Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on:15.09.2026
Pronounced on: 21 .09.2026
Uploaded on: 22.09.2026
WP(C) No.3216/2025
Dr. Abdul Hamid Mir, Aged 78 years
S/o Sh. Shah Nawaz Mir,
R/o Taranwali Tehsil Mendhar, District Poonch,
A/P Ward No.3, Near D C Colony, Kheora, Rajouri
...Petitioners(s)
Through:- Mr. K.S.Johal, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Supreet Singh Johal, Advocate
Versus
1.
2.
3.
4.
UT of Jammu and Kashmir through
Chief Secretary, Jammu & Kashmir Govt.,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
UT of Jammu and Kashmir through
Secretary to Government,
Health & Medical Education Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
Under Secretary to Government,
Health and Medical Education Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu
Director, Health Services,
Jammu.
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
WP(C) No.3216/2025
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar J
1.
This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India filed
by the petitioner throws challenge to an order and judgment
dated 9th October, 2025 passed by the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Jammu Bench [“the Tribunal”] in TA No.4002/2021
titled Abdul Hamid Mir v. State of J&K and others, whereby the
Tribunal has dismissed the TA of the petitioner being devoid of
any merit.
2.
Briefly stated, the facts leading to the filing of this petition are
that the petitioner was appointed as Assistant Surgeon in Jammu
& Kashmir Health Department on 29th November, 1973. The
service book, which was prepared at the time of his recruitment
along with some other record, reportedly got gutted in fire and a
new service book was prepared. As per the new service book
prepared, the date of birth of the petitioner was indicated on the
first page of the service as 27th March, 1949.
3.
The last posting of the petitioner before his superannuation was
Medical Superintendent, District Hospital, Udhampur. It is
during this tenure, a complaint was received by the respondents
against the petitioner for tampering in his date of birth from
1947 to 1949. As a result of this complaint, Vigilance
Organization registered FIR No.19/2006/PS/VOJ under Section
WP(C) No.3216/2025
5(2) of the J&K Prevention of Corruption Act read with Section
420 RPC.
4.
The Vigilance Organization vide its communication dated
01.02.2007 informed the respondents that, as per the actual date
of birth borne out from the documentary evidence, the petitioner
was liable to retire on superannuation w.e.f. 31.03.2005 but he
continued to be in service on the basis of manipulated date of
birth. The Vigilance Organization further intimated to the
respondents that the date of birth of the petitioner is 27th March,
1947, which also stood confirmed/verified from the Board of
School Education as well as Principal, Government Higher
Secondary School, Poonch.
5.
Acting upon the report of the Vigilance Organization, the
respondents in terms of Government Order No.71-HME of 2007
dated 14.02.2007 directed that the petitioner would be deemed to
have retired on superannuation w.e.f. 31.03.2005 on attaining
the age of superannuation i.e. 58 years. As a consequence,
respondent No.3 issued a communication dated 15.02.2007
calling upon respondent No.4 to serve a notice upon the
petitioner to deposit the entire amount of salary, which he had
received for period of overstay in service.
6.
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner filed SWP No.437/2007 before
this Court, which after promulgation of the J&K Reorganization
WP(C) No.3216/2025
Act, 2019 and constitution of the Central Administrative
Tribunal Bench at Jammu, came to be transferred to the
Tribunal. In the Tribunal, SWP No.437/2007 was re-numbered
and registered as TA No.4002/2021. It is this TA, which has
now been dismissed by the Tribunal in terms of the judgment
impugned.
7.
The impugned judgment has been assailed by the petitioner
primarily on the ground that the order dated 14.02.2007 has been
passed by the respondents in violation of the principles of
natural justice, in that, neither the petitioner was served with any
show cause notice nor was any enquiry worth the name
conducted to prove that there was interpolation in the date of
birth of the petitioner done by the petitioner himself.
8.
It is argued by Mr. K.S.Johal, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner, that, although, criminal proceedings against
the petitioner are pending adjudication before the competent
Court of criminal jurisdiction, yet the petitioner has not been
held guilty of any tampering or manipulation of date of birth nor
has he been convicted. He would argue that the allegation that
the petitioner has tampered the date of birth has not been
established in any departmental proceedings. He would further
argue that in the absence of there being any conclusive finding
of fact recorded by any competent authority that the date of birth
WP(C) No.3216/2025
was manipulated or fabricated by the petitioner, he cannot be
visited with harsh consequences like refund of entire amount of
salary which the petitioner has received while working after
attaining the age of fifty eight (58) years, going by his actual
date of birth i.e. 27th March, 1947.
9.
Per contra, Mr. Raman Sharma, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents, would argue that the manipulation/tampering of
the date of birth from 27.03.1947 to 27.03.1949 was only for the
benefit of the petitioner, therefore, there is strong presumption
that it is the petitioner and petitioner alone, who has
manipulated/tampered his date of birth either himself or in
connivance with others. He submits that since the Challan
against the petitioner is pending trial before the competent Court
of criminal jurisdiction, as such, the petitioner cannot claim the
reliefs prayed for till he is honorably acquitted of the criminal
charge.
10.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, we find that the facts in the instant case are
not much in dispute.
11.
Admittedly, the date of birth of the petitioner, as per the
documentary evidence available on record, is 27th March, 1947.
It is also a fact that the date of birth recorded by the Block
Medical Officer, Surankote, reflected on the first page of the
WP(C) No.3216/2025
service book of the petitioner, which is available on record of
the respondents, is 27th March, 1949. There is no manipulation
or fabrication or tampering visible to the naked eyes. As a matter
of act, the mischief seems to have been committed at the time of
preparing of the fresh/new service book after the original one
got gutted in fire.
12.
We are in agreement with Mr. Raman Sharma, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents that there is a strong presumption
that the date of birth was changed from 27.03.1947 to
27.03.1949 only for the benefit of the petitioner and, therefore,
nobody other than the petitioner may have played the mischief,
but it is trite law that presumption howsoever strong it may be is
not a substitute for proof.
13.
Undoubtedly, a mischief has been played by someone by
changing the date of birth of the petitioner from 27.03.1947 to
27.03.1949, and there is every possibility that this was done
either by the petitioner himself or by someone at his instance.
Nevertheless, the matter is sub judice before the criminal Court,
and the truth is yet to come out. If the petitioner is convicted and
held guilty by the competent criminal Court of manipulation or
tampering with his date of birth, the petitioner would definitely
lose the salary that he has received on account of his overstay in
service on the basis of manipulated date of birth. He could also
WP(C) No.3216/2025
be made liable to some disciplinary action as may be permissible
departmental under law. It is also not in dispute that the
respondents have not conducted any departmental enquiry in this
regard, in which the petitioner could have had an opportunity to
put forth his point of view.
14.
In these circumstances, we are left with no option but to accede
to the argument of Mr. Johal that the orders impugned before the
Tribunal were vitiated on account of non-compliance with the
principle of audi alteram partem. The petitioner had worked on
the post and had been paid the salary for the said period. He can,
of course, be deprived of that salary if the respondents
sufficiently establish that his overstay in service is attributable to
any fraud, tampering, or manipulation on his part. The Tribunal,
however, failed to appreciate all these aspects of the matter and
dismissed the petition solely on the ground that the Vigilance
Organization had found the petitioner guilty of manipulating his
date of birth and that, being the beneficiary of the altered date of
birth, he alone was responsible for such manipulation.
15. We are afraid the reasoning given by the Tribunal is not
sustainable in law. The orders impugned before the Tribunal
were in breach of principles of natural justice and were, thus, not
sustainable.
WP(C) No.3216/2025
16.
For the foregoing reasons, we allow this petition and set aside
and quash the impugned order passed by the Tribunal. The
OA/TA is allowed and orders impugned before the Tribunal are
also set aside. The petitioner is held entitled to provisional
pension and retention of salary. The release of provisional
pension in favour of the petitioner and the retention of salary for
the period during which he has worked after his actual date of
superannuation shall, however, be subject to the petitioner
furnishing an undertaking before the respondent to the effect
that, in the event he is convicted by the Criminal Court and held
guilty of any manipulation or tampering with his date of birth, or
is held guilty of the same in duly constituted departmental
proceedings, he shall refund the entire amount of salary received
for the period after his actual date of superannuation, i.e.,
31.03.2005 along with interest @ 6% per annum.
(Shahzad Azeem)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
21.09.2026
Vinod, Secy
Vinod Kumar
2026.09.22 12:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review