
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
29. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that he
would feel satisfied in case the conclusion drawn by the
said committee is brought to its conclusion and action in
this regard is taken within some time frame, to which,
learned counsel for the respondents are not averse.
30.
Therefore, this Court in the aforesaid backdrop deems
it
appropriate
to
direct
the
concerned
Deputy
Commissioner to take cognizance of the said report and
take remedial measures in this regard within a period
six weeks from today after affording an opportunity of
being heard to all the stake
holders including the
petitioners as well as the private respondents and pass a
detailed consideration order in this regard. It is made
clear that the consideration order shall be implemented
thereafter within a period of four weeks. It is further
made clear that in case the petitioners are not satisfied
with the decision which is likely to be taken by the
concerned Deputy Commissioner after hearing all the
stake holders, they shall be at liberty to challenge the
same by way of appropriate proceedings, if so advised.
31. At this stage, Mr. I Sofi, learned counsel appearing for
applicant(s) in CM No. 6571/2025 has
drawn
the
attention of this Court to an Order dated 11th August,
2026 passed in the instant writ petition, a perusal
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
whereof reveals that the Tehsildar Shalteng, Srinagar,
who was present in person, has made a categorical
statement
that
as
per
the
demarcation
already
conducted by Tehsildar Eidgah and Naib Tehsildar
Pantha Chowk, he would delineate and process of the
application of the applicant herein for the issuance of
Fard within a period of four weeks from the date of
passing of the said order, which order, according to Mr.
I.Sofi, has not been implemented.
32. The concerned Deputy Commissioner, while passing the
detailed consideration order in terms of the directions
passed by this Court mentioned supra, shall also give
due weightage to the Order passed by this Court in the
instant petition on 11th August, 2026 mentioned supra
33. The writ petition in the aforesaid backdrop is disposed
of along with all connected CM(s).
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
15.09.2026
“Shamim Dar”
WP(C) No. 1696/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review