Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/30
GAHC010183412025
2026:GAU-AS:10897
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4932/2025
ABDUL KARIM AND ANR
S/O- LATE ROIS ALI, R/O- DHARAKUNA, WARD NO. 2, KARIMGANJ
MUNICIPAL BOARD, P.O. AND P.S. KARIMGANJ, DIST. SRIBHUMI, ASSAM,
PIN- 788712.
2: PIYARA BEGUM
D/O- LATE ROIS ALI
W/O- ABDUL MUTLIB
R/O- VILL.- ALONGJURI
P.O. SILCHAR ROAD
P.S. KARIMGANJ
DIST. SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN- 788713 AND PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LONGAI ROAD (SARALKHA
ROAD) P.O. SETTLEMENT ROAD
P.S. KARIMGANJ
DIST. SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN- 788710
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF
ASSAM, HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT, ASSAM
SECRETARIAT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006.
2:THE DIRECTORATE OF HEALTH SERVICES (FAMILY WELFARE)
ASSAM
SWASTHYA BHAWAN
HENGRABARI
GUWAHATI-781036.
3:THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES CUM ADDITIONAL
Page No.# 2/30
DISTRICT
REGISTRAR OF BIRTHS AND DEATHS
KARIMGANJ OLD HOSPITAL ROAD
DIST. SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN- 788710.
4:THE REGISTRAR OF BIRTHS AND DEATHS
KARIMGANJ MUNICIPAL BOARD
MAIN ROAD
KARIMGANJ
DIST. SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN- 788710.
5:LILA BEGUM
W/O LT. MOSTAN ALI
D/O LT. ROIS ALI
R/O NARIKHOLI
P.O. LAKSHMIBAZAR
P.S. AND DIST- SHIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN-78870
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. O. Laskar, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. B. D. Das, Sr. Advocate
: Mr. D. Upamanyu, Standing Counsel
: Ms. R. Deka, Advocate
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: N/A
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 05.08.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: Yes
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: N/A
·
Page No.# 3/30
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. O. Laskar, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the Petitioners and Mr. D. Upamanyu, the learned Standing counsel
appearing on behalf of the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4. I have also
heard Mr. B. D. Das, the learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. R.
Deka, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent
No.5.
PREFACE:
2.
Both
the
Petitioners
herein
are
aggrieved
by
the
communication dated 28.01.2022 as well as the subsequent
communications dated 24.06.2022 which have been enclosed as
Annexures 6, 7, and 8 to the writ petition whereby the Birth
Certificates of both the Petitioners have been cancelled by the
Respondent No.4.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE:
3.
The case of the Petitioners herein is that the Petitioner No.1 is
the son and the Petitioner No.2 is the daughter of one Late Rois Ali
and Late Suran Bibi of Longai Road (Saralkha Lane), Karimganj.
The Petitioner No.1 was born on 05.10.1996 and the Petitioner
Page No.# 4/30
No.2 was born on 12.05.1991. In the year 2015 and more
particularly on 09.06.2015 and 01.07.2015, the Petitioner No.1 and
Petitioner No.2 respectively were issued their Birth Certificates by
the Respondent No.4.
4.
A perusal of the said Birth Certificates reveal that insofar as
the Petitioner No.1 is concerned, the date of issue of the said Birth
Certificate is 09.06.2015 and the registration date is 15.11.2013.
However, in the case of the Petitioner No.2, the date of registration
of the said Birth Certificate is mentioned as 15.11.2013 and the
signature of the Issuing Authority is 01.07.2015.
5.
It is the case of the Petitioners that the Petitioner No.1 was
issued a communication by the Respondent no.4 on 28.01.2022
informing him about the cancellation of his Birth Certificate and
further directed the Petitioner No.1 to return the said Birth
Certificate. Subsequent thereto, vide two separate communications
both dated 24.06.2022 were issued whereby both the Petitioners
were informed about the cancellation of the Birth Certificate and
directions were issued asking the Petitioners to submit the
cancelled birth certificate before the Respondent No.4 on or before
28.06.2022.
Page No.# 5/30
6.
The Petitioners being aggrieved, filed a suit being Title Suit
No.214/2022 before the Court of the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division) No.3, Sribhumi assailing the cancellation orders of their
Birth Certificates by the impugned communications which were
enclosed to the present proceedings as Annexures 6, 7 & 8. The
said suit was dismissed by the learned Trial Court on the ground
that the suit was not maintainable in view of Section 28(1) of the
Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969 (for short ‘the Act of
1969’). It is under such circumstances, the Petitioners have
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition.
7.
This Court duly takes note of that initially the Respondent
Nos.1 to 4 were the only parties arrayed by the Petitioners.
Subsequently, on an application filed by the Respondent No.5 as
Applicant i.e. I.A.(Civil) No.171/2026, the Respondent No.5 was
arrayed as a party to the present proceedings.
8.
The records reveal that notice in the instant writ petition was
issued on 27.08.2025. Even after a passage of almost 1 (one) year,
the Respondent Nos.1 to 4 have not cared to file their counter.
9.
The Respondent No.5 had filed an affidavit-in-opposition. A
perusal of the said affidavit-in-opposition reveals that it is on the
Page No.# 6/30
basis of the complaint being submitted by the Respondent No.5
and her mother Late Suran Bibi, the proceedings were initiated for
cancellation of the Petitioners’ Birth Certificates. This aspect would
be apparent from an undated communication issued by the
Respondent No.5 and her mother to the Respondent No.3. A
perusal of the said communication, which has been enclosed as
Annexure-1 to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the Respondent
No.5 would show that the Respondent No.5 and her mother did not
either contest the date of birth of the Petitioners or the place of
birth. The challenge to the Birth Certificates issued to the
Petitioners is on the ground that the names of the parents of the
Petitioners have been wrongly inserted in their Birth Certificates. It
was the contention of the Respondent No.5 and her mother in the
said application that Late Rois Ali was not the father of the
Petitioners.
10. On the basis of the said communication submitted by the
Respondent No.5 and her mother, the Respondent No.3 issued a
communication to the Deputy Commissioner cum District Registrar
of Births and Deaths, Karimganj. The communication issued by the
Respondent No.3 to the Respondent No.4 dated 30.06.2020 is of
relevance inasmuch as the Respondent No.3 not only asked the
Respondent No.4 to conduct an enquiry as to whether there was a
Page No.# 7/30
fraudulent entry as regards the name of the parents in the Birth
Certificates of the Petitioners but also to enquire as regards the
compliance to Section 13(3) of the Act of 1969.
11. The instant writ petition was listed before this Court on
03.08.2026 on which date, this Court fixed the matter today for
final disposal. Today, when the matter was taken up, Mr. D.
Upamanyu, the learned Standing counsel who represents the
Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 submitted that though the said
Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 have not filed their affidavit-in-opposition
however the Birth Certificates were cancelled after an enquiry was
carried out by the Respondent No.4. In that regard, a set of
documents were placed before this Court during the course of
hearing which included the enquiry report. The documents are
collectively kept on record and marked with the letter “X”. The
documents so placed were:
(A)
The communication issued by the Respondent No.4
dated 24.06.2022 to the Petitioner No.2;
(B)
The communication dated 24.06.2022 issued by the
Respondent No.4 to the Petitioner No.1;
(C)
The forwarding letter issued by the Assistant
Page No.# 8/30
Commissioner on behalf of the Deputy Commissioner,
Karimganj dated 20.01.2022 enclosing the legal
opinion;
(D)
The legal opinion of the Government Pleader,
Karimganj dated 17.01.2022 wherein it was opined
that the Birth Certificates should be cancelled;
(E) The Birth Certificate of the Petitioner No.1;
(F) The Birth Certificate of the Petitioner No.2;
(G)
The communication dated 28.01.2022 issued by the
Respondent No.4 to the Petitioner No.1 informing
about the cancellation of his Birth Certificate;
(H)
The communication dated 28.01.2022 issued by the
Respondent No.4 to the Petitioner No.2 informing
about the cancellation of her Birth Certificate;
(I)
The communication issued by the Respondent No.3 to
the Respondent No.4 dated 16.06.2022 directing the
Respondent No.4 to direct the Petitioners to hand over
the cancelled Birth Certificates; and
Page No.# 9/30
(J)
The Enquiry Report dated 07.11.2020 made by the
Respondent No 4.
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR THE
PARTIES:
12. Mr. O. Laskar, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioners submitted that the impugned communications of
cancellation of the Birth Certificates of the Petitioners dated
28.01.2022 as well as 24.06.2022 are in violation to the principles
of natural justice inasmuch as without giving the Petitioners an
opportunity, the said Birth Certificates could not have been
cancelled. The learned counsel for the Petitioners further submitted
that from the stand so taken by the Respondent No.5, it appears
that the Birth Certificates have not been challenged on the aspect
pertaining to the Date of Birth of the Petitioners, but the Birth
Certificates have been questioned by the Respondent No.5 on the
question of the parentage of the Petitioners. The learned counsel
for the Petitioners further submitted that the question of
parentage, if disputed, the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 have no
jurisdiction or authority inasmuch as the said aspect can only be
decided by the Civil Court.
13. Mr. D. Upamanyu, the learned Standing counsel appearing on
Page No.# 10/30
behalf of the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 have relied upon the
documents which have been placed before this Court and kept on
record and marked with the letter “X”. He submitted that there was
an enquiry being conducted on the issue as to whether the
Petitioners’ parents were Late Rois Ali and Late Suran Bibi. The
learned Standing counsel further referring to the enquiry report
submitted that notices were sent to Moni Bibi as well as the
Petitioners to appear before the Respondent No.4 and to give their
statements regarding the matter but they failed to do so. On
27.07.2020, the Petitioner No.1 submitted a petition along with
some documents and stated that if any complain made against him
by his sister i.e. the Respondent No.5 herein, or her husband, the
same should be rejected as the matter is under adjudication in the
competent Court of Law. On the basis thereof, the learned
Standing counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent Nos.1 to
4 submitted that the Petitioners were aware of the said enquiry
and the Petitioners were also granted an opportunity.
14. Mr. B. D. Das, the learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the Respondent No.5 submitted that a fraud was committed by
the Petitioners by inserting the names of the parents of the
Respondent No.5 in the Birth Certificates and on the basis thereof,
the
Petitioners
are
taking
advantage.
It
is
under
such
Page No.# 11/30
circumstances, the Respondent No.5 and her mother were
compelled to submit a complaint before the Respondent No.3. The
learned Senior counsel submitted that the Petitioners’ dates of birth
were sometime in the year 1991 and 1996 and they were issued
the Birth Certificates sometime in the year 2015 with the
registration date of 15.11.2013. These certificates could not have
been issued without the fulfillment of the requirement of Section
13 of the Act of 1969.
15.
The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the
legislature have categorically mentioned as to what steps are
required to be taken if there is a delay beyond one year from the
occurrence of the birth or the death when there is a request for
issuance of a Birth or Death Certificate. This aspect is very
pertinent for the purpose of the present case inasmuch as, if there
is a delay beyond one year, there is a requirement of an order
made by the District Magistrate or the Sub-Divisional Magistrate or
by the Executive Magistrate who would verify the correctness of
the birth. The learned Senior counsel submitted that without the
order of the District Magistrate or the Sub-Divisional Magistrate or
the Executive Magistrate, the Petitioners were issued these Birth
Certificates and a fraud was committed by the Petitioners in
concert and collusion with the officials of the Respondent No.4. He
Page No.# 12/30
therefore submitted that the cancellation of the birth certificates
vide the impugned communications which have been enclosed at
Annexures 6, 7, and 8 need not be interfered with.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION:
16. I have heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf of the
parties and have perused the materials on record.
17. From a perusal of the materials on record, it is relevant to take
note of that the Petitioners though were born in the years 1991
and 1996 but their dates of birth were registered only on
15.11.2013 and the birth certificates were issued in the year 2015.
18. Section 13 of the Act of 1969 as it stood prior to the
Registration of Births and Deaths (Amendment) Act, 2023 (for
short “the Amending Act of 2023”) is relevant for the purpose of
the present adjudication inasmuch as the Birth Certificates were
issued in the year 2015.
19. Section 13(1) of the Act of 1969 stipulated that any birth or
death of which information was given to the Registrar after the
expiry of the period specified therefor but within 30 (thirty) days of
its occurrence shall be registered on payment of such fee as may
Page No.# 13/30
be prescribed.
20. Sub-Section (2) of Section 13 of the Act of 1969 further
stipulated that if the information is given after 30 (thirty) days of
the occurrence of the birth or death as the case may be but before
one year, the said aspect would be registered subject to the written
permission of the prescribed Authority along with an affidavit made
before a Notary Public or any other Officer authorized by the State
Government.
21. Sub-Section (3) of Section 13 of the Act of 1969 is of
relevance inasmuch as any birth or death which had not been
registered within one year of its occurrence shall be registered only
on an order made by a Magistrate of the First Class or a Presidency
Magistrate after verifying the correctness of the birth and on
payment of a prescribed fee.
22.
This Court further finds it relevant to observe that the
Petitioners admit that they were born in the years 1996 and 1991
and their Birth Certificates were issued in the year 2015 and as
such, without orders of the Magistrate of the First Class, there
could not have been registration of their date of birth by the
Respondent No.4 and consequential issuance of Birth Certificates.
Page No.# 14/30
23. At this stage, this Court finds it relevant to peruse the enquiry
report dated 07.11.2020 made by the Respondent No.4 wherein it
is mentioned that the Birth Certificates were issued pursuant to the
production of Court affidavit by the informant and the information
was verified by the then Ward Commissioner of the concerned
Ward and after accord of permission by the District Magistrate for
Registration of Birth. Under such circumstances, the report dated
07.11.2020 shows compliance to Section 13(3) of the Act of 1969.
24. Let this Court now consider the most pertinent aspect as to
whether the Respondent No.4 could be initiated an enquiry on the
basis of the complaint submitted by the Respondent No.5 and her
mother. The complaint submitted by the Respondent.5 and her
mother is Annexure-1 to the affidavit of the Respondent No.5. A
perusal of the said complaint would show that the Respondent
No.5 and her mother Late Suran Bibi alleged that the Petitioners
have by fraudulent means obtained the Birth Certificates in
question by inserting Late Rois Ali as their father though the
Petitioners were not the son and daughter of Late Rois Ali.
25. The Respondent No.3 on the basis of the said complaint
requested the Respondent No.4 to carry out an enquiry. On the
basis of the said direction, the Respondent No.4 initiated an
Page No.# 15/30
enquiry and submitted a report on 07.11.2020 as would be
apparent from the documents kept on record and marked with the
letter “X”.
26. A perusal of the enquiry report shows that the Respondent
No.4 made enquiry on the aspect whether the Petitioners were the
son and daughter of Late Rois Ali and submitted a report to the
District Registrar without opining any decision. The question which
arises is whether such enquiry into the parentage of the Petitioners
by the Respondent No.4 was permissible as per the Act of 1969 in
the facts of the present case.
27. It is the specific contention of the learned Senior counsel for
the Respondent No.5 as well as the Standing counsel of the
Respondent Authority that such power can be traced to Section 15
of the Act of 1969. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
Petitioner submitted that it was impermissible for the Respondent
No.4 to conduct an enquiry into the question of parentage and
referred to the judgment of the learned Kerala High Court in the
case of Aaa vs State of Kerala reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Ker
5445.
28. For the purpose of deciding the said question formulated
Page No.# 16/30
hereinabove, it is relevant to take note of the scheme of the Act of
1969 as it stood in the year 2015 when the Birth Certificates were
issued and further what is the present position of law after the
Amending Act of 2023.
29. The Preamble of the Act of 1969 stipulates that the Act of
1969 was enacted for the regulation of registration of births and
deaths and for matters connected thereto. The Statement of
Objects and Reasons behind the enactment of the Act of 1969 was
the necessity of adequate and accurate data for registration of
births and deaths in the country for the Central Government to
further its purposes of national planning, organizing public health,
medical activities and developing family planning programmes.
30. Chapter II of the Act of 1969 deals with the Registration
Establishment. There had been significant amendments made to in
this Chapter by the Amending Act of 2023. Be that as it may, a
perusal of Sections 3 to 7 of the Act of 1969 would show the
hierarchical of powers conferred upon various authorities. In terms
with Section 4 of the Act of 1969, the State Government would
appoint a Chief Registrar for the State. The State Government
would also appoint such other officers with such designations as it
thinks fit for the purpose of discharging under the superintendence
Page No.# 17/30
and direction of the Chief Registrar, such of his functions as he
may, from time to time, authorize them to discharge.
31. Section 5 of the Act of 1969 empowers the State Government
by notification in the Official Gazette divide the territory within the
State into such registration divisions as it may think fit and
prescribe different Rules for different registration divisions.
32. Section 6 of the Act of 1969 empowers the State Government
to appoint District Registrars for each Revenue District and
Additional District Registrars to assist them.
33. Section 7 of the Act of 1969 relates to the post of Registrar.
The said Section 7 of the Act of 1969 as it stood prior to the
Amending Act of 2023 being relevant is reproduced hereunder:
“7. Registrars.— (1) The State Government may appoint a Registrar for each
local area comprising the area within the jurisdiction of a municipality,
panchayat or other local authority or any other area or a combination of any
two or more of them:
Provided that the State Government may appoint in the case of a
municipality, panchayat, or other local authority, any officer or other employee
thereof as a Registrar.
(2)
Every Registrar shall, without fee or reward, enter in the register
Page No.# 18/30
maintained for the purpose all information given to him under section 8 or
section 9 and shall also take steps to inform himself carefully of every birth
and of every death which takes place in his jurisdiction and to ascertain and
register the particulars required to be registered.
(3)
Every Registrar shall have an office in the local area for which he is
appointed.
(4)
Every Registrar shall attend his office for the purpose of registering
births and deaths on such days and at such hours as the Chief Registrar may
direct and shall cause to be placed in some conspicuous place on or near the
outer door of the office of the Registrar a board bearing, in the local language,
his name with the addition of Registrar of Births and Deaths for the local area
for which he is appointed, and the days and hours of his attendance.
(5)
The Registrar may, with the prior approval of the Chief Registrar,
appoint Sub-Registrars and assign to them any or all of his powers and duties
in relation to specified areas within his jurisdiction.”
34. It is relevant to take note of that by the Amending Act of
2023, Sub-Sections (2) and (5) of Section 7 of the Act of 1969 was
amended and an Explanation was inserted. The amended SubSection (2) of the Section 7 of the Act of 1969 is relevant inasmuch
as post the Amending Act, the Register maintained could be a
physical copy or electronic records or otherwise. Further, it was
made explicit that the entry in the register of all information given
to the Registrar under Section 8 and Section 9 of the Act of 1969
Page No.# 19/30
should be in respect to births and deaths which had taken place
within his jurisdiction.
35.
Now, let this Court take note of what information is required
to be provided to the Registrar and who is to provide such
information. Prior to the Amending Act of 2023, the information to
be provided under Section 8 of the Act of 1969 was such
information, the particulars of which is required to be entered in
the forms prescribed by the State Government under Section 16(1)
of the Act of 1969. Post the Amending Act of 2023, in addition to
the information to be provided of the particulars contained in the
forms prescribed by the State Government, there is a requirement
of providing the Aadhaar numbers of parents and informant, if
available, in case of birth. The persons who are to provide the
information are enlisted in the various Sub-Clauses of Sub-Section
(1) of Section 8 of the Act of 1969. It is noteworthy to mention
that post the Amending Act, the various types of persons to
provide the information in different circumstances have been
enlarged.
Before proceeding further, it is relevant to mention that the
State of Assam had in exercise of powers conferred by Section 30
of the Act of 1969 framed the Assam Registration of Births and
Page No.# 20/30
Deaths Rules, 1999 (for short “the Rules”). These Rules
commenced
w.e.f.
08.09.2000.
In
these
Rules
and
more
particularly Rule 5, the Forms etc. for giving information of births
and deaths were mentioned. Form-1 relates to information as
regards birth; Form-2 is as regards death and Form-3 is as regards
still birth.
A perusal of Form-1 would show that various types of
information are required to be provided for registration of birth. It
includes amongst others the date of Birth; Sex; Name of the Child
(if not named to be kept blank); Name of the Father; Name of the
Mother; Place of Birth; Religion; Father's Occupation; Mother's
Occupation; Age of the mother at the time of birth; type of
delivery; Method of delivery; birth weight (in Kgs) (if available) etc.
36. Therefore, from a conjoint reading of Section 8 of the Act of
1969 read with the Rule 5 of the Rules and Form-1 as prescribed, it
is clear that various details are required to be provided by the
informant which includes amongst others the name of the father
and mother of the child.
37. Let this Court now take note of Section 12 of the Act of 1969
which stipulates that based upon the information provided, the
Page No.# 21/30
Registrar shall after the completion of registration of birth or death
provide the extracts of the prescribed particulars under his hand
from the Register relating to such birth or death. The Amending
Act of 2023 had substituted Section 12 of the Act of 1969 by
inserting that the Registrar after completion of the registration of
birth or death shall provide within 7 (seven) days a certificate
extracted from the Register relating to birth and death in such form
and manner as may be prescribed.
The Birth Certificates in question were therefore issued in
terms with Section 12 of the Act of 1969.
38. Section 15 of the Act of 1969 is relevant for the purpose of the
instant case, as the impugned orders are made under the said
provision. Section 15 of the Act of 1969 is reproduced herein
below:
“15. Correction or cancellation of entry in the register of births and
deaths.—If it is proved to the satisfaction of the Registrar that any entry of a
birth or death in any register kept by him under this Act is erroneous in form
or substance, or has been fraudulently or improperly made, he may, subject to
such rules as may be made by the State Government with respect to the
conditions on which and the circumstances in which such entries may be
corrected or cancelled, correct the error or cancel the entry by suitable entry
in the margin, without any alteration of the original entry, and shall sign the
marginal entry and add thereto the date of the correction or cancellation.”
Page No.# 22/30
39. The above quoted Section is with the heading correction or
cancellation of entry in the register of births and deaths. In other
words, powers have been conferred upon the Registrar to correct
or cancel an entry in the Register. This power is distinct from the
power conferred under Section 12 of the Act of 1969 to issue a
certificate of the extracts of the prescribed particulars. A further
reading of Section 15 of the Act of 1969 would show when such
power can be exercised.
It has to be proved to the satisfaction of the Registrar that:
Any entry of a birth or death in any Register kept by him
under the Act of 1969 is
(a) Erroneous in form or substance; or
(b) Had been fraudulently or improperly made.
It is further apposite to observe that upon being proved to the
satisfaction of the Registrar, subject to the Rules framed by the
State, the Registrar may
(a) correct the error; or
Page No.# 23/30
(b) cancel the entry
by making a suitable entry in the margin, without alteration of
the original entry and shall sign the marginal entry and add thereto
the date of correction or cancellation.
40. Taking into consideration the manner in which the proceedings
are to be conducted by the Registrar under Section 15 of the Act of
1969 is spelt out in Rule 11 of the Rules, the said Rule 11 of the
Rules is reproduced hereunder:
“11.
Correction or cancellation of entry in the registrar of births and
deaths.
(1)
If it is reported to the Registrar that a clerical or formal error has ben made
in the register or if such error is otherwise noticed by him and if the register is in
his possession, the Registrar shall enquire into the matter and if he is satisfied that
any such error has been made, he shall correct the error (by correcting or
cancelling the entry) as provided in Section 15 and shall send an extract of the
entry showing the error and how it has been corrected to the Chief Registrar of
Births and Deaths
(2)
In the case referred to in sub-rule (1) if the register is not in his possession
the Registrar shall make a report to the District Registrar and obtain relevant
records and after enquiring into the matter, if he is satisfied that any such error
has been made, make the necessary correction with prior and express approval of
the District Registrar.
(3)
Any such correction as mentioned in sub-rule (2) shall be countersigned by
Page No.# 24/30
the District Registrar.
(4)
If any person asserts that any entry in the register of births and deaths is
erroneous in substance, the Registrar may correct the entry in the manner
prescribed under Section 15 upon production by that person a declaration setting
forth the nature of the error and true facts of the case made by tow credible
parsons having knowledge of the facts of the case.
(5)
Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), and sub-rule (4), the
Registrar shall make report of any correction made therein giving necessary details
to the District Registrar
(6)
If it is proved to the satisfaction of the Registrar that any entry in the
register of births and deaths has been fraudulently or improperly made, he shall
make a report giving necessary details to the officer authorised by the Chief
Registrar by general or special order in this behalf under Section 25 and on
hearing from him take necessary action in the manner.
(7)
In every case in which an entry is corrected or cancelled under this rule,
intimation thereof should be sent to the permanent address of the person who has
given information under Section 8 or Section 9.”
41. From the above quoted Rule, it would show that in the case of
clerical or formal error, the Registrar can enquire and after being
satisfied, correct the error. However, in the case of fraudulent or
improper entry, the Registrar upon being satisfied shall make a
report by giving details to the officer authorised by the Chief
Registrar and upon hearing from the said Officer, the Registrar shall
act.
Page No.# 25/30
42. The phrase “if it is proved to the satisfaction of the Registrar”
is of great relevance to analyse the powers of the Registrar to act
in terms with Section 15 of the Act of 1969. The said phrase is a
well recognized legislative tool used across various statutes thereby
indicating conferment of quasi judicial functions on the named
authority. It means that the party asserting the fact bears a burden
of producing evidence/material and the authority on the basis of
such material or evidence forms its own subjective satisfaction.
43. It is however apposite to observe that this quasi judicial
function so conferred upon the Registrar should not be mistaken
with the powers of inquisition/investigation which is usually
performed by the police officer or commission of enquiry or even a
Court exercising discovery.
44. Therefore, the power so conferred under Section 15 of the Act
of 1969 upon the Registrar are to be exercised upon production of
proof by way of evidence/materials before the Registrar by the
person asserting the fraudulent and improper entry in the Register.
45. In the instant case, the materials on record would show that
based upon the complaint submitted by the Respondent No.5 and
her mother, the Respondent No.3 requested the Respondent No.4
Page No.# 26/30
vide the communication dated 30.06.2020 to look into the
complaint and if necessary to carry out a detailed enquiry. The
Respondent No.4 thereupon carried out a fact finding enquiry. In
the fact finding enquiry, the Respondent No.4 found all the
documentary evidence in favour of the Petitioners inasmuch as, all
the documents i.e. Birth Reporting Form, Voters list of 2020, NRC
Application, 2015; Elector Photo Identity issued on 18.02.2017,
PAN Card, Bank Passbook of Petitioner No.1, Admit Cards,
Registration Cards, School Certificates etc. It is also seen that the
Respondent No.4 had taken certain statements from local people
who stated otherwise. Based upon such statements, the report
dated 07.11.2020 was prepared and submitted to the District
Registrar. There is no decision or opinion of the Respondent No.4 in
the Report. Under such circumstances, the Report would not show
that the Respondent No.4 exercised its jurisdiction of arriving at
any subjective satisfaction.
46. The records more particularly the documents kept on record
and marked with the letter “X” would show that based upon the
Report submitted by the Respondent No.4, a legal opinion was
sought by the District Registrar from the Government Pleader,
Karimganj. The Government Pleader opined that the Birth
Certificates issued to the Petitioners were issued on false
Page No.# 27/30
statements and representation, and advised that the Birth
Certificates may be cancelled. This legal opinion was given on
17.01.2022.
47. The records further show that the legal opinion was forwarded
to the Respondent No.4 by the Assistant Commissioner on behalf
of the Deputy Commissioner on 20.01.2022. Subsequent to that,
the impugned communications dated 28.01.2022 were issued.
48. In the backdrop of the above facts, it is absolutely clear that
the jurisdiction vested upon the Respondent No.4 which is a quasi
judicial function was not exercised by the Respondent No.4. The
Respondent No.4 in the report submitted on 07.11.2020 did not
opine that to his satisfaction it was proved that a fraud was
committed. The Respondent No.4 only made a fact finding enquiry
which was forwarded to the District Registrar without his opinion.
Apart from the above, it also transpires from the records that the
impugned communications were based upon a legal opinion.
49. It is well settled that when power is conferred upon an
Authority, the power is to be exercised only by the Authority. The
power conferred under Section 15 of the Act of 1969 is quasi
judicial power based upon the satisfaction of the Registrar upon
Page No.# 28/30
being proved. The said satisfaction cannot be substituted by a legal
opinion. Additionally, there is no Speaking Order placed before this
Court by the Respondent No.4 that he had exercised his quasi
judicial function of arriving at a subjective satisfaction based upon
the materials proved.
50. Under such circumstances, the impugned communications
enclosed as Annexures 6, 7 and 8 to the writ petition cannot be
sustained in law.
51. Let this Court look at the dispute from another angle i.e.
whether the Respondent No.4 could have decided the disputes as
regards parentage. Section 15 of the Act of 1969 as already
analysed above empowers the Registrar to correct or cancel a
registration on the satisfaction being accorded upon being proved
that there is a clerical or formal error in the entry made in the
Register. The said provision further empowers the Registrar to
decide on the question of fraudulent or improper entries made in
the Register. However, it is very relevant to observe that on the
basis of the quasi judicial power so conferred, the Registrar cannot
decide the question of parentage. It is the opinion of this Court
that in the garb of deciding whether any fraudulent or improper
entry was made in the Register, the Registrar cannot decide on the
Page No.# 29/30
question of parentage which power is specifically reserved upon
the competent Court of civil jurisdiction. It is also the opinion of
this Court that while deciding the question of fraudulent or
improper entry made in the Register, if the question of parentage is
required to be decided primarily, the Registrar has to defer his
decision to that of the competent Court of civil jurisdiction.
52. In the instant case, the Registrar conducted an enquiry into
the parentage of the Petitioners and submitted a report dated
17.11.2020. Thereupon, on the basis of the legal opinion dated
17.11.2020 which was forwarded to the Respondent No.4 vide the
communication dated 20.01.2022, the Respondent No.4 cancelled
the Birth Certificates of the Petitioners vide communications dated
28.01.2022. Such course of action was not permissible as the
Registrar or even the Government Pleader could not have decided
the parentage of the Petitioners and without such decision, it was
not possible for the Respondent No.4 to decide as to whether it
was a fraudulent or improper entry in the Register.
CONCLUSION:
53. Accordingly, the instant writ petition therefore stands disposed
of with the following observations and directions:
Page No.# 30/30
(i)
The impugned communications dated 28.01.2022 as well as
24.06.2022 so issued by the Respondent No.4, which have been
enclosed as Annexures 6, 7, and 8 to the writ petition are
interfered with. Accordingly, the Birth Certificates issued to the
Petitioners on 09.06.2015 and 01.07.2015 stands revived.
(ii)
The
interference
of
this
Court
to
the
impugned
communications dated 28.01.2022 as well as 24.06.2022 which
have been enclosed as Annexures 6, 7, and 8 shall not preclude or
prejudice the Respondent No.5 to approach the competent Court of
Civil Jurisdiction seeking appropriate declaration as regards the
parentage of the Petitioners, if so advised. It is also observed that
if a Court of Civil Jurisdiction makes appropriate declarations, the
present judgment would not come in the way of the Respondent
No.4 to make necessary correction/cancellation of the Birth
Certificates of the Petitioners.
(iii) Writ petition stands allowed. No costs.
Bijoy
Saha
Comparing Assistant
Digitally signed
by Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.08.19
11:03:44 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review